Mandatory Credit: Steve Roberts-Imagn Images
The Indianapolis Colts should seriously consider trading Anthony Richardson to the Philadelphia Eagles because Richardson’s development in Indy has stalled. So, the Eagles would be a logical landing spot where his skill set and potential could be nurtured behind Jalen Hurts.
*PREDICTION*
Richardson has shown rare physical tools, big arm strength, elite rushing ability, and explosive athleticism, but his tenure with the Colts never reached the expectations of a top-five pick, leading to a shift in plans.
Daniel Jones supplanted Richardson as the starter midway through the 2025 season, and with the organization now likely committed to Jones, Richardson’s future in Indy looks increasingly uncertain, which should bode well for a potential trade.
More NFL Content From TWSN
The Tua Tagovailoa Situation Points to the NFL’s Biggest Problem
Jim Schwartz Will Replace Robert Saleh as San Francisco 49ers DC in Epic Idea
Lamar Jackson is the Issue for the Baltimore Ravens
Anthony Richardson Trade to the Philadelphia Eagles
Richardson’s Colts experience has been hindered by injuries, setbacks, and inconsistency.
Indianapolis hoped his rare dual-threat profile would translate quickly, but Richardson has missed time due to multiple injuries and has completed just over 50 percent of his passes with more turnovers than touchdowns across his starts.
While his rushing production remains a strength, defenses have limited his passing impact, and the Colts’ offense has struggled to build around him and take advantage of his physical tools. The switch to Jones, a more seasoned passer with a defined NFL track record, reflects the franchise’s direction without Richardson.
Why the Eagles Would Want Anthony Richardson
For Philadelphia, trading for Richardson makes sense because the Eagles already possess a dynamic quarterback in Hurts, whose style aligns with Richardson’s strengths.
Hurts has been durable enough to anchor the offense but has also missed time due to injuries in multiple seasons, and having a high-upside backup with similar athletic traits would help maintain continuity if Hurts were unavailable.
The Eagles currently have Tanner McKee as Hurts’ backup, but McKee has been the subject of trade speculation this offseason as teams like the Miami Dolphins are predicted to pursue him in exchange for mid-round draft capital.
McKee, a sixth-round pick from 2023, has shown flashes in limited action, and Philadelphia could use a higher- ceiling developmental quarterback like Richardson if McKee is dealt.
Final Thoughts
From the Colts’ perspective, packaging Richardson in a trade to Philadelphia could yield draft picks or young roster assets, helping the team accelerate its rebuild or retool around Jones and the rest of the roster. Rather than keeping Richardson on the roster, the Colts should look to get value.
Philadelphia, meanwhile, benefits by adding a quarterback with physical traits rare in the NFL and a smooth fit with Hurts’s offense, especially if McKee is moved.
Richardson might never become a long-term starter, but in limited action behind Hurts, he could develop into a valuable roster piece and extend the Eagles’ competitive window. Trading for Richardson aligns with both the Colts’ need for return value and the Eagles’ desire to strengthen depth at the game’s most important position.