Michigan
Michigan Supreme Court upholds most of Benson’s changes for poll challengers guidance • Michigan Advance
![Michigan Supreme Court upholds most of Benson’s changes for poll challengers guidance • Michigan Advance Michigan Supreme Court upholds most of Benson’s changes for poll challengers guidance • Michigan Advance](https://michiganadvance.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/11/Vote-count-process-at-TCF-Center-scaled.jpg)
Most of the guidance on election challengers provided by Michigan Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson is legal and can be used for the upcoming Nov. 5 presidential election.
That’s after a 4-3 ruling Wednesday from the Michigan Supreme Court, which decided along party lines that Benson was not required to use the full rules-making process to issue guidance on the credentialing of election challengers and the procedures by which challenges could be reported.
Writing for the Democratic-nominated majority, Justice Kyra Harris Bolden noted Benson’s authority to set the guidelines.
“Under the Michigan Election Law, the secretary of state is the chief election officer of Michigan, and as such, the secretary has supervisory control over local election officials in the performance of their duties,” she wrote.
The decision brings to a close a legal battle that began in 2022 when a lawsuit was filed by two Republican legislative candidates and three Republicans who served as election challengers. They argued that new guidance issued by Benson violated Michigan election law by requiring polling places to have an election inspector designated as the “challenger liaison” through whom all challenges would be communicated. They further argued, among other issues, against a uniform credential form for challengers, and provisions permitting challengers to be ejected from polling sites if they fail to follow instructions.
The plaintiffs, which also included the Michigan Republican Party and Republican National Committee, additionally argued that the rule changes had not gone through the Administrative Procedures Act (APA), which provides for “processing, promulgation, publication, and inspection of state agency rules.”
In October, the Michigan Court of Appeals had agreed, ruling that the Secretary of State “must follow the requirements of the Michigan Administrative Procedure Act and that under the state law a department can set new rules only after it has gone through the public notice and comment process.”
In its opinion, however, the majority overturned that decision, noting exceptions written into the law exempting from the rulemaking process “a form with instructions, an interpretive statement, a guideline, an informational pamphlet, or other material that in itself does not have the force and effect of law but is merely explanatory.”
In a dissent, Republican-nominated Justice Brian Zahra said the majority opinion that the revisions to the guidelines were merely explanatory did not square with the fact that challenges by credentialed election challengers would be “subject to the arbitrary whim of the newly designated challenger liaison who is vested by the Secretary’s new rules with authority to deem a challenge “impermissible.” The Secretary’s revisions to the manual are, in fact, ‘rules’ that must be followed and followed without a trace of public discussion, accountability, or transparency.”
Benson, in a statement after the opinion was issued, said she was grateful the court had recognized her department’s legal responsibility to issue guidelines to clerks.
“As Michigan’s chief elections officer, the authority provided by the Legislature to issue uniform guidance to more than 1,600 clerks throughout the state is necessary to ensure every eligible voter can cast their ballot, while maintaining the security of our elections and the safety of our polling places,” said Benson.
“As our guidance has consistently made clear, challengers have a right to participate in the election process and they play an important role. But election officials have a responsibility to maintain order in the polling place and ensure voters can cast a ballot without interference. This clarity will help election officials, poll workers, challengers, and voters alike as we prepare for the November General Election and beyond. As always, we are committed to following the law as we administer accessible, secure, and transparent elections for Michigan citizens.”
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
![](https://newspub.live/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/np-logo.png)
Michigan
Scores show Michigan 3rd graders falling behind in English language arts, improving in math
![Scores show Michigan 3rd graders falling behind in English language arts, improving in math Scores show Michigan 3rd graders falling behind in English language arts, improving in math](https://assets1.cbsnewsstatic.com/hub/i/r/2024/08/29/06f2fadc-94f6-4a7e-aa88-3a0ec6351e23/thumbnail/1200x630/059d0b627b51cca0a944cba6b862f05b/gettyimages-1463651405.jpg?v=25685eaa472b1a5dbb5bd46ae506d232)
(CBS DETROIT) – The Michigan Department of Education released the 2024 results of the standard tests, M-STEP and SAT/PSAT, showing that some grade levels are falling behind in certain subjects.
The results showed that the percentage of students above or proficient in English language arts dropped for students in the third and fourth grades, according to a news release. While 40.9% of third graders tested above or proficient in ELA last year, that percentage dropped to 39.6% in 2024. Fourth graders also saw a decrease from 44.3% to 43.3%.
However, there were some improvements for third graders in math. Results show an increase from 42.9% above or proficient in 2023 to 43.4%.
When it comes to science and social studies, fifth and eighth graders saw improvements or remained steady. Meanwhile, 11th graders improved in social studies but declined in science.
State officials say the COVID-19 pandemic also impacted students’ progress. Results showed that 10% more students were proficient in math and reading when attending school in person than when attending school fully remotely.
“This year’s scores also show that, on average, being educated remotely during the 2020-21 school year rather than in-person during the pandemic affected progress,” said state Superintendent Michael Rice. “Being in the learning-to-read window – in preschool or early elementary grades – when COVID-19 hit also affected assessment results on average. Poverty, remoteness of instruction in the 2020-21 school year, and being in the learning-to-read window at the beginning of the pandemic have been layered challenges with which some of our children continue to struggle.”
Officials also say students who are economically disadvantaged have lower proficiency than students from middle-class backgrounds. The M-STEP results found that 27.3% of third-grade to seventh-grade students who are economically disadvantaged were proficient or advanced in ELA, while 57.6% of students not at an economic disadvantage were proficient.
Michigan
Column: Transferring in can be scary, but pushing past your comfort zone can help
![Column: Transferring in can be scary, but pushing past your comfort zone can help Column: Transferring in can be scary, but pushing past your comfort zone can help](https://snworksceo.imgix.net/cml/9c2e4dc4-6ead-4d13-9bc6-09b6f1686a13.sized-1000x1000.jpeg?w=800)
When I decided to transfer to Central Michigan University from Grand Rapids Community College in 2022, the college experience was still full of unknowns.
I had yet to have a college class in person due to COVID-19. I had never lived anywhere outside of home and was going to a place I had never been.
Everything was new, and something that I am not good at is change.
However, as I head into my last semester at CMU, I can’t imagine my life without the people I have met here. I have had access to so many opportunities that I would’ve never imagined if I stayed in my comfort zone.
The biggest piece of advice I would give incoming transfer students is to go out and find a job, RSO or club that fits your passion right when you arrive on campus.
When I arrived here, I knew two people at the university. One of those people steered me towards Central Michigan Life.
It was the first place I went when I got here, and it has been the most impactful place on campus for me.
I have met my best friends there, who have had such a big impact on me as a person.
I have been able to find so many opportunities, including covering football at Michigan State and Notre Dame, attending three MAC tournaments and developing my skills in audio and writing.
Now, that doesn’t mean that it hasn’t come with challenges. I felt extremely lonely and out of place when I got to campus. I lived off-campus and felt like it was so hard to meet new people.
I also felt behind. The people in my year had already gotten to know campus and had established friend groups.
I would have done anything to go back to where I was comfortable, working at a restaurant that I served at for five years and being back with my family and friends in Lowell.
But, if I gave up and didn’t push myself beyond my comfort zone, I wouldn’t have met my best friends. I wouldn’t have grown as a journalist and as a person.
Change is scary, and it comes with many challenges and obstacles that you will have to face, but I promise you it is worth it.
Get engaged on campus, go to sporting events, join a club that interests you and find events on campus. That is how I met some of the most important mentors and friends in my life, and you will too.
Don’t fear the unknown as you step onto a new campus. Instead, know that there are people in your corner who are going to cheer you on and there are places you belong.
You just have to take the jump.
Kaia Zimmerman is Central Michigan Life sports editor and summer news editor. The senior transfer student is slated to graduate in December 2024.
Michigan
As Michigan’s Connor Stalions saga wears on, some Big Ten foes are still simmering
![As Michigan’s Connor Stalions saga wears on, some Big Ten foes are still simmering As Michigan’s Connor Stalions saga wears on, some Big Ten foes are still simmering](https://cdn.theathletic.com/app/uploads/2024/08/26132003/USATSI_22069922-1.jpg)
As the NCAA continues to investigate Michigan’s role in an alleged sign-stealing operation run by former staffer Connor Stalions, no Big Ten coaches or administrators suggest the Wolverines’ national title is tainted or that their victories lack validity. But that doesn’t mean they are not angry, either.
The Athletic reached out to head coaches and assistants from at least five different Big Ten football programs spanning the former East and West Divisions for their thoughts on former Stalions and the team’s advance scouting scandal. In exchange for their candor, the coaches were given anonymity. None of the coaches volunteered to speak on the record, and none were from archrival Ohio State.
“I think their sign-stealing operation was a big deal,” said one assistant coach whose squad was impacted. “It cut at the integrity of the game. I know some people say it wasn’t a big advantage, but it was.
“On game day, as a coordinator, I don’t want to hear from anyone who doesn’t have valuable information pertaining to the game. Connor was talking directly to the coordinators. That tells you what he had to say was important. As far as Harbaugh is concerned, not a single head coach in the country would allow a ‘recruiting’ staff member to be talking to his coordinators on game day. Somehow, Connor was allowed to.”
Free, daily sports updates direct to your inbox.
Free, daily sports updates direct to your inbox.
Sign Up
Stalions’ work was considered pivotal enough to Michigan’s operation that former coach Jim Harbaugh awarded him a game ball following a 27-14 win at Iowa on Oct. 1, 2022. Stalions revealed the decorated ball to cameras in the Netflix documentary “Sign Stealer,” which was released Tuesday.
“The funny thing (Harbaugh) said after I got the game ball is, ‘Don’t get the big head, Connor,’” Stalions recalled in the documentary. “Getting this ball is a pretty cool moment in my life of just being acknowledged as doing a good job at what I do and helping Michigan win. I’ll remember it forever.”
The game ball was long rumored in Iowa City, especially as questions arose about Stalions. The documentary provided validation.
“I just heard about (the game ball footage in the documentary) maybe an hour ago, something like that, and got an email,” Iowa coach Kirk Ferentz said Tuesday in a news conference. “It’s so far out of mind — it’s history right now. Whatever happens, happens. The appropriate parties will deal with it.”
![go-deeper](https://cdn.theathletic.com/cdn-cgi/image/width=128,height=128,fit=cover,format=auto/app/uploads/2024/08/26163225/Untold_Sign_Stealer_00_07_02_08-1-1024x682.png)
GO DEEPER
Mandel: Don’t be fooled, Connor Stalions is not a victim in his own sign-stealing scheme
The 2022 game wasn’t the only time the spying scandal allegedly involved Iowa. Roughly four hours before the 2021 Big Ten championship game, a Big Ten coach called an Iowa staffer and issued a warning.
“Michigan has got all of your signals and calls,” the coach told the Iowa staffer. “I wished I’d gotten to you earlier.” That coach confirmed the context of that conversation to The Athletic. By then it was too late for Iowa to change its signals. Michigan dominated in every phase, blowing out the Hawkeyes 42-3 in Indianapolis.
This week, Michigan received a notice of allegations from the NCAA regarding Stalions and the football program’s alleged sign-stealing scheme. Stalions is accused of collecting film of opposing teams’ signals taken by people attending games around the country, which is against NCAA rules. Programs are allowed to review television footage or all-22 video but cannot conduct in-person advance scouting. In photos and game broadcasts, Stalions can be seen standing by the Michigan coordinators interpreting opponents’ signals during games (in-game deciphering of signals is not against NCAA rules).
![](https://cdn.theathletic.com/app/uploads/2024/07/22142320/USATSI_22001267-scaled.jpg)
Connor Stalions, right, was fired by Michigan for his part in a sign-stealing scheme (USA Today).
Neither Ferentz nor any other coaches suggest Stalions’ actions detract from Michigan’s victories. Last December, Michigan shut out Iowa 26-0 to claim its third consecutive Big Ten title, and that took place after Stalions’ resignation and after the Wolverines kept winning through a three-game suspension for Harbaugh imposed by the Big Ten. But throughout the conference, the vibe is clear: Coaches are upset that no controlling agency has held Michigan accountable.
“Based on the public info it’s surprising that there has been nothing adding to their penalty,” a second Big Ten assistant coach said. “I do believe there will be but the NCAA loses credibility when nothing is done or said and everyone is left wondering. Right now, the punishment does not fit the crime — there are more folks involved.”
There is nuance to Stalions’ actions, which a head coach explained. Most programs take television copies and game video and pair it with hand signals from the bench. Everyone wants an edge, he said, but scouting a future opponent in-person crosses the line. But, he added, schools also need to alter their signals more regularly, and teams can scout on the road in the NFL and high school.
Football espionage stories date to the game’s beginnings. According to one legend, former Northwestern assistant coach (and eventual New York Yankees owner) George Steinbrenner left for Purdue in 1956 and hired students in married student housing to watch the Wildcats’ practice. Northwestern coach Ara Parseghian (later of Notre Dame fame) found out and moved his main squad and left the junior varsity to practice in front of Purdue’s spies. Northwestern won 14-0.
Perhaps one day the Stalions story might join others in the somewhat harmless wing of conference lore and tall tales. But for now, there’s bitterness associated with the situation and a belief Michigan will receive preferential treatment.
“By nature, college football coaches don’t waste time on things that don’t have value,” the first assistant coach said. “The amount of time they spent on it tells you all you need to know.”
A different head coach just offered a verbal shrug.
“I guess it doesn’t matter now,” the coach said.
(Top photo: USA Today)
-
Connecticut6 days ago
Oxford church provides sanctuary during Sunday's damaging storm
-
Technology1 week ago
Breakthrough robo-glove gives you superhuman grip
-
News1 week ago
Ex-officer convicted in George Floyd's killing is moved to new prison
-
News1 week ago
Video: Protesters Clash With Police Near the Democratic National Convention
-
News1 week ago
Video: Biden Delivers Keynote on First Night of D.N.C.
-
News1 week ago
Video: D.N.C. Holds Enthusiastic Roll Call to Nominate Harris
-
Politics1 week ago
Former teacher reveals which students suffered 'the most' under Walz's pandemic-era guidelines
-
World1 week ago
Panama deports 29 Colombian migrants from Darien Gap under US deal