Connect with us

World

Diplomatic failings and ‘elite bargains’ prolonging Libya turmoil: Analysts

Published

on

Diplomatic failings and ‘elite bargains’ prolonging Libya turmoil: Analysts

After weeks of tension that saw the Central Bank of Libya (CBL) shuttered, salaries go unpaid and cash vanish, the country’s two rival governments appeared ready to accept a United Nations-brokered agreement to resume operations,  before once more reverting to a deadlock familiar to many in the country.

The internationally recognised Government of National Accord (GNA) in the west had tried to replace CBL Governor Sadiq al-Kabir, accusing him of mishandling oil revenues and going to the extent of sending armed men in to remove him from his office.

Angered, the Government of National Unity (GNU) in eastern Libya, which is supported by renegade commander Khalifa Haftar, shut down much of the country’s oil production, which it controls, in protest.

“This is serious,” said Jalel Harchaoui, an associate fellow with London’s Royal United Services Institute. “The CBL, although weaker now than it was a few years ago, remains a linchpin to the nation’s access to hard currency.”

He added that the CBL funds most of Libya’s imports of food, medicines and other staples, which the country cannot last long without.

Advertisement

The clash is the latest battleground in the 13-year rivalry between political and military elites that has dogged Libya since the overthrow of long-term ruler Muammar Gaddafi in 2011.

Since then, various analysts say, life in Libya has deteriorated as fighting has continued between rival Libyans and as the international community has tried to preserve the rule of a political and military elite, convinced they are the best for stability and for the proclaimed goal of “unifying Libya”.

Why the central bank?

As well as holding Libya’s vast oil wealth, the CBL unified Libya’s eastern and western “central banks” in one body to manage the salaries of civil servants and soldiers from both governments and build confidence that recovery was possible.

After the GNA-GNU struggle over who would head the CBL, al-Kabir fled the country, claiming that he took the access codes for bank deposits with him, leaving the bank isolated from international financial networks.

Asim al-Hajjaji, director of the CBL compliance department, said international contacts had been restored, although Al Jazeera understands that most international trading remains suspended.

Advertisement
Soldiers guard the gate of the Central Bank of Libya in Tripoli, on August 27, 2024 [Yousef Murad/AP Photo]

Meanwhile, oil exports have plunged to a new low, salaries are uncertain and everyday life for about six million Libyans is in turmoil.

“The United Nations is talking about talks, which is a sure sign we’re nowhere near resolution,” Tarek Megerisi, a senior fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said of negotiations to restart operations at CBL.

The West, which typically backs the GNA despite it being responsible for much of the uncertainty, “doesn’t know what to do, or really has the bandwidth to do it. They’re dealing with wars in Gaza and Ukraine,” he said.

“It’s just too much. In Libya, international efforts to achieve any kind of just settlement have lost momentum.”

And this is far from the first time.

Advertisement

Over more than a decade of uncertainty and war, analysts say, the international community’s efforts focused on shoring up the country’s elites in the hope that might lead to stability.

The latest talks over the CBL appear little different, with access to the millions of dollars in assets of primary interest to the country’s elites, and access to the services and certainty craved by much of the population seemingly an afterthought, analysts told Al Jazeera.

Elite bargains presiding over endless turmoil

“Preventing a shooting war has come to be seen as the only international strategy in Libya,” Tim Eaton, a senior fellow at Chatham House who contributed to a paper on the international practice of prioritising powerful elites, told Al Jazeera.

“It’s death by a thousand cuts,” Harchaoui said.

“Everyone’s talking about a return to the status quo as if there were ever a neat, static equilibrium,” he noted. “This was never the case. Even when things appeared quiet, the arrangements were continually decaying and degrading. And that gradual deterioration is what suddenly became visible last month with the CBL crisis.”

Advertisement

National elections, or even a framework that might lead to them, remain a distant prospect after the last vote, initially scheduled for December 2021, was postponed after infighting.

“Any move towards holding national elections has been blocked,” Eaton said. “Both [Abdul Hamid] Dbeibah [head of the GNA] and Haftar might say they want elections tomorrow, but they only really want their side, or at least their proxies, on the ballot paper.”

Both governments continue to rule separately, while their members, allies and militias profit from smuggling in both people and fuel and unregulated cross-border trade.

Members of Libyan National Army (LNA) commanded by Khalifa Haftar, get ready before heading out of Benghazi to reinforce the troops advancing to Tripoli
Members of the so-called ‘Libyan National Army’, commanded by Khalifa Haftar, get ready to head out of Benghazi to reinforce troops advancing to Tripoli, in Benghazi on April 13, 2019 [Esam Omran Al-Fetori/Reuters]

However, as individual members jockey for position within small and exclusive circles, systems intended to support everyday life in Libya continue to deteriorate and fail.

Eaton notes that the city of Derna, which flooded in September 2023 after a dam that the GNU was responsible for collapsed, remains unreconstructed.

“For healthcare, Libyans have to go overseas,” he noted. “And if anyone is ever caught in an emergency, there’s no one number or department they can call.

Advertisement

“All the while, the super-rich that are supposed to be looking after people, are getting even richer.”

Both sides, he explained, claim to work towards establishing a central government while state institutions needed to oversee any future state, like a strong central bank, have been hollowed out and captured by elites on either side.

Regionally, over its 13 years of sporadic conflict and political uncertainty, Libya has become a continued source of instability within an already unstable region.

Within a divided Libya, various actors have come to use the country’s east as a staging point from which to project their own international ambitions in Sudan, Syria and beyond.

FILE PHOTO: Governor of Central Bank of Libya, Siddiq al-Kabir gestures during an interview with Reuters in Tripoli, Libya
Ex-Governor of CBL Siddiq al-Kabir in an interview with Reuters in Tripoli on September 1, 2021 [Hazem Ahmed/Reuters]

Overwhelming human cost

In addition to the uncertainty piled on the Libyan population are the more than 1,000 refugees, irregular migrants and asylum seekers who have died or gone missing on the Central Mediterranean migration route, in which Libya is a key part, this year.

“The West and UN in Libya are performing diplomatic theatre while the country crumbles,” Anas El Gomati of the Sadeq Institute said.

Advertisement

“They have a toolbox of leverage gathering dust. Instead of applying pressure, they’re enabling corruption by legitimising those without electoral mandate or political credibility. That’s not diplomacy; that’s complicity in slow motion.”

El Gomati continued: “East or west, Libya’s compass points to chaos and corruption. Haftar and his kids carve out a fiefdom through war crimes in the east, while Dbeibah runs a ‘pay-as-you-go’ loyalty scheme with armed groups in the west.

“The irony? The elites don’t trust the very banking system they’ve bled dry, so they keep their assets overseas, which the West could freeze, but they’re too busy shaking hands with the very hands pickpocketing Libya’s future.

“Western policymakers and Libyan elites are locked in a race to the bottom of delusion and greed,” El Gomati concluded. “The West sees a finish line; the elites see an endless buffet. It’s not naivete, it’s willful blindness, and the Libyan people are paying for it. In the Libyan elite’s casino, the house always wins, and corruption is the chip that never runs out.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

World

Video: Zelensky Warns World Leaders of Continued Russian Threats

Published

on

Video: Zelensky Warns World Leaders of Continued Russian Threats

new video loaded: Zelensky Warns World Leaders of Continued Russian Threats

transcript

transcript

Zelensky Warns World Leaders of Continued Russian Threats

The president of Ukraine called Russia’s push for more land “insane” in his speech to world leaders at the U.N. General Assembly in New York.

There can be no just peace without Ukraine. And I thank every leader, every country that supports us in this, that understands us, that sees how Russia, a country more than 20 times larger than Ukraine in territory, still wants even more land — more land, which is insane — and is seizing it day by day while wanting to destroy its neighbor. I want peace for my people, real peace and just peace. And I am asking for your support from all nations of the world. We do not divide the world. I ask the same of you. Do not divide the world. Be United Nations, and that will bring us peace. Thank you. Slava Ukraini.

