Connect with us

Virginia

Virginia surrogacy bill doesn't go far enough

Published

on

Virginia surrogacy bill doesn't go far enough


Virginia is on the verge of legalizing surrogacy brokers. A bill sent to Gov. Glenn Youngkin last week would repeal the state’s ban on accepting compensation for facilitating surrogacy arrangements. The Republican governor has through March 8 to sign the bill into law.

Getting rid of the ban on brokering surrogacy is a good idea. But Virginia should go further and ditch its ban on commercial surrogacy, too.

Obsolete and Paternalistic

Under current law, it’s a Class 1 misdemeanor for any person or business “to accept compensation for recruiting or procuring surrogates or…otherwise arranging or inducing an intended parent and surrogates to enter into surrogacy contracts.” Doing so is punishable by up to a year in jail or a fine of up to $2,500. Someone in violation of this law could also be sued by parties to the brokered surrogacy contract.

“This 30-year-old statute is just absolutely obsolete, and it’s not enforced,” family law attorney Colleen Maria Quinn told a House subcommittee in January.

Yet House Bill 110, the measure repealing this provision, has been controversial—perhaps surprisingly so, considering that the old law is not being used and that actual surrogacy for pay would still be banned. In the Virginia House, votes on the measure were nearly evenly split (50–48).

The surrogacy brokerage ban was passed with an eye toward preventing people from being coerced into surrogacy, notes the Virginia Mercury. Some lawmakers have suggested that ending the brokerage ban would mean more coercion. But there are less extreme mechanisms that can ensure everything is on the up and up. As a surrogate, “you’ve got to have your own lawyer, for goodness’ sake,” Del. Rip Sullivan (D-Fairfax) said at the January subcommittee hearing. And this attorney is “obligated to make sure [a surrogate is] acting of [her] own free will.”

Advertisement

To recap: A woman can say she consents to be a surrogate, show through her actions that she consents to be a surrogate, have a lawyer attest to her consent to be a surrogate…and some people will still worry that she didn’t really consent to be a surrogate.

This is, alas, par for the paternalistic course when it comes to women’s decisions involving their bodies.

A certain sort of person will never be convinced that a woman would willingly become a surrogate, or get an abortion, or engage in sex for pay, and so on. So they deny the agency of women who do, in fact, willingly do these things. And they use this alleged lack of agency to justify roadblocks for women’s “protection.”

In this case, a woman who wants to be a surrogate is not only barred from being paid for her services, she also needs a court-appointed lawyer to speak for her so the state will see her as apable of speaking for herself.

Now Let People Pay Surrogates

There should be no ban on commercial surrogacy. Surrogacy is good for women and good for families (something I elaborated on in a recent op-ed for The Dispatch). It helps families have biological children they may not otherwise be able to have, and it can provide income and purpose to those serving as surrogates.

Advertisement

There’s been a good deal of research on surrogate mothers that counters conservative and radical feminist fears about the process. Far from being a last resort that only women with no other financial prospects do, surrogacy is often undertaken by women with altruistic as well as financial motives. Surrogates often report that their experiences are positive, harmonious, and meaningful. Decades of research on surrogate experiences has found that many are emotionally and psychologically well-adjusted. Studies also suggest that surrogates seldom regret the experience years later.

Of course, such positive experiences aren’t going to be universal. But we don’t generally ban things just because some fraction of people have negative experiences. In fact, it’s a bad idea to ban things based on the prevalence of positive or negative feelings about them at all. Is isn’t the government’s job to protect adults’ emotional well-being.

In this and so many other matters, the government should get out of the way and let consenting adults contract as they see fit.

Virginia lawmakers are right to repeal the state’s ban on surrogacy brokers. Next they should repeal the laws that forbid direct payment for the service of surrogacy and that allow surrogate compensation only for costs associated with the pregnancy.

They should also do away with laws making the whole process more burdensome for all  parties and giving the government final say over whether surrogacy arrangements are OK. Under current Virginia law, a court must approve all surrogacy contracts and the approval is only good for 12 months. To get approval, intended parents and surrogates must pass a home fitness and parental fitness investigation undertaken by a social service worker or child welfare agent. They also have to undergo “counseling concerning the effects of the surrogacy.” In addition, the surrogate must prove that she has given birth at least once before and the intended parents must prove that they are infertile or unable to bear a child “without unreasonable risk.” And all parties must undergo “physical examinations and psychological evaluation” and turn records of such over to the court. Only if all of these conditions are acceptably met will the state give people permission to go forward with a surrogacy contract.

Advertisement

Underlying all of this is the idea that women are too dumb or fragile to make decisions about their own bodies and that the state should get to say who’s allowed to form families and under what circumstances. These ideas need to go, as does the idea that economic concerns can render consent invalid.

As Virginia Del. Candi Mundon King (D–Prince William) told her colleagues during the legislative debate, “being economically disadvantaged does not make you any less intelligent. It does not make you any less able to make your own decisions, whether they be financial, health or otherwise. We should be careful not to stigmatize those who are economically disadvantaged or put them into a category that they cannot understand how complicated and deeply personal surrogacy is.”

Today’s Image

Colonial Beach, Virginia | 2018 (ENB/Reason)



Source link

Virginia

University named among ‘Top Wedding Vendors’ by Virginia Living magazine

Published

on

University named among ‘Top Wedding Vendors’ by Virginia Living magazine


Hopwood & LaRue Catering and Events at the University of Lynchburg has been named a “2026 Top Wedding Vendor” by Virginia Living magazine.

Hopwood & LaRue was listed among Central Virginia vendors in the following categories: Catering, Venue-Event Space, and Venue-Gardens & Estates. For earning a top spot, vendors are listed in the digital “2026 Top Wedding Vendors” guide and receive a virtual badge to share on their website.

According to Virginia Living, the annual list spotlights “vendors who help make Virginia weddings truly unforgettable — from florists and photographers to venues, planners, and more. … This exclusive online list is a companion to ‘Weddings 2026,’ featured in our February issue, one of the year’s most anticipated editorial sections.”

Through Hopwood & LaRue Catering and Events couples can plan weddings at University-owned facilities, including Snidow Chapel and Claytor Nature Center’s Cloverlea Farmhouse.

Advertisement

The company also offers event planning and a full range of beverage and catering services, including vegan, vegetarian, and ethnic options, along with “special curated menus” designed to help clients “develop their ideal cocktail hour and reception dinner experience for themselves and their guests.”

Referring to the 491-acre Claytor Nature Center specifically, Marsh described a typical event: “On their special day, the wedding ceremony typically takes place at the reflection pond, which holds a magical view of Sharp Top and Flat Top mountains,” she said.

“Cocktail hour is then enjoyed [on] the ash lawn, and the reception dinner is later paired with desserts, drinks, and dancing under our extra-large, tented reception area. And the sunset views are just as exceptional as the dining experience.”

According to Marsh, Hopwood & LaRue’s wedding sales have “increased significantly in the past year, and our Cloverlea wedding bookings have quadrupled since 2025. We now have over a dozen weddings and events lined up at Cloverlea for 2026 and are excited to book more and also look ahead into 2027.”

Advertisement



Source link

Continue Reading

Virginia

Instant takeaways from Cincinnati Bearcats basketball loss at WVU

Published

on

Instant takeaways from Cincinnati Bearcats basketball loss at WVU


play

  • The Cincinnati Bearcats lost to the West Virginia Mountaineers 62-60, dropping to 0-2 in Big 12 play.

MORGANTOWN, WV – The Cincinnati Bearcats have started Big 12 play in a hole, losing to West Virginia on the road Tuesday night, Jan. 6, 62-60. UC came back from a 13-point deficit in the first half, had a late lead, but for a second straight Big 12 game couldn’t close.

Up 57-52 with 4:46 to go on a Moustapha Thiam dunk, the Bearcats wouldn’t score again until a Jizzle James 3-pointer with three ticks left on the clock. They would get a final steal and a desperation heave that didn’t fall, and now are winless in two Big 12 starts with 16 remaining on the schedule.

Advertisement

The Mountaineers have recorded all of their wins at Hope Coliseum and are 10-5 (1-1) while UC drops to 8-7 (0-2). Hope Coliseum attendance was 9,903.

Honor Huff led West Virginia with 24 points and, at 5-foot-10, pulled down eight rebounds. Chance Moore added 14 points and Treysen Eaglestaff had 10, including the go-ahead 3-point heave with 1:12 left in the game.

“We’ve got to finish, we had a five-point lead there,” Miller said. “The shot Eaglestaff hits, you’ve just got to go play the next possession. You can’t defend it any better than that. You can’t foul the 3-point shooter (Huff) and we’ve got to step up and make some plays. We’ve got to convert more plays. Sometimes, guys are going to jump up and make a crazy shot. That’s just basketball.”

It’s the first loss this season for the Bearcats when they’ve led with two minutes remaining in the game. Last season, they were 19-0 in such situations, and overall, Wes Miller’s teams are now 88-8. But, on this night, Eaglestaff was “eagle eye” avoiding a shot-clock violation and nailing a “prayer” in Miller’s terms.

Advertisement

“I picked it up and was looking for Honor (Huff) because he was the hot hand,” Eaglestaff said. “I’m looking for him and I heard ‘3-2-1, I’ve got one second left, I’ve got to throw it up!’ I’m like praying, ‘Please go in!’”

As called by a couple of coaches as he released it, it tickled the nylons and gave West Virginia the lead for good.

Jalen Celestine led UC with five treys and 15 points. Day Day Thomas had nine points, making a pair of second-half 3s early to give UC a brief lead early in the second half, but didn’t score over the final 18:30.

The Bearcats were 12-of 35 from the arc, with West Virginia making 11-of-23. West Virginia takes a 14-12 lead in the all-time series and has now won eight of the last 10 meetings. In the Big 12, the Mountaineers are now 4-2 against the Bearcats and have won the last three contests.

“When you win a game like that, you feel really fortunate,” West Virginia coach Ross Hodge said. “A lot of things had to go right in the last four-minute stretch. They had a belief that they could still win the game, not necessarily knowing how we were going to win it, but just our belief that we could still win it.”

Advertisement

Buy Cincinnati Bearcats tickets

UC’s Wes Miller: Us against world

Miller made the comment on his post-game radio show with Dan Hoard and Terry Nelson. When asked in the post-game media conference, he clarified.

“I think our locker room has to have that mentality,” Miller said. “The noise is loud and people are going to doubt and everybody’s going to be against us. If we’d have won the last two games it wouldn’t be that way. Sometimes you have to recognize that’s fickle. We have to just make sure we stay tight and resilient as a team and we will. We’re right there very night against really good teams. We’ve just got to keep pounding the rock. It’ll crack.”

Top scorer Jalen Celestine, UC’s second-oldest next to Kerr Kriisa, agreed.

“We’re only two games in the Big 12,” Celestine said. “We’ve got a lot of basketball left.”

Advertisement

Tyler McKinley, Kerr Kriisa injury updates

Kerr Kriisa was greeting West Virginia friends in sweats before the game and did not play. He was officially listed “out” on the Big 12 game day injury report. Kriisa was recruited by Bob Huggins and played for the Mountaineers in 2023-24, including three games against UC.

As for Kriisa’s next availability, Miller said it was “day to day”.

Tyler McKinley practiced in Morgantown on Monday and was available for Tuesday’s game. Still, Halvine Dzellat was the first post player off the bench.

“I thought he looked good tonight,” Miller said. “I thought that was the best he’s looked. Yesterday (Jan. 5) was the first time he’s practiced since the day before the Georgia game (Dec. 13). It feels like ages ago. He looked good and felt good.”

McKinley finally came in at 8:57 of the first half and 47 seconds scored his first points since the Xavier game. Before halftime, he made a putback that cut the West Virginia lead to three points at the break. He finished with six points, making all three of his shots in just under nine minutes on the court.

Advertisement

West Virginia’s Brenen Lorient, a 6-foot-9 forward, didn’t play vs. No. 3 Iowa State, but returned against the Bearcats.

Cincinnati Bearcats dig early hole

Treysen Eaglestaff had the first five points of the game for West Virginia. UC got it to 10-6 less than five minutes in on a turnaround jumper by Thiam, then they would score for nearly four and a half minutes. West Virginia’s biggest lead was 19-6.

