Connect with us

Science

Millions of sea creatures lived on the Elly platform: Will they survive the oil spill?

Published

on

Millions of sea creatures lived on the Elly platform: Will they survive the oil spill?

Perched excessive above the waves about 9 miles off the coast of Huntington Seaside, the oil processing platform often known as Elly seems like an industrial eyesore — a tangle of arduous steel surfaces, cranes and pipes.

However plunge 30 toes beneath the waves, and also you enter a psychedelic wonderland of undulating marine life. Mussels, anemones and brittle stars coat the platform’s thick metal pilings, sea lions frolic between its beams and tens of hundreds of fish dart between its helps. Neon nudibranchs (small sea slugs) wander among the many different life. Sponges, scallops and corals are all a part of the combination.

No marvel the Elly platform is without doubt one of the most beloved dive websites in Southern California.

“It’s my No. 1 favourite dive,” stated Paige Zhang, a graduate scholar in marine biology at UCLA who spent a day diving Elly just some weeks in the past. “And that’s why I used to be so shocked and unhappy about this spill. It’s so loopy to assume that this occurred on one thing I dove earlier than.”

Paige Zhang, 29, a graduate scholar in marine biology at UCLA, is photographed in Venice. “It’s my No. 1 favourite dive,” she says concerning the Elly oil processing platform off Huntington Seaside.

Advertisement

(Genaro Molina / Los Angeles Instances)

Particulars concerning the scope of the current oil spill in Orange County are nonetheless murky, however officers say as a lot as 144,000 gallons of crude oil leaked from a 17.7-mile pipeline that runs from the Elly platform to the Port of Lengthy Seaside. Precisely the place and the way this leak occurred remains to be being decided.

Scientists and environmental teams rushed to guard the varied animal populations within the area’s marshes and wetlands — deploying booms to maintain oil from flooding and rescuing birds who’re already exhibiting apparent indicators of oil harm.

As of now, no one is aware of for certain how the oil spill will have an effect on the plentiful marine life dwelling on the rig itself.

Advertisement

Oil is lighter than water, so the excellent news for these creatures, who stay tens and a whole lot of toes beneath the waves, is that the overwhelming majority of it has in all probability risen to the floor. However there’s dangerous information too: Even hint quantities of oil might be lethal.

“I don’t know if the platform itself or all of the organisms which have connected to it have been coated with oil, however we all know that even small concentrations of oil within the water can have poisonous results,” stated Andrea Bonisoli Alquati, a biologist at Cal Poly Pomona who studied the aftermath of the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill within the Gulf of Mexico. “It doesn’t take a number of oil to kill these small organisms.”

“It’s an oasis in the midst of an ocean desert. You’ve obtained nothing however deep water ocean surrounding it.”

Ashley Arnold, proprietor of Jade Scuba Adventures

Advertisement
Photos of sea life under the oil platform Elly taken by Paige Zhang

This picture of an opalescent nudibranch below the oil platform Elly was taken by Paige Zhang, a graduate scholar in marine biology at UCLA. “You hear about oil spills on a regular basis on the information, and you are feeling like they’re up to now out of your life, however this one is so near all of us,” she stated.

(Paige Zhang)

It’s not a shock that animal life has congregated on the submerged infrastructure of Elly, stated Milton Love, an ichthyologist (fish scientist) at UC Santa Barbara who research how rigs perform as fish habitat.

“There are at all times extra invertebrate larvae drifting round in search of a spot to decide on then there are locations to decide on,” he stated. “After which right here is that this humongous construction with 1,200 toes of metal — that’s a number of stuff to decide on.”

Over time, he’s found that organisms aren’t at all times choosy about the place they make their properties.

Advertisement

Lobsters have been identified to stay in submerged rest room bowls, whereas sarcastic fringehead fishes (sure, that’s their actual identify) have been discovered dwelling in beer bottles that landed on the ocean flooring, he stated.

“You may take an outdated interior tube and throw it proper off of Lengthy Seaside in 80 toes of water, and in a few days there might be three brown rockfish staring on the tire,” Love stated. “They’re drawn to stuff. They don’t care what the stuff is.”

As extra offshore platforms are prone to be decommissioned within the subsequent few years, each in Southern California and elsewhere, there was dialogue about leaving the underwater elements intact due to their worth as synthetic reefs.

As a scientist, Love stated he’s impartial on the difficulty. As a human being, he’s not.

“Pulling out a platform means killing big numbers of marine life, and I don’t assume that’s ethical,” he stated. “That has nothing to do with being a biologist. That’s simply my ethical stance.”

Advertisement

The abundance of life round all these buildings is so notable {that a} 2014 paper in Proceedings of the Pure Academy of Sciences declared oil platforms off California some of the productive marine habitats globally.

Nonetheless, Love stated there’s something significantly particular about Elly and the rig sitting proper subsequent to it, often known as Ellen.

“The folks in my lab and myself have been round nearly all of the platforms in California, and Elly and Ellen have an unusually excessive range of fishes round them,” he stated. “They’re simply nice.”

Photos of the oil platform Elly taken by Paige Zhang

A photograph of the oil platform Elly taken by UCLA graduate scholar Paige Zhang. She stated she and her dive buddies instantly began texting forwards and backwards once they heard concerning the spill.

(Paige Zhang)

Advertisement

Shawn Wiedrick, who till just lately labored as an assistant curator of invertebrate paleontology on the Pure Historical past Museum of Los Angeles, described his first dive across the Elly rig as “surreal.”

“There have been organisms on prime of organisms, it was so thick,” he stated. “I used to be tasked with taking place and sampling issues, however there was a lot there, it was nearly overwhelming to say ‘What ought to I pattern?’”

It’s that huge range of life that makes the rig so attractive to native divers, stated Kevin Lee, an underwater photographer who has dived the Elly website greater than 30 occasions.

“It’s such a wonderful ecosystem,” Lee stated. “The life is excellent on the market, and it’s way more colourful than what you’ll see on shore. For some native divers it’s their favourite dive website.”

Ashley Arnold, proprietor of Jade Scuba Adventures, who works out of Huntington Seaside and Port Orchard, Wash., remembers seeing strawberry sea anemone, spiky acorn barnacles, and a stunning array of nudibranchs, some with spikes capturing off their smooth our bodies.

Advertisement

On a dive journey to Elly and Ellen in January, she captured video of 4 kinds of bioluminescent jellyfish — alien-looking life varieties that floated by way of the water. She additionally noticed all kinds of fish, together with shiny orange garibaldi, blue-and-silver halfmoons and several other kinds of rockfish.

“It’s an oasis in the midst of an ocean desert,” she stated. “You’ve obtained nothing however deep-water ocean surrounding it.”

Arnold stated rig diving is greatest for skilled divers: Having good buoyancy management is essential to staying protected when swimming among the many pilings and helps, and the ocean currents might be unstable. Someday there’s no present; different occasions “it’s tremendous loopy ripping.”

“It’s utterly unprotected on the market,” she stated.

Detailed look at some of the sea life below oil platforms Ellen and Elle.

A few of the marine life discovered under the oil platforms Ellen and Elle.

(Paige Zhang)

Advertisement

To get to the rig, divers usually constitution a ship from Lengthy Seaside or San Pedro. It may possibly take 45 minutes to an hour and a half to get to the location, relying on the pace of the boat. Divers additionally must get permission from the rig’s operator earlier than they head out.

“They’re energetic rigs and dealing your entire time we’re diving, but when they’ve a crew popping out to do work on the construction we don’t wish to be of their means,” Arnold stated.

Norbert Lee, a dive teacher and marine biologist who works for L.A. County Sanitation, stated that earlier than the spill, he tried to do day journeys to the rigs three or 4 occasions a yr.

“We often go between Ellen and Elly, and Eureka, which is a rig that’s quite a bit deeper,” he stated.

Advertisement

His technique is to rapidly descend to the utmost depth of the dive after which slowly make his means as much as shallower water — harvesting scallops to eat, and enjoying with sea lions alongside the best way.

“These scallops are tremendous tasty,” he stated. “It’s the most effective dive websites, to be sincere.”

Lee is hopeful the cleanup efforts might be efficient sufficient that he’ll have the ability to dive the rig once more sometime, however stated “it’s arduous to listen to that it got here out of a spot that you simply dive a lot, to not point out all of the ecological impacts it has on the wetlands. It sort of broke my coronary heart.”

Zhang stated she and her dive buddies instantly began texting forwards and backwards once they heard concerning the spill.

Column One

Advertisement

A showcase for compelling storytelling from the Los Angeles Instances

“You hear about oil spills on a regular basis on the information, and you are feeling like they’re up to now out of your life, however this one is so near all of us,” she stated.

She worries concerning the hundreds of thousands of stationary animals on the rig who’re unable to swim away from oil slicks. She wonders how she can assist with the cleanup. And he or she thinks about when she’ll have the ability to get again into the water, and the place.

Advertisement

Zhang obtained extra critical about diving through the pandemic, and, as with many frequent divers, it’s now an important a part of her life.

Strawberry anemones cling to the oil platforms Ellen and Elly off the Southern California coast.

Strawberry anemones cling to the oil platforms Ellen and Elly off the Southern California coast.

(Paige Zhang)

“As soon as I’m down there, I simply really feel like my head is cleared, I don’t take into consideration work, I don’t take into consideration something,” she stated. “You might be completely within the second. It’s gotten to the purpose the place I’ve hassle sleeping if I don’t dive for greater than per week.”

Although not sufficient info has been launched but to make a prediction on when the waters across the rig might be protected for divers once more, Love stated there may be motive to be optimistic that the animals that make their dwelling on Elly will survive this ecological catastrophe.

Advertisement

Ten miles off the coast of Santa Barbara, one other oil platform known as Holly is located amongst massive pure seeps of oil and fuel. Basically, it’s bathed in oil nearly on a regular basis, he stated.

However when Love seemed to see whether or not this platform might assist marine life, he was surprised to find it was coated in thriving sea creatures.

“We didn’t see a lifeless nudibranch or a lifeless something,” he stated.

Love thinks the animals have been spared as a result of all of the oil had risen to the floor. And he’s hopeful the identical might be true for the huge, various and delightful life dwelling on Elly.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Science

Long, frustrating waits for home care persist despite California expanding program

Published

on

Long, frustrating waits for home care persist despite California expanding program

Lyla Abuebaid needs to check on her 5-year-old son through the night to make sure he keeps breathing.

Sayfideen has a rare and serious syndrome that leaves him unable to walk. He relies on a ventilator and has to be monitored 24 hours a day, his mother said. Nurses once helped handle his care at home.

But for months now, that work has instead fallen to his mother, who is also juggling her job as a project manager.

“I’m not functioning,” the San Jose resident said. “I’m not doing well at work. I’m not doing well at home.”

Abuebaid said it feels as though she has to “beg the state for services which he absolutely deserves.”

Advertisement
Two women work with medical equipment used by a child who is wearing blue.
Close-up image of a mother helping her child put his feet into medical braces on a wheelchair.
Close-up image of a mother holding her son's hands.

Lyla Abuebaid has waited for months for help from the state with the care of her son. She sometimes gets help from a family friend, but 5-year-old Sayfideen needs a fulltime caregiver. (Peter DaSilva / For The Times)

She is among thousands of Californians who have been trying to get Medicaid benefits for services to help medically vulnerable people remain at home through the Home and Community-Based Alternatives waiver.

Demand for the HCBA waiver, which helps people who might otherwise have to live in nursing facilities, has far outstripped the available spots. Last summer, California stopped accepting applications for the program as it hit an enrollment cap. Amid an outcry from disability rights advocates and families, California got federal approval to gradually add 7,200 slots over four years to eventually serve more than 16,000 people at a time.

Yet thousands of Californians remain on the wait list. As of June, more than 4,900 people were waiting, according to the Department of Health Care Services — more than twice as many as last summer.

Advertisement

When people have to wait, either “aging adults or disabled people who need services are going without them, or family caregivers are left to fill in the gaps,” said Nicole Jorwic, chief of advocacy and campaigns for Caring Across Generations. Some could end up in nursing facilities “because there just aren’t alternatives.”

Disability rights advocates had warned the state last year that the planned increase in slots would not clear the existing wait list for years, let alone reach more Californians who might find themselves in need of care as they face unexpected illness or injury.

“I don’t know that they’ve done anything to solve the problem,” said Clovis resident Sarah Scharnick, who first spoke with The Times about the wait list last fall and is still on it. Her husband requires round-the-clock care, including being turned at night to prevent bedsores, after a bicycle crash.

Long hours of nursing care at home are not typically covered by private insurers, forcing many families to resort to placing their loved ones in nursing facilities or to shoulder their care themselves, advocates say. Abuebaid said her private insurance would not cover her son’s nursing care. He had previously gotten assistance through Medi-Cal, the California Medicaid program, then lost his coverage.

Paying for such care out of pocket “would bankrupt a millionaire,” said Katelyn Ashton, executive director of Loretta’s Little Miracles, which cares for medically fragile children. For many families unable to access the waiver, “their only option is to quit their job and provide that care themselves at home.”

Advertisement

State officials said that with the added slots, nearly 10,800 people could be in the program at a time this year. Despite the demand for the program, however, more than 1,500 HCBA slots remained unfilled as of June, according to the healthcare services department.

The reason: The department said it is currently releasing only about 200 slots a month. Throwing open all the slots at once, it said, “would cause administrative backlogs” for both local agencies that take applications and for the state, “due to the high number of applications to process.” The state agency said it has limited resources, “including staff, to review the existing volume of enrollment packets.”

It has seven nurses who work on reviewing the enrollment packets — only two of them doing so full time — and four other staffers who assist with the wait list, the agency said. DHCS said the process can also be delayed by scheduling difficulties at local agencies that field applications.

The lag has alarmed groups like Disability Rights California and Justice in Aging. U.S. Rep. Nanette Barragán (D-San Pedro) said she had called for Gov. Gavin Newsom “to put the resources there to make sure that they’re filling slots as quickly as they can.”

“Putting people in this program saves the state money in the long run,” she said.

Advertisement

Providing such care for someone at home is far less expensive than moving them into a nursing home, state figures show: The Department of Health Care Services estimated in a May report that the average nursing facility costs more than $134,000 annually, compared with roughly $53,000 for each person in the program.

“We step over a dollar to pick up a dime a lot of times,” said Jim Frazier, a former California Assembly member and director of public policy for the Arc of California, which advocates for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities. “We don’t look at the long-term cost savings.”

The healthcare department estimated 40% of people accessing the program were not coming from nursing homes, but “from the community.” Researchers have found that longer waits for such programs can prove costly even if people aren’t already living in institutions: In Iowa, older people were more likely to end up spending time in a nursing home within a few years if they had applied for such waivers when waits were long, researchers found.

The logjam has also undercut efforts to help homeless people who are medically vulnerable, advocates said. In the Bay Area, Cardea Health Chief Executive Alexis Chettiar said the unhoused clients that her nonprofit serves “are too sick to live in a home without support, they are disallowed from shelters because they may be incontinent or have malodorous wounds,” and nursing homes are often unwilling to take them.

Her nonprofit has instead worked to enroll them in the HCBA program as they are housed. The group said it has saved over $7 million annually by reducing emergency room visits, hospitalizations and other medical costs for such patients.

Advertisement

“It really works,” Chettiar said. “Or I should say — it was working really magnificently until we hit the cap.”

More than 90 of their clients are now on the waiting list, where some have languished over a year and a half. Cardea Health has been footing the bill for their care, but Chettiar said it cannot do so forever: It has relied on a few years of “seed funding” from local governments when it starts services at a site, but had planned to get patients onto the HCBA waiver for continued care.

As California releases slots, it has been prioritizing people under the age of 21, as well as people who have already been stuck for months in health facilities, among others. DHCS said opening up slots month by month has allowed it to continuously ensure that those applications go to the front of the line. Abuebaid said that after months of waiting, her child had recently been scheduled for an intake appointment.

For Californians who do not fit those criteria, however, the waits can be especially punishing. As of June, more than 90% of those on the HCBA wait list were not in the priority groups, according to the state.

The Marik family at their Santa Clarita home: Eli, 7; Jenina; Tyler and Owen, 4.

Jenina Marik has ALS. The family applied through the state nearly a year ago for in-home care, and husband Tyler Marik worries he may have to stop working to focus on caregiving.

(Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times)

Advertisement

Among them is Jenina Marik, who was diagnosed roughly a year and a half ago with the neurodegenerative disorder ALS. Within a few years, the 40-year-old Valencia woman went from running a half marathon, operating her wedding photography business and corralling her young sons to being unable to feed or dress herself.

Her husband, Tyler Marik, turned to a caregiving service to assist her while he went to work, but “I was going broke.” After months of struggle, the family eventually got some help through a government program for in-home care, but “it’s nowhere near enough.”

Because Jenina, now quadriplegic, still needs care throughout the night, “I get maybe five hours of sleep a night. … And when I’m tired that can compromise her safety,” Tyler Marik said.

The HCBA waiver could afford them more care, but it’s been nearly a year since they applied. Marik fears he may have to stop working if nothing changes. Moving his wife into a facility “would be a nightmare,” he said.

Advertisement

“That would be even worse than ALS.”

A father sprays a hose toward his son in a backyard of a suburban home. A child stands next to his dad; mother looks on.

Eli Marik, 7, cools off in the backyard with father Tyler, brother Owen, 4, and mother Jenina.

(Myung J. Chun / Los Angeles Times)

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Science

Ever see a star explode? You're about to get a chance very soon

Published

on

Ever see a star explode? You're about to get a chance very soon

Every clear night for the last three weeks, Bob Stephens has pointed his home telescope at the same two stars in hopes of witnessing one of the most violent events in the universe — a nova explosion a hundred thousand times brighter than the sun.

The eruption, which scientists say could happen any day now, has excited the interest of major observatories worldwide, and it promises to advance our understanding of turbulent binary star systems.

Yet for all the high-tech observational power that NASA and other scientific institutions can muster, astrophysicists are relying on countless amateur astronomers like Stephens to spot the explosion first.

The reason? It’s just too costly to keep their equipment focused on the same subject for months at a time.

“I think everyone will look at it while it happens, but sitting there just looking at it isn’t going to make it happen,” said Tom Meneghini, the director of telescope operations and executive director emeritus at the Mt. Wilson Observatory. “It’s like a watched pot,” he joked.

Advertisement

The star is so far away that it takes 3,000 years for its light to reach the Earth, meaning the explosion occurred before the last of the Egyptian pyramids were built. It will appear about as bright as the North Star for just a few days before fading into the darkness.

Once it’s spotted, some of the most advanced observatories on Earth and in space will join in watching, including NASA’s James Webb Space Telescope.

“A lot of people are eagerly waiting to spot the new jewel in the crown,” said Mansi Kasliwal, the Caltech astronomy professor who is planning to use the Palomar Observatory in northeast San Diego County to observe the event. The nova will erupt in the Corona Borealis, or Northern Crown, constellation.

Steve Flanders, outreach coordinator for Palomar Observatory, shows the observatory’s Gattini-IR telescope, which Caltech professor Mansi Kasliwal’s team will use to observe the Blaze star explosion.

(Hayne Palmour IV/For The Times)

Advertisement

T Coronae Borealis, also called the Blaze Star, is actually two stars — a hot, dense white dwarf, and a cooler red giant.

The dwarf star, which ran out of fuel long ago and collapsed to roughly the size of Earth, has been siphoning hydrogen gas from its larger neighbor for about a human lifetime.

This stolen gas has accumulated in a disk around the dwarf like a hot, messy version of Saturn’s rings. Soon, the disk will grow so heavy that it will become violent and unwieldy, and inevitably, explode like a thermonuclear bomb.

Neither star is destroyed however, and the process repeats itself roughly every 80 years.

Advertisement
Bob Stephens points to a computer screen with data from the Blaze Star.

Stephens has data from T Coronae Borealis going back years. The oscillations in the data represent the two stars orbiting around each other.

(Robert Gauthier/Los Angeles Times)

This time around, there’s an army of enthusiasts like Stephens ready to sound the alarm when the star goes nova.

Far from mere hobbyists, a number of these amateur observers have published their own scientific research. Stephens even built his own observatory as an addition to his house in Rancho Cucamonga.

“The city thinks it’s a sunroom,” Stephens said. After the inspector stopped by, he removed the screws securing the roof, allowing him to roll it off to reveal the clear sky to his telescope.

Advertisement

Every night, he turns on the telescope and spends more than an hour taking data, which he later posts to an online community of amateur astronomers who monitor the star almost nonstop.

Major observatories simply cannot keep such constant watch. Hundreds of scientists compete for time to look at a wide range of astronomical targets every night. For them, keeping these telescopes glued to the Blaze Star is a waste of valuable observation time.

Estimates on when the nova will occur vary, but most astrophysicists agree it will happen before the end of the year, and likely by the end of August.

Once it blows, there are a few alert systems set up to notify amateurs and professionals. Some observatories have even programmed their telescopes to autonomously ditch their current observation plan and look at the star when the notification comes in, Stephens said.

Major observatories also face another complication. Many of their telescopes are designed to look at the faintest and dimmest targets, but the Blaze Star nova will be anything but faint. Pointing these telescopes at the nova would overwhelm sensors, resulting in a washed-out, overexposed picture.

Advertisement

That’s why Palomar Observatory, Caltech’s research station in north San Diego County, isn’t using its iconic 16-foot-wide Hale telescope under its massive white dome. Instead, it’s using a much smaller telescope, called Gattini-IR, located in a small brick building about a quarter mile down the road.

Once the nova happens, Gattini-IR will go from observing the Blaze Star every couple nights to every couple hours.

Steve Flanders enters the small building on the Palomar Observatory grounds where the Gattini-IR telescope is set up.

Steve Flanders enters the small building on the Palomar Observatory grounds where the Gattini-IR telescope is set up. The Gattini-IR telescope is monitoring the Blaze Star, which is expected to go nova.

(Hayne Palmour IV/For The Times)

Scientists say they still have a lot to learn about novas. For example, physicists are still unsure why some erupt every decade while others likely don’t for millennia.

Advertisement

Some researchers suspect that novas like the Blaze Star could be precursors to supernovas. These explosions — billions of times brighter than the sun — destroy the star, often leaving behind a black hole. Supernovas are also a useful tool for astronomers to measure distance.

Studying similar events has already led to discoveries, however.

Recently, scientists determined that novas tend to fling material into space at faster speeds than what would be predicted based on the intensity of the explosion.

“We want to understand the physics of novae, so having a nova that’s as close as T Coronae Borelias, which will hopefully be very well studied by all telescopes … we can get a very full picture,” said Caltech professor Kasliwal.

Some of that understanding will be due in part to amateur astronomers.

Advertisement

Thanks to the rapid development of telescopes, amateurs are working with technology that professionals didn’t have just 20 years ago, let alone 80, said Forrest Sims, an amateur astronomer from Apache Junction, Ariz., who is also observing the star every clear night.

And the amateurs can achieve better coverage than the big telescopes because “we typically have complete control over when and where we can point [our telescopes],” said Sims. “A professional may have to write a grant to get a half hour or two hours time on a big telescope.”

That allows them to collect a lot of data. And with hundreds in the community observing from around the world, they can achieve almost continuous coverage of the Blaze Star. Many, including Sims and Stephens, post their data to the American Assn. of Variable Star Observers website, allowing everyone to use the data.

Stephens remembers reading a journal article from a professional who managed to observe five asteroids over two years. “I thought, I could do that in a month,” Stephens said. He went on to publish a paper with 10 observations.

A bearded man's face is reflected in the lens of a telescope.

In his at-home observatory, Bob Stephens is using a Borg 101 telescope. “Resistance is futile!” Stephens said when introducing the telescope, a reference to the phrase uttered by “the Borg” in “Star Trek.”

(Robert Gauthier/Los Angeles Times)

Advertisement

One professor was so shocked by the number Stephens was able to see that she reached out and agreed to fly to Puerto Rico for an asteroid conference just to meet him. They ended up working together — Stephens had the telescopes; she had the connections in the field.

Today, amateur astronomers’ work is getting so sophisticated, many in the field have a hard time calling them amateurs.

“We call ourselves ‘small telescope scientists,’ ” said Sims. “It sounds more fun, and in some respects, professionals — and not even grudgingly — will admit that the work we’re doing is often professional caliber.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Science

Artificial Intelligence Gives Weather Forecasters a New Edge

Published

on

Artificial Intelligence Gives Weather Forecasters a New Edge

The National Hurricane Center (American) 5-day, ECMWF (European), and GraphCast models from July 1, 2024 at 8 p.m. Eastern. All times on the map are Eastern.

By William B. Davis

In early July, as Hurricane Beryl churned through the Caribbean, a top European weather agency predicted a range of final landfalls, warning that that Mexico was most likely. The alert was based on global observations by planes, buoys and spacecraft, which room-size supercomputers then turned into forecasts.

That same day, experts running artificial intelligence software on a much smaller computer predicted landfall in Texas. The forecast drew on nothing more than what the machine had previously learned about the planet’s atmosphere.

Advertisement

Four days later, on July 8, Hurricane Beryl slammed into Texas with deadly force, flooding roads, killing at least 36 people and knocking out power for millions of residents. In Houston, the violent winds sent trees slamming into homes, crushing at least two of the victims to death.

A composite satellite image of Hurricane Beryl approaching the Texas coast on July 8.

NOAA, via European Press Agency, via Shutterstock

The Texas prediction offers a glimpse into the emerging world of A.I. weather forecasting, in which a growing number of smart machines are anticipating future global weather patterns with new speed and accuracy. In this case, the experimental program was GraphCast, created in London by DeepMind, a Google company. It does in minutes and seconds what once took hours.

Advertisement

“This is a really exciting step,” said Matthew Chantry, an A.I. specialist at the European Center for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts, the agency that got upstaged on its Beryl forecast. On average, he added, GraphCast and its smart cousins can outperform his agency in predicting hurricane paths.

In general, superfast A.I. can shine at spotting dangers to come, said Christopher S. Bretherton, an emeritus professor of atmospheric sciences at the University of Washington. For treacherous heats, winds and downpours, he said, the usual warnings will be “more up-to-date than right now,” saving untold lives.

Rapid A.I. weather forecasts will also aid scientific discovery, said Amy McGovern, a professor of meteorology and computer science at the University of Oklahoma who directs an A.I. weather institute. She said weather sleuths now use A.I. to create thousands of subtle forecast variations that let them find unexpected factors that can drive such extreme events as tornadoes.

“It’s letting us look for fundamental processes,” Dr. McGovern said. “It’s a valuable tool to discover new things.”

Importantly, the A.I. models can run on desktop computers, making the technology much easier to adopt than the room-size supercomputers that now rule the world of global forecasting.

Advertisement

Abandoned vehicles under an overpass in Sugar Land, Texas, on July 8.

Brandon Bell/Getty Images

“It’s a turning point,” said Maria Molina, a research meteorologist at the University of Maryland who studies A.I. programs for extreme-event prediction. “You don’t need a supercomputer to generate a forecast. You can do it on your laptop, which makes the science more accessible.”

People depend on accurate weather forecasts to make decisions about such things as how to dress, where to travel and whether to flee a violent storm.

Advertisement

Even so, reliable weather forecasts turn out to be extraordinarily hard to achieve. The trouble is complexity. Astronomers can predict the paths of the solar system’s planets for centuries to come because a single factor dominates their movements — the sun and its immense gravitational pull.

In contrast, the weather patterns on Earth arise from a riot of factors. The tilts, the spins, the wobbles and the day-night cycles of the planet turn the atmosphere into turbulent whorls of winds, rains, clouds, temperatures and air pressures. Worse, the atmosphere is inherently chaotic. On its own, with no external stimulus, a particular zone can go quickly from stable to capricious.

As a result, weather forecasts can fail after a few days, and sometimes after a few hours. The errors grow in step with the length of the prediction — which today can extend for 10 days, up from three days a few decades ago. The slow improvements stem from upgrades to the global observations as well as the supercomputers that make the predictions.

Not that supercomputing work has grown easy. The preparations take skill and toil. Modelers build a virtual planet crisscrossed by millions of data voids and fill the empty spaces with current weather observations.

Dr. Bretherton of the University of Washington called these inputs crucial and somewhat improvisational. “You have to blend data from many sources into a guess at what the atmosphere is doing right now,” he said.

Advertisement

The knotty equations of fluid mechanics then turn the blended observations into predictions. Despite the enormous power of supercomputers, the number crunching can take an hour or more. And of course, as the weather changes, the forecasts must be updated.

The A.I. approach is radically different. Instead of relying on current readings and millions of calculations, an A.I. agent draws on what it has learned about the cause-and-effect relationships that govern the planet’s weather.

In general, the advance derives from the ongoing revolution in machine learning — the branch of A.I. that mimics how humans learn. The method works with great success because A.I. excels at pattern recognition. It can rapidly sort through mountains of information and spot intricacies that humans cannot discern. Doing so has led to breakthroughs in speech recognition, drug discovery, computer vision and cancer detection.

In weather forecasting, A.I. learns about atmospheric forces by scanning repositories of real-world observations. It then identifies the subtle patterns and uses that knowledge to predict the weather, doing so with remarkable speed and accuracy.

Recently, the DeepMind team that built GraphCast won Britain’s top engineering prize, presented by the Royal Academy of Engineering. Sir Richard Friend, a physicist at Cambridge University who led the judging panel, praised the team for what he called “a revolutionary advance.”

Advertisement

In an interview, Rémi Lam, GraphCast’s lead scientist, said his team had trained the A.I. program on four decades of global weather observations compiled by the European forecasting center. “It learns directly from historical data,” he said. In seconds, he added, GraphCast can produce a 10-day forecast that would take a supercomputer more than an hour.

Dr. Lam said GraphCast ran best and fastest on computers designed for A.I., but could also work on desktops and even laptops, though more slowly.

In a series of tests, Dr. Lam reported, GraphCast outperformed the best forecasting model of the European Center for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts more than 90 percent of the time. “If you know where a cyclone is going, that’s quite important,” he added. “It’s important for saving lives.”

A damaged home in Freeport, Texas, in the hurricane’s aftermath.

Brandon Bell/Getty Images

Advertisement

Replying to a question, Dr. Lam said he and his team were computer scientists, not cyclone experts, and had not evaluated how GraphCast’s predictions for Hurricane Beryl compared to other forecasts in precision.

But DeepMind, he added, did conduct a study of Hurricane Lee, an Atlantic storm that in September was seen as possibly threatening New England or, farther east, Canada. Dr. Lam said the study found that GraphCast locked in on landfall in Nova Scotia three days before the supercomputers reached the same conclusion.

Impressed by such accomplishments, the European center recently embraced GraphCast as well as A.I. forecasting programs made by Nvidia, Huawei and Fudan University in China. On its website, it now displays global maps of its A.I. testing, including the range of path forecasts that the smart machines made for Hurricane Beryl on July 4.

The track predicted by DeepMind’s GraphCast, labeled DMGC on the July 4 map, shows Beryl making landfall in the region of Corpus Christi, Texas, not far from where the hurricane actually hit.

Advertisement

Dr. Chantry of the European center said the institution saw the experimental technology as becoming a regular part of global weather forecasting, including for cyclones. A new team, he added, is now building on “the great work” of the experimentalists to create an operational A.I. system for the agency.

Its adoption, Dr. Chantry said, could happen soon. He added, however, that the A.I. technology as a regular tool might coexist with the center’s legacy forecasting system.

Dr. Bretherton, now a team leader at the Allen Institute for A.I. (established by Paul G. Allen, one of the founders of Microsoft), said the European center was considered the world’s top weather agency because comparative tests have regularly shown its forecasts to exceed all others in accuracy. As a result, he added, its interest in A.I. has the world of meteorologists “looking at this and saying, ‘Hey, we’ve got to match this.’”

Weather experts say the A.I. systems are likely to complement the supercomputer approach because each method has its own particular strengths.

“All models are wrong to some extent,” Dr. Molina of the University of Maryland said. The A.I. machines, she added, “might get the hurricane track right but what about rain, maximum winds and storm surge? There’re so many diverse impacts” that need to be forecast reliably and assessed carefully.

Advertisement

Even so, Dr. Molina noted that A.I. scientists were rushing to post papers that demonstrate new forecasting skills. “The revolution is continuing,” she said. “It’s wild.”

Jamie Rhome, deputy director of the National Hurricane Center in Miami, agreed on the need for multiple tools. He called A.I. “evolutionary rather than revolutionary” and predicted that humans and supercomputers would continue to play major roles.

“Having a human at the table to apply situational awareness is one of the reasons we have such good accuracy,” he said.

Mr. Rhome added that the hurricane center had used aspects of artificial intelligence in its forecasts for more than a decade, and that the agency would evaluate and possibly draw on the brainy new programs.

“With A.I. coming on so quickly, many people see the human role as diminishing,” Mr. Rhome added. “But our forecasters are making big contributions. There’s still very much a strong human role.”

Advertisement

Sources and notes

The National Hurricane Center (NHC) and European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts (ECMWF) | Notes: The “actual path” of Beryl uses the NHC’s preliminary best track data.

Continue Reading

Trending