Cleveland, OH
OH Supreme Court: Summit County may be sued for not repairing road, not clearing obstructions when property was damaged
COLUMBUS, Ohio – An Ohio law that has been used to win judgments for vehicle damage from public agencies that don’t keep up with their roads doesn’t stop at the curb, the Ohio Supreme Court ruled.
In a 4-3 ruling reversing a lower court decision, the court said Summit County may be liable for damage to a woman’s Sagamore Hills home after part of a county road collapsed and the area started flooding.
The ruling overturns Ohio 9th District Court of Appeals decision that found the county was immune from liability for damage to Roberta Schlegel’s home when an adjacent roadway collapsed in May 2017. The appeals court had determined that in Schlegel’s case, there was no exception to the general lawsuit liability local governments receive under Ohio law. The appeals court ruled that the exception only applies to motorists or roadway users who are injured by a road condition.
But writing for the Supreme Court majority, Justice Jennifer Brunner, a Democrat, concluded the state law contains no such limitations, according to Court News Ohio, a service of the court.
Justices Patrick Fischer, a Republican, and Democrats Michael Donnelly and Melody Stewart joined Brunner’s opinion.
Chief Justice Sharon Kennedy, a Republican, dissented, joined by fellow Republican Justices Pat DeWine and Joseph Deters.
Rain in May 2017, Schlegel argued, resulted in the road collapsing into a culvert under the road. The resulting debris blocked stormwater, which flooded and damaged her Sagamore Hills home.
Schlegel said she was charged $6,636.56 for cleanup and remediation of the water from the basement flooding and was quoted $52,503.42 to complete other repairs.
Schlegel sued Summit County in October 2018, arguing it was negligent in its upkeep of a culvert. The county asked for a summary judgment about a year later, arguing it was immune from liability for the damage because it’s a local government. The trial court agreed it was not liable.
However, the trial court did not decide all the other arguments in the case, so Schlegel appealed to the 9th District, which ruled that she didn’t meet a burden of proof in her appeal and the county was immune from that part of her complaint.
Schlegel appealed to the Supreme Court.
Under Ohio law, “political subdivisions are liable for injury, death, or loss to person or property caused by their negligent failure to keep public roads in repair and other negligent failure to remove obstructions from public roads.” That section of law generally has applied when motorists seek money for car damage taken from potholes. The Ohio Department of Transportation, for instance, has a form drivers can fill out if they take damage on a state-maintained road. State cases generally go through the court of claims.
But the court’s opinion said that section of law is not limited to road users.
Brunner’s opinion noted that a factual question may remain about whether the county’s negligent failure to keep the road in repair resulted in the flooding of and loss to Schlegel’s property. The opinion added that there also are defenses in Ohio’s government immunity law that may restore the county’s immunity. Whether immunity can be restored is beyond the scope of what the Supreme Court agreed to review in this case, Brunner wrote.
The decision returns the case to the trial court to consider those issues.
In her dissent, Kennedy noted that the Ohio government immunity law defines “public roads” to mean “public roads, highways, streets, avenues, alleys, and bridges within a political subdivision.” That does not include the word “culverts” and that the meaning of the words in the “public roads” definition indicate they are part of the travelled roadway and surface on which vehicles drive.
Laura Hancock covers state government and politics for The Plain Dealer and cleveland.com.
CLEVELAND — For the first time in U.S. history, a Navy warship will be commissioned in Ohio.
Commissioning a ship is a time-honored naval tradition that formally places a ship into active duty.
The USS Cleveland arrived in its namesake city on Saturday, coasting into Cleveland’s North Coast Yard. It’s the fourth ship in U.S. Navy history to bear the name Cleveland.
“It’s a little bit bigger than a flight deck. About 25% bigger,” said Commanding Officer Bruce Hallett. “And it’s higher up, the water makes it a little easier for pilots to be able to land on it. So they like it.”
Hallett has served with the Navy for more than 20 years.
“There are up and overs. So these flags are actually single flags. So we have quartermasters on board,” Hallett said of the colorful flags seen across the ship. “So they can use these to send signals to other ships. But in this capacity right here, they’re just purely for decoration.”
Inside the ship, the decorations pay homage to Cleveland, with two murals in the waterborne mission zone depicting key landmarks and Cleveland Browns signs in the gym.
“It’s all swagged out with all kinds of Cleveland Browns stuff new,” said Hallett. “We got the colors down there, the flags, the towels. It looks phenomenal. And the crew loves it.”
Sailors have been touring the city throughout the week, and Executive Officer Adam Cline has been coordinating community relations events with the crew. He sent two specific sailors to City Hall.
“We have two members of our crew that are from Cleveland,” Hall said. “That’s where they grew up. So it was real nice to incorporate them into that and to get a great memento from the city, a nice flag for us.”
The USS Cleveland will be commissioned Saturday and then head to its home port of Florida. When the ship eventually retires, the USS Cleveland Legacy Foundation hopes to bring it back to become a museum.
CLEVELAND, Ohio (WOIO) – A U.S. Navy warship will be commissioned in Ohio on Saturday for the first time in 250 years.
The USS Cleveland is docked on Lake Erie ahead of the 10 a.m. ceremony.
Commander Bruce Hallett has commanded the USS Cleveland for more than two years.
“It is extremely exciting to be able to bring the USS Cleveland here to Cleveland and to be able to commission this ship here — obviously to introduce it to the city so that they can see the ship that bears their name,” Hallett said. “This has been a long time coming.”
The ship’s hallways are named after Cleveland streets, including East 9th and St. Clair Avenue.
A mural honoring the city of Cleveland is displayed on board. The Navy says it is rare to see something like this on a warship.
“Amazing mural, right? We’re so proud to have that on board,” Hallett said. “We’re just pretty much in awe when we saw all the stuff that we have in the city, and now we have it as part of the Cleveland. We love it as a crew.”
The ship’s weight room was outfitted by the Cleveland Browns with flags, towels, and mats.
“The Browns came and added their own touches to that weight room,” Hallett said. “So it’s all swagged out with all kinds of Cleveland Browns stuff now.”
The ship carries a crew of about 90, including two sailors who grew up in Cleveland.
The USS Cleveland is the final Freedom-variant littoral combat ship to be commissioned in the U.S. Navy.
Copyright 2026 WOIO. All rights reserved.
A trio of locally made films will grace area screens, here is your Movie Nerd Report for the week of May 11-17.
Thursday evening will bring the red-carpet premiere of “The Last Shop On Walnut” at the Cedar Lee Theatre (2163 Lee Rd Cleveland Heights, OH 44118) . The film, which was written and directed by Jason Richardson, was mostly shot in Ravenna. It stars Peter Lawson Jones and Cleveland native Kym Whitley. The screening will benefit the Charles & Margaret Jones Endowed Scholarship Fund at College Now. Tickets can be found at this link.
Can’t make the premiere? The Cedar Lee will be playing the film for at least a full week starting Friday!
Advertisement
“Blood & Rust” the debut feature from Kent State alumni Jeremy Herbert, will be coming to Cranked Up TV on May 19 and The Ashland Cinema (212 Center Street Ashland, OH 44805) will be offering a screening of it this Friday evening at 7 p.m., and it is free!
Sunday at 3:30 p.m. the Capitol Theatre (1390 W.65th Street Cleveland, OH 44102) will present the directorial debut of Frank Calo IV in “Last Call”. Sounds like this one is poised to sell out so click here to grab your tickets.
Over at the Cleveland Cinematheque (11610 Euclid Ave Cleveland, OH 44118) :
Cleveland is fortunate to be one of the five select cities of the Future of Film Is Female Series which highlights films from female and nonbinary filmmakers. The first film in this series kicks off Thursday at 6:30 p.m. with the Midwest road trip film, “Dreams In Nightmares.”
Thursday at 9 p.m. and Friday at 9 p.m. they will present a 4K Restoration of the Dutch classic “Malpertius,” which features Orson Welles.
Friday at 7 p.m. and Saturday at 4:30 p.m. they will present the Italian dramedy “The Last One For The Road.”
Saturday at 6:30 p.m. and Sunday at 7:35 p.m. they will present a documentary that explores the effects of colonialism on Northern Argentina in “Our Land.”
Saturday at 8:50 p.m. and Sunday at 5:45 p.m. they will present a 4K Restoration of the Argentinian film “The Headless Woman”
Sunday at 3:30 p.m. they will present the documentary “Four Rational People,” which looks at the Emerson String Quartet’s final performance.
More information about the films and ticket prices are at: cinematheque.cia.edu
At the Nightlight Cinema (30 N High Street Akron, OH 44308):
One of the most acclaimed films of the year is the Canadian drama “Blue Herron,” it is the feature debut of Sophy Romvari, who gained attention for her short films.
They also will be playing the documentary “Steal This Story, Please,” which highlights independent investigative journalist Amy Goodman.
More Information about the films and ticket prices are at: nightlightcinema.com
This weekend there are a trio of new films opening in wide release: The first is one that I would recommend if you are a horror fan – “Obsession”. This film continues a trend where we are seeing Youtubers become filmmakers, in this case it is 26-year-old Curry Barker. This is a spin on “be careful what you wish for” when a young man makes a wish for his crush to love him more than anything else in the world, and it gets increasingly disturbing from there. I personally loved it and thought the performance from actress Inde Navarrette will make her a star.
“Is God Is” is a revenge tale which was based on an award-winning play by Alesha Harris. Harris makes her feature directorial debut and currently the film stands at 95% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes!
The other film opening is the latest from director Guy Ritchie, the action-thriller “In The Grey” with Jake Gyllenhall and Henry Cavill.
Rounding out this busy week are some anniversaries hitting screens in “Top Gun” and “Top Gun: Maverick” for one week to commemorate the 40th Anniversary of Tony Scott’s original, and the original “Shrek” is also playing for one week to commemorate its 25th Anniversary (Anniversaries like this are making your resident movie nerd feel old!).
Lastly, I just wanted to wish congratulations to my longtime friend Dave Huffman, who has just been named the new director of The Cleveland Cinematheque! If you have ever attended some of the Late Shift Series back in the day at the Cedar Lee or Capitol, or the 12 Hours of Terror, you know that Dave is a huge cinephile and I am certain will do a great job at the Cinematheque!
Until next week my friends, see ya at the movies!
-
Technology3 minutes agoIs that traffic ticket text a scam or real?
-
Business9 minutes agoAltadena’s latest roadblock to rebuilding: Sewage
-
Entertainment15 minutes agoBreaking down Drake’s Temu haul of an album drop
-
Lifestyle21 minutes agoL.A. Affairs: He wanted to get kinky. But was his Madonna-whore complex a deal-breaker?
-
Politics27 minutes agoReport: Conditions at immigrant detention centers in California have worsened under Trump
-
Sports39 minutes agoPrep talk: Granada Hills coach Tom Harp goes for another boys’ volleyball title
-
World51 minutes agoSpanish row fuels north–south tensions ahead of tough EU budget talks
-
News1 hour agoWoman killed in Atlanta Beltline stabbing identified