Connect with us

Ohio

From the editor: Ohio Supreme Court majority plays politics, strikes blow to open records

Published

on

From the editor: Ohio Supreme Court majority plays politics, strikes blow to open records


It was a blatant political stunt, but I appreciate the gesture.

Last week, a Democrat in the Ohio House introduced a bill he’s calling the Super Bowl Entourage Expense Act. What’s behind the oddly specific piece of legislation? Let’s start at the beginning – which is a very good place to start.

Defying most expectations, the Bengals clawed their way to the Super Bowl in 2022. Among those who made the trip to SoFi Stadium in Englewood, California, was Gov. Mike DeWine, along with 19 members of his family.

DeWine was quick to note he paid for the trip, including the cost of the tickets. But when the governor travels, the state provides security for him and his entourage.

Advertisement

How much did the security detail cost taxpayers? It’s a fair question, so we asked for a breakdown of airfare, food, lodging, overtime and other expenses incurred by the Ohio State Highway Patrol troopers whose job it was to keep the governor safe.

Our request was denied. Lawyers for the Ohio Department of Public Safety said the information fell under a security exemption in Ohio’s open records law. Releasing expense receipts might reveal the size of the security detail, the hotels they stayed at and other tactical information that could be used by bad actors to attack the governor, they argued.

We disagreed – the Super Bowl was a unique event that occurred in the past – but offered a compromise. We modified our request and asked only for the total cost to taxpayers for the security detail. A lump sum, not an itemized list.

They wouldn’t budge. So we filed a lawsuit with the Ohio Supreme Court.

Advertisement

Nearly two Super Bowls later, the court issued its ruling. In a 4-3 split decision that followed party lines, the Republicans on the court struck a blow against government transparency and ruled the information we sought was not a public record.

In his dissent, Justice Michael Donnelly said it’s “more than a stretch” to conclude keeping gas receipts secret is essential for the governor’s security.

“It is obvious that all disclosures of public records come with some security concerns. As an extreme example, there is no doubt that any governor would be much safer if no one knew his or her name, what she or he looks like, or where he or she lives and works,” Donnelly said. “But the incremental concern at issue here is not, to my mind, sufficient justification for shrouding government spending in secrecy.”

I couldn’t have said that better myself. If there’s a security expert out there who can take a dollar amount and derive from it a sinister plan to hit a target, please send them my way.

[ Support local journalism: Click here to see a special offer for new subscribers ]

Advertisement

And now we get to State Rep. Eliot Forhan, the Cleveland-area Democrat who wants to create a law that overturns the court’s decision. First, thank you. I appreciate your support of open records. Second, don’t waste your time.

As our state government reporter Laura Bischoff wrote, the bill is dead on arrival. It has no chance of making it through the Republican-controlled General Assembly; if it did, DeWine would veto it; and since Forhan is being investigated by the Ohio Attorney General over accusations of harassment and intimidation, no one is rushing to support him right now.

So what’s next? The Enquirer will continue to fight for government transparency and open records. At any given time, Enquirer reporters have more than a dozen active public records requests, most of which are granted without involving the court.

Even though we lost this one, we forced the discussion. Ohio taxpayers might not know how much they spent to send the governor to the Super Bowl, but the fact his political allies fought to keep it secret suggests it was a sizable sum that would have raised some eyebrows.

No comments

Love ’em or hate ’em, reader comments have been suspended on our website, Cincinnati.com. In our announcement to readers online, we explained that the time and cost required to moderate the comment sections – attached to nearly every story – would be better spent reporting the news. Cincinnati.com was one of the few remaining Gannett-owned sites to feature reader comments; now, we join the other sites in our company in shutting down what too often was a free-for-all of anonymous personal attacks and gratuitous snark.

Advertisement

I have mixed feelings about it. In theory, online commenting is a natural extension of letters to the editor and other platforms we provide for community debate. But despite our efforts to thwart the trolls with text filters and human intervention, the comment sections did little to elevate the discussion.

Did we make the right call? Drop me an email and weigh in.

Enquirer Executive Editor Beryl Love writes a biweekly column that takes you behind the scenes at The Enquirer. Occasionally, he shares his thoughts on local issues, particularly as they pertain to a free press and open government. Love also serves as regional editor for the USA TODAY Network Ohio. Email him at blove@enquirer.com. He can’t respond personally to every email, but he reads them all.



Source link

Advertisement

Ohio

Math plan would help a generation of Ohio students | Opinion

Published

on

Math plan would help a generation of Ohio students | Opinion


Aaron Churchill is the Ohio research director for the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, an education policy think tank based in Columbus.

In November, the Ohio Senate unanimously passed math reforms that would help a generation of struggling students. House lawmakers should send that excellent package known as Senate Bill 19 to the governor’s desk post haste.

Math difficulties start early for many Ohio students. Last year, 45,000 third graders, or 36% statewide, fell short of proficiency on the state math exam. These youngsters had difficulty solving basic arithmetic and measurement problems. Without such skills, big trouble lies ahead for them.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, even larger percentages of high schoolers fare poorly in this subject. On last year’s algebra I state exam, 53,000 students – 41% of test takers – did not achieve proficiency, while a staggering 72,000 students (57%) fell short in geometry.

These failure rates are unacceptable. Students should not be left to struggle with the routine math needed to manage their personal finances, bake a cake or do a home repair. Nor should they lack the critical thinking, data interpretation and problem solving skills that are demanded by today’s employers and essential to career success.

Ohio must help more students gain fluency in math. Senate Bill 19 does this in the following ways.

First, it supports students with math deficiencies. The bill would require schools to provide math interventions to students scoring at the lowest achievement level (known as “limited”) on state tests. Importantly, schools must engage a child’s parents to create an individual improvement plan that outlines the interventions and how progress will be monitored.

Advertisement

Second, the bill promotes strong math curricula. The Ohio Department of Education and Workforce would be tasked with reviewing math materials and establishing a high-quality list. With dozens of programs and textbooks on the market – some far better than others – this vetting process would aid school districts in finding the best curriculum for their students.

Third, it asks colleges of education to better prepare elementary teachers. Research from the National Council on Teacher Quality shows that teacher training programs often lack serious math content, especially in the elementary grades, leaving teachers ill-prepared for effective instruction. To help address the problem, the bill mandates that prospective educators pass the math section of the state licensure test to teach the subject, something that is not presently required.

Fourth, it gives high-achieving math students a boost. Traditional course placement practices rely on teacher and parent referrals, which tend to overlook economically disadvantaged students who excel in math. Yet, as a recent Fordham Institute study found, access to advanced coursework is critical to high-achieving, low-income students’ college prospects. Through automatic enrollment provisions, Senate Bill 19 would ensure that all high achievers are placed in challenging math courses, including algebra I in eighth grade.

Some may view Senate Bill 19 as burdensome on schools. But the need for significant improvement in math is urgent and the reforms are commonsense. Students struggling in math ought to get help. Schools should use the best-available textbooks and materials. Teachers should know math before they teach it. Schools must push high achievers to reach their full potential.

Advertisement

Math and reading are the academic pillars that support students’ long-term success as well as the state’s economic growth. Thanks to the leadership of Gov. Mike DeWine, Ohio’s Science of Reading initiative is off to a strong start and promises stronger literacy statewide. It’s now time for policymakers to roll up their sleeves and help students get better at math. Their futures – and the state’s – are at stake.

Aaron Churchill is the Ohio research director for the Thomas B. Fordham Institute, an education policy think tank based in Columbus.



Source link

Continue Reading

Ohio

Remains of Ohio airmen killed in Iraq will be brought back March 29

Published

on

Remains of Ohio airmen killed in Iraq will be brought back March 29


play

The remains of three Ohio airmen who were killed in the crash of their KC-135 refueling plane in Iraq earlier this month will be returned this weekend, according to a family member of one of the deceased.

The airmen, identified as Master Sgt. Tyler Simmons, 28, of Columbus; Capt. Curtis Angst, 30, of Wilmington, and Capt. Seth Koval, 38, of Stoutsville, will be brought back March 29 to Rickenbacker Air National Guard Base near Columbus, said Charles Simmons, Tyler’s father.

Advertisement

“Tyler will have a hero’s welcome, because he is a hero,” said Charles.

The Columbus Division of Police will be involved in the funeral procession when the airmen’s remains are transferred from the airport to funeral homes, said Columbus police Sgt. James Fuqua. That will take place between 1 p.m. and 2 p.m. March 29, said Fuqua.

The airmen’s remains first arrived back in the U.S. on March 18 with a dignified transfer taking place at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware.

Curtis, Angst, and Simmons were members of the 166th Air Refueling Squadron connected to the 121st Air Refueling Wing based at Rickenbacker Air National Guard Base in Columbus.

Advertisement

The airmen, as well as three other servicemembers, died on March 12 when their KC-135 tanker crashed in western Iraq during a mission in support of Operation Epic Fury in Iran. The cause of the crash, which occurred in friendly airspace, has not been publicly identified. U.S. Central Command has said the incident did not involve hostile or friendly fire, and military experts have theorized the crash may have been the result of a collision with a second KC-135 that sustained heavy damage to its tail fin but landed safely at an airport in Tel Aviv, Israel.

Reporter Bethany Bruner can be reached at bbruner@dispatch.com.

Reporter Shahid Meighan can be reached at smeighan@dispatch.com, at ShahidMeighan on X, and at shahidthereporter.dispatch.com on Bluesky. 



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Ohio

Thousands head to Columbus for 23rd annual Home Improvement Show at Ohio Expo Center

Published

on

Thousands head to Columbus for 23rd annual Home Improvement Show at Ohio Expo Center


Thousands of people are expected to head to downtown Columbus for the 23rd annual Home Improvement Show this weekend.

Organizers say visitors can find ideas for everything from small interior design projects to major renovations.

The event is being held at the Ohio Expo Center and includes seminars, exhibits and demonstrations from local and national companies.

The show begins at noon Friday and runs until 6 p.m.

Advertisement

It continues Saturday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Sunday from 11 a.m. to 5 p.m.

Adult tickets cost $5 at the door.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending