Dallas, TX
Here's why the city of Dallas wasn't held liable in the Botham Jean shooting
Jury orders Amber Guyger to pay $100M to Botham’s family
The family was only seeking $54.4 million. They say any money they do collect will go to help others, like Botham would have wanted.
DALLAS – A Dallas appellate attorney says he is not surprised at the award handed down in the wrongful death civil trial of former Dallas Police Officer Amber Guyger.
It was a record number for a case where a police officer â off duty, but in uniform â killed an innocent man, Botham Jean.
Appellate attorney Thad Spalding says heâs not surprised at Wednesdayâs $98.6 million judgment for the Jean family in the wrongful death lawsuit against Guyger.
“I think it’s a very natural reaction to what the facts they were presented with,” he said.
The family was awarded $38.6 million in compensatory damages and $60 million in punitive damages.
“It’s hard to quantify the loss of a loved one,” Spalding said. “And so the way this law works is we put this in the hands of the jurors who get to hear the witnesses, get to hear the family members and decide based on that testimony.”
Family attorney Daryl K. Washington said the city should share in liability with Guyger, but the city filed a motion to be removed from the lawsuit, which was granted.
“The city of Dallas hired Amber Guyger. The city of Dallas was responsible for training Amber Guyger on the night that Botham was killed,” Washington said. “The city of Dallas, the police officers protected Amber Guyger. And yet when you have a situation like this, they kick police officers under the bus, and they run away from the liability.”
A U.S. Supreme Court case decided in 1978 called Monell Liability keeps municipalities, in many instances, from exposure in these kinds of excessive force civil rights violation cases.
“What the U.S. Supreme Court said under the civil rights statute that this case was brought under is that a city is not responsible in that same way for its officersâ conduct,” Spalding said.
So while Guyger was considered acting as a police officer, although off duty when she fatally shot Jean in his own apartment, the city has no financial responsibility for her actions.
Botham Jean’s family, lawyers speak after ruling: FULL
Botham Jean’s parents and lawyers speak after a jury awarded them $98.6 million in the civil wrongful death suit against former Dallas police officer Amber Guyger. Guyger shot and killed Jean in his apartment in 2018. She was sentenced to 10 years in prison for his murder.
“In any other scenario, if you’re driving a truck for a company, and you crash into somebody, and you’re negligent when you do that, you’re acting within the scope of your employment,” said Spalding. “And so your employer is responsible.”
Spalding has appeared before the Fifth Circuit and Supreme Court in Monell Liability cases. He says in order to win against Monell Liability, you have to prove one thing.
“It essentially requires that incidents like this have happened multiple times in the past, that the city was aware of these incidents having happened, and that they didn’t do anything about it,” he explained. “Itâs what’s called âdeliberate indifference.â”
For Jean’s family and others, itâs a high bar to cross, which is why, more times than not, cities are dismissed from these types of lawsuits.
Dallas, TX
MIN@DAL Postgame: Miro Heiskanen | Dallas Stars
DallasStars.com is the official Web site of DSE Hockey Club, L.P. The Dallas Stars primary logo is a registered trademark and the Stars name and secondary logos are trademarks of the Dallas Stars. NHL, the NHL Shield, the word mark and image of the Stanley Cup and NHL Conference logos are registered trademarks of the National Hockey League. All NHL logos and marks and NHL team logos and marks as well as all other proprietary materials depicted herein are the property of the NHL and the respective NHL teams and may not be reproduced without the prior written consent of NHL Enterprises, L.P. Copyright © 1999-2025 DSE Hockey Club, L.P. and the National Hockey League. All Rights Reserved.
Dallas, TX
Cowboys LB coach ‘feels really good’ after NFL draft, new additions
FRISCO, Texas â Smiles are being worn by everyone inside the Dallas Cowboys’ organization after what’s being roundly viewed as one of the most impressive NFL draft hauls in some time, headlined by the 11th-overall selection of superstar safety Caleb Downs ahead of grabbing UCF quarterback harasser Malachi Lawrence to round out the first round.
Not to be forgotten, however, is the work that was done on Day 2, when the Cowboys traded a fifth-round pick to add veteran linebacker Dee Winters to the roster, then using their lone third-round pick on Jaishawn Barham, a versatile Michigan linebacker who will play both inside and outside in Dallas.
The position coach directly responsible for acclimating them to the NFL level and for potentially turning them into impact players is former SMU defensive coordinator Scott Symons, and Symons can barely contain his enthusiasm about his new-look linebackers’ corps.
“The three guys I’ve been able to interact with the past couple of months â Justin [Barron], Shemar [James] and [DeMarvion Overshown] â I’m really excited about the guys that we currently have and the guys that we’ve added to this room, from a culture standpoint, from a leadership standpoint, I think we have a really good foundation to build on in there,” Symons said after the Day 2 moves in Dallas.
He then went on to gush over Winters, whom he knows well from their SMU vs. TCU days.
“[Winters] was very disruptive, an extremely athletic linebacker and the clear leader of the [TCU] defense,” Symons said. “This is a process that’s been going on for some time to try and make this happen. I’ve been a huge advocate for it. When you look at his [2025] production â his ability to run, his ability to cover, the multiplicity that he brings to the table and what it does to that room is really exciting for us. It feels really good.”
The trade was fortuitous for Winters, who is in the process of building a house in Arlington and, just like that, gets a call that he’ll be returning home for good to play football for the Cowboys.
The front office made it clear the decision for Winters began during talks that eventually sent Osa Odighizuwa to the 49ers, and given the fact future Hall of Fame linebacker Fred Warner rubber stamped the move by taking to social media to post that “Dallas got them a real one, for real” attached to a crying face emoji, there’s something to be said for his potential.
He and Barham already fit the mold of what Symons demands from his linebackers, as do the incumbents in the room, something else the Cowboys’ LBs coach pointed out.
“In this position, it’s important to look at the overall alpha mentality,” he said of his group. “All guys don’t have to be the same. You can have two different linebackers on the field, but you’ve gotta have guys that have strong leadership qualities.”
Dallas, TX
Game Day Guide: Stars vs Wild | Dallas Stars
First Shift đ
The Stars have a history of bouncing back quickly in the first two rounds of the playoffs.
In the past three seasons, Dallas is 14-1 after a loss in the first two rounds, and thatâs a big reason it has made it to the Western Conference Final for three consecutive seasons.
âItâs just the guys knowing how to park it,â said Stars goalie Jake Oettinger. âI think weâve done it enough, so itâs just part of who we are.â
Dallas has been a great response team for years. Former Stars forward Joe Pavelski pushed to not have consecutive losses at any point during the regular season, and that built a way of playing. Current players have carried that tradition and pushed for a mix of calm and intensity after a loss.
âWeâve been doing it as a group all year long,â said captain Jamie Benn. âOur group has been through a lot the last couple of years, so we have some good memories.â
The one time they lost two consecutive games, they still bounced back from an 0-2 hole to beat Vegas in seven games. Other than that, the team and Oettinger have come up with an answer quickly.
âJust play better, do more,â said defenseman Esa Lindell when asked how the team could improve after an overtime loss. âI thought we played pretty well, but we can be better.â
The Stars said they felt good about their effort in Game 4 â a 3-2 overtime loss. They had a 45-43 advantage in shots on goal, an 84-83 edge in shot attempts and a 32-29 advantage in faceoffs. Dallas scored twice on the power play and Minnesota scored three at even strength, and that is an area that will be studied.
But forward Rantanen said he was encouraged by his teamâs chances.
âWe just have to stick with it,â Rantanen said. âBoth teams can defend, both teams can play offense. We need to find a couple of bounces in the 5-on-5 game and go to the net and get lucky.â
Defenseman Heiskanen said he felt good about Game 4.
âWe played a solid game and could have won,â he said. âI think we played well 5-on-5, we just didnât score. If we play the same way, it will come at some point.â
Dallas coach Glen Gulutzan echoed those sentiments. He will have to shuffle his defense pairs because Nils Lundkvist suffered a facial laceration in Game 4 and will not play Tuesday. However, when asked about making changes in his forward group, Gulutzan said among the options is keeping the lineup the same.
âSometimes, success lags behind the good things youâre doing,â Gulutzan said. âRight now, we just have to keep doing things and take the next steps and hopefully weâll get success.â
Trade deadline acquisition Michael Bunting has yet to play in the playoffs and veteran Adam Erne came out after Game 1, so they are eligible replacements. But it would be tough to take out a player like Colin Blackwell, Oskar BÀck or Arttu Hyry, because they have been playing well.
âWhen you look at all the metrics, we just need to take the next step. We just need to get to loose pucks, get some tips, that kind of thing. Everything else is there. But there is another step to it, something harder,â Gulutzan said. âWe like where we are. There are certainly things we can do to create more offense, go to the net a little better and get to the tougher areas. Right now, youâre down to the last little tightening of the screws. After four games, teams know each other pretty good, so it becomes a little bit of a battle of wills.â
Minnesota understands. It battled back from a 2-1 deficit in the third period and then won in overtime in Game 4.
âWeâve been in a 2-2 series before, and weâve got to play a really, really good, smart, detailed game in Dallas,â Wild forward Marcus Foligno told reporters in Minnesota on Monday. âI think the momentum of the game is something that we have to learn to control in Dallas, so all eyes are just on Game 5. I mean, you canât look at Game 6 or 7, itâs got to be just, how can we win in Dallas for one game?â
The Stars have the same attitude. Itâs worked in the past.
âYou just move on and get to the next one,â said defenseman Heiskanen.
That easy?
âYeah. That easy,â he said.
-
Rhode Island2 minutes agoRhode Island Airport Could Lose Its Crosswind Runway
-
South-Carolina8 minutes agoâBring it onâ: Evette responds to SC State protests against commencement speech
-
South Dakota14 minutes agoHereâs how much South Dakotans could save on property taxes after accounting for higher sales taxes
-
Tennessee20 minutes agoGov. Lee on ‘America 250’ tour of Tennessee’s 95 counties
-
Texas26 minutes agoTexas Democrat Talarico Has Edge on Republicans in Senate Race
-
Utah32 minutes agoUtah Supreme Court to hear challenges to new ‘constitutional court’ law
-
Vermont38 minutes agoWhy Does Vermont Have the Lowest Birth Rate in the Nation? | Seven Days
-
Virginia44 minutes agoVirginia Beach businesses can seek compensation for curfew losses