Connect with us

News

He deported thousands of people, then learned he was undocumented | CNN

Published

on

He deported thousands of people, then learned he was undocumented | CNN


San Benito, Texas
CNN
 — 

Raul Rodriguez says he’ll always remember the second he realized his life was constructed on a lie.

He was so shaken that he felt the blood dashing to his ft. In a matter of seconds, a household secret had shattered the way in which he noticed the world and his place in it.

“That day won’t ever depart my thoughts. … It’s a horrible feeling,” he says.

All of it started in April 2018 when federal investigators confirmed him a surprising doc: a Mexican delivery certificates together with his title on it.

Advertisement

A dialog together with his father quickly afterward confirmed what Rodriguez had feared as quickly as he noticed the paperwork. The US delivery certificates he’d used for many years was fraudulent. Rodriguez wasn’t a US citizen. He was an undocumented immigrant.

Rodriguez says he had no thought he’d been born in Mexico earlier than his father’s confession that day, however he knew instantly how critical the state of affairs was. He’d spent almost 20 years working for the US authorities on the border.

By his estimates, he’d helped deport hundreds of individuals whereas working for US Customs and Border Safety and earlier than that, for the Immigration and Naturalization Service. All of the sudden, he discovered himself on the other finish of the spectrum, combating for an opportunity to remain in america.

He misplaced a lot so shortly after that: his job at CBP, his buddies in regulation enforcement, his sense of self. He hasn’t seen his father since that day in April 2018 and says he by no means needs to talk with him once more.

However now, almost 5 years later, Rodriguez, 54, says he realizes he additionally gained one thing shocking after that second when he realized he wasn’t a US citizen.

Advertisement

“It began off as a nightmare,” he says. “However then it turned out to be – holy moly – that is what I used to be meant to do.”

For Rodriguez, a journey started that day. And it’s ended up someplace he didn’t anticipate.

At first, Diane Vega couldn’t imagine the phrases she noticed in her Fb feed.

In her advocacy work serving to deported veterans and veterans liable to deportation as vice chairman of Repatriate Our Patriots, she’d seen first-hand how merciless and complicated the US immigration system may be. However this was in contrast to any story she’d heard earlier than – “anyone who thought they have been born right here, who was raised right here, who served within the army after which who was instructed, ‘you’re not American.’”

And the way, she questioned, may somebody who’d labored for CBP be dealing with deportation?

Advertisement

Vega, who’s primarily based throughout the state in El Paso, Texas, wasn’t the one one shocked by the story of the previous immigration inspector who’d realized he was undocumented. Rodriguez’s plight caught the eye of native and nationwide media.

Many responses to the protection have been unsympathetic, Vega says, particularly in border communities.

“They’d say, ‘That is what you get for going towards your personal individuals.’”

However Vega noticed the story one other method.

She’d served within the army. Rodriguez had, too. Earlier than his profession working for CBP and its predecessor, the Immigration and Naturalization Service, Rodriguez was within the Navy. He served from 1992 to 1997 and was stationed in Jacksonville and San Diego, with deployments in Iceland and the Persian Gulf as a member of the Navy’s army police.

Advertisement

Anybody who’s served within the army, Vega says, is aware of what it’s prefer to need to observe orders and put your private emotions apart. And to her, Rodriguez’s work at CBP was no completely different.

“It was his job,” she says. “Some jobs should not the very best, however all of us need to observe orders. … It was all the time for the protection of this nation. It was for the intent of taking good care of america and its individuals.”

So when others have been turning away from Rodriguez, Vega reached out.

Of their first cellphone dialog, she heard how alone he sounded.

Advertisement

“People who he thought have been his brothers turned their again on him,” she says.

Anita Rodriguez tears up as she remembers these days.

It was devastating, she says, to observe her husband spiral into despair as he misplaced the help of so many individuals and establishments he’d counted on.

“There’d be some days after I’d depart the home and marvel, ‘Is he going to be OK once we come dwelling? What are we going to search out?’” she says, her voice cracking with emotion.

Anita Rodriguez works for US Citizenship and Immigration Companies and met her husband once they have been each coaching to be inspectors for the immigration company then often known as INS.

Advertisement

Since then, she’d seen him dedicate so a few years to his job, and earn excessive accolades, too. In 2006, officers flew him to Washington to obtain an integrity award for his work in a smuggling bust.

Anita and Raul Rodriguez say their family has been struggling as Raul Rodriguez's immigration case remains in limbo. Advocates who help deported veterans, they say, supported them when other friends turned away.

