Connect with us

Fitness

How Close Should We Work Toward Failure For Optimal Muscle Growth? – Muscle & Fitness

Published

on

How Close Should We Work Toward Failure For Optimal Muscle Growth? – Muscle & Fitness

From the first moment that most of us hit the gym, the question of how many reps we should execute, and how intensely we should train is a quandary that stays with us throughout our sessions. Do too many reps overtrain the muscle and obstruct growth? And how do our goals of building muscle, or increasing strength, relate to our regime?

Fortunately, a new scientific report seems to have the answer. Researchers at Florida Atlantic University worked on the major new study, to determine the best models for both strength and muscle hypertrophy outcomes, collecting data from 55 previous studies to map out their conclusions. The results showed that if your goal is to build strength, then working close to failure doesn’t appear to have a significant advantage. For muscle mass gains, however, the closer you get to failure, the more muscle growth tends to occur.

“If you’re aiming for muscle growth, training closer to failure might be more effective. In other words, it doesn’t matter if you adjust training volume by changing sets or reps; the relationship between how close you train to failure and muscle growth remains the same,” said Michael C. Zourdos, Ph.D., senior author and professor and chair of the Department of Exercise Science and Health Promotion within FAU’s Charles E. Schmidt College of Science commenting to sciencedaily.com “For strength, how close you push to failure doesn’t seem to matter as much.”

Optimal Muscle Growth Method

So, how do we put this into practice? The study authors recommend working so that you get to 0-5 reps shy of failure for best results in terms of optimal muscle growth but remember to work within your limits to avoid injury. For strength training, the experts recommend stopping at 3-5 reps short of failure.

“When people estimate how many reps they have left, this perception influences the weights they choose. If the estimation is off, they might use lighter weights than needed, which could limit strength gains. On the flip side, our meta-analysis shows that training closer to failure also leads to greater muscle growth,” said Zac P. Robinson, Ph.D., first author and a Ph.D. graduate of FAU’s Department of Exercise Science and Health Promotion. “So, for the average individual, training close to failure may be the best option – as it seems to improve the accuracy of our perception of effort as well as gains in muscle size.”

Advertisement

Fitness

What an Oncology APP Should Know About Exercise in Cancer Care | Oncology Nursing News

Published

on

What an Oncology APP Should Know About Exercise in Cancer Care | Oncology Nursing News

Oncology advanced practice providers (APPs) should be aware of the transformative potential of exercise in cancer care and how to get patients started with a feasible exercise plan, said Daniel Glidden, MS, PA-C.

Ahead of his presentation at JADPRO Live 2025 on evidence-based diet and exercise tactics for patients with cancer, Glidden spoke with Oncology Nursing News about the key evidence APPs should be aware of, as well as actionable changes that can be made to incorporate exercise in patients’ care plans.

What data supports exercise as an essential part of cancer care?

For the longest time, we’ve had observational data that associates exercise and proper nutrition with improved survival, but it’s always been observational data. Now we have the first randomized, controlled trial—the phase 3 CHALLENGE trial (NCT00819208)—that shows us the true overall survival and disease-free survival benefit of a structured exercise program after adjuvant chemotherapy for colorectal cancer.

This was a phase 3 randomized controlled trial that randomized patients into either receiving health education materials alone or receiving health education materials plus a structured exercise program where they would go in for a supervised exercise and also have either in-person or virtual visits to talk about behavioral change to increase their exercise. What they found, of course, was that people in that exercise group had increased physical fitness in terms of their VO2 max and their 6-minute walk test and so on, but also that their disease-free survival was significantly improved. Around the 8-year mark, there was a [7%] improvement in disease-free survival in the patients in the intervention group. There was also an overall survival benefit.

Advertisement

Do the CHALLENGE data set a standard for all types of cancer care?

This is the first randomized control trial to show the true survival benefit that exercise can confer, at least in this patient population. We can’t extrapolate those data to all different cancers, but we have some good observational data that tells us that that there’s improved survival in many different cancers with exercise. As more of these studies come out, we’ll see more that exercise truly can be helpful for survival in cancer.

What level of exercise should patients with cancer be told to follow?

The general guidelines for people with cancer to start seeing health benefits from exercise are to get between 150 and 300 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic exercise per week. Moderate-intensity aerobic exercise is a brisk walk where, if you’re walking with a friend, you can have a good conversation with them, but if you tried to sing a song, you’d get out of breath. That’s a good “talk test” for moderate intensity exercise. We recommend that [routine], plus 2 to 3 days per week, getting resistance training of the major muscle groups for about a half hour at a time.

How can exercise plans be personalized for each patient?

The first step is finding out what people are doing. Are they exercising regularly? Are they exercising somewhat or completely sedentary? If they’re completely sedentary, I wouldn’t tell them to just go right off and exercise to those guidelines. We would want to start off slow and do a stepwise approach. …For many of our patients, cancer is not their only chronic condition, and there may be other safety issues like their neuropathy or bone [metastases] or poor bone health in general that we must take into consideration when we’re creating an exercise prescription.

What should all oncology APPs know about exercise in cancer care?

Exercise counseling is something that [oncology APPs] can integrate into their clinical visits. I want them to know that the true benefit of exercise is not just something that we can do, it’s something that we should be doing, all of us. If exercise was a medicine in a pill form, it would be something that we would all be lining up around the corner at our doctor’s offices to get a prescription for. Really, exercise truly is medicine.

What is integrative oncology, and what made you choose this field?

Integrative oncology is a patient-centered approach to cancer care that looks at the whole patient and combines their conventional cancer care with other treatment modalities like exercise; nutrition; stress management; and mind-body therapies like yoga, tai chi, and meditation to take care of the whole person.

Advertisement

I started off my career working first in emergency medicine, then in medical oncology. While I was working in medical oncology, I saw that we were doing a great job treating the cancer. We were winning the battle more and more, but there’s still a person there who needs to be taken care of, and that person was undoubtedly cared for by their cancer team. But there is certainly more that can be done.

I made the transition into integrative oncology at Dana-Farber so I could spend my entire clinical practice emphasizing and optimizing health, wellness, and quality of life. I will see people for consults and people come to me for different reasons. Sometimes it’s for treatment-related adverse effects. In those cases, we talk about how can acupuncture be helpful? For hot flashes, joint pains, or neuropathy, how can exercise, proper nutrition, and stress management be helpful?

This transcript has been edited for clarity and conciseness.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Fitness

I’ve interviewed yoga teachers, physical therapists and personal trainers—here are the five stretches they’ve recommended that have actually made a difference for me

Published

on

I’ve interviewed yoga teachers, physical therapists and personal trainers—here are the five stretches they’ve recommended that have actually made a difference for me

Now I’m hitting my third trimester of pregnancy—and as my energy levels have dropped—I’ve pressed pause on working out, but I’m still doing the same set of stretches to stay mobile and limber.

I work from home most days and whenever I need a screen break, I do a micro sequence of stretches that trainers, yoga instructors and physical therapists have recommended to me during interviews over the years—ones that have genuinely helped.

Continue Reading

Fitness

Nope, not pull-ups — this is the one bodyweight exercise you need to build strength and muscle in your back and biceps without weights

Published

on

Nope, not pull-ups — this is the one bodyweight exercise you need to build strength and muscle in your back and biceps without weights

I love pull-ups because they are the epitome of a challenging bodyweight compound exercise, meaning they target multiple muscle groups and joints simultaneously. If you can do them with just your own weight, great, but they are also endlessly scalable using one of the best resistance bands.

Don’t worry if you can’t do pull-ups yet, or you’re just looking for another way to build your back and biceps. All you need to start with is to improve foundational upper-body strength. And you can achieve this using a bodyweight exercise that targets the same muscle groups, but with a horizontal pulling motion rather than a vertical one.

Continue Reading

Trending