Connect with us

Midwest

Trial for Michigan school shooter's mother: Revelations from testimony, evidence in historic case

Published

on

Trial for Michigan school shooter's mother: Revelations from testimony, evidence in historic case

Jennifer Crumbley, the mother of Oxford High School shooter Ethan Crumbley, gave hours of testimony this week in her criminal trial related to the mass shooting her son committed in 2021.

Jennifer Crumbley and her husband, James Crumbley, who is being tried separately, are each charged with four counts of involuntary manslaughter in Ethan Crubley’s killing of four students  — Tate Myre, 16, Justin Shilling, 16, Hana St. Juliana, 14, and Madisyn Baldwin, 17 — at Oxford High Nov. 30, 2021.

“As a parent, you spend your whole life trying to protect your child from other dangers,” Jennifer Crumbley said on the witness stand Thursday while answering questions from the defense. “You never would think you’d have to protect your child from harming someone else. That’s what blew my mind. That was the hardest thing I had to stomach is that my child harmed and killed other people.”

She stopped short of calling herself a victim, saying the true victims in the case are the families of the deceased, but she added that she has lost “a lot” as a result of the shooting and her son’s actions. Ethan Crumbley, who was 15 at the time of the shootings, pleaded guilty to his crimes last year and was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

MICHIGAN SCHOOL SHOOTER ETHAN CRUMBLEY’S FATHER CALLS HIM ‘PERFECT KID’ IN INTERVIEW WITH POLICE

Advertisement

Jennifer Crumbley, the mother of the Michigan school shooter, took the stand Thursday in her trial for involuntary manslaughter after the jury heard the teenager blamed his parents, including his father, James Crumbley, for not getting him help before the 2021 attack that killed four students. (Mandi Wright/Detroit Free Press via AP, Pool)

“Of course, I look back after all this happened, and I have asked myself if I would have done anything differently. I wouldn’t have.” Jennifer said.

“I wish he would have killed us instead.”

— Jennifer Crumbley

Jennifer and her husband are accused of illegally purchasing a gun for their 15-year-old son, which he used in the school shooting. They are also accused of ignoring his pleas for help, and prosecutors have presented text messages and emails from Jennifer Crumbley in court to prove she did not take her son’s complaints seriously.

Ethan Robert Crumbley, left, was charged with first-degree murder in a high school shooting. His parents were also charged after the shooting. (Oakland County Sheriff)

Advertisement

James and Jennifer are the first parents to be charged in a school shooting.

MICHIGAN SCHOOL SHOOTER’S MOTHER JENNIFER CRUMBLEY CALLED SON AN ‘OOPSIE BABY,’ WITNESS SAYS

“There were a couple of times when Ethan expressed anxiety over taking tests,” she testified Thursday. “Anxiety about what he was going to do after high school. College? Military? But not at the level where I felt he needed to see a psychiatrist or a mental health professional.”

Jennifer Crumbley is being tried on four counts of involuntary manslaughter for the four students killed by her son, Ethan Crumbley, in 2021.  (Mandi Wright/Detroit Free Press via AP, Pool)

Jennifer broke down Thursday while watching a video of the shooting played in court.

Advertisement

She also answered questions from the state on Friday. Prosecutors suggested she could have stopped the shooting before it happened when she arrived at Oxford High on the morning of Nov. 30, 2021, to meet with school counselors after Ethan was caught scrawling disturbing notes in class.

MICHIGAN MOM ON TRIAL FOR SON’S DEADLY SHOOTING MASSACRE RAISES QUESTIONS ABOUT PARENT CULPABILITY IN SHOOTINGS

His notes included an image of a gun and the phrases “Help me,” “Blood everywhere” and “My life is useless,” along with a drawing of a gun.

James and Jennifer Crumbley met with their son and school leaders the morning of the shooting after a teacher caught Ethan Crumbley drawing disturbing images in class. (Oakland County)

“You could have been with him,” Oakland County assistant prosecutor Marc Keast said Friday.

Advertisement

OXFORD HIGH SCHOOL SHOOTER’S MOTHER ASKS TO DISMISS 3 WITNESSES, ‘GRUESOME’ EVIDENCE THAT COULD ANGER JURY

“I could have, yes,” Jennifer Crumbley testified.

Jennifer Crumbley, 45, is charged with involuntary manslaughter in the Nov. 30, 2021, attack on Oxford High School in Michigan. (Mandi Wright/Detroit Free Press via AP, Pool)

“And you didn’t,” Keast said.

Instead of taking their son home, prosecutors alleged, Jennifer and her husband left him at school and went about their day. Ethan later took a gun from his backpack and shot a total of 11 people, four of whom died.

Advertisement

MICHIGAN SCHOOL SHOOTER ETHAN CRUMBLEY SENTENCED TO LIFE AFTER ADDRESSING COURT: ‘I AM A REALLY BAD PERSON’

Prosecutors also said Ethan Crumbley made a 19-minute video the day before the shooting describing what he was going to do in school the next day.

Video showing Jennifer Crumbley, left, with her son Ethan Crumbley at a gun range Nov. 27, 2021, for target practice, was shown in the courtroom during Jennifer Crumbley’s trial Jan. 25, 2024, in Pontiac, Mich.  (Mandi Wright/Detroit Free Press via AP, Pool)

After the shooting, the Crumbleys allegedly fled Oxford and went to Detroit following some initial questioning from police. U.S. Marshals eventually apprehended them days later, on Dec. 4, 2021.

“The minute this shooting became public and ended up in the paper, in the media, Jennifer Crumbley started telling a story, and then she ran. And she didn’t run just because she was selfish. … She ran, and she started deleting text messages, and she started telling a different story because she knew she did something wrong,” Oakland County prosecutor Karen McDonald said in her closing statements Friday.

Advertisement

“She wants you to believe she’s somebody she’s not.”

— Oakland County prosecutor Karen McDonald

Detectives who did a general sweep of the Crumbleys’ home in Oxford prior to obtaining search warrants testified in Jennifer’s case on Wednesday. Photos presented of the home in court showed a disheveled home before authorities conducted a search. The detective said the home was likely in its normal state when they conducted the initial sweep.

Texts are shown from Jennifer Crumbley, mother of Ethan Crumbley, a teenager accused of killing four students in a shooting at Oxford High School, to a co-worker as Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald speaks in court. (AP Photo/Paul Sancya)

Photos showed shooting range targets with bullet holes hung up in Ethan’s messy bedroom. A second bedroom, which was also apparently the shooter’s room, also appeared messy, with items on the floor and on his bed.

ETHAN CRUMBLEY DETAILED PLAN TO ‘STALK, RAPE, TORTURE’ AND ‘KILL’ FEMALE CLASSMATE, PROSECUTORS SAY

Advertisement

Authorities found a gun safe on a shelf in James and Jennifer Crumbley’s bedroom. The safe had two guns inside. 

Inside Ethan Crumbley’s room, police found spent shell casings on a nightstand on the day of the shooting. They also found an empty bottle of whiskey beside his bed and knives on a shelving unit.

Jennifer Crumbley testified that her husband was generally in charge of keeping the family’s guns stored and secured inside their home. 

Jennifer’s defense attorney, Paulette Loftin, argued that the prosecution “cherry-picked evidence” to accuse Jennifer of involuntary manslaughter.

 

Advertisement

“It’s obvious real life is messy and complicated. And during this trial, I will openly admit that I’m a lawyer who messes up. … I am a human being, and so is Mrs. Crumbley, and that’s what this case is about. She’s not a perfect person or a perfect parent,” Loftin said in her closing statements

Loftin added that the shooting “was clearly not foreseeable to Mrs. Crumbley.”

Read the full article from Here

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Milwaukee, WI

We must have answers before awarding new wastewater contract | Opinion

Published

on

We must have answers before awarding new wastewater contract | Opinion



Milwaukee’s current wastewater treatment contract holder, Veolia Water Milwaukee, is under fire, with some calling for an audit.

Advertisement
play

It goes without saying that Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District (MMSD) is an essential community asset.

Recently, MMSD has been in the news and not in a good way. The MMSD Commission voted to approve an audit of the district’s private wastewater operator. This is less than six weeks after the community organization Common Ground launched a public campaign calling for an audit of Veolia Water Milwaukee, alleging mismanagement of the Jones Island and South Shore wastewater treatment facilities.

I was briefly on a six-member MMSD advisory committee for the 1998 United Water Services contract. Now 28 years, and 2008, 2018, contracts later, the question is what firm to hire for the 2028 contract. I read Milwaukee Journal Sentinel and Urban Milwaukee articles, whistle-blower letters and other materials and jotted down concerns listed below (there are others):

  • Veolia cut corners on treatment time and process chemicals
  • Veolia allowed MMSD assets — buildings and process equipment — to deteriorate
  • Veolia provided inadequate staffing
  • Employees, particularly those who questioned management, were treated poorly
  • Reversing these conditions will be very expensive, if it is even possible to do so

Aren’t these issues sufficient to disqualify Veolia from future consideration?

Advertisement

MMSD has an innovative civil engineering history.

The national American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) designated the Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewage Treatment Plant a National Historic Civil Engineering Landmark when they honored Milwaukee in 1974 for developing the waste-activated sludge treatment process and pioneering a beneficial reuse of biosolids (Milorganite). MMSD has also been recognized for the Deep Tunnel and many innovative infrastructure and flood management projects over the years.

Wisconsin has a strong civil engineering community, which includes the American Society of Civil Engineers-Wisconsin Section (ASCE-WI); five civil engineering university programs with three —Marquette, MSOE and UW-Milwaukee — in Milwaukee); as well as many technical school and apprenticeship programs. Civil engineering projects require many types of expertise and skills.

Is anyone asking questions such as what should be the future of wastewater treatment in Milwaukee? Or what do citizens know about wastewater treatment? Or what do citizens need to know about treatment options to make informed decisions about parameters such as feasibility, public health, environmental protection, costs and financing?

Advertisement

Before the next contract is decided and awarded, shouldn’t human waste generators (citizens), civil engineers and the wastewater industry be asking some of these important questions?

Carol Diggelman, PhD, Emerita Professor, Milwaukee School of Engineering, where she taught for over 30 years, has since retiring, resumed volunteer activities with the League of Women Voters and organized many programs at the intersection of infrastructure and natural resources. 



Source link

Continue Reading

Minneapolis, MN

Reform, money and trust: Council members’ key criteria for Minneapolis’ next police chief

Published

on

Reform, money and trust: Council members’ key criteria for Minneapolis’ next police chief


Minneapolis leaders agree the next police chief is a critical choice, but it remains unclear whether the mayor and City Council can align on a candidate.

Mayor Jacob Frey declined an interview on the topic after announcing the hiring process and timeline earlier in the week. But 5 EYEWITNESS NEWS spoke with City Council Member and Public Health, Safety & Equity Committee Chair Jason Chavez and Council Member LaTrisha Vetaw, the prior Public Health, Safety & Equity Committee Chair.

All agree the police chief is one of the most important roles in Minneapolis.

Asked what it would take to get enough members on board with a candidate so that they can be confirmed, Council Member Vetaw said, “I think we’re figuring some of those things out, but what I hear from all council members is someone who’s strong on reform and wants to actually get reforms done right.”

Advertisement

Vetaw added that the next permanent chief should also have a strong record on slowing overspending.

“We need somebody who’s really going to reel that in and handle our money with care. I think those are two things that I hear from all of my colleagues,” she said.

Brian O’Hara resigns as Minneapolis police chief after report shows he interfered with investigation into his conduct

Asked the same question, Council Member Chavez agreed on key candidate criteria, but he expressed less confidence in the hiring process.

“Well, I mean, I’ve cleared out — I’ve laid out some of the things that I would like to see in a candidate,” Chavez said. “And then I want us to feel included in this process, so they can hear our feedback, and I want there to be robust community engagement. I don’t think that it’s oppositional to this plan. I guess my only thing is I want to make sure that all 13 members are included in this process.”

Advertisement

“I really care about community engagement, I really care about the criteria, and I want to make sure that the police chief that comes into Minneapolis is strongly committed to police accountability,” he continued.

“People want transparency and accountability. They want someone who can speak to the community, and it’s truthful,” Vetaw said.

“Like, we’re all looking for the same kind of leader.”

The question comes as Community Safety Commissioner Todd Barnette, as the head of the department overseeing MPD and nominated by Mayor Frey in April, remains without enough City Council votes to be reappointed. Vetaw supports Barnette, while Chavez does not.

Vetaw said the lack of agreement over Commissioner Barnette is not an omen for the process of hiring a new MPD chief.

Advertisement

“I don’t believe that what’s happening with the commissioner is a direct reflection on the process for searching for a new chief. I think this council certainly separates those two,” she said.

“Do I want to move fast? Absolutely not. I want to move at a pace where we get the best person for the job … and I think we all want that. This is one of the most important roles in the city of Minneapolis.”

Chavez said he hopes the process leads to a chief he can support.

Asked if he believes he’ll be able to put his vote behind the candidate ultimately nominated by the mayor at the end of the process, Chavez said, “I would hope so.”

“And I want to be able to vote for a chief,” he continued. “I just think that we have to make sure that there’s a robust process that includes all council members, and that ensures that the voices of our community are not being left out.”

Advertisement

Former Chief Brian O’Hara was unanimously confirmed in 2022, though the council had a few different members at the time.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Mayor Frey said, “Mayor Frey has been very clear that the search for a new police chief will be a collaborative process that includes community, City staff, and Council Members.” 

5 EYEWITNESS NEWS will continue tracking the selection process, including its cost to taxpayers.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Indianapolis, IN

Ciara Myst is Indianapolis’ shapeshifting superstar on social media, too

Published

on

Ciara Myst is Indianapolis’ shapeshifting superstar on social media, too


play

This story is part of IndyStar’s ongoing series highlighting local influencers. Got a favorite you want to see featured? Nominate them here. 

In reality TV’s modern era, the end of the competition is far from the end of the game. The real work for contestants begins outside the TV bubble, phone back in hand and internet access restored.  

Advertisement

Social media is where reality TV contestants like Ciara Myst can hit their stride. Indianapolis’ “shapeshifting superstar” finished 11th on season 18 of “RuPaul’s Drag Race,” but Myst, a Purdue University graduate and Indianapolis resident with roots in Indy Drag Theater, has since parlayed deep Indy roots and momentum from the show into steady work and new projects capped with a headlining performance at this year’s Indy Pride. 

Ciara Myst, 32, is a drag artist who gained a national profile as a contestant on the most recent season of “Drag Race,” the Emmy-winning reality competition show where drag performers contend for the title of America’s next drag superstar. With a lifelong love of drawing, comic books and horror movies and a background as a special effects makeup artist, Myst began experimenting with drag while still living in Atlanta. She moved to Indianapolis during the pandemic and quickly became a staple in the local drag scene, building her resume for years before getting the “Drag Race” nod.  

With a lifelong love of drawing, comic books and horror movies and a background as a special-effects makeup artist, Myst first tried drag in 2019 while living in Atlanta and began pursuing it seriously in 2021. She moved to Indianapolis during the pandemic and quickly became a fixture in the local drag scene.

Advertisement

Since the show, Ciara Myst has ramped up her already-active Instagram account (@the_ciara_myst) and YouTube channel (@the_ciara_myst) taking fans behind the scenes of her drag. She sat down with IndyStar to dish on her “Drag Race” experience, her rules for handling online hate and why she’s sticking around in Indianapolis for a while.

This interview has been condensed and edited for length and clarity.

Question: How did you get started in drag? What were those early  days like?

Answer: I started as what you might call a “bedroom queen.” I was on YouTube doing a series called “Dabbling in Drag” where I was, every month, building a look head to toe, curating and art directing a photoshoot as a way to propel my own artistry and challenge myself beyond just, “What could I do if and when I want to do this?” Having that schedule and challenging myself to do something new every month is really what built Ciara Myst aesthetically from the ground up.  

It wasn’t until all of the Covid bans were lifted that we started to convene with the community here. Being a transplant from Atlanta meant we didn’t know a lot of the folks in the queer community yet, so we were eager to make those types of connections. It was through an organization called Indy Drag Theater that my partner and I auditioned for “Into the Woods.” That was the gateway for us to meet so many other artists in the community as well as for me to start my performance career here. I had been a performer on stage my whole life, so that was not something new to me. That unlocked the ability for me to engage with the community at large. Then it was performing at Almost Famous, it was hosting gigs. From there it was just sort of, “I’m really loving this. How can I continue to expand on this?”  

Advertisement

You’re consistently active on social media, and you post plenty of behind-the-scenes content and fun extras. Where do you get the inspiration for these ideas, and do you consider yourself an influencer? 

I love creating content. I’ve always loved YouTube. I’m a millennial, so YouTube was kind of the bread and butter of what we were doing with the little handi-cam, just throwing videos together. That aspect of capturing art for fun and sharing it with others was something I always enjoyed. Starting drag, I was like, “This is a place where I can do this.” It became sort of my first stage. 

The title “influencer” feels a little strange to me. For folks out there who want to be an influencer, just be yourself. Any influence that I have on other folks is just a byproduct of my artistry and being who I am. I don’t want to persuade people to go and buy something.  

As social media and content creation and influencing have all become these career paths, drag queen trajectory has also found itself on that path. In order to have longevity, there is now an entire digital platform that most people have to curate. Historically, it was bar performances or theater venue or cabaret or whatever. The digital audience is just a new avenue for folks to perform.  

Advertisement

We have to talk about “Drag Race.” How was your experience on the show? Was it strange to see yourself on TV in real time? 

“Drag Race” was some of the most fun I’ve ever had in my life. It sounds so cheesy, hokey pokey to say that, but I think so many people assume that you go on this TV show and you either come home a winner or you come home traumatized. For me, I was neither. It was like summer camp in the best way possible. To go no phones, which was a gift, and create art every day with a group of artists that I adore and that have become my best friends was such a special, unique experience.  

When you go to “Drag Race,” you relinquish a lot of control in the challenges and what you’re doing, in how you’re going to be presented to the world and how the world is going to react to you. Those are three layers that you sacrifice control, and those things define how the world is going to receive you. It’s a very unique, liberating and challenging experience to say, “I have to be comfortable with whatever happens on this, and I have to be myself no matter what.” 

“Drag Race” is an exciting opportunity, (but) it is a gig. We (the season 18 cast) approached it like, “Yes, this is a great platform. It is an exciting opportunity. It is also a job. It’s a gig.” Folks maybe assume that you go on this show and your whole life is changed and you move to New York, you move to LA, you’re in Hollywood and “Drag Race” is giving you all of these things. Those people worked to get those things. “Drag Race” was just an introduction for us. 

“Drag Race” comes with a very engaged fanbase. How did you handle all the sudden attention online as your season was airing, specifically negative comments?  

Advertisement
play

Indianapolis Drag queen Ciara Myst shares her top three accounts to follow

Indianapolis Drag queen Ciara Myst shares her top three accounts to follow in a video highlighting her favorite creators and influences

You have to create very intentional boundaries. And you will not do that. You will break your boundary, and then you will get your fi-fi’s hurt, and then you’re like, “That’s why I needed to create that boundary.” We’re excited by the idea of like, “Oh my gosh, I want to hear what people think about this.” There is an overwhelming amount of positive, but the loudest voices online are the ones who are passionately disgruntled, who have access to a computer and a lot of free time and need to turn in their homework. 

There was an excitement when this project was coming out, and then very quickly you are exposed to the negative comments about you or anything that you do. It can be very discouraging, so a lot of us talked about ways to create digital boundaries around what types of comments could come into our feed, what types of comments we could see online, what types of websites could we access. That way, when you’re kind of lonely and you’re like, “What did people think about this?” Your internet is like, “Baby, we set the boundary months ago. You don’t need to look for this.”  

I treat my internet like my house. If you want to come to my house, knock on my door and tell me, “I hate that thing that you did, and I think you’re ugly and terrible at makeup.” That’s pretty bold. Most people feel very safe to do that in a digital way. Don’t come to my house and leave hate mail. Don’t graffiti my wall. Don’t leave negativity here because I don’t have room for it.  

Advertisement

Your drag is very intertwined with political activism. Was this always a goal for you? 

In school, we were always taught to be aware of politics. It wasn’t something that I was necessarily as staunchly involved in as I am now. I think the first segue was coming into my queerness and realizing that there is an importance to your community, to your fellow people that comes being queer. A lot of that is respect for the history of where we come from and the people who fought for access to things that I can take advantage of now. 

I think drag just doubled down on it. When I think about the people who were the pillars of the community or the pioneers, it is the trans people who come before us. It is the drag queens. It is the drag artists. Drag offers the community a reason to gather. When it comes to spreading information, sharing education, sharing resources, drag shows were the place to do that. I knew if I was to participate in the art form of drag, it couldn’t just be to be the most beautiful person in the room — that’s just a given. It had to be a commitment to championing the causes of queerness and being an ally to all other marginalized communities. 

Reality TV contestants often move to New York or Los Angeles after their shows air in search of bigger opportunities, but you’ve remained in Indianapolis. Why? 

BeelzeBabe is a fabulous king here in Indy, and he said, “They already have it in New York. They already have it in LA. Why should the people of Indiana or wherever not have access to amazing art just because they don’t live in one of those hubs?” I thought that was such an astute answer because people here crave creativity. They crave art.  

Advertisement

The philosophical answer is that we need great art here in Indiana, and I would be humbled to be a part of that. And I’ve been so privileged to participate in amazing art here already. The practical answer is we’re just a hop skip out of “Drag Race.” People think you go on TV and you’re a millionaire. That reality is not true. We are still building and growing our work and our business. Where that takes us is to be determined, but the home right now for us is Indianapolis, and I love that. I have a drag family here. I have an amazing community here. To choose to take a chance and move on the “what if” of where we go doesn’t feel as enticing as somebody who’s in their 30s.  

You’ve said you want to help revitalize the Indianapolis drag scene. Have you seen any progress, and do you think your “Drag Race” run is helping the city gain traction? 

In decades’ past, we had many other avenues for drag to happen in Indianapolis. That’s simply not the case anymore.  

There are so many systemic things that need to adjust in order to make Indianapolis a sustainable hub for drag artistry. We’re at such an interesting crossroads where there’s so much drag but there’s so few places for people to consume it. The younger folks who are excited about drag on TV, they’re not as excited about going out in public, or going to a bar and paying cover as they are gathering with their friends and watching it on TV. Live drag, local drag is suffering, especially under the current climate. 

I was hopeful that we would see more excitement come out of my TV appearance, and we did see that. That’s the change that brought me a lot of joy. There were more folks who found pride in Indiana than maybe there were before. We saw people have that passion and enthusiasm when they knew there were Hoosiers on TV. The trick is how to capture that all the time. It’s not just the Hoosiers on TV, it’s the Hoosiers who are performing Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday at your local bar.  

Advertisement

Fast facts: Who is @the_ciara_myst? 

Name: Ciara Myst 

Age: 32 

Hometown: Indianapolis 

Content: Drag, makeup, fashion, pop culture 

Favorite Indy spots: Tsaocaa, Beauty 4 U, Monon Trail  

Advertisement

Three local creators she recommends: Indy Drag Theater (@theindydragtheater), Haus of Diva, Pancha’s Penthaus (@penthaus69) 

Advice to potential creators: Be yourself, and don’t give any energy to the negative comments.  

Contact IndyStar Pop Culture Reporter Heather Bushman at hbushman@indystar.com. Follow her on X @hmb_1013.





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending