Connect with us

World

Migration back on top of EU agenda but same old divisions remain

Published

on

Migration back on top of EU agenda but same old divisions remain

After years immersed in a deadly pandemic, a historic restoration fund, a devastating warfare, an power disaster and dizzying inflation numbers, EU leaders are able to convey again migration to the very prime of the political agenda.

The difficulty, accountable for opening deep fissures between EU nations, by no means really pale away. However a 64% surge in irregular border crossings – round 330,000 – and a 46% rise in asylum functions – almost 924,000 – final 12 months have sparked a brand new sense of urgency amongst politicians to offer the explosive matter one other go.

Austria is asking for EU funds to finance a brand new fence alongside the Bulgaria-Turkey border. Italy is pushing for an EU-wide code of conduct for rescue ships within the Mediterranean. And Denmark, a rustic that pursues a “zero-asylum” coverage, is in search of help to arrange reception centres exterior the bloc.

Brussels seems to have learn the room: a unprecedented two-day summit has been convened this week to handle migration and the management of exterior borders head-on.

The European Fee is making an attempt to grab the second to advance its long-stalled “New Pact on Migration and Asylum,” an intricate, holistic proposal that’s meant to piece collectively all varied points of migration coverage and change the present ad-hoc disaster strategy.

Advertisement

“Migration is a European problem which should be met with a European response,” European Fee President Ursula von der Leyen wrote in a letter to leaders forward of the February summit.

Crucially, the “New Pact” relies on the precept that has for years pitted member states in opposition to one another: truthful sharing of duty and solidarity.

‘Between a rock and a tough place’

Beneath the so-called Dublin Regulation, adopted for the primary time in 2013, the applying submitted by an asylum seeker turns into the duty of the primary member state of arrival.

This method has been extensively criticised by governments and civil society organisations alike as a result of it locations a disproportionate burden on frontline nations, equivalent to these within the Mediterranean, that are confronted with the large process of processing asylum claims from migrants who, very often, don’t wish to keep in that nation and like to journey north.

Right here is the place the large query on the core of the perennial debate emerges: How can the EU, as a political union with shared exterior borders, relocate and redistribute these tons of of 1000’s of candidates in a matter that’s thought of truthful and balanced?

Advertisement

Thus far, the reply has been: it simply cannot.

“The present migration is caught between a rock and a tough place, primarily. Migration flows, migration pressures proceed, however member states are discovering it very troublesome to agree on a set of efficient and customary options to that,” Andrew Geddes, the director of the Migration Coverage Centre on the European College Institute (EUI), advised Euronews.

“Some member states simply refuse and won’t take part in schemes that contain the relocation of migrants throughout the EU.”

‘A debate disadvantaged of recent energies’

The proposed “New Pact” gives one other reply to the relocation dilemma: an “efficient solidarity” mechanism.

The mechanism would current EU nations with three choices to help a fellow member state whose migration system is underneath stress on account of a surge in new arrivals: settle for plenty of relocated asylum-seekers, pay for the return of rejected candidates to their nation of origin, or finance an array of “operational measures,” equivalent to reception centres and technique of transport.

Advertisement

The pledges can be calculated based mostly on the nation’s GDP and inhabitants. As soon as agreed, the European Fee would then undertake an act to make the pledges legally binding.

It does not take too lengthy to grasp the system presents two circumstances which might be anathema to member states on opposing sides of the controversy.

For these pushing for extra relocation, equivalent to Germany, France, Italy and Greece, the system lets reluctant nations off the hook by providing two choices – return sponsorship and operational measures – that don’t entail taking in any particular person inside their borders.

For these pushing in opposition to relocation, equivalent to Poland, Hungary, Slovakia and Austria, the system introduces obligatory pledges that may pressure them to contribute whether or not they prefer it or not.

The clashing views have condemned the “New Pact” to a legislative limbo, with little to no progress since its presentation again in September 2020.

Advertisement

‘Nationwide pursuits and short-term political agendas’

“There isn’t any marvel drug or magic answer prepared at hand to the divisive challenge of responsibility-sharing,” Alberto-Horst Neidhardt, head of the migration programme on the European Coverage Centre (EPC), advised Euronews.

“For too lengthy, the migration debate has been disadvantaged of recent energies and very important oxygen, pressed right into a nook by nationwide pursuits and short-term political agendas.”

A voluntary relocation mechanism backed by 23 European nations has thus far resulted in 435 relocated asylum-seekers – out of 8,000 pledges anticipated to be fulfilled on an annual foundation.

The perpetual lack of consensus on the way to cope with migration internally “dangers translating into disproportionate consideration on return and readmission,” Neidhardt added.

“EU migration and asylum insurance policies are something however in a wholesome state.”

Advertisement

In reality, the discussions in Brussels have acquired a marked concentrate on the exterior dimension of migration, the relations between the EU and the quite a few nations of origin, reflecting a rising shift from managing to stopping arrivals.

All-time highs in asylum functions filed by nationals from nations historically thought of “protected,” like Turkey, Bangladesh, Morocco, Georgia, Egypt and Peru, have additional fuelled requires a extra forceful and persuasive worldwide engagement.

“Lots of the different nations which might be mentioned are removed from steady and they don’t seem to be ‘protected’ in any sense of the phrase,”  Catherine Woollard, director of the European Council on Refugees and Exiles (ECRE) stated in a essential assertion, noting the “alarmism” throughout the bloc is being manufactured for political ends.

“Coverage-making in panic mode feeds an strategy based mostly on unfounded fears moderately than on wants, pursuits, useful resource issues or authorized obligations.”

EU to make use of ‘leverage’ in opposition to nations of origin

Consideration has additionally centred on the EU’s return charge of ineligible asylum-seekers.

Advertisement

The low determine (round 21%) has outraged hard-line governments, which have raised the spectre of invoking Article 25a of the EU’s Visa Code to slap restrictive measures on uncooperative nations.

Von der Leyen’s letter acknowledges this actuality and speaks of anti-smuggling initiatives, joint operations groups and expertise partnerships to hurry up returns and curb departures.

“Leverages from totally different coverage areas, together with visas, commerce, funding (…) and authorized migration alternatives ship clear alerts to companions about the advantages of cooperation with the EU and needs to be used to the complete,” the Fee chief wrote.

However consultants warn the externalisation of asylum coverage, also called “off-shoring,” ignores the basic causes that drive migration flows, equivalent to financial hardship, discrimination and local weather change, and may result in human rights violations and illegal detentions exterior of the EU.

“Asylum in search of is a symptom moderately than the trigger,” stated Andrew Geddes. 

Advertisement

“Clamping down on boats and smugglers and issues like which will have some results, might result in extra folks dying, after all, but it surely’s not doing something to deal with a few of the a lot deeper underlying causes of this displacement.”

This text has been up to date to incorporate new figures.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

World

Biden Calls Debate 'Bad Episode' in ABC News Interview

Published

on

Biden Calls Debate 'Bad Episode' in ABC News Interview
WASHINGTON (Reuters) – U.S. President Joe Biden again called his debate against Donald Trump “a bad episode,” suggesting in an interview with ABC News on Friday that his shaky performance was due to poor preparation, exhaustion and illness. “No indication of any serious condition. I was exhausted. I …
Continue Reading

World

NATO takes on AI as the next great theater of war

Published

on

NATO takes on AI as the next great theater of war

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become the next great domain in the theater of war, and NATO allies have made it a top priority as they look to bolster the alliance’s collective defense.

A summit in Washington, D.C., next week will not only commemorate the 75th anniversary of the alliance but will focus on safeguarding NATO in an increasingly hostile geopolitical sphere. 

The global consequences of the war in Ukraine have been far-reaching, and the deepening divides between the West and top authoritarian adversaries has had an effect on everything from defense to trade. 

At the core of how NATO is looking to safeguard itself in challenging times is change in AI technology.  

