Connect with us

Movie Reviews

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World Film Review: Controlled Chaos

Published

on

Scott Pilgrim vs. the World Film Review: Controlled Chaos

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is Edgar Wright’s most chaotic film, but that does not mean it’s all style and no substance.


Director: Edgar Wright
Genre: Action, Comedy, Fantasy, Teen, Rom-Com
Run Time: 112′
U.S. Release: August 13, 2010
U.K. Release:August 25, 2010
Where to Watch: on digital and on demand

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (2010) is a film I once described as being “on absolute crack.” With the movie’s fast-paced dialogue, quick-cut editing, and overall vibrant energy, I could be forgiven for simply thinking Edgar Wright’s film was a fun, frantic, mess. Upon repeat viewings, however, I have come to appreciate Wright’s controlled chaos, using a committed cast and a distinct style to comment on growing up, relationships in the 21st century, and learning to accept the lots of life.

In the film, Scott Pilgrim (Michael Cera) is in his early twenties, trying to navigate his budding music career and his revolving-door of relationships. The movie begins with Scott dating a high schooler, Knives (Ellen Wong) but quickly meeting and falling in love with Ramona Flowers (Mary Elizabeth Winstead). Scott quickly realizes that, in order to win Ramona’s affection, he must battle and defeat her “seven evil exes.” The resulting adventure is a mishmash of mid-2000s cultural touchstones (comic books, fighter-style video games, and punk music) that is unlike any other film released during that time, and something we are unlikely to ever see again.

Before diving into what makes this film truly insane, it is important to note how much the cast is on board with Wright’s vision. Cera bounces between calm awkwardness and goofy heroism, while Winstead provides some stability in an otherwise tumultuous roller coaster. Kieran Culkin, Brie Larson, Chris Evans, Aubrey Plaza, Anna Kendrick, and Jason Schwartzman round out the cast, all dialing it up to 11. Each brings a unique sense of humor to the characters. Wright then uses these individual personalities to inhabit an incredibly zestful world.

Advertisement

That zestful world features the “booms!” and “pows!” reminiscent of the 1960s Batman show, hilarious title cards, and a visual flare that is pulled straight out of a comic book or an arcade-style fighting game (Mortal Kombat quickly comes to mind). Each ex Scott faces feels like the next big boss battle, each one increasingly zany and difficult to defeat. These fights are choreographed, colorful, and completely stylized. When the film feels teetering on the edge of becoming slightly redundant, the next battle begins, looking and feeling different than what came before. Wright keeps his audience on their toes at every turn.

Scott Pilgrim and Ramona Flowers sit on a bus in a still from Scott Pilgrim vs. The World
Scott Pilgrim and Ramona Flowers in a still from Scott Pilgrim vs. The World (Universal Pictures)

With everything that is happening in the filmmaking itself, critics of Scott Pilgrim could easily say the movie is all style and no substance. Even worse, Wright could be accused of mocking his own characters, reducing the serious struggles young adults go through as nothing more than a game we all must play. I don’t think this is the case however. Rather, Wright is drawing on the culture that he knows to empathize with his characters. There are genuine moments of heart on display, especially towards the end, when Scott begins to realize the ways he’s hurt those closest to him. The film seems seriously concerned with questions about how we can escape our past, how we learn from mistakes, and how human relationships can persevere despite the personal challenges each individual has. 

Towards the end of the film, Scott receives two “level-ups” as he faces down his final opponent. The first is “love.” Wright centers love as the driving force of human relationships, something that can overcome any obstacle. The second is “self-respect,” a challenge for the audience to accept their own individuality. To say that Wright simply utilizes these visual moments as gags would be to undersell the very real issues the film grapples with. The chaos may seem out of control, but Wright seems to suggest that, much like the real world, chaos can be controlled by the power of our own emotions. One can easily watch the movie and simply be entertained, but for some — especially ones in a certain generation — the film brilliantly blends its wild mise en scéne with themes that will certainly resonate throughout time.


Get it on Apple TVGet it on Apple TV

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is now available to watch on digital and on demand. Read our review of Netflix series Scott Pilgrim Takes Off!

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World Trailer (Universal Pictures)
Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Movie Reviews

Venom: The Last Dance (Movie Review)

Published

on

Venom: The Last Dance (Movie Review)

Have you ever heard of “Middle Book Syndrome”? For those who haven’t heard of it, this phrase accompanies complaints that the installment had no point: nothing happened, the characters went in circles, and the plot only served to get to the third book. Well, Venom: The Last Dance manages to get this syndrome while being the final film in this trilogy. And that’s not a good start to a review of a character that I love in comic books and other media.

Title: Venom: The Last Dance
Production Company: Columbia Pictures, Marvel Entertainment, Arad Productions, Matt Tolmach Productions, Pascal Pictures, Hutch Parker Entertainment, and Hardy Son & Baker
Distributed by: Sony Pictures Releasing
Directed by: Kelly Marcel
Produced by: Avi Arad, Matt Tolmach, Amy Pascal, Kelly Marcel, Tom Hardy, and Hutch Parker
Written by: Tom Hardy & Kelly Marcel
Starring: Tom Hardy, Chiwetel Ejiofor, Juno Temple, Rhys Ifans, Stephen Graham, Peggy Lu, Clark Backo, and Alanna Ubach
Based on: Venom by Todd MacFarlane & Marvel Comics
Release dates: October 25, 2024
Running time: 109 minutes
Rating: PG

spoilers

From The Void…

Venom: The Last Dance Story Summary – SPOILERS

Click to read Summary

Advertisement
Eddie Brock and the Venom symbiote are drunk in a bar in Mexico, while on the run. With their recent battle with Carnage and the murder of Patrick Mulligan making headlines and an arrest warrant issued out on them, Eddie sets out for New York City to try and clear his name. Unbeknownst to either one of them, a creature known as a Xenophage has begun tracking them. The events catch the eye of Rex Strickland, who oversees Imperium, a government operation at the site of the soon-to-be-decommissioned Area 51 for the capture and study of other symbiotes that have fallen to Earth. Mulligan, revealed to have survived his encounter with Carnage, is captured after being left for dead by another symbiote, who eluded Strickland’s soldiers. He is bonded with one of many contained symbiotes and questioned by Imperium to learn about the symbiotes’ purpose on Earth before Strickland is ordered to bring Venom down.

While attaching themselves onto the side of a plane bound for New York City, Eddie and Venom are attacked by the Xenophage tracking them and are forced to drop from the airplane into a desert field. Venom explains to Eddie that they are being hunted on the orders of Knull, the creator of the symbiotes, who has ordered his Xenophages to search the universe to find the “Codex”, which can be only detected in Venom’s true form, to be freed from his prison the symbiotes trapped him long ago. After being ambushed by Strickland and his team and barely escaping from them and the Xenophage, Eddie eventually comes across a traveling hippie family in the woods, who offer him a ride to Las Vegas. Meanwhile, Mulligan’s new symbiote informs Strickland and his team of Knull’s true intentions and the role of the Codex, which can only be destroyed if one of the hosts in a symbiote dies.

Arriving in Las Vegas, Eddie and Venom run into Mrs. Chen at a casino and Venom shares a dance with her before being ambushed by the Xenophage again. Suddenly, Strickland’s team arrives, captures Venom and incapacitates Eddie. In Area 51, Eddie is interrogated before Venom manages to escape confinement, attracting the Xenophage’s attention to the Codex again and attacking the base. Venom orders the release of the other symbiotes confined in the lab, which bond with new hosts, to fight off the Xenophage. Eddie, Strickland and lead researcher Teddy Payne run into Martin and his family, who have also infiltrated Area 51 in search of aliens. Knull finds the location of the Codex and begins sending multiple Xenophages through portals to attack Venom. Eddie attempts to lure the creatures away to save Martin and his family, who escape through a broken fence on the outside. Realizing that he must separate from his host to destroy the Codex and save the universe, Venom bids Eddie goodbye and separates, merging with the Xenophages and dosing them in acid before a mortally wounded Strickland sets off his grenades, destroying them. Eddie passes out as the base burns.

Eddie wakes up in a hospital and is informed by a federal official that due to his heroic actions with Venom at Area 51, his entire criminal record has been expunged but he may never mention it to anyone. Arriving in New York City, Eddie reminisces on the memories he had with Venom, while watching the Statue of Liberty.

In a mid-credits scene, Knull exclaims that the universe is no longer safe with the death of Venom.

Advertisement

In a post-credit scene, the bartender escapes Area 51 in a panic, while a cockroach appears to be fused with the Venom symbiote.

Venom: The Last Dance

Story Review – Some Vague Spoilers

This is the third time I’ve reviewed a Venom movie, with the first movie being favorable for an origin film, then the follow-up of Venom: Let There Be Carnage saw a slight dip on the Venom side of things, only to be saved by the Carnage side of things. Walking out of Venom: The Last Dance… I felt nothing. All I could think while watching Venom go from Horror/Action film to Comedy was this clip from The Godfather III:

I felt like they just took what should have been one of the most violent, aggressive, action-packed characters in comic books and turned him into a bickering married couple who just wanted to do anything except admit their relationship failed and divorce.

Advertisement

There was a movie at some point, with the vague idea of a story. Adapting the beginning to “The King in Black”, while not my favorite Venom event storyline, is at least something that a movie should be able to do well on the big screen. However, the story just feels like bookends to something else that was shoved into the middle of the film to remind us that Symbiotes are a thing and have something to do with Venom… Who is off to the side bickering with Eddie while they make their way to the B plot while avoiding the A plot as much as possible… Then have a side trip to one of the most out there non-sensical “why the fuck are they doing this” moments in film history.

spoilers

Venom: The Last Dance

Venom: The Last Dance Partners.

  • Tom Hardy as Eddie Brock / Venom:
    Where I once praised Tom Hardy for being the voice of Venom as well as the actor for Eddie, by the time I was halfway through Venom: The Last Dance I was begging for it all to end. What started as “Eddie goes crazy” had become a bickering married couple, and not in a funny way. Eddie spends the majority of the film complaining. Then in the final moments, instead of connecting and feeling sad about Venom, I was almost glad because it meant the movie was almost over… and so did others as people started clapping as if it was the end of the movie.
  • Chiwetel Ejiofor as Rex Strickland:
    Typical Military guy who goes power mad as he just wants to defend the world against the evil aliens who are invading and you can’t change my mind. When he does get that power, it instantly backfires on him and everything goes crazy, leading to a last-minute trust of the aliens and doing one thing to save everyone from the threat in the end. Very trope-style in acting and character.
  • Juno Temple as Dr. Teddy Payne & Clark Backo as Sadie Christmas:
    I sum these two up as “Dr. Inclusion” and “Dr. Diversity”. They are two scientists, one of which has a “dead” arm due to a lightning strike hitting her shoulder (Dr. Payne), and the other who wears a Christmas Tree pin all the time because her last name is Christmas (It’s a joke… GET IT?!). Both of them spend most of their time looking longingly at the captured symbiotes like they want to make out with them and say that the symbiotes are good creatures who are running from something. They do get their wishes of being covered by symbiotes in the last act of the film, with Dr Payne getting to keep her symbiote (who doesn’t have a name, none of them do), while Christmas loses hers in battle. Meh.
  • Stephen Graham as Patrick Mulligan:
    If you don’t remember Mulligan from Venom: Let There Be Carnage, then I don’t blame you. The scientists infect him with one of the symbiotes in order to keep him alive and use his body to communicate with the symbiote. He adds nothing to the plot except to give all the women who want to fuck something that looks like a monster a thing to get wet over.
  • Peggy Lu as Mrs. Chen:
    She’s back in one of the most pointless cameos ever. I’m sure she was included because someone writing this shit loved her, or some idiots online created some theory about how she is the center of the Venom movies. Mrs. Chen shows up to give Eddie a moment to fix himself up, leading to “that dance scene” that killed the film completely.
  • Andy Serkis as Knull:
    Ok, first of all, Serkis as Knull nails the aura of that big bad evil guy who is a threat to the world PERFECTLY. All he does is sit on a throne, covered in symbiote “ropes”, and talk about how he is going to fuck the whole universe over when he gets free and it WORKS. It’s a shame that we will probably not get a follow-up to anything he does and this epic-looking guy is going to be remembered as nothing more than bookends to one of the worst Superhero movies since Steel.

Venom: The Last Dance

It’s Good If You Wanted A Comedy

If you try to look at Venom: The Last Dance in the same way you looked at Venom or Venom: Let There Be Carnage, then you’re going to miss what this film trilogy has become. Instead of the Lethal Protector, you get a man who is annoyed with having to do anything at all and an alien who wants to eat brains all the time and make shitty references that make no sense.

Venom: The Last Dance is a comedy movie, and if you think it’s an action or adventure movie then you have blinders on. That being said, if you view it in the same vein as The Odd Couple, a TV show that maybe 3 people besides me remember, then it is not too bad. Venom’s wisecracks land with a chuckle, and a few actual laughs at times. The sillier moments could be forgiven with this mindset too.

It’s hard to find praise for Venom: The Last Dance as I just feel numb to the movie, almost forgetting about 90% of it as I want to keep my original love and view of Venom and his adventures in New York… And yes, he finally gets to New York, and not once do they mention Spider-Man, not that he would save this shitshow of a movie.

We did get to see a little bit of blood and gore for a PG-rated film, something that this trilogy should never have been rated after Deadpool was a thing. Seeing Venom bite the heads off some villains was a step forward from the first film, but without any blood spurting, it just felt like the effects were forgotten and the edge of the scene was lost. PG rating for Venom should never have been a thing and it is one of the main things that should have been addressed by now.

Advertisement

Venom: The Last Dance

Too Many Symbiotes in the Kitchen

The King in Black is a large and epic storyline that brings in all of Marvel’s roster in order to take down Knull, and with Venom being a forced stand-alone movie trilogy, there is ZERO chance that we will see Venom interact with anyone from the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Hell, they start the movie by ripping Venom out of that specific universe just to make sure that the viewer knows that there is no hope at all for a Spider-Man cameo or anything to happen in these movies.

That being said, using Knull makes Venom: The Last Dance feel like there is still one more film to go, but since his scenes are the opening of the film and then a mid-credits scene, there doesn’t feel like there was a point to having him in Venom: The Last Dance at all, even to create a reason for the Xenophages to hunt Venom down.

Venom: The Last Dance stuffers from ADHD, as in it cannot focus correctly for more than 5 seconds. Venom spends the majority of the film making his way to Las Vegas, which just happens to be near the real focus of the movie: Area 55, a hidden underground version of Area 51 where Dr Inclusion and her assistant Dr Diversity spend a lot of time looking at a returning character from Venom: Let There Be Carnage as he becomes the main character from something that can only be described as one of those Monster Fucker “Romance novels” that fill your local book shop these days. Venom: The Last Dance is an internet degenerate’s wet dream in most ways with these Scientists and their many floating space-goo monsters.

Then there is “that dance scene” aka The Last Dance as mentioned in this movie. When Venom/Eddie makes it to Las Vegas, after knocking out a drunk guy and stealing his suit (Let’s just forget that Venom can MIMIC CLOTHING! aka one of the many abilities that the writers forgot about over THREE FUCKING MOVIES!), he encounters Mrs Chen, the store clerk from the other two films who just happens to have won so much in the Casino that she has the Penthouse Suite, leading to her and Venom dancing to the ABBA song “Dancing Queen”… Well, a remix of it anyway. This scene is the point where my excitement of anything good happening died completely.

Sure, we got the big explosive action-filled final act, but by that time the damage had been done. People were getting bored, so bored that we noticed a bunch of people walking out of the film to go to the bathroom, get more popcorn, or just walk around to do anything but fall asleep in the theater chairs. When the credits started to roll, I had never seen a theater room empty so fast with people complaining about how they wasted time and money on a sub-par film.

Advertisement

Venom: The Last Dance

Venom: The Last Dance… Thank God For That

My wife and I had a discussion about Venom as a trilogy of films now that it has been completed, and the conclusion we came to was that Venom: The Last Dance should have been called something different, then it could have been used to set up Carnage and Knull for the third film. We agreed that Sony blew its load too quickly with Venom: Let There Be Carnage as anything that came afterward would not be able to handle the standard that came from Carnage showing up.

Venom: The Last Dance is not the ending I would have wanted for my favorite comic book character, not at all. Venom should have been going out swinging, taking down a world-ending threat like Knull instead of making a “noble sacrifice” of holding 4 to 5 Xenophages under an acid bath, which sounds more exciting than it looked on screen. The final scene of Eddie looking at the Statue of Liberty should have been the beginning of the real adventure of Venom, not the end of a trilogy that just got even more lost along the way.

Summary

Venom: The Last Dance should have been the big send-off for what should have been the biggest, most kick-ass anti-hero character to ever grace the Superhero genre, instead, we were given a sub-par road trip movie with a bickering married couple combined with a bookended story briefs in order to tease a possible continuation. From the opening moments, you can tell this movie had no direction and no idea what to do to fill 109 minutes… A sad end for one of comic book’s most popular characters.

 

Advertisement

Pros

  • The Xenophages looked cool
  • Some jokes landed with a laugh

Cons

  • That fucking dance scene
  • PG Rating
  • Knull/King in Black story used as bookends
  • No notable Symbiotes
  • The Eddie & Venom bickering wears thin on the nerves
  • The Hippie Family
Advertisement
Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Movie review: Conclave – Baltimore Magazine

Published

on

Movie review: Conclave – Baltimore Magazine

I know what you’re thinking: A movie about a group of Cardinals electing a new pope? Do you have any paint I can watch dry while you’re at it?

But what if I told you that Edward Berger’s Conclave was one of the most exciting and best films of the year—a tense and beautifully shot procedural filled with intrigue, surprise twists, double-crosses, and almost incalculably high stakes.

Early in the film, the stage is set. The pope has died and while many high-ranking clergymen fuss over his death bed, only one seems to truly be in mourning. That’s the Dean of the College of Cardinals, Thomas Lawrence (Ralph Fiennes), whom we find out later had recently tried to resign his post—without success. Maybe the pope knew he was going to die, Lawrence speculates, and he wanted someone he trusted running the conclave.

A conclave, for the uninitiated, is a special election of a new pope by the Cardinals. That deal with the smoke billowing out of the Vatican until we get a new pope? That’s the conclave.

And if you think it’s a peaceful and stress free process, may I direct your attention to HBO’s Succession?

Advertisement

Four candidates emerge early on. There’s Stanley Tucci’s Bellini, the self-described liberal of the group, who wants the Catholic church to continue its progress on social issues. There’s Adeyemi (Lucien Msamati), who would be the first Black pope, but has some skeletons in his closet. There’s the entertainingly loathsome Tedesco (Sergio Castellitto), who vapes like he’s in some South Beach nightclub and believes that the Catholic Church should regress to its traditional ways—Latin liturgy, no women in the church, no gay marriage. (Tedesco makes the mistake of assuming Lawrence shares his values. When he casually mentions what a disaster it would be if Adeyemi becomes pope, Lawrence radiates with visible disgust.) Finally, there’s the seemingly mild-mannered Tremblay (John Lithgow), the moderate choice—but what to make of the rumors that the pope asked for his resignation shortly before he died?

As Dean, it falls on Lawrence to oversee the conclave, but there is a complicating factor—the cardinals are in lockdown, and therefore he has no access to outside information that might help him get to the bottom of the various rumors.

The first of many votes comes in and there are a few surprises: For one, Lawrence gets a few votes, even though he made it clear he wasn’t interested. Adeyemi is in the lead, with the other three main contenders fairly far behind. And there’s an even a more surprising vote bringing up the rear—for the humble Benitez (Carlos Biehz), a newcomer to the Vatican who had been serving a dangerous Catholic ministry in Afghanistan and had been secretly made a Cardinal by the pope.

The similarities to American politics, to all politics for that matter, are strictly intentional. Tucci’s Bellini pretends to be a reluctant candidate, but secretly craves the job. Tremblay is so blinded by ambition, he’s lost his moral compass. And as for Tedesco, his motto may as well be, “Make the Vatican Great Again.”

All the cardinals are so grasping they can hardly believe that Lawrence means it when he says he doesn’t want to be pope. They accuse him of secret ambition and sabotage, when he’s actually only seeking someone worthy of the job. (That said, he does have a papal name picked out: John. It’s that old aphorism about American politics: “Something happens to a man when he looks in the mirror and sees a president.”)

Advertisement

Although I was a fan of Edward Berger’s All Quiet on the Western Front, I found its score a little jarring (intentionally so, but still…). Here, the jangly and stuttering sounds of a string quartet perfectly enhance the tension. The film is shot beautifully in a recreated Vatican—all long halls, secret chambers, and light-filled sanctuaries. (The film’s recreation of Sistine Chapel is impeccable.) But there’s a sense of claustrophobia, too. The cardinals are perfectly cloistered. It might as well be the 17th century up in there.

All the acting is top notch—Castellitto in particular is a riot—but Ralph Fiennes is nothing short of masterful as Lawrence, a good man caught in the maelstrom of these red-robed men and their outsized ambition, all while grieving the pope and suffering his own crisis of faith. And look for a quietly powerful Isabella Rossellini as the all-seeing and all-knowing Sister Agnes.

Conclave is gripping from beginning to end. It’s one of those movies that reminds you why you love movies.

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

‘Black Box Diaries’ Review: The Face of Japan’s #MeToo Movement Tells Her Compelling Story

Published

on

‘Black Box Diaries’ Review: The Face of Japan’s #MeToo Movement Tells Her Compelling Story

There’s a scene in Shiori Ito’s searing documentary Black Box Diaries, in which the director, who is also the film’s subject, tells a swarm of reporters about trying to press criminal charges against her rapist. Like many sexual violence survivors forced into this ritual of public re-litigation, she is a model of what society has come to expect of courageous women. Her face betrays no emotion and she is dressed in the chaste uniform of the aggrieved: delicate earrings (Ito opts for pearls), a conservatively tailored blouse (a black button down here), and wearing little to no makeup (faint signs of blush and a single stroke of eyeliner).

Ito’s voice remains calm as she recounts the police’s initial refusal to accept her victim’s report and their arsenal of excuses: Sex crimes were difficult to investigate, they said; her rapist, Noriyuki Yamaguchi, the former Washington Bureau chief of the Tokyo Broadcasting System and friend to the late Japanese prime minister Shinzo Abe, was too powerful a figure to scrutinize.

Black Box Diaries

The Bottom Line

A sobering doc about a courageous act.

Advertisement

Release date: Friday, Oct. 25
Director: Shiori Ito

1 hour 42 minutes

After a couple of months, the authorities abandoned Ito’s case and the young woman, a journalist in her own right, decided to go public. She held the aforementioned press conference in May 2017 and published a memoir five months later.

Ito’s actions  — a rare move in Japan, where less than 10 percent of rape victims report their case — sparked a #MeToo moment in the country, forcing the nation to reckon with its attitudes about sexual violence, its perpetrators and its survivors.

Advertisement

Black Box Diaries, which opened Oct. 25 in the U.S., chronicles Ito’s attempts to procure legal redress. With its combination of diaristic iPhone videos, news reports, hotel security footage from the night of Ito’s rape and various audio recordings, the film is a visceral testimony of survival and recourse. 

In its devastation and familiarity, Ito’s debut feature finds company among works that realize the power of survivor testimony.

An obvious one that comes to mind is She Said, Maria Schrader’s conventional dramatization of New York Times reporters Megan Twohey and Jodi Kantor’s investigation of Harvey Weinstein. Schrader deployed testimony in a striking way, using the actual recording of Ambra Battilana Gutierrez’s encounter with Weinstein to shift the film’s perspective and jolt viewers out of the comforting lull of fictionalized narratives.

Another is Chanel Miller’s 2019 memoir Know My Name, in which Miller, who was assaulted by Stanford University athlete Brock Turner in 2015, reclaims her identity from the anonymizing moniker Emily Doe. Like Ito, Miller’s narrative finds a galvanizing energy in self-revelation.

A more recent work is director Lee Sunday Evans and actress Elizabeth Marvel’s sobering play The Ford/Hill Project at New York’s Public Theater. That production, which recently ended its run, interpolates the hearings of both Anita Hill, who went before the Senate Judiciary Committee in 1991 to testify against then Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas, who sexually harassed her, and Christine Blasey Ford, who went before the same committee in 2018 after accusing then Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh of sexually assaulting her in high school.

Advertisement

The material power of the accused — conferred by a society more likely to side with perpetrators than survivors of assault — connects these works, which span different countries and years. Together, these women’s stories form an imposing chorus of damning disclosures, speaking to the difficulty survivors face when trying to tell the truth. 

Most people in Ito’s life begged her not to go public. Conversations with her family and one of the investigators in the aborted criminal case, some of which are included in Black Box Diaries, reveal the depths of fear that nurture a culture of silence in Japan. These people are concerned about losing their jobs, tarnishing their reputations and the threat of violence that might come from Ito subjecting herself to an unsparing public.

Still, the journalist, propelled by the values that drew her to her profession, is compelled to try. Ito approaches her case with the same rigor as she would a news story. This method makes the doc easy to follow for those unfamiliar with contemporary Japanese society while giving Black Box Diaries the propulsive rhythm of, ironically, a procedural.

Many scenes show Ito recording phone calls, taking copious notes and sitting in rooms surrounded by highlighted transcripts and folders of evidence. As director, she uses conversations with her editors, lawyers and friends to give context for why a criminal case was abandoned, a civil suit pursued and the politics within Japanese society that have complicated every step in her journey.

Anecdotes gleaned from clandestine meetings with an anonymous investigator underscore Yamaguchi’s power. In one particularly implicative story, the investigator tells Ito that despite having an arrest warrant for the high-profile journalist, police chief Itaru Nakamura, who counts Yamaguchi as a friend, decided against it. 

Advertisement

The details of Ito’s case, especially for audiences familiar with the narratives of survivors, echo stories that have become more common since the height of the #MeToo movement. The callousness of investigators, the craven police interrogation methods that seek to discount the memory of survivors by insisting the truth hinges on minute details and the vitriol of a misogynistic public are all on display in Black Box Diaries.

Where Ito’s film distinguishes itself is in the diaristic iPhone videos, which serve as a mode of confrontation for the director as subject. In these clear-eyed and visceral confessions, Ito the journalist dissolves and Ito the person comes into better view.

They reveal the chronic isolation of survivors and give space to the private demons that come to the fore when they aren’t required to mask their pain through calibrated outfits and steady intonations. They reclaim the idea of testimony, changing it from a public act to an urgent and healing private one. 

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending