Connect with us

Finance

Machines Aren’t Coming for the Lords of Finance, Yet

Published

on

Machines Aren’t Coming for the Lords of Finance, Yet

(Bloomberg Opinion) — Central bankers aren’t born as chronic worriers, but they quickly acquire the trait. They are now spending considerable time fretting about artificial intelligence: Its ability to play havoc with prices, jobs, and the security of banking. As gut-wrenching as the meltdown of 2008 was, imagine if a rogue machine turbocharged a market rout. 

It’s not quite a doomsday scenario where AI runs amok and destroys the Earth, said Eddie Yue of the Hong Kong Monetary Authority at a recent conference. But there are plenty of dangers emerging, he added. Yue’s counterpart in Singapore warned of the potential for fraud and cyber attacks. American and UK officials are fearful that algorithms will be used to curtail lending to minorities. While acknowledging the benefits of rapid technological advances to the overall economy, most are wary. 

One thing the lords of finance shouldn’t stress about is dilution of their power. Sure, the legions of Ph.D economists that staff central banks may thin. New algorithms that sift real-time data on everything from car sales to foot traffic at malls will rightly push analysts to think about how their roles will transform. But rather than make the men and women who actually set interest rates redundant, AI could make them mightier citizens. 

The Bank for International Settlements declared as much, saying that the most basic of tasks, deciding borrowing costs, will still be done by mortals. HAL, the computer that assumes God-like qualities in the film 2001: A Space Odyssey, isn’t coming for the Federal Open Market Committee and its global peers. “The ways we organize ourselves and our societies are that we like to hold human beings accountable,” Cecilia Skingsley, head of the Innovation Hub at the BIS, told reporters last month. “You know, changing politicians, possibly changing central-bank governors from time to time.”

She may be lowballing it. The importance of Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell and his cohort may only grow. As retailers develop applications to keep ever closer tabs on competitors and broader markets, the price of milk in Denmark, for example, may fluctuate during a press conference by Powell, argues Lars Christensen, an associate professor at the Copenhagen Business School. When OPEC raises or cuts oil production, that’s very quickly reflected in the price of gasoline at the roadside. Why shouldn’t the same apply to basic food staples, asks Christensen, cofounder of PAICE, a consulting firm specializing in AI and data analysis.

Advertisement

“In many high-income countries, we already have electronic price tags,” he told me. “You might as well plug them into an algorithm. I don’t think my example of standing in a supermarket watching the price of milk change on the screen as Powell announces rates is unrealistic. For practical reasons, we might change the price only when the supermarket closes or you might have a mechanism that says the price can’t be increased while the customer is in the store. The concept is there.”(1)

Utterances from a generation ago can be resurrected to provide bond-market signals, thanks to a ChatGPT-based language model. JPMorgan Chase & Co. built a program that uses speeches dating back decades to detect the evolution of policy signals. The bank’s economists discovered that when the model showed a rise in inflation concern among Fed speakers between meetings, the following FOMC statement had grown more hawkish. The opposite is also true. Turn that into a trading strategy and the opportunities for a payday are plenty. Initially tracking the Fed, European Central Bank and Bank of England, JPMorgan expanded the method to 10 major developed-market central banks.

There’s always room for nuance and considered opinion. Sometimes the signals aren’t especially clear. For example, how do you interpret the Reserve Bank of Australia’s phrase du jour, “We aren’t ruling anything in or out?” A career Bundesbank policymaker might be less inclined to ease than, say, someone from the Bank of France. Bank of Japan Governor Kazuo Ueda can veer off on tangents. His predecessor delighted in surprising investors.   

AI works best when complementing human judgment. In some arenas, there is no substitute for experience. The machines helping reduce tax evasion in Turkey perform a public service, for example. Still, nobody would consider the country a gold standard for performance: Inflation is a stratospheric 72%. There needs to be a combination of electrons and brain waves.The employment mandate of central bankers themselves is unlikely to disappear. If Donald Trump wins this year’s presidential election, he’s pledged not to re-appoint Powell, who may not even want a third term. Safe to say HAL won’t make the shortlist —  this time.  

More From Bloomberg Opinion: 

Advertisement

(1) Christensen discussed the subject at length in George Mason University’s Macro Musings podcast last month.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

Daniel Moss is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering Asian economies. Previously, he was executive editor for economics at Bloomberg News.

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion

HomeNewsMachines Aren’t Coming for the Lords of Finance, Yet
Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Finance

City of Burbank Wins Excellence in Financial Reporting

Published

on

City of Burbank Wins Excellence in Financial Reporting

The ACFR has been judged by an impartial panel to meet the high standards of the program, which includes demonstrating a constructive “spirit of full disclosure” to clearly communicate its financial story and motivate potential users and user groups to read the ACFR. Founded in 1906, GFOA advances excellence in government finance by providing best practices, professional development, resources, and practical research for more than 21,000 members and the communities they serve. Learn more about GFOA by visiting www.gfoa.org.

Previous articleLtter to the Editor: Resident Concerned About Candidate Campaign Donations

The following is a press release sent to myBurbank for publication. Refer to the references in the article for more information

Advertisement

Continue Reading

Finance

Chart of the Week: The jobs report's instant expectations shift

Published

on

Chart of the Week: The jobs report's instant expectations shift

This is The Takeaway from today’s Morning Brief, which you can sign up to receive in your inbox every morning along with:

The labor market offered an unexpected surprise on Friday as the September jobs report showed 254,000 payrolls added in September — 104,000 more than expected.

Worries of a flagging labor market have been the main point of economic focus over the past month as the conversation has turned from inflation, which appears to be in control at last, to the other half of the Fed’s dual mandate.

In the leadup this week, two key reports showed mixed data. The JOLTS numbers showed more job openings, but more conservative hires and quits. The ADP numbers showed surprising strength in private payrolls, but lower wage gains for job switchers — a key labor market thermometer that dogged the inflationary 2021 and 2022 years.

As our Chart of the Week shows, the economists have been caught off guard. September’s report has suddenly changed expectations for the Fed’s trajectory, as the market now sees four 25 basis point rate cuts over the next four meetings and a higher terminal rate when the cuts end.

Advertisement

Renaissance Macro Research’s Neil Dutta sees the print as bolstering the guidance of a 25 basis point cut per meeting until 2025, noting that the report “overwhelms all other employment indicators” that showed a weakening labor market.

“Today’s data might be the first sign of stabilization,” Dutta wrote on X, formerly Twitter.

Nearly every note we saw from Wall Street economists Friday was in agreement. This shifting dynamic suggests that not only is 50 basis points off the table for November’s meeting — some are even questioning any further cutting with numbers so strong.

“Looking at the [labor] market strength evident in September’s employment report, the real debate at the Fed should be about whether to loosen monetary policy at all,” Capital Economics chief North America economist Paul Ashworth wrote in a note to clients on Friday. “Any hopes of a [50 basis point] cut are long gone.”

On the one hand, life comes at you fast. A new report comes and blows everybody’s views out of the water and even threatens to pull the dreaded topic of inflation back in, just when we thought we were out.

Advertisement

On the other, to quote Fed Chair Powell from the June meeting, “it always makes sense to look at a series … rather than just one report.” The “totality” of data, not just one report — which of course will get more weight because it’s still warm from the printer, magnifying the effect of an already huge beat.

What is clear is that the Fed’s wait-and-see, meeting-by-meeting attitude is far from ready to be abandoned, as the moment’s uniqueness keeps showing itself.

Besides the unexpected headline numbers, the unemployment rate-focused Sahm Rule — which has already been played down by its creator, Claudia Sahm — showed an unusual retreat after previously surpassing a recessionary mark that, once passed, usually keeps going up. Another point for the “this time could be different” camp.

It doesn’t end there. Year-over-year wage growth was 4%, up from 3.9%, a gain that would typically spark serious inflation concerns, but hasn’t. Putting aside whether “not cutting” is perhaps tantamount to hiking, the fundamental narrative of the Fed’s directionality hasn’t changed, only adjusted.

Advertisement

Counterbalancing the jobs numbers is survey after survey that shows labor sentiment declining — a factor arguably as important as the actual numbers. (If people feel like jobs are scarce, they may also feel like spending a little more conservatively.)

“On the face of this the Fed should be hiking rates with these sorts of figures, not cutting rates,” wrote ING’s James Knightley. “Nonetheless, we feel that the risks remain skewed towards weaker growth and lower Fed funds given the perception amongst households of a deteriorating jobs market (even if today’s numbers don’t confirm that), which may lead to consumers spending more cautiously.”

For the Fed, at least, the wait-and-see approach looks even better than it did previously as it seeks to gently land the plane. With both the economy looking strong and inflation getting in check, nothing sits to force its hand — for now.

Ethan Wolff-Mann is a Senior Editor at Yahoo Finance, running newsletters. Follow him on X @ewolffmann.

Click here for the latest economic news and indicators to help inform your investing decisions

Advertisement

Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance

morning brief image

morning brief image

Continue Reading

Finance

New Mountain Finance Strategizes for Future with Financial Restructuring

Published

on

New Mountain Finance Strategizes for Future with Financial Restructuring

The latest update is out from New Mountain Finance ( (NMFC) ).

New Mountain Finance Corporation has revamped its financial strategy by amending its NMFC Credit Facility, increasing commitments to $638.5 million, extending maturity for a majority of the funds to 2029, and adjusting the interest margin. Additionally, the company has fully terminated its DB Credit Facility, including the associated collateral security, aligning with the completion of its obligations to the lenders. This strategic financial restructuring marks a significant shift in the company’s approach to managing its credit facilities and debt portfolio.

For detailed information about NMFC stock, go to TipRanks’ Stock Analysis page.

Continue Reading

Trending