Connect with us

Lifestyle

How Not to Be a Character in a ‘Bad Fashion Movie’

Published

on

How Not to Be a Character in a ‘Bad Fashion Movie’

About 10 months in the past, Laura Brown placed on an emerald inexperienced go well with and walked into an East Village artwork gallery, the place two rows of benches lined the partitions of a sq., high-ceiling room. She took her seat within the entrance row.

It may have been a scene in what Ms. Brown calls a “B.F.M.,” or “unhealthy style film” — a phrase she started utilizing a number of years in the past to explain the style editor archetype: elitist, egomaniacal and downright “Satan Wears Prada”-ish. Someday earlier, the writer Dotdash Meredith introduced that Ms. Brown’s job, editor in chief of InStyle journal, had been eradicated.

In her “B.F.M.,” the scene would have performed out like this: A fallen editor makes her first public look at a style present, striding right into a den of whispers and side-eyes, as steely as ever.

Besides that Ms. Brown was simply concerning the furthest a mainstream style editor may get from Miranda Priestly’s ilk. She didn’t present up that day sporting sun shades and a cool smirk. She wore beachy waves and a jaunty smile. She bear-hugged some seatmates and made them snicker in between seems to be.

When folks requested about InStyle, she didn’t say “I left,” which is what style folks typically say after being fired, Ms. Brown stated. She had little interest in “going away for some time to, like, acquire myself after which announce my subsequent factor.”

Advertisement

In addition to, she knew “the facility of magazines isn’t what it was.” A few years in the past, social media leveled the taking part in area in style; in right now’s entrance row, prime editors are usually sandwiched between Instagram personalities and well-known associates of the model. On this case, Ms. Brown was all three without delay.

“I knew what fairness I had earned,” stated Ms. Brown, who’s 48 and deeply Australian, whereas having lunch final month on the deeply Parisian restaurant Le Voltaire. “My value didn’t rely on being the editor in chief of InStyle.”

However, oh, what energy these style magazines as soon as held. Raised in Sydney by a single mom, Ms. Brown waited tables as a youngster at a seafood restaurant, the place she realized to banter with grown-ups for suggestions. With out the web, studying magazines felt like “springboarding” herself into different folks’s worlds, she stated. Working for magazines was all she ever wished.

She moved to New York at 27, one week earlier than Sept. 11, 2001. This was nonetheless the age of imperial editors, although budgets have been already shrinking. Ms. Brown had solely been working at Speak journal for just a few weeks when she realized the journal was folding, halfway via producing a younger Hollywood photograph shoot by Melvin Sokolsky. (The idea was oiled-up actors hatching from eggs.)

In 2005, after temporary stints at W and Particulars, Ms. Brown started working at Harper’s Bazaar. The journal’s then-editor, Glenda Bailey, favored theatrical images, like Rihanna lounging within the mouth of a shark, which she referred to as “coups.” Considered one of Ms. Brown’s early “coups” concerned sending “The Simpsons” to Paris with Linda Evangelista (greater than a decade earlier than Balenciaga’s created its personal “Simpsons”-take-Paris episode).

Advertisement

Bazaar can be the place Ms. Brown started befriending some very well-known girls. “I distinctly bear in mind a cheese board with sweating cheese,” Jennifer Aniston wrote in an e mail, describing her first interview with Ms. Brown on the Beverly Hills Resort. (Ms. Brown later elaborated: “This wad of Brie was getting sweatier and sweatier, about as sweaty as I used to be. We simply ignored it the entire time.” There was one other elephant within the room: Ms. Aniston’s very latest separation from Brad Pitt. “I bear in mind saying to her, ‘That sucks.’”)

Ms. Brown’s highly effective enthusiasm one way or the other made these girls really feel calmer, shifting the middle of gravity away from them and making them really feel much less alienated. Michelle Pfeiffer stated she met Ms. Brown whereas selling a perfume, carrying round samples to editors’ workplaces in a Ziploc bag: “Laura was bouncing on the sofa like an 8-year-old, instantly diffusing any nervousness I had.”

Kiernan Shipka met Ms. Brown when she was 12, whereas Harper’s Bazaar filmed a tour of the “Mad Males” actress’s high-end closet. “I’m preparing in my lavatory, and the brightest power simply barges via the door,” Ms. Shipka, now 23, recalled. Final month they discovered themselves at a restaurant, ingesting Champagne and dancing on the cubicles to Whitney Houston. “There’s no stress to carry out round her,” Ms. Shipka stated.

Befriending these girls wasn’t difficult, Ms. Brown stated. She wished them to really feel welcome; in flip they noticed her as a rarity in style. “A pleasant woman who eats spaghetti,” Ms. Brown stated. She wasn’t one of many “pointy folks,” one other time period she deploys for a sure type of style individual: exclusionary, intimidating, obsessive about punching a “sandwich card of stylish” (and in addition, she stated, with sporting pointed shoulder clothes).

“‘I’m sporting this, subsequently I’m stylish,’” stated Ms. Brown, whose personal uniform leans towards floral tops and high-waist, wide-leg denims. “‘I’ve this physique, subsequently I’m stylish. I’ve been invited to this celebration, subsequently I’m stylish.’ That’s not very imaginative.”

Advertisement

“After I was youthful, I used to suppose everyone in New York style was on some kind of superhighway. Extra related, extra glamorous and smarter than me. And then you definately get within the room and also you’re like, ‘Oh,’” — and right here, she virtually cackles — “‘this isn’t Mensa.’”

Ms. Brown was named editor of InStyle in 2016, after 11 years at Harper’s Bazaar. Her first cowl was Emily Ratajkowski, sporting a Virgil Abloh-designed white tee printed with “In” on the entrance and “Fashion” on the again. The message was: “Everyone’s invited to the celebration,” Ms. Brown stated. Even when that celebration takes on end-of-the-world vibes, because it did in 2020.

But the chaos of the pandemic and racial reckoning galvanized Ms. Brown, who leaned into overlaying the work of activists (and associates) like Tarana Burke of Me Too Worldwide and Ayọ Tometi of Black Lives Matter.

Journey restrictions meant as a substitute of attending style weeks or advertiser journeys, “you may buckle again right down to the journalism itself,” stated Ms. Brown, who put Dr. Anthony Fauci, Stacey Abrams and Deb Haaland on InStyle’s covers (each print and digital) all through 2020 and 2021. (When The New York Occasions requested 9 of the business’s most influential style magazines about their racial illustration, InStyle was the one publication keen to reply questions.)

However in November 2021, InStyle possession modified, as the corporate Dotdash acquired Meredith. Two months later, InStyle’s print publication ceased — together with Leisure Weekly and others — and Ms. Brown was dismissed.

Advertisement

Whereas she was involved for youthful folks on her crew, Ms. Brown felt comparatively “sanguine,” she stated. She didn’t “chuck a wobbly,” which is, apparently, an Australian time period for “freak out.” (She additionally had a marriage to plan: In April, in Hawaii, she married a 31-year-old author named Brandon Borror-Chappell, whom she met as a Sundown Tower Resort waiter, in entrance of an entire lot of well-known associates, whereas sporting a taffy-pink off-shoulder customized Valentino robe.)

“So perhaps I’ll get fewer purses despatched to me,” Ms. Brown stated, earlier than instantly turning severe. “In case you’ve earned your stripes and finished the work, you’re taking it with you. You don’t simply fly off into area.”

To some extent, she was additionally ready. Two years earlier, she determined to register an organization, Laura Brown Media, and begin fascinated by her subsequent strikes.

These strikes are extra clear right now: Ms. Brown will launch a podcast in early 2023 referred to as “So Seen,” made with SeeHer (Ms. Brown advises or serves on the board of a number of nonprofits, together with this one, which is dedicated to portrayals of girls in advertising and media). She is executive-producing a movie concerning the style world with Bruna Papandrea, a producer of “The Undoing” and “Huge Little Lies” on HBO. She is consulting for luxurious manufacturers. She is engaged on a collaboration with the French model Sezane.

At a dinner celebrating that collaboration in October, Ms. Brown was, true to type, straddling the roles of host and courtroom jester, doing humorous little dances and making fast introductions. (Laura Dern calls Ms. Brown “the grand connector. There’s no dialog anybody ends round Laura Brown the place she’s not like, ‘ who you want to know?’”)

Advertisement

Sezane had rented a TriBeCa condominium for the candlelit dinner, filling a wall-size bookcase with dozens of latest sweaters, which, towards the tip of the evening, have been provided to every visitor. At first, the actresses and supermodels and stylists hesitated. However as soon as Ms. Brown started slinging the knits at folks like a human T-shirt gun, all pretenses have been dropped. Ladies piled sweaters into their arms. No one was overly cool about it. And there was one thing very Laura Brown about that.

“I at all times type of had an excellent sense of what style worlds I wished to be in and what ones I didn’t,” she stated. “The sharp ones I’m not so curious about. I like colour and creativity and generosity and heat.”

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Lifestyle

The Zendaya-led 'Challengers' is much more than a sexy tennis movie : Pop Culture Happy Hour

Published

on

The Zendaya-led 'Challengers' is much more than a sexy tennis movie : Pop Culture Happy Hour
The terrific new film Challengers is about being intense about tennis, sex, and competition. Directed by Luca Guadagnino, the film stars Zendaya as Tashi, a tennis coach and object of desire to two men. She’s married to Art (Mike Faist), who is facing his old friend Patrick (Josh O’Connor) at a Challengers event. This reopens all the trio’s old wounds, and they excavate all of their relationships with each other.
Continue Reading

Lifestyle

How L.A. Chess Club is giving nerd culture a Gen Z makeover

Published

on

How L.A. Chess Club is giving nerd culture a Gen Z makeover

Picture this: It’s a Thursday night in Santa Monica, and you’re feeling good. You’re sitting across from a cute stranger, and the vibes are vibing. In a spacious warehouse-style space, which might sound a tad sketch but somehow isn’t at all, 20- and 30-somethings are seated around rows of tables with chess boards. House music is bumping, and drinks are flowing. There’s pizza being made on-site, and two tattoo artists are around if you’re feeling adventurous and looking to commemorate the experience. And if you need a buffer for maintaining conversation with someone unfamiliar, no worries.

All of this is unfolding as you play a low-stakes game of chess. This is the magic of L.A. Chess Club.

From 8 p.m. to midnight every Thursday, happy regulars and excited first-timers show up to play chess and exercise their social muscles. On this particular night in early April, 250 people show up, some opting for heels and outfits you’d see at a chic lounge, with many others going the casual route — yet neither group looks out of place. Whether you’re looking to competitively play chess, learn the game , meet new friends or mingle as a single person, all are welcome by founder Michelle Kong.

A circular chess board made by an event attendee is shown at a weekly L.A. Chess Club meetup.

Advertisement
A man holding his hands close to his face in focus as he looks at a chess board that is off-camera.

Chess player Jonathan Erving waits for his opponent to make a move.

Two people play a game of chess together with new friends.

Imani Cheadle, left, and Mandy Sherma play a game of chess together with new friends.

Around the country, people are hungry for connection and eager to seek it out following the collective trauma of COVID-19 closures. In-person gatherings that lean into the preciousness of sharing space and being still with one another are on the rise, and Los Angeles is no exception. More supper clubs have emerged, while slow burns like magazine collaging are a hit. There’s more emphasis on romanticizing and reimagining everyday activities and an increased interest in speed dating. The need for more thoughtful spaces to connect with new friends or romantic prospects for a few hours of casual conversation is palpable, and L.A. residents are stepping up.

Advertisement

Liam Blackburn, 22, has been coming to L.A. Chess Club for the last nine months. The exciting rounds of speed chess plus the consistent young crowd initially piqued Blackburn’s interest. But the meaningful connections he’s made while attending are what quickly turned him into a regular.

“I feel like I can actually talk to people and even meet them at a deeper level instead of ‘Hey, how you doing? Wanna dance?’” Blackburn says, emphasizing the refreshing change of pace that low-key, mellow-yet-lively chess meetups offer versus the loud music and social pressure of being at L.A. bars and nightclubs.

On this night, Blackburn arrived at L.A. Chess Club with his girlfriend, Courtney Zajac, 23. After the two met and played a game of chess at a past Chess Club event, sparks flew, and they decided to spend time together again. Now the couple, both of whom were already seasoned chess players, count the Thursday event as a regular stop on their social calendar.

“Sometimes you just cross paths with someone who is an absolute breath of fresh air, and Liam is undoubtedly one of those people no matter the setting,” Zajac says of her experience connecting with Blackburn. “I didn’t attend Chess Club with the intention of finding a romantic connection but I left my first evening in attendance knowing I’d met someone whose company I couldn’t get enough of — and whose chess skills were truly humbling. It was absolutely special and memorable, and I can’t say I’ve experienced anything quite like it before.”

Two friends play a game of chess together.

New friends Sofia Contreras, left, and Jen Castro play a game of chess together.

Advertisement
Three people play chess together on a multi-player board.

Suha Kalish, left, and couple Fred Muth and Hanz Legaspi play chess together on a multi-player board during an L.A. Chess Club night.

Founder Kong, 26, has struck gold with this formula: an event with the laid-back ease of a chill game night and all the social and romantic possibility of a night out on the town. However, what the popular weekly chess events have grown into was never Kong’s intention when she launched the club in June 2023. “I just wanted to play chess,” she says lightheartedly.

About two years ago, when Kong first started playing chess, she was “immediately hooked” and became an avid online player. “My friends didn’t play chess, and I was like, ‘I need to find people to play chess with in person,’” Kong says. “I did my own research and went to a chess club, and it was just all older men playing chess in silence in this basement.” After Kong did some additional research and checked in with friends, she noticed that chess clubs for children and adult clubs made up almost exclusively of men seemed to be the norm.

“I really needed a chess club for people my age and in my proficiency level as well, so I made one,” she says.

After the success of L.A. Chess Club’s singles event for Valentine’s Day in February, Kong better understood how many people came to the events in search of deeper, meaningful connections. The club has relocated to a permanent location in the downtown Arts District to accommodate its growing roster of regulars.

Advertisement

Actor and event producer DeShawn Cavanaugh says L.A. Chess Club is helping to meet the growing need for fresh social spaces beyond the typical nightlife scene.

Cavanaugh, who produces comedy events around L.A. such as Curson n’ Screamin’ and A Tribe Called Melanin through his company 3mpower Media, enjoyed himself during his first Chess Club experience.

“I think people are looking for activities and something stimulating that’s not just drinking or listening to music,” he says. “All of those things are great, but especially in L.A., we have so many artists, they need something to chew on. These types of social events have been a really great way for people to reconnect with others and themselves.”

Two people play a game of chess at a table.

Janet Akisanmi, left, from Dallas, plays a game against Kabir Kang, of Los Angeles. Akisanmi and her friend Grace Feyisetan were visiting L.A. for a month from Dallas and saw the event on TikTok, so they decided to check it out.

Two people in the center of a crowded room, playing chess and laughing.

Tiger Ji, left, and Imani Cheadle play chess together during a recent L.A. Chess Club night. It was Ji and Cheadle’s first time at the event. “It’s really fun,” Ji says. “I got really into chess during COVID, but most of it was playing online. It’s rarely social. This is less so about playing chess and much more about getting to know people. I just moved to L.A., and this is great.”

Advertisement

Bijan Sanchez, 30, has been in quite a few chess communities in L.A., but none were a great fit. “I stopped playing chess for the longest time, and I just joined Catan clubs. I feel like the community is more friendly,” Sanchez says.

After friends recommended he visit L.A. Chess Club, Sanchez has finally found a chess environment that resonates. “I loved it a lot. I think it was one of my favorite nights out in L.A.,” he says. “I like that there was a good diversity of different people. I feel like everyone is kinda like cool nerds, and I think I identify as that, as someone that’s an outgoing nerdy guy. I vibe with the culture and people.”

Sofia Contreras felt compelled to visit L.A. Chess Club after seeing the event highlighted on TikTok by Taylor Morgan McPherson, a.k.a. the Sparkle Queen. McPherson featured the event in her “Where to Meet Men” series, which has grown increasingly popular among L.A. singles, and helped boost awareness of Chess Club. “She motivated me to come out. The [turnout] was a lot better than what I expected it to be,” Contreras says with a smile, standing next to Jen Castro, a friend she made earlier in the evening. “I’m here now and I’m having fun.”

“I’m always checking out what’s new in L.A. to meet people in person because I don’t have the best luck on dating apps,” says McPherson. “You know, being a Black woman, dating apps aren’t really skewed for us.” On McPherson’s first visit to Chess Club, she arrived solo and had a pleasant experience. “I was a little nervous. I was a little timid,” she says.

“Men approached me immediately. It was really nice,” McPherson says, recounting a positive experience at the bar and that more seasoned male players patiently walking her through the game. “Everyone was so open and willing to teach, which was so refreshing.” By the end of the night, McPherson had made a connection and exchanged numbers with someone. Now, McPherson is another attendee-turned-vendor who offers a range of glittery body, face and hair embellishments to Chess Club members each week through her Kourtney Kardashian-approved biodegradable Sparkle Bar.

Advertisement
A closeup of a hand moving a chess piece on a green chess board.

Kamarya Singh makes a move against her opponent at L.A. Chess Club.

A closeup of a woman focusing on tattooing another woman behind her ear.

Tattoo artist Clover Fields gives Eliana Pandian a small heart tattoo behind her ear during L.A. Chess Club. Other highlights included a DJ, glitter tattoos, hair tinsel and tarot readings.

A man sitting behind a table DJing music.

Dennis Neymit, a.k.a. DJ Dill, plays music during the second half of L.A. Chess Club on a recent April night.

Advertisement

Attending the event cost $60 for men, with free admission for women. Regulars can access a discounted rate through a recently launched loyalty program.

The price structure is a move that aims to boost the low number of women in chess while eliminating barriers to entry, says Kong, adding that many of the club’s long-term male members were supportive and willing to pay double in support of the mission.

“Women making up only 10% of chess players is crazy,” Kong says. “The statistics do not look great. Our ratio is almost 2 to 1 now, women to men, and it’s proven that it works. A lot of people are very supportive. It’s really great to see.”

Ultimately, the event is what you make of it, Kong says, noting that people who’ve attended L.A. Chess Club have made all sorts of connections: finding roommates, meeting romantic partners (straight and queer) and making new friends.

For Nyne Nelson, 33, an intuitive and attendee-turned-vendor at L.A. Chess Club, getting to know people within the chess community has been rewarding, especially after enduring the intense isolation of the COVID-19 shutdown. “I’m a very introverted person, so coming to a place where I can play a game and talk to people works out very well for me — and also reading people and giving guidance,” says Nelson, who offers tarot readings on a sliding scale at the weekly event. “Sometimes people just need guidance, and that’s what I’m here to do. I don’t tell the future. I just give a direction on where to go.”

Advertisement
A person gives a tarot-card reading.

Nyne Nelson, a.k.a. Haus of 9 Tarot, gives a reading during L.A. Chess Club.

A group of people, some sitting and some standing, playing chess and socializing.

Jonathan Erving, center left, and Kamarya Singh play chess against each other as friends Jared Washington and Brandon Walker cheer them on.

Kong left her finance job and focused on L.A. Chess Club full time. “I think betting on yourself when you’re young yields good returns,” she says. “I invested everything I had to keep Chess Club running every week for nine months before I monetized [it]. It’s not easy. I’m just very determined.”

Despite the club still being in its infancy, the growth has been rapid, with weekly events averaging about 200 people.

“When you’re waking up at 5 a.m. and listening to Bloomberg in the morning and looking at stocks, it’s a very different start of the day than when you get to wake up and work on something you’re passionate about,” she says. “There’s so much opportunity here, especially compared to the environments that I was exposed to when I first went to chess clubs. I’m so happy that I’m able to bring this type of positive experience to people for the first time they interact with chess.”

Advertisement

Continue Reading

Lifestyle

Netflix's 'Baby Reindeer': A dark, haunting story bungles its depiction of queerness

Published

on

Netflix's 'Baby Reindeer': A dark, haunting story bungles its depiction of queerness

Richard Gadd as Donny in Baby Reindeer. The new Netflix series is based on Gadd’s autobiographical one-man show.

Netflix


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

Netflix


Richard Gadd as Donny in Baby Reindeer. The new Netflix series is based on Gadd’s autobiographical one-man show.

Netflix

Note: You can’t really talk about this series without discussing a major revelation that occurs in episode four of its seven-episode season. So be warned: Spoilers ahead.

There’s a reason that the first scene in the first episode of Baby Reindeer, now streaming on Netflix, plays like it’s a classic setup to a joke: Woman walks into a bar.

Advertisement

Creator and star Richard Gadd is setting our expectations exactly where he wants them set; he needs us to think that the story he’ll tell us over the next seven episodes will conform to the narrative contours of dark comedy.

He’s already tipped us off that the comedy in question will be dark indeed, via a framing device that opens the show: We see his character Donny Dunn filing a police report that he’s being stalked by a woman named Martha (Jessica Gunning).

Cut to six months earlier: Martha enters the pub where Donny tends bar. Everything that follows is meant to place us inside Donny’s head. As he tells us about her, we can’t help but see her as he does: A sad, fat, pitiable middle-aged woman who’s clearly lying about her life. She’s not the high-powered lawyer she says she is – if she were, surely she could afford to buy a drink. And why would she spend all those potentially billable hours bellied up at Donny’s bar whenever he’s working a shift? And why would she proceed to send him thousands of unhinged text messages and stalk him, his girlfriend, and his family?

Right, we think. We know what we’re in for: Baby Reindeer is the story of one hapless young man getting cruelly stalked by a mentally ill woman, who, it turns out, has a history, and a criminal record, for doing so.

Moreover, it’s a true story. True-ish, anyway, as Baby Reindeer is based on Gadd’s autobiographical one-man show.

Advertisement

But Gadd soon complicates our understanding of events. It turns out Donny is a struggling would-be comedian; we watch a series of his cringeworthy sets before sparse, stone-faced audiences. He seems depressed and friendless – his work colleagues at the bar are hostile louts; he’s living with his ex-girlfriend’s mother on the outskirts of London.

Plus there’s the nagging fact that while Donny may not actively encourage Martha’s fawning attention, he is awfully passive about shutting down her determination that they could get together, even as she grows more insistent, and more threatening.

Also, as the cop asks him at the start of the first episode. Why did he let it all go on for six months before filing a formal complaint?

Jessica Gunning as Martha.

Netflix


hide caption

Advertisement

toggle caption

Netflix


Jessica Gunning as Martha.

Netflix

Advertisement

The rug-pull

The answer to that question is what Baby Reindeer is truly about. It’s where the conventional and familiar trappings of dark comedy and psychological thriller fall away to reveal the show’s true, beating heart: Sexual abuse, and its lingering aftermath.

It isn’t until episode four that we learn that five years before Martha entered his life, Donny met a successful television writer named Darrien (Tom Goodman-Hill) who gave him career advice, promised to set him up with opportunities, and supplied him with drugs. During those sessions, while Donny was helpless to stop him, Darrien would sexually abuse him.

This, the series proceeds to argue – far too tidily – is the answer to everything. It’s why Donny became the depressed, self-loathing man we’ve come to know. It’s why his comedy career stalled. It’s why he’s since chosen to degrade himself by having meaningless sex with both men and women, doing more drugs, and by developing an interest in “extreme” pornography.

It’s also, of course – or so the show would have us believe – why he was so disarmed and flattered by the attention Martha gave him, which seems (compared to the drug-filled sexual cesspits he once frequented) pure and wholesome and, not for nothing, reassuringly straight. At one point Donny guiltily admits to us that, at his very lowest point, he even started to find Martha – imagine that! a fat woman! – sexually arousing.

It’s this aspect of Baby Reindeer – Gadd/Donny’s ultimate willingness to confront his abuse and explore its aftereffects – which has earned the show its most fulsome praise from critics and audiences. But in practice, the series repeatedly and clumsily conflates the horror of abuse with the simple fact of queer sexuality. Purely for dramatic purposes, Baby Reindeer implies that Donny’s sexuality conforms to the laws of cause (the abuse) and effect (queerness). Worse, it does so in a way that seems specifically designed to reassure those audiences who believe queerness is something that happens to people, something that can be triggered from the outside.

Catching queerness like a cold

Let me be clear: Baby Reindeer is not making any kind of broad sexual/political case that same-sex abuse leads its victims to experience same-sex desire. Neither is it saying that all putatively straight men who get sexually abused by other men will henceforth be attracted to trans women.

But it does want us to believe – in fact it entirely depends upon us believing – that Donny, for one, experienced same-sex desire only after his abuse – desire it goes out of its way to depict as filthy and degrading. It does, too, want us to believe that Donny failed to make any romantic connections with women or men after his abuse – until he met Teri (Nava Mau) on a trans dating site.

Advertisement

Gadd himself identifies as bisexual, which makes it all the more puzzling and frustrating that, again and again, the series takes absurd pains to present Donny as someone who is not at all like the kinds of queer folk who (shudder!) willingly have sex with each other and (shock horror!) use recreational drugs and (gasp!) watch porn.

Rest assured, straight audiences: Donny’s queer sexuality was something forced upon him – a fact that his stoic father (Mark Lewis Jones) understands and underscores because, as he tearfully explains to his son, “I grew up in the Catholic Church.”

It’s a jaw-dropping scene, but not for the reason it wants to be. It’s meant as a moment of startling honesty and searing empathy between father and son.

It plays like a tasteless, homophobic joke.

Sticking the dismount

For all its queasy discomfort with, and prissy diffidence about queer sexuality, there is one thing Baby Reindeer gets absolutely, hauntingly right: Its ending.

Advertisement

As the series concludes, Martha has been jailed for stalking Donny. In a thinner, less resonant series, our hero would take this as an unalloyed victory, as vindication. But smartly, Gadd shows us a Donny who has acknowledged his abuse but has only begun to effectively deal with it.

Donny, instead, wallows. He walks the streets, playing Martha’s tender/terrifying voicemails in his headphones. He sets out to confront his abuser, only to cave and accept a job working for him. He shambles through his life alone, until he enters a pub (Man walks into a bar) and realizes he can’t pay for his drink. The handsome bartender comps him out of pity, just as Donny did to Martha in the first episode. The end.

… OK, that pity-drink callback at the very end is a bit on-the-nose, but the series’ refusal to afford Donny a clear, uncomplicated, once-and-for-all victory is a smart one. Had the series ended with a sense of triumph and finality, it would have been dramatically satisfying but emotionally dishonest. Human psychology is more complex than that, and the damage done by abuse more insidious.

When we leave him, Donny is still trapped by his past, because he hasn’t yet done the work he needs to do. He still believes he deserves to be trapped, defined, by what happened to him.

But the series plants the seeds for the change that we know is coming: When he’s alone in that room of his, he’s turning his experience into the one-man show that will become Baby Reindeer. It’s that process of transmutation and creation that will ultimately allow him to process his abuse and turn it into something that engages with the wider world, and grant him the ability, finally, to heal.

Advertisement

Maybe, in the process, he will manage to move past finding other queer folk and fat people disgusting. Baby Reindeer suggests that Richard Gadd hasn’t quite managed to do that, yet.

But I’m holding out hope for Donny.

Continue Reading

Trending