Rhode Island
Illegal seawall still stands. State regulators sit on proposed change in development rules. • Rhode Island Current
More than a year has passed since state regulators fined a North Kingstown country club for building a seawall along its property line, without permission and in violation of state coastal regulations.
The 600-foot-long stone wall, built in January 2023, is still standing.
Meanwhile, a parallel but separate consideration of Quidnessett Country Club’s application to ease development restrictions — in turn, potentially, allowing a seawall — remains under review by the Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council after a panel punted a recommendation on Tuesday.
The Planning and Procedures Subcommittee’s 4-0 vote will give the country club and its attorney time to make the case for a permanent safeguard between its flagship golf course and the adjacent tidal waters.
“We haven’t seen the evidence yet as to why it’s necessary,” Anthony DeSisto, attorney for the CRMC, said in an interview after the meeting. “We have got to be fair to everyone.”
‘If we get sued’
Also on DeSisto’s mind: the threat of litigation, which has proven a popular route for various parties unhappy with coastal regulators’ decisions.
“If we get sued, we need to make sure there are no appealable issues,” DeSisto said.
The decision to delay a decision came after an hourlong presentation from the council’s coastal policy analysts, who, in a Sept. 20 report, recommended against Quidnessett’s petition to redesignate a section of tidal waters along its northeastern property line.
If approved, the April 12 petition would downgrade the water classification from the existing Type 1 “conservation area” to a less stringent Type 2 “low intensity use,” which could — though it doesn’t have to — allow for a permanent structure like a seawall. Under the existing designation, all permanent structures are banned.
Jennifer Cervenka, attorney for Quidnessett and former CRMC chair, pointed to nearby residential development and recreational use as reasons why the strict conservation designation should be reconsidered.
The staff in its report argued just the opposite, stressing the importance of the sensitive salt marshes surrounding the shoreline, along with marine wildlife, which were the very reason why the agency restricted development there in the first place — formally codified under state water type classifications created in the early 1980s.
“To suggest that shoreline characteristics have changed to the point where there is no longer a balanced relationship between the shoreline characteristics of mainland upland activities and the water type classification is to admit that a party has altered the shoreline’s characteristics in violation of [agency] rules and regulations,” the report stated.
A civil engineering firm hired by the country club backed its argument that a non-permanent structural barrier was insufficient to protect against rising sea levels and weather events. Yet the staff report said the “severe wave action” and shoreline erosion makes the area “particularly unsuitable for structures.”
Council staff also was unpersuaded by country club members’ focus on the golf course’s historic significance. The 18-hole golf course designed by architect Geoffrey Cornish opened in 1960, and is not listed in federal or state historic registers.
300 pages of public comments
As for the members-only club’s insistence that it is a key economic support for its employees and the many charities that host fundraisers there? “Anecdotal,” was the staff analysis, adding that a full cost-benefit analysis may be needed if the council considers advancing the club’s request to change the water type.
The 300 pages of written public comments received included a mix of support and opposition. Among the critics: Jim Boyd, former CRMC deputy director; the Rhode Island Office of the Attorney General; and Save the Bay.
Jed Thorp, advocacy coordinator for Save the Bay, said he was disappointed in the lack of a decision Tuesday.
“The facts of the case aren’t going to change,” Thorp said. “The laws and the rules that the staff clearly laid out in the staff report aren’t going to change…. They should have denied the petition today.”
To Thorp, the delay also showcases shortcomings in the agency structure, in which the politically appointed council can — and does — defy recommendations of its expert staff. Save the Bay for years has petitioned state lawmakers to abolish the council and restructure the agency as an administrative authority, akin to the Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management.
The facts of the change aren’t going to change. The laws and the rules that the staff clearly laid out in the report aren’t going to change. They should have denied the petition today.
– Jed Thorp, advocacy coordinator for Save the Bay
“Given the council’s track record of ignoring staff recommendations, it’s unfortunately not surprising,” Thorp said.
Asked to respond to Thorp’s comment, Raymond Coia, CRMC chair, said in an interview after the meeting that the council has not decided against what its staff recommended. It hasn’t made a decision at all.
Cervenka, the country club’s attorney, and its owners, spoke during the July public hearing. But they have not submitted formal evidence, nor presented expert witnesses, Coia said.
The subcommittee is tentatively scheduled to take up this additional information at an October meeting. A subcommittee recommendation, for or against the reclassification petition, still requires final approval from the full, seven-member council.
“While we don’t agree with the conclusion of the staff report, we look forward to presenting our petition in the near future,” Mike Raia, a spokesperson for Quidnessett, said in an email Tuesday night. “We believe it will show that the change we seek is appropriate for this area of shoreline. What’s clear is that the climate is changing rapidly and the State of Rhode Island needs to modernize its regulatory processes to ensure that resilient infrastructure can be built at the speed of climate change. Rhode Island’s coastal businesses – big and small – cannot survive if resilient infrastructure investments take decades to get approved. We’ll continue to work with CRMC and other regulatory partners to find a path forward that protects our historic property and our cherished Bay.”
If the water reclassification is granted, the club must then apply for a permit to build any kind of permanent structure along the shoreline.
A separate review of the required plan to remove the existing seawall and restore the shoreline remains under review, CRMC Executive Director Jeff Willis said Tuesday.
Updated to include a response from Mike Raia on behalf of Quidnessett Country Club.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Rhode Island
BBBSRI honors local community member for raising funds and improving sustainability | ABC6
BARRINGTON, R.I. (WLNE) — Big Brothers Big Sisters of Rhode Island awarded a local community member for his efforts which have collected almost 4,000 pounds in clothes and linens for the organization.
Barrington resident Richard Staples was awarded the Bonney B. Sevellon Award for Creative Impact, which honors those who introduce new ideas that assist BBBSRI.
Staples has held neighborhood clothing drives since 2022, which was inspired when he spotted a cardboard donation box at BBBSRI’s office.
“Why not bring my neighbors together to fill one at our house?” Staples said.
Since then, he has collected dozens of donations on the front lawn of his home.
According to BBBSRI, his efforts have raised funds for youth mentorship, improved sustainability, and allowed for the community to both “declutter” their homes and support children in the area.
“Folks like Richard, who rally their communities behind BBBSRI, are essential to our mission,” BBBSRI CFO Jack Blatchford said. “Richard’s leadership and commitment not only raise crucial funds for mentoring but also foster a culture of sustainability and giving back. His work shows how one person’s vision can make Rhode Island a stronger, more supportive community.”
BBBSRI asks Rhode Island residents to drop donations off at any of the 150 green bins across the state or at one of five donation centers, as well as offers free scheduled pick-ups from homes for those who are not able to drop off.
Additionally, BBBSRI encourages men to consider becoming a mentor for the over 350 boys on the waitlist.
For more information, visit BBBSRI’s website.
Rhode Island
Rhode Island drew record number of visitors in 2023 • Rhode Island Current
The silver lining of inflation: Rhode Island’s tourism economy benefited from $5.6 billion in visitor spending in 2023, according to new research by a state commissioned consultant.
A presentation by international firm Tourism Economics for Rhode Island Commerce Corporation showed visitor spending grew more than twice as fast as the increase in the number of visitors in 2023. The 28.4 million people who traveled to the Ocean State in 2023 is 2.2% higher than the prior year, but their total spending on travel, food, lodging and entertainment grew 4.6% year-over-year.
That’s driven by demand growth as well as price hikes for commodities and services, according to the research.
More than one-quarter of the direct spending, 26%, stemmed from food and beverage sales. Lodging, including hotels, second houses and short-term rentals, was the second-highest expense, contributing $1.2 billion.
Air transportation saw the biggest annual increase, up 10.2%, to $328 million in 2023. Rhode Island Airport Corporation, the quasi-public entity that manages the state’s airports, gets a share of revenue from passengers on flights, as well as fees for the airlines to land, use hangar space, and other related services.
In March 2023, Breeze Airways opened a permanent base at Rhode Island T.F. Green International Airport, with plans to invest $160 million and hire up to 250 employees over the next five years. Commerce awarded the Utah-based airline $2.9 million in tax credits tied to the job creation plans.
Commerce has also experimented with various destination marketing ploys, from giant, traveling stuffed quahogs to the $2.2 million “All That” ad campaign rolled out in February of this year.
“The economic activity generated from the travel sector represents a critical component of the state’s current and future growth,” Anika Kimble-Huntley, Commerce’s chief marketing officer, said in a statement. “The Commerce team will continue to work with our great partners, statewide, to support the upward trajectory of tourism and record-breaking visitation.”
Visitor count and direct spending in 2023 broke prior state records, exceeding pre-pandemic numbers. However, the number of jobs tied to the state’s tourism economy remains slightly below its 2019 peak.
The 38,329 jobs directly tied to the tourism economy in 2023 remains about 1,000 jobs, or 2.5%, below 2019 levels. Including jobs that indirectly benefited from tourism, 2023 activity helped to sustain 86,612 jobs, while generating $935 million in state and local tax revenues, according to the research.
“Tourism plays a vital role in Rhode Island’s economy by creating jobs, supporting our local businesses, and showcasing everything that makes our state a premier destination,” Commerce Secretary Liz Tanner said in a statement. “I applaud the dedicated efforts of the tourism team at Rhode Island Commerce and all others in the industry that helped reach this accomplishment.”
Including direct spending, jobs and tax revenue, the visitor economy totaled $8.3 billion in 2023, a 4.5% increase over the prior year.
The research reflects federal labor and jobs statistics, state and local tax revenues, short-term rental information and information from market research group Longwoods International.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES.
Rhode Island
Rhode Island’s Farrell, Brown’s Lilly collect hoops hardware. Here’s what they won
Brown men’s basketball coach Mike Martin speaks after a Bears win Sunday
The Bears recorded 27 assists and 15 made-threes, the most assists in at least a decade, the close out the College Hill Classic on Sunday night.
Kino Lilly Jr. and Tyonne Farrell took home some hardware as college basketball season cruised past the halfway point of its opening month.
Lilly was named the Ivy League Player of the Week and Farrell repeated as the Atlantic 10 Rookie of the Week. The guard from Brown and forward from the University of Rhode Island received their respective honors on Monday afternoon.
Lilly posted three 20-point games in as many nights for the Bears at their College Hill Classic, which was played at the Pizzitola Center. He hit for 26 points in an opening Friday win over New Hampshire and collected 20 in a closing Sunday victory over Sacred Heart. Lilly was 14-for-29 from 3-point range and posted 13 assists.
Lilly set a Brown program mark in the middle game against Holy Cross, surpassing JR Hobbie as the all-time leader in 3-pointers. Hobbie connected 257 times from beyond the arc in his 115 games, a career that ran from 2013-17. Lilly is currently at 264 makes from deep through 91 career games, starting with the Bears in 2021.
Farrell recorded a first career double-double in a blowout of Franklin Pierce, totaling 10 points and 10 rebounds in the 105-73 triumph. Farrell added six assists and two steals in just 22 minutes, as the Rams pulled away in the second half. He was a plus-22 in the box score.
Farrell is the first URI freshman to win consecutive conference rookie honors since E.C. Matthews grabbed four straight in 2013-14. That string was broken by teammate Hassan Martin — both cornerstones were among the first recruiting class brought in by former coach Dan Hurley. Farrell looks to have the makings of an impact talent for the Rams, starting each of his first three career games.
Brown will be back in action on Saturday at Canisius. URI returns sooner, hosting Lafayette in a 7 p.m. tip on Wednesday. The two teams will renew their rivalry series on Dec. 10 on the East Side.
bkoch@providencejournal.com
On X: @BillKoch25
-
News1 week ago
Herbert Smith Freehills to merge with US-based law firm Kramer Levin
-
Technology1 week ago
The next Nintendo Direct is all about Super Nintendo World’s Donkey Kong Country
-
Business6 days ago
Column: OpenAI just scored a huge victory in a copyright case … or did it?
-
Health6 days ago
Bird flu leaves teen in critical condition after country's first reported case
-
Business3 days ago
Column: Molly White's message for journalists going freelance — be ready for the pitfalls
-
Politics1 week ago
Editorial: Abortion was on ballots across the country in this election. The results are encouraging
-
World1 week ago
Sarah Palin, NY Times Have Explored Settlement, as Judge Sets Defamation Retrial
-
Politics2 days ago
Trump taps FCC member Brendan Carr to lead agency: 'Warrior for Free Speech'