New Hampshire
Drag queens settle defamation lawsuit against N.H. lawmaker for $100k each plus a public apology – The Boston Globe
McMahon, 25, said he’s a big fan of free speech.
“But I think people need to realize that it comes with consequences,” he said.
Their case highlights a tense environment for drag performers and LGBTQ+ people more broadly, both in New Hampshire and across the country, as conservative state lawmakers and some extremist groups have sought to exert political pressure against rising acceptance and visibility for people who defy binary notions of sex and gender.
Love, a Republican, was sponsoring an ill-fated bill in 2022 to require public libraries to conduct background checks on all staff and volunteers when he cited concerns about recent library events featuring drag queens. He mentioned two performers in particular without naming them.
Love testified before a New Hampshire House committee that one performer had been revealed to be a “convicted sex offender” after an event at a library in Nashua and another had been seen “rubbing butts” with kids during an event that was held at a private venue in Derry after opponents objected to holding the event at the local library — but he didn’t have his facts straight.
In bringing their lawsuit, Champion and McMahon alleged Love had clearly been referring to them. They noted Champion had performed for a teen-oriented event at the Nashua Public Library, and McMahon had performed for a family-friendly storytime event at the Tupelo Music Hall in Derry.
Love claimed the lawsuit hadn’t adequately alleged that his comments were about the plaintiffs, but Merrimack County Superior Court Judge Brian T. Tucker disagreed. In a preliminary ruling in January, he found that Champion and McMahon had each outlined a plausible defamation claim.
Tucker also rejected an assertion that Love was entitled to absolute legislative immunity for comments he made as a sitting lawmaker discussing pending legislation.
Although the New Hampshire Constitution says legislative speech and debate “cannot be the foundation of any action, complaint, or prosecution,” that shield didn’t apply to comments Love made when he expounded on his testimony during a subsequent public meeting and an interview with a local online news outlet, Tucker ruled.
In a statement released as part of the settlement agreement, Love said he had been given inaccurate information and failed to verify it before publicly relaying false claims about Champion and McMahon in the legislative hearing then repeating the claims during a Derry Town Council meeting and an interview with the Manchester Ink Link.
“I have since learned that those assertions were completely false,” he said. “I wish to publicly retract those statements and apologize to Robert and Michael.”
The statement said Love has agreed to a monetary judgment of $100,000 for each plaintiff.
An attorney for the plaintiffs, Olivia F. Bensinger of Shaheen & Gordon, released Love’s statement to the Globe on Wednesday when asked about the settlement, which was first reported by the Manchester Ink Link. The terms of the agreement are confidential aside from the text of the statement, she said.
This outcome shows “there are consequences for defamatory remarks,” Bensinger added.
A motion to dismiss the lawsuit was filed Monday by the parties because a settlement had been reached.
Love and his attorneys, Gretchen M. Wade and Michael J. Tierney, did not respond to requests for comment. Nor did they answer emailed questions regarding the source of the funds Love would use to pay the $200,000 settlement.
Love, who represents Rockingham County District 13 in the New Hampshire House, is running for re-election.
Tense environment for drag performers
Drag performances, particularly those advertised as family-friendly, have been the subject of political controversy in recent years, not just for policymakers but also for extremist groups.
“Drag has been under attack,” Champion said, recounting recent examples of far-right groups seeking to intimidate performers and attendees.
In June 2023, the Weeks Memorial Library in Lancaster, N.H., canceled an LGBTQ+ Pride group’s Drag Story Hour event with just four days’ notice, citing safety concerns after a barrage of harassing phone calls and public backlash. That same month, a group of masked neo-Nazis from the Nationalist Social Club-131 (NSC-131) shouted and knocked on windows of the Teatotaller cafe in Concord, N.H., to disrupt and intimidate those who gathered for a family-oriented drag event inside. And in November another fascist group, the Proud Boys, distributed pamphlets ahead of a Teatotaller drag event.
New Hampshire Attorney General John M. Formella is pressing civil rights charges against NSC-131 and the masked individuals for their alleged efforts to terrorize Teatotaller patrons on account of their actual or perceived sexual orientation, gender identity, or sex.
As similar incidents and litigation have happened elsewhere in New England and across the country, the headlines have felt personal for Champion and McMahon and others like them.
“Every time we do shows now, we’re always looking, we’re always watching, we’re always on high alert,” Champion said. “It’s so hard to just relax and enjoy your job as a drag queen because you’re so afraid of violence now.”
All the while, Champion said, a sense of uncertainty about the pending defamation lawsuit lingered in the back of his mind. Even though it was clear Love had spread lies about them, the positive outcome they ultimately secured was never guaranteed, he said.
“So you live with this fear,” he said. “Somebody put out there that I was a pedophile. Are people going to believe that? Are people going to come after me for that?”
Debate rages over age appropriateness
While critics often say drag performances are hypersexualized and categorically inappropriate for kids, advocates for the art form contend performers generally tailor their material to their audience and venue, much like stand-up comics.
Champion, the father of an 8-year-old boy, likened the diversity of drag styles and performances to the diversity of movie genres. While some are family-friendly, others are not, he said.
“If we’re going into an event for children, obviously we’re not going to go in there doing anything inappropriate for children,” he added.
Champion — who has been doing drag for about as long as McMahon has been alive — said he recalls feeling unsafe at times outside the bars where he performed years ago, but also finds himself wishing things now could be a bit more like they were before cellphones were ubiquitous and drag queens were the focus of so much political ire.
McMahon, who started doing drag shortly before the COVID-19 pandemic, said he feels lucky to have come of age in an era with social media, though he acknowledges the downsides. There seems to be more acceptance and more backlash, he said.
One difference now, McMahon added, is that people like him these days are more comfortable being themselves. This settlement agreement represents something of a silver lining in the dark cloud that has lingered overhead for more than two years, he said.
“The more and more we stand up for ourselves, the more and more people are going to realize that like, no, they don’t have to like drag, they don’t have to like this stuff, but that doesn’t mean they can’t respect us,” he said.
Steven Porter can be reached at steven.porter@globe.com. Follow him @reporterporter.
New Hampshire
New Hampshire woman arrested after high-speed chase ends in crash
DOVER, New Hampshire (WGME) — A New Hampshire woman is facing charges after reportedly speeding more than 100 miles per hour during a police chase.
New Hampshire State Police say it happened Saturday night on Route 16 in Dover.
Troopers say they tried to pull over the driver, Stephanie Dupont, but she took off at high speed.
Troopers say they followed her to Exit 3, where she veered off the road.
After the crash, they say she jumped out of the car and tried to flee on foot.
An off-duty officer from Ogunquit happened to be near by and was able to stop her.
JOIN THE CONVERSATION (3)
Officials say Dupont suffered non-life-threatening injuries in the crash.
New Hampshire
Judge strikes down challenge to NH absentee voting law
A superior court judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a group of visually impaired New Hampshire voters who argued a newly passed absentee voter law violates the state constitution.
In a lawsuit filed this summer, the plaintiffs alleged the measure, which was backed by state Republicans, places a disproportionate burden on people with disabilities by making it harder to vote.
On Friday, New Hampshire Superior Court Judge David Ruoff dismissed the case, ruling that the new policies are reasonable.
The new law requires people requesting an absentee ballot to prove their identity in one of three ways: either mail in a photocopy of an ID, along with their ballot application; have their ballot application notarized; or show an ID at town hall prior to an election.
In his opinion, Ruoff said, “The identification requirements impose ordinary burdens on all absentee voters, and the possibility that it may cause additional burden on a subset of absentee voters does not render the entire statute unconstitutional.”
It isn’t clear if the plaintiffs will appeal the ruling to the New Hampshire Supreme Court.
“We appreciate the Court’s recognition that the identification requirements for absentee voters are reasonable, constitutional, and consistent with New Hampshire’s long-standing election practices,” said New Hampshire Attorney General John Formella, who defended the law in court.
New Hampshire residents who vote in person are already required to show an ID at the polls when requesting a ballot. Supporters of the new law say the same safeguards should be in place for those voters who request an absentee ballot.
New Hampshire
Reduced federal funds to boost broadband in New Hampshire – Valley News
Despite some angst that the Trump Administration might vaporize the money, funds are coming to New Hampshire to expand broadband internet access throughout the state, although the amount isn’t what was originally allocated.
The recently announced funding is $18.6 million, significantly less than the original $196.5 million.
The news was, nevertheless, greeted with bipartisan enthusiasm.
“New Hampshire is proud to be No. 1 in the nation for internet connectivity, and this new federal funding we have secured will help us reach our goal of delivering reliable broadband access to everyone in our state,” Republican Gov. Kelly Ayotte said in a statement.
“Having worked on the broadband provisions in the bipartisan infrastructure law, I know how important internet connectivity is for small businesses to grow and compete, for students to learn and thrive and for those in remote areas to access health care,” said Democratic U.S. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen.
The broadband funding is $18.6 million. It comes from the Broadband Equity Access and Deployment Program (BEAD), part of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021, bipartisan legislation passed and enacted during the President Joe Biden administration.
Originally, the state was slated to get $196.5 million from BEAD for 9,527 locations across the state, especially in rural areas where access to broadband internet can be difficult because of distance, terrain and lack of infrastructure.
With the arrival of Donald Trump in the White House, given his disdain for the Infrastructure Act, he signed an executive order that paused a disbursement of all funds related to the bill, pending a review by his new administration.
Subsequent policy changes from the National Telecommunications and Information Administration (NTIA), an agency within the U.S. Department of Commerce, worried the state’s Democratic congressional delegation that the changes could derail the disbursement of the state’s $191 million in BEAD funds.
“The administration has now removed discretion from state and local communities, instead requiring that BEAD funds be allocated solely to the lowest-cost projects — even if those projects deliver extremely low-quality internet service to rural areas. This change is especially harmful to rural Granite Staters, who may now be limited to slow, weather-dependent internet,” the delegation wrote in August to U.S. Secretary of Commerce Howard Lutnick.
And, indeed, the changes meant that the $191 million originally slated for the Granite State had been trimmed to the newly announced $18.6 million, reducing the new broadband locations from 9,527 to 5,250.
The Trump Administration saw the policy changes as a means to distribute the money in a more cost-effective manner. That was recognized by the administration with the completion of the state’s application process for the funds.
“Congratulations to New Hampshire for getting their BEAD Final Proposal over the finish line,” said U.S. Department of Commerce Assistant Secretary for Communications and Information and NTIA Administrator Arielle Roth. “The state’s commitment to cutting excessive costs and technology diversity resulted in a strong deployment plan that will achieve universal connectivity across the Granite State.” Roth’s statement was provided by the governor’s office.
The state’s approved plan accelerates the timeline for implementation, with the hope that the state will be fully broadband wired by the end of next year.
The state’s proposal for upgrades includes a mix of coax, fiber, and satellite connections provided by Comcast, Consolidated Communications, New Hampshire Electric Co-op, and SpaceX.
Contracts for the work still have to be approved by the governor’s Executive Council.
Congressional Democrats at least seem happy that they got what they could get. And everyone seems to be putting a happy face on the news of the reduced funding.
“Everyone deserves access to high-speed, reliable internet no matter where they live,” said U.S. Sen. Maggie Hassan. “I worked with my colleagues to negotiate and pass the bipartisan infrastructure law to help expand access to reliable internet, and am glad to see our state one step closer to ensuring that everyone has access to broadband. I will continue to push for federal funding that supports Granite state families and small businesses and ensures that communities across our state, including in rural areas, can grow and thrive.”
“Under the bipartisan infrastructure law, Congress worked together to approve critical investments that are making our communities safer, stronger, and more prosperous. Access to high-speed internet is a necessity for every city and town, and it helps businesses compete, ensures students can learn, and allows patients to see a provider. This funding should never have been threatened or delayed, and I’m relieved that it will soon be delivered to New Hampshire,” said 1st District U.S. Rep. Christopher Pappas. “I will continue working to secure resources that modernize our infrastructure and improve Granite Staters’ quality of life.”
“Access to reliable, high-speed internet is not a luxury. It is a lifeline and economic driver for hardworking families, small businesses, farmers, and rural communities across our state,” said 2nd District U.S. Rep. Maggie Goodlander. “I look forward to seeing these federal dollars put to work quickly and effectively to deliver for New Hampshire.”
Ayotte pointed to a recent report that shows New Hampshire is the No. 1 internet connected state in the country.
Reviews.org used census data and reported in October that 95.37% of all households in the Granite State are connected to the internet.
“Expanding broadband will help keep our communities safe, grow our economy, improve access to health care in our rural communities, and more. I thank the Department of Commerce for helping us continue to get more Granite Staters connected,” Ayotte said in her statement.
The state’s broadband application process and oversight are the work of the state Department of Business and Economic Affairs (BEA).
“This investment is critical in reaching the last mile in bringing high-speed service to rural towns, which will support small businesses, enable remote work, and increase access to educational opportunities, healthcare, and other facets of our quality of life,” said Matthew Conserva, program manager of the BEA Office of Broadband Initiatives.
These articles are being shared by partners in The Granite State News Collaborative. For more information visit collaborativenh.org.
-
Alaska1 week agoHowling Mat-Su winds leave thousands without power
-
Texas1 week agoTexas Tech football vs BYU live updates, start time, TV channel for Big 12 title
-
Washington6 days agoLIVE UPDATES: Mudslide, road closures across Western Washington
-
Iowa1 week agoMatt Campbell reportedly bringing longtime Iowa State staffer to Penn State as 1st hire
-
Miami, FL1 week agoUrban Meyer, Brady Quinn get in heated exchange during Alabama, Notre Dame, Miami CFP discussion
-
Iowa2 days agoHow much snow did Iowa get? See Iowa’s latest snowfall totals
-
Cleveland, OH1 week agoMan shot, killed at downtown Cleveland nightclub: EMS
-
World1 week ago
Chiefs’ offensive line woes deepen as Wanya Morris exits with knee injury against Texans