Utah
Utah could require device manufacturers to add content filters to phones, tablets for kids
Estimated read time: 4-5
minutes
SALT LAKE CITY — The state of Utah could require cellphone and tablet manufacturers to enable obscenity filters on devices used by minors, under a proposal that received initial support from a Senate committee on Wednesday.
Sen. Todd Weiler, R-Woods Cross, the sponsor of SB104, told the Senate Judiciary, Law Enforcement and Criminal Justice Committee last week the Utah Legislature approved a similar bill several years ago, which would only have gone into effect if at least five other states adopted the same legislation.
Tired of waiting for action from other states — which have so far declined to enact similar laws — Weiler said he’s ready for the Beehive State to move forward on its own, if need be.
“In the years since, we’ve made ourselves an outlier when it comes to social media and foreign websites,” Weiler said, in reference to the state’s high-profile social media regulations passed last year.
So, why not be an outlier when it comes to blocking pornography and other potentially harmful content on devices used by minors?
“The idea is to provide minors with protection and opportunities that they deserve as children to protect them from developing maybe an addiction to pornography before they’re even adults and allow them time to develop good online habits while they’re still young,” the senator said.
Weiler said many phones made by major manufacturers come with preinstalled software to enable content filtering, but they are deactivated by default and sometimes not easily enabled by parents.
His bill would allow the state attorney general to sue manufacturers who don’t comply with the requirements.
Elder Mervyn B. Arnold, a general authority seventy of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, spoke in favor of the bill during its initial hearing on Jan. 23. Arnold — who joined Weiler as a private citizen to present the bill — praised efforts to keep children from coming across obscene material.
“This state has a fabulous record … for being out in front and protecting our children and grandchildren from these kinds of issues,” he said. “We do have a right to protect our children from obscene material.”
SB104 was supported by several parents and sexual exploitation advocates, but an earlier version of the bill was held in committee last week after a handful of business groups expressed concern that the bill could present liability to businesses beyond just the manufacturers.
Dave Davis, president and chief legal officer for the Utah Retail Merchants Association, asked why lawmakers aren’t waiting for other states before moving forward. The purpose of the earlier bill was to ensure “a critical mass for manufacturers so that Utah wouldn’t be on an island, and you just don’t get devices.”
He also called the criminal penalties “very, very, very heavy-handed,” and said he was concerned about the potential impact to retailers who sell phones. Representatives from mobile carriers AT&T and Verizon said they hoped to address concerns about liability to retail clerks who sell phones to Utahns.
“We’re just opening the box,” said Jodi Hart with AT&T.
Those with concerns all said they’re supportive of keeping pornography out of the hands of minors, as did Dylan Hoffman with TechNet, a national network of technology companies.
“However,” Hoffman said, “we must respectfully oppose this bill on the basis that we don’t believe that there’s a technically feasible way to comply.”
Instead, he said parents can install free or commercial third-party software to block inappropriate content, and raised the possibility that manufacturers could block sales of smartphones and tablets in Utah as a way to avoid liability.
Hoffman on Wednesday said his organization “(agrees) wholeheartedly with the intent of this bill,” but said he believes it may not pass constitutional muster.
Weiler acknowledged during the Jan. 23 hearing that the bill still needed some tweaks, and asked the committee to hold it without taking a vote while he worked to resolve them.
He introduced an amendment to the bill stating that nothing in it creates a cause of legal action against against the retailer of a device. The amendment also states that an adult — other than a parent or legal guardian — who disables a content filter on a minor’s device “for the purpose of disseminating pornography to the minor” can be charged with a class A misdemeanor subject to a fine up to $5,000.
The bill cleared committee unanimously on Wednesday after lawmakers adopted Weiler’s amendments.
The bill would allow the state attorney general to block a company’s action in violation of the law and seek civil penalties up to $5,000 for each violation. The attorney general would also be allowed to seek to strip companies of their license to operate in the state if they are found in violation.
Weiler was the sponsor of a bill last session that required adult websites to verify the ages of users. The law sparked the ire of the pornography industry and PornHub has since blocked access to users in the state.
Industry groups and the Free Speech Coalition challenged the law in court, but their lawsuit was dismissed in August 2023.
Related stories
Most recent Utah Legislature stories
More stories you may be interested in
Utah
Utah expands traction law for vehicles in Cottonwood Canyons
SALT LAKE CITY — The latest version of Utah’s traction laws may upset people looking to enjoy Big and Little Cottonwood canyons before a storm even hits the area.
With the newest update to the law being implemented by the Utah Department of Transportation, officials are now able to enforce traction requirements up to 24 hours before a storm front moves in.
UDOT says the update, which came through legislation passed earlier this year, allows drivers to “prepare before snow starts falling.” The revised law also requires vehicles in the canyons to have at least 5/32 inch of tire tread, and allows for “stricter enforcement” during storms.
The new version enables law enforcement agencies to issue citations for those who violate the traction law.
“Our new, enhanced traction requirements are all about safety,” UDOT Region Two Director Robert Stewart said. “These updates make sure drivers have the right equipment before heading into the canyons, even if a storm rolls in while they’re parked. We hope this gives everyone more peace of mind knowing they, and the drivers around them, are ready for winter conditions.”
Traction law enforcement is handled by the Cottonwood Heights and Sandy City police departments, with additional support from the Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office for roadside and parking enforcement.
UDOT is working to help drivers prepare, offering the free Cottonwood Canyons Sticker Program, which provides voluntary winter tire inspections at more than 140 tire shops. Those inspections run from November 13 to February 28.
The sticker program is free and voluntary, and the stickers are not required to drive in Big or Little Cottonwood Canyon. The stickers work to show that a vehicle has proper traction devices for traveling in the canyons when the Traction Law is in effect.
“It takes all of us working together to keep our canyons safe,” Stewart said. “Winter recreation is a Utah tradition we all value. A little preparation now means more time enjoying the mountains, and less time worrying about safety or compliance.”
According to UDOT, since launching the sticker program in 2021, 86% of participants say they noticed more vehicles in the canyon that are properly equipped for winter.
Drivers are also encouraged to plan ahead, slow down, and consider using transit to reach ski resorts. Real-time updates on canyon conditions are available through the UDOT website.
Utah
Despite economic fears, holiday season expected to be busy for Utah storeowners
SALT LAKE CITY — As the calendar nears December, the National Retail Federation predicts holiday sales will surpass the one trillion dollar mark for the first time. But how does that add up when, at the same time, officials claim consumer confidence is in bad shape?
“This is kind of the disconnect that we’re seeing in the economy right now,” explained Zions Bank senior economist Robert Spendlove.
According to Spendlove, a trillion dollars in holiday sales would be a 4 percent increase over last year’s numbers. It would be an increase despite the federation sharing numbers that show consumer confidence hasn’t been this low in 50 years.
“That’s both at the national level and at our state level. And I hear this when I talk to people that they just don’t feel great about the economy, but they continue to spend,” said Spendlove.
That’s just the news Amanda Stewart wants to hear as owner of Mochi Kids in the 9th and 9th shopping district. Her store features a children’s clothing line, along with toys and gifts from all over the world.
“Holiday shopping is so crucial. We’ll sell probably, like, three times more during the holidays than we do during a normal month,” Stewart said.
Amanda has sensed the lack of confidence in the economy and seen an increase in wholesale prices due to tariffs, forcing her to make adjustments so she doesn’t price out her clientele.
“We’ve experienced probably about 10% price increase across the board compared to last year, and so we’ve definitely had to change how we buy,” Stewart said. “We purchased things that are a little less expensive, knowing that some people, you know, who are spending more on groceries will have less of a budget to spend on toys this year.”
Nonetheless, both the experts and those on the front lines, like Stewart, anticipate brisk sales once the holiday shopping season kicks into high gear later this month.
“Even though consumers don’t feel good about inflation, they don’t feel good about the government shutdown, they’re nervous about tariffs, we expect that in this holiday season, consumers will be spending about $890,” Spendlove said.
“It’s not surprising to me,” added Stewart. “I think people want to have a magical experience for their families, no matter what the economic circumstances are. I think that’s just part of our culture here in the U.S.”
Utah
Inmate charged with capital murder accused of assaulting Utah County deputies at jail – again
SPANISH FORK — The man charged with capital murder in the death of Santaquin Police Sgt. Bill Hooser is once again facing additional charges for allegedly spraying a deputy at the Utah County Jail with an unknown liquid.
Michael Aaron Jayne, 43, of Garrett, Indiana — who is already awaiting trial on a charge of aggravated murder and is facing a possible death sentence if convicted — is now accused of propelling an unidentified liquid into the face of a Utah County sheriff’s deputy while incarcerated.
On Sunday, about 6:50 p.m., Jayne allegedly used his hands “to forcefully hit something on the inside of his cell door through the crack, causing liquid to spray out onto the victim. When this happened, the cell door was shut. It took planning and effort to shoot the substance through the crack in his door at the right time. The victim then stepped back and radioed for an additional deputy. I then entered the unit and saw the victim wipe his face and liquid droplets on the victim’s pants and shirt,” according to a police booking affidavit.
Deputies later reviewed surveillance video and saw Jayne watching the deputy as he entered the housing unit to do a head count, the affidavit states.
He was initially arrested and later charged for allegedly running over Hooser with a semitruck intentionally on May 5, 2024, according to charging documents. A preliminary hearing in that case is scheduled to begin Nov. 24.
In August, Jayne was charged with aggravated assault by a prisoner, a second-degree felony; two counts of assault by a prisoner, a third-degree felony; and causing property damage, a class A misdemeanor. In that case, he is accused of attacking multiple deputies on July 30.
In September, his defense team filed a motion stating they are “gravely concerned” that if their client isn’t moved out of the Utah County Jail, he may not live to see a trial. But just a week later, that motion was withdrawn.
The Key Takeaways for this article were generated with the assistance of large language models and reviewed by our editorial team. The article, itself, is solely human-written.
-
Austin, TX1 week agoHalf-naked woman was allegedly tortured and chained in Texas backyard for months by five ‘friends’ who didn’t ‘like her anymore’
-
Nebraska5 days agoWhere to watch Nebraska vs UCLA today: Time, TV channel for Week 11 game
-
Hawaii4 days agoMissing Kapolei man found in Waipio, attorney says
-
Vermont2 days agoNorthern Lights to dazzle skies across these US states tonight – from Washington to Vermont to Maine | Today News
-
Southwest6 days agoTexas launches effort to install TPUSA in every high school and college
-
New Jersey4 days agoPolice investigate car collision, shooting in Orange, New Jersey
-
World1 week agoIsrael’s focus on political drama rather than Palestinian rape victim
-
West Virginia2 days ago
Search for coal miner trapped in flooded West Virginia mine continues for third day