BATTLEFIELD DEMANDS SPARK AI RACE IN UKRAINE AS WAR WITH RUSSIA RAGES ON

Advertisement

A UJ-22 Airborne (UkrJet) reconnaissance drone prepares to land during a test flight in the Kyiv region Aug. 2, 2022, prior to being sent to the front line.  (Sergei Supinsky/AFP via Getty Images)

The reliance on drones in kinetic warfare drastically ramped up with the conflict in Ukraine, prompting an AI race and the need for evolving offensive and defensive strategies.  

“There should be concern about countering Chinese and Russian AI capabilities in wartime, but concern should not be mistaken for despair,” said retired Rear Adm. Mark Montgomery, a senior fellow at The Foundation for Defense of Democracies.

“Just as there are reasons for concern in countering Chinese and Russian kinetic weapons — such as hypersonic maneuvering cruise missiles — the U.S. has the ability to build effective offensive and defensive systems to deter and, if necessary, defeat adversary actions,” he added.

In March, NATO more than doubled its tech accelerator sites under a program known as Defense Innovation Accelerator for the North Atlantic (DIANA), which works with private and public companies to develop “deep technologies” to address the alliance’s defense challenges.

Advertisement

Under DIANA, there will be testing sites in 28 of the 32 NATO nations in a move to support innovation across the alliance in AI, cyber, 5G, hypersonic and autonomous systems.

But the vast expansion of AI capabilities means the alliance is also looking to establish guardrails, particularly when it comes to AI use in wartime. 

Zelenskyy standing, Biden sitting

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, left, receives applause from NATO members, including British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, center, and U.S. President Biden ahead of a meeting of the NATO-Ukraine Council during the NATO Summit in Vilnius July 12, 2023.  (Doug Mills/Pool/AFP via Getty Images)

PUTIN, XI MEET TO BOLSTER ALLIANCE AGAINST WEST AHEAD OF NATO SUMMIT

“There will be doctrinal discussions at NATO on making sure that we don’t have ‘SKYNET’ take over and start engaging in kinetic action without humans making decisions,” former NATO Assistant Secretary General for Defense Investment Marshall Billingslea told Fox News Digital. 

“As drones become increasingly sophisticated, while remaining inexpensive, and as people introduce artificial intelligence into drones for attack, there is a need for a comparable level of AI that has to get incorporated into countering UAS [unmanned aircraft systems], as well as theater missile defense capabilities,” he said.

Advertisement

Billingslea said AI is already being used effectively by the U.S. when it comes to intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance, but that is now being expanded throughout NATO.

As the alliance looks to ramp up its collective defense, its AI initiatives are aimed at not only collecting security and intelligence data from all partner nations, but utilizing that intel more efficiently by offloading the human burden of analyzing it.

Iran drones Ukraine

Firefighters work after a drone attack on buildings in Kyiv, Ukraine, Oct. 17, 2022. (AP Photo/Roman Hrytsyna, File)

RECORD NUMBER OF NATO MEMBERS REACH DEFENSE SPENDING GOAL AS UKRAINE WAR PERSISTS

AI in kinetic warfare is not the only area that has NATO on high alert. 

Propaganda has long played a role in wartime, but the use of disinformation campaigns and malware have become key tools in soft-war operations that can be widely employed using AI, making AI-augmented soft-war tactics a significant challenge to counter. 

Advertisement

“The area of greater concern for me is the use of AI to improve malign influence operations during peacetime or in a crisis buildup,” Montgomery said. “Russia and China have both demonstrated a willingness to operate in the gray zone to a much greater degree than the U.S. and its democratic allies. As a result, Chinese and Russian AI-infused malign influence operations could have a significant negative impact.”

Dependence on Chinese systems has long been debated between the U.S. and its European allies, though Beijing’s ties with Moscow has prompted many in Europe to cut ties with Chinese digital infrastructure companies. 

The war in Ukraine has highlighted NATO’s need to safeguard its members and partner nations, particularly non-NATO countries in Europe and in areas like the Indo-Pacific, from threats posed by AI technologies.

Xi Jinping and Putin toast during dinner

Russian President Vladimir Putin and Chinese President Xi Jinping toast during their dinner at The Palace of the Facets in Moscow, Russia, March 21, 2023. (Pavel Byrkin/Sputnik/Kremlin Pool Photo/AP)

“There’s a coalition of authoritarians that NATO has to deal with, and that is China, Russia, North Korea and Iran,” Montgomery said, pointing to how all four have not only positioned themselves against the West but have done so, in part, by backing Moscow with military and economic aid for its war in Ukraine.

Advertisement

“From my perspective, Ukraine is on the front line of fighting all four of these authoritarian regimes. NATO better step up to support it,” he added. 

Continue Reading

World

Russia-Ukraine war: List of key events, day 862

Published

on

Russia-Ukraine war: List of key events, day 862

As the war enters its 862nd day, these are the main developments.

Here is the situation on Saturday, July 6, 2024.

Fighting

  • Multiple Russian attacks killed at least seven people and wounded more than two dozen others in the eastern Donetsk oblast of Ukraine, according to officials. Russia has centred its firepower on the industrial region that has been partially controlled by Kremlin-backed forces since 2014.
  • Two of the Russian strikes on the town of Selydove, which lies close to the front where Moscow’s forces are advancing, killed at least five people and injured eight, regional governor Vadym Filashkin said.
  • A 32-year-old woman was also killed and 20 others were wounded by Russian shelling in the town of Komar, damaging homes, shops and an administrative building, Filashkin said.
  • One person was killed in a Russian Smerch rocket attack on the town of Ukrainsk, rounding up the seven casualties in Russian strikes. One person was reported wounded in the same town.
  • Denis Pushilin, the Russia-installed official in the Donetsk region, said five people were killed in various Ukrainian attacks on territory that Russia controls.
  • Further north in the Donetsk region, Russian forces are pushing towards the hilltop settlement of Chasiv Yar. Images distributed by Ukrainian forces show rows of destroyed and smouldering Soviet-era housing blocks in the town.
  • Ukraine’s air defence says it shot down 24 of 27 Russian drones fired in an overnight attack on Saturday. It said the drones were downed over 12 regions across the country.

  • Russian drone attacks on the northern Ukrainian city of Sumy early on Saturday cut power to the local water system and knocked out the water supply. Ukraine’s public broadcaster Suspilne reported a series of explosions in the city northeast of the capital, Kyiv.

Politics and diplomacy

  • In Moscow, Russian President Vladimir Putin told visiting Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban that Ukraine must abandon four regions in the east and south – including Donetsk – if it wants peace.
  • Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico, who was shot in May, said he would have joined Orban on his controversial visit to Moscow if his health had permitted.
  • The United States has joined the European Union in criticising Orban’s trip to Russia. White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said the trip “will not advance the cause of peace and is counterproductive to promoting Ukraine’s sovereignty, territorial integrity and independence”.
  • Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy thanked Keir Starmer for pledging his government would continue to support Ukraine, in a phone call hours after the United Kingdom’s new prime minister took office. Britain has been one of Ukraine’s staunchest supporters since Russia’s full-scale invasion in February 2022.
  • Starmer told US President Joe Biden that British support for Ukraine’s war with Russia was “unwavering”, in a first call hours after he took charge.
  • NATO allies at their summit in Washington, DC, next week will unveil a “bridge to membership” plan for Ukraine and announce steps to bolster Kyiv’s air defences, a senior US official said.

  • Mihail Popsoi, the foreign minister of Moldova, a former Soviet Republic, said his government reserved the right to order further expulsions of Russian diplomats if Moscow engaged in new activities harmful to the country’s interests. Moldova’s relations with Russia have deteriorated as President Maia Sandu has denounced Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and led a drive to join the European Union.

Russian soldiers firing from the BM-21 Grad self-propelled 122mm multiple rocket launcher from an undisclosed location inside Ukraine [File: Russian Defence Ministry Press Service via AP]
Continue Reading

Trending