Connect with us

Movie Reviews

‘Review bombing’ of shows and movies like ‘She-Hulk’ and ‘Turning Red’ is ruining the credibility of online ratings

Published

on

‘Review bombing’ of shows and movies like ‘She-Hulk’ and ‘Turning Red’ is ruining the credibility of online ratings

This type of sabotage has occurred to tales with a various forged and crew, particularly people who espouse progressive views

This type of sabotage has occurred to tales with a various forged and crew, particularly people who espouse progressive views

A few weeks in the past, Marvel launched its newest present, the largely comedic She-Hulk: Lawyer at Legislation, created by Jessica Gao, which follows Jennifer Walters (Tatiana Maslany) who by accident will get uncovered to her well-known cousin Bruce Banner’s blood and turns into the titular ‘She-Hulk’, a 6’7” green-skinned being with super-strength.

Like its predecessor Ms. Marvel, She-Hulk too is numerous enjoyable and options eccentric, vibrant characters. Crucially, these are each exhibits created by ladies of color — Ms. Marvel’s showrunner Bisha Ok. Ali is Pakistani-American whereas She-Hulk’s Gao is Chinese language-American. Straight white males are, for a change, nowhere close to the thick of issues.

Advertisement

A nonetheless from Ms.Marvel

Due to this, these two exhibits — in addition to a bunch of different women-led and -centred Marvel productions, reminiscent of Black Widow, for example — have been topic to a really modern type of sabotage: review-bombing.

This phrase refers to annoyed or bad-faith commentators ‘downvoting’ one thing on the Web, or within the case of leisure database IMDB, writing a really giant variety of 1-star opinions in a coordinated method, ensuing within the movie or present’s general ranking falling drastically. Sometimes, this has occurred to motion pictures or exhibits with a various forged and crew, particularly tales that espouse progressive views.

‘Too woke’

Unsurprisingly, high-profile initiatives like these of Marvel or Pixar are sometimes within the firing line. Not too way back, Pixar youngsters’s film Turning Pink, directed by Chinese language-born Canadian animator Domee Shi, was review-bombed.

Advertisement
A still from Turning Red.

A nonetheless from Turning Pink.

The pretext, or so conservative teams would have us imagine, is that the movie pursued “woke ideology” by overtly discussing intervals and menstrual cycles (therefore the pun within the film’s title) in a youngsters’ film. As soon as once more, the film centred a Chinese language immigrant household in Canada and a lot of the characters had been non-white.

One of many first main examples of a mainstream, modern Hollywood launch being review-bombed — on this case even earlier than the discharge of the movie — was 2016’s all-female reboot of the Ghostbusters franchise. Male followers complained that Hollywood studios had been ruining their favorite IPs (mental property) with wokeness and variety mandates.

This acquainted tune translated into tens of hundreds of 1-star opinions on IMDB and sabotage on different platforms as properly. Captain Marvel (2019) acquired the identical therapy, solely a lot worse — inside hours of the movie’s launch, it acquired a staggering 50,000-plus 0 and 1-star scores on IMDB. All as a result of the film’s star Brie Larson had declared that the film “isn’t for straight white males” (she was making some extent about American movie critics being largely white males).

Poisonous fan base

Advertisement

The main grouse that filmmakers and actors have towards platforms like IMDB is that it has no mechanism in place to differentiate between real detrimental opinions and sabotage endeavours undertaken in dangerous religion, usually with out even watching the movie or present in query.

Because of this, it has no means of eradicating these pretend opinions, thus lending a physique blow to its credibility as a helpful and illustrative platform.

She-Hulk: Attorney at Law  stars Tatiana Maslany

She-Hulk: Lawyer at Legislation stars Tatiana Maslany

In fact, Indian audiences and filmmakers aren’t any strangers to review-bombing. In February 2014, the Yash Raj movie Gunday, starring Ranveer Singh, Arjun Kapoor and Priyanka Chopra, was launched. Inside weeks, it scored the doubtful distinction of turning into the worst-rated film of all time on IMDB, with a ranking of simply 1.4/10 after over 40,000 votes in whole.

In fact, it had been review-bombed by irate Bangladeshi viewers who claimed that the movie (which was set within the fast aftermath of the 1971 Indo-Pak struggle, which finally led to the creation of Bangladesh) portrayed Bangladesh and Bangladeshis in a derogatory mild.

Advertisement

Furthermore, they mentioned, the movie over-represented India’s function within the creation of Bangladesh and downplayed Bengali freedom fighters’ contributions (this a lot is actually true for Gunday and several other different Indian motion pictures on the topic).

As fandoms develop extra poisonous throughout the planet, on-line platforms should hold tempo with a purpose to counter mass bullying ways like these. If the likes of IMDB are to remain related within the months and years forward, they have to deal with this as a high-priority difficulty and act now.   

The author and journalist is engaged on his first ebook of non-fiction

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Movie Reviews

Movie Review | 'Nosferatu'

Published

on

Movie Review | 'Nosferatu'

Robert Eggers’s take on the 1922 F.W. Murnau film “Nosferatu: A Symphony of Horror” has long been a passion project for the director, in various stages of development since he broke out with 2015’s “The Witch.” Now that the film has finally made its way to screens, Eggers has the opportunity to shine. And like any of his films, “Nosferatu” has mood and style to spare.

Eggers’s movies always have great attention to detail, but sometimes the style can outweigh the story and “Nosferatu” is no different. “The Witch” was about setting a moody atmosphere and “The Northman” was about showing off the muscularity in his filmmaking and in between he made arguably his best movie, “The Lighthouse,” which is a bizarre, fever dream kind of experience.

In the first frames of “Nosferatu,” Ellen (Lily-Rose Depp) emerges from the shadows with tears running down her face. She is calling out to something, but nothing is there. What is making her body move in such unpleasant ways? Who is the mysterious voice calling out to her? From the shadows emerges a silhouette of Count Orlok (Bill Skarsgård), who is haunting Ellen.



Years later, Ellen is in a relationship with Thomas (Nicholas Hoult, who is having a busy year between “Nosferatu,” “Juror #2” and “The Order”). Thomas is heading to Transylvania to meet with Count Orlock, foreshadowing a great deal of dread in the movie. Back home,  Ellen is not doing well, constantly haunted by the looming presence of Count Orlock, who will not let her know peace.

Not only does Count Orlock hang over Ellen’s life, but his existence hangs over the entire movie. Eggers effectively uses the character sparingly, shooting him in shadows and only revealing his face every so often. It’s best to go into the movie surprised by the design, because Eggers certainly doesn’t settle for recreating the well-established imagery from the original film. Skarsgård, who is becoming a horror film regular, is nowhere to be found in his performance, completely disappearing behind the character.

Advertisement

Depp delivers the strongest performance of her young career, as she is required to run the gauntlet of emotional and physical pain. Her suffering helps bring some emotion to the movie, which can occasionally feel cold and distant in service of emphasizing the film’s craft. Individual moments of dread feel palpable, but the movie goes through plodding stretches (including with superfluous characters played by Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Emma Corrin; Eggers regular Willem Dafoe also plays a role), where the emotionality of Depp’s performance and the grim appearance of Skarsgård become sorely missed.

Even when the movie is choppy, it’s hard to not get lost in the impeccability of the craft. Egger and cinematographer Jarin Blaschke partially use natural lighting to establish the mood, while production designer Craig Lathrop transports viewers to 1838 Germany. Getting lost in the world of “Nosferatu” isn’t hard — though sometimes being moved by it as a whole is a tough task.

“Nosferatu” is currently playing in theaters.

Matt Passantino is a contributor to CITY.






Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

‘Max’ movie review: A fiery Sudeep drives this high-octane action thriller

Published

on

‘Max’ movie review: A fiery Sudeep drives this high-octane action thriller

Sudeep in ‘Max’.
| Photo Credit: Special Arrangement

Inspector Arjun Mahakshay a.k.a Max takes charge unofficially a day before his suspension ends. A huge blunder inside the station puts Max against powerful men, who come for his life. As he is faced with the improbable task of saving his colleagues and coming out unscathed from the problem, the daring cop pauses to prepare a cup of tea.

Director Vijay Kartikeyaa’s debut project is driven by a protagonist who keeps you guessing about his next move. Even if Max aims to provide unhinged ‘masala’ entertainment, the movie’s leading man isn’t a one-note character. Since the events unfold during one night, and he has limited time to cross a series of hurdles, Max puts his sharp brain to quick use. And once he enters the risky zone of facing the criminals head-on, he unleashes the beast inside him.

Max (Kannada)

Director: Vijay Kartikeyaa

Cast: Sudeep, Varalaxmi Sarathkumar, Ilavarasu, Uggram Manju

Runtime: 132 minutes

Advertisement

Storyline: A day before reporting for duty after a two-month suspension, inspector Arjun Mahakshay faces an unexpected situation. Can he save the day?

Max is a celebration of Sudeep, who oozes style in his aggressive portrayal of an all-conquering officer. If you saw him as a subdued yet classy cop carrying a deep pain within him in Vikrant Rona (2022), Sudeep cuts loose in Max to cater to his fans, who were hungry for ‘mass’ moments involving their favourite star.

The one-man show is great fun to watch to an extent. Director Vijay scripts an old-school world where the hero emerges as the ultimate saviour of distressed people. However, as a whole, Max leaves you wanting more as you expect the protagonist to face the heat of a mighty antagonist.

Sunil, essaying the main villain, is undone by a toothless character. Varalaxmi Sarathkumar’s character of a cop with a negative shade shows promise early on but gets fizzled out eventually as she fails to make any difference to the plot. Right from the beginning, it’s apparent that both the characters are bracing for an inevitable onslaught from Max.  

It’s also quite shocking how Max has an almost incompetent team. When they aren’t blindly following the instructions from Max, the junior-level officers are scared and clueless. Ilavarasu, playing an experienced officer, delivers a measured performance. The rest of the cast, including Uggram Manju, Samyuktha Hornad, Sukrutha Wagale and Vijay Chendur, are too loud in their respective portrayals.

Advertisement

One can’t blame the actors as their characters are designed to artificially amp up the tension. With a highly dramatic plot in hand, the director’s decision to showcase stronger emotions than what’s necessary dents the film.

ALSO READ:‘UI’ movie review: Upendra’s political commentary is a one-of-a-kind experience despite its flaws

The core idea of Max might remind you of Lokesh Kanagaraj’s Kaithi (2019). With so much happening in a short span of time, it’s tough to emotionally invest in the proceedings. On the other hand, Max’s racy screenplay keeps you curious about the events on screen. A superb fusion of Chethan D Souza’s action choreography and Ajaneesh Lokanath’s ensures an adrenaline-pumping experience.

Max is a star vehicle with admirable experiments from the makers. With Vikrant Rona and Max, Sudeep has deviated from traditional commercial films. The big stars of Kannada cinema are seeking change, and that’s a good sign.

Max is currently running in theatres.

Advertisement

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Barroz Twitter Review: Is Mohanlal’s directorial debut with the fantasy film worth a watch? Check out these 11 tweets to know

Published

on

Barroz Twitter Review: Is Mohanlal’s directorial debut with the fantasy film worth a watch? Check out these 11 tweets to know

Mollywood icon, Mohanlal has now ventured into the director’s chair and his directorial debut film Barroz has made its theatrical release today, December 25, 2024. The Malayalam fantasy movie, within hours of release, has gotten some vivid reviews from fans, who have highlighted their opinions on social media.

Well, it seems that Barroz has received mixed opinions from some fans, who have significantly highlighted how the film has not lived up to the expectations considering it being the senior actor’s directorial debut.

Fans have expressed disappointment at the fact that the film’s storyline is weaker, and it is only the specialised use of VFX that has been pulling it all together.

On the other hand, some other fans have appreciated the impeccable acting chops of Mohanlal himself, with special mention to the excellent 3D presentation appealing to mass audiences for more than one reason.

Advertisement

There have been specific references to a few underwater scenes, which have been touted as an epitome of masterclass cinematic presentation, not to forget how it would not hit as a mass entertainer.

Check out the fans’ reviews about Barroz on Twitter:











Mohanlal has left no stone unturned when it comes to the jam-packed promotional spree for Barroz. The film’s cinematography has been done by the talented Santosh Sivan, while the musical score is handled by Mark Killian.

Coming to the plot of the film, it is said to revolve around the conquest undertaken by Barroz, the guardian of a treasure which has been hidden for over 400 years. This wealth has been trusted to only a true descendant of Da Gama. 

Advertisement

It is inspired as an adaptation of Jijo Punnoose’s novel Barroz: Guardian of D’Gama’s Treasure. However, the scenes were rewritten by Mohanlal and Thazhathupurakkal Karunakara Panicker, including characters and locations, leading to the exit of the novelist, forfeiting his credits.

Speaking of the cast of Barroz, besides Mohanlal, it stars Maya Rao West, Cesar Lorente Raton, Kallirroi Tziafeta, Daniel Caltagirone, Aadukalam Naren, Tuhin Menon  and others.

ALSO READ: Nayanthara enjoys ‘best holiday’ in Europe with Vignesh Shivan and twins; sunsets, long walks and Eiffel Tower sum up her travel diaries; PICS

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending