Connect with us

News

Despite Trump’s Claims, Footage Shows Large Crowd at Harris’s Detroit Rally

Published

on

Despite Trump’s Claims, Footage Shows Large Crowd at Harris’s Detroit Rally

Kellen Browning/The New York Times

Former President Donald J. Trump claimed without evidence on Sunday that his rival in the 2024 presidential election, Vice President Kamala Harris, had used artificial intelligence to doctor or create an image of a rally that showed a large crowd in Detroit last week.

“She ‘A.I.’d’ it, and showed a massive ‘crowd’ of so-called followers, BUT THEY DIDN’T EXIST!” Mr. Trump wrote on his social networking site, Truth Social.

Three reporters from The New York Times who attended the Michigan rally confirmed that the crowd numbered in the thousands, contrary to Mr. Trump’s assertion that “there was nobody there.” A Times analysis of photos and videos of the event also showed that Mr. Trump’s claims about the size of the crowd were unfounded. Other images and videos from multiple vantage points showed a large audience.

Advertisement

Graphic by The New York Times; aerial image by NearMap

Crowd size is often a point of comparison between candidates, but Mr. Trump has now given it more intense focus.

A Harris campaign official told The Times by email that the original photo in question was taken by a campaign staff member and was not modified by artificial intelligence.

The crowd was packed tightly inside the airplane hangar. Some attendees waited for Ms. Harris’s arrival on elevated platforms that gave them a higher vantage point, but a majority stood on the floor. From some angles at the back of the hangar where reporters were positioned, it was difficult to gauge how far the crowd extended.

Advertisement

Rally attendees watched as Air Force Two landed on the tarmac.

Julia Nikhinson/Associated Press

But by moving over to a nearby riser that faced the open door of the hangar, Times reporters could see the size of the crowd more clearly. It stretched beyond the hangar, spilling out onto the tarmac beyond — not far from where Air Force Two came to a stop.

Supporters inside the hangar as Gov. Tim Walz addressed the crowd.

Advertisement

Brittany Greeson for The New York Times

Attendees crowded near the stage as Ms. Harris spoke.

Jeff Kowalsky/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Advertisement

As Ms. Harris spoke, crowds that could not fit inside the hangar viewed her speech on screens along the tarmac.

Jeff Kowalsky/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

Ms. Harris’s X account streamed the rally, with the first few minutes panning over the crowd as Air Force Two arrived. The Harris campaign later posted on X that the image reflected what the campaign said was 15,000 attendees, and it also responded to Trump’s post with a video of the crowds as Air Force Two arrived at the Detroit Metro Airport.

Posts calling into question the authenticity of the crowd photo, and of the size of Ms. Harris’s audience, had already begun to bubble up among far-right Trump supporters before Mr. Trump seized on it. Mr. Trump’s Truth Social post included a screenshot of an X post by Chuck Callesto, calling the crowd image “FAKE.”

Advertisement

Mr. Callesto is a conservative social media strategist who has frequently posted falsehoods and “Stop the Steal” content about the 2020 election. Laura Loomer, a right-wing activist whom Mr. Trump wanted to hire for a role on his campaign, posted multiple times about the photo, and Joe Hoft, a far-right blogger, wrote a post about it.

Before Ms. Harris’s rally, Mr. Trump had already been focused on comparing crowd sizes at her rallies with those at his own. He said during one of his campaign speeches that Ms. Harris had drawn crowds because she had entertainment and that he did not need to do the same to attract attendees.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

News

Live news: Scientists discover liquid water in the crust of Mars

Published

on

Live news: Scientists discover liquid water in the crust of Mars

Scientists have discovered liquid water deep in the crust of Mars, a breakthrough that suggests life could have existed on the planet.

“Large volumes of liquid water transiently existed on the surface of Mars more than 3 billion years ago,” said a paper published on Monday in PNAS, a journal published by the US National Academy of Sciences.

The authors of the paper analysed data from Nasa’s Mars Insight Lander, which arrived on the planet in 2018 and stayed until the end of 2022. It measured seismic movements to determine the presence of liquid water billions of years ago.

“Our results have implications for understanding Mars’ water cycle, determining the fates of past surface water [and] searching for past or extant life,” the authors wrote.

Continue Reading

News

Costco says it's going to start cracking down on membership sharing

Published

on

Costco says it's going to start cracking down on membership sharing

A customer loads a pickup truck after shopping at a Costco store on July 11 in Richmond, Calif.

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Are you craving that $1.50 hot-dog-and-soda combo from Costco? Be sure to have your own membership card handy.

Over the coming months, shoppers will have to start scanning their membership cards at the entrances to Costco warehouses rather than just presenting them to a store employee, the retail giant announced.

The Washington-based company is the latest to crack down on membership sharing, as businesses seek to prevent consumers from glomming onto their friends’ and families’ paid accounts without forking over membership fees themselves.

Advertisement

Costco members with active memberships will have to scan their physical or digital cards at a machine at the store’s entrance. Members who have cards without a photo will have to show a valid photo ID, and guests will only be able to enter a Costco store with an active member.

“If you have any questions or concerns, there will always be an attendant at the door to assist you!” Costco said in a statement.

Costco isn’t the only company out to stop some consumers from getting a free ride. Disney recently announced that it would start blocking Disney+ account holders from sharing their passwords to the streaming service outside their households.

A similar move by Netflix last year led to an uptick in subscribers but may also have damaged the company’s reputation, Fast Company reported.

Costco executive Richard Galanti told MarketWatch in January that the company was aiming to prevent nonmembers from dodging fees by using a member’s card to shop, an issue that emerged after the company introduced self-checkout lines.

Advertisement

Costco relaxed the enforcement of its rules during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, Galanti said, when people asked others to shop for them to avoid going outside.

In response to the problem, the company announced that it would begin asking customers in self-checkout lines — in addition to regular checkout lines — to show their membership cards and a photo ID.

Costco has 128 million members and reported that it earned $4.6 billion in revenue from membership fees last year.

Costco’s annual membership fees are set to increase beginning in September, from $60 to $65 for Gold Star members and from $120 to $130 for Executive members.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

News

Muhammad Yunus calls for Bangladesh free speech and independent judiciary

Published

on

Muhammad Yunus calls for Bangladesh free speech and independent judiciary

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

Bangladesh’s new interim leader Muhammad Yunus has said the country of 170mn must reform its judiciary and ensure freedom of speech in order to fix the “complete mess” left by toppled prime minister Sheikh Hasina.

The Nobel Peace Prize-winning economist hailed as a “revolution” the ousting of Sheikh Hasina, who fled last week after a popular uprising against her authoritarian rule over Bangladesh, the world’s second-largest garments exporter.

“The monster is gone,” Yunus told foreign journalists in a briefing in the Bangladeshi capital Dhaka.

Advertisement

An estimated 500 people have been killed since Sheikh Hasina last month ordered a crackdown on student protesters, triggering anger that ultimately toppled her government and provoked a wave of retaliatory attacks. Police have mostly gone into hiding, with security on Dhaka’s streets temporarily taken over by the military and student volunteers. 

Yunus said his most urgent task was to restore law and order “so that people can sit down or get to work”, but that he hoped to turn to broader reforms. “The opposition, young people always are talking: ‘There is no freedom of speech’,” he said. “Give them the freedom of speech.”

The 84-year-old added that ensuring “the independence of the judiciary” was another priority.

Sheikh Hasina, who had ruled Bangladesh since 2009, claimed to have brought development to what had been one of the world’s poorest countries. Her critics accused her government of corruption, rights abuses, rigging elections and stacking the judiciary with loyalists from her Awami League.

Chief justice Obaidul Hassan, the head of Bangladesh’s judiciary, resigned at the weekend following new demonstrations against him by student protesters.

Advertisement

Yunus, who was celebrated internationally for founding microfinance pioneer Grameen Bank, was subject to a barrage of investigations under Sheikh Hasina that his supporters called a vendetta.

Yunus said he only agreed to lead the interim government because student protest leaders asked him to. He has two students in his new cabinet, and Yunus said they should play an even greater role. “Every ministry should have a student,” he said.

Yet he faces considerable obstacles in implementing his agenda. Legal experts debate how long his administration should be in power, with opinions ranging anywhere from three months to three years.

Opposition groups such as the Bangladesh Nationalist party are demanding new elections. And the Awami League is seeking to regroup following its routing last week.

The former prime minister’s son Sajeeb Wazed told the Financial Times that his mother, who is currently in neighbouring India, wanted to return to Bangladesh.

Advertisement

“We are waiting to see how things unfold in Bangladesh and her hope is that at some point she will be able to go back,” Wazed said in a video interview from the US. He said Sheikh Hasina had not requested asylum in a third country.

Wazed denied his mother was responsible for the violence against protesters and said she was “absolutely” ready to face charges if it came to that “because she did nothing illegal”. 

Wazed also attacked Yunus’s interim government, saying it was “an unconstitutional government. There is no democracy in Bangladesh right now.”

Yunus told foreign journalists that Sheikh Hasina’s rule left “a mess, complete mess . . . Whatever they did, just simply doesn’t make sense to me”.

But he acknowledged the early euphoria around his leadership might not last. “The moment you start taking decisions, some people will like your decisions, some people will not like your decisions,” he said.

Advertisement

“I’m doing this because this is what the youth of the country wanted, and I wanted to help them to do it. It’s not my dream, it’s their dream.”

Continue Reading

Trending