Northeast
Gilgo Beach murders: Serial killer suspect Rex Heuermann faces more possible charges a year after arrest
RIVERHEAD, N.Y. – A year after the arrest of Rex Heuermann, a New York City architect accused of living a double life in the family-friendly Massapequa Park suburb, a task force is still pulling new evidence out of the trove of items seized during a 12-day search of his house.
On July 13, 2023, Suffolk County police arrested Heuermann, now 60, outside his Manhattan office in three cold case murders — the deaths of Melissa Barthelemy, 24, Megan Waterman, 22, and Amber Costello, 27, in 2010.
Over the next 12 months, they tacked on charges in four additional slayings. First, they charged him with killing Maureen Brainard-Barnes, 25, whose remains were near the other three. Then they filed charges for the alleged murders of Jessica Taylor in 2003 and Sandra Costilla in 1993.
GILGO BEACH SERIAL KILLER SUSPECT ALLEGEDLY HAS MORE VICTIMS, HUNTING GROUNDS THAN POLICE FIRST IMAGINED
Alleged Gilgo Beach serial killer Rex Heuermann, center, inside Suffolk County Court in Riverhead June 6, 2024. His attorney, Michael J. Brown, is at left. (James Carbone/Newsday via AP, Pool)
He remains the prime suspect in at least one more murder, the killing of Valerie Mack, whose remains were also dismembered and scattered across two locations, the brush east of Gilgo Beach and the woods of Manorville. Investigators in at least three other states where Heuermann had ties are also examining cold cases in their jurisdictions for potential connections.
SIGN UP TO GET TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER
Heuermann’s suspected victims were all notably petite, many barely 5 feet tall. In a gruesome note to self recovered from one of his computers by forensic investigators, Heuermann allegedly wrote that “small is good.”
The computer file, known as “HK2002-04,” had been deleted but was still accessible by law enforcement. In it, Heuermann allegedly kept a list of “problems,” “supplies,” targets and dump sites.
An evidence photo shows Rex Heuermann’s personal copy of “The Cases That Haunt Us,” a book detailing several famous serial murder cases, in his home office. According to court documents, the book was discovered when authorities executed a search warrant in July 2023. (Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office)
When he wasn’t designing buildings or preying on women, prosecutors allege Heuermann read up on other serial killers and studied the work of John Douglas, a former FBI profiler who wrote the influential book “Mindhunter.”
REX HEUERMANN’S FAMILY KEPT GRUESOME PIECE OF EVIDENCE, SOURCE SAYS
He even listed page numbers from the book in the HK document and kept a running list of traffic cameras along the two highways between his home and the two known dump sites in Manorville and North Sea toward the eastern end of Long Island.
Rex Heuermann’s house in Massapequa Park, N.Y., July 26, 2023. (MEGA for Fox News Digital )
The file, in part, led police to search those locations and to return to Heuermann’s house for a second look, months after they spent nearly two weeks scouring through it.
Four of Heuermann’s alleged victims are referred to as the Gilgo Four, whose remains were all discovered near one another just east of Gilgo Beach south of Long Island’s Great South Bay.
An undated photo of Sandra Costilla. Prosecutors announced June 6, 2024, that Rex Heuermann is charged with the alleged murder of Costilla, whose remains were found in November 1993.
Both Taylor and Costilla were dismembered, and police found parts of their remains near Gilgo Beach and parts in eastern Long Island.
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
Police found 11 bodies along Ocean Parkway, east of Gilgo Beach, in 2010 and 2011, after Shannan Gilbert placed a panicked 911 call begging for help in the neighboring community of Oak Beach.
A sign welcoming visitors to Gilgo Beach outside a tunnel that connects a parking lot to the beach underneath Ocean Parkway. (Michael Ruiz/Fox News)
An investigation into most of the deaths remains ongoing, although Gilbert’s demise has been ruled an accidental drowning, a finding disputed by a private autopsy conducted by Dr. Michael Baden, who found evidence of strangulation.
GET REAL TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB
According to the filings, police have now received reports of Heuermann’s old Chevy Avalanche from two witnesses in two separate murders. They have decades of phone records and internet searches. They have his DNA.
The Gilgo Four, clockwise from top left: Maureen Brainard-Barnes, Melissa Barthelemy, Megan Waterman and Amber Costello. The background shows a wooden cross in the marsh next to Gilgo Beach, N.Y., where their remains were found in the brush just yards from Ocean Parkway. (Suffolk County Police Department/Mega for Fox News Digital)
As the case against Heuermann has progressed, his family has struggled to get by.
His wife, Asa Ellerup, filed for divorce shortly after his arrest and then revealed she was fighting cancer.
Her attorney, Bob Macedonio, told Fox News Digital this week her life remains upside-down.
Jessica Taylor, left, and Valerie Mack, right, were both murdered and dismembered. Suffolk County police discovered partial remains of each victim in both Manorville, N.Y., and along a stretch of Ocean Parkway near Gilgo Beach. (Suffolk County Police Department/Handout)
“Every day after July 13, 2023, has been a new normal,” he said. “She’s in remission now. Her and her children are adjusting to life the best they can.”
Ellerup, who previously said she does not believe her estranged husband was capable of the horrific crimes he’s accused of, has continued to visit him in jail but is reserving judgment until the outcome of his trial.
Read the full article from Here
Boston, MA
No-show Bruins embarrassed by Sabres on home ice
Almost 15 years have passed since Milan Lucic blew up goalie Ryan Miller on Garden ice, an infamous hit that would help send the Buffalo Sabres into their Dark Ages. On Sunday in Game 4 at the Garden, the Sabres finally got a little payback.
With a chance to tie the best-of-seven series on Causeway Street, the Bruins were embarrassed by the Sabres thanks to a comically bad first period that put them in a hole from which they had no chance to extricate themselves. The B’s took a well-deserved 6-1 loss and are now down in the series 3-1. They will be down to their last out of the season when they face the Sabres in Game 5 on Tuesday at Keybank Center.
“Man to man in here, if we’re not f—- embarrassed with what just happened, I don’t know what to say,” said Charlie McAvoy, who along with his partner Jonathan Aspirot was minus-4. “It’s not over after three games. We have everything to play for here and we know we’re such a better team than what we did today.”
“Embarrassed” was the operative word after the game.
The B’s had won 29 games on Causeway Street this season, tied with the Carolina Hurricanes for most home Ws in the NHL. But they couldn’t win either of their home games in the series and, if they don’t get their game in order before Game 5, they will have played their last game at the Garden for the season.
Meanwhile, the Sabres, after 14 years out of the playoffs, are on the verge of their first playoff series win since 2007.
The Bruins’ have suffered more dramatically painful losses on home ice in recent memory. The Game 7 Stanley Cup Final loss in 2019 comes to mind. But it’s hard to think of one that was less competitive. The Sabres’ forecheck made mincemeat of the Bruins’ defense in the first period.
How do you explain a team not being ready to compete and/or execute in such a big game?
“I can’t,” said coach Marco Sturm. “I don’t know. I really don’t know. I could feel a little bit of it in Game 3, for no reason, and definitely today. If you’re a Boston Bruin and playing at home, you should be very excited going into a playoff game. We didn’t, so I can’t really answer that question right now.”
The first period was a theater of the macabre for Bruins fans, at least those fans who hadn’t sold their tickets to Sabres fans.
They fell down 4-0 and it could have been much worse than that. The B’s were outshot 19-5 and they were charged with 10 giveaways, which felt like some charitable counting from the stat crew.
The first goal against at 4:17 was a harbinger of things to come. McAvoy’s simple D-to-D pass didn’t connect with Aspirot and the puck drifted dangerously toward the blue line. One of their best defensive forwards, Fraser Minten, jumped in to help. But after he collected the loose puck, Minten’s reverse bank pass went right to Alex Tuch, who fed Peyton Krebs for the one-timer goal. The Sabres’ fans in the building popped loudly and it was the beginning of a long afternoon for the home team.
The Sabres made it 2-0 seconds after a Buffalo power play ended at 7:10. Hampus Lindholm’s soft clear attempt was knocked down and then Ryan McLeod fed Josh Doan at the top of the crease for a redirect.
On the third goal, Jordan Harris, inserted into the lineup for Mason Lohrei, coughed up the puck upon Doan’s stick check and it went right to Zach Benson, who moved in and tossed an in-tight backhander at Jeremy Swayman, who made the initial stop but the rebound bounced off Benson and trickled in.
Sturm was in no mood to discuss what wrong from an X-and-O standpoint.
“I can’t even going into the rush game, the O-zone, D-zone, I really can’t,” said Sturm. “In all areas, we were just behind. Emotionally, if you’re not ready for it…it didn’t matter. So I don’t talk about little details because they were not there today.”
Sturm called his timeout at that point at 9:15 after the Benson goal.
“We were just hurting and I had to stop this, first of all,” said Sturm. “Message-wise, there’s a few things I had to address and the other thing, you had to wake them up. For some reason, two games in a row, we were just totally flat. In a playoff game. That just can’t happen.”
But happen it did, and the timeout couldn’t stop the hemorrhaging.
Buffalo made it 4-0 at 14:24 when Aspirot knocked a Sabre into Swayman, leaving the goaltender flailing. Bowen Byram used the opportunity to score his third of the series into the shortside.
Predictably, the Bruins fans that were in the house booed their team off the ice at the of the first.
To make matters worse, the B’s were without Viktor Arvidsson to start the second after he had taken a high hit from Mattias Samuelsson late in the first.
Pride kicked in a little bit in the second period and the B’s finally spent a little time in the Sabres zone, especially late in the period. But Alex Lyon (22 mostly easy saves) made the stops he needed to, when the Sabres didn’t block the shots in front of him. The B’s earned one power play late in the second but they did nothing with it and they still faced the daunting four-goal deficit to start the third.
For the most optimistic of Bruins fans, even their hopes were doused when Beck Malenstyn scored on a deflection early in the third, followed up quickly by a Tuch goal, both goals coming off turnovers.
Sturm then gave Swayman the mercy pull, which frankly could have happened after the disastrous first. The netminder appeared to let his teammates have it before he went down the tunnel.
Only a Sean Kuraly goal with 39.9 seconds left, with the B’s killing a Nikita Zadorov major after he cross-checked and punched Rasmus Dahlin, kept the B’s from suffering their first shutout of the season.
That didn’t change the overriding feeling utter failure one iota.
“A waste of opportunity,” said David Pastrnak, who took nine shots, only one of which got through to the net. “Unacceptable. We expect more from ourselves. We are better than that. You can’t show up like that, in an afternoon game. The first period is so f— important…to show up like that as a team is unacceptable.”
We will see on Tuesday what, if anything, they can do about it.
Pittsburg, PA
Woman killed, 3 others injured in Armstrong County bar shooting; suspect in custody
A woman has died, and three others were injured following a shooting at a bar in Vandergrift, Armstrong County, according to Pennsylvania State Police.
Troopers said they were called shortly after 1:15 a.m. Sunday to Niki’s Quick Six on First Street in Vandergrift for reports of shots fired.
A local police officer who arrived first found one woman dead and multiple people suffering from gunshot wounds, according to a public information report provided by state police.
The woman who died was identified as Jessica Hilliard, 34, of Apollo. Hilliard was pronounced dead at the scene. Another victim, Rebecca Boston, 24, of McIntyre, was found at the scene and was last listed in critical condition.
Two other victims, Hector Saballos, 34, of Vandergrift, and Dominik Dellach, 25, of Vandergrift, left before troopers arrived. Police said both were later listed in stable condition.
The suspect has been identified as David Dunmire, 36, of Vandergrift. Police said he remained at the scene and was taken into custody without incident.
An investigation determined that a physical altercation broke out in the parking lot outside the bar before Dunmire allegedly pulled out a firearm and fired multiple rounds, striking several people.
State police said they consulted with Armstrong County District Attorney Katie Charlton, who approved a criminal homicide charge.
The investigation remains ongoing.
Connecticut
Family called Connecticut police about suspect in D.C. Correspondents’ Dinner shooting, Trump says
Family members of the accused gunman who tried to storm the ballroom at the White House Correspondents’ Association dinner alerted police in Connecticut with concerns about the man, the president said Sunday.
In an interview with Fox News Channel, President Donald Trump said the man — who was armed with guns and knives — had written about targeting Trump administration officials.
Separately, police in New London confirmed in a statement that a person contacted them at approximately 10:49 p.m., about two hours after the incident. Police said the person expressed concern about events that unfolded earlier that evening at the dinner.
“The reporting individual wanted to share information they believed to be pertinent to the matter,” the statement said.
New London police immediately contacted federal law enforcement partners. Both local and federal officers then interviewed the person, according to the statement.
“The New London Police Department remains committed to working collaboratively with our law enforcement partners at all levels to ensure public safety,” the statement said.
New London police said their investigation into the matter is no longer active and directed further inquiries to the U.S. Secret Service. The federal agency didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.
The suspect, identified by law enforcement officials as 31-year-old Cole Tomas Allen of Torrance, California, was expected to face criminal charges on Monday from the Justice Department, whose acting leader, Todd Blanche, said the suspect traveled by train from California and checked in as a guest days earlier at the Washington hotel where the Saturday night gala dinner was held with its typically tight security.
Authorities said Allen attempted to charge into the cavernous ballroom at the Washington Hilton but was tackled to the ground in a violent scene that resulted in shots being fired, Trump being hurried off the stage and guests ducking for cover beneath their tables.
Fox reported Sunday that the White House said Allen’s brother contacted New London police and reported Allen had sent family members “an alleged manifesto outlining his intent to target administration officials.”
During a live telephone interview, Fox News journalist Jacqui Heinrich asked the president to comment on information she said was provided by the White House about the suspected shooter and his motive.
“I’m being told that he had a manifesto saying he wanted to target Trump administration officials,” Heinrich said. “He had a lot of anti-Trump and anti-Christian rhetoric on his social media accounts, and left a manifesto in his hotel room that his brother had notified New London police about prior to this incident.”
She added that secret service agents had been talking to Allen’s family members, and that Allen attended a No Kings protest in California. She asked Trump for his reaction to the new details.
“I heard about the London situation and I wish they would have told us about it a little bit,” Trump said. “But it is what it is.”
A law enforcement official familiar with the investigation told The Associated Press the suspected shooter sent writings to family members minutes before the attack in which he railed against Trump administration policies and referred to himself as a “Friendly Federal Assassin.”
The writings made repeated references to Trump without naming him directly and alluded to grievances over a range of administration actions and recent events, including U.S. strikes on drug smuggling boats in the eastern Pacific, the official said Sunday.
The official was not authorized to discuss the ongoing investigation and spoke on condition of anonymity.
Allen’s brother contacted police in New London after receiving the writings, according to the official.
This story has been updated. Material from The Associated Press was used in this report.
-
San Francisco, CA5 minutes agoDrizzle Clings To San Francisco, Then Sunshine Cranks Up The Heat
-
Dallas, TX11 minutes agoDallas Mavericks’ Top Choice for GM May Actually Be ‘Gettable’
-
Miami, FL17 minutes agoMiami Claims Sixth Straight Series Win, Defeating Cal Without Superstar Hitter
-
Boston, MA23 minutes agoNo-show Bruins embarrassed by Sabres on home ice
-
Denver, CO29 minutes agoChristian Braun, Denver Nuggets confident with backs against wall
-
Seattle, WA35 minutes agoRefsnyder’s pinch-hit HR lifts Seattle Mariners over Cards
-
San Diego, CA41 minutes agoMLB Rumors: New San Diego Padres Owner Eyeing Massive Splash Move
-
Milwaukee, WI47 minutes ago
One woman dead after Saturday night house fire on Milwaukee’s North Side