Pennsylvania
University of Pennsylvania grapples with donor crisis after ‘Palestine Writes’ event causes uproar
A prominent University of Pennsylvania donor sent his alma mater a $1 check with an annual pledge for the same amount as long as UPenn President Liz Magill remains at the school, joining a handful of other mega-donors who continue to withhold donations over the school’s response to the Israel-Hamas conflict and accusations of excusing antisemitism.
He’s just one of several major donors that’s calling for changes at the top as the elite university grapples with the fallout of a recent on-campus event. It’s gotten to the point that alumni president Michael Barrett penned a letter to his fellow Quakers reaffirming support for Magill, defending the school’s handling of the situation and criticizing the “misinformation” and heavy scrutiny the school has faced this month.
On Sunday, Magill released a statement saying the school didn’t move fast enough to address criticism of the “Palestine Writes” event and strongly condemned the Hamas “terrorist assault” on Israel; her initial statement to the school didn’t refer to Hamas a terrorist group, although it called its attack “abhorrent” and “horrific.”
Here are the donors who are speaking out against the university.
JONATHON JACOBSON
Jonathon Jacobson, a 1983 Wharton graduate and founding member of private investment firm HighSage Ventures LLC, announced his reduced donation in a letter obtained by Fox News, in which he scolded his alma mater for its lack of “moral courage” and inability to distinguish between “what is clearly right and clearly wrong.”
Jacobson, who has previously given “multi-seven figure donations,” to the university in addition to student scholarships and financial support for the school’s sports program, called out UPenn leadership for its “completely inept” handling of the Palestine Writes festival that took place on campus in September and “too little too late” statement on the Hamas terrorist attack which killed at least 1,400 Israelis and 31 Americans.
HARVARD STUDENT ORGANIZATIONS CLAIM ISRAEL ‘ENTIRELY RESPONSIBLE’ FOR GAZA ATTACKS
“Enclosed is a check for $1 which represents the first installment of a multi-year pledge which we will renew until you find employment elsewhere and the board of trustees grows the backbone to fulfill its mission, which is to govern the university according to the principles upon which it was founded,” Jacobson wrote in the letter addressed to Magill.
“The university that I attended and that shaped me, is virtually unrecognizable today, and the values it stands for are not American ones,” he continued.
Jacobson accused the school of “hiding behind free speech” as an excuse for its “fecklessness” in the two-page letter, further tearing into the leadership, who he described as a “product of a very screwed up higher-ed system.”
“Unfortunately,” he wrote, “an entire generation of our kids is also a product of this system and this ideology, which is now deeply ensconced at Penn and other countless universities, has now also affected the media, our legal apparatus and Congress.”
“We live in an unserious and highly dangerous time,” he added. “Enough. It is time to reverse this trend and restore our ‘elite’ universities to the principles upon which they were founded: as places of inquiry, where lively debate, diversity of opinion and communication across lines of difference is not only cherished, but actually mandated.”
MARC ROWAN
Jacobson was likely inspired by Apollo CEO Marc Rowan, who earlier this week called on prominent UPenn donors to send $1 checks with the hopes of forcing a change in leadership at the university. The outrage began after the school hosted a Palestinian literary festival on campus which included speakers with a history of antisemitic comments, including calls for “death to Israel.” Many donors reached their boiling point when the University failed to, in their view, immediately condemn Hamas’ vicious attack.
The billionaire private equity firm CEO, also a Wharton graduate, called for donors to “close their checkbooks” in a letter sent to the school’s newspaper, The Daily Pennsylvanian, where he demanded the resignation of Magill and Scott Bok, chair of the board of trustees. Rowan is the chairman of the board of advisers to the Wharton School, UPenn’s elite college of business, and in 2018 he and his wife gave the business school $50 million.
“It took less than two weeks to go from the Palestine Writes literary festival on the University of Pennsylvania’s campus to the barbaric slaughter and kidnapping of Israelis,” Rowan wrote.
“The polarizing Palestine Writes gathering featured well-known antisemites and fomenters of hate and racism, and it was underwritten, supported and hosted by various UPenn academic departments and affiliates.”
After several students expressed concern with the event, UPenn issued a statement signed by Magill and Provost John Jackson Jr. arguing that it was a “public event” and wasn’t organized by the university.
Still, the school leaders said they support “the free exchange of ideas,” including “the expression of views that are controversial and even those that are incompatible with our institutional values.”
Outrage among donors only intensified following Hamas’ terror attack on Israel, forcing Magill and Jackson to put out a separate statement.
“We are devastated by the horrific assault on Israel by Hamas that targeted civilians and the taking of hostages over the weekend. These abhorrent attacks have resulted in the tragic loss of life and escalating violence and unrest in the region,” they said. Many members of our community are hurting right now. Our thoughts are especially with those grieving the loss of loved ones or facing grave uncertainty about the safety of their families and friends.”
DAVID MAGERMAN
On Tuesday, venture capitalist and philanthropist David Magerman joined the growing list of donors severing ties with the university for not taking a bolder stance against antisemitism. In a letter he shared on LinkedIn, Magerman, an observant Orthodox Jew and Penn donor, wrote that he was “deeply ashamed” to be associated with the university following the Palestine Writes festival and that he wouldn’t donate another dollar.
Magerman called on all “self-respecting Jews” to “dissociate themselves” from the university.
“There is no action anyone at Penn can take to change that. I’m not asking for any actions,” he wrote. “You have shown me who you are. My only remaining hope is that all self-respecting Jews, and all moral citizens of the world, dissociate themselves from Penn,” the letter, dated October 15, said.
But unlike some of his fellow donors, Magerman said he found calls for Magill’s resignation insufficient.
“I feel your firing is unnecessary, because it is wholly inadequate,” he wrote. “If in fact the University of Pennsylvania as an institution has such a misguided moral compass that it can fail to recognize evil when it is staring us all in the face, I don’t think replacing you will accomplish anything. Frankly, I don’t think there is anything anyone can do to redeem the school, short of rebuilding its moral foundations from the ground up,” he wrote.
Magill issued a statement on Sunday, the same day Magerman wrote the letter, and said the university should have moved faster to share their position and clarify that they did not endorse the views of the speakers at the controversial event.
“I know how painful the presence of these speakers on Penn’s campus was for the Jewish community, especially during the holiest time of the Jewish year, and at a University deeply proud of its long history of being a welcoming place for Jewish people. The University did not, and emphatically does not, endorse these speakers or their views. While we did communicate, we should have moved faster to share our position strongly and more broadly with the Penn community,” Magill said.
RONALD LAUDER
Billionaire Ronald Lauder, heir to the Estée Lauder cosmetics empire and a major donor to the University of Pennsylvania, informed the school this week that he is now “reexamining” his financial support for the institution after it allowed people with histories of “outright antisemitism” to speak at the festival event on campus despite his repeated pleas to have it canceled.
In a letter obtained by Fox News, Lauder – whose family funded the creation of the Lauder Institute at UPenn’s famed Wharton School – lambasted Magill and the Ivy League institution for refusing to cancel the event in September.
“I told you that those invited to the event had a history of not just strong anti-Israel bias, but outright antisemitism. You were already aware of much of this,” Lauder wrote. “I now know that the conference has put a deep stain on Penn’s reputation that will take a long time to repair.”
Lauder said he sent two people to the event on his behalf, who reported “antisemitic and viscerally anti-Israel” remarks from the panel of controversial speakers.
The billionaire, who is president of the World Jewish Congress, added that “the timing of the event could not possibly have been worse.”
“I have spent the past 40 years fighting antisemitism all over the world and I never, in my wildest imagination, thought I would have to fight it at my university, my alma mater and my family’s alma mater.”
“Let me be as clear as I can: I do not want any of the students at The Lauder Institute, the best and brightest at your university, to be taught by any of the instructors who were involved or supported this event,” Lauder wrote. “In my mind, they put their bias against Israel ahead of any academic honesty. We know who they are and what they said.”
Lauder has not yet ruled out future donations to the university, but said Magill is “forcing” him to reexamine his financial support “absent satisfactory measures to address antisemitism at the university.”
“Liz, you should know that this letter is written with the greatest sorrow, a sorrow I never expected to encounter at Penn and a sorrow and one I don’t think I will get over,” he concluded. “I am so sorry you did not cancel the event.”
JON HUNTSMAN
Former Utah governor Jon Huntsman Jr. also recently announced his foundation would be stopping donations to the school over the controversy.
“To the outsider, it appears that Penn has become deeply adrift in ways that make it almost unrecognizable,” Huntsman wrote in an email obtained by The Daily Pennsylvanian. “Moral relativism has fueled the university’s race to the bottom and sadly now has reached a point where remaining impartial is no longer an option.”
“Consequently, Huntsman Foundation will close its checkbook on all future giving to Penn – something that has been a source of enormous pride for now three generations of graduates,” the former governor wrote.
CLIFFORD ASNESS
Clifford Asness, a hedge fund manager and co-founder of AQR Capital Management who holds degrees from the university, wrote to Magill to say “what has been going on at Penn is unacceptable” and that the school has turned away from freedom of thought and expression, according to a copy of the letter posted on X.
He said he has “long been dismayed” about the “drift away from true freedom of thought, expression and speech at our best Universities, very much including my beloved alma mater Penn.”
Asness described the Palestine Writes festival as an “antisemitic Burning Man festival” that “pushed matters further.”
“I’m 100% for free speech but not asymmetrical free speech where some have it and some don’t. Imagine Penn’s action if that event was as anti-anyone else other than Jews!? Hiding behind ‘free speech’ when it is a right only embraced for antisemites and other fellow travelers is not OK.”
Asness echoed some of his fellow donors who took issue with the university’s response to Hamas’ terror attack on Israel.
“Of course, most distressing to me was your first statement making vague equivalences between the intentional murder of children (and others) by terrorists and the accidental injury to children that sadly occurs when murdering terrorists hide behind children to escape justice,” he wrote. “There is no semblance of equivalence. I must believe this equivalence was not your goal. But it clearly reads that way to me.”
He indicated that having recently completed a five-year pledge of donations to UPenn, he “will not be considering another until such meaningful change is evident.”
“I do not like making something like this about money – but it appears to be one of the only paths that has any hope of mattering,” he concluded, “and it has become clear that is the only voice some of us have.”
Penn isn’t the only Ivy League school that’s landed in hot water since Hamas’ attack on Israel last week. Harvard has been the center of controversy, with pro-Palestinian student groups releasing a joint statement claiming Israel was “entirely responsible” for Hamas’ attack. It said, “Today’s events did not occur in a vacuum. For the last two decades, millions of Palestinians in Gaza have been forced to live in an open-air prison.”
Separately, multiple pro-Palestinian student groups hosted a march and “die-in” at Harvard Business School Wednesday in protest of Israel’s “genocide” of Palestinians in Gaza.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
The Wexner Foundation, a nonprofit started by Victoria’s Secret founder Leslie Wexner and his wife Abigail, announced in a letter this week that they will be stopping their funding to Harvard, saying they were “sickened and stunned” by the school’s “dismal failure” to take an unequivocal stand against the “barbaric murders of innocent Israeli civilians.” They accused the school of “tiptoeing” around the issue and announced a hard stop to their financial and programmatic support of the university in a letter obtained by Fox News.
On Monday, Scott Bok, the Chair of the Penn Board of Trustees, released a statement about a meeting with Magill where Trustees condemned the Hamas attacks and Magill in turn outlined plans to “enhance education and training to combat antisemitism on campus.”
“The unanimous sense of those gathered was that President Magill and her existing University leadership team are the right group to take the University forward,” he said.
For her part, Magill released a statement Tuesday, “Alumni are important members of the Penn community. I hear their anger, pain, and frustration and am taking action to make clear that I stand, and Penn stands, emphatically against the terrorist attacks by Hamas in Israel and against antisemitism. As a University, we support and encourage the free exchange of ideas, along with a commitment to the safety and security of our community and the values we share and work to advance. Penn has a moral responsibility to combat antisemitism and to educate our community to recognize and reject hate in all its forms. I’ve said we should have communicated faster and more broadly about where we stand, but let there be no doubt that we are steadfast in our beliefs.”
Reached for comment, a University of Pennsylvania spokesperson directed Fox News Digital to Bok and Magill’s recent comments and statements on the matter.
Fox Business’ Breck Dumas and Eric Revell and Fox News’ Hanna Panreck contributed to this report.
For more Culture, Media, Education, Opinion and channel coverage, visit foxnews.com/media.
Pennsylvania
Books and coffee? Both shine at Pressed in Erie, Pennsylvania
Independent bookstores are the heartbeats of their communities. They provide culture and community, generate local jobs and sales tax revenue, promote literacy and education, champion and center diverse and new authors, connect readers to books in a personal and authentic way, and actively support the right to read and access to books in their communities.
Each week we profile an independent bookstore, sharing what makes each one special and getting their expert and unique book recommendations.
This week we have Pressed in Erie, Pennsylvania!
What’s your store’s story?
Founded in Erie, Pennsylvania in 2018, our goal is to encourage others to step away from their device and enjoy the feel, smell, and look of a book, paired with a comforting coffee. We love it when customers take their time checking out what’s new (or old!), and have a lovely time reconnecting with their senses as they explore the books and gifts in our shop.
What makes your independent bookstore unique?
Customers love the vibe in our store. It’s modern and upbeat, but with good old-fashioned books in the spotlight! They’re encouraged to take their coffee or warm drink (from our full-service coffee shop) and explore.
We’re known for a curated but wide variety of reading genres, along with fun literary gifts (staff take real pleasure in hearing customers laugh out loud as they peruse the store), as well as our large kids’ area, with our famous reading tree. We’re proud to do our part to make Erie a vibrant and interesting city, something more than just a cluster of big-box stores.
What’s your favorite section in your store?
My favorite section is the front, where all the best displays are and where we greet our customers. But a close second is the kids’ room — the reading tree and the moss-covered cobblestone look of the carpet are so inviting!
Why is shopping at local, independent bookstores important?
People vote for what they want in their community with their dollars. If they like having indie bookstores in their town, they simply must spend money there. Spending money elsewhere is exactly like submitting a vote for the indie to close. As long as people understand what they’re doing when they choose not to shop local, I have no problem with it. But if people want that local shop to stay, because it adds value and personality to their town and because they enjoy shopping there, they have to be okay with spending a few extra dollars on a book there. That’s the bottom line.
Check out these books recommended from Pressed owner, Tracey Bowes:
- “Z: A Novel of Zelda Fitzgerald” by Therese Anne Fowler. It’s a page turner, well-written, entertaining and informative, and often hasn’t yet been read.
- “We Should All Be Feminists” by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
- “The Women” by Kristin Hannah
- “The Fury” by Alex Michaelides
Pennsylvania
Criminal charges for climate pollution? Some argue a Pa. law would apply
While Braman agrees it would be difficult to take on as a prosecutor, he said that could change as more young people move into positions of influence.
“As the catastrophes escalate and as young people who face their entire future in an environment dominated by increasing climate harms, [and] start to join the jury pool, start to become prosecutors, start to become judges and start to become shareholders, I think that the writing’s on the wall,” Braman said, “and I hope that everybody, including everyone inside fossil fuel companies, starts to pay attention to that.”
But Weber said prosecutors would still have to convince a judge or jury to convict beyond a reasonable doubt.
Fossil fuel companies have permits to conduct their business, essentially government permission to do what they are doing, another way for the company to defend itself in court.
If the companies are charged and convicted of risking or causing a catastrophe, the fines are in the range of $15,000 to $25,000 per count, Weber said.
“Is that going to deter a multimillion dollar company? Is that going to interfere with the operation of their business and the money that they’re making? I don’t think so,” Weber said. “I mean, did Energy Transfer go out of business by that criminal prosecution?”
“Maybe you put the CEO in jail,” Weber said. “And do you think that the other fossil fuel companies are going to say, ‘That guy went to jail, so we shouldn’t do what we’re doing anymore’? No, they’re going to do what drug dealers do. Drug dealers say, ‘Well, that guy got caught for drug dealing because he’s stupid. We’re not stupid.’”
‘Win by losing’
Environmental attorney Rich Raiders said there are a lot of questions with the strategy, but says the article does serve an important purpose.
“The idea behind these articles isn’t necessarily to come to an answer, but to get people to start thinking about how to address a question. And in that respect, it does that and it does it well,” Raiders said.
Raiders represented homeowners who sued Energy Transfer over the Mariner East pipeline construction. He said a case like this would be a battle of the experts, but there are fundamental questions the article does not address about whether the charges would stick.
“What do you have to show responsible for climate change to meet the definition of a catastrophe?” Raiders said. “What is that level of threshold that you have to show before you can write a complaint that actually can survive objections? And how do you prove that it was the fossil fuel emissions caused by the marketing aspects of these companies to get you far enough that you can meet this definition? We don’t know.”
Raiders said the goal of this type of prosecution could be to get a large settlement, similar to what happened with the tobacco companies settlement or a previously proposed Sackler family settlement over opioids.
In that case, it makes sense to bring a case where you “win by losing.”
“And maybe that’s what a case like this does. It’s not necessarily to win the case, but it’s to move the needle,” Raiders said.
For example, he said it could get the legislature to take action. But it also requires someone willing to lose.
“I think this is an interesting discussion in the long term for how to get people to think about the problem,” Raiders said. “And as a thought piece it does have some merit. But will you see something like that filed in the next 12 months? No, not anytime soon.”
Braman, one of the co-authors of the piece, is more optimistic.
“We desperately need some kind of solution that will allow the public to hold these massive corporate criminal actors accountable and have them really address the harms that they’re generating,” he said.
Pennsylvania
Cash reward offered for information leading to Pennsylvania cold case homicide resolution
LEBANON COUNTY, Pa. (WHTM) — A cash reward is being offered for anyone who has information surrounding a 2021 cold case homicide in Lebanon County.
The $2,000 reward is for anyone who has information that can solve the case of the death of 35-year-old Zachary Lauderman, according to State Police.
Lauderman was found dead with two gunshot wounds to his head in his home, located along Ulsh lane in Bethel Township Sept. 10 just before 3 p.m., according to Troopers.
Anyone who knows something is asked to contact PSP Tips at 1-800-4PA-TIPS (8477), or they can go online to submit a tip by clicking here.
-
Sports1 week ago
The top out-of-contract players available as free transfers: Kimmich, De Bruyne, Van Dijk…
-
Politics1 week ago
New Orleans attacker had 'remote detonator' for explosives in French Quarter, Biden says
-
Politics1 week ago
Carter's judicial picks reshaped the federal bench across the country
-
Politics7 days ago
Who Are the Recipients of the Presidential Medal of Freedom?
-
Health6 days ago
Ozempic ‘microdosing’ is the new weight-loss trend: Should you try it?
-
News1 week ago
21 states are getting minimum wage bumps in 2025
-
World1 week ago
South Korea extends Boeing 737-800 inspections as Jeju Air wreckage lifted
-
Technology2 days ago
Meta is highlighting a splintering global approach to online speech