Montana
Montana hunters: Pheasant stocking hurts youth and birds
Laura Lundquist
(Missoula Present) This weekend Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks is holding its Youth Pheasant and Waterfowl Weekend in an effort to recruit younger hunters. Whereas Montana hunters help such alternatives, most say FWP’s pen-raised pheasant hunt is dangerous for each the youngsters and the birds.
The Youth Pheasant Weekend is meant to permit 12- to 15-year-olds who’ve accomplished hunter schooling to hunt with an grownup over a few days once they don’t need to compete with different hunters.
The issue, hunters say, just isn’t the youth occasion however the truth that FWP is paying the Montana State Jail – by means of a division referred to as Montana Correctional Enterprises – to place prisoners to work elevating the birds for launch. And FWP is utilizing greater than $1 million of federal Pittman-Robertson cash and sportsmen’s license {dollars} to do it.
In opposition to the need of many Montana hunters, the 2021 Legislature handed Home Invoice 637, a hodgepodge of things proposed by the FWP Administrators Workplace, that included spending about $1 million on a pheasant stocking program.
That is now the second yr of this system, and its reputation amongst hunters hasn’t improved. Previous makes an attempt in Montana and people in different states have proven that stocking pen-raised pheasants isn’t cost-effective and doesn’t present an excellent expertise for younger hunters.
A number of efforts had been made to get remark from FWP spokesman Greg Lemon however they had been ignored.
Final yr, FWP did a “soft-release” of two,700 pheasants, however this system hadn’t had a lot time after the invoice was signed to get going. So the company ended up releasing immature birds that wouldn’t flush from the bottom.
Former FWP biologist Jeff Herbert stated it didn’t educate youngsters tips on how to be good hunters.
“Some associates noticed the discharge at Lake Helena final yr. The birds had been poorly feathered and didn’t know any higher. Some flew onto the street and had been getting run over,” Herbert stated. “Some people within the gun-dog membership who had been mentoring stated quite a few the birds had been getting sluiced on the bottom, so we’re not instilling the looking ethics and duties in younger youngsters.”
The prisoners have had a little bit extra time this yr, however that doesn’t imply the subsequent batch of birds are going to supply any higher expertise for teenagers.
Walker Conyngham, president of Hellgate Hunters and Anglers in Missoula, stated FWP director Hank Worsech stated there’s no science telling him to not do it. However a scientific evaluate of pheasant-rearing applications in a number of states discovered most artificially reared birds die inside a number of weeks of launch and the principle reason behind the excessive mortality price is predation, partly as a result of they don’t know tips on how to act within the wild.
FWP launched its pheasants per week in the past so it’s unlikely that many stay for teenagers to hunt this weekend.
“We hunted a (wildlife administration space) that had birds on it final yr. Noticed 150 birds in the midst of a stubble subject that had been flying round like a flock of geese. They weren’t in good habitat – it was habitat that I assume seemed like what they had been raised in,” Conyngham stated.
Herbert stated FWP has already tried stocking pheasants and it was unsuccessful. After a couple of decade of elevating pheasants close to Heat Springs, FWP shut the pheasant farm down within the 1980’s as a result of it was deemed ineffective and too expensive.
“I keep in mind tales from Bob Inexperienced who managed the power. They used to simply snicker, saying ‘We’d launch these birds and it was only a dinner bell for something that thought the birds had been good to eat,” Herbert stated. “The one method to do it’s launch them proper in entrance of the gun and that’s primarily a capturing protect. This takes wildlife administration areas, that are supposed to point out the most effective of what we do, and turns them right into a de facto capturing protect.”
Studying good ethics is a giant a part of studying to hunt, and canned hunts don’t educate that. Plopping a bunch of younger birds in a subject for teenagers to shoot doesn’t educate something about truthful chase, which says animals shouldn’t be put at an obstacle.
“It sends younger hunters the fallacious message: habitat doesn’t matter, simply put out some extra birds. It’s a one-and-done form of factor. Throw a number of pheasants on the market and children are going to possibly get some pictures after which it’s accomplished,” Munther stated.
Conyngham thinks most children need the actual deal slightly than a man-made hunt. Much like fishing in a stocked kiddie pond, a rigged hunt tends to thrill solely little youngsters. And in the event that they do kill a chicken, it units youngsters as much as count on they’ll stroll out and bag a chicken in a number of hours. They’re studying tips on how to shoot however not tips on how to hunt ethically.
“I query whether or not it’s price it. It took me some time to get my first chicken – it was a wild chicken out on the Entrance – nevertheless it was actually price it,” Conyngham stated.
Many query why the Montana state jail was chosen to boost the pheasants. FWP proposed the deal after the state jail misplaced a 30-year contract to exploit cows for Darigold. The Division of Corrections misplaced $1.5 million of funding for its work program, which Joliet Republican Seth Berglee made up for utilizing FWP cash with Home Invoice 637.
“It’s making a make-work undertaking for the jail by robbing {dollars} from the wildlife administration applications,” stated Missoula hunter Greg Munther, a retired Forest Service biologist. “It’s actually stealing from the sportsmen. It’s been confirmed time and again to be a waste of {dollars}. I testified one time saying pen-raised pheasants are form of like placing leghorn chickens out within the subject and anticipating them to be there when the hunters arrive. They’ve an especially low survival price and harvest price and an especially excessive price per chicken.”
If FWP needed to inventory pheasants, Herbert stated, there ought to have been a bidding course of or financial evaluation as as to if a non-public farm may do it extra economically.
A number of research present that the cash could be higher spent on preserving and bettering good habitat for wild pheasants which are already right here. These birds have discovered tips on how to take care of predators and survive Montana’s climate.
Even so, the latest drought has stress pheasants in some areas in order that they want all the assistance they’ll get. Good habitat with water, meals and canopy provides them an edge. Research present that translocation of untamed birds is way more efficient if areas have to be stocked.
Munther stated there are such a lot of higher choices for offering youngsters with high-quality alternatives. Years in the past, he unsuccessfully tried to get FWP to designate a number of Block Administration areas only for youth all through the season.
Block administration areas are personal lands the place landowners have contracted with FWP to permit entry to public hunters. Munther stated that would assist dad and mom who can’t take their youngsters out in the course of the Youth Weekend. Plus, pheasants are inclined to desire the fields and prairie of central and japanese Montana so western Montana isn’t a pheasant hub. So there aren’t any pheasant alternatives for teenagers in Area 2.
“So the dad and mom who couldn’t make the opening weekend may take their youngsters out after college at instances once they may. I feel landowners who usually don’t need to become involved in block administration would if it was for youth,” Munther stated.
Throughout a public assembly with Worsech in Missoula a number of weeks in the past, Conyngham raised the difficulty of pen-raised pheasants being a waste of FWP cash and requested Worsech if he would ask legislators in the course of the upcoming session to discontinue this system if an evaluation confirmed it was ineffective. Worsech stated no as a result of he didn’t know if it was ineffective.
“Will it work? I do not know,” Worsech stated on the Sept. 7 assembly.
FWP isn’t doing any monitoring or evaluation of this system. They aren’t monitoring hunter curiosity; they aren’t tagging birds to search out what number of hunters take; they usually aren’t attaching radio transmitters to estimate what number of is perhaps killed by predators. Not accumulating knowledge ensures this system can proceed as a result of there’s no proof both method, which frustrates hunters.
“There are higher methods to enhance hunter recruitment that throwing out a bunch of tame birds. I’d like to see some extra accountability. This is happening for the subsequent 5 years at this level,” Conyngham stated.
As a FWP biologist specializing in migratory birds, Herbert was energetic in attempting to recruit chicken hunters and noticed a variety of enhancements through the years within the social science of hunter recruitment, together with with the ability to analyze license knowledge.
“We developed an evaluation primarily based upon age teams: at what age are we bringing them in and the place are they dropping out,” Herbert stated. “The massive drawback with this present effort: It sounds good, however there’s nothing right here that’s primarily based on any form of knowledge that we have now in hand if somebody needed to do an evaluation earlier than you spend $1 million. (
FWP Particular Packages director) Deb O’Niel instructed somebody that their success metric was smiles on faces. I assumed ‘Bullshit, you don’t spend 1,000,000 {dollars} to see six smiles in the event you discuss to 10 youngsters.’ Efficiency metrics and measures of success are lacking from this complete factor. It amazes me that there’s nothing right here for say a legislative analyst to have a look at and communicate as to if that is profitable or not.”
Pheasants have been launched within the following wildlife administration areas: Area 1: North Shore WMA; Foys Bend Fisheries Conservation Space Area 3: Canyon Ferry WMA, Lake Helena WMA Area 4: Freezout Lake WMA Area 5: Grant Marsh WMA, Yellowstone WMA Area 6: Vandalia WMA, Cree Crossing WMA, Sleeping Buffalo WMA, Fresno WMA, Rookery WMA Area 7: Isaac Homestead WMA
Contact reporter Laura Lundquist at lundquist@missoulacurrent.
Montana
Land Board approves 33,000-acre conservation easement in northwest Montana
A proposal to put nearly 33,000 acres of working forestland in northwest Montana into a conservation easement has cleared its last major hurdle.
In a 3-1 vote on Monday, the Montana Land Board adopted language amending an agreement between timber company Green Diamond and Montana Fish, Wildlife, and Parks that closes the book on a conservation project that took four years and nearly $40 million to finalize.
The Montana Great Outdoors Conservation Easement is located between Kalispell and Libby and encompasses parts of the Salish and Cabinet mountains. The roughly 33,000 acres of land will be protected from development to support wildlife habitat and “key landscape connectivity,” according to FWP.
An FWP memo on the project says the easement also provides “permanent free public recreation access” to the enrolled lands while sustaining their use as a working forest.
The U.S. Forest Service’s Montana Forest Legacy Program is putting $20 million toward the easement. Habitat Montana, a fund administered by FWP, is contributing $1.5 million, and the Trust for Public Lands coordinated another $4.2 million of financial support for the project. Finally, Green Diamond is donating about $14 million of the land’s value.
The easement is perpetual, meaning the terms of the agreement will remain in effect indefinitely, even if Green Diamond later sells the land.
In addition to supporting long-term timber harvest, the easement will confer tax benefits to Green Diamond, which owns and manages working forests in nine states throughout the southern and western U.S. According to a FAQ on the easement, Green Diamond will continue to pay local property taxes in Lincoln, Sanders and Flathead counties once the easement is recorded.
The easement faced a tumultuous path to adoption. When the Land Board first voted on it in October, WRH Nevada Properties, which owns the mineral estate beneath approximately half of the 33,000 acres, argued that the easement jeopardized its ability to develop the subsurface mineral estate.
Peter Scott, an attorney representing WRH and Citizens for Balanced Use, argued before the Land Board on Oct. 21 that the board would be ill-advised to authorize the easement while a lawsuit over it is pending, and given that ground-disturbing activities are “not compatible” with the Montana Forest Legacy Program’s purpose.
“The folks that fund mineral exploration are not looking for conservation easements as part of their program,” Scott said. “In fact, they’re leaving and taking their mineral exploration money elsewhere. From their standpoint, Montana is not open for business in the context of mineral exploration.”
To help alleviate that concern, the board voted in October to draft language recognizing its intention to protect the mineral rights holders’ ability to access and develop their mineral rights within the easement’s bounds.
The board’s 3-1 vote effectively alters the easement to read that the mineral rights holders “shall not be infringed upon.” The mineral rights holder will retain the ability to “enter and use the [conserved land] for exploration, recovery and development of the minerals consistent with state law,” per the language adopted by the board.
State Superintendent and Land Board member Elsie Arntzen opposed a final vote on the easement, arguing that more discussion is needed and indicating that the state Legislature, which is set to gavel in for its biennial session next month, may be inclined to weigh in. She sought to postpone final action until at least the spring, a delay Gov. Greg Gianforte did not support for fear it would compromise the Forest Service’s $20 million contribution to the easement.
RELATED
Habitat conservation in Montana undergoing a ‘sea change’
When Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks quietly unveiled a proposal to put Habitat Montana funds toward 30- and 40-year conservation leases, proponents described it as a “new conservation planning tool” while opponents warned of a “sea change” that could weaken one of the state’s most popular habitat protection programs.
“The staff worked with all of the concerned parties to get language that was agreeable. For us to make additional changes here, without consultation with all of the parties, would put us in a difficult position,” Gianforte said, adding that Arntzen had effectively missed her window to oppose the easement writ large.
“At this point, the easement has been approved, subject to this language,” Gianforte continued. “I feel a strong compunction to honor the local consensus which has been built around this, which I think is reflected in this modified language.”
Arntzen also attempted to issue a “no” vote by proxy for Montana Attorney General and Land Board member Austin Knudsen. Gianforte, who chairs the Land Board, said only members who are actively present can vote.
Gianforte also struck down an amendment offered by Secretary of State and Land Board member Christi Jacobsen to make the easement subject to a 99-year term rather than perpetual.
The easement “has been granted, has been finalized,” Gianforte said. “So I would rule your amendment out of order.”
A variety of conservation and forestry-oriented organizations support the easement, arguing that it contributes to conservation and recreational objectives, and supports local economies reliant on forestry by facilitating access to a long-term timber supply. Those groups include Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation, Montana Wildlife Federation, Trust for Public Land, Montana Wood Products Association, Montana Logging Association,Stimson Lumber and FH Stoltze Land & Lumber.
A trio of current and former elected officials opposed the easement in a letter to the Land Board, arguing that more due diligence should have been done to assess the prevalence of subsurface minerals and communicate with WRH about the project. A letter signed by Rep. Steve Gunderson, R-Libby; Sen. Dan Bartel, R-Lewistown; and Kerry White, a former state representative from Bozeman who now leads Citizens for Balanced Use, a nearly 20-year-old nonprofit that calls for more motorized recreation and resource development on public land.
The second stage of the Montana Great Outdoors Conservation Easement is still in development. It’s estimated to top 52,000 acres to the west and south of the Lost Trail National Wildlife Refuge.
LATEST STORIES
Little green surprises
Green pasta is easy to make, and a festive option for holiday lasagna and more.
Little Shell Tribe marks 5 years of federal recognition
Five years after federal recognition, the Little Shell tribe is starting to see its holdings grow around its Great Falls headquarters. The tribe has institutionalized cultural programs, developed housing assistance with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development and made business investments around the region.
The Session: We’re back. So are newly elected party leaders.
The Session is back for the 69th Montana Legislature. This week, we preview lawmakers work that starts January 6. Reporters talk about new party leaders, legislative rules, and how the governor wants to spend public money.
Montana
Search for missing Montana woman suspended at landfill north of Great Falls
How to report a missing person
Here’s how to take action when a person goes missing.
The search for a missing Conrad woman at the High Plains Landfill north of Great Falls has been suspended, the Cascade County Sheriff’s Office announced on Monday afternoon.
Alicia Wood, 46, was last seen on Nov. 22 and was reported missing on Nov. 30 to the Conrad Police Department. Wood’s car was found abandoned on the side of Highway 91 between Conrad and Brady and blood was later found inside the vehicle.
The Montana Department of Criminal Investigation took over the case and a lead prompted a search for Wood at the landfill. The search began on Dec. 5 and lasted nine days.
“The is not a decision we took lightly, however, we feel we have conducted a thorough search of our landfill based on the information and leads provided,” Cascade County Sheriff Jesse Slaughter said in a statement.
DCI and the Pondera County Sheriff’s Office will continue to lead the investigation.
“As I said at the beginning of our search this is just one lead in this investigation. I’m confident that the Division of Criminal Investigation will continue to follow all current and future leads,” Slaughter said.
Anyone with information about the disappearance of Alicia Woods is asked to contact the Division of Criminal Investigation by calling or 406-444-3874 or emailing contactdci@mt.gov.
The Cascade County Sheriff’s Office also thanked the numerous law enforcement and civilian agencies who assisted in the landfill search, as well as community supporters who provided meals for the search party.
Montana
7 Most Unconventional Towns In Montana
Millions of Americans and visitors from all over the world come every year to Montana, and perhaps most know the Big Sky Country state for its access to renowned national parks, like Glacier and Yellowstone. But it offers so much more. A confluence of cultural forces has shaped this region — from the Native American traditions to the gold rushes — and it is that Old West spirit that Montana’s residents have proudly kept alive. In Montana, we’ve discovered seven of the most unconventional towns. They dot the Montana map, inviting visitors to experience and be fully immersed in the state’s heritage and traditions.
Philipsburg brings a bygone mining era back to life. Red Lodge is the ultimate rugged alpine experience. Bigfork is valued for its art scene and summer theater. Livingstone is the “Gateway to Yellowstone.” Virginia City is a well-preserved gold rush historical experience. Whitefish is a haven for outdoorsy types, but it also has a touch of sophistication. Fort Benton, is remembered as the “Birthplace of Montana.” Join the tour and discover how each of these towns is as unique as the landscapes they inhabit.
Philipsburg
Nested in a verdant valley between the Sapphire Mountains and Flint Creek is the town of Philipsburg, with its dense pine forests and alpine lakes. The downtown is marked by restored 19th-century buildings with colorful frontages. The friendly town has a nostalgic vibe with its antique shops and boutique shopping, such as the Sweet Palace, a candy store. Historical landmarks include the Opera House Theatre, built in 1891, and The Granite Country Museum, showcasing the town’s mining heritage. Sapphire mining at Gem Mountain is a unique experience. The Granite Ghost Town State Park and the annual Flint Creek Valley Days festival with its parade and live music make Philipsburg extra special.
Red Lodge
With access to Beartooth Highway, what has been dubbed “the most beautiful drive in America,” Red Lodge is an exceptional town. The downtown boasts of Wild West-style architecture, with saloons, eateries and art galleries. Historical landmarks are The Carbon County Historical Society and Museum, displaying the town’s ranching and mining history. Commercial attractions include the Yellowstone Wildlife Sanctuary. The town is settled at the base of the Beartooth Mountains and surrounded by rolling meadows.
Bigfork
Enveloped by forests, rolling hills and settled along the northeastern shore of Flathead Lake is the town of Bigfork. Bigfork’s downtown blends rustic log cabins with modern designs. The charming town is lined with bistros, galleries and shops. The town has a thriving art scene, annual events like the Bigfork Festival of the Arts, brings the whole community together. Wayfarers State Park provides breathtaking views of Flathead Lake and is rich in Native American history. One thing that is special about this town is The Bigfork Summer Playhouse, a seasonal theater that has given the town the nickname “Montana’s Broadway.”
Livingston
Downtown Livingston with its turn-of-the-century brick buildings hosting quirky cafes, bars and bookshops, presents residents and visitors with a relaxed, artsy vibe. The town is prized as a “foodie paradise” with local favorites like Fainting Goat Pub and Engine Room Deep Dish Pizza. Lying along the Yellowstone River, the small town is surrounded by the Crazy and Absaroka mountains. One thing that stands out is Livingston hosts an annual famous rodeo and has become known as the “Gateway to Yellowstone.” The Livingston Depot Center is a restored train station, which showcases the town’s railroad history. Livingston is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts with activities like fly-fishing, hiking and, of course, access to Yellowstone National Park.
Virginia City
Once known as “Fourteen Mile City,” the gold rush era town of Virginia City is based in a valley and surrounded by sagebrush hills and the Tobacco Root Mountains. During its heyday period the town was regarded as a social center and transportation hub in the region. Today the entire town is a historic site. Something that makes Virginia City unusual is the town actors that bring the mid-1800s to life again. The small settlement feels like a well-preserved ghost town with its wooden sidewalks, saloons, and mercantile shops. Be sure not to miss the Virginia City Opera House and Alder Gulch. Visitors can pan for gold and take a historic stagecoach ride.
Whitefish
The town of Whitefish has a unique tradition, known as their annual Huckleberry Days, which celebrates the local berry. A gateway to Glacier National Park, surrounded by forests and lakes with views of Big Mountain, Whitefish is plentiful in natural beauties, with much to explore and see. The downtown combines rustic architecture with a sophisticated modern touch. Be sure to check out the Whitefish Farmers’ Market, along with the many fine dining options and boutiques. Big Mountain has the best skiing in the winter and the tail rides through Bar W Guest Ranch are second to none. No visit to Whitefish is complete without some time by or on the water. Whitefish City Beach is a great place for the whole family to play. The Great Northern Railway Depot and Whitefish Lake State Parks are historical landmarks.
Fort Benton
When visitors drive past herds of antelope and deer while enjoying majestic views in all directions, they quickly come to understand why Fort Benton has been praised for its beauty by both Forbes and National Geographic Traveler. Located along the Missouri River and surrounded by rolling planes and the region’s rich agricultural land, Fort Benton is a gem of a town. Fort Benton’s downtown blends well-maintained frontier-era buildings and modern designs. Landmarks include The Lewis and Clark Memorial and the Museum of the Upper Missouri, which display the town’s role in westward expansion. Be sure to book boat tours with groups like Upper Missouri River Guides for excursions along the Missouri River that showcase views of bluffs and local wildlife.
Parting Thoughts
Montana is the fourth-largest state in the U.S., covering over 147,000 square miles. Its name comes from the Spanish word montaña, meaning “mountain,” reflecting its dramatic landscapes. The Missouri River, one of North America’s longest rivers, begins in Montana. The state experiences a range of weather, from snowy winters to warm summers. Rich in history, Montana was once home to Native American tribes like the Crow and Blackfeet. Today, it’s celebrated for its outdoor recreation, including hiking, fishing, and skiing. These seven most unconventional towns in Montana are each marked out for something special in their natures, which have become woven together into the cultural tapestry of this Old West state. From world class national parks to outstanding natural wonders to rich Native American and gold rush histories, these towns are quintessentially Montana.
-
Technology1 week ago
Struggling to hear TV dialogue? Try these simple fixes
-
Business1 week ago
OpenAI's controversial Sora is finally launching today. Will it truly disrupt Hollywood?
-
Politics4 days ago
Canadian premier threatens to cut off energy imports to US if Trump imposes tariff on country
-
Technology5 days ago
Inside the launch — and future — of ChatGPT
-
Technology3 days ago
OpenAI cofounder Ilya Sutskever says the way AI is built is about to change
-
Politics3 days ago
U.S. Supreme Court will decide if oil industry may sue to block California's zero-emissions goal
-
Politics5 days ago
Conservative group debuts major ad buy in key senators' states as 'soft appeal' for Hegseth, Gabbard, Patel
-
Technology3 days ago
Meta asks the US government to block OpenAI’s switch to a for-profit