Connect with us

Arizona

‘They failed us’: Arizona mother demands accountability after son’s death in DCS custody

Published

on

‘They failed us’: Arizona mother demands accountability after son’s death in DCS custody


MESA, AZ — Serious questions are being raised about the Arizona Department of Child Safety after newly released records show a 15-year-old boy died in DCS custody while living at a Mesa group home.

Christian Williams, 15, is now the second child with Type 1 diabetes to die in the state’s care. The second child to be allowed to refuse his insulin, the lifesaving medication he needed to live, according to police reports and a state incident report.

“They failed us,” said Christian’s mother Bobbie Williams.

911 call from group home came too late

The call for help happened two months ago and haunts the Williams family.

Advertisement

“What’s going on?” the 911 dispatcher asked the woman who made the call from the group home.

“Yes. I have a youth that’s refusing insulin or refusing medical help. Won’t go anywhere. Now he’s making weird noises on the floor,” the employee said.

“He’s making a scene. Now he’s acting like he’s like dead on the floor,” the group home staff later told the 911 dispatcher.

The call for help was ultimately too late to save Christian’s life.

“They could have called sooner,” said Bobbie Williams.

Advertisement

Christian was found unconscious inside the Mesa group home where he was living, according to the police report.

“They assumed because he has behavioral issues that he was faking,” said Christian’s father, DeForrest Williams.

“And he was seeking attention,” said Bobbie.

But records show they were wrong.

Police body camera video shows response

Body camera video obtained by the ABC15 Investigators details the Mesa police and Mesa fire response.

Advertisement

The video brings into question whether the group home’s employees were properly trained to manage Christian’s diabetes.

“So now he’s pretending he’s dead on the floor,” a female on scene told the Mesa officer.

The group home employee then told the Mesa officer, “He’s fine. He’s holding his breath.”

But once officers and paramedics get inside, the situation escalates.

The video shows Christian is unresponsive. Paramedics must physically carry him out of the bathroom where he was found.

Advertisement

“We need to get his heart pumping,” a paramedic said on the body camera video.

According to the Mesa police report: “Christian’s lips appeared to be blue, and his eyes were barely open.”

“Paramedics began conducting chest compressions after it was discovered he was not breathing,” the report states.

“It’s very hard for me to watch those videos and to read what happened,” said Bobbie.

Christian died at the hospital a few days later on July 10, 2024. The medical examiner ruled his cause of death was diabetic ketoacidosis, a preventable condition caused by not having enough insulin.

Advertisement

“I lost my baby. He was my firstborn. I’ll never get him back,” said Bobbie. “We trusted the Arizona Department of Child Safety.”

Christian struggled with mental health

Christian lived with his parents his whole life, except the last seven months. As Christian got older, he started struggling with mental health. His family turned to the Arizona Department of Child Safety for help.

“We were told that they had more resources than we were able to do ourselves,” said DeForrest.

“He was in their care,” said Bobbie, while holding back tears. “And I beat myself up every day for making that decision.”

Incident report shows DCS knew group home had concerns

The state incident report from Catalyst Community Corporation, the group home where Christian was living, only amplifies the family’s anger and frustration.

Advertisement

The report says weeks before Christian’s death managers at the group home held an emergency child and family team meeting with DCS where they said Christian was, “in need of a higher level of care due to his medical concerns and mental health. While the team was in agreeance [agreement], there was no progress on making these changes.”

“How could you?” said DeForrest.

It was also the second time in two weeks, records show, Christian needed emergency care for his diabetes while living at this group home.

“I said … what’s it’s going to take for my son to die?” Bobbie said. “And then two weeks later we get that call.”

Another child with Type 1 diabetes died in DCS custody

The ABC15 Investigators have previously reported on the death of Jakob Blodgett, 9, who died just 18 days after being placed in DCS custody.

Advertisement

Jakob was a Type 1 diabetic, and he died in December of 2022. Records show he was also allowed to refuse his insulin, the lifesaving medication he needed to live, while at another group home contracted by the state.

Senator T.J. Shope, R-Casa Grande, demanded accountability and answers following ABC15’s reporting into Jakob’s death.

“Why didn’t you learn the first time? Why didn’t you change then? Why does it have to be another child?” said Bobbie.

It’s the Arizona Department of Child Safety’s job to protect the state’s most vulnerable children and DCS pays group homes to take care of kids like Christian.

Attorney files notice of claim

Attorney Robert Pastor has filed a lawsuit against DCS and the group home in Jakob’s case.

Advertisement

“This is the Department of Child Safety, and they’ve lost sight of the children and the concept of safety.”

Pastor now also represents the Williams’ family and recently sent DCS and the group home a notice of claim, which is the precursor to a lawsuit.

The claim alleges, “The Arizona Department of Child Safety has a pattern and practice of placing children in foster care settings that pose an unreasonable risk of harm.”

“It’s utter disgust. Like, ‘you did this again, what is wrong with you?’” said Pastor.

Under the state’s contract and license with Catalyst Community Corporation, administrative rules state a group home must “ensure that each child in care receives all prescribed medication at the prescribed time and in the prescribed dose.”

Advertisement

“Instead, they sat there and said, ‘oh, he’s faking it.’ And they were dead wrong. Unfortunately, that meant Christian died,” Pastor said.

For more than a year, ABC15 has asked DCS what changes have been made to prevent another tragedy. But DCS has refused to answer that question, citing the pending litigation.

“Here are two kids who are dead. What are you doing? Do we need a third?” said Pastor.

The Williams family is sharing their story because they want DCS to change and make sure no other family has to go through their pain.

“It’s not fair for a mother to go to a graveside and eat her lunch with her son,” Bobbie said while crying.

Advertisement

DCS launches investigation after Christian’s death

DCS responded to ABC15’s reporting and said the agency shares in the grief the family is experiencing over Christian’s tragic loss.

“At times, children come to us experiencing escalated medical and behavioral crises. Our team of providers work hard to address the child’s medical and behavioral health needs,” a DCS spokesman said in a statement.

The agency also said:

“In response to this tragedy, the Department is currently investigating this incident as well as reviewing licensing rules to determine if anything different can be done to better understand and care for youth facing extreme health challenges.”

DCS said the results of the investigation will be publicly available once complete.

Advertisement
Null

ABC15 is committed to finding the answers you need and holding those accountable.

Submit your news tip to Investigators@abc15.com

ABC15 reached out to Governor Hobbs and requested an on-camera interview to discuss this failure within her state agency but the interview request was declined.

“As a social worker, I worked directly with children like Christian in the hopes of giving them a better life. This experience has guided my work throughout my career,” Governor Hobbs said in a statement. “As Governor, I continue to be committed to protecting the health and safety of all Arizonans, especially vulnerable children like Christian, and every child in DCS care. I am heartbroken by Christian’s story and extend my full condolences to his family and loved ones.”

ABC15 called and sent multiple emails to the group home administrator but did not hear back by our deadline.

Advertisement

Have a tip for the ABC15 Investigators? Email Investigator Jennifer Kovaleski at jennifer.kovaleski@abc15.com.

Read DCS’ full statement below:

“We share in the grief his family is experiencing over Christian’s tragic loss.  At times, children come to us experiencing escalated medical and behavioral crises. Our team of providers work hard to address the child’s medical and behavioral health needs. 

We have many rules in place to guide providers who care for our children. You can find them here. [apps.azsos.gov]

In response to this tragedy, the Department is currently investigating this incident as well as reviewing licensing rules to determine if anything different can be done to better understand and care for youth facing extreme health challenges.

Advertisement

The Department is committed to strengthening our partnerships with the provider community, including our medical, behavioral health, and contracted providers. We are dedicated to learning from these tragedies and making any necessary improvements to enhance care and safety. Through our robust Multidisciplinary Review Process, we strive to foster collaboration, ensure continuous learning, and improve outcomes for Arizona’s children and families.”





Source link

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Arizona

Additional 120K Arizona voters may be affected by MVD coding error

Published

on

Additional 120K Arizona voters may be affected by MVD coding error


PHOENIX (AZFamily) — It appears an additional 120,000 voters in Arizona may have been affected by a database error that didn’t confirm their citizenship status, the state Secretary of State’s Office said on Monday.

The voters have lived in the state for decades, but a data coding oversight allowed them access to the full ballot even though they hadn’t provided documented proof of citizenship.

This is in addition to the nearly 98,000 people whose citizenship documents hadn’t been confirmed that was discovered earlier this month.

But, Secretary of State Adrian Fontes said the Arizona Supreme Court’s Sept. 20 decision that 98,000 voters can vote in state and local races should apply to the 120,000 voters also affected by the data error.

Advertisement

The high court said these registered voters can cast a ballot since they registered long ago and had attested under the penalty of law that they are citizens. The justices also said the voters were not at fault for the database error and also mentioned the little time that’s left before the Nov. 5 general election.

The total number of those affected by the oversight is roughly 79,000 Republicans, 61,000 Democrats, and 76,000 Other Party, bringing the total number of impacted individuals to approximately 218,000, the Secretary of State’s Office said.

Arizona considers driver’s licenses issued after October 1996 to be valid proof of citizenship. However, a system coding error marked the voters who obtained licenses before 1996 as full-ballot voters, state officials said.

Election officials will contact the affected Arizonans with information regarding their status after the conclusion of the Nov. 5 if necessary, officials said.

Fontes said documentation for proof of citizenship is “an extreme law.”

Advertisement

“The reality is these registrants have met the same legal standard as every other American who registers to vote: swearing under penalty of perjury that they are U.S. citizens. We can’t risk denying actual citizens the right to vote due to an error out of their control. This issue is another example of why we need to fund elections, update systems and staff, and carry forward our proven tradition of safe, fair and secure elections,” Fontes said in a written statement.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

See a spelling or grammatical error in our story? Please click here to report it.

Do you have a photo or video of a breaking news story? Send it to us here with a brief description.

Advertisement



Source link

Continue Reading

Arizona

Micah Bernard says Utah’s red zone efficiency needs improvement after Arizona loss

Published

on

Micah Bernard says Utah’s red zone efficiency needs improvement after Arizona loss


Utah suffered its first loss of the season in a 23-10 defeat against Arizona at Rice-Eccles Stadium on Saturday night. The game highlighted significant execution issues for the Utes, particularly in the red zone, which was a recurring theme throughout the game. Despite being able to move the ball effectively between the 20-yard lines, Utah struggled to capitalize on scoring opportunities.

Utes head coach Kyle Whittingham didn’t hold back when assessing the team’s performance, saying, “We were horrible, awful in the red zone.” This inefficiency was evident on Utah’s first two drives, both of which ended in failures deep in Arizona territory. The first drive resulted in a turnover on downs after Mike Mitchell was stopped for a loss on fourth and 1 at the Arizona 10-yard line. On the next drive, freshman quarterback Isaac Wilson had a pass broken up on fourth and goal from the 2-yard line.

Where Utah ranks in AP top 25 poll after loss to Arizona

In total, the Utes went 0-for-4 on fourth-down conversions and managed only 10 points in four trips to the red zone. Utah running back Micah Bernard expressed frustration with the team’s performance, emphasizing that the red zone should be a primary focus moving forward.

Advertisement

“We’re just not executing well enough,” said Bernard. “Red zone should be the focus for us. It’s unacceptable for us.”

Despite outgaining Arizona 280-to-197 through the air, Utah failed to convert those opportunities into points as efficiently as the Wildcats. The only bright spot for the Utes was an 80-yard touchdown drive early in the fourth quarter, but they managed just 65 total yards on their other six second-half possessions. Utah’s inability to execute in crucial moments proved costly, with Isaac Wilson, in his third start, showing flashes but unable to lead a consistent offense in the absence of injured starter Cam Rising.



Source link

Continue Reading

Arizona

Key Senate race in Arizona could hinge on voters who back Trump and the Democratic candidate

Published

on

Key Senate race in Arizona could hinge on voters who back Trump and the Democratic candidate


PHOENIX (AP) — If Ruben Gallego is going to give Democrats their fourth straight U.S. Senate victory in Arizona, he’s probably going to need support from an unlikely group: Donald Trump voters.

Gallego and his GOP rival, former television news anchor Kari Lake, are both targeting undecided Republicans in a contest that will test the strength of Trump’s coattails. Ticket-splitting voters are increasingly rare in an era when partisan loyalty reigns, but they could be central in determining which party controls the Senate.

For Gallego, that means winning over voters like Winfield Morris, a 62-year-old Republican farmer and rancher who plans to vote for Trump for president but can’t get behind his loyal ally in the Senate race.

“I don’t like Kari Lake and I’m not going to vote for her,” said Morris, who lives in southern Arizona and has businesses across the state. “I don’t think she has what it takes.”

Advertisement

Morris supported former U.N. Ambassador Nikki Haley over Trump and Pinal County Sheriff Mark Lamb over Lake in the GOP primaries. He said he was furious to see Lake attack the late Arizona Republican Sen. John McCain in her failed 2022 campaign for governor. Trump also has attacked McCain, but Morris said he doesn’t see Democrat Kamala Harris as a viable alternative.

Morris said he likes that Gallego was a Marine and may vote for him but wants to learn more about him. He’s also considering writing in a Republican he respects, such as Lamb, who got 40% of the vote in the Senate primary despite being vastly outspent and overshadowed by Lake.

Democrats have a difficult path to keep the Senate

Democrats’ difficult path to retaining control of the Senate relies on winning over Republicans in states so red, neither presidential candidate is putting much effort into winning them. But some of those races involve established incumbents who already have a record to run on.

