Connect with us

Iowa

Iowa Building’s Flaws Were Well Documented Before Deadly Collapse

Published

on

Iowa Building’s Flaws Were Well Documented Before Deadly Collapse


The warnings about the old brick building on Main Street just kept coming.

There was an engineer’s report in February about a compromised wall. There was another report on May 24 noting that large patches of a brick facade “appear ready to fall imminently.” And on May 27, there was a 911 call asking emergency crews to check a side of the structure that seemed to be bulging.

Over months, assessments were written, work permits were issued and some repairs were made. Still, as alarm grew and complaints mounted, people were allowed to remain in their apartments at 324 Main Street in Davenport, Iowa, a city of 100,000 residents situated about halfway between Des Moines and Chicago.

But last week, a day after that 911 call, a section of the downtown building cleaved off and fell into a parking lot. Three men died, dozens of people were left homeless and half-collapsed apartments became dioramas of lives upended — kitchen appliances teetering near the edges of shorn-off floors, shirts still hung on closet hangers. All the while, residents and their families were left questioning why more was not done to stave off a disaster that, at least in hindsight, seemed all too predictable.

Advertisement

“I want the people who are responsible for this to know they have failed us and they need to be held accountable,” said Desirée Jane Banks, who had two children with Branden Colvin Sr., 42, a resident of the building who died in its collapse.

On Wednesday, Gov. Kim Reynolds of Iowa announced that she had asked President Biden to declare an emergency and to send federal help for debris removal and demolition.

When it was built 116 years ago, the six-story Davenport Hotel at 324 Main was a jewel of the growing city, where the economy was shaped in many ways by the Mississippi River, which flows alongside downtown. The hotel became a resting spot for well-heeled travelers that featured “elevators, a dining room, some private baths, and fireproof construction throughout,” according to documents on file with the National Register of Historic Places, where it is listed.

Over time, it was converted into a residential building and became something decidedly less grand. Public records and interviews with several recent residents portrayed an apartment building plagued by maintenance problems, safety issues and complaints that went unaddressed for weeks or months.

Eugene Cyphers, 86, who said he had lived there for two decades, described a rapid decline in conditions in recent years. Homeless people sometimes stayed in the lobby, he said. He described seeing feces on stairs and garbage rotting the halls. For a time this past winter, he recalled, there was no heat.

Advertisement

“We always hoped for a better day,” said Mr. Cyphers, a retired teacher who after the collapse, carrying only his keys, wallet and phone, made it to safety through smoke-filled hallways smelling of gas.

The building was home to a diverse mix of residents — long-timers and new arrivals, young professionals and older adults seeking a fresh start — who appreciated the relatively low downtown rents and bonded over shared disappointment with the building’s upkeep.

Attempts to reach Andrew Wold, the building owner, were not successful, and two lawyers who have represented him in recent years in other matters did not respond to requests for comment.

Terrence Glover said he lived in the building for six years until 2020, when it sustained storm damage. His friend and co-worker, Ryan Hitchcock, 51, whose family described him as a devoted Christian, was among those who died. Daniel Prien, 60, also died in the collapse.

“As the wear and tear issues began to mount, those of us who had the means to move did,” Mr. Glover said. “Unfortunately, some just didn’t have that luxury.”

Advertisement

Toriana Hill, who moved in with her 3-year-old son last fall, said she thought “it was a steal to be downtown in a loft-style apartment for $850” each month. Ms. Hill, a postal carrier, appreciated many aspects of the apartment, and said her neighbors included a journalist, an engineer and several college students.

But from the start, Ms. Hill said, there had been unsettling problems: a toilet that barely flushed, cabinets that did not close, an elevator that repeatedly broke down. A visitor earlier this year noticed falling bricks and cracks near windows and suggested that she move.

Records show that Davenport’s city inspectors were acquainted with problems at the building. More than 140 inspections, complaints or permits related to 324 Main were filed with the city since the start of 2019, according to public records. They included complaints from residents who said they went long stretches without heat or hot water. Davenport officials repeatedly referred to the building as a nuisance property and ordered trash to be removed, including in the weeks before the collapse.

More alarmingly, serious structural issues became apparent. On Feb. 8, a structural engineer made an “emergency site visit” and found a patch of cracked and crumbling brick. The engineer said at the time “that this is not an imminent threat to the building or its residents, but structural repairs will be necessary.” City records show that a permit was issued for repair work, which was completed.

Concerns about the building continued.

Advertisement

On May 24, the same engineer who visited in February returned and warned that a brick facade “looks poised to fall” and “is currently about to topple outward.” A building permit to fix the facade was issued by the city, records show, and work started.

The final warning came roughly 26 hours before the building fell, when an employee of the local chamber of commerce called 911 to report that a colleague told him that the wall was bulging outward and looked dangerous. Records show that firefighters responded and were at the building for about four minutes.

That crescendo of warning, and the absence of more aggressive action to fix the problems, has led to accusations of negligence and calls for justice in recent days.

After the collapse, city officials cited and fined Mr. Wold, the building owner, asserting in court records that he “failed to maintain his building in a safe, sanitary, and structurally sound condition.” No lawyer is listed for Mr. Wold in the case.

Residents have also questioned the city’s role, both before the collapse and after.

Advertisement

The day after the collapse, officials said they were not aware of anyone still stuck in the rubble and that demolition was “expected to commence” soon.

But protesters called for a delay, raising concern that people might remain trapped. A woman inside made her way to a window and was helped out of the building in a bucket ladder, and officials announced that other people were missing. The city called search-and-rescue teams back to the rubble. Days later, the bodies of the three men who died were found.

“It was like the city leaders were trying to hold onto a greased football and they kept fumbling it,” said Broc Nelson, a resident for more than three years who is now staying with family. Mr. Nelson, a bakery worker, said he lost his I.D. and birth certificate in the collapse.

Neither Mayor Mike Matson nor Richard Oswald, the director of the city department that oversees code enforcement, responded to interview requests for this article. In news conferences last week, both men described difficult decisions for the city in the lead-up to the collapse.

Ordering people to vacate their homes is a difficult and serious step, they said.

Advertisement

“It is a line to say it’s so unsafe you have to be kicked out of your home,” Mr. Matson said last week when asked about potentially missed warning signs revealed in documents released by the city. He added: “Believe me, we’re going to look at that again, over and over, and for the rest of my life.”

The collapse on Main Street led to concern about the safety of other old buildings in Davenport. Local officials said they were working to step up inspection efforts on other structures.

Roberto T. Leon, an engineering professor at Virginia Tech, said most brick structures from the early 1900s were safe, but that they were built at a time before rigorous building codes. Because of construction techniques that differ from those used today, and because detailed building plans might no longer be available, doing more than a cursory inspection of such structures can be both pricey and time-consuming.

“You have to go in and do materials testing and take a lot of measurements,” Dr. Leon said.

In Davenport, a smattering of residents continued to gather near the unsteady building at the center of downtown, where signs from last week’s protests were still posted on fencing.

Advertisement

With the search over, demolition work was starting in earnest. If workers do not take the rest of the building down, city leaders have said, it will topple on its own.



Source link

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Iowa

Kirk Ferentz’s Reputation On The Line In Iowa vs Washington

Published

on

Kirk Ferentz’s Reputation On The Line In Iowa vs Washington


The Iowa Hawkeyes are coming off of a 35-7 thumping at the hands of the Ohio State Buckeyes, and while a loss to Ohio State was expected, it was how Iowa lost that has Hawkeyes fans livid.

Iowa’s offense was absolutely lifeless, Cade McNamara looked lost and head coach Kirk Ferentz did not seem to have any answers.

Not only that, but Ferentz doubled down on McNamara remaining the starter after the game, saying that the quarterback actually showed improvement.

That’s why Ferentz’s reputation may actually be on the line when the Hawkeyes face the Washington Huskies this Saturday.

Advertisement

Iowa is just 3-2 on the season, as it also lost to the Iowa State Cyclones back in Week 2. A loss to Washington would drop the Hawkeyes to .500, and it would add more fuel to the “fire Ferentz” discussion that has been smoldering.

The Huskies are a new addition to the Big Ten and just beat the Michigan Wolverines, and while Michigan has not been as good as expected, Washington is no joke.

However, make no mistake: Iowa needs to beat these guys.

Here is the thing: barring a catastrophic remainder of the 2024 campaign at Iowa City, the Hawkeyes aren’t canning Ferentz. The man is under contract through 2029 on a hefty salary. It isn’t happening.

But Ferentz’s reputation is a different story.

Advertisement

The 69-year-old has been at the helm for Iowa since 1999 and is highly respected by the fans, but patience is running thin.

Last year, the Hawkeyes played three ranked opponents and lost by a total score of 92-0. They also just got destroyed by Ohio State. The Iowa fan base is tired with being second-best, and at this point, that is all Ferentz has offered them.

Sure, Iowa does not have the cachet or prestige of schools like Ohio State, Michigan or Alabama. It typically won’t land the very best recruits as a result. But the Hawkeyes’ inability to even put together respectable offenses over the years does reflect poorly on Ferentz, who is the longest-tenured coach in the country.

And Iowa fans are sick of it.

The Hawkeyes absolutely need to beat the Huskies this Saturday. Iowa should be better than Washington, and at some point, the Hawkeyes are going to have to display that they can consistently beat good teams.

Advertisement

Is all of the Ferentz criticism deserved? No, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that all of it is completely unfounded.

Ferentz can provide some nice pushback to all of the naysayers with a Week 7 win over Washington. Or, he can give fans more reason to complain with a loss.



Source link

Continue Reading

Iowa

Who the ranked Iowa high school football teams face in Week 7

Published

on

Who the ranked Iowa high school football teams face in Week 7


Williamsburg’s Grant Hocker looks to throw for a 2-point conversion against Cedar Rapids Xavier earlier this season. (Savannah Blake/The Gazette)

The Gazette offers audio versions of articles using Instaread. Some words may be mispronounced.

Advertisement

Here’s who all 71 Iowa high school football teams ranked in this week’s Gazette poll face in Week 7 games Friday night.

Class 3A gets the spotlight this week as its top two teams face top-seven opponents. No. 1 Algona visits No. 7 Humboldt, while second-ranked Williamsburg hosts a Solon team eager to bounce back from last week’s loss to Benton Community that dropped it from the top spot.

There is intrigue in the 8-Player top five as well, where three of the top five teams face fellow unbeaten foes. That includes No. 1 Remsen St. Mary’s taking on No. 10 Woodbine and No. 2 Algona Garrigan hosting Ruthven GTRA.

Class 5A

No. 1 West Des Moines Valley (5-1) vs. Waterloo West (5-1)

No. 2 West Des Moines Dowling (5-1) at Urbandale (3-3)

Advertisement

No. 3 Bettendorf (6-0) at Davenport Central (2-4)

No. 4 Pleasant Valley (5-1) vs. Muscatine (2-4)

No. 5 Ankeny Centennial (4-2) vs. Des Moines Roosevelt (1-5)

No. 6 Linn-Mar (5-1) vs. Davenport West (0-6)

Advertisement

No. 7 Johnston (4-2) vs. Council Bluffs Lincoln (4-2)

No. 8 Iowa City Liberty (5-1) vs. Ankeny (3-3)

No. 9 Waukee (4-2) at Southeast Polk (3-3)

No. 10 Sioux City East (4-2) vs. Des Moines Lincoln (1-5)

Class 4A

No. 1 Lewis Central (6-0) at Winterset (4-2)

Advertisement

No. 2 Pella (6-0) at Des Moines Hoover (0-6), Thursday

No. 3 North Polk (6-0) at No. 10 Indianola (4-2)

No. 4 Gilbert (6-0) vs. Bondurant-Farrar (1-5)

No. 5 Decorah (6-0) at Marion (2-4)

No. 6 Adel ADM (5-1) at Ballard (3-3)

Advertisement

No. 7 Cedar Rapids Xavier (4-2) at Oskaloosa (1-5)

No. 8 North Scott (4-2) at Clear Creek Amana (4-2)

No. 9 Newton (4-2) vs. Carlisle (0-6)

No. 10 Indianola (4-2) vs. No. 3 North Polk (6-0)

No. 10 Western Dubuque (4-2) at Waterloo East (2-4)

Advertisement

Class 3A

No. 1 Algona (6-0) at No. 7 Humboldt (5-1)

No. 2 Williamsburg (5-1) vs. No. 5 Solon (5-1)

No. 3 Dubuque Wahlert (6-0) at West Delaware (4-2)

No. 4 Sergeant Bluff-Luton (6-0) vs. Carroll (4-2)

No. 5 Mount Vernon (5-1) vs. Fort Madison (0-6)

Advertisement

No. 5 Solon (5-1) at No. 2 Williamsburg (5-1)

No. 7 Humboldt (5-1) vs. No. 1 Algona (6-0)

No. 8 Sioux City Heelan (4-2) at Boyden-Hull/Rock Valley (1-5)

No. 9 Independence (4-2) at Maquoketa (1-5)

No. 10 Nevada (5-1) at Harlan (3-3)

Advertisement

Class 2A

No. 1 West Lyon (6-0) at Sheldon (2-4)

No. 2 Monroe PCM (6-0) at West Marshall (5-1)

No. 3 Spirit Lake (5-1) at Garner GHV (1-5)

No. 4 Van Meter (5-1) vs. Centerville (4-2)

No. 5 Carroll Kuemper (5-1) vs. Saydel (1-5)

Advertisement

No. 6 North Fayette Valley (5-1) vs. Oelwein (0-6) — canceled, Oelwein to forfeit

No. 7 Northeast (6-0) at Tipton (2-4)

No. 8 Central Lyon/George-Little Rock (4-2) vs. No. 10 Western Christian (4-2)

No. 9 Roland-Story (4-2) vs. Des Moines Christian (4-2)

No. 10 Western Christian (4-2) at No. 8 Central Lyon/George-Little Rock (4-2)

Advertisement

Class 1A

No. 1 Grundy Center (6-0) at Alburnett (4-2)

No. 2 Wilton (6-0) at West Branch (2-4)

No. 3 Dike-New Hartford (5-1) vs. Aplington-Parkersburg (2-4)

No. 4 Emmetsburg (6-0) vs. Eagle Grove (0-6)

No. 5 Iowa City Regina (6-0) at Dyersville Beckman (4-2)

Advertisement

No. 6 Ida Grove OABCIG (5-1) vs. No. 10 Hinton (5-1)

No. 7 South Hardin (5-1) at Hudson (5-1)

No. 8 Treynor (5-1) vs. Shenandoah (3-3)

No. 9 Sigourney-Keota (5-1) at Colfax-Mingo (1-5)

No. 10 Hinton (5-1) at No. 6 Ida Grove OABCIG (5-1)

Advertisement

Class A

No. 1 West Hancock (6-0) at Lake Mills (4-2)

No. 2 Guthrie Center ACGC (6-0) vs. Mount Ayr (5-1)

No. 3 Saint Ansgar (5-1) at West Fork (1-5)

No. 4 Lisbon (6-0) vs. Danville (4-2)

No. 5 Earlham (5-1) at Oakland Riverside (4-2)

Advertisement

No. 6 Tri-Center (5-1) vs. No. 8 Woodbury Central (5-1)

No. 7 Le Mars Gehlen (5-1) at South O’Brien (0-6)

No. 8 Woodbury Central (5-1) at No. 6 Tri-Center (5-1)

No. 9 North Linn (6-0) vs. Maquoketa Valley (5-1)

No. 10 Madrid (4-2) at North Mahaska (3-3)

Advertisement

8-Player

No. 1 Remsen St. Mary’s (6-0) vs. No. 10 Woodbine (6-0)

No. 2 Algona Garrigan (6-0) vs. Ruthven GTRA (6-0)

No. 3 Don Bosco (6-0) vs. Turkey Valley (3-3)

No. 4 Audubon (6-0) vs. Collins-Maxwell (4-2)

No. 5 Lenox (6-0) vs. Southeast Warren (6-0)

Advertisement

No. 6 Iowa Valley (6-0) vs. HLV (1-6)

No. 7 Gladbrook-Reinbeck (5-1) at Clarksville (5-2)

No. 8 Anita CAM (5-1) at Fremont-Mills (5-1)

No. 9 Bedford (5-1) vs. Lamoni (4-2)

No. 10 Woodbine (6-0) at No. 1 Remsen St. Mary’s (6-0)

Advertisement

Comments: nathan.ford@thegazette.com





Source link

Continue Reading

Iowa

Iowa State women’s basketball star Emily Ryan discusses eating disorder in video

Published

on

Iowa State women’s basketball star Emily Ryan discusses eating disorder in video


Iowa State women’s basketball star Emily Ryan released a video Thursday in which she discusses her battle with an eating disorder.

Ryan, a senior from Claflin, Kansas, has been one of the Big 12 Conference’s best point guards for the past few seasons. She was a first-team all-conference pick in 2022, and a second-team selection in 2023.

Advertisement

“By sharing my story, I hope to build awareness and provide hope to everyone else fighting an invisible battle,” Ryan said in the video.

Ryan said her sense of self-worth was dependent on Iowa State’s success and her individual performance. That led to increased time spent in the weight room in an effort to get stronger and faster. When Ryan didn’t see the results that she desired, she began to focus on her diet.

Ryan said the Iowa State medical staff expressed their concern about Ryan’s eating habits and what it was doing to her body. Ryan said she was in “complete denial” about having an eating disorder, but her health continued to worsen.

Ryan missed the first nine games of the 2023-24 season due to the eating disorder. When she returned, she said, “off the court I was really struggling. By the end of the season, I was physically and mentally hanging on by a thread.”

Advertisement

During the offseason, Ryan spent 88 days at a treatment center in Denver.

“It took a long time but I finally came to the understanding that being sick wasn’t my fault, and eating disorders are real, complex illnesses,” she said.

How to get help

For resources on disordered eating, call the National Eating Disorders Helpline at 800-931-2237 or text NEDA to 741741.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending