San Diego, CA
Criticized for restricting public comment, city council vows to respect the Brown Act
At a San Diego City Council meeting this summer, the chamber was a sea of navy blue from the early morning hours. Swaths of the city’s police force had arrived en masse. Even Mayor Todd Gloria showed up.
The day was meant to be ceremonial, or at the very least symbolic. Fronting the council agenda on June 4 was a proclamation declaring the date Police Chief David Nisleit Day. After 36 years with the force, his last six as police chief, Nisleit would be donning his navy blue uniform one last time that week.
One by one, city officials from Councilmember Marni von Wilpert to Gloria took turns speaking on Nisleit’s legacy. And the outgoing chief himself gave a few but lasting words to wrap up his tenure: “I will continue to love this city, but I will be on the sidelines rooting for all of you.”
But on the sideline elsewhere, an undercurrent of frustration began to brew.
Unlike for other items on the agenda, public testimony was not permitted before or during the presentation of the proclamation.
That drew the ire of a group of community members who suggested the council was violating the Brown Act, California’s open meetings law. Former state Assemblymember Lori Saldaña, one of those barred from commenting, later threatened to sue the city.
In a resolution passed Tuesday evening, the city reiterated its “unconditional commitment to cease, desist from, and not repeat any act preventing public testimony on items presenting proclamations appearing on the council’s agenda as required by the Brown Act.”
When presenting the resolution, Assistant City Attorney Leslie FitzGerald said that the motion was intended “to avoid unnecessary litigation” without admitting any violation of the Brown Act by the city. No lawsuit has yet been filed, she added.
Out of the attendees, few seemed swayed.
“It’s a total disregard for the public’s right to simply express dissent or support,” Saldaña said. “It’s as hollow and empty as (the city’s) commitment for our right to speak.”
Nearing the end of the day, only a few people remained in the queue for public comment. But among those left, one message was consistently brought forth:
“I hope that you truly do have an unconditional commitment to California law and the Brown Act,” said Susan Baldwin, a retired San Diego Association of Governments planner.
The City Attorney’s Office declined to comment on the city’s decision to propose the resolution.
It’s not the first time the city has faced accusations of violating public transparency laws.
In 2017, the Center for Local Government Accountability sued the city for not allowing public comment on non-agenda items, including ceremonial proclamations. The city would ultimately pay the center $70,000 to settle the lawsuit.
The city is now fighting another lawsuit, filed in 2022, by a group that says it “suffered interference or reprisal” by officials during public comment sessions. Among those represented by the plaintiff was Saldaña.
An email obtained by The San Diego Union-Tribune shows that ahead of the June meeting, staff from Council President Sean Elo-Rivera’s office had stipulated that there would be no public comment on the “ceremonial items” on the agenda that day.
Coming up soon at the council may be a proposal to eliminate public comments by phone and Zoom during council meetings. The item was postponed from a recent committee hearing.
Elo-Rivera said it would streamline meetings and noted that other cities and public agencies have made similar moves, after adopting virtual public comment earlier in the pandemic.
But his effort has already been met with steady backlash from critics who call it an intentional effort to curb public comment. Elo-Rivera pushed Wednesday’s hearing on the proposal with the council’s Rules Committee to September so that more time can be given to discuss the item through the next meeting.
During public comment on Tuesday, Baldwin suggested that the city should reconsider any such proposal before being cut off and told to stick to the pertinent agenda item.
Originally Published:
San Diego, CA
Opinion: Proposed federal rule would hammer beauty industry
Beauty and wellness are a staple of American culture. Thousands of citizens visit our spas and salons throughout the United States for critical, everyday grooming services they rely on. However, if the U.S. Department of Education has its way, Americans could soon have trouble finding qualified professionals to perform these traditional self-care rituals.
The department is proposing a new rule that would end access to many professional beauty programs — an important and growing trade. The department also is mistakenly labeling professional beauty programs as “low-value programs,” even though these programs offer students almost immediate employment opportunities providing professionals a flexible work-life balance.
Driven by high demand for skincare and hair services, there are currently more than 1.4 million professionals throughout the U.S. who work in the professional beauty industry. The professional beauty and wellness industry’s economic trajectory tells a story of continued and sustained growth. Growing at an annual rate of 7% from 2022 to 2024, according to McKinsey & Co., the United States ranks among the 10 fastest-growing wellness markets worldwide.
But even a robust and resilient industry like ours cannot overcome bad policy decisions that threaten an entire industry. Congress never included an accountability metric for certificate programs like cosmetology or massage therapy programs in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act does contain an accountability metric called “Do No Harm,” which is designed to keep colleges and universities that offer degree programs or graduate-level certificates accountable to the American people.
The accountability metric for degree programs, when applied to certificate programs, will eliminate opportunities for Americans to receive federal student aid, including Pell Grants, to unlock a career in cosmetology or massage therapy. The Department of Education has acknowledged using the Do No Harm provision as an accountability metric will have a severe negative impact on the cosmetology and massage schools nationwide, and determined that 92% of accredited cosmetology and massage therapy schools eventually will lose access to all federal student aid, including Pell Grants, for their students and most likely will be forced to close in the near future.
The one saving grace is that the department has not finalized its proposed rule, and it is not too late for the public to tell the department that this rule does not fit the bill for professional beauty students and schools. Comments must be received on or by May 20. You can submit your comments on the Accountability in Higher Education and Access through Demand-driven Workforce Pell (AHEAD) rule through the Federal eRulemaking Portal at regulations.gov/commenton/ED-2026-OPE-0100-0001. The department will not accept comments submitted by fax or by email or comments submitted after the comment period closes.
Any new rule adopted by the agency needs to account for the overall demographic and work-life balance goals of students and the professional beauty industry. These students and future small business owners deserve the same opportunities as students pursuing careers in other disciplines and fields.
Lynch is the owner and chief executive officer of the Poway-based Bellus Academy and the founding chair of the nonprofit Beauty Changes Lives, which awards nearly $500,000 in scholarships annually.
San Diego, CA
San Diego health officials monitor hantavirus situation as cruise ship passengers return to U.S.
SAN DIEGO (KGTV) — American passengers from a cruise ship hit with a hantavirus outbreak are back in the United States.
San Diego County health officials say they are monitoring the situation and there is no need for panic.
“The risk to Californians is really low and especially here in San Diego. Since the year 2000, we’ve only had 4 cases of hantavirus and the majority of those were in travel related cases so not even acquired here locally,” Ankita Kadakia, deputy public health officer for the County of San Diego, said.
According to the CDC, hantavirus is spread through contact with infected rodents.
“The virus can be in their saliva, feces or droppings,” Kadakia said.
San Diego County does see cases of rodents infected with hantavirus, but the strain seen locally is not the same strain connected to the cruise ship outbreak.
“The vast majority of strains of hantavirus are mouse or animal to human transmission. Not human to human transmission. So the Andes strain, which is found in Argentina, there is evidence that there is human to human transmission,” Dr. Ahmed Salem, a pulmonologist at Sharp Memorial Hospital, said.
Salem treated hantavirus during the 2012 Yosemite National Park outbreak.
“One of the ways you die from hantavirus is you get a collapse of your cardiac system and your pulmonary system and you have to go on something called ECMO. It’s one of the most aggressive forms of life support that you can do. So I do remember that case, and unfortunately, that person passed away,” Salem said.
There is currently no cure or vaccine for hantavirus. Health officials stress that for those who were not on the cruise ship, the risk of contracting the virus remains low.
This story was reported on-air by a journalist and has been converted to this platform with the assistance of AI. Our editorial team verifies all reporting on all platforms for fairness and accuracy.
San Diego, CA
Machado's walk-off lifts Padres to 10-inning comeback victory over Cards
Here’s some instant reaction from the Padres’ wild 3-2 victory
-
Seattle, WA3 minutes agoSeattle weather: 80s on the horizon before a long cooldown
-
San Diego, CA9 minutes agoOpinion: Proposed federal rule would hammer beauty industry
-
Milwaukee, WI15 minutes agoWhat the Bucks can learn from this year’s playoffs: Eastern Conference First Round
-
Atlanta, GA21 minutes ago
From skid pad to train car: How the public safety training center is used
-
Minneapolis, MN27 minutes agoMinneapolis grocery store owner charged in $1 million food assistance fraud
-
Indianapolis, IN33 minutes agoThese vacant school district properties will become affordable housing
-
Pittsburg, PA39 minutes agoMan shot and killed in East Hills
-
Augusta, GA45 minutes agoAugusta factory to produce key component for drugs to fight malaria