An ad supporting Montana Sen. Jon Tester — one of the most endangered Democrats in the Senate, who has declined to endorse Harris — showcases Republicans crossing party lines.

“Jon got over 20 bills signed into law by President Trump,” one man says in the ad.

Advertisement

Trump is well positioned in Ohio, but the race between incumbent Democratic Sen. Sherrod Brown and Republican challenger Bernie Moreno could be more competitive.

The effort to win over ticket-splitters is harder for less established candidates, but some are trying. In North Dakota, longshot Democratic Senate candidate Katrina Christiansen released an ad this week narrated by a rancher who says he’s voting for Trump but not for Republican Sen. Kevin Cramer.

In swing-state North Carolina, where Republican Mark Robinson’s campaign for governor is struggling following a CNN report linking him to disturbing posts on an online porn site, the Trump campaign is counting on ticket-splitting in the opposite direction, hoping GOP voters who bail on Robinson will stick with the former president in a state he badly needs to win.

In Arizona, meanwhile, Gallego is hoping to replicate the model that has propelled Democrats to narrow statewide victories since Trump’s first victory, including Sens. Kyrsten Sinema and Mark Kelly and Gov. Katie Hobbs, who defeated Lake in 2022.

He’s getting plenty of help. Democrats so far have outspent Republicans on advertising by a wide margin on the race, according to AdImpact, which tracks campaign ad spending. As of Thursday, Democrats had spent $60.7 million on the race, compared to $16.4 million spent by Republicans. Democrats also have $35.7 million in spots reserved between now and Election Day, compared to $11.7 million reserved by GOP-affiliated groups.

Advertisement

What to know about the 2024 Election

Gallego’s strategy relies on Democrats keeping their own supporters united, getting a majority of independents and picking up a small but decisive share of Republicans by appealing to conservatives who dislike Trump.

“Especially in modern times, to have ticket splitters that big is extraordinary. But I think it’s entirely accurate,” said Mike Madrid, a California-based Republican strategist who has worked to defeat Trump. “They’re sticking more to Trump because he’s the top-of-the-ticket nominee, and losing the presidency is a lot different than losing a Senate seat.”

Republicans have had a hard time replicating Trump’s coalition

Celebrity candidates who are close to Trump but lack strong ties to the GOP establishment have had a hard time replicating Trump’s coalition, Madrid said. Television doctor Mehmet Oz and football legend Herschel Walker both lost Senate races two years ago. As a well-known local news personality, Lake fits the mold.

Both Lake’s and Gallego’s messaging reflect the importance of undecided Republicans to the outcome of the race.

Advertisement

Both are running ads focused on border security, almost exclusively so in Lake’s case. Gallego even gently rebukes the Biden-Harris administration in one ad playing in heavy rotation, saying, “Arizonans know — on the border, there is no plan.” He did not appear with Harris when she visited the Arizona-Mexico border on Friday.

And both Gallego and Lake are showcasing support from Republicans. For Gallego, it’s a businessman who says in ads he’s a Republican and calls the congressman a “man of principles.” For Lake, it’s Trump himself, as she reminds his supporters that he’s backing her. She’s been one of his most steadfast allies, embracing his lie that the 2020 election was stolen from him due to widespread fraud.

The cross-currents of divided loyalties among traditionally Republican groups often surface at campaign events. For example, the Arizona Police Association, which represents thousands of officers in the state, endorsed Gallego, citing his background as a Marine combat veteran. Just three days earlier, Trump called the group’s president, Justin Harris, to the stage to bestow an endorsement on the former president at a rally outside Phoenix.

Gallego hopes there’s more where that came from, and there’s some history to suggest that’s possible.

In 2020, Republican Senate candidate Martha McSally privately fretted that she was running behind with Trump voters, which turned out to be the case. While Trump lost Arizona by 10,457 votes — .03 percentage points — McSally lost by 78,806 to Kelly, indicating tens of thousands of voters split their tickets.

Advertisement

Some observers say Gallego fits the profile of the kind of candidate who could replicate the path forged by Kelly, a tough-talking former astronaut.

“Ruben is a legitimate tough guy,” said Stacy Pearson, a Phoenix-based Democratic strategist, who ran the successful 2016 campaign to oust Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio, which relied on voters who backed Trump at the top of the ticket. “He’s an Iraq War vet. He is a person who sincerely pulled himself up by his bootstraps, and that resonates very much with this Western state.”

___

Associated Press writers Jack Dura in Bismarck, North Dakota, and Amy Beth Hanson in Helena, Montana, contributed to this report.





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending