Connect with us

Idaho

The Idaho Constitution strictly prohibits public funds for religious schooling

Published

on

The Idaho Constitution strictly prohibits public funds for religious schooling


Legislators who insist on using taxpayer money to pay for private schooling consistently claim that their so-called “school choice” schemes would not violate the Idaho Constitution by making public funds available for religious education. They are dead wrong. Article IX, Section 5 of that revered document, sometimes called the “Blaine Amendment,” emphatically states that no public funds shall ever be used “to help support or sustain any school, academy, seminary, college, university or other literary or scientific institution, controlled by any church.”

Some people, who simply don’t know what they are talking about, falsely claim the Blaine Amendment has been overruled by the United States Supreme Court. Quite to the contrary, the Supreme Court has decided two cases dealing with the Blaine Amendment and neither has overruled it. In the latest case, Carson v. Makin, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote: “A State need not subsidize private education. But once a State decides to do so, it cannot disqualify some private schools solely because they are religious.”

What the Court was saying is that if, and only if, a state establishes a program to provide taxpayer money for private schooling, it must also provide program money for religious schooling. Some politicians are trying, for the first time in Idaho history, to force Idaho taxpayers to pay for private schooling, which would then open the back door to require that taxpayers also pay for religious schooling. So-called “school choice” legislation is a workaround to evade and subvert the Constitution. Whether the use of public funds for private schooling is–by means of a tax credit or school voucher or some other form–it is still a raid on the public treasury in violation of the Blaine Amendment.

A dispute over the Blaine Amendment arose during a candidate forum held by the Greater Idaho Falls Chamber of Commerce last month. Representative Wendy Horman, a strong advocate of using taxpayer money to pay for private education, claimed the Blaine Amendment had been voided by the Supreme Court. Representative Stephanie Mickelsen correctly responded that it is still the law of Idaho. She said, “When you take public tax dollars, and you give them to parochial and private schools,” there is no accountability for the spending. She pointed out that school choice schemes have become budget busters for many, many states.

Advertisement

No matter what you call a school choice plan, it is still a violation of the Idaho Constitution if it results in public money being used for religious instruction. The Legislature has consistently violated its constitutional obligation to adequately fund the public school system, both for instructional purposes and for construction and maintenance of school buildings. Thanks to the good work of pro-education legislators, progress was made this year in addressing both deficiencies. This is not the time to require taxpayers to shoulder the additional burden of financing private and religious schooling.

It should not go unnoticed that one of the most vociferous interest groups pushing for school choice programs is the Idaho Freedom Foundation (IFF). That organization is dedicated to the proposition that the State has no business educating our kids. The IFF’s avowed plan is to do away with public schools. A school choice plan would certainly be a big step in that direction.

Other powerful out-of-state interests have spent heavily to force budget-busting school choice programs on the Gem State. Idaho Business for Education recently disclosed that a Texas-based organization, American Federation for Children (ADF), together with two other dark-money interest groups, spent a total of $134,148 unsuccessfully promoting school choice during this legislative session. ADF has vowed to defeat legislators who opposed these schemes and is rewarding those who bent to its will. Voters should take heed and vote for those like Mickelsen who support our Constitution.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Idaho

Wounded 73-year-old survives 5 days in snowy Idaho backcountry without food or shelter after his raft flips

Published

on

Wounded 73-year-old survives 5 days in snowy Idaho backcountry without food or shelter after his raft flips


A 73-year-old boater whose raft capsized survived in the snowy Idaho backcountry for five days without food — before he was found just after he had given up and rescued, according to authorities.

Thomas Gray’s incredible tale of survival — which included eating snow, drinking creek water and hiking 23 miles with an injured leg — began during a three-day trip earlier this month on the Middle Fork of the Salmon River.

He was rafting down Dagger Falls on May 18 to meet his wife the next day when his boat flipped over, the Custer County Sheriff’s Office said.

Thomas Gray, 73, survived in the Idaho backcountry for 5 days after his raft fell apart on the Salmon River. KSL.com

Gray was thrown to the base of the falls and forced to swim to shore with the raft out of reach.

Advertisement

The septuagenarian, who had suffered a leg injury, hiked toward a launch site where he found shelter in an outhouse for two nights, the sheriff’s office said.

During the day, he unsuccessfully looked for other floaters on the Middle Fork.

After coming up empty, he then walked toward another location, the Fir Creek Pass, and found shelter at a snowmobile club trailer. While there was a wood stove in the trailer, Gray couldn’t find any matches, the sheriff said.

Meanwhile, authorities were furiously searching for the missing man after his punctured cataraft was discovered in the water.

After a night in the trailer, Gray continued on his journey toward the pass, but “became too exhausted” and laid down in the snow.

Advertisement

He hadn’t eaten food in days and was only relying on taking bites of snow and drinking water from the creeks to hang on, the sheriff’s office said.


Gray relied on taking bites of snow and drinking water from the creeks to survive.
Gray relied on taking bites of snow and drinking water from the creeks to survive. christiannafzger

“Tom was totally exhausted; he decided this was it. He just laid down in the snow and said a prayer,” said Custer County sheriff’s marine deputy John Haugh, according to KSL.

“He was resigned that this was not going to end well.”

But as he lay there in the snow, the owners of an excursion business spotted him.

Steve and Annie Lentz, of Far and Away River Adventures, quickly reached him with their vehicle and first responders who were on board rendered aid.

“If they hadn’t come along, he probably wouldn’t have lasted much longer,” Haugh said, according to the station. “He was in pretty bad shape when they got him.”

Advertisement

Gray’s younger brother, Robert Gray, actually died in 2022 when his raft flipped over in around the same area, Haugh reportedly said.

“Tom called me and said I was his ‘lifesaver,’ but I said, ‘No, I’m just your Uber deputy,’” Haugh said.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Idaho

Jury awards drag performer $1.1M in case against blogger who made false posts

Published

on

Jury awards drag performer $1.1M in case against blogger who made false posts


The day after Eric Posey put on three drag performances at a 2022 Idaho Pride event, a conservative blogger falsely claimed that he had exposed himself in front of children.

Summer Bushnell, an Idaho resident who runs a conservative online blog, encouraged readers to share the posts, which included an edited, blurred video from Posey’s performance and contact information for local police and the state attorney general. Posey sued Bushnell in September 2022, accusing her of defamation.



Source link

Continue Reading

Idaho

Drive safe, the 100 Deadliest Days are upon us – East Idaho News

Published

on

Drive safe, the 100 Deadliest Days are upon us – East Idaho News


The following is a press release from Idaho Transportation Department.

BOISE— Memorial Day weekend is shaping up to be a busy travel time in the Gem State. Idaho is about to enter the 100 Deadliest Days on Idaho roads- the time between Memorial Day and Labor Day when there is a spike in fatal and serious injury crashes. Seventy* people have been killed in crashes on Idaho roads so far this year — including the recent crash on US 20 in Bonneville County that tragically killed six people in one vehicle. The Idaho Office of Highway Safety (OHS) is imploring drivers to be vigilant and drive engaged this Memorial Day weekend and all summer.

“We call this period the 100 Deadliest Days, but it would be great to be proven wrong. Make it safer out there for yourself and others by slowing down, putting down distractions, buckling up, and planning a sober ride home,” said OHS program manager Josephine Middleton.

While it would seem like winter is the most dangerous time to drive, driving is more dangerous in summer. This seems paradoxical. Why would roads be more dangerous in summer when weather conditions are better? During the summer more people are out of school or work, on vacation, and celebrating leading to higher rates of risky behavior behind the wheel like impaired driving, distracted driving, and speeding.

Advertisement
Graph: Fatal crashes by month 2018-2022 | Courtesy Idaho Transportation Department.

This summer OHS and its partners across the state will work together to remind people to make safer choices whenever they are on the road. Some of these activities will include partnering with law enforcement agencies to get dangerous drivers off the road, public awareness campaigns, and community outreach events.

“We have a lot of wonderful partners who help us make Idaho’s roads a safer place, but we can’t just rely on them,” Middleton said. “We can all do a better job of looking out for each other on our roads and make it safely through this summer.”

2024 Fatality information*:

70 people killed in traffic crashes to date

  • 58 people in vehicles
  • 5 people on motorcycles
  • 4 people on foot
  • 1 person on a bicycle
  • 2 people on ATVs/UTVs/etc.

2024 Fatalities by county:

District 1

Advertisement
  • Bonner – 2
  • Kootenai – 2
  • Benewah – 1
  • Boundary & Shoshone – 0

District 2

  • Nez Perce – 4
  • Idaho – 2
  • Latah – 1
  • Lewis – 1
  • Clearwater – 0

District 3

  • Ada – 7
  • Canyon – 9
  • Elmore – 1
  • Valley – 1
  • Washington – 2
  • Payette – 2
  • Owyhee – 1
  • Adams, Boise & Gem – 0

District 4

  • Lincoln – 3
  • Cassia – 7
  • Jerome – 3
  • Twin Falls – 1
  • Blaine – 1
  • Minidoka – 1
  • Camas & Gooding – 0

District 5

  • Franklin – 2
  • Bingham – 3
  • Bannock -2
  • Oneida – 1
  • Power, Bear Lake & Caribou – 0

District 6

  • Bonneville – 8
  • Custer – 1
  • Madison – 1
  • Lemhi, Butte, Clark, Jefferson, Fremont, & Teton – 0

*All 2024 data is preliminary and subject to change.

=htmlentities(get_the_title())?>%0D%0A%0D%0A=get_permalink()?>%0D%0A%0D%0A=htmlentities(‘For more stories like this one, be sure to visit https://www.eastidahonews.com/ for all of the latest news, community events and more.’)?>&subject=Check%20out%20this%20story%20from%20EastIdahoNews” class=”fa-stack jDialog”>





Source link

Continue Reading

Trending