Connect with us

Fitness

Can stretching replace other types of exercise? Fitness experts explain positives and negatives of the latest trend

Published

on

Can stretching replace other types of exercise? Fitness experts explain positives and negatives of the latest trend
Stretching is one part of a healthy approach to fitness, says Maureen Watkins, shown here working with Northeastern student Abigail Honson. Credit: Alyssa Stone/Northeastern University

There is massage. There is yoga. There is physical therapy.

Now, there are stretching sessions.

Stretching isn’t new, of course. But the recent focus on extensive one-on-one sessions with stretching specialists has inspired a new layer of businesses within the fitness industry.

Hundreds of shops dedicated to stretching have opened throughout the U.S.—including the StretchMed franchises started by Northeastern graduate Brian Cook.

Advertisement

The stretching sessions have been growing for years, fueled in part by TikTok and other social media platforms. Health clubs have created stretching areas as participation in stretching classes almost doubled in 2023.

“Stretching helps to elongate our connective tissue,” says Maureen Watkins, a Northeastern University associate clinical professor of physical therapy, human movement and rehabilitation sciences. “It decreases stiffness in both our muscles and our tendons, which means you’re going to improve your range of motion when you stretch.”

How beneficial is stretching alone?

Is the focus on stretching—and only stretching—enough to help people develop fitness? “Stretching is important,” says David Nolan, an associate clinical professor at Northeastern’s Department of Physical Therapy, Movement and Rehabilitation Sciences and director of the Mass General Hospital/Northeastern University Sports Physical Therapy Residency. “But I don’t necessarily think that it’s the end-all and be-all.”

Stretching is one necessary aspect of a healthy regimen, the Northeastern experts say.

“Typically, more than one intervention or exercise type is needed to be well,” adds Watkins. “Yes, stretching is important for all of us to stay healthy and to maintain our range of motion. But it’s not going to fix all our problems. Just like in life, we need a balance of mobility and stability.”

Advertisement

Why has stretching become popular?

The focus on stretching has boomed as working hours have become more sedentary. And there’s the unavoidable truth that bodies grow stiffer with age.

“These companies that are focused on stretching have identified a need,” says Nolan, a clinical specialist at Mass General Sports Physical Therapy who oversees physical therapy care operations for the Boston Marathon. “When I talk to athletes and other patients about their typical routine, often I’m hearing them say, ‘I know I should stretch more.’”

For people who haven’t worked out for a while, Nolan says that beginning an exercise regimen with a focus on stretching isn’t necessarily a bad idea.

“If you’re doing nothing, and that’s where you’re starting?” Nolan says of stretching. “Then that’s awesome. As a physical therapist I would celebrate that.”

Advertisement

But he and Watkins insist that stretching alone won’t get the job done.

Quarterback Tom Brady was able to extend his NFL career to age 45 because of his devotion to muscle and joint “pliability.” But there was so much more to his regimen, says Watkins.

“His focus was to address muscle pliability through stretching, applying pressure through foam rolling and strengthening,” Watkins says. “It’s not just one-stop shopping. Stretching is not going to fix everything.

“Stretching is going to help—along with soft-tissue massage and a combination of other interventions.”

What else is necessary besides stretching?

Strength and cardiovascular training are also necessary, Nolan says.

Advertisement

For those who are seeking to stretch on their own, Watkins recommends holding a stretch for 20 to 30 seconds. Then perform each stretch two to three times. And aim for three to four sessions per week.

“It does take a while for your muscles to get elongated and gain new motion,” Watkins says. “Many people are tight—and it took a while for them to get tight. So it’s going to take a little while to get more flexible. If motion is limited, the key is consistency and stretching multiple times a week to address those affected muscle groups.”

If you feel pain during a stretch, Watkins says that’s the signal to back off. If you’re suffering from an injury, she recommends seeking a physical therapist to help guide you through recovery.

“And then the trick is to use your body,” Watkins says. “You have this beautiful new range of motion and we want to maintain it. After you stretch make sure that you’re doing some type of active movement and strengthening to maintain that motion.”

Focus on strengthening your muscles

If you’re already limber, adds Watkins, it may be a sign that you should be focused on strengthening your muscles more so than elongating them.

Advertisement

For most people, stretching should be embraced as a natural instinct.

“If you ever see animals when they first get up in the morning, what do they do? They stretch,” Watkins says. “They instinctively put their bodies through that motion. And so I always try to start my day off with a nice big stretch before I get out of bed. The animals do it without even thinking about it because they know it’s important.”

Provided by
Northeastern University

This story is republished courtesy of Northeastern Global News news.northeastern.edu.

Advertisement

Citation:
Can stretching replace other types of exercise? Fitness experts explain positives and negatives of the latest trend (2024, April 12)
retrieved 12 April 2024
from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2024-04-experts-positives-negatives-latest-trend.html

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no
part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Advertisement

Fitness

Bristol fitness expert offers free exercise for Parkinson’s

Published

on

Bristol fitness expert offers free exercise for Parkinson’s

Anne said she first noticed something was wrong with her when she started to get cramps in her hands and she started to have difficulty walking without feeling stiff.

“I was sent for a brain scan and, as a result of that, they diagnosed Parkinson’s disease,” she said.

She said exercising and meeting others in the same position had helped her.

“I find exercising with other people helps as you don’t feel quite as isolated, you meet people with the same condition,” she said.

“I wouldn’t have done what I do now, or met the people I met now, if it wasn’t for the diagnosis.”

Advertisement

She said her son was “so enthusiastic” about everything he does.

“He certainly gets a lot of good remarks from people with Parkinson’s who feel they are dong something for themselves,” she said.

Continue Reading

Fitness

Hybrid training: is this the secret to getting fitter and stronger?

Published

on

Hybrid training: is this the secret to getting fitter and stronger?

Tough Mudder. CrossFit. Hyrox. Some of this century’s biggest fitness trends have one thing in common: they require feats of both strength and endurance. People used to pick a side: either you used weights and resistance machines to build your muscles or you did cardio for the sake of your heart and lungs. Now everyone wants to be a “hybrid athlete”. So is this the best way to get fit – and where do you start if you’re a complete beginner?

What exactly is hybrid training?

Matt Lee, a postdoctoral research fellow at the Deakin Institute for Physical Activity and Nutrition in Australia, says: “Hybrid training – also known as concurrent training – combines cardio and resistance exercises (eg weights) within the same programme, performed either within a single session, or across separate sessions during the week.”

Where does it come from?

Hybrid training is not a new concept – official physical activity guidelines have long recommended a combination of strength and cardio exercises. But among athletes it was believed that endurance training had a negative impact on strength development (known as the “interference effect”); recent research has shown that is not the case.

Phil Price, a senior lecturer in strength and conditioning science at St Mary’s University, Twickenham, is the author of The Science of Hybrid Training. He says the term itself was coined by Alex Viada in his influential 2015 book, The Hybrid Athlete (which was updated last year). “He was a powerlifter and then he started running, so he was actively chasing two goals that don’t necessarily support one another,” Price says. “Hybrid came to mean a very clear focus on two separate goals that come from two separate sports.”

The hybrid concept has evolved, making it appeal to anyone who wants to get fitter and stronger. “It has been used for anything that requires an endurance component and a strength component,” says Price. “The rise of CrossFit really developed it and it’s definitely been utilised by those who do Hyrox.” CrossFit is a high-intensity workout combining cardio with elements of weightlifting and gymnastics; Hyrox is a fitness competition mixing running with burpees, kettlebell carries, sled pushes and more.

Advertisement

Thomas Jones, an associate professor of sport, exercise and rehabilitation at Northumbria University, says: “Hyrox, which is super-popular at the moment, is almost the definition of hybrid. Those events are aerobic-based, so there’s a running element, and then there’s also a strength element and a power element.” Organisers say more than 1 million people entered a Hyrox race during the 2025/26 season, which culminates with the world championships in Stockholm this month.

Hyrox is almost the definition of hybrid training, with a running element, as well as power and strength elements. Photograph: HYROX

A hybrid scene has also developed through social media, says Price. “More and more people have created these hybrid goals of, for example, doing a 500lb [227kg] squat and on the same day running a sub-five-minute mile. People are online competing with each other and through that, the culture has really boomed.”

What are the benefits?

Lee says hybrid training has numerous benefits for overall health and wellbeing, as well as sports performance. “Research has shown hybrid training can improve strength, muscle mass, power, endurance, speed and agility,” he says. “Beyond physical gains, studies of people who do hybrid training such as CrossFit report perceived improvements in quality of life, reduced stress, increased self-esteem and social benefits.” A previous study found this sense of belonging was significantly higher at CrossFit gyms than at traditional ones.

And hybrid training is a boon for busy schedules. “For many people, lack of time is a major barrier to exercise,” says Lee. “Combining cardio and resistance exercises within a single session is a time-efficient way to meet training goals.” I can relate to that – the “warrior” class at my local gym combines treadmill or rowing intervals with free-weight sets, for a full-body workout in just 45 minutes.

Hybrid training is perfect for those who are time poor. Photograph: Posed by models; Pekic/Getty Images

Alexios Batrakoulis, an assistant professor of applied and clinical exercise physiology at European University Cyprus, has conducted extensive research into hybrid training. He has seen great results from participants completing a 30-minute circuit-style hybrid programme up to three times a week. After 10 to 12 months, he reports: “Previously inactive middle-aged adults with overweight/obesity have significant body mass and fat reduction, as well as improvements in performance, cardiometabolic and psychological health.” He found that people enjoyed these “moderate to vigorous” circuits more than “traditional moderate-intensity continuous training”.

Advertisement

Is it suitable for beginners?

Absolutely – with the caveat that you check with your GP if you have any existing injuries or health conditions (and pay no attention to social media challenges). Kim Way, a senior lecturer at the Deakin Institute and an exercise physiologist with Exercise and Sports Science Australia, says beginners should do a combination of aerobic and resistance training two or three times a week.

“Start with low- to moderate-intensity exercise to help the body get used to the different exercises and get used to a routine. Use intervals to help break up aerobic activity to get used to moderate intensity with some recovery as well,” she says. “The talk test is a great way to gauge if you are going too hard with aerobic exercise. Moderate-intensity does make you a bit breathless, but you’d still be able to maintain a conversation with someone or be able to sing.” Build a foundation with four to six weeks of consistent training before adding another day or a high-intensity session, she adds.

What sort of aerobic exercise should I do?

This depends on your goals, says Lee. If you want to build up to a Hyrox event, running is essential – each race includes eight 1km runs – as is training on skiing and rowing machines. If you just want to get fitter, running is one option, but you may enjoy others more. “Substituting other cardio options such as swimming or cycling can still improve cardiovascular fitness while reducing the risk of overuse injuries that may occur from high volumes of running,” says Lee.

And what sort of strength training?

Again, if you’re training with Hyrox in mind, it make sense to focus on the strength-based events in the races: sled push and pull, farmer’s carry, sandbag lunges, wall balls … If you’re new to these exercises, says Way, scale back the weights, reps and sets. But if you just want to improve your general strength, she recommends “whole-body, compound movements such as squats, deadlifts and bench presses, which will provide immense benefit”.

Body-weight exercises, such as press ups, are a good alternative to using weights. Photograph: Posed by model; Organic Media/Getty Images

“Two of the biggest predictors of quality of life in old age are strength (one-rep max) and aerobic fitness (VO2 max),” says Jones. “Strength is what often gets neglected by those who are new to exercise – they just run.”

Advertisement

Does the order I do them in matter?

“Research, including my own, suggests the order of cardio and resistance exercise has little influence on improving cardio fitness,” says Lee. “However, if a person’s goal is to improve strength, some research suggests completing resistance exercise before cardio might lead to greater strength gains, and that greater recovery time between modes (more than three hours) may benefit explosive strength development (power) – but more research is needed on these.”

Do I need to join a gym?

“For people with limited exercise experience, gyms can be a great place to start, as they provide access to professionals who can help develop suitable training plans and guidance on techniques,” says Lee. If you want to get into CrossFit, for example, there are about 10,000 gyms in 150 countries.

You can do your own hybrid training on the gym floor, using the cardio and resistance machines and/or free weights, but another option is joining a hybrid-style class. “Group classes can provide a sense of community and social support, which may also help with motivation and consistency,” says Lee. Some gyms offer dedicated Hyrox classes; others to look out for include bootcamp, circuits, functional fitness, and strength and conditioning. “When joining a group class, always remember to listen to your body,” says Way. “It is OK to stop and have a break if your body is not used to what is happening.”

Going to the gym doesn’t necessarily mean committing to a year-long membership. Apps such as ClassPass enable you to buy credits to use at a variety of gyms, and there are no-contract, pay-monthly budget chains such as PureGym and the Gym Group (which also offer classes). Community centres often have low-cost hybrid-style workouts – my local one has an hour’s circuit training for £8 – and many parks have free sessions, such as the beginners’ bootcamps and other classes run by Our Parks across the UK.

Can’t I do hybrid training at home?

Absolutely – you can combine cardio with home strength training. For example, you could follow the NHS’s Couch to 5K running programme alongside Our Parks’ Couch to Fitness programme. Jones says: “Remember what Joe Wicks was doing during Covid? That would be hybrid training.” Wicks is still posting free videos on YouTube – a recent 20-minute “strength, cardio and abs” workout fits the hybrid bill.

Advertisement

You don’t need any specialist equipment, at least initially. “For people just getting started, body weight exercises are enough,” says Jones. “If you can’t do 10 good push-ups, that’s a really good place to start.” Way suggests squats, lunges and pull-ups alongside your push-ups. When you’re ready to move on, “Filling up a backpack with cans or water bottles can add load,” she says.

Batrakoulis says you don’t need to invest in heavy weights to progress further, but some “functional training tools” can be useful: resistance bands, kettlebells, exercise balls and medicine balls; even suspension straps and battle ropes, if you have space.

Outdoors gyms make it easy to combine cardio and strength training … and they’re free! Photograph: Posed by model; coldsnowstorm/Getty Images

Jones is also a fan of outdoor gyms in parks: “They’re great because it gives you the opportunity to run and then jump in and do some pull-ups and body-weight exercises.”

How much training should I do?

Lee says: “For overall health, the World Health Organization recommends adults aged 18 to 64 engage in at least 150-300 minutes a week of moderate-intensity aerobic physical activity, or 75-150 minutes a week of vigorous-intensity aerobic physical activity (or an equivalent combination of the two), plus muscle-strengthening activities at moderate or greater intensity on two days a week.” But don’t try to go from zero to hero, says Way: “If you are not currently meeting these guidelines, a slow and gradual buildup in activity is recommended.”

This is especially important in hybrid training, says Price, because of the various demands it puts on the body. “The endurance exercise is going to fatigue things in different ways to the resistance exercise. The high-intensity stuff is going to fatigue your body in different ways to the long-duration, low-intensity stuff. All of a sudden you’ve got a mix of everything.” His advice is to “start off slowly and progress very slowly because you don’t know how well your body will respond to the different stimuli and how close they are together”. The good news? “The body is really adaptable and will start to deal with that type of mixed stress quite well.”

Advertisement

Should I do cardio and strength training in the same session?

If you’re doing hybrid classes, clearly yes. Otherwise, says Jones, it’s down to preference and time. “I cycle some days and I lift weights other days. But some people wouldn’t like that approach. My wife, for instance, loves getting out in the garden and doing a circuit. So whatever works for you will be effective.”

Should I train every day?

No – rest days are essential. “It’s important to allow enough recovery time between sessions, not only for adaptations to occur, but to also minimise the risks of overuse injuries and overtraining,” says Lee. Way says beginners need at least 24-48 hours of recovery between sessions to help the body adjust.

Prioritise sleep. “Sleep for all exercise is really quite important. I think people underestimate that,” says Price. “I see it like a triad. Quite often if people are struggling with their training or they have a niggling recurring injury, they think there must be something that they’re doing wrong in training. But they need to go and make sure that they’re getting enough water, their nutrition’s right and they’re getting enough sleep. Quite a lot of the time, it’s their everyday life that isn’t providing that support to recover for them.”

Do I need to change my diet?

Keep energy levels topped up with a good combination of protein and carbs, as well as lots of water. Photograph: filadendron/Getty Images

“As long as you’re getting good protein and carbs between sessions and lots of water, you should be good to go,” says Price. Specifically, he says, you need sufficient amounts of the amino acid leucine, which is found in most protein sources (meat, fish, cheese, beans, nuts, seeds, tofu etc). “Whenever the body tries to respond to the training stress from a strength point of view, the intake of protein is one of the signals to spark protein synthesis, which then improves muscle hypertrophy [growth]. So you’re trying to avoid that molecular process getting disrupted.”

Protein is often prioritised these days, but don’t overlook carbohydrates. “Carbohydrates broken down can get stored into muscle glycogen [fuel], and both strength and endurance training can reduce those stores. So if you’ve trained, you want to make sure that anything that was used from the previous session has been replenished,” says Price.

Advertisement

And finally … where do I sign up for the Hyrox world championships?

Sadly, that is invite-only for the top 0.5% of athletes. How about a Hyrox cruise instead?

Continue Reading

Fitness

Tight on Space? You Can Still Get a Great Workout With This Compact Home Gym Equipment

Published

on

Tight on Space? You Can Still Get a Great Workout With This Compact Home Gym Equipment

Our team decided the TRX Home 2 System is the best multipurpose piece of compact home gym equipment you can invest in, thanks to its lightweight and multipurpose functions. I love that it supports both resistance training and cardio workouts while taking up zero surface area of my shoebox apartment.

All you do is hook the TRX Home 2 System onto the back of a door, beam, or pole with the included anchors. The hooks and suspension straps stay in place (which is essential for safety) while executing explosive movements like lunges and squats. In my apartment, I attached it to the back of my door and was able to install it properly on my first attempt. It’s never budged, no matter how much weight I put on it.

After using it a dozen times, I never lost balance or felt at risk of injury. It may look flimsy, but I attest it’s strong and mighty. For further stability, the straps feature grippy handles, which Sheridan recommends.

I know this product is top-notch because it has superior durability to withstand high-resistance, low-impact workouts. With weekly use, the anchors are not worn out and still feel good as new—you get what you pay for! Plus, the TRX Home 2 System was specifically designed by a Navy Seal over 20 years ago and has proven its effectiveness.

As a runner, it’s excellent for cross-training muscles I wouldn’t otherwise use, and stretching out my tired limbs. I plan on also using it on vacation for quick hotel room workouts because I need my daily endorphins.

Advertisement

Read More: Best Portable Home Gyms

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending