Connect with us

Montana

Last-known images of Montana missing mom caught on tape

Published

on

Last-known images of Montana missing mom caught on tape


On Highway 93, en route to Missoula, it’s hard to miss this billboard and Jermain Charlo’s haunting gaze.

Missoula police detective Guy Baker has been searching for Jermain for more than six years.

Det. Guy Baker: When I see that billboard … I’m frustrated. … We’ve … just time and time again, come up empty handed …

The last known images of Jermain Charlo were captured on surveillance video on Friday, June 15, 2018, in downtown Missoula. Jermain is seen chatting with people outside a bar called The Badlander.

Advertisement
Police in Missoula, Montana, have released security camera video showing 23-year-old Jermain Charlo, who has been missing for more than six years. The video was released exclusively to

Police in Missoula, Montana, have released security camera video showing 23-year-old Jermain Charlo, who has been missing for more than six years. The video was released exclusively to

A little before midnight Jermain walks away from the camera, a man by her side, and disappears into the night.

Six years later, with no arrest and no publicly named suspect, police released the video to “48 Hours” hoping to generate leads.

Det. Guy Baker:  Someone out there knows what happened to Jermain Charlo. … Jermain walks out of view … so, maybe somebody saw something … that has never thought about contacting us. … so, if anybody has any information about that night or any aspect of this investigation. I encourage them to call me.

For Jermain’s aunts, Dani Matt and Valenda Morigeau, this painful ordeal began on Saturday June 16, 2018, with a call from Jermain’s grandmother.

Valenda Morigeau: She was very close with my mom. My mom’s actually the one who had called me and said, “Have you heard from Jermain?” And I said, “No.”

Advertisement

The family says Jermain never went anywhere without her phone, so it would be unusual for her not to text or call. They knew she had been in Missoula.

Valenda Morigeau: So, I kept calling her, calling her …

And when she didn’t answer her phone, Matt had a feeling something wasn’t right.

Dani Matt: We’d called … the hospitals, to the shelters, anywhere we could think of … just ’cause it was not natural for her not to talk to my mother like she did on a daily basis.

Michelle Miller: She disappeared without a trace?

Advertisement

Dani Matt: Nothing.

The family was sick with worry.

No one had heard from her, and she had not returned to her home on the Flathead Reservation, about 40 miles from Missoula. On Monday, June 18, 48 hours after Jermain was last seen, Morigeau contacted authorities for help.

Valenda Morigeau: Because she went missing out of Missoula, I had called Missoula Police Department to … let them know she had gone missing.

Valenda Morigeau: There was, like, no sense of let’s make sure that we check all the boxes and make sure that we’ve done everything that we can to make sure she’s safe.

Advertisement

The family also contacted the Flathead Reservation police.

Police Chief Craige Couture: We try to get as much information out there as we can, try to get flyers, pictures, whatever we can do out there. … As the days go on people start thinking, hold on, maybe there is … more to this than just she’s gone.

Then, on June 20, four days after Jermain disappeared, Morigeau made the drive from the Flathead Reservation to the Missoula Police Department, officially filed a missing person report and met with a detective assigned to Jermain’s case.

Valenda Morigeau: He did his “due diligence,” and he checked the hospitals and the homeless shelters. … I was told that … she was not in immediate danger.

Morigeau knew in her heart Jermain was in immediate danger. Frightened and frustrated, the family reached out again.

Advertisement

THE SEARCH FOR JERMAIN CHARLO

Volunteer searches were organized.

Jen Murphy: I’ve been on a couple of the searches …

Michelle Miller: Describe them to me.

Jen Murphy: They’re heartbreaking.

Advertisement
Jermain Charlo / Credit: Valenda MorigeauJermain Charlo / Credit: Valenda Morigeau

Jermain Charlo / Credit: Valenda Morigeau

Jen Murphy is an educator living in Montana.

Jen Murphy: Every little step that you take … it’s a grid search, so you can’t be any farther than an arms-length apart … so that you don’t miss anything. … So, grid searching a mountain with trees that are right next to each other is almost impossible.

During one of those searches Murphy met Valenda Morigeau.

Michelle Miller: How would you describe your bond with Valenda?

Jen Murphy: She’s like a sister to me now.

Advertisement

Michelle Miller: So, her pain is your pain?

Jen Murphy: Absolutely.

After Jermain had been missing for about 10 days, Baker, who’d just come back from vacation, volunteered to take over the case.

Michelle Miller: Is it unusual for someone to go missing in Missoula?

Det. Guy Baker: Uh, no. No … I think we have sometimes multiple people per week … 97, 98% statewide reported missing people are found … so it’s that 2% that are the difficult ones.

Advertisement

Baker was concerned Jermain’s case was among that difficult 2%. Then, in mid-July, one month after her disappearance, there seemed to be a new and disturbing development.

NEWS REPORT | JILL VALLEY | KPAX: Missoula police are concerned that a missing Dixon woman might be held somewhere against her will tonight. They are continuing to investigate the disappearance of 23-year-old Jermain Charlo who also goes by the name “Liz.”

Det. Guy Baker: We had some information early on that there might have been some people in Missoula from outta state that were trying to buy a girl, and I was thinking there was a connection there.

Brittany Williams: There are thousands of rural areas and miles to go across this state and there are people who are extremely vulnerable.

Brittany Williams is a Missoula County deputy attorney.

