(FOX 2) – More than 60 Michigan schools will be released from state oversight after meeting graduation and performance-based benchmarks set by the education department.

Included in the list of 68 schools that no longer need help from the state are 24 Detroit schools, according to a news release from the Michigan Department of Education.

Big picture view:

Schools in Detroit, Warren, Melvindale, Oak Park, Highland Park, and Madison Heights make up just some of the Southeast Michigan school districts no longer in need of oversight and support from the state.

The release from state monitoring includes 23 schools under the Detroit Public Schools Community District. Another six Detroit schools will also no longer be identified for specialized targeted support.

In total, there are 68 schools that will be released from oversight. There are still 113 schools that will fall under the umbrella for Comprehensive Support and Improvement (CSI).

Michigan Oversight Eligibility 

Schools are identified as needing Comprehensive Support and Improvement when they meet one of the following criteria:

• The school is in the bottom 5% of schools in Michigan
• Is a high school with a four-year graduation rate of 67% or less
• The school was in a CSI cohort but did not meet CSI exit criteria
• The school was in an ATS cohort but did not meet ATS exit criteria and so supports are elevated to CSI

There is another category for state support called Targeted Support and Improvement. The eligibility criteria for that program includes:

• Schools having at least one student group (such as a racial group, economically disadvantaged students, or students with disabilities) performing in the bottom 25% of each of the school’s components on the Michigan School Index.
• Identified annually

The backstory:

Schools are determined to need state support through the Michigan School Index, which is a requirement from the federal government that states maintain some sort of school accountability system.

The program is used to identify schools that are in need of additional support to help students perform better. Academic outcomes, attendance, and graduation rates are some of the parameters the state measures for signs of improvement. 

Schools may leave the state program if they no longer meet the criteria that made them eligible in the first place, like math and English proficiency over two years. 

Catching up:

According to the 2023-24 results, there were slight gains among Michigan’s schools. 

Of the 3,324 public schools in Michigan, 113 were identified for state support – about 3.4% of all schools in the state. That includes 57 districts entering partnership agreements with MDE, which means they will get specialized support.

“I am very pleased to see that 68 schools—including 33 out of 98 schools that were in partnership agreements with MDE—no longer require additional supports from the department because of the hard work by local district and intermediate school district staff, children, parents, community members and MDE employees,” said Interim State Superintendent Dr. Sue C. Carnell. 

Schools no longer under oversight

There are 68 schools that will no longer use the CSI program for state help:

• Academy for Business and Technology High School, Melvindale
• Academy of Warren
• Barack Obama Leadership Academy, Detroit
• Beecher High School (Beecher Community School District)
• Fair Plain East Elementary School (Benton Harbor Area Schools)
• Buchanan Virtual Academy (Buchanan Community Schools)
• Detroit Academy of Arts and Sciences (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Detroit Leadership Academy K-8 (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Ann Arbor Trail Magnet School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Blackwell Institute (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Bunche Preparatory Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Burns Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Carver STEM Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Central High School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Cooke STEM Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Davis Aerospace Technical High School at Golightly (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Frederick Douglass Academy for Young Men (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Garvey Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Henderson Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• J.E. Clark Preparatory Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Mackenzie Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Marquette Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Martin Luther King Jr. Senior High School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Noble Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Nolan Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Palmer Park Preparatory Academy (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Priest Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Pulaski Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Wayne Elementary School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Oak Park Service Learning Academy
• Pleasantview Elementary School (East Pointe Community Schools)
• FlexTech High School, Brighton
• Eisenhower School (Flint Community Schools)
• George Washington Carver Elementary School, Highland Park
• Ottawa Hills High School (Grand Rapids Public Schools)
• Dickinson West Elementary School (Hamtramck Public Schools)
• International Academy of Flint
• John R. Lewis Elementary School (Jackson Public Schools)
• Joy Preparatory Academy, Detroit
• Washington Writers’ Academy (Kalamazoo Public Schools)
• KEYS Grace Academy, Madison Heights
• Gardner International Magnet School (Lansing School District)
• Lyons School (Lansing School District)
• Mt. Hope School (Lansing School District)
• Wexford Montessori Academy (Lansing School District)
• Mildred C. Wells Academy, Benton Harbor
• Multicultural Academy, Ann Arbor
• Oakland FlexTech High School, Farmington Hills
• Woodrow Wilson Elementary School (Port Huron Area School District)
• Saginaw Preparatory Academy
• Arthur Eddy Academy (Saginaw Public Schools)
• Jessie Loomis School (Saginaw Public Schools)
• Westfield Preparatory High School, Redford

There are also schools that will exit additional targeted support:

• Burton Glen Charter Academy
• Bow Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Detroit International Academy for Young Women (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Munger Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Spain Elementary-Middle School (Detroit Public Schools Community District)
• Dove Academy of Detroit
• Hamilton Virtual School (Hamilton Community Schools)
• Tyrone Elementary School (Harper Woods School District)
• Holt Junior High School (Holt Public Schools)
• Michigan Collegiate Middle/High School, Roseville
• New Paradigm College Prep, Detroit
• Parchment Middle School (Parchment School District)
• Beech Elementary School (Redford Union Schools)
• Grogan Elementary School (Southgate Community Schools)
• Clarence Randall Elementary School (Taylor School District)

Recent revelations that the Detroit Riverfront Conservancy, which has been one of the city’s premier jewels, is making major changes, after a massive corruption scandal that took its former chief financial officer William Smith to jail for embezzling $44.3 million is good news. 

The internal financial controls the conservancy is putting in place, including periodic independent audits, is necessary, considering this public body has been the recipient of millions of dollars in taxpayer money as well as private funding over the years. 

No one should provide an excuse for how the conservancy was running its finances under Smith. Yes, Smith was the culprit but the blame should also be placed on everyone who had collective and overall fiduciary responsibility of the organization. The nonprofit should recognize they dropped the ball as a whole and then move forward in a way that instills public trust so it continues to draw support to beautify the riverfront. 

The reduction of its board seat to 30 members from 50 is a good sign. Organizations with that many board members sometimes are bogged down in unnecessary bureaucracy which slows swift decision-making and can lead to less engagement from those who oversee the agency. Some members may feel sidelined because the major decisions often are made by an executive committee.