Connect with us

Movie Reviews

September 5 Is Almost Nauseatingly Suspenseful

Published

on

September 5 Is Almost Nauseatingly Suspenseful

Peter Sarsgaard captures the right pitch for this type of role: a soft-spoken single-mindedness that can quickly shift to outrage or bewilderment.
Photo: Paramount Pictures

Tight as a drum and almost nauseatingly suspenseful, Tim Fehlbaum’s September 5 presents an unexpected angle on a familiar event. The violent standoff at the 1972 Munich Olympics, which saw the Palestinian terror group Black September take a group of Israeli athletes hostage — an incident that resulted in the shocking deaths of all the captives and most of the captors — has been well documented on film, most notably in Steven Spielberg’s Oscar-nominated 2005 drama Munich. Fehlbaum returns to the event via its on-the-ground transmission: the ABC sports team that, while providing round-the-clock live coverage of the Olympics that year, suddenly found itself in one of the biggest, most dramatic news events of its time.

This approach is filled with potential pitfalls. At heart it’s kind of an underdog story, about sports guys, chroniclers of the frivolous, punching above their weight when given the opportunity. Make it too much of one, however, and you undermine the deadly gravity of the situation. At one point, network headquarters suggests to ABC sports chief Roone Arledge (Peter Sarsgaard) that they let the news team handle this one, and he refuses; his guys found the story, they have access to the satellite link, and they’re the ones on the ground. Sarsgaard, who gave his greatest performance more than two decades ago in another true-life journalism drama, Shattered Glass, once again captures the right pitch for this type of role: a soft-spoken single-mindedness that can quickly shift to outrage or bewilderment as the situation demands. You can imagine this guy, with those seemingly kind eyes that also look like they could slice right through you, leading a newsroom. (The actor, who won the Volpi Cup at Venice last year for Memory, probably deserves a bit more recognition these days as one of the best we’ve got.)

Advertisement

The movie stays largely within the confines of ABC’s remote studio in Munich, which Fehlbaum and his crew have scrupulously re-created, reportedly down to the tiniest details. Its dark, cramped corridors and control rooms absorb the sinister mood of the events happening outside; every decision begins to feel like a life-and-death matter, even though in many of these cases it’s just journalists and technicians pressing buttons and saying words. Much of the suspense derives from the ways that the studio crew, led by Geoffrey Mason (John Magaro) and Marvin Bader (Ben Chaplin), figures out how to cover the unfolding story, from tapping into radio frequencies being used by the police to dressing up a crew member as an athlete so he can smuggle canisters of film in and out of the now-cordoned-off Olympic Village. At 94 minutes, the film races by, but it also demonstrates a patience and fascination with the process — with the whirr of tape reels, the tangle of cables, the lumbering weight of cameras — that enhances the tension. By focusing so intently on this particular group of people covering this broader event, Fehlbaum finds his way into an otherwise pre-determined drama. We know what happened at Munich, yet we find ourselves living through the events as if their outcome was unwritten.

The film also takes on the quality of a conjuring. Fehlbaum has also remained ruthlessly faithful to the facts, interweaving acres of real, contemporaneous television footage with this modern-day reconstruction, so that his actors are interacting with actual images from the era. When they talk to the legendary sportscaster Jim McKay, we’re seeing the actual McKay (who died in 2008) as if he were responding in real time; when an Israeli athlete who got away from the kidnappers comes into the studio for an interview, we’re seeing the real guy. That may not sound like such a dramatic aesthetic gambit, but the incorporation is so thorough, so constant, that the movie starts to feel like a conversation with the past. Which it is: We forget, perhaps, that the presence of Israeli athletes at Munich was a big deal in 1972, just a generation and a half removed from World War II, in a landscape where the shadow of the Holocaust still loomed large.

Of course, September 5 comes at a time when it’s bound to become part of another conversation, about what’s currently happening in Palestine. The film serves as an important reminder that civilians have died on both sides of this conflict for decades — that nobody anywhere, really, has a monopoly on the murder of innocents. And while September 5 was filmed before the events of October 7 and Israel’s subsequent attack on the Gaza Strip and beyond, the filmmakers didn’t walk into this guilelessly; the struggle in the Middle East might sometimes exit the news cycle, especially in the U.S., but it’s been an ongoing debacle for most of our lifetimes.

The hermetically sealed quality of Fehlbaum’s film perhaps prevents us from reading too much into it about contemporary politics — or maybe it invites us to read whatever we want. But of course, such a framing can itself reveal the real-time political machinery of a historical event. Within this heated environment, we see how attitudes and language become codified. At one point, there’s even an internal conversation about whether to refer to the Black September captors as “terrorists.” We know how that one turned out. September 5 reminds us — as did Munich, as does No Other Land, for that matter — that it’s the drip, drip, drip of small, seemingly minor decisions and actions that wind up determining how we see, experience, and understand history.

See All

Advertisement

Movie Reviews

Movie Review: In ‘Miroirs No. 3,’ a slender and elegant tale of mutual rehabilitation

Published

on

Movie Review: In ‘Miroirs No. 3,’ a slender and elegant tale of mutual rehabilitation

Christian Petzold’s beguiling and restorative new drama “Miroirs No. 3” begins with a glance and a car crash.

Wreckage and its long-term aftermath have long marked the movies of Petzold, arguably Germany’s foremost filmmaker. In his finest and most exquisitely haunting film, 2014’s “Phoenix,” an Auschwitz survivor and cabaret singer (Nina Hoss, colossally good) returns unrecognized to her German hometown with a reconstructed face, to a husband who’s said to have betrayed her to the Nazis.

“Miroirs No. 3” doesn’t have that film’s grandiosity of melodrama; it’s more of a lightly enigmatic chamber piece. But it’s likewise preoccupied with piecing life together again after tragedy, and maybe finding some catharsis in music. (The title comes from a Ravel piano piece.) And its startling power will, like “Phoenix,” sneak up on you.

Laura (Paula Beer, the star of Petzold’s “Undine” and “Transit”), a piano student from Berlin, is reluctantly riding in the backseat of a car. Our first glimpse of her, before this road trip, was staring blankly, maybe suicidally, into a river. With Laura is her musician boyfriend, Jakob (Philip Froissant) and a producer that Jakob is hoping to impress. As they drive through the countryside, Laura locks eyes with a solitary middle-aged woman standing outside her home. For a fleeting moment they share a mysterious connection, maybe of some shared strain of depression.

Soon after, Laura says she wants to return to Berlin and Jakob, annoyed, drives her to the nearest train station. But just after again passing the same woman’s house, they skid off the road in a wreck that kills Jakob and throws Laura from the car. The woman runs to help. After the paramedics arrive and treat a still dazed Laura, they’re surprised at her request. She asks if she can stay at the woman’s house, rather than go to the hospital.

Advertisement

What follows is a sweetly oblique, even dreamlike interlude of recuperation. But it’s not just Laura’s. It’s also healing for the woman who happily takes her in. Betty is her name, and Barbara Auer’s performance is as deft and delicate as any you’re likely to see this year. Their time together is spent not discussing their own traumas, but with soft, unspoken kindnesses and daily routine.

Petzold, who also wrote the script, is masterful at meting out backstory. He does it in a way that never feels like withholding to the audience or girding for a big twist, but remains tied to the psychology of his characters. As much as his films might ebb and flow with grief and recovery, their backbone is that of a thriller. Petzold, a great admirer of Hitchcock and “Vertigo,” in particular, makes movies where identity, rather than people, can go missing.

The source of Betty’s pain isn’t revealed until well into “Miroirs,” but it’s not hard to guess at. We learn that her husband Richard (Matthias Brandt) and their adult son Max (Enno Trebs) — auto mechanics who look skeptically on Laura’s arrival — live separate of Betty. Meanwhile, Betty gives Laura her daughter’s clothes to wear, and encourages her to play the piano her daughter used to. Together, they paint a fence and restore a herb garden.

Strange as their domestic life might seem, something warm and good is taking place. We have the feeling Richard and Max haven’t been around much, even though their shop is just a bike ride away. But the four soon begin to almost resemble a family unit. In a movie about two women who intuitively understand each other, Brandt and Trebs are charmingly oafish as men who are eager to fix a dishwasher but less keen on how to repair trauma.

That this idyll is bound to expire, sooner or later, goes without saying. But while another filmmaker might steer such a story toward either disaster or, more likely, schmaltz, Petzold ends “Miroirs” without sacrificing the ambiguous grace that came before. And he turns “Miroirs,” a slender and sweet 86-minute puzzle, into one of the more lovely and profound little movies about how hearts can be mended by just opening a door.

Advertisement

“Miroirs No. 3,” a 1-2 Special release in theaters, is not rated by the Motion Picture Association. In German, with subtitles. Running time: 86 minutes. Three and a half stars out of four.

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Movie Review: READY OR NOT 2: HERE I COME

Published

on

Movie Review: READY OR NOT 2: HERE I COME
Rating: R Stars: Samara Weaving, Kathryn Newton, Sarah Michelle Gellar, Shawn Hatosy, Néstor Carbonell, David Cronenberg, Elijah Wood Writers: Guy Busick & R. Christopher Murphy, based on characters created by Guy Busick and R. Christopher Murphy Directors: Matt Bettinelli-Olpin & Tyler Gillett Distributor: Searchlight Pictures Release Date: March 20, 2026 READY OR NOT 2: HERE I COME may be even more fun than its predecessor, 2019’s READY OR NOT. (Those who didn’t find the first one entertaining won’t be happy here either.) Writers Guy Busick & R. Christopher Murphy and directing team Matt Bettinelli-Olpin & Tyler Gillett are back, along […]Read On »
Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

WHEN HOPE CALLS: BROOKFIELD: Episode 3001: “Gratitude” Review

Published

on

WHEN HOPE CALLS: BROOKFIELD: Episode 3001: “Gratitude” Review
WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD streams on Great American Family and Pure Flix. The Season 3 opener, “Gratitude,” picks up the morning after the cattle raids, as Brookfield faces the aftermath of danger and uncertainty. The residents wake to destruction; farmers assess damaged property and neighbors check on one another. The first episode of Season 3 of WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD delivers high production value with authentic sets and beautiful costumes that highlight the small-town charm fans love. Expansive shots of the surrounding landscapes draw viewers into every corner of the community, while the actors heighten the drama with heartfelt performances

The first episode of Season 3 of WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD contains a strong Biblical and Christian worldview with an emphasis on community, helping others and protecting your neighbor. Characters discuss starting a local church and interview a prospective preacher who speaks on trusting God’s timing and presents a Bible. While the episode delivers wholesome entertainment, there is action violence and peril. An unmarried couple discusses kissing, shares a kiss and embrace. Otherwise, Season 3 of WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD opens championing Christian values, inspiring viewers with hope, courage and uplifting entertainment.

(BB, CC, V, S, M):

Dominant Worldview and Other Worldview Content/Elements:

A strong Biblical and Christian worldview with an emphasis on community, helping others and protecting your neighbor. Characters discuss starting a local church and interview a prospective preacher who speaks on trusting God’s timing and presents a Bible. A woman selflessly cares for orphans. Pro-law enforcement element as Mounties protect and serve their community;

Advertisement

Foul Language:

No foul language but some unkind language with the use of words like idiot, scamps, scoundrels and snake in the grass;

Violence:

Instances of action violence, a man kidnaps, binds and threatens a woman, characters follow a trail of blood to capture an outlaw, characters brandish guns and shoot at each other. A man has a bloody arm from being clipped by a bullet, a man burns his hand lighting fireworks, a character hits another on the head with a shovel, a man tackles a man to the ground and punches him in the face;

Sex:

Advertisement

An unmarried couple discuss kissing, share a kiss and embrace;

Nudity:

No nudity;

Alcohol Use:

No alcohol use;

Advertisement

Smoking and/or Drug Use and Abuse:

No smoking or drug use,

Miscellaneous Immorality:

Characters discuss bribery and speak on not trusting banks to hold their money.

WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD streams on Great American Family and Pure Flix. The Season 3 opener, “Gratitude,” picks up the morning after the cattle raids, as Brookfield faces the aftermath of danger and uncertainty. The residents wake to destruction; farmers assess damaged property and neighbors check on one another.
Advertisement

The first episode of Season 3 of WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD delivers high production value with authentic sets and beautiful costumes that highlight the small-town charm fans love. Expansive shots of the surrounding landscapes draw viewers into every corner of the community, while the actors heighten the drama with heartfelt performances.

The episode opens with the town restoring safety after rustlers brought chaos to Brookfield. Local Mounties, Russell, and Donovan are on the case to track the mastermind. Meanwhile, Tess lands in danger when wounded outlaw, Jerry Huntsman, captures her, confesses his involvement in crimes and threatens her life.

Hannah balances her fashion design projects with her commitment to help Wyatt with work responsibilities. Hannah plans to open a permanent bakery, planting roots in the recovering community. Sam and Maggie explore a possible romance after sharing a kiss the night before. Nora discovers a troubling secret about her former boss that may carry serious legal consequences.

The first episode of Season 3 of WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD has a strong Biblical and Christian worldview with an emphasis on community, helping others and protecting your neighbor. Characters discuss starting a local church and interview a prospective preacher who speaks on trusting God’s timing and presents a Bible.

While the episode delivers wholesome entertainment, there is light action violence and some peril. An unmarried couple discusses kissing and shares a kiss. Otherwise, Season 3 of WHEN CALLS THE HEART: BROOKFIELD opens championing Christian values, inspiring viewers with hope, courage and uplifting entertainment.

Advertisement

Continue Reading

Trending