Michelle Miller: Human trafficking is a huge problem nationwide … But how does it differ in Montana?

Advertisement

Brittany Williams: I would say it differs from a lack of knowledge.

Brittany Williams: I think people have an idea that Montana is rural and undeveloped, and we don’t have major crimes that occur here, But the fact of the matter is we have one of the largest interstates that runs through our state right here through Missoula, Montana.

Brittany Williams: There are people who can be swept away in an instant and because of … lack of GPS or cell towers you might never hear from that person again, — in a matter of minutes, they could be gone, and they could be trafficked to another state … potentially another country.

If Jermain Charlo was a victim of trafficking could law enforcement find her?

WHERE IS JERMAIN CHARLO?

Advertisement

While Detective Baker was investigating the possibility Jermain Charlo may have been a victim of sex trafficking, her family was desperately trying to get her back home.

Dani Matt: We called her phone … seems like a million times over … tried to Facebook, FaceTime –

Valenda Morigeau: Even from the time she was a little kid … she had like the best personality. she’s very outgoing …

Dani Matt: Beautiful, resilient … animal lover. Oh gosh, the list of pets she had is —

Valenda Morigeau: I think she had, like, a flying squirrel or something.

Advertisement

Dani Matt: And then a pig.

Valenda Morigeau: She had two pigs.

Jermain Charlo fishing with one of her sons.  Jermain Charlo fishing with one of her sons. 

Jermain Charlo fishing with one of her sons.

Valenda Morigeau: She’s very outdoorsy … she had always loved to be by the river and fishing.

Morigeau was only 10 when her niece Jermain was born. Soon they were as close as sisters.

Valenda Morigeau: When she was born, I didn’t like her at all (laughs) … I was the baby of the family, and she stole my thunder … and then one day my grandma was cooking … and Jermain … she needed to be fed. My grandma’s like, “hold this baby.” I was like … I remember like looking at her, I was like, all right you’re not that bad. And then from that day on, she was my baby. … she was my baby sister.

Advertisement

Jermain was creative and imaginative.

Valenda Morigeau: She was an amazing artist.

Her dream was to attend the Institute of American Indian Arts in New Mexico.

Valenda Morigeau: She was like using fingernail polish to make an octopus. … (laughs) she would, like, crochet grocery bags to try to save the environment.

Dani Matt: That girl could do anything she set her mind to. I swear she was so smart and so talented.

Advertisement

Jermain grew up on the Flathead Reservation.

Dani Matt: You’ve got the confluence of the Flathead and Jocko Rivers. You’ve got the bison range right next to you and mountains, you know, as far as you can see. A really strong sense of community.

And Jermain Charlo’s roots run deep on this reservation. She’s a member of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai tribes and a descendant of Chief Charlo, known for his peaceful resistance during the 1870s when the tribe was forced to move from their ancestral land in Montana’s Bitterroot Valley to the Flathead Reservation.

Michelle Miller: We are on tribal land?

Dani Matt: Yes.

Advertisement

Jermain was balancing life while coparenting her two young sons, Jacob and Thomas. Her relationship with their father was strained.

Valenda Morigeau: Oh, she was a great mother. … Her world revolved around those boys. She wanted to teach ’em all about fishing and hunting … take ’em to the fair, try to give ’em the best life she knew how.

Jermain had been working at the Big River Cantina on the Flathead Reservation. She was hoping to find work as a seasonal firefighter and had an interview scheduled. But she didn’t show up.

Michelle Miller: Is she the first Native woman to disappear from the Flathead Reservation?

Brittany Williams: No.

Advertisement

Missoula County Deputy Attorney Brittany Williams knows it all too well. In Montana, Indigenous persons make up only about six percent of the population, but 24 percent of the state’s active missing persons cases.

Michelle Miller: Would you consider it to be an epidemic?

Brittany Williams: I would, yes.

Michelle Miller: And is there any indication why?

Brittany Williams:  I think that there’s — that’s a very complex question. There’s a lot of history there.

Advertisement

Jen Murphy: I think there’s just so many different factors that go into each missing person. From domestic violence to human trafficking, to poverty, to homelessness.

As law enforcement began digging deeper into Jermain Charlo’s disappearance, they would rule out the possibility the 23-year-old mother of two had been a victim of trafficking.

Brittany Williams: That was initially an avenue of investigation … Ultimately, I don’t believe that she was trafficked.

Michelle Miller: Why?

Brittany Williams: I think that we have enough evidence through this investigation that lends itself to believe something else has happened to her.

Advertisement
At left, Jermain Charlo is seen in a TikTok posted the day of her disppearance.  Charlo's family and the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes put her information on a billboard. They hoped that someone would drive by and recognize Jermain. For six years, her gaze has haunted drivers as they travel down that road. / Credit: Valenda Morigeau/CBS NewsAt left, Jermain Charlo is seen in a TikTok posted the day of her disppearance.  Charlo's family and the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes put her information on a billboard. They hoped that someone would drive by and recognize Jermain. For six years, her gaze has haunted drivers as they travel down that road. / Credit: Valenda Morigeau/CBS News

Jermain posted a TikTok video, lip synching lines from a TV show the day she disappeared. It’s the same image seen in her missing poster billboard. She’s wearing the same clothes in the surveillance video.

Baker discovered the video early in his investigation, and he shared excerpts of it with “48 Hours.” He told us that the man standing behind Jermain in the video was Michael DeFrance — Jermain’s ex-boyfriend and the father of their two children. He agreed to speak with police without a lawyer.

Michelle Miller: You believe Michael DeFrance was the last person to see Jermain Charlo?

Det. Guy Baker: That’s what the investigation has determined — and he told us that.

According to police, sometime around midnight, DeFrance and Jermain walked away and got in his 2011 brown Dodge truck.

Advertisement

Det. Guy Baker: He said that uh … they left the downtown area and that he … dropped her off … and that — that ended their night together.

According to law enforcement, “Michael DeFrance stated he dropped Jermain off at the Orange Street Food Farm. Michael DeFrance did this because Jermain stated that her friend ‘Cassidy’ lived nearby, and Jermain was going to spend the night there.”

Michael DeFrance dropped Jermain off at approximately “0100 hours” — 1 a.m. Police didn’t find a “Cassidy,” but they learned Jermain had been visiting Missoula regularly because she was dating a man named Jacob who lived in that neighborhood.

Valenda Morigeau: They had met on a dating app, and they weren’t together for very long … but it seemed like they had a very strong connection, and he was just totally infatuated with her.

Authorities say Jacob was out of town — miles away in another state. Morigeau says he and Jermain were texting each other that night before she disappeared.

Advertisement

Valenda Morigeau: Her plan, according to, like, her message to him, was that she was gonna go back to his place that night ’cause he was out of town.

According to law enforcement, when “Jacob attempted to call Jermain” shortly before 1 a.m. on June 16, he “… thought it was strange because the phone rang several times before it went to voicemail. Jacob felt that somebody purposely ended the call.”

Brittany Williams: And this particular call that was made to her has been shown through the carrier to have been silenced by someone.

Jacob also told police that the day before she disappeared, “Jermain told Jacob that Michael had been yelling at her, asking if she was dating anyone and wanted to get back together with her.”

Police say Jacob cooperated with the investigation and was never considered a suspect.

Advertisement

It’s unsettling to see Jermain Charlo, socializing that night, and Michael DeFrance — the last known person to see her alive — and not know what they were talking about or what may have been going on between them.

DeFrance has not been named as a suspect in Jermain’s disappearance.

“48 Hours” showed the surveillance video to Morigeau and Matt. They’re seeing it for the first time.

If you have any information about Jermain Charlo's disappearance, contact Missoula Police detective Guy Baker at 406-552-6284. / Credit: Missoula Police DepartmentIf you have any information about Jermain Charlo's disappearance, contact Missoula Police detective Guy Baker at 406-552-6284. / Credit: Missoula Police Department

If you have any information about Jermain Charlo’s disappearance, contact Missoula Police detective Guy Baker at 406-552-6284. / Credit: Missoula Police Department

Dani Matt: Mm-hmm, there she is.

Valenda Morigeau: For her to be walking in front of him … it seems like he keeps like trying to catch up to her.

Advertisement

They sensed Jermain was sending a message about DeFrance.

Valenda Morigeau: And she’s … you know we gotta go our separate ways.

KEEPING JERMAIN CHARLO’S CASE RELEVANT

Jermain Charlo never went anywhere without her phone. So, it was crucial for investigators to find it.

Det. Guy Baker: We got cellphone data … linked to Jermain’s cellphone that indicated it was active on the night she disappeared, and it was active multiple times, primarily between the hours of 2 a.m. … and up until just about 10 a.m. on the 16th of June.

Advertisement
When Jermain Charlo's cellphone went silent in June 2018, her family suspected something was wrong. When Jermain Charlo's cellphone went silent in June 2018, her family suspected something was wrong.

When Jermain Charlo’s cellphone went silent in June 2018, her family suspected something was wrong.

Michelle Miller: And where was the phone?

Det. Guy Baker:  So, the phone’s never been recovered, so we don’t know where the phone was, but judging by the information we got from the tower … it was most definitely north of Missoula, and it was in the area of Evaro Hill.

Evaro Hill is on the Flathead Reservation. It’s a rugged area with lots of trees and wildlife. It’s a place Michael DeFrance knows well.

Brittany Williams: He lives specifically up on the Evaro Hill area … he was the last person to be with Jermain Charlo before her life, as we know it, came to a standstill.

Searches have been conducted on Evaro Hill, but Jermain was not found.

Advertisement

Jen Murphy: There’s always that hope that she’s out there somewhere.

Jen Murphy, who has joined several volunteer searches for Jermain, came up with the idea to put Jermain Charlo’s missing poster on a billboard.

Jen Murphy: I currently am doing a project with billboards throughout Montana and throughout the United States. … I try to — have billboards as close to our reservations as possible … trying to make sure that — speaking to the perpetrators too, like, “we see you.”

The investigation into Jermain’s disappearance is just one of many cases of missing and murdered Indigenous women – known as MMIW. In 2019, the Justice Department created a task force to investigate cases of missing and murdered Indigenous people around the country.

Social media has helped to ignite the movement. At the 2024 Emmy Awards, “Reservation Dogs” actor and nominee D’Pharoah Woon-A-Tai was on the red carpet, bringing attention to the crisis.

Advertisement

Jen Murphy: I feel like we’re all of the human race and should be looked for the same. … It’s not like we’re asking for special treatment, we’re just asking for the same treatment. … We’re not going to stop looking for our people … We’re not. Our lives matter.

Vina Little Owl stands for justice in th same alley where Jermain Charlo was last seen. / Credit: Jen Murphy/Tveraa PhotographyVina Little Owl stands for justice in th same alley where Jermain Charlo was last seen. / Credit: Jen Murphy/Tveraa Photography

Vina Little Owl stands for justice in th same alley where Jermain Charlo was last seen. / Credit: Jen Murphy/Tveraa Photography

A photo shoot with Vina Little Owl was in the same alley where Jermain was last seen.

Jen Murphy: Starts out with … praying and trying to set yourself right … to painting on the paint.

Vina Little Owl (leading the prayer): We offer a moment of silence in a space for our sisters.

Michelle Miller: What does the red hand mean?

Advertisement

Jen Murphy: The red handprint really symbolizes … our people being silenced … how we have always been looked at differently and that our people have not been heard in the same way that other people are. … That’s a harsh reality and it has been since the beginning of time … since colonization.

Jermain’s family can’t help but wonder about how her case was treated in those critical, early days in the investigation.

Valenda Morigeau: When I reported her missing, there was no sense of urgency. … I don’t know if it’s because she’s … over … 18 or …  because she was drinking or the fact that she was Native American.

Lead detective Guy Baker can’t speak to those first days of the investigation. Remember, he didn’t get the case until 10 days after Jermain disappeared. But he’s well aware that some missing persons cases do get more attention than others.

Det. Guy Baker: You know, just look at our national media. Gabby Petito goes missing and look at the national exposure she got for a week or two for a Caucasian female and how many missing Native American females went missing in that same time period and got nothing. … so I’ve made a concerted effort … to keep Jermain relevant.

Advertisement

It’s Baker’s hope that by releasing the surveillance video to “48 Hours,” he’ll gain new leads. For Morigeau and Matt, it’s the last glimpse of Jermain’s life the night she disappeared.

Michelle Miller (watching the surveillance video): Do you see her?

Valenda Morigeau: Yeah. … Being social.

Dani Matt: Silly, being herself.

It’s the last glimpse of Jermain’s life the night she disappeared.

Advertisement

Dani Matt: Jermain, her bubbly self is beautiful to — to see her, um, hurts at the same time, but, um, so full of life.

Then, they zero in on the man standing behind Jermain: Michael DeFrance.

Dani Matt (watching the security video): Introduces him.

Valenda Morigeau (watching the security video): Then he’s got his arms crossed like and rolls up his sleeves like trying to intimidate whoever that dude is that she’s talking to.

Security footage of the alley outside The Badlander.  / Credit: Missoula Police DepartmentSecurity footage of the alley outside The Badlander.  / Credit: Missoula Police Department

Security footage of the alley outside The Badlander. / Credit: Missoula Police Department

Michelle Miller: Does it tell you anything?

Advertisement

Valenda Morigeau: It kind of shows me his demeanor that night. … looks like he’s in a rush to leave and that he’s annoyed that she’s — her attention isn’t focused on him.

Matt was surprised and relieved to see there were other people — potential witnesses — in the alley that night.

Danielle Matt: There’s a lot of people which reassures me that somebody knows something. Somebody’s seen her … somebody’s gotta know what that conversation was.

Baker says he spoke with several of the people seen on the video, but because this investigation is still active, he wouldn’t say much about what he learned.

Valenda Morigeau: I’m hoping that maybe by chance, somebody … saw them and just has no idea that she’s been missing and says something and that is just like the small missing piece that we need.

Advertisement

A RELATIONSHIP UNDER THE MICROSCOPE

While authorities did not name DeFrance as a suspect in Jermain’s disappearance, they did want to learn more about the couple’s relationship.

They started at the beginning. Jermain Charlo was 14 when she met 16-year-old Michael DeFrance in 2010 when his family moved in across the street. They both enjoyed fishing on the river and taking long walks. The teens were practically inseparable, but there were red flags.

Jermain Charlo and Michael DeFrance. / Credit: Valenda MorigeauJermain Charlo and Michael DeFrance. / Credit: Valenda Morigeau

Jermain Charlo and Michael DeFrance. / Credit: Valenda Morigeau

Valenda Morigeau: I don’t remember why I had her phone, but, like, I had found some explicit photos of her on her phone … like, you know, I had mentioned it to Michael … I was like, “she was never like this before,” like, “you know this is not OK. This is not something that you guys should be sharing at your age.”

Michelle Miller: What was his reaction?

Advertisement

Valenda Morigeau: He didn’t really say much.

Despite family disapproval, Jermain continued to see DeFrance. Then in April 2013, just two weeks shy of Jermain’s 18th birthday, Morigeau got a harrowing call.

Valenda Morigeau: There was an incident where um, she had called me and said, “auntie I need you down here. Michael hit me.”

According to court documents, DeFrance, who was 19, admitted he assaulted Jermain: “On 4-14-2013 in Sanders County I caused bodily injury to my girlfriend.” The documents also state how he hurt Jermain: “The Defendant made the following admissions: That he hit her 3 times. That he used his fist.”

Danielle Matt: It was hard to hear that and see her go through that and the emotional phone calls and conversations that followed … you know, she was a kid.

Advertisement

DeFrance pleaded guilty to partner family member assault. He wouldn’t serve any jail time, but he would be prohibited from possessing firearms.

Despite the violence, Jermain and DeFrance remained together. Jermain’s family says she was staying with DeFrance in a camper on his parents’ property.

A few months later, DeFrance left town to work as a seasonal firefighter.

Jermain, alone, lonely, and living in a camper, began sharing her world on YouTube:

I’m home alone for two more weeks. So, every day, blog will probably be only me until my boyfriend/fiancé gets home from work.

I usually don’t do much. I’m just … supposed to be a housewife.

Advertisement

Valenda Morigeau: She was very good about hiding pain … and try to pretend like everything was OK.

Soon, they were young parents raising their two boys. But Morigeau says the violence continued.

Valenda Morigeau: Multiple times of getting phone calls and going down to make sure she was OK and … it was hard for us to watch her go back, but that’s what happens to a lot of women who were victims of domestic violence.

Danielle Matt: They’d break up and make up and breakup and make up.

According to Matt, the couple eventually broke up for good in 2017.

Advertisement

Danielle Matt:  Michael … still wanted Jermain to do as Michael said. And, so, when Jermain started to create a life without him, um, it seems like things got worse for her … she was the mother of his kids and had to kind of walk on eggshells around what Michael wanted or how you know he pictured her or wanted her to be as mom.

In early 2018, just months before her disappearance, Jermain and DeFrance had a heated custody battle over the boys. According to her family, Jermain had limited resources. DeFrance, it seemed, had more.

Danielle Matt: He had an attorney. … She didn’t have an attorney … Jermain … was working hard to find stability with work.

A judge decided the kids would live with their father and she would have visitation rights. The parenting plan, says her family, was stressful for Jermain. Chayla Russell noticed a change in her cousin’s behavior.

Chayla Russell: Michael had the boys and so she was lonely and scared for her safety.

Advertisement

Michelle Miller: She was scared for her safety?

Chayla Russell: Yeah … she would talk about having nightmares or being scared to be alone …

After Jermain’s disappearance, investigators would discover something else about Michael DeFrance.

Jill Valley | KPAX anchor: Detectives realize that he was in possession of firearms, which is against the law when you’ve been convicted of partner family member assault.

Guns seized from Michael DeFrance's property. / Credit: District Court of MontanaGuns seized from Michael DeFrance's property. / Credit: District Court of Montana

Guns seized from Michael DeFrance’s property. / Credit: District Court of Montana

Investigators seized guns from Michael DeFrance’s property. In 2021, he was arrested and charged with possessing firearms – a violation of his 2013 sentence. KPAX anchor and reporter Jill Valley covered the federal trial.

Advertisement

Jill Valley:  On one side it’s the DeFrance family … on the other side it’s Jermain’s family and friends. And it is tense. I don’t think there’s any love lost between those two families.

In 2023, Michael DeFrance was convicted and sentenced to 21 months in prison. He hasn’t served any time because he is appealing the conviction. “48 Hours” requested an interview through his attorney. He declined our request.

In their effort to find Jermain, authorities secured numerous search warrants, including at least two on DeFrance’s property.

But because this is an active investigation, many of the search warrants have been sealed.

Brittany Williams: Dozens of searches … for Jermain over the last six years. … there have been canine searches … Canines who are trained to detect bodies.

Advertisement

Det. Guy Baker: Every place that we’ve searched has not yielded the evidence that would give us the answer.

Michelle Miller: What do you think happened to her and why?

Det. Guy Baker: All I can say without compromising the investigation is I think Jermain’s disappearance is a result of a criminal action. … and somebody knows what happened to Jermain, and we need their — their assistance. Somebody knows something.

Something that always baffled Baker is what happened to Jermain’s cellphone. Turns out, DeFrance provided an answer.

WHAT HAPPENED TO JERMAIN CHARLO’S CELLPHONE?

Advertisement

Evaro Hill is the last known area where Jermain’s cellphone was active. According to investigators it was pinging between 2 a.m. and 10 a.m. the morning after she was last seen.

Brittany Williams: It’s a very heavily forested area, lots of different wildlife … And then, one — sole highway that runs through the top of Evaro Hill.

It’s the area where Jermain’s ex, Michael DeFrance, was living. In his initial statement to police, he said that he’d dropped Jermain off in Missoula around 1 a.m., and that she had her phone with her. So why was it active on Evaro Hill, roughly 14 miles north of Missoula, hours later? DeFrance changed his story and said her phone was with him.

Brittany Williams: In a subsequent interview, he provided a statement that she left her cellphone and he attempted to go through her cellphone, and he was unable to get into her cellphone.

What he said he did next surprised Baker. DeFrance admitted that two days after he last saw Jermain, he threw her phone away.

Advertisement

Det. Guy Baker: So, Mr. DeFrance had told us during one of his interviews that he discarded, uh, Jermain’s cellphone in Idaho.

DeFrance, then working as a truck driver, told authorities he disposed of Jermain’s phone in Idaho at mile marker 94 on Highway 12. Law enforcement searched the area, but never found the phone.

Michelle Miller: I have to ask, why would he get rid of her cellphone? What explanation did he have?

Det. Guy Baker: I –

Michelle Miller: You can’t tell me?

Advertisement

Det. Guy Baker: — can’t tell you.

Michelle Miller: … is that unusual that someone would – one, admit to having a missing person’s cellphone and then, two, that they would dispense with it?

Det. Guy Baker: Yeah. Why would you get rid of the cellphone if someone was around to give the phone back to ’em?

