New Hampshire
Drag queens settle defamation lawsuit against N.H. lawmaker for $100k each plus a public apology – The Boston Globe
McMahon, 25, said he’s a big fan of free speech.
“But I think people need to realize that it comes with consequences,” he said.
Their case highlights a tense environment for drag performers and LGBTQ+ people more broadly, both in New Hampshire and across the country, as conservative state lawmakers and some extremist groups have sought to exert political pressure against rising acceptance and visibility for people who defy binary notions of sex and gender.
Love, a Republican, was sponsoring an ill-fated bill in 2022 to require public libraries to conduct background checks on all staff and volunteers when he cited concerns about recent library events featuring drag queens. He mentioned two performers in particular without naming them.
Love testified before a New Hampshire House committee that one performer had been revealed to be a “convicted sex offender” after an event at a library in Nashua and another had been seen “rubbing butts” with kids during an event that was held at a private venue in Derry after opponents objected to holding the event at the local library — but he didn’t have his facts straight.
In bringing their lawsuit, Champion and McMahon alleged Love had clearly been referring to them. They noted Champion had performed for a teen-oriented event at the Nashua Public Library, and McMahon had performed for a family-friendly storytime event at the Tupelo Music Hall in Derry.
Love claimed the lawsuit hadn’t adequately alleged that his comments were about the plaintiffs, but Merrimack County Superior Court Judge Brian T. Tucker disagreed. In a preliminary ruling in January, he found that Champion and McMahon had each outlined a plausible defamation claim.
Tucker also rejected an assertion that Love was entitled to absolute legislative immunity for comments he made as a sitting lawmaker discussing pending legislation.
Although the New Hampshire Constitution says legislative speech and debate “cannot be the foundation of any action, complaint, or prosecution,” that shield didn’t apply to comments Love made when he expounded on his testimony during a subsequent public meeting and an interview with a local online news outlet, Tucker ruled.
In a statement released as part of the settlement agreement, Love said he had been given inaccurate information and failed to verify it before publicly relaying false claims about Champion and McMahon in the legislative hearing then repeating the claims during a Derry Town Council meeting and an interview with the Manchester Ink Link.
“I have since learned that those assertions were completely false,” he said. “I wish to publicly retract those statements and apologize to Robert and Michael.”
The statement said Love has agreed to a monetary judgment of $100,000 for each plaintiff.
An attorney for the plaintiffs, Olivia F. Bensinger of Shaheen & Gordon, released Love’s statement to the Globe on Wednesday when asked about the settlement, which was first reported by the Manchester Ink Link. The terms of the agreement are confidential aside from the text of the statement, she said.
This outcome shows “there are consequences for defamatory remarks,” Bensinger added.
A motion to dismiss the lawsuit was filed Monday by the parties because a settlement had been reached.
Love and his attorneys, Gretchen M. Wade and Michael J. Tierney, did not respond to requests for comment. Nor did they answer emailed questions regarding the source of the funds Love would use to pay the $200,000 settlement.
Love, who represents Rockingham County District 13 in the New Hampshire House, is running for re-election.
Tense environment for drag performers
Drag performances, particularly those advertised as family-friendly, have been the subject of political controversy in recent years, not just for policymakers but also for extremist groups.
“Drag has been under attack,” Champion said, recounting recent examples of far-right groups seeking to intimidate performers and attendees.
In June 2023, the Weeks Memorial Library in Lancaster, N.H., canceled an LGBTQ+ Pride group’s Drag Story Hour event with just four days’ notice, citing safety concerns after a barrage of harassing phone calls and public backlash. That same month, a group of masked neo-Nazis from the Nationalist Social Club-131 (NSC-131) shouted and knocked on windows of the Teatotaller cafe in Concord, N.H., to disrupt and intimidate those who gathered for a family-oriented drag event inside. And in November another fascist group, the Proud Boys, distributed pamphlets ahead of a Teatotaller drag event.
New Hampshire Attorney General John M. Formella is pressing civil rights charges against NSC-131 and the masked individuals for their alleged efforts to terrorize Teatotaller patrons on account of their actual or perceived sexual orientation, gender identity, or sex.
As similar incidents and litigation have happened elsewhere in New England and across the country, the headlines have felt personal for Champion and McMahon and others like them.
“Every time we do shows now, we’re always looking, we’re always watching, we’re always on high alert,” Champion said. “It’s so hard to just relax and enjoy your job as a drag queen because you’re so afraid of violence now.”
All the while, Champion said, a sense of uncertainty about the pending defamation lawsuit lingered in the back of his mind. Even though it was clear Love had spread lies about them, the positive outcome they ultimately secured was never guaranteed, he said.
“So you live with this fear,” he said. “Somebody put out there that I was a pedophile. Are people going to believe that? Are people going to come after me for that?”
Debate rages over age appropriateness
While critics often say drag performances are hypersexualized and categorically inappropriate for kids, advocates for the art form contend performers generally tailor their material to their audience and venue, much like stand-up comics.
Champion, the father of an 8-year-old boy, likened the diversity of drag styles and performances to the diversity of movie genres. While some are family-friendly, others are not, he said.
“If we’re going into an event for children, obviously we’re not going to go in there doing anything inappropriate for children,” he added.
Champion — who has been doing drag for about as long as McMahon has been alive — said he recalls feeling unsafe at times outside the bars where he performed years ago, but also finds himself wishing things now could be a bit more like they were before cellphones were ubiquitous and drag queens were the focus of so much political ire.
McMahon, who started doing drag shortly before the COVID-19 pandemic, said he feels lucky to have come of age in an era with social media, though he acknowledges the downsides. There seems to be more acceptance and more backlash, he said.
One difference now, McMahon added, is that people like him these days are more comfortable being themselves. This settlement agreement represents something of a silver lining in the dark cloud that has lingered overhead for more than two years, he said.
“The more and more we stand up for ourselves, the more and more people are going to realize that like, no, they don’t have to like drag, they don’t have to like this stuff, but that doesn’t mean they can’t respect us,” he said.
Steven Porter can be reached at steven.porter@globe.com. Follow him @reporterporter.
New Hampshire
New Hampshire woman chosen as President- elect Trump’s press secretary
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
New Hampshire
Trip Report: Skiing Opening Day At New Hampshire's Largest Ski Area
New Hampshire – The Northeast’s ski season officially kicked off last week.
After a warm start to the month, a cold stretch last week across the Northeast allowed various ski areas to open up for the season or temporarily. This included Killington, Sunday River, Sommet Saint Sauveur, Belleayre, Gore, Whiteface, and Bretton Woods. Situated across the street from the famous Omni Mt. Washington Resort, the New Hampshire ski area opened on Saturday with two trails and two lifts operating.
I decided to head up to Bretton Woods to experience their opening day. I decided over Killington because while its my favorite ski resort in New England, it can be a crowded experience during those first couple of days.
Lift tickets at Bretton Woods this past weekend were $72. This is a bit pricey for opening day, but they offered a $10 discount if you brought a non-perishable food item as part of their “Say Goodbye to Hunger” Food Drive.
One of the lifts that was open was the Learning Center Quad. This lift services Rosebrook Meadow, a mellow beginner trail. It’s nice to get your sea legs back on this run, but it kind of gets boring for more tenured skiers and riders after a few turns.
The main trail that was open was Range View, which was serviced by the Zephyr High-Speed Quad. It has two small steep sections, but its relative mellowness makes it a beginner piste. The snow was soft and buttery. Crowds were minimal across the ski area, so it allowed for peace of mind.
As the photos show, there was a small snowpack. However, there wasn’t any indication of a thin base (e.g., grass and rocks) on the slopes.
Overall, I was impressed by the snow quality for opening day. These early-season days are typically icy endeavors, but this wasn’t close to that. The above-average temperatures helped with the snowpack’s quality, but the conditions also showed the strength of Bretton Woods’ snowmaking and grooming team.
Bretton Woods will be closed for the next several days. Conditions permitting, the New Hampshire ski area aims to reopen this weekend.
Image/Video Credits: Ian Wood, Bretton Woods
Related
New Hampshire
Security footage from inside NH Hospital shows speed of events in 2023 shooting
In the days and weeks after last November’s shooting inside New Hampshire Hospital, a lot of information came out about the gunman.
John Madore had a history of schizophrenia, and had previously been a patient at New Hampshire Hospital, a state-run psychiatric facility. Madore was transient, staying in hotels, but in regular contact with loved ones.
An investigation by the New Hampshire Attorney General’s office revealed that Madore obtained the pistol he used to kill Bradley Haas, a security guard stationed in the hospital lobby, from a licensed firearms dealer, even though he was prohibited from having a gun because of his past psychiatric commitments.
The attorney general’s report, released in August, also outlined Madore’s whereabouts that day, before he pulled a rented U-Haul loaded with an additional gun and ammunition into the parking lot of the hospital. The investigatory report included still images and a detailed timeline, but the state declined to release any video footage, despite its longstanding practice of doing so at the conclusion of its investigations into officer-involved shootings.
Security improvements remain a work in progress, one year after NH Hospital shooting
NHPR recently obtained five videos from the state, with angles from both inside and outside the hospital lobby, including a birds eye view that shows the main entrance, security desk and most of the lobby. Portions of the video are redacted or blurred; the state said that decision was made to protect the privacy interests of the families involved.
We sought the footage, through a Right to Know request, with two main goals: To better understand what happened that day and see what, if anything, could have been done differently. And second, to try to understand what changes could be made to improve security.
Here’s what we learned.
What the videos show
The main video from inside the lobby is approximately 30 minutes in length.
Jeff Czarnec, one of two experts NHPR asked to review the footage, served 23 years in law enforcement in Manchester, and now teaches criminal justice at Southern New Hampshire University.
He described the layout of the lobby as appealing and bright, which is important for a psychiatric facility, but that the metal detectors near the entrance could be easily skirted.
“Those are great to have in place,” said Czarnec. “But they’re not necessarily a deterrent to someone who’s looking to do harm.”
And that’s clearly what Madore was looking to do.
NH gun reform failed after hospital shooting. Advocates will try again in 2025.
The video shows him walking from the parking lot dressed in black pants, a flannel shirt and a vest. He moves quickly. As soon as he enters the lobby through the sliding glass doors, he reaches his right hand into his right pocket without breaking stride, and pulls out a gun.
“He just comes right in, and he was fully prepared. I don’t think he even had two feet inside when he started shooting,” Czarnec said.
The video shows Bradley Haas, the security guard, standing at a table next to the metal detector, looking at his phone. He barely has time to lift his head before he’s shot.
“A matter of seconds. There’s no prep, there’s no warning,” Czarnec said.
Haas was a 28-year veteran of the Franklin Police force, rising to the rank of chief. Since retiring from that position, he had been working as a security guard at New Hampshire Hospital for more than three years.
There were questions afterwards about why someone in that position — with his level of experience — wasn’t armed. Attorney General John Formella was asked about this by reporters the day after the shooting, and said that “it wouldn’t be typical for that position to be armed, working the security in the front lobby.”
During the legislative session this year, a bipartisan bill sought to close a perceived gap in the background check reporting system that Madore took advantage of to buy the gun.
Republican state Rep. J.R. Hoell, speaking on the House floor, said the problem wasn’t state gun laws, but instead that Haas wasn’t carrying a gun that day, to protect himself and others.
“So why was the person manning the security booth, manning the metal detector, not carrying a personal firearm that day?” Hoell asked.
There’s no consensus nationally about whether armed security guards are appropriate for acute psychiatric facilities. But what this video from last November makes clear is that having a gun may not have saved Bradley Haas that day.
“Even if he’d been armed, there aren’t many measures you could take that would have prevented what we saw [that day],” said Brian Higgins, who teaches at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, who also reviewed the hospital security footage at NHPR’s request. “It’s almost as if he didn’t have a chance.”
A state trooper confronts the gunman
After Madore shoots Haas, he walks around the lobby firing at bullet proof windows, though that section of the video has been redacted. The attorney general describes in its report that Madore ultimately fires again at Haas while he’s on the ground.
The next set of doors into the hospital are locked, however. Madore is essentially blocked from getting any further into the building.
Approximately 22 seconds after Madore fired his first shot, state trooper Nathan Sleight can be seen on the right side of the frame. He cracks open the door to an office connected to the lobby, where he had been positioned when the gunfire broke out.
Madore sees him, but continues trying to reload his gun. According to the report, Sleight ordered Madore to drop the weapon, but there is no audio footage from the lobby.
Sleight then opens fire from a protected position.
“The trooper there is doing all the right things by virtue of training: conceal and cover,” said Czarnec.
Madore drops to the ground, wounded, leaning up against a wall. He keeps moving his hands, though, trying to reload.
Sleight fires a second time: The muzzle flashes in rapid succession.
“He then shoots again to make sure that that threat is over,” Higgins said. “So I don’t have an issue with that at all. As a matter of fact, that’s good tactics.”
In total, Sleight fired 11 shots, emptying his magazine. The attorney general would later rule he was justified in his use of force; both experts we asked to review this footage agreed with that conclusion.
Just seconds after Madore is shot, the glass sliding doors leading out onto the sidewalk open again. A man wanders into the lobby. The report would later identify this person as a patient of the hospital. He can be seen walking over to Madore, and then to Haas. Sleight quickly ushers him outside.
In the video, Sleight runs to his cruiser parked out front to grab more ammunition; then he runs out of the lobby a second time to grab his bullet proof vest.
Within minutes, Concord police officers and more state troopers are on scene.
They provide cover while Haas is pulled bleeding from the lobby, and transported to nearby Concord Hospital, where he later dies.
Madore is dead at the scene.
A resilient staff remembers a colleague
New Hampshire Hospital had a patient count of 153 the day of the shooting. There were dozens of doctors, nurses, and other staff in the building. In the five minutes before the shooting, 13 people passed through the hospital’s lobby, according to the footage NHPR reviewed.
By pure chance, the lobby was empty — except for the security guard — when Madore entered.
“It is really a great thing that, despite the tragedy, the event was contained in this area and it really could have been far worse than it was,” Ellen Lapointe, New Hampshire Hospital’s CEO, recently said while giving a tour of the lobby.
In the aftermath of the shooting, there were changes made to how staff and visitors enter the building. For instance, the glass sliding doors from the outside no longer open automatically into the lobby.
This will slow down, in theory, anyone looking to do harm.
Everyone now needs a badge or has to check-in to enter. There is also now an armed law enforcement officer positioned in the lobby during visitor hours.
Next January, a major construction project that was already in the works will completely overhaul the entry and traffic flow.
But for now, this space is the main in-and-out point for staff.
Every day, they’re walking right past where their colleague Bradley Haas was killed.
Lapointe says it’s been a hard year.
“There’s been a tremendous amount of resiliency of the staff and a really great focus on patient care, as well as honoring Brad’s memory and really remembering him, for the positive, kind, helpful gentleman that he was,” said Lapointe. “And trying to not focus on the tragedies that occurred here.”
-
Business1 week ago
Ref needs glasses? Not anymore. Lasik company offers free procedures for referees
-
News1 week ago
Herbert Smith Freehills to merge with US-based law firm Kramer Levin
-
Technology1 week ago
The next Nintendo Direct is all about Super Nintendo World’s Donkey Kong Country
-
Business6 days ago
Column: OpenAI just scored a huge victory in a copyright case … or did it?
-
Health6 days ago
Bird flu leaves teen in critical condition after country's first reported case
-
Business2 days ago
Column: Molly White's message for journalists going freelance — be ready for the pitfalls
-
Technology1 week ago
How a researcher hacked ChatGPT's memory to expose a major security flaw
-
Politics1 week ago
Editorial: Abortion was on ballots across the country in this election. The results are encouraging