New York
Richard Ravitch, Rescuer of the Subways and New York’s Finances, Dies at 89
Richard Ravitch, a politically savvy, civic-minded developer and public citizen who helped rescue New York City from the brink of bankruptcy and its decaying subways from fiscal collapse, died on Sunday in Manhattan. He was 89.
His death, in a hospital, was confirmed by his wife, Kathleen M. Doyle.
Mr. Ravitch never won elective office. But he left an outsize mark on government at every level as one of the backstage wise men recruited to stave off the financial collapse of New York’s Urban Development Corporation in 1975 and, a few months later, of New York City’s own overdrawn municipal accounts.
By rallying public support for inventive means of raising revenue, he was also instrumental in rejuvenating the city’s mass transit system in the 1980s as the chairman of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
He later served as New York’s lieutenant governor, enlisted by David A. Paterson in 2009 to lend gravitas to his teetering administration. (Mr. Paterson had succeeded Eliot Spitzer, who resigned in disgrace after a prostitution scandal.)
Mr. Ravitch, who inherited a construction company, also left his mark on the cityscape with signature apartment projects like Waterside and Manhattan Plaza.
A progressive in the tradition of Franklin D. Roosevelt and Adlai Stevenson, he espoused an Emersonian faith in democracy as a dynamic symbiosis between politics and good government. Invoking a lesson learned from Daniel Patrick Moynihan, whose successful Senate candidacy he helped promote in 1976, Mr. Ravitch recalled in his 2014 memoir, “So Much to Do: A Full Life of Business, Politics, and Confronting Fiscal Crises,” “There is a more powerful connection than people think between the world of ideas and the world of practical politics.”
He relished the intellectual challenges posed by crises. “Like Cincinnatus of the early Roman republic,” Stephen Eide, a scholar at the Manhattan Institute wrote in the magazine City Journal in 2014, “Ravitch is best known for serving temporarily during times of great need.”
Together with Paul A. Volcker, a former chairman of the Federal Reserve, he formed the State Budget Crisis Task Force in 2011 to draw attention to the fiscal vulnerabilities of governments across the country. In 2014, he volunteered for another rescue mission: He was named to advise a federal judge and the governor of Michigan as Detroit clawed its way out of bankruptcy.
Mr. Ravitch was shrewd, guileless and so unambiguously blunt that he was sometimes dismissed as a doomsayer.
“As pessimistic as we were, he was always a darker shade of gray,” recalled Eugene Keilin, who was chairman of the Municipal Assistance Corporation during New York City’s fiscal crisis in the mid-1970s. Mayor Edward I. Koch labeled him a Cassandra. But Mr. Ravitch countered that only by relentlessly sounding the alarm could he galvanize the requisite political constituency to confront a given crisis.
“What distinguished him,” said State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli, “was the credibility he had with stakeholders who knew his aggressiveness about issues he cared about wasn’t part of any political calculation, his depth of knowledge and experience, and a youthful impatience.”
Richard Ravitch was born in Manhattan on July 7, 1933. His father, Saul, the son of a Jewish immigrant from Russia who manufactured manhole covers, was a builder. His family company, HRH Construction, would redefine the city skyline with majestic structures that included the Beresford and San Remo apartment buildings. His mother, Sylvia (Lerner) Ravitch, was an accomplished sculptor.
Richard attended the Lincoln School and graduated from the Fieldston School. He then enrolled in Oberlin College in Ohio but transferred to Columbia College, where he graduated in 1955 with a degree in history. It was there that he received his formal introduction to party politics.
Drawn to Adlai Stevenson’s 1952 presidential campaign, he invited Eleanor Roosevelt to a rally at Columbia and, as her chaperone on campus, had a heady one-on-one lunch with her beforehand.
But he was bewildered to learn on the stump that the local Democratic organization was doing nothing to help Mr. Stevenson, because registering more voters would inject too much unpredictability into what really mattered to party regulars: the next year’s mayoral race.
“This was my introduction to the reality that politics is complicated, and that campaigns, for better or worse, are not necessarily driven by idealistic fervor or loyalty,” he wrote.
He graduated from Yale Law School in 1958, worked in Washington as assistant counsel to a House military operations subcommittee, and briefly served in the Army, where he was called up for active duty during the 1961 Berlin Wall crisis.
In Houston in 1960, he married Diane Silvers, who went on to become a prominent education historian and policy analyst. They divorced in 1986. His marriage to Betsy F. Perry, in 1994, also ended in divorce.
In 2005, he married Ms. Doyle, the chairwoman of William Doyle Galleries. She survives him as do two sons, Joseph and Michael, from his first marriage (another son, Steven, died in 1966); three stepdaughters, Carrie and Laura Doyle and Liz Doyle Carey, from his marriage to Ms. Doyle; and 13 grandchildren.
In 1960, Mr. Ravitch joined the family company, which he had inherited with his cousins, and which built the Whitney Museum of American Art and Citicorp Center in Manhattan, as well as the Ebbets Field Apartments and Trump Village in Brooklyn. But it was reform Democratic politics that opened the door to a lifetime of networking, both in private development and in public service.
He was a partner in the first desegregated housing project in Washington. One of its first tenants was Robert C. Weaver, who would become the nation’s first secretary of Housing and Urban Development and the first African American to hold a cabinet-level post.
Through the civil rights leader Bayard Rustin, with whom he participated in the 1963 March on Washington, Mr. Ravitch was introduced to A. Philip Randolph, the illustrious labor leader, with whom he created an apprenticeship program to prepare young Black men for union jobs.
He also met Joseph A. Califano Jr., who would join Lyndon B. Johnson’s cabinet and become a lifelong friend, and Lewis Davis, an architect with whom he would collaborate on major projects.
Two projects that were built in the 1970s severely tested Mr. Ravitch’s problem-solving skills while creating new neighborhoods.
One, Waterside Plaza, was built along the East River on rubble from the World War II Blitz in Bristol, England, that was used as ballast in ships coming to the United States. He had to overcome concerns that the project, by protruding into the estuary, would impede navigation.
The other, Manhattan Plaza on West 42nd Street, was conceived as a luxury apartment complex but was hobbled by financial woes. It was transformed with heavy government subsidies to attract low- and moderate-income performing artists.
In 1975, Mr. Ravitch was enlisted by Gov. Hugh L. Carey to rescue the Urban Development Corporation, which had been created by a predecessor, Nelson A. Rockefeller, to override local zoning constraints and build housing for low-income New Yorkers.
The corporation defaulted on its short-term borrowing, but Mr. Ravitch persuaded the Legislature to create the Project Finance Agency to issue new debt backed by federal subsidies to repay old borrowing.
That new agency not only allowed the corporation to complete its pending projects, but also served as a model for the Municipal Assistance Corporation, which spared New York City from bankruptcy later in 1975 by assuming the city’s crushing debt.
On Oct. 18, with the city facing a deadline later that day to repay short-term notes, Albert Shanker, the leader of the teachers’ union, balked at an earlier agreement to buy $200 million in Municipal Assistance Corporation bonds with his union’s pension funds. Mr. Ravitch, playing the honest broker, persuaded him to honor his agreement and then contacted the comptroller of the currency in Washington to keep the banks open beyond their closing time so the city could pay its debts before the midnight deadline.
In 1979, Mr. Ravitch was again enlisted by the governor, this time to salvage the transit system. He was uniquely qualified: A rarity among public officials, he was a regular subway rider.
He warned that fares would rise unless legislators approved a tax increase. They complied. He weathered an 11-day transit strike in 1980 and lived with a police escort after an intruder shot his police bodyguard in the thigh at Metropolitan Transportation Authority headquarters.
Lobbying for long-term financing to rebuild the transit system, Mr. Ravitch fashioned an $8.5 billion plan under which private corporations would buy buses and railroad cars from the M.T.A. and lease them back at a saving to the authority, and the companies would receive tax benefits.
“In terms of having a vision,” Robert F. Wagner Jr., a member of the M.T.A. board, said at the time, “in terms of what the system needed, putting together a plan and overwhelming the odds, he produced one of the extraordinary legacies a public official will have left behind in the past 50 years.”
Mr. Ravitch retired from the transit agency in 1983, but not from public life. He led a group of investors who restored the ailing Bowery Savings Bank to profitability in two years; was the chairman of a New York City charter revision commission that strengthened ethics and public campaign financing rules; and remained active in Jewish philanthropies.
As Major League Baseball’s chief negotiator, he proposed a revenue-sharing plan that placed a cap on players’ salaries, which helped precipitate the strike of 1994 and 1995.
When he sought the Democratic nomination for mayor in 1989, he received critical acclaim as a cerebral and politically independent civic savior, but he ran a distant third, behind David N. Dinkins, who came in first, and Mr. Koch, the incumbent.
Two decades later, Mr. Ravitch became the state’s lieutenant governor by appointment, filling a vacancy created when Mr. Paterson succeeded Mr. Spitzer, who resigned after being identified by federal investigators as a client of a prostitution ring.
Because the appointment was subject to challenge by Senate Republicans (who were seeking a court order to block it), Mr. Ravitch was sworn in hastily over steak, tomatoes and creamed spinach at Peter Luger Steak House in Brooklyn. (Steak from Luger’s was served on May 2 at an early 90th-birthday party for Mr. Ravitch, held at the New-York Historical Society.)
Mr. Ravitch took the job seriously, winning a hearing among legislators for his proposals for a payroll tax and tolls on East River bridges to support mass transit. He also recommended borrowing to help close a $9 billion state budget gap, coupled with stringent fiscal and accounting controls. The governor rejected most of his advice.
But the underlying budgetary demands persisted, in New York and in other states. The challenge, Mr. Ravitch wrote in “So Much to Do,” is “how a free society can reduce benefits for some and increase burdens for others without tearing unacceptably at the social fabric.”
“In a democracy,” he argued, “if you insist on being above politics, you cannot govern well.”
New York
Large Blaze Ravages Bronx Apartment Building, Leaving Many Displaced
Dozens of families were looking for shelter after a large fire broke out at an apartment building in the Bronx early Friday, injuring at least seven people, the Fire Department said. There were no fatalities or life-threatening injuries, according to officials.
About 250 firefighters and emergency medical responders rushed to a six-story residential building on Wallace Avenue near Arnow Avenue after a fire was reported there just before 2 a.m., the Fire Department said. The blaze on the top floor was elevated to a five-alarm fire about an hour later, it said.
Several dozen firefighters were still gathered outside the building at around 10 a.m. Many windows on the top floor were blown out and some had shards of glass hanging in place that resembled jagged teeth. Smoke continued to climb from the building as a firefighter on a ladder hosed the roof.
The fire was brought under control shortly before 2 p.m., according to fire officials.
The seven people who were injured included five firefighters, the department said in an email. One person was treated at the scene but declined to be taken to a hospital.
A spokeswoman for the Police Department said earlier that some people had suffered smoke inhalation injuries.
Robert S. Tucker, the fire commissioner, said during a news conference that it was a miracle that there had been no serious injuries or fatalities. Officials said that all of the apartments on the building’s top floor were destroyed.
Firefighters blasted water at the smoke and flames pouring out of the upper floors and roof, according to videos posted online by the Fire Department and television news outlets. Heavy winds had fueled the blaze, the department said.
The cause of the fire was under investigation, officials said.
The Red Cross was at the scene helping residents that were displaced by the fire, and a temporary shelter had been set up at the Bennington School on Adee Avenue nearby. Doreen Thomann-Howe, the chief executive of the American Red Cross Greater New York Region, said during the news conference that 66 families had already registered to receive assistance, including lodging. She said she expected that number to increase.
Juan Cabrera and his family were among those seeking help at the Bennington School. Mr. Cabrera said that he and his family had not heard a fire alarm but had instead heard glass breaking as residents climbed out of windows. He said he had also heard people race across the hall one flight above him while others screamed “Get out!”
Mr. Cabrera, 47, said he had smelled smoke and woke up his daughter, Rose, 13. He and his wife, Aurora Tavera, grabbed their IDs, passports and cellphones, and the family left the building.
“I felt desperate,” Ms. Taverna, 32, said.
“Thank God we are still alive,” said Mr. Cabrera, who works as a school aide and custodian and has lived in the building for five years. “The material stuff you can get back, but we have our family,” he said.
Louis Montalvo, 55, was also among those seeking help. He said firefighters banged on his door at around 3 a.m. and that he had smelled smoke.
“I am grateful to be around,” Mr. Montalvo said, as he stood outside of the temporary shelter. He was still wearing his felt pajama pants, which had snowmen printed on them.
Vanessa L. Gibson, the Bronx borough president, said she was “so grateful” there had been no fatalities from the fire.
The last major apartment fire in the Bronx occurred in 2022, and resulted in 17 deaths, which experts said were entirely preventable. Self-closing doors in the building did not work properly, allowing smoke to escape the apartment where the fire started and rapidly fill the structure’s 19 stories.
New York
New York’s Chinese Dissidents Thought He Was an Ally. He Was a Spy.
The Chinese government’s paranoia about overseas dissidents can seem strange, considering the enormous differences in power between exiled protesters who organize marches in America and their mighty homeland, a geopolitical and economic superpower whose citizens they have almost no ability to mobilize. But to those familiar with the Chinese Communist Party, the government’s obsession with dissidents, no matter where in the world they are, is unsurprising. “Regardless of how the overseas dissident community is dismissed outside of China, its very existence represents a symbol of hope for many within China,” Wang Dan, a leader of the Tiananmen Square protests who spent years in prison before being exiled to the United States in 1998, told me. “For the Chinese Communist Party, the hope for change among the people is itself a threat. Therefore, they spare no effort in suppressing and discrediting the overseas dissident community — to extinguish this hope in the hearts of people at home.”
To understand the party’s fears about the risks posed by dissidents abroad, it helps to know the history of revolutions in China. “Historically, the groups that have overthrown the incumbent government or regime in China have often spent a lot of time overseas and organized there,” says Jessica Chen Weiss, a professor of China studies at Johns Hopkins University. The leader Sun Yat-sen, who played an important role in the 1911 revolution that dethroned the Qing dynasty and led eventually to the establishment of the People’s Republic of China, spent several periods of his life abroad, during which he engaged in effective fund-raising and political coordination. The Communist Party’s own rise to power in 1949 was partly advanced by contributions from leaders who were living overseas. “They are very sensitive to that potential,” Weiss says.
“What the Chinese government and the circle of elites that are running China right now fear the most is not the United States, with all of its military power, but elements of unrest within their own society that could potentially topple the Chinese Communist Party,” says Adam Kozy, a cybersecurity consultant who worked on Chinese cyberespionage cases when he was at the F.B.I. Specifically, Chinese authorities worry about a list of threats — collectively referred to as the “five poisons” — that pose a risk to the stability of Communist rule: the Uyghurs, the Tibetans, followers of the Falun Gong movement, supporters of Taiwanese independence and those who advocate for democracy in China. As a result, the Chinese government invests great effort in combating these threats, which involves collecting intelligence about overseas dissident groups and dampening their influence both within China and on the international stage.
Controlling dissidents, regardless of where they are, is essential to China’s goal of projecting power to its own citizens and to the world, according to Charles Kable, who served as an assistant director in the F.B.I.’s national security branch before retiring from the bureau at the end of 2022. “If you have a dissident out there who is looking back at China and pointing out problems that make the entire Chinese political apparatus look bad, it will not stand,” Kable says.
The leadership’s worries about such individuals were evident to the F.B.I. right before the 2008 Beijing Olympics, Kable told me, describing how the Chinese worked to ensure that the running of the Olympic flame through San Francisco would not be disrupted by protesters. “And so, you had the M.S.S. and its collaborators deployed in San Francisco just to make sure that the five poisons didn’t get in there and disrupt the optic of what was to be the best Olympics in history,” Kable says. During the run, whose route was changed at the last minute to avoid protesters, Chinese authorities “had their proxies in the community line the streets and also stand back from the streets, looking around to see who might be looking to cause trouble.”
New York
Hochul Seeks to Limit Private-Equity Ownership of Homes in New York
Gov. Kathy Hochul of New York on Thursday proposed several measures that would restrict hedge funds and private-equity firms from buying up large numbers of single-family homes, the latest in a string of populist proposals she intends to include in her State of the State address next week.
The governor wants to prevent institutional investors from bidding on properties in the first 75 days that they are on the market. Her plan would also remove certain tax benefits, such as interest deductions, when the homes are purchased.
The proposals reflect a nationwide effort by mostly Democratic lawmakers to discourage large firms from crowding out individuals or families from the housing market by paying far above market rate and in cash, and then leasing the homes or turning them into short-term rentals.
Activists and some politicians have argued that this trend has played a role in soaring prices and low vacancy rates — though low housing production is widely viewed as the main driver of those problems.
If Ms. Hochul was inviting a fight with the real estate interests who have backed her in the past, she did not seem concerned. She even borrowed a line from Jimmy McMillan, who ran long-shot candidacies for governor and mayor as the founder of the Rent Is Too Damn High Party.
“The cost of living is just too damn high — especially when it comes to the sky-high rents and mortgages New Yorkers pay every month,” Ms. Hochul said in a written statement.
James Whelan, president of the Real Estate Board of New York, said his team would review the proposal, but characterized it as “another example of policy that will stifle investment in housing in New York.”
The plan — the specifics of which will be negotiated with the Legislature — is one of several recent proposals the governor has made with the goal of addressing the state’s affordability crisis. Voters have expressed frustration about the high costs of housing and basic goods in the state. This discontent has led to political challenges for Ms. Hochul, who is likely to face rivals in the 2026 Democratic primary and in the general election.
In 2022, five of the largest investors in the United States owned 2 percent of the country’s single-family rental homes, most of them in Sun Belt and Southern states, according to a recent report from the federal Government Accountability Office. The report stated that it was “unclear how these investors affected homeownership opportunities or tenants because many related factors affect homeownership — e.g., market conditions, demographic factors and lending conditions.”
Researchers at Harvard University found that “a growing share of rental properties are owned by business entities and medium- and large-scale rental operators.”
State officials were not able to offer a complete picture of how widespread the practice was in New York. They said local officials in several upstate cities had told them about investors buying up dozens of homes at a time and turning them into rentals.
The New York Times reported in 2023 that investment firms were buying smaller buildings in places like Brooklyn and Queens from families and smaller landlords.
Ms. Hochul’s concern is that these purchases make it harder for first-time home buyers to gain a foothold in the market and can lead to more rental price gouging.
“Shadowy private-equity giants are buying up the housing supply in communities across New York, leaving everyday homeowners with nowhere to turn,” she said in a statement on Thursday. “I’m proposing new laws and policy changes to put the American dream of owning a home within reach for more New Yorkers than ever before.”
Cracking down on corporate landlords became a prominent talking point in last year’s presidential election. On the campaign trail, Vice President Kamala Harris called on Congress to pass previously introduced legislation eliminating tax benefits for large investors that purchase large numbers of homes.
“It can make it impossible then for regular people to be able to buy or even rent a home,” Ms. Harris said last summer.
In August, Representative Pat Ryan, Democrat of New York, called on the Federal Trade Commission to investigate price gouging by private-equity firms in the housing market. He cited a study that estimated that private-equity firms “are expected to control 40 percent of the U.S. single-family rental market by 2030.”
Statehouses across the country have recently looked at ways to tackle corporate homeownership. One effort in Nevada, which passed the Legislature but was vetoed by Gov. Joe Lombardo, proposed capping the number of units a corporation could buy in a calendar year. It was opposed by local chambers of commerce and the state’s homebuilders association.
A bill was introduced in the Minnesota State Legislature that would ban the conversion of homes owned by corporations into rentals. It has yet to come up for a vote.
At the federal level, Senator Jeff Merkley, Democrat of Oregon, and Representative Adam Smith, Democrat of Washington, introduced joint legislation that would force hedge funds to sell all the single-family homes they own over 10 years.
-
Business1 week ago
These are the top 7 issues facing the struggling restaurant industry in 2025
-
Culture1 week ago
The 25 worst losses in college football history, including Baylor’s 2024 entry at Colorado
-
Sports1 week ago
The top out-of-contract players available as free transfers: Kimmich, De Bruyne, Van Dijk…
-
Politics1 week ago
New Orleans attacker had 'remote detonator' for explosives in French Quarter, Biden says
-
Politics1 week ago
Carter's judicial picks reshaped the federal bench across the country
-
Politics6 days ago
Who Are the Recipients of the Presidential Medal of Freedom?
-
Health5 days ago
Ozempic ‘microdosing’ is the new weight-loss trend: Should you try it?
-
World1 week ago
Ivory Coast says French troops to leave country after decades