Danielle Matt: Why would he have her phone? … Why would he destroy it, throw it out at mile marker what the hell ever …  I — I don’t understand.

Brittany Williams: I wouldn’t say Michael DeFrance is not a person of interest. I would say that I’m not at liberty to say who is or who is not a person of interest.

Advertisement

No suspects have been named in connection with Jermain’s disappearance. Police are now considering the case a no body homicide, but without a body, prosecuting a homicide is a challenge.

Brittany Williams: I think it’s important for everyone to know that you only get one bite at the apple here, only one shot. And so I wanna gather as much information to ensure a successful prosecution, should we meet that crossroad.

Brittany Williams: It’s my belief that we are close to moving forward in this case.

Michelle Miller: Moving forward meaning filing charges against a suspect?

Brittany Williams: If it ultimately is determined that this is criminal means, absolutely.

Advertisement

Brittany Williams: Jermain and her family deserve answers. And it is my hope … that someone comes forward, provides us some new lead that can lead to justice.

Det. Guy Baker: I have my cellphone on that billboard, not just the police department’s main number, ’cause I want someone to call me … because I want the information.

The billboard’s location was important to Matt and Morigeau. It looks out toward the reservation and Evaro Hill, where DeFrance was living with Jermain’s two sons.

Dani Matt: I know that Michael would probably have to take that route … to come to Missoula. And I thought, well, the boys might not be able to see her in person, but that picture will be there and … Jacob and Thomas could see their mother … every time they drove by there.

Dani Matt: I hope throughout these years that Thomas and Jacob haven’t forgot who their mother is, and I hope they know that she loves them very much.

Advertisement

In Missoula, there’s a different billboard, this one showing Valenda Morigeau’s face. Her photo stands as a stark reminder of the ongoing crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women.

Valenda Morigeau: It took me a long time to do that photo shoot because I don’t want people thinking that, like, I want attention on myself. … it’s not about me. It’s about Jermain. … We will no longer be silent about our women going missing. … We have to fight for justice for our loved ones.

Michelle Miller: Do you still plan on searching for Jermain?

Valenda Morigeau: Always … I don’t care how long it takes.

Valenda Morigeau: … I’m never gonna give up on her. I don’t care if I have to search until I’m 80 years old.

Craige Couture | Flathead Reservation police chief: If this case is never solved and I retire, it’s not going away in my mind. … That’ll be one of those things that will be with me until the day I die … That weighs on us. … That weighs on our tribal council. … Everyone here thinks about it.

Advertisement
Jermain Charlo / Credit: Valenda MorigeauJermain Charlo / Credit: Valenda Morigeau

Jermain Charlo / Credit: Valenda Morigeau

Six winters have passed since Jermain disappeared. Matt and Morigeau no longer believe she is alive.

Valenda Morigeau: So, I have a gift of when my family makes it to the other side. When my grandma passed away, she came and told me she made it. … When my grandpa passed away, he told me he made it.

Valenda Morigeau: And I had this dream and Jermain was there and she’s like … “I just wanted to tell you I found grandma and grandpa, and I’m fine.” … And she gave me a hug and she turned to walk away. (crying) And I said, “Jermain,” and she goes, “what?” I was like, “where’s your body?” … And she looked me dead in the eyes, she said, “it’s in Evaro.” She’s like, “I love you, but I have to go.”

If you have any information pertaining to Jermain Charlo’s disappearance, contact the Missoula Police Department at 406-552-6284. 

Produced by Marcelena Spencer and Emma Steele. Stephen A. McCain is the development producer. Richard Barber is the producer/editor. Diana Modica and George Baluzy are the editors. Peter Schweitzer is the senior producer. Nancy Kramer is the executive story editor. Judy Tygard is the executive producer.

Advertisement

Boeing says it plans to cut 10% of global workforce amid strike

Harris releases medical records, pressures Trump to follow suit

NFL stadium tackles climate change in a new way



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Montana

Brawl of the Wild Replay: No. 9 Montana at No. 2 Montana State

Published

on

Brawl of the Wild Replay: No. 9 Montana at No. 2 Montana State


BOZEMAN — Second-ranked Montana State was seeking regular-season perfection when it welcomed rival Montana to Bobcat Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2024.

The Bobcats entered the 123rd Brawl of the Wild with an 11-0 overall record with a chance to finish 12-0 for the first time in program history and also win the outright Big Sky Conference championship.

The ninth-ranked Grizzlies, meanwhile, were 8-3 and aiming to play spoiler for Montana State while also improving their own seeding for the FCS playoffs.

Watch a condensed replay of the game between No. 2 Montana State and No. 9 Montana in the video above.

Advertisement





Source link

Continue Reading

Montana

‘Yellowstone’ highlights influence behind a changing Montana

Published

on

‘Yellowstone’ highlights influence behind a changing Montana



The popular “Yellowstone” TV series, set and filmed in Montana, taps into a lesser-known chapter of the state’s history: its settlement by Confederates and ex-Confederates during and after the Civil War.

I come to this story with a unique perspective. I’m a fourth-generation Montanan. I’m also a scholar of U.S. Western literary and cultural studies and left the state in my 20s to pursue a career in academia.

Advertisement

Then, during the pandemic, I returned to Montana for a time to lead a statewide cultural organization that connects Montana’s history and literature to its modern-day residents.