Within six minutes, UC was able to whittle it down to 25-24, as the crowd let out a handful of boos. McKinley’s putback before half cut the deficit to three at 31-28.

The Bearcats came back to lead early in the half, and again late in the game with an 11-0 run that flipped the script from 52-46 WVU to 55-52 UC with a timeout at 3:49. The lead would go to 57-52 before the Bearcats went cold once again.

Advertisement

Honor Huff hoists

The 5-foot-10 transfer from Chattanooga was hot early in the half, making his first five shots before finishing the stanza 5-for-9 with 16 points. The Bearcats were more effective with him in the second half. But late, Huff delivered with his final 3-pointer and a pair of clutch free throws. He was 6-for-10 from the arc, but was most impressed with his eight rebounds among UC’s towers.

“That’s good for me, eight rebounds,” Huff said. “I’m going to have to help no matter what my size is. I put emphasis on putting myself in the right positions to grab rebounds.”

Baba Miller, 13 inches taller than Huff at minimum, led UC with seven rebounds. West Virginia beat the Bearcats on the boards 37-33.

10 Bearcats played before halftime

Down 13 with some of the starters cold, Wes Miller played 10 guys in the first half, including McKinley’s first minutes since the Georgia game.

“Kerr’s injury has been difficult,” Miller said. “We were starting to find real rhythm with older players. Kerr goes down and that’s difficult, but we have some young guys that are ready to contribute.”

Advertisement

Miller mentioned Keyshuan Tillery, who played almost nine minutes and hit a big 3-pointer and Shon Abaev (four points in less than 12 minutes), making key plays in the second half.

“He’s been waiting to break out,” Miller said. “It’s coming.”

Cincinnati Bearcats injuries have been critical

“It’s been something like I’ve never experienced, because it’s been so inconsistent,” Miller said. “Jalen Celestine with the back, we’re getting him where he can practice. T-Mac (McKinley) has been up and down. Kerr now, Jalen Haynes (transfer big man still out). It’s felt like one thing after another. It’s been hard to figure out and Jizzle wasn’t with us. There’s been quite a lot to deal with in terms of roster consistency. It hasn’t been the easiest month, but good things are ahead for us.”

Cincinnati Bearcats Big 12 schedule

The Bearcats are back on the road in Orlando, where Moustapha Thiam returns to face his old UCF team on Sunday at 5 p.m. on ESPN2. The Knights played in Stillwater against Oklahoma State Tuesday night, Jan. 6. The Bearcats return to Fifth Third Arena on Wednesday, Jan. 14 vs. Colorado at 7 p.m.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Virginia

AG Miyares urges Virginia schools to adopt stricter definition of antisemitism

Published

on

AG Miyares urges Virginia schools to adopt stricter definition of antisemitism


Virginia Attorney General Jason Miyares urged all Virginia public schools to adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism (IHRA definition) into their codes of conduct and anti-discrimination policies.

His office pointed to a 25 percent increase in reported hate crimes statewide in 2024, with crimes involving anti-Jewish bias rising 155 percent – the sharpest increase among all categories tracked by Virginia State Police in their most recent annual crime report.

READ MORE | Shots fired near Compass Creek Parkway in Loudoun County

In the letter addressed to superintendents and school boards sent Monday, Miyares states Jewish students “have been excluded, harassed, threatened, and even assaulted.” Miyares pointed to the U.S. Department of Education using the IHRA definition to enforce Title VI and to the Commonwealth’s 2023 adoption of the non-legally binding definition “as a tool and guide for training, education, recognizing, and combating antisemitic hate crimes or discrimination and for tracking and reporting antisemitic incidents in the Commonwealth.”

Advertisement

“Thus, the law of the Commonwealth requires use of IHRA to ‘recognize’ the discriminatory motive behind antisemitic conduct and act upon such discrimination findings pursuant to the Virginia Human Rights Act,” Miyares wrote in the letter, adding: “As part of your compliance with Federal and Virginia law, you must implement the [HRA definition and its contemporary examples into your codes of conduct and discrimination policies to assess unprotected activity.”

7News has reached out to Northern Virginia school districts for their response to Miyares’ letter.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending