Connect with us

Fitness

HIIT vs long workouts: Which is better for metabolic health?

Published

on

HIIT vs long workouts: Which is better for metabolic health?
Share on Pinterest
Recent research suggests that physical activity in shirt bursts may lead to greater energy expenditure than long, continuous workouts. Image credit: Lumina/Stocksy.
  • Walking in short bursts or climbing stairs can burn 20% to 60% more energy than sustained activity for the same distance, a new study has found.
  • Researchers at the University of Milan, in Italy, enrolled 10 participants with an average age of 27 who were subjected to 10- to 240-second bursts of treadmill walking or stair-climber rounds.
  • Experts caution that the findings cannot be broadly applied due to the small number of participants and their relatively young, healthy status.

Walking for short bursts or climbing stairs can burn 20% to 60% more energy than sustained activity for the same distance, a new study published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B has found.

Researchers at the University of Milan, in Italy, wanted to understand how walking’s metabolic cost was affected by the duration of the activity.

To this end, they recruited 10 participants with an average age of 27, who were agreed to undertake 10- to 240-second bursts of treadmill walking or stair-climber rounds.

Using an oxygen mask to measure oxygen uptake and metabolic cost, they determined that the shorter bouts of activity had greater metabolic cost, with 30-second bouts consuming 20% to 60% more oxygen than steady bouts of activity.

The researchers concluded that by starting and stopping activity, the participants were able to expend more energy due to the metabolic processes that the body encounters while ramping up to strenuous bursts versus the sustained energy use of longer bouts.

Advertisement

In their view, people looking to maximize their exercise returns might consider implementing shorter bursts of activity rather than a longer sustained effort.

Ryan Glatt, CPT, NBC-HWC, a senior brain health coach and director of the FitBrain Program at Pacific Neuroscience Institute in Santa Monica, CA, who was not involved in the study, told Medical News Today that the study’s claim of higher energy expenditure hinges on what he referred to as “specific circumstances.”

“While shorter bursts might burn more calories, the actual benefit may vary depending on individual metabolism and exercise habits,” Glatt said, adding that the implications for similar short-burst activity like high-intensity interval training (HIIT) are also unclear.

”The study implies HIIT could burn more calories due to frequent stopping and starting, but it’s not conclusive. While HIIT can be effective, the benefit over traditional workouts might not be as significant for everyone,” he cautioned.

Advertisement

Christopher A. Schneble, MD, an assistant professor of orthopaedic surgery at the Yale School of Medicine, who was also not involved in the study, told MNT that the study’s conclusions cannot be applied broadly to any general form of workout because of the emphasis on shorter activity times.

“We have to keep in mind that this study only looked at very short exercise durations, those between 10 seconds and 4 minutes. We can’t necessarily apply this concept to longer durations. The authors more or less hint at there being a potential phase of energy inefficiency with increased oxygen intake very early into a workout. Their results suggest that on average, we are disproportionately using more oxygen within the first 30 seconds of exercise, however most of this phenomenon corrects back to a steady state within the first few minutes.”

– Christopher A. Schneble, MD

“The authors’ findings apply more to situations of starting exercise, like going for intermittent short walks, than they do for sustained exercise,“ Schneble explained.

“The increased energy expenditure and oxygen intake during the initial 30s of working out is interesting, but don’t think it makes sense to prioritize your workouts around this phenomenon given it is so short lived, and you may find yourself waiting spending more time recovery periods than actually exercising,” he advised.

Advertisement

Given the relatively young average age of the participants — of which there were only 10 — the study’s findings may not apply broadly to a general population, Schneble said.

“I don’t know that we can conclude very much from this article about the role age plays in influencing the results. We also have to consider how these results might vary based on physical fitness, which can have a substantial impact on maximum oxygen consumption, [which is the] amount of oxygen we can make available for maximum intensity,” he pointed out.

“What I found particularly interesting was that regardless of the activity, there was an initial over intake of oxygen more often in excess of the eventual intake required down downstream. To some degree, this could be our bodies doing their best to put us in a situation to be ‘overprepared’ for bursts of physical activity, but a lot more research is needed to get down to the bottom of this and understand what drives this finding,” said Schneble.

Glatt also emphasized the lack of diversity in the study’s ability to infer larger trends among broad populations.

“The study doesn’t explore age-related differences, so it’s unclear if younger people, with higher energy levels, gain less from short bursts than older adults. More research is needed to verify any age-based outcomes,” he told us.

Advertisement

“With only 10 participants, the findings are far from definitive. The small sample size limits the study’s reliability and broader applicability. More data is needed to draw solid conclusions,” Glatt pointed out.

Fitness

A few extra minutes of exercise and sleep may help you live a year longer

Published

on

A few extra minutes of exercise and sleep may help you live a year longer

Adding just a few minutes of exercise per day could impact a person’s life expectancy, a new study has found.

Combined with an extra 24 minutes of sleep and small improvements to diet quality, those daily changes could add up to several additional years of life. 

The research is one of two studies published this week that examine how small adjustments to day-to-day movement, sleep and diet are associated with substantial health improvements.

Sleep, physical activity and diet study

The study, published in eClinicalMedicine, followed up a group of people eight years after they signed up for UK Biobank, a massive project that collected data on demographics, health and lifestyle in the early 2000s.

The team of researchers, led by Nicholas Koemel of the University of Sydney, fitted 59,078 people with trackers to monitor their exercise and sleep patterns for a week.

Advertisement

They also rated the participants’ self-reported diet at the time they signed up for UK Biobank to come up with a score out of 100.

According to the researchers, the study is the first of its kind to investigate the minimum combined doses of device-measured sleep and physical activity, alongside a comprehensive dietary score. 

“We were aiming to look at the interconnection between sleep, physical activity, and diet; and our lifespan — which is the number of years that we live — and our healthspan, that’s essentially the number of years we live free from chronic disease,” Dr Koemel said.

The research found that small improvements in all three areas made gains in both lifespan and healthspan.

Advertisement

The study found that improvement of life expectancy by one year when participants added:

  • just five extra minutes of sleep per day,  plus
  • just under two minutes per day of moderate-to-vigorous physical activity, and 
  • an extra half serving of vegetables.

“One of the core findings from our study was that realistic improvements, these modest tiny tweaks across multiple behaviours, the sleep, physical activity, and diet, were able to create meaningful improvements in our lifespan and healthspan,” Dr Koemel said. 

While these baby steps could help, overall the  study found that the “optimal combination” of the three categories correlated with an additional nine years of life expectancy was:

  • seven to eight hours of sleep, 
  • just over 40 minutes of moderate exercise per day, 
  • and a healthy diet.

Moira Junge, an adjunct clinical professor and health psychologist at Monash University, praised the studies and said looking at the combination of sleep, exercise and diet over the long term is crucial in longevity research.

“We absolutely need to put it together, and research like this is proof that even small changes can make a really big difference to your health and wellbeing,” Dr Junge said.

Cutting sitting by half hour helps with life expectancy

The second study, published in The Lancet, examined participants who had low activity levels and spent hours sitting throughout the day. 

Advertisement

Data from more than 135,000 adults across Norway, Sweden and the United States, combined with data from the UK Biobank examined the impact of daily physical activity and reductions in sedentary behaviours on mortality. 

The researchers found a nine per cent reduction in mortality risk when those sitting for eight or more hours a day reduced their sitting time by 30 minutes. 

Studies have linked long periods of sitting with increased risk of several chronic health conditions including cardiovascular disease, diabetes and some types of cancer.  (ABC News: Danielle Bonica)

Sedentary behaviour has previously been linked to higher rates of chronic health conditions, such as diabetes, colon cancer and cardiovascular diseases, prompting some claims that “sitting is the new smoking”.

The study also found that increasing physical activity by just five minutes a day could have a significant health impact, especially for minimally active people. 

Advertisement

Increasing from one minute to six minutes of exercise per day was associated with an approximately 30 per cent reduction in mortality risk. Those who increased activity from one minute to 11 minutes per day saw an approximate 42 per cent reduction in mortality risk.

Loading…

In 2022, a reported four in 10 Australian adults (aged 18–64) were insufficiently physically active: not meeting the recommended 150–300 minutes of moderate to vigorous activity across five or more days per week. 

