Connect with us

San Francisco, CA

2024 Fantasy Football Draft Prep: San Francisco 49ers player outlooks, schedule, depth chart and more to know

Published

on

2024 Fantasy Football Draft Prep: San Francisco 49ers player outlooks, schedule, depth chart and more to know


The 49ers showcased their offensive prowess, finishing top five in total offense, passing yards per game, rushing yards per game and total points scored. Additionally, four players recorded over 1,000 scrimmage yards, which was a league first. Despite a narrow 34-31 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs in Super Bowl LVIII, they retain the majority of their core starters, setting the stage for another deep playoff run.  

Below the CBS Sports Fantasy staff will take a look into the 49ers’ entire team outlook including changes to the top of the depth chart that matter for Fantasy, a burning question for Fantasy Football managers that needs to be answered, a review of their draft class, strength of schedule, and individual player outlooks for all of the notable 49ers players who may end up on your Fantasy rosters.

49ers 2024 lineup changes

Burning question: How much more does Christian McCaffrey have in the tank?

Christian McCaffrey’s versatility earned him the Offensive Player of the Year award last season, amassing 1,459 rushing yards and 14 touchdowns, along with 564 receiving yards and seven touchdowns. His ability to excel as a receiver sets him apart. This much was evident in 2019 when he became one of three running backs in NFL history with 1,000 yards rushing and receiving in a single season. However, at 28 years old and entering the 2024 NFL season, age is a factor. In addition to McCaffrey, San Francisco’s running back room consists of Elijah Mitchell and this year’s fourth-round draft pick Isaac Guerendo. Both running backs are known for their game-breaking speed, and the 49ers would be wise to put more on their plate to preserve McCaffrey until the back half of the regular season.  

49ers 2024 schedule

WK DATE OPP TIME TV VENUE
1 Sep 9, 2024 vsN.Y. Jets 8:15 pm ABC Levi’s Stadium
2 Sep 15, 2024 @Minnesota 1:00 pm CBS U.S. Bank Stadium
3 Sep 22, 2024 @L.A. Rams 4:25 pm FOX SoFi Stadium
4 Sep 29, 2024 vsNew England 4:05 pm FOX Levi’s Stadium
5 Oct 6, 2024 vsArizona 4:05 pm FOX Levi’s Stadium
6 Oct 10, 2024 @Seattle 8:15 pm AMZN Lumen Field
7 Oct 20, 2024 vsKansas City 4:25 pm FOX Levi’s Stadium
8 Oct 27, 2024 vsDallas 8:20 pm NBC Levi’s Stadium
9 BYE
10 Nov 10, 2024 @Tampa Bay 1:00 pm FOX Raymond James Stadium
11 Nov 17, 2024 vsSeattle 4:05 pm FOX Levi’s Stadium
12 Nov 24, 2024 @Green Bay 4:25 pm FOX Lambeau Field
13 Dec 1, 2024 @Buffalo 8:20 pm NBC Highmark Stadium
14 Dec 8, 2024 vsChicago 4:25 pm FOX Levi’s Stadium
15 Dec 12, 2024 vsL.A. Rams 8:15 pm AMZN Levi’s Stadium
16 Dec 22, 2024 @Miami 4:25 pm CBS Hard Rock Stadium
17 Dec 30, 2024 vsDetroit 8:15 pm ABC Levi’s Stadium
18 Jan 5, 2025 @Arizona TBA State Farm Stadium

49ers 2024 player outlooks

By Dave Richard and CBS Fantasy staff

QB Brock Purdy

Easily one of the most efficient quarterbacks in the league, Purdy has solidified himself as a top-12 Fantasy QB thanks to averaging over 20 Fantasy points (six points per passing TD) in each of his first two seasons. In fact he’s hit that 20-point mark in nearly 70% of his regular-season games. It’s not because of volume — Purdy averaged 27.8 passes per game last year, putting him 22nd among 23 qualifiers in the stat. It’s what he does with the ball: Purdy was first among qualifying passers in yards per attempt (9.6), second in TD rate (7.0%) and second in completion rate (69.4%). In fact if he threw more passes more often, he’d challenge to be among the best quarterbacks in Fantasy. As it stands, he’s consistent with a high ceiling in any matchup with high scoring potential. That’s why he’s a top Fantasy option once you’re past all the QBs in the first two tiers. In fact, he’s a value in one-QB leagues because you’ll draft him after 100th overall. In Superflex/two-QB leagues he’ll be taken in Round 2 as approximately the 10th quarterback off the board.  

Advertisement

QB Joshua Dobbs

Dobbs took Fantasy managers on a wild ride in 2023 with two teams. It began in Arizona where Dobbs started for the injured Kyler Murray, and he scored at least 19.1 Fantasy points in four of eight games. Then he went to Minnesota as a replacement for Kirk Cousins, and Dobbs scored at least 18.9 Fantasy points in three games in a row before eventually being replaced by Nick Mullens. Dobbs was very helpful for Fantasy managers at times, mostly because of his rushing prowess (77 carries for 421 yards and six touchdowns), and now he’s a backup in San Francisco behind Brock Purdy. If Purdy gets injured then Dobbs could be a popular waiver-wire option, but don’t plan to draft Dobbs in the majority of leagues this season.  

RB Christian McCaffrey

The consensus No. 1 overall pick in one-QB formats remains McCaffrey, who has averaged at least 21 PPR points in each of his past two seasons. In fact, of the 27 regular-season games McCaffrey played in with the 49ers, he’s hit at least 21 PPR points 17 times (63% of his games) and at least 30 PPR points five times (nearly 20% of his games). If there’s a worry, it’s that McCaffrey is 28 years old and coming off of a 417-touch season including the playoffs. The previous time McCaffrey had over 400 touches in a year was 2019, and he followed it up with two injury-plagued seasons. The 417 touches were also his most in a season ever. The best way to safeguard your investment in McCaffrey would be to add his backup, presumably Elijah Mitchell, with a pick in Round 9 or later.

RB Elijah Mitchell

If Mitchell remains the primary backup behind Christian McCaffrey, he’s among the best “lottery ticket” running backs you could draft in Round 9 or later. That’s because Mitchell would be primed for a large role in a brilliant offense whenever McCaffrey misses playing time. Keep his name in mind when building your bench late.

RB Isaac Guerendo

Every year the 49ers add a rookie running back and every year Fantasy managers swoon over the pick. It’s Guerendo this year, a part-time back from Louisville with good cutting skills and solid size and power to match. He ran a 4.33 in his 40-yard dash, but he’s also beginning his NFL career at age 24, making him an older rookie who might not have a long shelf life. If he impresses this preseason then he could end up catapulting to the second string in San Francisco’s offense, which would make him a prized pick in the late rounds. Short of that he wouldn’t be worth drafting in seasonal leagues but does make the cut as an intriguing second- or third-round choice in rookie-only drafts since he could be McCaffrey’s backup as soon as 2025.

RB Patrick Taylor

Taylor signed with the 49ers this offseason, and we’ll see if he can play a role in a crowded backfield this year. Taylor is not worth drafting in the majority of leagues. San Francisco has Christian McCaffrey, Elijah Mitchell and rookie Isaac Guerendo ahead of Taylor on the depth chart, and he also has to contend with Jordan Mason as well. At best, Taylor could move up to the No. 2 spot, but he would need a McCaffrey injury to be Fantasy relevant in most formats. If that scenario unfolds then just add Taylor off the waiver wire.

Advertisement

RB Cody Schrader

The 49ers added Schrader as an undrafted free agent, giving them more depth at running back. Schrader was a stat machine at Truman State in 2021 before transferring to Missouri and leading the team in rushing for two years while also flashing some nice hands in the passing game. He’s a good-sized back with experience in the zone-run scheme the 49ers use, but he’s not a burner (4.61 in the 40-yard dash) and he’ll also be 25 years old as a rookie. Schrader doesn’t figure to be in the draft plans in seasonal leagues but could be worth a late-round flier in rookie-only drafts.  

WR Brandon Aiyuk

Aiyuk would be a Fantasy monster if he garnered more than the 6.6 targets per game he had in 2023, but he’s still a borderline top-12 WR even without the mega-volume. That’s because he proved to be among the most efficient receivers in the NFL last season, ranking top three at the position in yards per catch (17.9), yards per route run (3.06), yards per target (12.8 was tops in football) and explosive reception rate (a gain of at least 16 yards on 35.2% of his grabs, way ahead of the rest in the league). The best part is that of Aiyuk’s 37 receptions of 16-plus yards, a dozen were on short receptions that Aiyuk turned upfield on for longer gains. It suggests Aiyuk is more than just a deep-ball receiver, though it is those splash plays that helped him land some dominant weeks last year (four with 20-plus PPR). A lift in targets would do so much more for him, and it’s a possibility not only because of his talent and value to the Niners but also because of the ages of both Deebo Samuel and George Kittle, both of whom take targets away. Tack on Aiyuk playing in a contract year and you have the potential for a humongous season. Aiyuk is worth rolling the dice on in Round 3 in all leagues.

WR Deebo Samuel

Samuel proved in 2023 that he’s still a fierce stat producer, averaging 17 PPR points per game even though he left one of his 15 games after nine snaps. It helped that he averaged 2.5 rush attempts per game and 6.1 yards per rush with five rushing touchdowns — take those away and he would have averaged 12.7 PPR points per game. If he maintains his prominent role in the Niners offense he should be a locked-in starter. Just keep in mind that he’s 28 and has missed multiple games in three of his past four campaigns. Samuel is a quality No. 2 Fantasy WR worth a third-round choice, but the younger Aiyuk has more upside.  

WR Ricky Pearsall

The Niners surprised many with the selection of Pearsall in the 2024 draft, but the pick was more about the long-term, not the upcoming season. Pearsall is a tremendous route runner with great hands and a knack for getting open against zone coverage, but he lacks top-end straight-line speed. He produced modest numbers at Arizona State (with Jayden Daniels) and Florida (with Anthony Richardson) but truly broke out in 2023 with nearly 1,000 yards on 65 grabs. His value will rise dramatically when he takes over for either Brandon Aiyuk or Deebo Samuel, but that’s not promised this year. Pearsall might be a late-rounder in redraft leagues but figures to go between 10th and 15th overall in pretty much every rookie-only draft.

WR Jacob Cowing

Cowing will compete for playing time with the 49ers this preseason. For two years at Arizona and a year at Texas-El Paso, Cowing tied or led his teams in receptions with over 1,000 yards in two of the seasons and at least seven touchdowns in each. Cowing is a fast but small receiver with good route-running skills, but as his college career went on, his average depth of target slid. He’s also 23 years old, so the clock’s ticking on his career. Unless there’s some serious buzz this preseason, Cowing figures to be selected exclusively in rookie-only drafts with a pick in Round 3 or later.  

Advertisement

TE George Kittle

Kittle’s 12.7 PPR points per game last year was good enough to finish as the sixth-best tight end in Fantasy, but it was still a six-year low for the veteran tight end. Hand in hand with that is a declining target share that hit 5.6 per game last season (5.1 in games Deebo Samuel and Brandon Aiyuk were involved in). Most TEs with that low volume need a lot of touchdowns to compensate for it; Kittle recorded six scores in 2023, tied for the second-most in a season of his career. The 31-year-old is still fun to watch and playing in a fantastic offense, but it seems like a return to a heavy-volume role is unlikely. Think of him as a start-worthy Fantasy option worth grabbing as soon as 70th overall, but not as an elite-tier at tight end.  

K Jake Moody

Moody’s first year with the 49ers doesn’t evoke much confidence in a bigger second year, which is why not many folks will draft him. As a rookie he attempted just 25 field goals and averaged under 8.0 Fantasy points per game. Until his field goal opportunities grow larger (which might happen once the 49ers offense slows down), he’s not worth drafting.

49ers DST

At 10 points per game, the 49ers DST ranked as a top-10 unit, but they’ll get drafted like a top-five unit this year. That’s because they’re headlined by pass rusher Nick Bosa and linebacker Fred Warner, two absolute studs. New additions this offseason include rushers Leonard Floyd and Yetur Gross-Matos, D-tackle Maliek Collins and linebacker De’Vondre Campbell, but it’s new defensive coordinator Nick Sorensen who might be the biggest addition of all. Sorensen, a former safety, is very much in line with other former Niners defensive playcallers in that he’s aggressive and values zone coverage. Expect him to help keep the Niners defense as one of the better units in Fantasy. Tack on a mostly favorable schedule to begin the year (the Jets, at the Vikings, at the Rams, vs. the Patriots) and there isn’t a major weakness to call out. The Niners are worth one of your last two picks on Draft Day.  





Source link

Advertisement

San Francisco, CA

Where to Find Free Street Parking for Shows in San Francisco | KQED

Published

on

Where to Find Free Street Parking for Shows in San Francisco | KQED


Cross that big street
Major arteries like Market Street and Van Ness constitute mental borders for many drivers. If your destination is near a popular street, aim for the other side of it, where there’ll typically be more vacancies.

Stray uphill
Hills, too, create mental obstacles for people looking for parking. If you’re willing to walk up one of San Francisco’s many hills either before or after the show, you’ll find more spots.

Always check signs
Pay attention to posted time restrictions to avoid tickets. Some meters in San Francisco mercilessly run until 10pm. Also, street cleaning hours can start at 12am, before some shows get out.

Know when you’re beaten
Some neighborhoods are hopeless. North Beach, Nob Hill, Divisadero — forget about it. The sooner you accept this, the more inner peace you will find.

Advertisement

Trust your gut
I acknowledge that I am a 6’1” man, and not everyone feels as comfortable as I do walking alone at night. If you’re not a local, and you’re feeling unsure, read up on the neighborhood beforehand.

Realize the ‘right’ way can be painful too
If you’re tempted to suck it up and pay for a parking lot or garage, remember: after the show, you may be stuck for a long time in a parking-lot traffic jam as cars try to get out all at once.

Okay! On with my list, with suggested free parking areas marked red.

Where to find parking for Davies Symphony Hall, War Memorial Opera House, Herbst Theater or Bill Graham Civic Auditorium

East side of Gough Street, between Golden Gate and McAllister
Pro tip: Park on the left side of the street. Quick eats to go are almost nonexistent in the area, so pick up any pre-show provisions you may need at the Super Sam corner store.

Advertisement

Where to find parking for SFJAZZ, Rickshaw Stop or Mr. Tipple’s Jazz Club

North side of Oak Street between Buchanan and Octavia
Pro tip: The right lanes are almost always congested due to the upcoming freeway onramp. Watch for cars speeding down the hill behind you in the left lanes, and nose in rather than backing into the spot, if possible.

Where to find parking for the Castro Theater

Castro Street, between 14th and 16th
Pro tip: Separated from the Castro by Market Street, and up the hill a little, most people don’t think of parking here. I found a cool old metal dustpan on the street here once. Still use it.

Where to find parking for the Chapel

South Van Ness Avenue between 17th and 21st
Pro tip: Parking in the Mission District can be maddening; find solace on either the east or west side of the main artery on the edge of the neighborhood. Say hi to Whiz Burger for me.

Where to find parking for the Great American Music Hall

Franklin Street between Ellis and Geary
Pro tip: I’ve also found Geary Boulevard, between Van Ness and Franklin, to usually have open spots. (Plus, you’re right next to Tommy’s Joynt for post-show eats.)

Where to find parking for the Regency Ballroom

Franklin Street between Post and Bush
Pro tip: Separated from the venue by Van Ness, and up the hill a little, most people don’t think of parking here. Aim for the left side of this one-way thoroughfare, where parking is usually more open. Pour one out for the closed Walgreens.

Advertisement

Where to find parking for Mabuhay Gardens or On Broadway

Leavenworth Street between Francisco and Chestnut
Pro tip: Trying to find parking in North Beach is like repeatedly hitting yourself in the face with a hammer for a half hour. I park an entire mile away, and enjoy the walk along Columbus, which is teeming with action on weekends.

Where to find parking for the Midway

Illinois Street between 23rd and 25th
Pro tip: Do not be seduced by the road leading toward Pier 80; it looks wide open, but is full of private parking, and Pier 80 itself will be closed off.

Where to find parking for Chase Center

16th Street between Carolina and Connecticut
Pro tip: For concert parking, the Chase Center garage currently charges $75. Ahem. I think you’ll agree that a nice 10-minute stroll down 16th Street is a better alternative.

Where to find parking for the Bottom of the Hill

16th Street between Carolina and Connecticut
Pro tip: Parking’s not nearly as plentiful as it used to be here; be aware of the new-ish protected bike lanes on 17th and the many time restrictions. (Also, bring presents for the excellent staff at one of the city’s best clubs before it closes at the end of the year.)

Where to find parking for the Fillmore

Geary Boulevard between Divisadero and Scott
Pro tip: I agonized for years driving in circles on neighborhood streets until finding this wonderful stretch of Geary, down the road and on a slight curve, where no one thinks to park.

Advertisement

Where to find parking for the Warfield

Folsom Street between 7th and 6th
Pro tip: This one’s tough, being close to both Union Square and the Tenderloin. I shoot for the less-populated area south of Market and walk up 6th Street, home of harm-reduction services, pizza-by-the-slice joints, SROs and Tú Lan.

Where to find parking for the Brick and Mortar Music Hall or Public Works

Gough Street between Market and McCoppin
Pro tip: This is on an odd little diagonal block that’s off of most people’s radar, on the other side of a freeway overpass. It’s never let me down.

Where to find parking for Oracle Park

Harrison Street between 3rd and 4th
Pro tip: Optimal ballpark spots used to change each year. In a coincidence that I won’t overanalyze, I’ve had luck parking on this block ever since Buster Posey left the Giants in 2021.

Where to find parking for the Masonic

Van Ness Avenue or Franklin Street between Sacramento and Pine
Pro tip: Sorry, man. You will not find parking on Nob Hill. You can try driving up California while looking for a spot, but likely, you’ll have to head back and make the five-block walk.

Where to find parking for August Hall

Mission or Howard Streets, between 5th and 6th
Pro tip: The “park up the hill” trick doesn’t work here, since the nearby hill is Nob Hill. If you strike out on Mission or Howard, Folsom is often open.

Advertisement

Where to find parking for the DNA Lounge

Treat Street between Florida and Alameda
Pro tip: Luckily the DNA is surrounded by a pretzel of strange, short, wiggly streets, good for finding parking; head south of the freeway overpass to this hidden curve. (It’s where I parked when I saw Prince at the tiny club in 2013; yes of course I am bragging.)

Where to find parking for Golden Gate Park, Outside Lands or Hardly Strictly

Clement Street between 34th and 38th
Pro tip: The best way to get to these festivals is to throw a bike in the trunk, park near Ocean Beach, and ride in past the bison to the free bicycle parking area. Barring that, your other best bet is to park up the (very) steep hill, near the VA hospital.

Where to find parking for the Cow Palace

Geneva Avenue between Stoneridge and Carter
Pro tip: I don’t really have a pro tip for this one. I just want to say that there should be more concerts at the Cow Palace, which is cool as hell.

Where to find parking for Stern Grove

Portola Drive between San Fernando and Santa Clara
Pro tip: Park across the major artery of 19th, and up the hill a little bit. And, since Stern Grove concerts always take place on Sundays, there are no two-hour parking restrictions to contend with.

Where to find parking for the Independent

Divisadero Street between O’Farrell and Turk
Pro tip: You’ll have to go back in time to when you could park at the DMV lot, because this neighborhood is impossible now. I go down the hill a ways, and usually find a spot north of Primo Pizza.

Advertisement

Where to find parking for the Black Cat

East side of Van Ness Avenue, between Turk and Ellis
Pro tip: Aim for Van Ness, the west boundary of the Tenderloin. For a major thoroughfare, Van Ness often surprises me with open spots, especially on the east side heading north.

Where to find parking for Cafe du Nord or Swedish American Hall

16th Street between Guerrero and Sanchez
Pro tip: Once the daycare that’s just east of Dolores on 16th closes for the day, the white curb — which tends to scare off many drivers — is free for you to park at. Bonus points for the view of the Mission Dolores basilica, just a beautiful building.

The SF venues you don’t need my help parking at





Source link

Continue Reading

San Francisco, CA

Trump derangement syndrome: San Francisco can’t let baseball be baseball

Published

on

Trump derangement syndrome: San Francisco can’t let baseball be baseball


San Francisco is having a civic nervous breakdown because the brother of President Donald Trump’s son-in-law is buying a minority stake in the Giants.

Not Donald Trump. Not Jared Kushner. Joshua Kushner. And not control of the team. A minority stake.

Apparently, that is enough to send parts of San Francisco’s activist and media culture into full panic mode.

One Giants employee posted a video from Oracle Park turning in their uniform and quitting because Kushner was buying into the team.

Advertisement

Social media lit up with complaints about “MAGA ownership” and Trump-world influence invading one of San Francisco’s most beloved civic institutions.

San Francisco is having a civic nervous breakdown because the brother of President Donald Trump’s son-in-law is buying a minority stake in the Giants. Steven Hirsch
One Giants employee posted a video from Oracle Park turning in their uniform and quitting because Kushner was buying into the team. Getty Images

There is just one problem. Joshua Kushner is not exactly Steve Bannon in a Giants cap.

He has historically donated heavily to Democrats and has occupied a very different political lane than his brother Jared and the Trump orbit. But nuance never stood a chance here.

For some in San Francisco, the name “Kushner” was enough. That is the story.

The Giants are not some random expansion franchise nobody cares about. They are one of the oldest and most storied franchises in Major League Baseball history — with eight World Series titles and a lineage that includes Willie Mays, Barry Bonds, Buster Posey, Madison Bumgarner, and Bruce Bochy.

Advertisement
There is just one problem. Joshua Kushner is not exactly Steve Bannon in a Giants cap. Getty Images

Oracle Park is one of the great settings in American sports. Giants-Dodgers is still one of baseball’s defining rivalries. Generations of Northern Californians are emotionally attached to this team.

Which is precisely why the reaction has been so revealing.

Nobody was arguing about payroll. Nobody was debating the farm system. Nobody was asking whether this helps the Giants close the gap with the Dodgers in the NL West.

The panic was political from the first pitch.

That tells you where we are now.

Advertisement

Sports ownership used to be judged mostly by whether owners were competent, stable, and willing to spend money to win. Now it is an ideological background check.

So even indirect association becomes contamination. Joshua Kushner does not have to be Trump. He does not even have to be conservative. He just has to be Kushner. AFP via Getty Images

Who donated to whom? Who attended what fundraiser? Whose brother married whose daughter? Who might show up in the owner’s suite?This is what happens when politics becomes religion. Everything becomes a loyalty test. Even baseball.

The irony is almost too perfect.

San Francisco is not exactly at risk of becoming a MAGA beachhead because a Democratic donor with the wrong last name bought a small piece of the Giants. But symbolic politics runs the city now.

In Democrat circles in San Francisco, politics is not just something people believe. It is something they perform. It is identity. It is status. It is social sorting.

Advertisement

So even indirect association becomes contamination. Joshua Kushner does not have to be Trump. He does not even have to be conservative. He just has to be Kushner.

That is enough.

San Francisco is not exactly at risk of becoming a MAGA beachhead because a Democratic donor with the wrong last name bought a small piece of the Giants. But symbolic politics runs the city now. Kevin Mazur/Getty Images for The Met Museum/Vogue

To be fair, Giants ownership was already politically sensitive. Current owner Charles Johnson has drawn years of criticism for conservative political donations.

So this latest development landed on dry grass.

Still, the reaction says more about San Francisco’s liberal elite than it does about the Giants. The city’s activist class cannot even let baseball remain baseball.

Advertisement

A minority owner becomes a political emergency. A family connection becomes a scandal. A business transaction becomes a moral crisis.

This is not normal.

Fans used to argue about batting orders and pitching rotations. Now they investigate ownership family trees.

And the Giants are not being bought by Donald Trump. They are not being turned into a Trump campaign surrogate. They are not replacing team mascot Lou Seal with a MAGA hat.

A minority stake is changing hands. That’s it.

Advertisement

Yet for the loudest voices in San Francisco, even that apparently requires public anguish.

If this is the reaction to the brother of Trump’s son-in-law buying a minority piece of the Giants, imagine what happens if Donald Trump ever throws out the first pitch at Oracle Park.

Jon Fleischman, a longtime strategist in California politics and a lifelong baseball fan, writes at SoDoesItMatter.com.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

San Francisco, CA

Casting shade on shadows: S.F. supervisor seeks to bar using shadows to block new housing

Published

on

Casting shade on shadows: S.F. supervisor seeks to bar using shadows to block new housing


Shadows cast by tall and not-so-tall buildings alike have long been used to block housing in San Francisco, and Supervisor Bilal Mahmood wants it to end.

The District 5 legislator is announcing a law on Thursday that would eliminate the ability for people to say shadows cast by a building are an “environmental concern” that can be used to delay, and possibly block, new housing. 

“In San Francisco, we’ve literally paid the price of being too afraid of our own shadow,” Mahmood said, pointing to data showing that shadow-based concerns were used to delay or block 2,195 housing units in 11 projects since 2017.

Whenever a new housing project is proposed in the city, its developer must create an environmental impact report on a variety of factors, like toxic waste and seismic hazards. 

Advertisement

San Francisco requires that report to include a shadow analysis noting whether the new building will cast shade on any open space in the city. Mahmood’s legislation would get rid of that requirement; it is not in state guidelines, and most California cities do not consider shadows an environmental factor. 

The environmental impact report is intended to help politicians make an informed decision about whether to approve or deny a development proposal. But any resident can file an appeal if they think environmental impacts were not fully considered, which can delay, block, or alter projects. 

Shadows ultimately led to a delay for the infamous 469 Stevenson St. project from 2021, a 495 unit building on the site of a Nordstrom parking lot in SoMa.

Some SoMa residents were concerned that the project, which contained about 100 affordable housing units, would gentrify the area. 

But gentrification alone is not a legal reason for supervisors to block a project. So residents filed an appeal alleging the project’s environmental impacts were improperly evaluated. The Board of Supervisors ended up siding with them in an 8-3 vote, citing shadows cast on nearby Mint Plaza in their decision. 

Advertisement

The developer was forced back to the drawing board and had to redo his environmental report, delaying the project by several years. 

Even when projects are 100 percent affordable, shadows cast uncertainty: Residents near 16th and Mission’s “La Maravilla” housing project, a 380-unit project next door to Marshall Elementary that broke ground last month, raised concerns that the development would darken the school’s playground. That forced the nonprofit developers to hold meetings and negotiate with residents about the issue.

Mahmood said even if appeals are ultimately rejected, the length and cost of the appeals process makes it difficult to produce housing projects and leads developers to avoid building in San Francisco. 

“The housing problems we’re facing are death by a thousand cuts,” said Witt Turner of the Housing Action Coalition, a proponent of the bill. “We need to start sewing them up one by one.”

San Francisco is required by the state to plan for 36,000 more housing units by 2030, and the city’s best guess is that even under the most favorable scenarios developers will build less than half of that, and in four times as much time.

Advertisement

Mahmood, a YIMBY, has made streamlining housing a focus of his 15 months in office. His new legislation eliminates certain intermediate appeals and hearings and shortens appeal timelines, mostly from 30 days to 15 days. 

The bill will be evaluated by the planning commission and the Board of Supervisors in early summer. 

The bill is no silver bullet, however. Environmental appeals often cite more than just shadows when seeking to change projects. In the case of the Nordstrom parking lot building, for example, a failure to properly consider the seismic impact of a building was also a component of the decision. 

YIMBYs have long pursued reform to CEQA, a California law outlining the environmental appeals process.

“We shouldn’t let outdated laws get in the way of building housing, which is actually important to making progress on our climate goals,” Mahmood said.

Advertisement





Source link

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending