Montana

Class action lawsuit claims Montana discriminates against out-of-state financial advisers – Daily Montanan

Published

2 years ago

January 12, 2024

Class action lawsuit claims Montana discriminates against out-of-state financial advisers – Daily Montanan

A Montana attorney has filed a class-action lawsuit against the state, the Montana Department of Revenue and the state auditor’s office for what they say is an illegal, unconstitutional fee charged to more than 100,000 investment advisers and representatives who live outside the Treasure State.

Even more, the lawsuit, filed in Lewis and Clark County on Friday, says that the 2019 Legislature knew that the law likely violated the privileges and immunities clause of the United States Constitution, but passed it anyway.

That constitutional clause prohibits treating residents from other states differently than residents in-state, and House Bill 694 sought to increase the licensing fees for out-of-state residents to $100 while keeping the fees for Montana-based investment advisers at $50.

Rep. Jim Hamilton, D-Bozeman, told fellow lawmakers in 2019 that, “the reason for raising this fee is that we have a group of people who are not contributing to the economy they are taking advantage of with their businesses, and therefore, I think it appropriate that we not sell Montana so cheaply.”

He said that because those same advisers don’t pay income tax or property tax in Montana, they should be charged more.

Different lawmakers and witnesses who testified in 2019 raised issues of legality with the bill, and it was even stopped in the Montana Senate because of constitutional concerns.

However, in 2019, Sen. Steve Fitzpatrick, now the Senate Majority Leader and a Republican from Great Falls, brought it back to life when it was eventually passed as part of the overall budget.

Because licensing fees are handled in a uniform way with a payment portal that’s consistent throughout the states, and because no other state differentiated between resident and non-resident licensees, Montana also developed a system where Montana resident licensees could apply for a $50 refund, while out-of-state licensees were ineligible.

In 2019, the state estimated that around 2,200 of the 108,000 financial adviser licensees were Montana-based, meaning that more than 97% financial advisers registered in the Big Sky State do not live in-state.

The class-action challenge is being brought by Thomas Strobhar, who has challenged laws and business practices in several different states on different topics. He is being represented by former state lawmaker and attorney Matthew Monforton.

“The committee knew that the discriminatory fee structure in HB 694 was unconstitutional, yet approved it anyway,” the lawsuit said.

The Montana Supreme Court has upheld the privileges and immunities clause of the U.S. Constitution, and said in 1981 that the “rights of nonresidents to ‘ply their trade, practice their occupation, or pursue a common calling in the state’” is something that shall be “free from discrimination based upon state residency.”

Even though lawmakers pointed out that Montana and other states may charge non-residents fees for recreational licenses, like hunting, that is limited to recreational, not occupational licenses.

“Montana’s policy of imposing discriminatory fees upon nonresident investment adviser representatives and securities salesperson (does not) bear a substantial relationship to any important state interest,” the lawsuit said.

The lawsuit asks that the courts declare the measure unconstitutional and issue an injunction prohibiting the state from charging a different fee for non-resident advisers as Montana-based advisers.

The lawsuit also seeks an award of damages to Strobhar and other class members.

If Strobhar and the class-action suit was successful, it would mean the state would have to disgorge as much as $25 million that Montana has collected from these fees since 2019.

Strobhar, a resident of Ohio, is no stranger to being in the middle of controversy.

Strobhar has authored more than 70 shareholder resolutions to ban corporate support for pornography, religious bigotry, fetal tissue research, abortifacients, Planned Parenthood, and policies he considers hostile to marriage. His resolutions have changed the way several large businesses operate, including American Express, AT&T, Berkshire Hathaway, General Mills and Target.

Last year, Strobhar also led an initiative that would force The Walt Disney Company to disclose charitable contributions of more than $10,000. Though Disney fought against that, arguing that Strobhar was attempting micromanagement of the company, the Securities and Exchange Commission ultimately allowed the a vote on the resolution.

240112 Complaint

Source link

Click to comment

Montana

Photos: Montana State clips Illinois State to win national championship

Published

11 hours ago

January 6, 2026

Press Room

Photos: Montana State clips Illinois State to win national championship

Montana State plays Illinois State in the FCS national championship game at FirstBank Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., on Monday, Jan. 5, 2026.Justin Hosa / MTN Sports

Montana State topped Illinois State 35-34 in overtime to claim their first National Championship since 1984.TOM WYLIE/MTN Sports

Montana State plays Illinois State in the FCS national championship game at FirstBank Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., on Monday, Jan. 5, 2026.Kyle Hansen / MTN Sports

Source link

Montana

Watch: Bobcat Built – Montana State’s Championship Quest

Published

23 hours ago

January 5, 2026

Press Room

Watch: Bobcat Built – Montana State’s Championship Quest

NASHVILLE, Tenn. — Montana State squares off with Illinois State Monday night in the FCS national championship game at FirstBank Stadium on the campus of Vanderbilt University. Kickoff is set for 5:30 p.m. and the game will be broadcast on ESPN.

The Bobcats are making their third trip to the title game in the past five seasons under coach Brent Vigen. The program is seeking its first championship since 1984.

MTN Sports has been on the ground in Nashville for the past five days covering the lead-up to the game, including the pregame show “Bobcat Built: Montana State’s Championship Quest” hosted by Scott Breen and Kyle Hansen.

In it the MTN staff provides game previews, features, facts and figures and sights and sounds from the past several days in Music City in the run-up to the game. To watch, see the video reel below.

Watch: Bobcat Built – Montana State’s Championship Quest

Bobcat Built: Montana State’s Championship Quest

Source link

Montana

Photos: Past and present Montana State Bobcats meet in Nashville

Published

1 day ago

January 5, 2026

Press Room

Photos: Past and present Montana State Bobcats meet in Nashville

Past Montana State football players meet with current Bobcats during a team walk-through at the indoor practice facility at Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tenn., on Sunday, Jan. 4, 2026.Kyle Hansen / MTN Sports

Source link

Hamas builds new terror regime in Gaza, recruiting teens amid problematic election

World1 week ago

Hamas builds new terror regime in Gaza, recruiting teens amid problematic election

Indianapolis Colts playoffs: Updated elimination scenario, AFC standings, playoff picture for Week 17

Indianapolis, IN1 week ago

Indianapolis Colts playoffs: Updated elimination scenario, AFC standings, playoff picture for Week 17

For those who help the poor, 2025 goes down as a year of chaos

News1 week ago

For those who help the poor, 2025 goes down as a year of chaos

Podcast: The 2025 EU-US relationship explained simply

World1 week ago

Podcast: The 2025 EU-US relationship explained simply

Instacart ends AI pricing test that charged shoppers different prices for the same items

Business1 week ago

Instacart ends AI pricing test that charged shoppers different prices for the same items

Apple, Google and others tell some foreign employees to avoid traveling out of the country

Business1 week ago

Apple, Google and others tell some foreign employees to avoid traveling out of the country

ChatGPT’s GPT-5.2 is here, and it feels rushed

Technology1 week ago

ChatGPT’s GPT-5.2 is here, and it feels rushed

‘Unlucky’ Honduran woman arrested after allegedly running red light and crashing into ICE vehicle

Politics1 week ago

‘Unlucky’ Honduran woman arrested after allegedly running red light and crashing into ICE vehicle

News Pub

Class action lawsuit claims Montana discriminates against out-of-state financial advisers – Daily Montanan

Montana

Class action lawsuit claims Montana discriminates against out-of-state financial advisers – Daily Montanan

Leave a Reply
Cancel reply

Leave a Reply

Montana

Photos: Montana State clips Illinois State to win national championship

Montana

Watch: Bobcat Built – Montana State’s Championship Quest

Montana

Photos: Past and present Montana State Bobcats meet in Nashville

Oklahoma opens applications for winter heating assistance

Oregon National Guard troops begin demobilization after federal Title 10 deployment

Pennsylvania Gov. Shapiro has $30 million for his reelection bid, a new state record

Rhode Island weighs new tax on highest earners as Trump policy pressures mount

Joe Riley’s new memoir shares life leading Charleston for 40 years

Florida High School Football Rankings: Top 25 teams – Oct. 21

Cleary's 21 help Le Moyne down Central Connecticut State 69-64 in OT

How old is Bo Nix? What to know about Oregon quarterback ahead of 2024 NFL Draft

99th annual Pony Swim held in Virginia

Video: ‘It Didn’t Have to Happen This Way:’ U.Va. Faculty Call for Review of Police Response to Protests

Video: Nvidia Shows Off New A.I. Chip at CES

Pelosi heir-apparent calls Trump’s Venezuela move a ‘lawless coup,’ urges impeachment, slams Netanyahu

EU Commission examines childlike sexual images created by Musk’s AI

Lawmakers split over Maduro’s seizure. And, CDC cuts childhood vaccine schedule

Federal officials to halt more than $10B in funding to 5 states over non-citizen benefit concerns: report

Trending

News Pub

Class action lawsuit claims Montana discriminates against out-of-state financial advisers – Daily Montanan

You may like

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Leave a Reply

Montana

Photos: Montana State clips Illinois State to win national championship

Montana

Watch: Bobcat Built – Montana State’s Championship Quest

Montana

Photos: Past and present Montana State Bobcats meet in Nashville

Oklahoma opens applications for winter heating assistance

Oregon National Guard troops begin demobilization after federal Title 10 deployment

Pennsylvania Gov. Shapiro has $30 million for his reelection bid, a new state record

Rhode Island weighs new tax on highest earners as Trump policy pressures mount

Joe Riley’s new memoir shares life leading Charleston for 40 years

Florida High School Football Rankings: Top 25 teams – Oct. 21

Cleary's 21 help Le Moyne down Central Connecticut State 69-64 in OT

How old is Bo Nix? What to know about Oregon quarterback ahead of 2024 NFL Draft

99th annual Pony Swim held in Virginia

Video: ‘It Didn’t Have to Happen This Way:’ U.Va. Faculty Call for Review of Police Response to Protests

Video: Nvidia Shows Off New A.I. Chip at CES

Pelosi heir-apparent calls Trump’s Venezuela move a ‘lawless coup,’ urges impeachment, slams Netanyahu

EU Commission examines childlike sexual images created by Musk’s AI

Lawmakers split over Maduro’s seizure. And, CDC cuts childhood vaccine schedule

Federal officials to halt more than $10B in funding to 5 states over non-citizen benefit concerns: report

Trending

Leave a Reply
Cancel reply