More than 10 hours after it opened debate on a bill that would ban transgender girls from girls sports teams in Alaska, the Alaska House of Representatives remained bogged down on the issue late Saturday.

With the legislative session scheduled to end on Wednesday, the protracted debate forced the postponement of other priority work, including on legislation that addresses crime, a pending energy crunch along the Railbelt, and other education topics.

Republican members of the House, with one exception, are supporting the bill, while a coalition of Democrats, independents and one Republican have vowed to use every possible means to defeat it. 

The result on Saturday was a grinding, trench-warfare-like legislative process that saw supporters of the bill defeat or table opposition amendments, one by one, for hours.  

“We’re doing it on behalf of women and young ladies and girls who would like to participate in female sports,” said Rep. David Eastman, R-Wasilla.

Supporters of the bill do not believe that transgender women are women, and allowing transgender girls to participate on girls sports teams would mean that “there would be no female sports left to participate in, which would be a disappointment,” he said.

The bill’s opponents vehemently and at times emotionally argued that transgender women are women and deserve to be granted equal treatment under the law.

“Trans girls in sports (are) not a threat to any other girl,” said Rep. Donna Mears, D-Anchorage.

Opposition lawmakers had known for months that the bill was likely to advance to the House floor and prepared dozens of amendments in an attempt to kill the bill by drawing out debate 

On Saturday morning, with the House majority ready to table those amendments without discussion, opposition lawmakers grew angry and refused to vote, bringing proceedings to a halt.

“If you would like to set this precedent of just tabling minority amendments because you do not like them, you will reap what you sow for years to come,” said House Minority Leader Calvin Schrage, I-Anchorage.

That statement brought raised voices from Republicans in the House who saw it as a personal threat against Speaker of the House Cathy Tilton, R-Wasilla, and told Schrage should “take it outside” with them.  

“You brought this upon us! You are the majority. You said this is your priority. Give us the right to defend the children in our districts who you are hurting because of this,” said Rep. Jennie Armstrong, D-Anchorage, shouting across the House chambers.

“Yeah, well, you’re discriminating against women!” said Rep. Jamie Allard, R-Eagle River, shouting back.

“I’m a woman, Jamie!” Armstrong responded, even louder. 

A short break brought more interruptions and delay. 

“You’re making a mockery of this,” said Rep. Kevin McCabe, R-Big Lake. 

“You’re making a mockery with this bill,” Armstrong said. 

“Oh, stop,” McCabe said. 

“It’s not a bill. It’s an attack on children in our state!” Armstrong responded.

Armstrong, who identifies as bisexual, and Democratic Rep. Andrew Gray, a gay man from Anchorage, have been among the most passionate opponents of the bill, as has Rep. Alyse Galvin, I-Anchorage, who has a transgender daughter.

“One of my four daughters won’t come into this building. She’s very uncomfortable here. It breaks my heart,” Galvin said.

After Armstrong’s heated exchanges, Tilton and Schrage negotiated a compromise that allowed the opposition to present some amendments. 

The compromise agreement set a strict time limit for each legislator to speak on an amendment, but even with that restriction, each amendment took 15 minutes or more, and there were dozens.

The bill’s supporters, to save time, declined to speak on each proposal. This left the floor open to the bill’s opponents, who said the bill implicates the state’s constitutional right to privacy. It would require girls to prove that their gender at birth — as shown on a birth certificate and medical tests — matches their gender identity.

“When you’re asking women to give up their constitutional rights to play sports … it’s a shame this is where we think we should be on Day 117 of the Legislature,” said Rep. Sara Hannan, D-Juneau.

Opposition lawmakers repeatedly offered procedural exit ramps to members of the majority, saying they were willing to move on from the issue, if the majority was willing. 

But majority Republicans voted down requests to table and indefinitely postpone the bill, keeping the debate going. 

As debate extended into the night, lawmakers recognized an important fact: Even after amendments wrap up, a final vote on the bill itself won’t take place until the next legislative day, promising further delays. 

“There’s so much hate out there. Why would we move forward with a bill that will just enable more hatred and discrimination? It’s insane,” Schrage said. 

JUNEAU — With just days left in the Alaska Legislature’s regular session, major policy measures are unresolved related to energy, crime, homeschool allotments and elections.

In recent years, the budget has been the biggest source of contention and debate between legislators and Gov. Mike Dunleavy. This year, the budget has largely advanced smoothly. However, the size of this year’s Permanent Fund dividend has not been reconciled. Across the political spectrum, legislators expect it will be close to the Senate’s approved figure of almost $1,600 — lower than the nearly $2,300 figure sought earlier in the session by the House.

Senate President Gary Stevens, R-Kodiak, said Saturday that crime and energy bills are the “most crucial” measures being considered this year.

Legislators say that a multipart elections bill is the least likely of the big policy items to pass. It combines a proposal to clean up the state’s voter rolls with election provisions typically supported by progressives, like same-day voter registration.

Fairbanks Democratic Sen. Scott Kawasaki, the chief sponsor of the elections measure, acknowledged that energy, education and the budget are the highest priorities for the Legislature.

”But you can’t forgo the other issues that are part of this Legislature, like elections,” he said. “These are other things that have to pass.”

The House spent more than seven hours Saturday debating a doomed bill to restrict how transgender girls participate in school sport teams. Meanwhile, the Senate Finance Committee continued discussing and amending some of the Legislature’s biggest policy priorities.

There have been frequent breaks so legislators and the governor’s staff can meet behind closed doors to negotiate. But House members were kept largely occupied by the floor debate, halting their work on some legislation they have sought to prioritize.

The Alaska Legislature’s regular session must end by midnight on Wednesday, May 15.

Energy and transmission

Addressing a looming shortfall of Cook Inlet natural gas has been a key priority this year for Dunleavy and many in the Legislature.

Several measures have been heard to reduce royalties on oil and gas production, which are intended to incentivize new gas production. Members of Senate leadership have raised concerns that forgoing state royalty revenue won’t necessarily see more gas produced. Stevens said there’s simply not enough time left to consider and approve those bills.

“I just don’t see how we can come to a conclusion on that because we just don’t know the implications,” he said Saturday.

Asked if he thought royalty relief was off the table this year, Sutton Republican Rep. George Rauscher said, “Not at all.” He said House Bill 223 could be considered Saturday or Sunday on the House floor as discussions continue with the Senate.

The bill was initially scheduled for a floor hearing Saturday morning, but its hearing was delayed to allow time for the hours-long debate on transgender policy.

“We’re still negotiating but I’m stuck on the floor. Otherwise, I would have been able to get a lot farther today,” Rauscher said Saturday.

Green bank bills have advanced to a final vote on the House and Senate floor. The measures proposed by Dunleavy would allow the Alaska Housing Finance Corp. to offer loans for renewable energy projects. More than 80% of the Railbelt’s power comes from natural gas. A green bank bill has been supported as a way to diversify the Railbelt’s sources of energy, and is expected to pass into law this year.

Measures are also being heard by the House and Senate finance committees to modernize the Railbelt electric grid. The proposal for an integrated transmission system has divided the Railbelt utilities. Several prior attempts to form a transmission organization have fallen short over the past 50 years.

Chugach Electric Association — the state’s largest electric utility — has opposed key elements of the plan, leading legislators to coalesce around a more limited version of the proposal. The transmission organization would not have planning authority or management of the utilities’ assets. Sen. Cathy Giessel, R-Anchorage, said Saturday that would be a “shell” of the proposed transmission organization she helped author.

The measure originally proposed by Dunleavy would also have exempted renewable power producers from local property and sales taxes. On Saturday, legislators said that provision is still being negotiated between lawmakers and the governor.

Another key measure is House Bill 50. It would develop a statutory framework so the state could lease depleted gas reservoirs to store carbon dioxide deep underground. Once pitched as a revenue-raising tool for the state, carbon sequestration has now been supported as a way to attract oil and gas investment.

A provision added to HB 50 would allow the Alaska Industrial Development and Export Authority, or AIDEA, to issue loans to producers based on their gas reserves. Those loans are intended to assist BlueCrest, an Alaska-based producer, that needs $400 million to buy a platform to produce gas from the Cosmopolitan Unit in Cook Inlet.

The bill has a provision intended to prevent oil companies from deducting carbon capture and storage expenses from their state oil production taxes. But producers could still deduct costs for enhanced oil recovery.

Officials at the Department of Natural Resources have said enhanced oil recovery is a currently allowable tax deduction, and part of the oil industry’s normal operations on the North Slope. Sen. Bill Wielechowski, D-Anchorage, has argued that allowing deductions for enhanced oil recovery could potentially “blow an enormous hole” in the state budget.

A contentious provision to raise taxes on Hilcorp by more than $100 million per year was removed from the bill Wednesday after a fierce lobbying campaign.

The carbon storage bill was in the Senate Finance Committee as of Saturday evening. There have been concerns expressed in public testimony that carbon sequestration is expensive and largely unproven. But the bill has been a key priority for Dunleavy and many in the Legislature, and is expected to pass this year.

Crime bill

An omnibus crime package in the Senate combines proposals from a handful of House and Senate bills. The package has been crafted to get enough support in both legislative chambers, and is broadly expected to pass this year.

“As we move into an election here, people want to take a stance on crime. It’s such a powerful thing for people to run on,” Stevens said.

House Bill 66 contains provisions for tougher sentences for stalking; enhanced penalties for committing domestic violence and sex assault offenses in the presence of a child; renaming child pornography as child sex abuse material in state law; and the imposition of “some additional jail time” for repeated violations of conditions of release from prison.

Homer Republican Rep. Sarah Vance, chair of the House Judiciary Committee, said “it is very, very important” to pass a crime bill this session.

”Addressing crime and protection for victims is just as important as addressing energy and education. I believe we can do all at the same time,” said Vance.

”Do I love everything? No. But I can live with most of it,” Anchorage Republican Rep. Craig Johnson said Saturday.

Alaska reported its highest-ever rate of fatal opioid overdoses in 2023. As a response to the state’s fentanyl crisis, a contentious set of provisions would impose longer sentences on drug offenses.

Sandy Snodgrass, whose son Bruce Snodgrass died from a fentanyl overdose in 2021, spoke in support of those provisions. She said Alaska’s leaders need to respond “to the scourge of fentanyl and illicit drug poisonings in our state.”

The ACLU of Alaska opposes several key elements in the bill. Michael Garvey, advocacy director of the civil rights law firm, said longer sentences would not act as a deterrent.

“However, they often have the opposite effect of incarcerating people with substance use disorders and deterring people from calling for help,” Garvey said Thursday.

Under HB 66, crime victims and witnesses would no longer need to present in-person at grand juries. That change would allow law enforcement officials to summarize a victim’s testimony or to show a video of that testimony at grand jury proceedings. Victims’ rights groups have said that could help avoid retraumatizing crime victims, particularly in domestic violence and sexual abuse cases.

The federal government and 33 states allow “hearsay” evidence to be presented to grand juries to secure an indictment, which is constitutionally required in Alaska for a felony charge to proceed to court. The change would apply not just to domestic violence and sexual abuse, but to all felony offenses.

Civil liberties groups have raised concerns that using second- and third-hand evidence at grand juries could deny Alaskans long-held protections against unfounded charges.

Susan Orlansky, a private attorney who often volunteers with the ACLU of Alaska, said she was concerned because grand jurors could not evaluate the credibility of witnesses or ask follow-up questions. Under the bill, the law enforcement officer presenting to the grand jury may not have interviewed the victim or investigated the case.

”By allowing second- and third-hand hearsay, the bill authorizes testimony that’s no more reliable than the last statement in a game of telephone,” Orlansky said.

Sen. Jesse Kiehl, D-Juneau, said Saturday that he’s sensitive to the concerns of victims’ rights groups, but he is also trying to craft an amendment to narrow what hearsay evidence can be presented to grand juries.

Another key provision in the bill would extend the period certain people can be involuntarily committed. That comes after an Anchorage woman, Angela Harris, was stabbed in the back two years ago in the Loussac Library by a man who had been deemed unfit to stand trial.

Supporters say involuntary commitment reforms could help protect Alaskans. But the ACLU of Alaska has raised constitutional concerns about the impacts of extending involuntary commitment from a maximum period of six months to two years. Sen. David Wilson, R-Wasilla, said he was concerned that the long-struggling Alaska Psychiatric Institute could also be overwhelmed with new patients.

Homeschool and education

Competing bills in the House and Senate would instruct the Alaska board of education to draft new regulations governing Alaska’s correspondence programs, after an Anchorage Superior Court judge ruled last month that two state statutes violated the state constitution by allowing public funds designated for the program to be used at private and religious schools.

But the bills — and the urgency that some lawmakers see in passing legislation to shore up the schools that serve nearly 23,000 homeschooled Alaskans — could be used as a vehicle to add other education provisions, including a permanent increase to state spending on education long sought by educators.

The correspondence school statutes, conceived by Dunleavy when he was a state senator, were enacted in 2014, allowing for a growing practice of families using correspondence allotments of up to $4,500 per student per year to be used to pay tuition at private schools.

The decision by Judge Adolf Zeman, which prohibited the practice but kept correspondence programs in place, was paused through June. It was appealed by the Dunleavy administration to the state Supreme Court, which has proposed an expedited hearing schedule.

House Bill 400, authored by Rep. Justin Ruffridge, a Soldotna Republican, would create a temporary solution, instructing the state board — whose members are appointed by Dunleavy — to put in place regulations that will expire in 2025, allowing lawmakers to work on a permanent solution when they return to Juneau next year that takes into account the supreme court decision.

At Dunleavy’s urging, the bill would also keep on the books the statutes that Zeman found violated the state constitution, meaning they could be reinstated if the Alaska Supreme Court overturns Zeman’s decision.

The House Finance Committee held a hearing on the bill that lasted late into the evening on Friday. During the hearing, some minority members raised concerns about whether the state board of education could be trusted to enact regulations that followed the constitution.

“They’re going to philosophically follow what the attorney general tells them to follow,” said Rep. Andy Josephson, an Anchorage Democrat. Attorney General Treg Taylor has used correspondence allotments to pay tuition at private Christian schools.

Senate Bill 266, authored by Sen. Löki Tobin, an Anchorage Democrat, would instruct the state board to author permanent regulations — with more defined guardrails on how the correspondence allotments can be used, including a limit on the amount of funds that can be kept from year to year, and a limit on the amount of funds that can be used to pay for private music, arts and physical education classes.

Stevens, a Kodiak Republican, said he trusted that the board would enact constitutional regulations, even if lawmakers failed to pass a bill instructing them to do so before the end of the session.

“In the end, if we can’t get a bill through — I’d prefer it if we could, but if we can’t — then I think the governor and the administration and the department has the wherewithal to write the rules,” said Stevens.

The Senate bill must be heard by the Finance Committee before it can head to a floor vote. It has yet to be scheduled for a committee hearing.

“As they often say, they are not a rubber stamp, so they’re going to do their due diligence,” Tobin said of the coming hearing in the Finance Committee, adding that she expected the House proposal could pass before the Senate finishes considering its competing proposal.

Despite Dunleavy’s indication that he wanted to keep the struck-down statutes on the books, Tobin said she wanted to see them amended in legislation that lawmakers consider this year.

“My approach is to pass legislation that will create stability and certainty,” she said.

In Friday’s House Finance Committee hearing, Rep. Alyse Galvin, an Anchorage independent, proposed an amendment that would have permanently increased Alaska’s education funding formula. That amendment was tabled in a narrow 6-5 vote. The committee ended its work for the day at 8 p.m. without passing the bill, leaving open the possibility of further changes when the House Finance Committee reconvenes.

“To me, there’s nothing more important than having predictable, adequate, stable funding,” said Galvin. “This is just a lift-all-boats amendment.”

Lawmakers earlier this year agreed to permanently increase the Base Student Allocation from $5,960 to $6,640, amounting to an increase of roughly $175 million per year. But Dunleavy vetoed that bill and lawmakers failed by a single vote to override his veto.

The current year’s budget already has an equivalent funding boost, but the funding was added on a one-time basis, meaning it would not be included in next year’s budget without additional action by lawmakers, and schools are limited in how they can use the funds.

Supporters of the permanent boost have said it will aid all public school students in Alaska, including correspondence and charter students, who have been championed by Dunleavy.

Lawmakers opposed to the move, including many House Republicans, have said they opposed it because Dunleavy has said he will veto an increase to the Base Student Allocation unless his priorities are satisfied.

Dunleavy said earlier this year that he is seeking to empower the state board of education to approve new charter schools — a power currently given only to locally elected school boards. Leaders of the bipartisan Senate majority have said they’re opposed to the proposal.

Tobin said that without specific guidance from Dunleavy on whether he would support a permanent BSA increase, the bipartisan Senate majority would be unlikely to pursue adding a funding boost to a bill meant to stabilize correspondence schools.

“I do not see the bandwidth of my caucus to go back through the negotiation process just to have a similar outcome as what happened (on the vetoed bill),” said Tobin.

“It is a little difficult to know what we could get across the finish line at this point in time. So it feels like it’s a bit of a shot in the dark.”

• • •

Harry Subertas was initially drawn to Alaska for its elevation, arriving in Haines to attend and then work for Alaska Mountain Guides & Climbing School.

And it was in Alaska where he began to push himself to new heights as a runner, eventually taking on ultramarathons.

On Wednesday, Subertas won the Cocodona 250 in Arizona, breaking the race record by finishing in 59 hours, 50 minutes, 55 seconds.

Subertas, 33, completed an amazing rally down the stretch, passing professional ultra runner Jeff Browning just a few miles from the finish line on the outskirts of Flagstaff.

He said the conditions were excellent for the roughly 250-mile race, which starts in Black Canyon City heading northwest before curling back east to Flagstaff.

Subertas admitted to trying to push too hard at the onset, but a pair of 15-minute naps energized him as he got going into his second full day of running. That allowed him to keep pace with the top group, and eventually he found himself in second place outside of Sedona. He realized he was also on pace to crack 60 hours, which was his ultimate goal.

In his previous 200-mile races, Subertas said he hadn’t had a crew or pacers. This time, he said that crew was vital for him winning the race. He said his partner ran multiple sections of the race with him and he even had a pacer he’d never met before come out to run sections of the trail with him starting at 3 a.m.

By midway through the third day, he realized his second-place finish was in jeopardy and pushed the pace. He was shocked that he was able to make up the time to catch Browning, who was already on the downhill portion of Mount Elden outside Flagstaff.

“Three miles to catch up in a 20-mile section, it’s a lot,” Subertas said.

But as Subertas and his pacer descended Elden, they kept crossing local hikers who told them Subertas was steadily closing the gap.

With just a couple miles left in the race, he caught Browning, who had been slowed by bronchial airway inflammation and was having difficulty breathing.

“Even after 240-plus miles, it’s not that easy,” he said. “Even downhill was hard, but the motivation was there and we kept pushing.”

Subertas was born and raised in Lithuania and ran track and cross-country growing up, but wanted to push himself even further.

“I was always looking for a challenge,” he said. “That’s how I ended up in Alaska, the mountains and mountaineering.”

In 2017, he signed up for a 100-mile ultra marathon in Kentucky and continued to run two to three ultras a year. Well known in the Alaska ultra scene, Subertas won the 2021 Alaska Endurance Trail Run in Fairbanks with 108 miles in 24 hours, and last year he won the Susitna 100 in Big Lake. In 2021, he topped a small field at the Sangre de Cristo Trail Festival in Colorado, and in 2022 he won the Tahoe 200 Endurance Run.

“Most recently, I just had become more and more addicted to longer and more challenging stuff,” he said.

Although he’s won a number of ultras across the U.S. in recent years, he was uncertain of how he’d fare at Cocodona, in a field packed with pro runners.

“This race was very unique because it’s, as far as I understand, in this 200-mile realm was the most competitive that we have seen,” he said.

Subertas relocated to Reno, Nevada last fall to be with his partner but still maintains his place in Haines. Subertas, who’s a truck driver, said that despite his success, he has no plans to run professionally.

“I’m definitely not a professional, but this is my passion,” he said.

He has at least three more races he’s planning to run in 2024, including another Tahoe 200, the Bigfoot 200 in Washington and the Moab 240 Endurance Run in Utah in the fall.