Connect with us

Utah

Inside Voices: Who should decide which books are banned in Utah?

Published

on

Inside Voices: Who should decide which books are banned in Utah?


Happy Friday, and welcome to Inside Voices, a weekly newsletter that features a collection of ideas, perspectives and solutions from across Utah — without any of the vitriol or yelling that’s become all too common on other platforms. Subscribe here.

Earlier this summer, the Utah State Board of Education ordered the removal of 13 book titles from every public school to comply with a new state law. The news spread fast, attracting criticism and support across the state and nation.

I wanted to hear what Utahns thought about book bans. Specifically, I want to know who — and how – decisions like these should be made. Here’s a sample of what you said:

  • “As a teacher who is also a parent, I support the selection of age appropriate content for school libraries,” writes Eric in Smithfield. “I feel like the phrase ‘book banning’ is misleading because the books are still available through many other avenues (including local public libraries) if a student really wants to read them. School libraries, which cater only to a very specific age group, should contain content that is appropriate for that age group.”

  • “I’m a librarian, and I’ve been doing some research about how people talk about libraries,” writes Amy in Salt Lake City. “One common story is about finding a life-changing book. Often, such books are about gender identity, religion, politics, racism or some other topic that the reader’s family was afraid to talk about. The fear of book banners seems to be that teachers and librarians are handing kids inappropriate books, and really they are not. However, migrating from the YA section of the library to books for grown-ups is a rite of passage. Mature, well-educated readers can pick their own books.”

  • “[It should be] a collaboration between parents and the district with minor teacher input,” writes Teresa in Taylorsville. “Giving teachers too much control means potential for bias — including books that reflect their lifestyle or ideology. Teachers want too much control over other people’s kids under the guise of ‘helping’ kids with socialization. I was in Taylorsville High School where I found a book called ‘Gender Queer’ on the bookshelf. It’s disgustingly graphic and pornographic. I brought the vice principal to see it … he took photos and said he’d ‘take care of it.’ That book should absolutely be banned.”

  • “Children need to be exposed to differing perspectives to become discerning adults, and books are one of the best and safest ways to make that happen,” writes Thom in Murray. “‘Protecting’ children from conflicting opinions simply condemns them to weakness later when confronted with real world dilemmas and disagreements. If a family’s, or even community’s, values and beliefs are so fragile that they cannot withstand challenge and examination, that is perhaps the surest sign they are sorely in need of it. As recent years have demonstrated, you don’t have to believe everything you read, but you need to be aware it is out there and that others do.”

  • “As an educator I feel that schools should make smart decisions about what books they have available to students at the elementary, middle and high school levels that are age appropriate,” writes Mariah in Millcreek. “However, banning books is not the answer. You need to trust teachers and parents to monitor their own students’ book choices. These broad guidelines are too hard for teachers to manage and take away student choice, which is crucial in getting kids to read.”

  • “The book bans are ridiculous, the only thing they are worried about is sex,” writes Laura in Salt Lake City. “Violence is fine. More often than not the books being banned represent LBGTQ+ characters or people of color. Utah is no longer all white, straight, Mormon students. We have rich diversity and should embrace this rather than isolate these students more.”

  • “I think there are some books that can be considered dangerous if they are made popular again (for example, things Hitler wrote),” writes Erin in Sandy. “All these people clutching their pearls because an adult topic is covered in a teen book have forgotten that the internet exists. I would much rather my kid read a book than find potentially damaging content on the internet.”

I’m curious: Was there a book you read as a child that challenged your beliefs or changed your perspective? Tell me about it.

Advertisement

Utah Voices

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Pollution builds in the Salt Lake Valley on Monday, Nov. 29, 2021.

The following excerpts come from op-eds recently published in The Tribune.

  • “Utah’s own environmental crises — air pollution and desiccation of the Great Salt Lake — could become the humiliation of Salt Lake’s Winter Olympics in 2034 if we don’t act now,” writes Edwin R. Stafford, a marketing professor in Utah. Read more.

  • “For African Americans, the significance of Labor Day goes far beyond the celebration of labor itself; it is a history rooted in enslavement, resilience and the unyielding spirit of freedom and entrepreneurship,” writes Robert S. Burch Jr. Read more.

  • “The expertise housed in leading research institutions like the University of Utah remains foundational to our state’s welfare and the nation’s security,” writes Michael Christopher Low, the Director of the University of Utah’s Middle East Center. Read more.

  • “Utah is unlikely to ever run on Dunkin’, but allow me to convince you that it can at least trot on Dunkin’,” writes comedian Brian Higgins. Read more.

  • “If the amendment is approved, the Legislature would effectively enshrine in the Constitution its authority to nullify all citizen initiatives,” write Mormon Women for Ethical Government members Melarie Wheat and Leslie Zabriskie. Read more.

  • “The Games bring together athletes who push the boundaries of human performance, and the humanities should similarly strive for international excellence, balancing tradition with innovation,” write Scott Black and Robert Carson from the University of Utah. Read more.

  • “My neighbors and I stay in this valley in spite of its raw nature because we love it, knowing the same forces that created the beauty are the same forces that could displace us,” writes Terry Tempest Williams. Read more.

Share Your Perspective

(Francisco Kjolseth | The Salt Lake Tribune) Poll workers assist voters at Trolley Square in Salt Lake City during primary Election Day on Tuesday, June 28, 2022.

Are you a young voter — between the ages of 18 and 30 — in Utah? Let me know what matters most to you.

From Bagley’s Desk

The Book Police | Pat Bagley

Advertisement

I’m always looking for unique perspectives, ideas and solutions that move our state forward. Learn more about our guidelines for an op-ed, guest essay, letter to the editor and more here, and drop me a note at voices@sltrib.com.



Source link

Utah

How a gesture from Utah’s coaching staff helped solidify Devon Dampier’s decision to return to Utah

Published

on

How a gesture from Utah’s coaching staff helped solidify Devon Dampier’s decision to return to Utah


Amid the change of Kyle Whittingham stepping down and Morgan Scalley taking over as Utah football’s head coach last December, one question hung in the air: Would quarterback Devon Dampier come back to the program?

On Dec. 18, in the immediate aftermath of Whittingham stepping down, Dampier hinted that he was going to return to Utah.

“Y’all going to see. Y’all going to see, but it is great. I’m very happy to be here. Seriously,” Dampier said with a smile.

Though there were rumblings that Dampier had already signed a deal to stay in Salt Lake City, as time passed without an announcement from the man himself, more and more Ute fans started to wonder if their starting quarterback would return after all.

Advertisement

On Jan. 13, two weeks after Dampier dazzled in a Las Vegas Bowl win over Nebraska, the Utah quarterback posted a video on social media with his face superimposed over Leonardo DiCaprio’s in the famous “Wolf of Wall Street” clip.

“I’m not leaving.”

As Utah’s program underwent significant change — ushering in a new era under Scalley, losing offensive coordinator Jason Beck and five other assistant coaches to Michigan and dealing with departing players in the transfer portal — Dampier’s decision to come back was a stabilizing force for a program in flux.

Make no mistake, Dampier will be rewarded handsomely for staying at Utah, but in an age when the highest dollar almost always wins out in the transfer portal, there were a few other factors that weighed into the quarterback’s decision to return.

Loyalty, finishing what he’s started at Utah and playing in front of the fans at Rice-Eccles Stadium were all elements, but a gesture by Scalley and his coaching staff also made a big impression on Dampier.

Advertisement

“When I had surgery, I came back and our whole entire staff was waiting for me to get off the plane. That meant a lot to me,” Dampier told the Deseret News.

What sealed the deal for Dampier was a conversation with Scalley.

“Just us having this conversation about what he wanted out of me and just his background and my background, we just got on the same page and I love what he said. I love what I felt and I’m sticking to it,” Dampier said.

Despite Scalley being the defensive coordinator at the time, he was the person Dampier talked to the most during his initial recruiting visit in 2025. When Whittingham went to Michigan, there was no hesitation from Dampier to put his full trust in Scalley.

“For him to step into the head coaching job, I had full belief in it. No question. I think he’s worked hard to get to this position, and just as time goes on, it keeps reminding me that I picked the right decision just where things have been so far and I’m loving it,” Dampier said.

Advertisement

While this fall will be Scalley’s first full season as head coach, Dampier already got a taste of what he will be like at the helm.

The original plan was for Whittingham to cap off his Utah career in the Las Vegas Bowl, but when Michigan courted him for its open job and Whittingham accepted, that plan was scrapped.

Instead, Scalley abruptly took over as head coach of his alma mater just days ahead of the New Year’s Eve bowl game. Dampier described the time period of losing Whittingham and Beck as “a lot emotionally,” but as Scalley took the reins, the players rallied around him.

Utah quarterback Devon Dampier (4) runs past Kansas State Wildcats safety Daniel Cobbs (4) during the first half of an NCAA football game held at Rice-Eccles Stadium in Salt Lake City on Saturday, Nov. 22, 2025. | Rio Giancarlo, Deseret News

“Something that we live by at Utah is no one’s bigger than the team,” Dampier said. “No one’s bigger than the program, so when you lose one person, man, there’s so many other people in the building, we worked so hard to get to this point that one person doesn’t control our destiny.”

“So just sticking to that, sticking to our culture, and I mean, Scalley came with so much energy. It kind of lightened us up as players just to feel that energy going into a game and it all worked out obviously.”

Advertisement

It was as good of a head coaching debut as Scalley and the Utes could have asked for. Dampier threw for 310 yards and two touchdowns and rushed for 148 yards and three scores and was named the MVP of the Las Vegas Bowl and wore a huge chain with a Utah logo on it postgame.

The next day, Beck left for Michigan, along with five other coaches.

New Utah head coach Morgan Scalley, left, looks on as quarterback Devon Dampier fields a question at the Las Vegas Bowl press conference Tuesday in Las Vegas.
New Utah head coach Morgan Scalley, left, looks on as quarterback Devon Dampier fields a question at the Las Vegas Bowl press conference Tuesday in Las Vegas. | Utah Athletics

‘He’s going to be able to put me in the best situation every play’

Scalley wasted no time and quickly went to work building his staff, and a lot was on the line as he selected Utah’s new offensive coordinator.

Beck was the only offensive coordinator Dampier had known in college, and the pairing was highly successful. Dampier had excellent command of the offense, and in turn, Beck entrusted him with a lot of control.

In his first season with Utah after making the jump with Beck from New Mexico in 2025, Dampier threw for 2,490 yards and 24 touchdowns with five interceptions on 63.75% accuracy. He answered the two biggest knocks on him from 2024, improving his completion percentage while lowering his turnovers.

Utah went 11-2 including the bowl win, and Dampier helped guide the Utes to a new school rushing record, contributing 835 rushing yards and 10 touchdowns.

Advertisement

All of that production came while Dampier was fighting through injury through much of the year.

Dampier’s signature in the 2025 season came in a dramatic comeback win over Kansas State. On a night when Utah’s defense could not get a stop for much of the game, Dampier put the team on his back.

First, he threw a 20-yard touchdown to Larry Simmons to get Utah within three points, then led a two-minute drill that featured a 59-yard run from him on fourth-and-1 to set up a touchdown run from him to take the lead.

“That last score, it was surreal,” Whittingham said postgame. “It was just a moment that, like I said, you can’t even dream it up.”

Certainly, Dampier wasn’t perfect in 2025, but he elevated Utah’s offense and quarterback play — something sorely needed after the 2023 and 2024 seasons — and he also made an impact on the team with his leadership, often taking his teammates out to eat on his dime.

Advertisement

It’s no surprise that Dampier was named to the leadership council this spring, and he should be a captain for the Utes in the fall.

With Beck in Ann Arbor, Scalley needed to nail the offensive coordinator hire. Scalley, who has kept a running list of possible candidates for the last decade, turned to Utah State offensive coordinator Kevin McGiven.

Led by former Ute quarterback Bryson Barnes in 2025, the Aggies scored 30.9 points per game (No. 36 in the country) and averaged 409.5 yards per game (No. 39 in the country), and that’s with an offensive line that didn’t play up to par, to put it mildly, during most of the season.

At Utah State, McGiven utilized Barnes in the run-pass option to success, with the former Ute throwing for 2,803 yards and 18 touchdowns with five interceptions on 59.3% accuracy and rushing for 740 yards and 10 scores.

Utah State’s offense was explosive, a word multiple Utah players have used this spring when describing what it’s like to play in McGiven’s system.

Advertisement

One selling point for McGiven is that he has a lot of similar offensive concepts as Beck, and that should make the transition easier for Dampier. McGiven has also been willing to adopt the offensive language that the Utes used under Beck to help ease the transition.

McGiven has proved that he can tailor an offense to best utilize each team’s unique skillset, and that’s something that resonated with Dampier.

“You definitely don’t want to play under anyone that doesn’t utilize your skillsets,” Dampier said. “Coach McGiven made it an emphasis that he loves my skillset. He loves what I do.

“He’s going to be able to put me in the best situation every play, … he trusts me, gives me the freedom to do what I want to do every play.”

That trust is important for Dampier, and it’s stood out since his first meeting with Utah’s new OC.

Advertisement

“To have that, to hear that from the beginning, not even when we got to meet for a long time, it’s a different type of feeling that I got of trust and belief that he already had in me,” Dampier said.

“So every day we’re out here, it’s showing up more and more of his faith in me and how much we’re getting on the same page and we’re starting to learn what each other is thinking.”

When he met with Dampier, McGiven pointed to his track record of developing quarterbacks and laid out where the senior signal caller needs to improve in order to achieve his dream of playing in the NFL.

“It’s a goal of his to go to the NFL and so, OK, how do we need to develop you to get you to the next level?” McGiven said. “We need to get you more in tune with protection. We need to get you more in tune with certain types of reads, with certain types of concepts so that you can become more of a complete player.”

So far this spring, McGiven has emphasized the importance of film for Dampier and has coached him on decision making and being a smarter player.

Advertisement

“Developing the total quarterback, and I think the biggest thing with their development, probably with the system and schematics of the system, is just developing their decision making, developing their processes,” McGiven said.

“Reads, going from maybe where he’s got an object receiver, it’s like ‘throw to this guy’, and then all of a sudden you’re going through a full-field progression with certain concepts just because of what the system requires you to do.”

‘Just extra work and a lot of conversations’

Along with learning a new offensive system, Dampier is tasked with building chemistry with a number of new starters, beginning with the offensive line.

The Utes return veteran linemen with experience — Keith Olson (295 snaps last year), Alex Harrison (143 snaps) and Zereoue Williams (156 snaps) — and Solatoa Moea’i (335 snaps at “Y” tight end), but there are new faces such as five-star freshman tackle Kelvin Obot and Montana State transfer Cedric Jefferson.

All in all, it will be a completely new group of starters protecting Dampier.

Advertisement

“Obviously with the O-line as well, just me being involved in pass protection and things like that now, just having that authority, it feels great. I feel like I’m being tested as a leader and I’m embracing it,” Dampier said.

Dampier also has a lot of new pass-catchers — Utah State transfer Braden Pegan (926 receiving yards last year) and San Jose State transfer Kyri Shoels (768 yards) chief among them.

The work to build chemistry between Dampier and his new targets began in the winter and is continuing through the spring.

“Just extra work and a lot of conversations. We kind of have an unsaid rule where if a receiver comes up to me and says something, I’m going to listen to what they say and I’m going to respect what they say, and same way for them,” Dampier said.

“If I say something to them, they’re going to take it and we all know we’re having these conversations to get better. I think that puts us a step closer and closer to the same page on different situations the defense gives us.”

Advertisement

As Scalley heads into his inaugural season as head coach, a lot is riding on the performance of Dampier.

Last season showed that Utah’s offense can be dynamic with him in charge. With the return of Dampier, fellow quarterback Byrd Ficklin, running back Wayshawn Parker and the additions of Pegan and Shoels, there is a high ceiling on offense, but much of it will come down to offensive line and quarterback play.

As Scalley — who has been on the defensive side of the ball for his entire coaching career — shifts to command the entire team, he is focusing in on how to help Dampier become the best version of himself.

“He obviously wants me to get better as a passer, better as a decision maker, learn how to lead an offense fully, having the ability to be engaged with the O-line protections and just all of that,” Dampier said.

Advertisement

“He’s challenging me. He’s making me better. He’s preparing me the right way for the NFL and that’s all I want. The next goal is to get to the NFL, and with my senior year coming up, that’s a huge priority.”

Devon Dampier during Utah football spring practice in Salt Lake City on Thursday, March 19, 2026. | Anna Fuder/Utah Athletics



Source link

Continue Reading

Utah

Former death row inmate asks Utah judge to dismiss murder case slated for retrial

Published

on

Former death row inmate asks Utah judge to dismiss murder case slated for retrial


PROVO, Utah (AP) — A man who spent decades on death row in Utah asked a judge Friday to throw out his aggravated murder case after the state Supreme Court last year ordered a new trial due to misconduct by investigators.

Douglas Stewart Carter, 70, was sentenced to death in 1985 after a jury found him guilty of murdering Eva Olesen, the aunt of a former Provo police chief. No physical evidence linked him to the crime scene, but the jury convicted Carter, a Black man, based on a signed confession and two witnesses who said he had bragged about killing Olesen, a white woman.

Carter argued his confession was coerced. The witnesses — a couple living in the U.S. without legal status — said years later that police and prosecutors offered to pay their rent, coached them to lie in court and threatened them and their son with deportation if they did not implicate Carter.

Judge Derek Pullan reversed the conviction in 2022, and the Utah Supreme Court affirmed that ruling last May, saying “numerous constitutional violations” merited a retrial. Carter has remained in prison while awaiting that trial. The judge scheduled a bond hearing for June.

Advertisement

“Douglas Carter spent over 40 years on death row for a crime which he, and the evidence, says he did not commit. Legally, enough is enough,” his defense team said in a motion filed Friday.

Prosecutors have maintained that Carter’s case should not be dismissed.

Defense attorneys argue in the new motion that an investigator suppressed evidence pointing to other suspects, including the victim’s husband, Orla Olesen. The motion alleges prosecutors were close to filing charges against the husband, but a Provo police lieutenant asked them not to so he could continue investigating. Carter was identified as a suspect soon after, the document alleges.

The Provo Police Department and prosecutors with the Utah County Attorney’s Office did not respond Friday to email and phone messages seeking comment. Prosecutors have not yet filed a response to the motion.

Orla Olesen, who died in 2009, had told police he found his wife dead in their home, partially undressed and with her hands tied behind her back. She had been stabbed 10 times and shot in the back of the head, according to court documents.

Advertisement

Prosecutors said in court filings last week that they were not sure if Provo police still had the tape recording of Orla Olesen’s polygraph test. They also said they state does not have any of the clothes seized from him during the investigation. They did not have information on any other items of his that may have been taken as evidence.



Source link

Continue Reading

Utah

Utah Completes Comeback, Beats Seattle 6-2 | Utah Mammoth

Published

on

Utah Completes Comeback, Beats Seattle 6-2 | Utah Mammoth


The Mammoth’s power play continues to dominate with three goals on the man-advantage against the Kraken. In addition, Thursday was Utah’s third straight game with multiple power play goals. Cooley’s first period power play goal kicked things off before Schmaltz scored with 5:04 left in the second period, while on the man-advantage. Carcone’s third period power play tally rounded out Utah’s special teams scoring with 3:23 left in regulation.

“I think we’re doing a better job shooting the puck,” Schmaltz said of the power play. “A lot of times, we look for the perfect play and it’s not there. We’re shooting pucks and then making plays off of that. We got a good attack mindset and we’re doing a really good job of recovering loose pucks and keeping possession time.”

“Confidence,” Peterka said of the power play’s recent success. “We’re out there making plays, getting opportunities, and I think just shooting more. That’s the main factor right now.”

Utah’s penalty kill shut down Seattle’s power play on all three opportunities. One of those times was late in the second period when the Mammoth had a narrow 3-2 lead, and were looking to escape the middle frame ahead of their opponent. Utah is 18-for-19 on the penalty kill since Mar. 16 and has had multiple successful kills in six of those eight contests.

Advertisement

Utah won both of its challenges tonight and each helped keep momentum in Utah’s favor. The first was when Seattle scored 6:11 into the second period to take a 3-1 lead. The Mammoth challenged for goaltender interference, won the challenge, and kept it a one-goal game. This was a significant momentum swing for the Mammoth and Utah tied the game four minutes later. In the third period, Dylan Guenther scored to make it 5-2, seven and a half minutes into the third period. However, it was immediately waved off for goaltender interference. The call was overturned, a goal was awarded, and the Mammoth extended their lead. This break allowed Utah to take away Seattle’s energy in the final frame.

“I like to keep the credit on the players, but this one, need to give some credit to (head video coordinator Hunter Cherni) and his group,” Tourigny smiled. “They did a really good job. As much as the one we challenge and the one we didn’t challenge in a sense, I think that was the right call. So, good job by them.”

Cooley’s 21st and 22nd goals of the season allowed Utah to rally from a 2-0 deficit. The forward has scored five goals in his last three games and has had back-to-back multi-goal outings for the second time in his NHL career. His three-game goal streak is the second-longest streak in his career, which currently stands at four games.

Schmaltz has lit the lamp in back-to-back games and has six points over his last five contests. Guenther has three goals and six total points over his last three games, and the forward had a three-point night (1G, 2A). Since the start of February, his 14 goals in 20 games are tied with Tampa Bay’s Nikita Kucherov for the third-most in the NHL in that time frame.

With the win, Utah has a five-point lead over the San Jose Sharks (WC2), Nashville Predators, and Los Angeles Kings who all have 79 points. The Mammoth have a six-plus point lead over the remaining teams chasing playoff berths in the west. Coming into this two-game road trip, the Mammoth knew how important it would be to win these games. After getting the first win, Utah is determined to keep going with Saturday’s game in Vancouver.

Advertisement

“I think it just gives us confidence,” Peterka said of the win. “We’re in a really good spot right now and just have to keep pushing. The road trip is really important for us, big game in Vancouver, so we need to keep pushing.”

Additional Notes from Tonight

  • Forward Jack McBain left the game during the second period and did not return. According to Mammoth PR he has a lower-body injury. McBain played 9:00, had two hits, and one block.
  • Utah swept the season series against Seattle with three multi-goal wins. Thursday was the first win in franchise history at Climate Pledge Arena. The Mammoth outscored the Kraken 17-8 during the 2025-26 campaign.

Upcoming Schedule



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending