New Jersey
NJ state Senate passes bill that will dismantle public access to government records, data
3-minute read
Legislation that would gut public access to government records and data was passed by the state Senate on Monday. It was to be considered by the Assembly later Monday afternoon.
State Senate President Nick Scutari said after the Senate’s voting session that the legislation — billed as a reform of the New Jersey Open Public Records Act — was an effort to save taxpayers money.
While the bill was under discussion last week in the Senate budget committee, lawmakers said it was focused on limiting data brokering and commercial access. Provisions dealing with regulation of data brokers, however, were removed from the final version of the bill.
Scutari also said the Legislature — controlled by Democrats — has been exempt since the bill was introduced and that the legislation’s sponsors are listening to the concerns of small-town New Jersey mayors.
“This isn’t about us. This is what I heard on my first day as Senate president at the League of Municipalities when I wasn’t even sworn in yet,” he said.
There were 21 votes in favor and 10 votes against. Nine state senators did not vote, including Sens. Anthony Bucco, James Holzapfel and Shirley Turner, who were not present.
One lawmaker noted after the session that not voting is the equivalent of a no but shows respect to the effort of the sponsors.
State Sen. Andrew Zwicker voted against the bill in committee both in March and last week. He said after the voting session, “From everything I understand this will make it more difficult [to get records], and that is my concern.
“I think we made it better in the amendments, but it didn’t go far enough for me to vote for the bill,” Zwicker said.
Will government records ‘be readily available?’
The bill cleared committee in both chambers on Thursday and Friday after hours of testimony in opposition from advocates.
The proposed law initially cleared committee in the upper chamber in March but was pulled from consideration in an Assembly committee that same week just minutes before it was set to start.
There were no such delays this month, though, and while there were votes against the bill in each committee — three in the state Senate and one in the Assembly — it ultimately moved forward.
The most recent version of the bill removes the presumption of access clause at the beginning of the OPRA statute, which notes that “government records shall be readily accessible,” and the Senate Majority Office said that section “will remain intact as part of the OPRA law.”
“That section is not being removed from the OPRA law, just from the bill,” spokesperson Richard McGrath said. “It came out of the legislation because that section of the law is no longer being amended.”
While advocates from groups like the ACLU, New Jersey Working Families and New Jersey Citizen Action have been outspokenly opposed to the bill since it was first introduced in March, not everyone thinks it’s a bad bill.
Representatives from organizations including the League of Municipalities, New Jersey School Boards Association and New Jersey Association of Counties have been supported the legislation. Some spokesmen for those organizations — including the league’s executive director, Michael Cerra — said they would have liked the legislation to go even further to restrict public access to government records and data.
Since the bill was first heard in committee in March, Republicans in both chambers have joined as sponsors — state Sen. Anthony Bucco in the upper chamber and Assemblywoman Victoria Flynn in the lower chamber.
Our view: Amended OPRA bill an absolute sham. Gov. Murphy, veto this affront to democracy
What will the legislation do to gut OPRA?
The updated bill includes the renewed ability to make anonymous requests and the removal of exemptions for call and email logs and digital calendars.
It also implements stricter requirements on how to request things like texts and emails including specific accounts, times, topics and titles.
There are modifications to the provision limiting access to metadata to allow for access only to the “portion that identifies authorship, identity of editor, and time of change.”
Language restricting data brokers and commercial entities that resell information obtained through OPRA was removed.
The parts that remain mostly intact include one of the most controversial, known as the fee-shifting provision. This provision previously required public record custodians that had not, according to a judge, properly provided records to pay the requesters’ attorney fees.
The bill initially changed that to say winners of OPRA lawsuits “may” be entitled to legal fees if the public agency is found to have knowingly violated the law or unreasonably denied access. In its amended form, the bill still eliminates the attorney fee requirement but does allow for judges to decide that fees are warranted if the denial was unreasonable, if the agency “acted in bad faith, or knowingly and willfully violated” the law.
The amendments also include language that would allow for a court to “issue a protective order limiting the number and scope of requests the requester may make” if they “sought records with the intent to substantially interrupt the performance of government function.”
The legislation was first enacted in 2002 and requires local, county and state government entities to provide the public with access to government records in New Jersey.
Katie Sobko covers the New Jersey Statehouse. Email: sobko@northjersey.com
New Jersey
New Jersey governor’s race: Jack Ciattarelli votes early; Mikie Sherrill to campaign with Obama
NEW JERSEY (WABC) — Democrat Mikie Sherrill is preparing for a campaign blitz this weekend and Republican Jack Ciattarelli cast his vote in the New Jersey gubernatorial election on Friday.
The energy was high and so was the optimism for Ciattarelli who voted early in Bridgewater. He has shifted to a full court press of campaigning over the next four days until Election Day.
“We try to touch four counties every day, there’s eight stops today, we’ve got rallies all throughout the state, reminding people that we’re still in the midst of early voting,” Ciattarelli said. “Two more days after today and reminding people to don’t wait till Tuesday. Anything can happen.”
Turnout is high for early voting and mail-in ballots as nearly one million New Jerseyans have already voted.
“I am a strong law and order, yet compassion for our citizens. I think we could do both with Jack,” voter Claudia Levin Bateman said.
“New Jerseyans are fed up, paying high electrical bills, paying taxes, fees, tolls, everything keeps going up. Our government’s a mess. We need to sort of rally to come in and save New Jersey,” voter Phillipe Pedroso said.
This is the second most expensive gubernatorial race in the state’s history.
Sherrill’s campaign has edged out Ciattarelli in fundraising — $51 million to $47 million.
That is mirrored by campaign spending. Sherrill has spent $43 million and Ciattarelli has spent $39.7 million.
“I feel great, I only have ’21 to compare it to, I really thought I was going to win that race,” Ciattarelli said. “You know how close we came? This one feels very different. Energy up and down. The state is electric. The reception in the minority communities across states been overwhelming positive.”
Sherrill has also been on the campaign trail all week and former President Barack Obama will headline a rally for her Saturday in Newark.
“To me, centering a campaign and what you are hearing on the ground, cutting out the noise sometimes from what’s going on online or elsewhere, but really centering on the very people that you want to serve is incredibly important and I think incredibly successful,” Sherrill said.
———-
* Get Eyewitness News Delivered
* More New Jersey news
* Send us a news tip
* Download the abc7NY app for breaking news alerts
* Follow us on YouTube
Submit a tip or story idea to Eyewitness News
Have a breaking news tip or an idea for a story we should cover? Send it to Eyewitness News using the form below. If attaching a video or photo, terms of use apply.
Copyright © 2025 WABC-TV. All Rights Reserved.
New Jersey
Addressing NJ Food Bank luncheon, Feeding America CEO stresses the need as SNAP cuts loom
More than 350 people came together in Whippany, New Jersey, on Thursday for the annual Women Fighting Hunger Luncheon to benefit the Community FoodBank of New Jersey (CFBNJ).
New Jersey’s largest anti-hunger organization, CFBNJ services 15 counties in helping more than 750,000 people with food insecurity.
NBC 4 New York Anchor Natalie Pasquarella moderated a discussion on how to tackle hunger with keynote speaker Claire Babineaux-Fontenot, the CEO of Feeding America and Elizabeth McCarthy, President and CEO of CFBNJ.
“I think sometimes people misunderstand SNAP and don’t know that 82% of households who are getting SNAP have a working adult in the household,” says McCarthy. “It’s just really hard with prices going up and wages staying flat for people to make it paycheck to paycheck. Almost half the people on SNAP are children.”
More than 350 people came together for the Women Fighting Hunger luncheon in Whippany. NBC New York’s Natalie Pasquarella moderated a discussion with local advocates and Feeding America’s CEO, who has called SNAP cuts a “crisis situation” for local families, adding that one in nine New Jersey residents are food insecure.
Babineaux-Fontenot, head of the nation’s largest domestic hunger-relief organization, told NBC New York that this is a crisis situation and people can take action in their communities.
“The reality is that this could truly be cataclysmic for this whole state and the nation,” said Babineaux-Fontenot. “They should reach out to their members of Congress and tell them, this issue matters. It’s not something we should play around with. It’s not a bargaining chip. Let’s make sure that everyone in your community gets the food that they need.”
Prior to the luncheon, guests packed donation bags full of non-perishable items which will be distributed across New Jersey.
To learn more about CFBNJ, click here. To learn more about Feeding America, click here.
New Jersey
George Norcross threatens lawsuit over New Jersey racketeering case, seeks reporters’ records
South Jersey political boss George Norcross is threatening to sue New Jersey law enforcement leaders who fingered him and key associates in a criminal racketeering case that was thrown out of court earlier this year.
In an Oct. 7 “litigation hold” letter, Norcross attorney Joseph Podraza of the Lamb McErlane firm in Philadelphia writes that tort claim notices have been filed—the written notification required before filing a lawsuit against a public entity or employee—over the “unfounded allegations and charges” against the party leader and his associates.
A damage suit, if filed, would be the latest in a series of efforts by Norcross and his allies to attack and discredit Attorney General Matthew Platkin, his investigators, and other state officials who have alleged wrongdoing connected to the party leader or his Camden-based insurance brokerage.
This time, Norcross is seeking the records of journalists who published stories that raised questions about how the Democrat and his political allies benefited from a state tax break program they helped author.
Be more informed and empowered with the facts. Never miss a story. Sign up for our free newsletter. →
The letter sent by Podraza singles out two journalists — this writer and former WNYC reporter Nancy Solomon.
The pair, while working in 2019 for the New York-based investigative news outlet ProPublica, documented how Norcross and his allies, including his brother, lawyer-lobbyist Philip Norcross, amassed properties and development rights on Camden’s Delaware River waterfront.
The 111-page racketeering indictment against Norcross and his associates, including former Camden Mayor Dana Redd, claimed the cabal strong-armed rival businessmen and nonprofits out of their legitimate property rights on the waterfront to capitalize on the lucrative tax breaks carved out for the city.
Norcross and two partners used $245 million in state tax breaks to build an 18-story office tower for their businesses on the river. Norcross also used the tax break money to partner in a new waterfront hotel.
Norcross is now seeking all audio recordings, interview notes, text messages, social media messages and posts, videotapes, spteadsheets, databases, telephone logs, Internet usage files, and records of any electronic correspondence between the reporters and a range of individuals who were connected to Platkin’s investigation or took part in the Camden development.
We uncover stories no one else is telling about the Garden State. Stand with independent news and help us keep digging. →
All told, the letter from Norcross’ attorney names some four dozen people, from Attorney General’s Office investigators and former members of Gov. Phil Murphy’s executive staff, such as ex-senior aide Dan Bryan, to outside political advisers such as Brad Lawrence and Steve DeMicco, founders of the New Brunswick communications firm Message & Media Inc.
Norcross is also demanding records of any communication with prominent figures from his own circle, including Susan Bass Levin, president and CEO of Cooper Health System in Camden, the hospital network chaired by the party leader. He also seeks records from several individuals who emerged as unnamed witnesses in the indictment, including Anthony Perno, the former head of a Camden nonprofit allegedly muscled aside by the Norcross network.
Perno and the others would figure prominently in any corruption trial if Platkin’s request to reinstate the racketeering charges is granted by a state appeals court. Oral arguments on the appeal are scheduled for Nov. 6.
Media lawyers say that any effort to force reporters to disclose notes or sources or information is likely to fail. New Jersey law affords journalists and other news media employees strong protections against such disclosure in the form of the state “shield law.”
The law “provides the news media far-reaching protections that are equaled by few states in the nation,” according to a history of the law compiled by the nonprofit Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press.
The shield created an absolute privilege against compelled disclosure in civil cases and a qualified privilege in criminal cases, according to the orrganization. Journalists in New Jersey who have been pressured to disclose information have prevailed and have been awarded attorney fees, lawyers point out.
“There’s no doubt about it, it’s the best shield law in the country,” said Bruce Rosen, a prominent First Amendment lawyer with the Pashman Stein firm in Hackensack. “I can’t see a situation where a reporter has to give up sources in any civil damage case.”
Platkin’s office declined to comment on a possible damage suit.
Norcross has enjoyed steady support in his campaign against the hard-charging Platkin from political allies who have benefited from the party leader’s influence in Trenton and beyond.
Former Gov. Chris Christie, a Republican and former U.S. attorney known for prosecuting political corruption, at one point called Platkin’s racketeering case “garbage.”
Earlier this week, speaking at a New Jersey Business and Industry Association forum, Christie upped his criticism.
“I don’t think there’s been a person more deceitful and more destructive to state government in my lifetime here than the current attorney general. He is a disgrace to law enforcement,” he said. “As someone who did it for seven years myself, I’m embarrassed.”
The following day, Platkin responded to the criticism, saying: “I wish the former governor well in the twilight of his career.”
Another Norcross ally, longtime New Jersey NAACP President Richard Smith, sent an amicus brief to the Superior Court arguing that Platkin’s case be dismissed. The move raised the hackles of Camden progressives, including members of the African American community, who have sought to end the party boss system developed by Norcross.
In August, Smith, who serves on the Cooper University Health Care Board of Trustees with Norcross, took things a step further, calling for the abolishment of the state Office of Public Integrity and Accountability. The office, overseen by Platkin, led the investigation of Norcross and his associates. Smith joined a letter signed by several lawmakers and other Norcross allies claiming the “scandal-plagued” office was wasting millions while using illegal tactics to harass innocent defendants.
Norcross’ public defense campaign has also been taken up by prominent Democrats such as Donald Scarinci, a Hudson County attorney who has represented politicians, including the disgraced Robert Menendez. The former U.S. senator from Union City is serving an 11-year prison sentence after he was caught accepting gold bars and other bribes from foreign agents.
Earlier this year, Scarinci also attacked State Comptroller Kevin Walsh for pursuing an investigation that documented how insurance brokerages owned by George Norcross under the banner of Conner Strong & Buckelew benefited from public insurance funds the party boss has managed for more than 15 years—a claim Norcross denies.
“Much like the Norcross criminal indictment, the [Comptroller] report appears politically motivated and legally unsupported,” Scarinci wrote in a Sept. 27 column published in The New Jersey Globe.
Scarinci described Platkin’s case against Norcross as “lawfare” and defended the hardball politics and dealmaking the party leader is known for. “There is a very important difference between violating the law and taking advantage of business opportunities,” he wrote.
Power accountability journalism in the Garden State
Your support keeps independent journalism working for New Jersey — and for you. Help our nonprofit newsroom hold leaders accountable and keep the Garden State informed by donating today.

Jeff Pillets is a freelance journalist whose stories have been featured by ProPublica, New Jersey Spotlight News, WNYC-New York Public Radio and The Record. He was named a Pulitzer Prize finalist in 2008 for stories on waste and abuse in New Jersey state government. Contact jeffpillets AT icloud.com.
-
New York1 week agoVideo: How Mamdani Has Evolved in the Mayoral Race
-
News1 week agoVideo: Driver Crashes Car Into Security Gate Near White House
-
News1 week agoVideo: Inside Our Reporter’s Collection of Guantánamo Portraits
-
World1 week agoTrump to host NATO chief at White House as Putin meeting collapses
-
Politics1 week agoJack Smith defends subpoenaing Republican senators’ phone records: ‘Entirely proper’
-
News1 week agoNew York City ICE raid nets 9 arrests of illegal aliens from West Africa, 4 protesters also arrested
-
News4 days agoWith food stamps set to dry up Nov. 1, SNAP recipients say they fear what’s next
-
Milwaukee, WI3 days agoLongtime anchor Shannon Sims is leaving Milwaukee’s WTMJ-TV (Channel 4)