Advertisement

Recent episodes in Ukraine Crisis

Continue Reading

World

Hungarian FM recalls strong Trump admin 'experience,' claims 'our hope is all' on former president

Published

on

Hungarian FM recalls strong Trump admin 'experience,' claims 'our hope is all' on former president

Join Fox News for access to this content

Plus special access to select articles and other premium content with your account – free of charge.

By entering your email and pushing continue, you are agreeing to Fox News’ Terms of Use and Privacy Policy, which includes our Notice of Financial Incentive.

Please enter a valid email address.

Having trouble? Click here.

UNITED NATIONS, New York – Hungarian Foreign Minister Peter Szijjártó revealed in an interview with Fox News Digital that former President Donald Trump alone is his country’s “hope” for helping bring stability to a fraught and increasingly chaotic international security landscape. 

“We do believe that actually the game changer here can be the U.S. presidential election, in case President Trump wins,” Szijjártó said, referring specifically to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. “Because knowing Trump, I think it’s absolutely possible – absolutely likely – that with two phone calls he can end this conflict.” 

Advertisement

“No one else can do so,” he insisted. “I think only President Trump has the hope and our hope is all in President Trump to do this.”

When pressed on whether that could be understood as a preference for a second Trump administration, Szijjártó insisted that “We are not Americans, so we cannot say we prefer this or that.” 

EL SALVADOR’S BUKELE SLAMS CENSORSHIP AS HE TOUTS HIS COUNTRY’S TURNAROUND: ‘WE HAVE FREED MILLIONS’

“What we can definitely say is the following: Politics is based on experience, and we have a clear experience about the term of President Trump in office, and we have clear experience from the terms when the Democrats were there,” he said. 

Minister of Foreign Affairs of Hungary Peter Szijjarto addresses the 79th United Nations General Assembly at U.N. headquarters in New York City on Sept. 25, 2024. (Reuters/Eduardo Munoz)

Advertisement

“From the aspect of the U.S.-Hungary relations and from the aspect of the global security situation, when it comes to the U.S.-Hungary relations, it’s obvious that during President Trump[‘s term] these relations have been on the top – best ever,” Szijjártó added. 

Trump and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán have done little to hide their rosy friendship, with Trump invoking the Hungarian leader as a “strong man of Europe” who speaks well of the former president. 

DANNY DANON: UN ABDICATES ROLE OF MIDDLE EAST PEACEMAKER BY BACKING TERRORISTS

Orbán proved this is a mutual dynamic when he chose to leave the NATO summit in Washington, D.C., earlier this year to instead meet with Trump in Mar-a-Lago in Florida to discuss foreign relations.

Hungary foreign policy

Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, left, with former President Donald Trump during his visit to Mar-a-Lago on Thursday, July 11, 2024. (@PM_ViktorOrban)

“Under President Trump, everything was under control,” Szijjártó said. “Since President Trump has left office, the whole global security situation is deteriorating, so, I mean, these are experiences.” 

Advertisement

“If we base it on our experience, we say yes, from a perspective of U.S.-Hungary relations, I think President Trump would bring another impetus, freshness, dynamism to this relationship, and I think if President Trump is elected, I think the world has a good chance to become a more peaceful place compared to the current situation.” 

Trump shakes hands with Orban outside the White House

Then-President Donald Trump, left, shakes hands with Viktor Orban, Hungary’s prime minister, at the West Wing of the White House in Washington, D.C., on Monday, May 13, 2019. (Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Szijjártó argued that “if you look at an administration which is led by a president and vice president, and we didn’t hear too much initiatives from the vice president … means to me that the vice president was part of the structure 100%.” He noted that this comment came from a personal opinion “based on logic” and not the opinion of the Hungarian foreign minister. 

ARGENTINA’S PRESIDENT JAVIER MILEI SAYS UN TURNING INTO ‘LEVIATHAN’ LIKE ORGANIZATION

Hungary has attempted to pursue peace talks between Ukraine and Russia, positioning itself as a chief facilitator for resolving the conflict. Hungary assumed the presidency of the European Union as part of a rotating six-month structure.

Orbán seized on the opportunity to visit both Russian President Vladimir Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy within the first days after taking the seat, but European leaders moved quickly to stress that the role is purely ceremonial and that Hungary had no official capacity to represent Europe in any peace talks. 

Advertisement
Hungarian Foreign Minister

Hungarian Foreign Minister Peter Szijjarto spoke with Fox News Digital on politics and tensions in the international security landscape. (Fox News Digital)

Szijjártó blasted those who criticized the Hungarian effort, claiming “those who have been criticizing us, the prime minister, the peace mission, have clearly been the pro-war politicians.” 

“They just simply don’t like that there is a country, there is a government, there is a prime minister in Europe who speaks direct language, who speaks honestly and who is not a hostage of the liberal mainstream,” Szijjártó said. “Therefore, it is very unpleasant and inconvenient for them that we are there and that we act, that we speak, that we make actions.”

Szijjártó resisted the idea that Ukraine should join NATO, noting that “including Ukraine into NATO would put us in a totally exposed situation, security-wise, because it would mean that NATO could be easily dragged into a war against Russia at any time, and this is something that we don’t want.” 

“Everyone knows that any kind of direct confrontation between NATO and Russia would mean an outbreak of Third World War immediately, and we have joined the NATO to enhance our security and not to make ourselves exposed,” he said.  

Advertisement
Continue Reading

World

Several Ukrainian cities hit in Russian overnight aerial attack

Published

on

Several Ukrainian cities hit in Russian overnight aerial attack

At least eight people were injured in Zaporizhzhia, and Ukrainian air defences battled additional missiles and drones over Kyiv for over five hours.

ADVERTISEMENT

Several Ukrainian cities, including Zaporizhzhia, Ivano-Frankivsk, and Kyiv, were struck during a night of intense Russian shelling.

Russia launched six missiles and 78 Shahed drones at Ukraine overnight from Wednesday to Thursday, according to Ukraine’s air forces, which reported intercepting and destroying four missiles and 66 drones.

The attack on Zaporizhzhia injured at least eight people, including a 14-year-old boy, according to Governor Ivan Fedorov.

The State Emergency Service released a video of severely damaged residential houses with blown-out windows and shrapnel-pierced walls, reporting that 12 buildings were affected and 18 people evacuated.

“Launching strikes against the civilian population, and doing it at night, is the peak of Russian cynicism,” Fedorov wrote on his Telegram page. “Russia is a terrorist country. The world must stop this arbitrariness!!!” he added.

Advertisement

In a separate attack, the wreckage of a Russian drone damaged a critical infrastructure facility in Ivano-Frankivsk, causing a fire, but no one was injured.

The attack caused damage to power grids. Four central streets of the city and some of the adjacent ones remain without power. Power engineers are currently repairing the damage.

Some of the city’s educational institutions will have power outages for at least a day, while trolleybuses have stopped running on certain routes. The authorities plan to provide additional buses as replacements.

Russian missiles and drones target Kyiv for over five hours

Ukraine’s air defences also battled Russian missiles and drones over the capital Kyiv for over five hours, the Ukrainian Air Force said.

The attack injured at least two people, according to Ukraine’s Emergency Service. A nursery, a gas pipe and around 20 cars were damaged in the city, the Kyiv Military Administration said.

Advertisement

Long-range strikes have been a hallmark of Russia’s military campaign in Ukraine, now deep in its third year, often hitting civilian areas. Attacks on the electricity network have knocked out around 70% of Ukraine’s energy generation capacity, according to the United Nations, bringing blackouts as winter approaches.

Air defence systems are a critical need for Ukraine, and President Volodymyr Zelenskyy was due to meet President Joe Biden in Washington on Thursday in an effort to ensure continuing US military support for his country.

Continue Reading

Trending