That’s why, for me, the story of the show’s protagonist, John Dutton III, who heads a wealthy-but-embattled Montana ranching family, is not just a cultural phenomenon. Rather, “Yellowstone” offers insights into the dynamics that are currently influencing a changing Montana.

Montana’s little-known legacy

One of the series’ prequels, “1883,” provides the crucial backstory for the Dutton family’s journey to Montana.

James Dutton, portrayed by Tim McGraw, was a former Confederate captain; his wife, Maggie, was a nurse for the Confederate Army. In leaving behind their war-torn lives to seek new opportunities, they mirror the historical trend that saw Confederate settlers moving West during and after the Civil War.

According to Montana historian and scholar Ken Robison, Confederate prisoners of war languishing in Union prisons were paroled to western territories like Montana. By 1864, two such parolees had discovered gold in what is still called Confederate Gulch, at the time one of the largest settlements in Montana Territory. Other settlements, such as Dixie Town and Jeff Davis Gulch, dotted the landscape. Montana’s territorial capital was briefly called Varina, named after the Confederate president’s wife.

Advertisement

Although there is no way to know for certain, it’s possible that during the latter half of the war, half of Montana Territory’s residents — maybe 30,000 — were pro-secession. Some had been in Confederate service; the rest shared their sentiments.

After the war, many of those Confederates stayed. By the late 1800s, Montana was home to 13 United Confederate Veterans organizations totaling 176 members. In 1916, the Montana Chapter of the Daughters of the Confederacy erected a Confederate memorial in Helena, the state capital; it stood for a century. The 1920s saw the rise of about 40 Ku Klux Klan chapters across the state to promote xenophobic policies against immigrants and racist policies against nonwhites. Today, Montana remains one of the whitest states in the U.S. — about 85% of Montanans are white; less than 1% are Black.

Recasting the ‘Lost Cause’

Numerous historical echoes surface briefly in “Yellowstone.”

In Season 2, there’s a violent confrontation involving a militia group that displays Confederate and “Don’t Tread on Me” flags. This subplot speaks to Montana’s long history as a hub for populist and anti-government movements. The Southern Poverty Law Center reports that Montana has 17 hate and anti-government groups, which include three defined as white supremacist or neo-Nazi.

This depiction of militia groups in “Yellowstone” represents the broader history of populist resistance in the American West. From the Sagebrush Rebellion of the 1970s to the Montana Freemen’s standoff with federal agents in the 1990s, Westerners have often resisted federal control over land and resources — tensions that perhaps trace back to the Confederacy’s own secession, a resistance rooted in defiance of federal authority, particularly over slavery.

Advertisement

After the Confederacy’s defeat, the “Lost Cause” narrative, in an attempt to preserve Southern pride, recast the South’s secession as a fight for states’ rights, and not a defense of slavery.

Those Lost Cause connections reverberate through John Dutton III’s relentless battle to preserve his family’s ranch. Fighting overwhelming political and economic pressures, Dutton remains steadfast in his determination to hold onto the land, even when it goes against his best interests.

This tenacity reflects the Lost Cause mindset — a clinging to a nostalgia-tinged, yet unattainable, past. Dutton embodies the archetype of the “aggrieved white man,” a figure central to many populist movements, who feels displaced from his former position of power in politics, work and family life.

Populist contradictions

It’s hard to discern to what degree recent changes in Montana can be attributed to “Yellowstone.” What is certain: Today’s longtime Montana residents find themselves exposed to a fresh set of political, economic and cultural forces.

Tourism and the local economy are up, due in part to the “Yellowstone” effect. But so are concerns about the rising costs of most everything, particularly houses.

Advertisement

These trends have been spurred, in part, by outsiders moving to Montana — newcomers who romanticize the state’s hardscrabble past and what they perceive as its current rough-hewn lifestyle.

What’s more, Montana has morphed from a purple state known for its political independence into a reliably conservative stronghold.

The drastic shift from purple to red solidified in 2020 with the election of a Republican governor after 16 years of Democratic leadership. It was further underscored by the defeat of Democratic Sen. Jon Tester by Republican Tim Sheehy in the 2024 election.

In “Yellowstone,” as Dutton is sworn in as Montana’s new Republican governor, he tells his constituents that he is “the opposite of progress” in response to changes that outside influences are bringing to the state.

Yet the politics of “Yellowstone” are “hard to pin down,” and the Duttons themselves espouse various versions of left- and right-wing populism as they simultaneously battle and embody the political and economic elite.

Advertisement

By the same token, Montanans resent wealthy outsiders but have given them political power by voting them into office.

Montana’s current governor, Greg Gianforte, is a tech millionaire, originally from Pennsylvania; Sheehy, similarly, is a wealthy out-of-stater.

Neither one might approve of the fictional Gov. Dutton’s proposed policy of doubling property and sales taxes for out-of-state “transplants” — though many Montanans probably would. For some, the rapid changes of the past few years have been, like life for the Dutton family, a challenge.

Randi Lynn Tanglen served as professor of English at Austin College in Texas (2008-2020), executive director of Humanities Montana (2020-2022), and is currently vice provost for faculty affairs at the University of North Dakota (2023-present). She holds degrees from Rocky Mountain College,  the University of Montana and the University of Arizona.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Montana

No. 2 Montana State whips No. 9 Montana 34-11, clinches 12-0 regular season

Published

on

No. 2 Montana State whips No. 9 Montana 34-11, clinches 12-0 regular season


BOZEMAN — The only thing that could have made this football season any sweeter for Montana State was the one thing that remained on its list of regular-season expectations.

Against their arch nemesis on Saturday, the Bobcats didn’t blink.

Adam Jones rushed for 197 yards and two touchdowns, the defense rose up and No. 2-ranked MSU took care of ninth-ranked Montana 34-11 to win the 123rd Brawl of the Wild at Bobcat Stadium.

Slim Kimmel / MTN Sports

Advertisement
Montana State running back Adam Jones looks to evade Montana’s Ryder Meyer during the 123rd Brawl of the Wild at Bobcat Stadium in Bozeman on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2024.

With the win, the Bobcats clinched a perfect regular season at 12-0, won the outright Big Sky Conference title with an 8-0 league mark and in all likelihood secured a top-two seed and home-field advantage for the upcoming FCS playoffs — if not the overall No. 1 seed.

Though their running back corps was diminished with both Scottre Humphrey and Julius Davis in street clothes on the sideline, the Bobcats still rushed for 326 yards with Jones, a redshirt freshman out of Missoula Sentinel, leading the way.

The home team has now won five in a row in the storied history of the Cat-Griz rivalry, and Montana State has still not lost a regular-season home game in the four-year tenure of coach Brent Vigen.

Montana vs. Montana State

Slim Kimmel / MTN Sports

Montana and Montana State play in the 123rd Brawl of the Wild at Bobcat Stadium in Bozeman on Nov. 23, 2024.

The Bobcats established their running game at the outset by marching 75 yards on 14 plays, 12 of which were runs. Mellott capped the drive with a 5-yard touchdown run on what appeared to be a broken play to put MSU ahead 7-0.

Advertisement

MSU converted two third downs on that drive and took nearly nine minutes off the clock.

A promising Griz drive was slowed by penalties in the second quarter, but Ty Morrison got Montana on the board by splitting the uprights on a 47-yard field goal to make the score 7-3.

But the Bobcats stretched their lead on the next possession when Mellott dropped a pretty pass over the top to tight end Rohan Jones for a 35-yard touchdown at the 10:16 mark of the second quarter.

Toward the end of the first half, the Bobcats got a 27-yard field goal from Myles Sansted to extend the lead to 17-3. With an even bigger kick, Sansted drilled a 49-yarder as time expired at halftime to extend it to 20-3.

Each team’s defense rose up in the second half as the offenses combined for five consecutive fruitless possessions. But with the Bobcats backed up on their own 5-yard line, Adam Jones exploded took a handoff and exploded through the line for an 88-yard gain.

Advertisement
Montana vs. Montana State

Slim Kimmel / MTN Sports

Montana and Montana State play in the 123rd Brawl of the Wild at Bobcat Stadium in Bozeman on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2024.

Two plays later Jones punched it into the end zone from the 3 to put the Bobcats ahead 27-3 toward the end of the third quarter.

As the weather started to take a turn with strong wind and snow flurries, Montana scored its first touchdown early in the fourth on a 1-yard rush by Eli Gillman. Sawyer Racanelli then made a one-handed catch while being interfered with for a two-point conversion.

Jones, though, capped a 9-play, 71-yard drive with a 2-yard TD run with 4:49 remaining to ice the game.

The Grizzlies own the all-time series with a 74-43-5 record, but the Bobcats now have the edge with an 11-10 mark since 2002.

Advertisement

Turning point: The game had hit a defensive standstill in the third quarter until Jones’ 88-yard burst to the UM 7. Griz safety Jaxon Lee prevented a touchdown, but two plays later Jones was in the end zone and the Bobcats had a 27-3 lead with 1:55 remaining in the third.

Stat of the game: The Bobcats rushed for more than 300 yards again, but perhaps more important was the defense’s ability to get off the field on third down.

Montana vs. Montana State

Slim Kimmel / MTN Sports

Montana and Montana State play in the 123rd Brawl of the Wild at Bobcat Stadium in Bozeman on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2024.

MSU’s defense held the Grizzlies to a 2 for 12 success rate on third down and forced seven punts. In the end, the Bobcats limited Montana’s offense to 234 total yards.

Game balls: MSU RB Adam Jones (Offense). Davis was injured in the first quarter and didn’t return and Humphrey had just one attempt, so Jones was called up on to take the brunt of the carries. He delivered with a standout performance.

Advertisement

MSU S Rylan Ortt (Defense). The Bobcats defense played a great game overall, and Ortt was one of the ringleaders with 11 tackles (eight solo), was in on a tackle for loss and had one quarterback hurry.

MSU PK Myles Sansted (Special teams). Sansted hit both of his field goal tries, and his 49-yarder as time expired in the first half allowed MSU to take a 17-point lead into the locker room.

What’s next: With a 12-0 record, Montana State is in line for a top-two seed in the FCS playoffs, which would mean a first-round bye and home-field advantage through the semifinal round. The Cats could get the No. 1 overall seed after South Dakota beat North Dakota State 29-28.

The Grizzlies, who are now 8-4 (and 5-3 in the Big Sky), are likely to receive an at-large bid into the tournament.

The 24-team bracket will be announced Sunday with the 2024 NCAA Division I Championship Selection Show on Sunday at 10:30 p.m. Mountain time on ESPNU. The show is also available for streaming on ESPN+.

Advertisement





Source link

Continue Reading

Trending