The previous few years, she says, have introduced their household a dramatically completely different actuality.

“He’d been all around the world for the US,” she says, “and but he couldn’t journey exterior his personal yard. He couldn’t go previous a (Border Patrol) checkpoint.”

Rodriguez knew deportation to Mexico would imply leaving his spouse, 4 kids and 5 grandchildren behind, and leaving dwelling wasn’t well worth the danger.

As he fought for the possibility to stick with his household, individuals he as soon as thought of colleagues turned individuals he feared.

Advertisement

Rodriguez says years of federal background checks by no means turned up his Mexican delivery certificates. It solely got here to mild when Rodriguez filed a visa software for his brother.

Data present prosecutors declined to pursue a case towards Rodriguez after investigators from the Division of Homeland Safety’s Workplace of the Inspector Common couldn’t discover any proof that he’d knowingly submitted a fraudulent delivery certificates to the federal government. That meant he wouldn’t face legal prices, however his job was nonetheless in jeopardy.

After putting him on depart in the course of the investigation, Rodriguez says CBP fired him in 2019 as a result of he wasn’t a US citizen and subsequently not met the necessities to work as an officer.

In an announcement to CNN, CBP mentioned Rodriguez is not employed by the company however declined to remark additional on his case.

“All allegations involving CBP staff are dealt with in a uniform method in accordance with relevant Division of Homeland Safety Coverage,” the assertion mentioned.

Quickly after dropping his job, Rodriguez obtained a tattoo on his left arm. It exhibits a Mexican flag splitting his CBP badge in two.

“Being a Mexican citizen,” Rodriguez says, “broke my profession and tore it aside.”

Advertisement

Rodriguez is not working and depends on the incapacity advantages he receives as a consequence of a head harm sustained throughout his time within the Navy.

He stays happy with the integrity award he received on the job. He nonetheless has it on a shelf in his front room. And he retains a photograph of him shaking the CBP commissioner’s hand that day on his cellphone.

However he says most of the buddies he thought he’d made throughout his years on the company have disappeared.

“They deserted me as a result of they thought I used to be unlawful,” he says.

The integrity award Raul Rodriguez won during his tenure at Customs and Border Protection is still so important to him that it's on display in his living room, alongside other awards and badges.

Gone are the texts and calls that used to maintain his cellphone buzzing. At a neighborhood restaurant, he was silently spurned by somebody he’d beforehand invited to dinner at his dwelling.

Advertisement

“He simply turns round, places his head down and doesn’t search for as he’s going by,” Rodriguez says.

It left him feeling misplaced and betrayed. So many issues he’d thought have been sure, he says, turned out to not be.

Rodriguez realized he was altering, too.

“Something that I ever did revolved round regulation enforcement. I misplaced the whole lot … That’s who I believed I used to be. That was my id,” he says. “They take that concept from you, you’re again at sq. one.”

Raul and Anita Rodriguez had a long time of expertise working within the US immigration system, however assembly Vega launched them to issues they by no means knew existed.

Advertisement

“We have been actually shocked. We had by no means heard of a veteran getting deported,” Anita Rodriguez says.

The Biden administration introduced a brand new initiative to assist deported veterans in 2021, with Homeland Safety Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas stating on the time that officers have been “dedicated to bringing again army service members, veterans, and their speedy members of the family who have been unjustly eliminated and making certain they obtain the advantages to which they might be entitled.”

Since then, the Division of Homeland Safety says it’s helped greater than 65 veterans return.

But it surely’s nonetheless unclear precisely what number of US army veterans america has deported through the years or what number of stay overseas.

A 2019 report from the Authorities Accountability Workplace discovered that Immigration and Customs and Enforcement hadn’t constantly adhered to its personal insurance policies about veterans’ instances or tracked what number of veterans had been kicked overseas.

Advertisement
As a CBP officer and an inspector for the Immigration and Naturalization Service, Rodriguez estimates he helped deport thousands of people.

Advocates say extra must be performed to attach deportees with the Biden administration’s help program and help veterans as soon as they return to america.

Vega estimates there might be hundreds of veterans who’re nonetheless on the market and aren’t getting sufficient assist, between veterans who’ve been deported and veterans who’re in immigration detention combating their instances.

The Division of Homeland Safety says details about assets for returning veterans is obtainable on its web site, and notes {that a} Could 2022 coverage directive requires Immigration and Customs Enforcement to think about army service when deciding the best way to deal with instances.

