Connect with us

Kentucky

Kentucky Allowed to Enforce Trans Care Ban, Appeals Court Rules

Published

on

Kentucky Allowed to Enforce Trans Care Ban, Appeals Court Rules


The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit has again allowed a ban on gender-affirming care for trans youth to be enforced.

The ruling came Monday in a case out of Kentucky. The same three-judge panel of the court had ruled similarly in a case from Tennessee, making the Sixth Circuit the first court to decide in favor of any gender-affirming care ban.

In the Kentucky case, a lower court had issued an injunction in June blocking the ban from enforcement while a lawsuit against it proceeds. But the judge in that case, U.S. District Judge David Hale, lifted the injunction in July after the Sixth Circuit ruled that Tennessee’s ban could go into effect. The Sixth Circuit covers Tennessee, Kentucky, Ohio, and Michigan. The seven trans minors and their parents who had sued over the ban filed an emergency motion with the appeals court to have the injunction reinstated.

But Judges Jeffrey Sutton and Amul Thapar, who had ruled that Tennessee’s ban could be enforced while the suit against it is heard, did the same for the Kentucky law. Judge Helene White dissented in both cases.

Advertisement

Sutton and Thapar held that those challenging the Kentucky ban are unlikely to prove that it violates the constitutional rights to due process and equal protection of the laws. They noted that the young people affected by the ban are given time to wean off puberty blockers and hormones, which they said lessens the harm done by the law. However, in Kentucky the law requires the weaning period to begin immediately, while Tennessee gives doctors and patients until next year to start it. This did not make a difference to the judges, though.

In Kentucky, unlike in Tennessee, some state officials disagree with the ban, and the judges recognized this, but this did not make a difference to the judges either; they said the state has the same interest in making and enforcing its laws.

Kentucky legislators passed the ban over Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear’s veto in May. It was part of a broad anti-LGBTQ+ bill that also bars public schools from teaching about sexual orientation and gender identity, restricts restroom use by trans students, and requires school personnel to out LGBTQ+ youth to their parents.

White, in her dissent, contended that the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on their constitutional claims. In addition, the fact that Kentucky trans youth must begin weaning immediately makes it more likely that they will suffer harm, she wrote. “I would lift the stay [of the injunction] at least with regard to those who were undergoing the now-banned treatments when the law took effect,” she explained.

The Kentucky case is known as known as Doe v. Thornbury. The plaintiffs are represented by the American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky, the National Center for Lesbian Rights, and Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP. The Advocate has sought comment from the lawyers but has yet to receive a response.

Advertisement

The Sixth Circuit court is one of the most conservative appeals courts in the nation. If it and other courts eventually rule differently on whether bans on gender-affirming care are unconstitutional, it could result in a case going to the U.S. Supreme Court. The high court’s 2015 ruling in favor of marriage equality in Obergefell v. Hodges came in a case out of the Sixth Circuit.

Gender-affirming care bans have been temporarily blocked (while cases are heard) in Alabama, Florida, and Indiana because federal judges believed that those who are challenging them are likely to prove unconstitutional discrimination, and a judge in Arkansas has gone further by striking down that state’s law, the first ruling on such a law’s merits. In a suit in Oklahoma, the state and the challengers have agreed that the law will not be enforced while the case proceeds.



Source link

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Kentucky

Otega Oweh setting the tone is a key factor in his hot start to the season

Published

on

Otega Oweh setting the tone is a key factor in his hot start to the season


Kentucky basketball is through its first four games of the season, coming off a blowout 97-68 victory over Lipscomb on Tuesday. The Wildcats have the type of team were any given night, a different player may step up in the stat sheet. Through these four games, though, the most consistent has been Otega Oweh, who has been near the top of the stat sheet in every game so far.

Last game out, Oweh had 14 points on 5-6 shooting, 4 rebounds, an assist, and 2 blocks. Mark Pope spoke with the media ahead of Kentucky’s matchup with Jackson State on Friday, and he said a key part of Oweh’s hot start to the season is his “knack” for really setting the tone to start games and help Kentucky come out strong, which will be crucial when the opponents get tougher.

“Otega (Oweh) has been unbelievable. I don’t know if he’s the headline guy of any game, but he’s the best player in every game almost, give or take. He gets us off to unbelievable starts. Man, he has a knack to start the game. It’s been brilliant, actually. He has an impact. His conditioning has gotten better and better. He’s not getting fatigued on the floor. He’s understanding us better. He’s making a defensive impact. …Otega’s been incredible. I’m so proud of him. He might not have been the most highly heralded guy coming in in this portal class, but he’s been beautiful with his teammates. He’s been really mature about taking advantage of every opportunity he’s given and earning them. He’s grown immensely since the summer.”

– Pope on Otega Oweh’s hot start.

Oweh has been electric in Kentucky’s backcourt, and will be absolutely important in the team’s success throughout the season, especially with his hot starts to games to begin the season.

Advertisement



Source link

Continue Reading

Kentucky

Kentucky vs. Texas Injury Report: Things stay the same

Published

on

Kentucky vs. Texas Injury Report: Things stay the same


We are less than 48 hours away from the Kentucky Wildcats kicking off their week 13 matchup with the Texas Longhorns in Austin.

In what is going to be a tough matchup for the Cats, but for the first time this season the Cats will be the closest to healthy as they have been all season. Now it will feature some big players that will miss the marquee matchup with the Longhorns, but it appears the Cats could return some key players.

In tonight’s update, the UK staff had the report hold the same as Courtland Ford and Kahlil Saunders remain questionable and JJ Weaver stays in a probable status.

The Cats will need all the help they can get this weekend if they hope to pull off the upset. Adding a player back like Weaver to the defense can only help the Cats’ chances of a monster road upset.

Advertisement



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Kentucky

Drone Shows Wintry Mist in Southern Kentucky

Published

on

Drone Shows Wintry Mist in Southern Kentucky


Stormy conditions hit east of Somerset, Kentucky, on Thursday, November 21, as scattered showers passed through the region. Footage filmed and posted to X by Johnnie Nicholson shows fog and wintry precipitation shrouding an area east of Somerset on Thursday. Three rounds of precipitation are expected to move through the region on Thursday and Friday, according to a local news outlet. According to the National Weather Service (NWS), the first measurable snow of the season is forecast for parts of eastern Kentucky on Friday as well. Credit: Johnnie Nicholson via Storyful



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending