Pennsylvania
The nation is watching Gov. Shapiro; he should lead on educational freedom in Pennsylvania | Opinion
By Charles Mitchell
The state has a public education system with students trapped in failing schools. The governor wants to create the school choice funding they need to escape these schools. However, the governor’s own party in the state House refuses to pass such a proposal despite its popularity, resulting in a legislative stalemate.
For Pennsylvanians, this story is familiar. But it’s also familiar to Texans. There are striking similarities between Pennsylvania Gov. Josh Shapiro and Texas Gov. Greg Abbott and their struggles to pass their education agendas into law—but one huge difference is their approach to leadership.
Just like Shapiro, Abbott endorsed educational freedom throughout his political career. Abbott publicly stated school choice is his top legislative priority, even declaring it an “emergency item” in his 2023 State of the State address.
Just like in Pennsylvania, school choice is popular and widely supported in the Lone Star State. A recent survey shows 58 percent of Texans support Abott’s Education Savings Account (ESA) proposal.
“Empowering parents to choose the best educational path for their child remains an essential priority this session,” said Abbott in a press release. “A majority of Texans from across the state and from all backgrounds support expanding school choice.”
The Texas House leadership, like Pennsylvania’s, let politics get in the way of improving and expanding educational opportunities. Though not as combative as Pennsylvania House Majority Leader Matt Bradford, Texas House Speaker Dade Phelan has been far less supportive of school choice than his governor likes.
Here’s where our protagonists have handled adversity differently. Two roads diverged in the woods, and these two governors took different paths—and that’s making all the difference.
Abbott plays hardball with legislators. The Texas governor vetoed occupational licensing legislation, writing in his proclamation, “This bill can be reconsidered at a future special session only after education freedom is passed.”
Rather than sit back and wait for the next legislative session, Abbott called a special 30-day legislative session with a limited agenda: pass the ESA bill. Sadly, this type of bold leadership—what Pennsylvanians need and want—is absent in the Keystone State.
Abbott’s actions starkly contrast with Shapiro’s. Rather than double down on his campaign promise, Shapiro line-item vetoed the very program he publicly endorsed: Lifeline Scholarships, known as the Pennsylvania Award for Student Success (PASS). The Lifeline Scholarship/PASS Program will provide Educational Opportunity Accounts to kids stuck in the lowest-performing schools.
Shapiro chose political expediency over student achievement. But Shapiro’s flip-flop disrupted the 2023–24 state budget negotiations. Already past the deadline, Pennsylvania’s budget remains unfinished amid Shapiro’s uninspiring efforts to speed things along.
Rather than act, Shapiro has passed the buck, blaming the budget impasse on a “divided legislature” and calling Lifeline Scholarships/PASS “unfinished business” for legislators to handle.
While the Pennsylvania legislature remained in recess and the budget impasse continued, Shapiro didn’t pressure the legislature to return to work. Instead, he went on a self-promotion tour, bragging about the quick turnaround rebuilding I-95 and headlining an out-of-state convention. When legislators returned to finalize the budget with the fiscal code bills (which now include Lifeline Scholarships/PASS in the Senate-approved version), Shapiro remained absent.
The scuttlebutt is Shapiro wants to run for president.
However, if Shapiro aspires to break through on the national level, he had better recognize that everybody is keeping a close eye on what he does in Pennsylvania. The Associated Press published an article that described Shapiro as “a rising political star” and highlighted how his support for Lifeline Scholarships/PASS crosses “the partisan school choice divide.”
This article was syndicated in more than 200 publications nationwide. Suffice it to say, the nation has its eye on Shapiro.
Shapiro could make national headlines by delivering educational freedom. By signing Lifeline Scholarships/PASS into law, he would be the first Democratic governor to defy traditional party lines and sign significant school choice legislation into law. Shapiro has a unique opportunity to reset his legislative strategy and produce something that would truly raise his national profile.
Shapiro could learn a thing or two from Abbott. As they say in Texas, let’s take this bull by the horns.
Charles Mitchell is president and CEO of the Commonwealth Foundation, Pennsylvania’s free-market think tank.
Pennsylvania
Books and coffee? Both shine at Pressed in Erie, Pennsylvania
Independent bookstores are the heartbeats of their communities. They provide culture and community, generate local jobs and sales tax revenue, promote literacy and education, champion and center diverse and new authors, connect readers to books in a personal and authentic way, and actively support the right to read and access to books in their communities.
Each week we profile an independent bookstore, sharing what makes each one special and getting their expert and unique book recommendations.
This week we have Pressed in Erie, Pennsylvania!
What’s your store’s story?
Founded in Erie, Pennsylvania in 2018, our goal is to encourage others to step away from their device and enjoy the feel, smell, and look of a book, paired with a comforting coffee. We love it when customers take their time checking out what’s new (or old!), and have a lovely time reconnecting with their senses as they explore the books and gifts in our shop.
What makes your independent bookstore unique?
Customers love the vibe in our store. It’s modern and upbeat, but with good old-fashioned books in the spotlight! They’re encouraged to take their coffee or warm drink (from our full-service coffee shop) and explore.
We’re known for a curated but wide variety of reading genres, along with fun literary gifts (staff take real pleasure in hearing customers laugh out loud as they peruse the store), as well as our large kids’ area, with our famous reading tree. We’re proud to do our part to make Erie a vibrant and interesting city, something more than just a cluster of big-box stores.
What’s your favorite section in your store?
My favorite section is the front, where all the best displays are and where we greet our customers. But a close second is the kids’ room — the reading tree and the moss-covered cobblestone look of the carpet are so inviting!
Why is shopping at local, independent bookstores important?
People vote for what they want in their community with their dollars. If they like having indie bookstores in their town, they simply must spend money there. Spending money elsewhere is exactly like submitting a vote for the indie to close. As long as people understand what they’re doing when they choose not to shop local, I have no problem with it. But if people want that local shop to stay, because it adds value and personality to their town and because they enjoy shopping there, they have to be okay with spending a few extra dollars on a book there. That’s the bottom line.
Check out these books recommended from Pressed owner, Tracey Bowes:
- “Z: A Novel of Zelda Fitzgerald” by Therese Anne Fowler. It’s a page turner, well-written, entertaining and informative, and often hasn’t yet been read.
- “We Should All Be Feminists” by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie
- “The Women” by Kristin Hannah
- “The Fury” by Alex Michaelides
Pennsylvania
Criminal charges for climate pollution? Some argue a Pa. law would apply
While Braman agrees it would be difficult to take on as a prosecutor, he said that could change as more young people move into positions of influence.
“As the catastrophes escalate and as young people who face their entire future in an environment dominated by increasing climate harms, [and] start to join the jury pool, start to become prosecutors, start to become judges and start to become shareholders, I think that the writing’s on the wall,” Braman said, “and I hope that everybody, including everyone inside fossil fuel companies, starts to pay attention to that.”
But Weber said prosecutors would still have to convince a judge or jury to convict beyond a reasonable doubt.
Fossil fuel companies have permits to conduct their business, essentially government permission to do what they are doing, another way for the company to defend itself in court.
If the companies are charged and convicted of risking or causing a catastrophe, the fines are in the range of $15,000 to $25,000 per count, Weber said.
“Is that going to deter a multimillion dollar company? Is that going to interfere with the operation of their business and the money that they’re making? I don’t think so,” Weber said. “I mean, did Energy Transfer go out of business by that criminal prosecution?”
“Maybe you put the CEO in jail,” Weber said. “And do you think that the other fossil fuel companies are going to say, ‘That guy went to jail, so we shouldn’t do what we’re doing anymore’? No, they’re going to do what drug dealers do. Drug dealers say, ‘Well, that guy got caught for drug dealing because he’s stupid. We’re not stupid.’”
‘Win by losing’
Environmental attorney Rich Raiders said there are a lot of questions with the strategy, but says the article does serve an important purpose.
“The idea behind these articles isn’t necessarily to come to an answer, but to get people to start thinking about how to address a question. And in that respect, it does that and it does it well,” Raiders said.
Raiders represented homeowners who sued Energy Transfer over the Mariner East pipeline construction. He said a case like this would be a battle of the experts, but there are fundamental questions the article does not address about whether the charges would stick.
“What do you have to show responsible for climate change to meet the definition of a catastrophe?” Raiders said. “What is that level of threshold that you have to show before you can write a complaint that actually can survive objections? And how do you prove that it was the fossil fuel emissions caused by the marketing aspects of these companies to get you far enough that you can meet this definition? We don’t know.”
Raiders said the goal of this type of prosecution could be to get a large settlement, similar to what happened with the tobacco companies settlement or a previously proposed Sackler family settlement over opioids.
In that case, it makes sense to bring a case where you “win by losing.”
“And maybe that’s what a case like this does. It’s not necessarily to win the case, but it’s to move the needle,” Raiders said.
For example, he said it could get the legislature to take action. But it also requires someone willing to lose.
“I think this is an interesting discussion in the long term for how to get people to think about the problem,” Raiders said. “And as a thought piece it does have some merit. But will you see something like that filed in the next 12 months? No, not anytime soon.”
Braman, one of the co-authors of the piece, is more optimistic.
“We desperately need some kind of solution that will allow the public to hold these massive corporate criminal actors accountable and have them really address the harms that they’re generating,” he said.
Pennsylvania
Cash reward offered for information leading to Pennsylvania cold case homicide resolution
LEBANON COUNTY, Pa. (WHTM) — A cash reward is being offered for anyone who has information surrounding a 2021 cold case homicide in Lebanon County.
The $2,000 reward is for anyone who has information that can solve the case of the death of 35-year-old Zachary Lauderman, according to State Police.
Lauderman was found dead with two gunshot wounds to his head in his home, located along Ulsh lane in Bethel Township Sept. 10 just before 3 p.m., according to Troopers.
Anyone who knows something is asked to contact PSP Tips at 1-800-4PA-TIPS (8477), or they can go online to submit a tip by clicking here.
-
Business1 week ago
These are the top 7 issues facing the struggling restaurant industry in 2025
-
Culture1 week ago
The 25 worst losses in college football history, including Baylor’s 2024 entry at Colorado
-
Sports1 week ago
The top out-of-contract players available as free transfers: Kimmich, De Bruyne, Van Dijk…
-
Politics1 week ago
New Orleans attacker had 'remote detonator' for explosives in French Quarter, Biden says
-
Politics1 week ago
Carter's judicial picks reshaped the federal bench across the country
-
Politics6 days ago
Who Are the Recipients of the Presidential Medal of Freedom?
-
Health5 days ago
Ozempic ‘microdosing’ is the new weight-loss trend: Should you try it?
-
World1 week ago
Ivory Coast says French troops to leave country after decades