Most veterans who’ve confronted deportation have been honorably discharged from the army however then later charged with crimes after returning to civilian life.

Rodriguez’s case was completely different; he hadn’t been convicted of any crime and hadn’t even identified he was an immigrant when he joined the army.

Advertisement

However Raul and Anita Rodriguez say that in Vega and different advocates for deported veterans they discovered the sense of neighborhood they’d misplaced.

“It’s simply superb, these individuals, the love we felt from them – and acceptance,” Anita Rodriguez says. “They made issues occur once we have been at such a loss. Individuals have been prepared to assist him with out ever assembly him.”

Raul Rodriguez knew he wished to pay it ahead. He realized his experience as somebody who’d labored contained in the immigration system might be priceless for fellow veterans who have been making an attempt to return to the US or to develop into US residents. The concept of contributing to that trigger excited him. And he began volunteering to assist Repatriate Our Patriots with different instances that got here up.

However he was additionally reminded of a worry that haunted him: Earlier than lengthy, he may find yourself turning into a deported veteran, too.

Vega knew Rodriguez, like so many others, was combating for his life. And he or she knew he wanted all of the allies he may get.

Advertisement

She instructed others in her group concerning the case.

They reached out to lawmakers asking for assistance on his behalf, inspired him to register with the VA for medical care and did the whole lot they might to help him.

“We have been simply actually fearful and making an attempt to plan forward for what if he was deported,” says Danitza James, Repatriate Our Patriots’ government director.

Advocates feared his previous work for CBP would make Rodriguez a goal for cartels and different legal organizations south of the border. They labored to kind out the place he may be capable of reside safely.

And as Rodriguez ready to go to a key immigration courtroom listening to in November, Vega tried to encourage him.

Advertisement

“Regardless of the end result is, you’ll get via it. We’ll discover a strategy to enchantment it,” she instructed him. “Simply don’t lose religion. You’re not alone.”

Later that day, Vega says Rodriguez referred to as her with thrilling information.

The choose had mentioned she deliberate to rule in his favor and grant him cancellation of elimination – a key step that will enable Rodriguez to develop into a authorized US resident. However there was nonetheless a catch: The regulation permits solely 4,000 of these instances to be authorized annually, so as soon as once more, Rodriguez must wait.

It might be years earlier than he has a doc declaring he’s within the nation legally, and years after that till he’s in a position to develop into a US citizen.

Every single day, Rodriguez checks the immigration courtroom web site for extra info. And day-after-day, he sees the identical phrase describing his case: “pending.”

Advertisement

He is aware of that is his finest shot for staying within the nation; a earlier software for citizenship via his spouse was rejected. For years he says his case has confronted pointless delays that made him really feel like he was being punished at the same time as he tried do the suitable factor.

“All I used to be asking was, simply deal with me like everybody else. I served this nation so a few years. I feel I deserve one thing – at the very least the possibility to remain in it,” he says.

His November listening to introduced him a reprieve, nevertheless it’s arduous for Rodriguez to rejoice. His oldest son, who was born in Mexico, additionally misplaced his US citizenship when Rodriguez’s Mexican delivery certificates was found. He’s acquired momentary permission to remain in america as a consequence of his father’s army service, however nonetheless struggles to search out work and fears being separated from his spouse and kids. Rodriguez says it’s been devastating to observe his son endure.

“Regardless that it’s not my doing, I nonetheless really feel responsible that he’s going via this due to me, due to my standing,” Rodriguez says.

He is aware of the emotional and monetary prices of residing in limbo all too nicely, even with the prospect of a courtroom determination in his favor on the horizon.

“I’m nonetheless restricted in what I can do,” Rodriguez says. “I nonetheless need to look over my shoulder.”

However Rodriguez is beginning to look towards the longer term, too.

Advertisement

In his free time today, Rodriguez is doing what he can to help efforts to convey deported veterans again to america and assist those that’ve not too long ago returned discover their footing. He additionally tries to assist advocates monitor down veterans in immigration custody.

“He has modified,” Vega says. “There’s nonetheless some weight on his shoulders, nevertheless it’s not like earlier than.”

After deporting individuals from america for years, Rodriguez says, “now I’m making an attempt to convey them again.”

As soon as his personal immigration case is resolved, Rodriguez says he hopes to work extra straight with veterans inside and out of doors the US to assist them navigate the immigration system.

“Having the ability to journey will enable me to do this,” he says.

Advertisement

Regardless that he’s needed to keep away from main journey for years, Rodriguez has been on a unique form of journey.

“I used to be blind,” he says, describing his life earlier than his personal immigration ordeal started. “I didn’t see what was happening.”

He nonetheless feels immigration legal guidelines must be adopted. However he says he now realizes so many people who find themselves making an attempt to do issues the suitable method are caught.

“I’ve been on either side, and I sympathize with them much more now due to what I went via. And now I do know what they’ve gone via,” he says. “It’s not, ‘When you make it, you’re good.’ You continue to need to wrestle whilst you’re right here.”

Above all, Rodriguez says, veterans who fought for america shouldn’t need to face deportation or endure in hospitals overseas.

Advertisement

“If (the federal government) treats its personal patriots like this, are you able to think about what it’s going to do to its individuals? It’s a shame,” he says.

The Division of Homeland Safety says the federal government is dedicated to serving to veterans entry advantages and companies, and serving to members of the army develop into residents as soon as they’re eligible. Greater than 10,600 members of the army turned US residents final 12 months, a division spokesperson mentioned.

“We’re profoundly grateful for the service and sacrifice of army service members, veterans, and their households,” the spokesperson mentioned.

However Rodriguez says his expertise left him feeling discarded and deserted by the federal government he served, and he says he’s met different veterans who share related sentiments.

The state of affairs infuriates him. However sitting on the dinner desk in his Texas dwelling – some 10 miles from the Mexico border – he smiles as a textual content message flashes throughout his display.

Advertisement

It’s from a deported veteran who not too long ago returned to america.

“Howdy brother. … All of us prayed to your keep [of removal]. Hope you and your loved ones are okay.”

After greater than a 12 months speaking and texting, they’re planning to satisfy up in particular person quickly. It’s a reminder of the brand new friendships Rodriguez has cast, and the brand new mission he’s discovered.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

News

Anglo American plans break-up after rejecting £34bn BHP bid

Published

on

Anglo American plans break-up after rejecting £34bn BHP bid

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Anglo American plans to break itself up as the embattled mining group tries to win over shareholders following its rejection of a £34bn takeover bid from rival BHP.

In a series of sweeping changes to the 107-year-old mining company, Anglo said on Tuesday that it would sell or demerge its De Beers diamond business, its South African-based Anglo American Platinum operation as well as its coking coal assets.

London-listed Anglo will instead focus on its copper, iron ore and crop nutrients businesses. BHP, the world’s biggest miner, has set its sights on securing Anglo’s copper business, which is expected to boom as the world decarbonises.

Advertisement

Since rebuffing two approaches from BHP, Anglo’s chief executive Duncan Wanblad has been under intense pressure to set out the group’s future as a standalone group.

Laying out the proposed changes, Wanblad said: “These actions represent the most radical changes to Anglo American in decades.” They will result in “a radically simpler business [that] will deliver sustainable incremental value creation”.

Anglo said it would also pull back on spending on Woodsmith, a flagship project in the UK designed to create a vast underground mine producing a yet-unproven fertiliser. Instead of spending $1bn a year to build the mine by 2027, only $200mn will be spent next year and nothing in 2026.

Shares in Anglo fell 0.5 per cent to £27.03 in early trading on Tuesday. BHP’s improved offer valued Anglo at £27.53, up from approximately £25 in its original bid.

Anglo shareholders have predicted that the group would struggle to sustain its current structure. They have long complained that the value of Anglo’s coveted copper mines in Latin America has been obscured by its other lacklustre operations, particularly its platinum and diamond divisions.

Advertisement

As part of its bids, BHP has a provision requiring Anglo to spin off its two Johannesburg-listed subsidiaries, Anglo American Platinum and iron ore miner Kumba.

Following Anglo’s announcement on Tuesday, shares in Anglo American Platinum, which produces a range of metals in South Africa, fell 7 per cent. Anglo intends to keep Kumba Iron Ore as part of a “premium” iron ore division that would also include its Minas Rio mine in Brazil.

Alongside dismantling the structure it has maintained for years, Anglo also vowed to cut a further $800mn of costs annually on top of $1bn already earmarked.

Anglo provided few details on where the cost savings would come from, saying it would “need to consider its global workforce arrangements to realise the opportunities for its employees and to ensure delivery of the accelerated strategy”.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

News

Collapsed Baltimore bridge span comes down with a boom

Published

on

Collapsed Baltimore bridge span comes down with a boom

Explosive charges are detonated to bring down sections of the collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge resting on the container ship Dali on Monday in Baltimore.

Mark Schiefelbein/AP


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

Mark Schiefelbein/AP


Explosive charges are detonated to bring down sections of the collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge resting on the container ship Dali on Monday in Baltimore.

Mark Schiefelbein/AP

BALTIMORE — Crews set off a chain of carefully placed explosives Monday to break down the largest remaining span of the collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge in Baltimore, and with a boom and a splash, the mangled steel trusses came crashing down into the river below.

The explosives flashed orange and let off plumes of black smoke upon detonation. The longest trusses toppled away from the grounded Dali container ship and slid off its bow, sending a wall of water splashing back toward the ship.

Advertisement

It marked a major step in freeing the Dali, which has been stuck among the wreckage since it lost power and crashed into one of the bridge’s support columns shortly after leaving Baltimore on March 26.

The collapse killed six construction workers and halted most maritime traffic through Baltimore’s busy port. The controlled demolition will allow the Dali to be refloated and restore traffic through the port, which will provide relief for thousands of longshoremen, truckers and small business owners who have seen their jobs impacted by the closure.

Officials said the detonation went as planned. They said the next step in the dynamic cleanup process is to assess the few remaining trusses on the Dali’s bow and make sure none of the underwater wreckage is preventing the ship from being refloated and moved.

“It’s a lot like peeling back an onion,” said Lt. Gen. Scott Spellmon of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

Officials expect to refloat the ship within the next few days. Then three or four tugboats will guide it to a nearby terminal at the port. It will likely remain there for a several weeks and undergo temporary repairs before being moved to a shipyard for more substantial repairs.

Advertisement

“This was a very big milestone for our progression forward,” Col. Estee Pinchasin, Baltimore District Commander for the Army Corps of Engineers, said in the immediate aftermath of the demolition. She said crews don’t anticipate having to use any more explosives.

The Dali’s crew remained on board the ship during the detonation, and no injuries or problems were reported, said Capt. David O’Connell, commander of the Port of Baltimore.

The crew members haven’t been allowed to leave the grounded vessel since the disaster. Officials said they’ve been busy maintaining the ship and assisting investigators. Of the crew members, 20 are from India and one is Sri Lankan.

Explosive charges are detonated to bring down sections of the collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge resting on the container ship Dali on Monday in Baltimore.

Mark Schiefelbein/AP


hide caption

Advertisement

toggle caption

Mark Schiefelbein/AP


Explosive charges are detonated to bring down sections of the collapsed Francis Scott Key Bridge resting on the container ship Dali on Monday in Baltimore.

Mark Schiefelbein/AP

Advertisement

Engineers spent weeks preparing to use explosives to break down the span, which was an estimated 500 feet (152 meters) long and weighs up to 600 tons (544 metric tons). The demolition was postponed Sunday because of thunderstorms.

“This is a best practice,” Gov. Wes Moore said at a news conference Monday, noting that there have been no injuries during the cleanup to date. “Safety in this operation is our top priority.”

Fire teams were stationed in the area during the explosion in case of any problematic flying sparks, officials said.

In a videographic released this week, authorities said engineers were using precision cuts to control how the trusses break down. They said the method allows for “surgical precision” and is one of the safest and most efficient ways to remove steel under a high level of tension. Hydraulic grabbers will now lift the broken sections of steel onto barges.

The National Transportation Safety Board and the FBI are conducting investigations into the bridge collapse. Officials have said the safety board investigation will focus on the ship’s electrical system.

Advertisement

Danish shipping giant Maersk had chartered the Dali for a planned trip from Baltimore to Sri Lanka, but the ship didn’t get far. Its crew sent a mayday call saying they had lost power and had no control of the steering system. Minutes later, the ship rammed into the bridge.

State and federal officials have commended the salvage crews and other members of the cleanup operation who helped recover the remains of the six construction workers. The last body was recovered from the underwater wreckage last week. All of the victims were Latino immigrants who came to the U.S. for job opportunities. They were filling potholes on an overnight shift when the bridge was destroyed.

Officials said the operation remains on track to reopen the port’s 50-foot (15-meter) deep draft channel by the end of May. Until then, crews have established a temporary channel that’s slightly shallower. Officials said 365 commercial vessels have passed through the port in recent weeks. The port normally processes more cars and farm equipment than any other in the country.

Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, a Baltimore native whose father and brother served as mayor decades ago, compared the Key Bridge disaster to the overnight bombardment of Baltimore’s Fort McHenry, which long ago inspired Francis Scott Key to write “The Star-Spangled Banner” during the War of 1812. She said both are a testament to Maryland’s resilience.

Advertisement

Pelosi, a Democrat who represents California’s 11th district, attended Monday’s news conference with two of her relatives. She praised the collective response to the tragedy as various government agencies have come together, working quickly without sacrificing safety.

“Proof through the night that our flag was still there,” she said. “That’s Baltimore strong.”

Continue Reading

News

Why Hong Kong should put debt restructuring back on the legislative agenda

Published

on

Why Hong Kong should put debt restructuring back on the legislative agenda

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

In January, journalists, corporate consultants and restructuring specialists filled up a Hong Kong courtroom in a rare scene to attend Evergrande’s winding-up hearing where judge Linda Chan declared “enough is enough” and handed down a liquidation order.

The landmark case involving China’s once-biggest property developer by sales with more than $300bn in liabilities has put the territory’s legal framework for resolving debt problems back in the spotlight. More than 20 Chinese developers have been slapped with winding-up petitions in Hong Kong since China’s real estate crisis began in 2021, with at least five being ordered to be wound up by a Hong Kong judge.

This is not a great result for any of the parties involved. Often described as a “nuclear option” and a lose-lose scenario by lawyers, these winding-up court proceedings leave creditors with little to no return. And proceedings can drag out for many months.

Advertisement

Lawyers and restructuring specialists say Hong Kong’s legal framework for other debt restructuring options is lacking compared with financial jurisdictions such as London, New York and Singapore.

A restructuring bill to remedy this has been in discussion for more than 20 years in the Asian financial hub but other legislative priorities have taken precedence amid a lack of consensus on what it should contain. The last push to introduce one came in 2020 when a draft legislative proposal was made as the Covid-19 pandemic struck.

The Hong Kong government carried out a consultation but later put the plan again on hold. Although it said it would continue to consult stakeholders to refine the legislative proposals, there does not appear to be a timeframe for that.

Lawyers said there was a pressing need to raise the proposal back up the agenda, particularly as offshore creditors increasingly use Hong Kong courts to force distressed Chinese developers into speeding up their restructuring plans.

Chinese developers have defaulted on a massive $115bn of $175bn in outstanding offshore dollar bonds since 2021, according to Bloomberg data. And property developer Shimao last month became one of the latest to face a winding-up petition, unusually from a Chinese state-backed bank. Country Garden, which defaulted in October, received a winding-up petition in February involving more than $200mn worth of debt.

Advertisement

A key element of a restructuring bill is that after the appointment of a supervisor for a debt restructuring, a statutory moratorium would be imposed to halt parties from rushing off to court and asking for a winding up.

Under the current legal system in Hong Kong, creditors are free to go after distressed companies by filing wind-up petitions before a scheme of arrangement for a restructuring is agreed and then approved by a court, according to Jamie Stranger, a Hong Kong-based partner at Stephenson Harwood.

Law firm Herbert Smith Freehills says this gives “dissenting creditors significant leverage to hold the company and other consenting creditors to ransom and otherwise encourages ‘rogue’ behaviour by them, which in turn jeopardises the restructuring efforts”. It adds: “This often leads to a worse outcome for all interested parties where there is a genuine prospect that the restructured business would be able to trade out of its difficulties.”

One problem is to what extent would a restructuring bill cover mainland Chinese assets. Under the existing winding-up process in Hong Kong, it is very unlikely for offshore creditors to get back any onshore mainland assets. This is despite a “mutual recognition agreement” on insolvency and restructuring rolled out in 2021 that applies in some parts of mainland China. Offshore creditors remain typically subordinated to onshore stakeholders, lawyers say.

A bill “would need to interface with the mainland laws and provide some ability for a provisional supervisor to be recognised and assisted in the mainland”, Jonathan Leitch, a Hong Kong-based partner at Hogan Lovells, told me. Otherwise, the roles of a Hong Kong-based provisional supervisor in most cases “would be severely hampered”.

Advertisement

Lance Jiang, a partner in restructuring and insolvency at law firm Ashurst, says: “Most practitioners would like to have the new restructuring bill, because it definitely mitigates the gap between Hong Kong and other international centres and would give the companies and also the creditors side with more options to do consensual restructuring.”

“It’s Hong Kong, you know, the legislative council can do it quickly, efficiently,” says Jiang, adding that this would benefit everyone in the market.

thomas.chan@ft.com

Continue Reading

Trending