“In reality, there’s always going to be people who don’t meet the guidelines,” said Melody Ding, a professor of public health at University of Sydney who co-led the study.

But what we know is that especially for those who are extremely inactive, for them to get to do a little bit more, that’s where we get the most bang for their buck.

“It tells us in terms of the benefits of physical activity, that we don’t need to get everybody to do so much. This micro-dosing concept, especially for those who are inactive, could make a huge difference in terms of health outcomes,” she said.

Advertisement

Something better than nothing

Dr Junge hoped the study findings could help people feel positive health outcomes are achievable. 

“I think that when people can feel like they’ve got mastery over something then they’re more likely to change their behaviour and more likely to have motivation to change. Health is a confidence game,” she said. 

Lauren Ball, a professor of community health and wellbeing at University of Queensland, said the two new studies reconfirm the importance of diet, physical activity and sleep for overall health and wellbeing. 

“The notion that modest increases in physical activity is beneficial is also supported by other studies, suggesting that doing something is always better than nothing,” she said. 

“The results also support behaviour change theories that suggest that improving one aspect of health behaviour, such as eating well, may increase motivation or self-efficacy for other health behaviours, such as being physically active. 

Advertisement

This is an uplifting reminder for us all about the value of these health behaviours.

‘Not a silver bullet’

While these numbers might be inspiring for some, Dr Koemel said they were not a “silver bullet”.

“It’s something that’s easy to accidentally take away from this; that maybe we only need to do one minute of exercise, and that’s not the case,” he said. 

“We still have physical guidelines, and those are there for a reason. This is really about helping us go that extra step, and ask what we would need to do to take the first step in the right direction.” 

The studies found that mortality improvements were most significant in participants who were inactive.

But Dr Ding said there was a “saturation point”.

Advertisement

“For example, in this study our data has shown that for those who are already doing 30 or 40 minutes per day; the active people who are meeting the guidelines, adding another five minutes, you don’t really see visible change.”

Despite this, Dr Koemel said looking at small daily changes across sedentary behaviours, sleep, diet and physical activity could have positive impacts more widely.

“We want to try to create opportunities where everybody can make change. The idea that we need to make these massive overhauls; wake up and and run a marathon or go to the gym every day of the week, that might not necessarily be the best starting place,” he said.

This gives that open door for us to go through and say, ‘Well, look, if we won’t be able to make massive changes or consume a perfect diet in the ideal world, here’s a starting place for everybody to put the best foot forward.’

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Fitness

Trending Exercise & Fitness Gear for the new year…

Published

on

Trending Exercise & Fitness Gear for the new year…
“Exercising” topped the list of resolutions for 2026, followed by “eating better” and “saving money.” Beauty and Style Editor, Marianne Mychaskiw, joins California Live with trending exercise products that will help you keep your fitness resolution… Or motivate you to get started.
Continue Reading

Fitness

You can now exercise with Dunkin’ weighted fitness bangles

Published

on

You can now exercise with Dunkin’ weighted fitness bangles

Dunkin’ has released a limited-edition set of weighted bangles on Tuesday, Jan. 12 through a collaboration with fitness accessory brand Bala, coinciding with the nationwide launch of its new Protein Milk option.

The 2-pound weighted bangles are available exclusively at ShopBala.com/dunkin-bala-bangles for $65 while supplies last. The wearable weights, which can be worn on arms or legs, feature Dunkin’s signature pink-and-orange color scheme and add resistance to walks, stretches, and everyday movement.

The bangles coordinate with Dunkin’s existing Dunk N’ Pump Collection.

Alongside the fitness accessory launch, Dunkin’ introduced Protein Milk as a new beverage addition available at locations nationwide. Customers can add 15 grams of protein to any medium drink that includes a milk or non-dairy base.

The coffee chain rolled out several protein-focused beverages featuring the new Protein Milk, including Megan’s Mango and Strawberry Protein Refreshers, a Caramel Chocolate Iced Protein Latte, and an Almond Iced Protein Matcha Latte.

Advertisement

Continue Reading

Trending