Ohio
$750 for body cam video? Ohio police agencies set steep prices after law change
See Ohio trooper rescue kitten from drain pipe in Columbus
Body camera footage shows the moments when an Ohio State Highway Patrol trooper saved a kitten that was trapped in a drain pipe.
Some Central Ohio police agencies will now charge the public up to $750 for officer body and dash-cam footage under a new law signed by Gov. Mike DeWine in January.
The law that took effect in April gives Ohio’s law enforcement agencies discretion to charge up to $75 per hour for video records, including body camera and dashboard camera footage and surveillance video, with total fees per request capped at $750.
The law allows individual agencies to decide whether to charge fees and set their own rates. Central Ohio agencies that spoke with The Dispatch said they are still deciding whether to impose fees. Police in Grove City, Reynoldsburg and Whitehall have already set new fee schedules, charging as much as the new law allows.
Media outlets often use body camera footage to provide insight into critical incidents involving police, including shootings. Critics, including media groups and civil rights organizations, have argued that increased fees for body camera videos could hinder transparency and give policing leaders the ability to pick and choose what the public sees.
ACLU says body cam fees ‘financially impossible’
“It shouldn’t depend on how much money Ohioans have in their pocket to be able to enjoy access to public records,” Gary Daniels, chief lobbyist for the ACLU of Ohio, said.
Daniels said the ACLU of Ohio has grave concerns about the new law, which “sets a bad precedent” and will impede access to records. He added that many police agencies will likely charge the max for records, and it will become “financially impossible” for smaller news organizations to access footage.
Body camera footage is important for the public to access because it sheds light on sometimes hotly-contested moments in which police and witnesses disagree on events, such as when officers fire their guns or are killed in the line of duty.
On the other hand, compiling the footage is expensive and time-consuming for police agencies to produce. Some portions of the videos must be redacted to comply with state laws, including limiting images of uncharged suspects and crime victims. Many police agencies receive large volumes of requests; the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office fielded 400-500 requests for videos last year, spokeswoman Tracy Whited said.
The law allows agencies to recoup pay for employees who redact and produce the videos, as well as video storage fees, redaction software costs, and other expenses.
Ohio police departments say body cam footage review takes time, money
Grove City adopted its new policy on June 13, according to a copy provided to the Dispatch. The Grove City Police Department will charge a flat $10 base fee per video record to cover costs of redaction software and video storage, with maximum fees capped at $75 per hour of footage and $750 per video.
The requester must pay the estimated fee upfront before Grove City will produce the records. For “certain critical incidents,” the Grove City police chief may choose to release footage at no cost, according to the policy.
The Reynoldsburg Police Department’s policy, adopted March 12, says it will release footage of any incident in which an officer fires a gun without charge. Other videos cost up to $75 per hour or up to $750 per request.
Requesters must pay a $75 deposit to the Reynoldsburg police before the department will begin redacting the footage.
The Whitehall Division of Police states in its fee schedule that video footage costs $75 per hour or $1.25 per minute, with a maximum fee of $750 per request.
The Ohio State Highway Patrol, the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office, the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office, and police in Columbus, Gahanna, Hilliard, Dublin, New Albany, Grandview Heights and Upper Arlington stated that they have not made any changes to their fee schedules. Several of those agencies said they are still reviewing the new law.
Whited said body camera footage requests make up the bulk of the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office records department’s workload and have caused a significant backlog, leading the sheriff’s office to consider outsourcing some of the work to a third party.
But hiring a private company would be expensive, and the sheriff’s office would prefer to keep doing the work “in-house,” Whited added.
Whited said the unit often watches videos three times: once to check for visuals that need to be redacted, a second time to review the audio, and a third time to ensure nothing was missed. That means a half-hour of footage could take over an hour and a half to edit.
In other cases, a less complex 15-minute video might take about 20 minutes to redact one segment of footage. Most of the videos are about 30-45 minutes long.
Currently, the sheriff’s office has software that can track objects in footage that need to be redacted, like a piece of paper with a social security number or a child’s face. Sometimes, for unknown reasons, the tracking fails, and staff must redact frame by frame, Whited said.
The sheriff’s office hasn’t received any quotes for outsourcing the video redaction process, but it did request one for an AI redaction service to speed up its staff’s work. That quote came to $30,000-$35,000 for 120 hours of raw video and gave the sheriff’s office “sticker shock,” Whited said.
Setting new fees while the backlog is in place presents some challenges. The requesters already waiting on records can’t be charged, and telling new requesters they must pay fees, then informing them they must also wait 4-5 months to receive the footage “doesn’t seem like good customer service,” Whited said.
The Delaware County Sheriff’s Office is speaking with prosecutors and reviewing other Ohio police departments policies before coming to a decision, Whited said.
“There’s a lot of things we’re still looking at before we could implement it,” Whited said.
Columbus police spokeswoman Nicole Jaros said the division is still developing a policy in response to the new law. The division currently charges $1 per CD for records and does not typically charge for records provided in digital formats, such as email attachments.
Gahanna spokesman Dan Pearlman said the city doesn’t currently charge for video.
“We continue to research and discuss this with area agencies to see if there is a standardized approach,” Pearlman said in an email.
New Albany Police Department records supervisor Laura White said the department is considering charging fees and will likely do so.
YouTube creators, bloggers increase demand
The department doesn’t just field requests from traditional journalists or local citizens, White said. Many of the requests come from YouTube channels or other social media content creators.
Numerous YouTube channels and social media pages upload large volumes of police footage, publishing viral videos of traffic stops, shootings and embarrassing DUI arrests.
“We get inundated with requests from … YouTube and social media outlets that are looking for a wide range of information and records,” White said. “It’s very time-consuming.”
In March, the Columbus Division of Police fired Officer Spencer Badger, who runs the ‘Columbus Police Body Camera’ YouTube channel. The division said he violated policy by downloading some videos himself instead of submitting public information requests.
Daniels said the new law may have been introduced as a response to bulk requests from bloggers, YouTube channels, and other organizations that publish large amounts of videos, and he understands that those requests pose a burden.
But Daniels said those concerns could have been better addressed in other ways, like limiting the number of requests one entity could make per month. The ACLU wouldn’t be “thrilled” by that, either, he said, but it would be better than restricting access across the board.
“It’s hard to believe a compromise couldn’t be reached,” Daniels said.
Public Safety and Breaking News Reporter Bailey Gallion can be reached at bagallion@dispatch.com.
Ohio
Papa Johns employee in Ohio accused of shooting, killing man inside store
An employee of a Papa Johns restaurant in Cincinnati, Ohio, is accused of shooting and killing a man inside the store on Tuesday night.
Police in Cincinnati said Murphy Tilk, 21, fatally shot 23-year-old Nawaf Althawadi inside the West Price Hill restaurant around 11 p.m., CBS affiliate WKRC reported. When first responders arrived at the restaurant on West Eighth Street, they performed life-saving measures on Althawadi, who died at the scene. Officials said the 21-year-old Tilk, who was taken into custody without incident and charged, is a Papa Johns employee, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer.
Tilk booked into the Hamilton County Justice Center on a first-degree murder charge, the center’s records show. During Tilk’s initial court appearance on Wednesday, he was held without bond. The 21-year-old man has a bond hearing set for Saturday.
Law enforcement has not said what led up to the shooting or if Tilk and Althawadi knew each other. Police are investigating the shooting.
KDKA reached out to Papa Johns on Wednesday evening for comment, but has not heard back.
Papa Johns is a pizza chain with 6,000 locations globally, according to its website. It has 15 locations in Cincinnati.
Ohio
Ohio State Falls to No. 13 Illinois, 88-80, Despite Best Efforts of Bruce Thornton
Bruce Thornton’s best efforts weren’t enough.
Ohio State’s longtime star guard delivered another signature performance in his team’s uphill climb against No. 13 Illinois on Tuesday. Thornton racked up 34 points on 13-of-17 shooting, his second 30-point performance of the season. But he was still just a man. The Fighting Illini had a flight of well-coordinated, sharp-shooting soldiers.
| TEAM | 1 | 2 | FINAL |
|---|---|---|---|
| #13 ILLINOIS | 48 | 40 | 88 |
| OHIO STATE | 42 | 38 | 80 |
Illinois (8-2, 1-0 Big Ten) led the final 16 minutes of its 88-80 win over Ohio State (8-2, 1-1), keeping the Buckeyes at arm’s length most of the way despite only twice leading by double-digits.
Four Illini reached double-figures. Freshman guard Keaton Wagler paced the squad with 23 points, trailed closely by fellow guard Andrej Stojakovic (17 points) and forward David Mirkovic (22 points). Center Zvonimir Ivisic added 13 points.
Devin Royal, Christoph Tilly and John Mobley Jr. all hit double figures for Ohio State to join Thornton, but did so at the cost of a combined 12-of-36 shooting (33.3%) and 2-of-16 from 3 (12.5%). Tilly fouled out of the game in the final minute.
First Half
| ILLINOIS | STAT | OHIO STATE |
|---|---|---|
| 88 | POINTS | 80 |
| 24-54 (44.4%) | FGM-FGA (PCT.) | 28-61 (45.9%) |
| 11-27 (40.7%) | 3PM-3PA (PCT.) | 9-28 (32.1%) |
| 29-32 (90.6%) | FTM-FTA (PCT.) | 15-21 (71.4%) |
| 9 | TURNOVERS | 6 |
| 37 | TOTAL REBOUNDS | 30 |
| 9 | OFFENSIVE REBOUNDS | 7 |
| 28 | DEFENSIVE REBOUNDS | 23 |
| 15 | BENCH POINTS | 2 |
| 3 | BLOCKS | 2 |
| 0 | STEALS | 3 |
| 12 | ASSISTS | 11 |
Bruce Thornton and Christoph Tilly worked to keep Ohio State afloat in the early stretches.
Thornton drained a trio of triples, stepping into two in transition, including a contested look at least seven feet beyond the arc. Tilly opened the game’s scoring with an offensive rebound he stuck back, then showcased a nice arsenal of dribble moves and spins to attack the basket, drawing a foul once and making a layup another time.
But the Illinois shooters were orange hot. The Illini drained four consecutive 3-point attempts, three from Mirkovic and one from Ivisic, to charge ahead 24-15. Thornton answered with a corner 3 off an inbounds pass and a steal for a coast-to-coast layup, then the Illini strung together four points to push their lead back to eight.
Thornton remained undeterred. He rose above a strong contest for a baseline jumper, pump-faked an Illinois defender to make him fly by to drain another 3-pointer. Then he flew past a defender for a transition layup and canned another triple from the left wing to give Ohio State its first lead in more than 11 minutes at 34-33.
Chants of “Bruce” rang about the Schottenstein Center as the crowd got to its loudest volume of the night, rising to get their star senior a standing ovation. Thornton scored 24 points in the first half and started 9-of-9 shooting, including a 6-of-6 mark from distance.
The momentum didn’t maintain. Illinois launched an 11-0 run capped by a circus 3-pointer from Wagler and carried a 48-42 lead into halftime, though Devin Royal beat the buzzer to get the deficit back to six for Ohio State.
Second Half
Thornton finally got a bit of sustained scoring support to start the second half. Brandon Noel made a 3-pointer, and John Mobley Jr. connected on two floaters in the lane before freshman forward Amare Bynum got on the board with a nice drive and finish. A gorgeous double-clutch layup by Thornton tied the ballgame at 53.
The Buckeyes went 3:17 without changing the number in their score column as Illinois pushed back ahead 61-56. Tilly picked up his fourth foul during the stretch, impacting Ohio State’s lineup, in a game laden with foul calls. A Wagler 3-pointer and two Ivisic free throws extended the Illini edge to 66-58.
Fouls piled up on both sides. Exchanges of free throws kept the margin relatively the same as both teams were in the double bonus midway through the period. Illinois proved far more efficient at that game, however. A spin into a floater by Stojakovic pushed the Illinois lead back to three scores again with under six minutes to play.
It bounced back and forth between a two- and three-score lead several more times for the Illini, each reextension feeling like a tiny dagger plunged into the Buckeyes’ collective heart.
Ohio State went to a full-court press in the final two minutes and chipped the lead back down to a single score on a layup by Devin Royal, which made it 79-76 with less than 75 seconds remaining. But a friendly bounce – for Illinois, that is – on a 3-pointer by Ivisic stuck one final dagger in at 82-76 with 45 seconds to play.
What’s Next?
Ohio State plays the first of back-to-back neutral-site games with power-conference opponents, taking on West Virginia in Cleveland on Saturday. Tipoff is at 8 p.m. on ESPNU.
Game Notes
- The Buckeyes held a “Teddy Bear Toss” at halftime, with fans throwing stuffed animals onto the court to donate to children through the Ronald McDonald House.
- Illinois shot 7-of-14 (50%) from 3 in the first half.
- The contest featured 48 total personal fouls called between the two teams.
- Ohio State is now 77-110 all-time against Illinois.
Ohio
When experience doesn’t clock out: seasoned Northeast Ohio leaders often reemerge in public service
CLEVELAND HEIGHTS, Ohio — Sharon Dumas had been retired for more than three years when Cleveland Heights’ Interim Mayor Tony Cuda tapped her this fall to be his interim city administrator.
The move followed a familiar solution that public entities turn to when facing challenges: bringing back experienced public servants with decades of institutional knowledge.
Dumas, who retired from Cleveland City Hall in 2022 after more than 40 years in public and private service, agreed to return through the end of Cuda’s interim term, which runs until Dec. 31. Her appointment was Cuda’s first official act after voters recalled Mayor Kahlil Seren in September.
The move comes as Cleveland Heights continues to navigate its transition to a strong-mayor form of government, marked by a contentious 2024 budget process and temporary spending plans earlier this year. Cuda said his priority is stabilizing operations and laying groundwork for a fiscally responsible 2026 budget.
Dumas brings deep experience in municipal finance and administration. She served as Cleveland’s finance director for 15 years and as chief of staff for five years under former Mayor Frank Jackson, managing the city’s $1.3 billion budget and overseeing major fiscal reforms.
Her return reflects a broader trend in Northeast Ohio: veteran leaders stepping back into public roles or consulting after retirement. Just a handful of examples include:
- Ken Silliman, former chief of staff to Cleveland mayors Michael White and Frank Jackson, later led the Gateway Economic Development Corp. and authored a book on stadium financing.
- Eric Gordon, who spent 12 years as CEO of Cleveland schools, now heads Positive Education Program after a stint at Cuyahoga Community College.
- Dan Horrigan, Akron’s former mayor, briefly served as Cleveland Heights city administrator earlier this year before resigning amid internal conflict.
- Jay Westbrook, a longtime Cleveland council member, works with Western Reserve Land Conservancy on housing stability and neighborhood revitalization.
- Lee Fisher, former Ohio attorney general and lieutenant governor under Gov. Ted Strickland, left Cleveland State University’s law school to become president of Baldwin Wallace University in July.
- Ronald Adrine, who served 36 years on Cleveland Municipal Court, remains active in justice reform through statewide committees and advocacy groups.
Dumas’ appointment underscores Cleveland Heights’ reliance on institutional knowledge as it seeks to restore trust and stabilize operations ahead of a pivotal election year.
-
Alaska4 days agoHowling Mat-Su winds leave thousands without power
-
Politics1 week agoTrump rips Somali community as federal agents reportedly eye Minnesota enforcement sweep
-
Ohio7 days ago
Who do the Ohio State Buckeyes hire as the next offensive coordinator?
-
News1 week agoTrump threatens strikes on any country he claims makes drugs for US
-
World1 week agoHonduras election council member accuses colleague of ‘intimidation’
-
Texas5 days agoTexas Tech football vs BYU live updates, start time, TV channel for Big 12 title
-
Iowa3 days agoMatt Campbell reportedly bringing longtime Iowa State staffer to Penn State as 1st hire
-
Miami, FL4 days agoUrban Meyer, Brady Quinn get in heated exchange during Alabama, Notre Dame, Miami CFP discussion