Leaked Chinese language authorities data reveal detailed surveillance experiences on Uyghur households and Beijing’s justification for mass detentions
By Ivan Watson and Ben Westcott
Hong Kong (CNN) — Rozinsa Mamattohti couldn’t sleep or eat for days after she learn the detailed data the Chinese language authorities had been protecting on her complete household.
She and her kin, most of whom reside in China’s western Xinjiang area, aren’t dissidents or extremists or well-known. However in a spreadsheet stored by native officers, her complete household’s lives are recorded at size together with their jobs, their non secular exercise, their trustworthiness and their stage of cooperation with the authorities. And this spreadsheet may decide if Mamattohti’s sister stays behind razor wire in a authorities detention middle.
Advertisement
Her household’s data, and tons of of presidency experiences like them, have been leaked to journalists by a patchwork of exiled Uyghur activists.
The doc reveals for the primary time the system utilized by the ruling Chinese language Communist Celebration to justify the indefinite detention on trivial grounds of not solely Mamattohti’s household however tons of — and probably hundreds of thousands — of different residents in closely fortified internment facilities throughout Xinjiang.
It’s the third main leak of delicate Chinese language authorities paperwork in as many months, and collectively the knowledge paints an more and more alarming image of what seems to be a strategic marketing campaign by Beijing to strip Muslim-majority Uyghurs of their cultural and spiritual id and suppress habits thought of to be unpatriotic.
The Chinese language authorities has claimed it’s operating a mass deradicalization program concentrating on potential extremists, however these official data, verified by a workforce of consultants, present folks will be despatched to a detention facility for merely “sporting a veil” or rising “an extended beard.”
For Mamattohti’s sister, 34-year-old Patem, the crime for which she was detained, in response to the doc, was a “violation of household planning coverage,” or put merely, having too many kids. Below the countrywide coverage, which not often if ever is trigger for imprisonment, rural households in Xinjiang are restricted to 3 kids. Patem had 4.
Advertisement
It was the primary time since 2016 that Mamattohti had acquired any concrete information of what had occurred to her household.
“I by no means imagined that my youthful sister could be in jail,” Mamattohti informed CNN, by means of tears, in her home in Istanbul. She stated she first noticed the leaked data after they have been informally circulated on social media amongst Uyghurs abroad. “As I used to be studying their names I couldn’t maintain myself collectively, I used to be devastated.”
The leak exposes what seems to be an in depth and far-reaching system of state surveillance within the area, run by the native authorities in Xinjiang, designed to focus on Chinese language residents for peacefully training their tradition or faith.
CNN has solely been capable of independently confirm a few of the data contained within the doc. However a workforce of consultants, led by Adrian Zenz, senior fellow in China research on the Victims of Communism Memorial Basis in Washington DC, say they’re assured that it’s an genuine Chinese language authorities doc.
The leaked doc is a 137-page PDF file, probably generated from an Excel spreadsheet or Phrase desk. Zenz pointed to the usage of related terminology and language on this doc, which he refers to because the Karakax Record, and different data leaked from Xinjiang.
Advertisement
He stated the data confirmed that Beijing was detaining Uyghur residents for actions that in lots of instances didn’t “remotely resemble a criminal offense.”
“The contents of this doc are actually important to all of us as a result of it exhibits us the paranoid mindset of a regime that’s controlling the up-and-coming tremendous energy of this globe,” Zenz informed CNN.
A redacted model of a part of a Chinese language authorities PDF doc which was leaked to CNN, displaying data of detainees in Xinjiang.
CNN despatched a replica of the doc to each the Chinese language Ministry of Overseas Affairs and the native authorities in Xinjiang, to see if they may confirm its authenticity. There was no response.
Talking in Germany on Thursday, Chinese language Overseas Minister Wang Yi stated that he would gladly welcome any worldwide diplomats or media to go to Xinjiang to see the reality for themselves.
“(Those that have come) haven’t seen any focus camps or persecution in Xinjiang. Nevertheless, what they’ve seen is that each one ethnic teams are capable of reside peacefully and harmoniously … Their non secular freedom is completely protected they usually can apply their faith with none restrictions,” he stated.
Advertisement
“The so-called focus camps with so-called 1 million individuals are 100% rumors. It’s fully pretend information. I don’t perceive why these individuals are nonetheless mendacity whereas having the info. I can solely say that these individuals are deeply prejudiced towards China.”
A earlier try by CNN to go to the detention facilities in Xinjiang was blocked by native authorities authorities.
The doc: Household, neighbors, faith
China’s huge western area of Xinjiang has for hundreds of years been house to a big inhabitants of predominantly Muslim ethnic teams, the most important of which is the Uyghur. Till lately, there have been many extra Uyghur residents in Xinjiang than Han Chinese language, the ethnic majority in the remainder of the nation.
Since 2016, proof has emerged that the Chinese language authorities has been working large, fortified facilities to detain its Uyghur residents. As many as two million folks might have been taken to the camps, in response to the US State Division.
Advertisement
Former detainees and activists say the amenities are literally designed for the needs of re-education — locations the place inmates are forcibly taught Mandarin and instructed in Communist Celebration propaganda. Some testimonies from former detainees describe over-crowded cells, torture and even the deaths of fellow detainees.
The leaked doc seems to be a compilation of 667 data of detained Uyghur residents, all of whom lived inside a small neighborhood of Karakax county, also referred to as Moyu, in southwestern Xinjiang. A variety of the 667 data look like duplicates, however in whole they signify 311 people who have been despatched to detention facilities.
Advertisement
Inhabitants figures from 2015 present Karakax was house to simply over 560,000 folks, 97.6% of whom have been ethnically Uyghur.
In December 2016, 5 folks have been killed — together with three assailants — when a gaggle of males allegedly attacked the native Karakax Communist Celebration workplace with knives and detonated an explosive system. Chinese language state media described it as a terrorist assault.
It was a sequence of lethal assaults like this throughout Xinjiang and different elements of China which Beijing has used to justify its mass detention of Uyghurs, purportedly as a method of nullifying the alleged risk of Islamic extremism. The Chinese language Overseas Ministry says that for the reason that system was put in place three years in the past, nobody has been killed in terror assaults in Xinjiang.
Advertisement
Few dates are included on the leaked doc, however the earliest date of detention listed is in January 2017, suggesting that these Uyghurs started to be put into camps after the December assault.
The leaked evaluations include detailed experiences on every of the detained residents and their households, together with not solely their nationwide ID numbers and occupations, however descriptions of their neighbors and rigorous assessments of their day by day non secular exercise.
These parts are referred to within the doc because the Three Circles — household, social and spiritual associations. Based mostly on these evaluations, every report additionally incorporates an official judgment on whether or not the detainee must be allowed to depart their camp.
How a detainee is judged
Advertisement
One report concludes: “(The detainee’s) keep has been lower than one 12 months and it’s endorsed she proceed her coaching to enhance her Mandarin.”
The doc by no means refers to detention facilities or detainees particularly, referring to them euphemistically as coaching facilities and trainees, consistent with the Communist Celebration’s practices of referring to the camps as locations for “vocational coaching.”
The truth that the doc’s assessments all query whether or not or not the folks despatched to the detention facilities must be allowed to depart would seem to point their actual perform.
Advertisement
It isn’t clear who has compiled the record or from which authorities division it comes, however the stage of element on every detainee’s day by day non secular habits earlier than they have been despatched away is fastidiously recorded and particular.
Editor’s observe: it is a recreation of 1 report, not a replica.
One case research reads: “It’s discovered that earlier than (the detainee) was despatched to the coaching middle, she did namaz (day by day prayers) daily in 2014, prayed after meals and prayed on the household graves throughout festivals. Her non secular information got here from her grandmother.”
One other detainee is recorded as having refused to take off her face veil for years. “She went to Saudi Arabia together with her husband twice, she insisted on sporting a face veil … with the excuse of rhinitis (allergic reactions), regardless of committee cadres asking her (not) to take action a number of occasions,” the report says. The girl took off her veil in 2016, however was nonetheless despatched to a detention middle for being a “potential risk.”
The alleged offenses for which Uyghurs and different ethnic Muslim minorities have been detained look like at odds with Beijing’s claims of a program of deradicalization.
Advertisement
For instance, about 114 of the detainees within the leaked data have been despatched to the camps for having too many kids, 25 for having a passport with out having traveled internationally and 13 for having “sturdy non secular traditions” of their household.
Some have been detained merely for studying or proudly owning “unlawful books” or having a member of the family who was in jail.
Primary causes for detention within the doc
Violation of household planning coverage (having extra kids than is allowed)
Potential risk (varied causes)
Having a prison report, ex-prisoner
Holding a passport with out visiting a overseas nation
Advertisement
Visiting one in all 26 “delicate international locations”
Unlawful preaching, attending or permitting room for unlawful preaching
Liable to being radicalized resulting from non secular traditions in household
Member of the family of a prison or ex-prisoner
Sporting a face veil
Advertisement
Having an extended beard
Your spouse sporting a face veil
Making an unauthorized pilgrimage
“The doc clearly exhibits … that the re-education camps usually are not for individuals who have been convicted of something in any respect. They’re merely for individuals who fall into some type of common class of common suspicion or who’ve merely practiced their very own faith,” Zenz stated.
Advertisement
Uyghur activists who shared the doc have declined to disclose their supply, resulting from fears of retaliation.
Since receiving the knowledge, educational Adrian Zenz and his workforce have authenticated the identities of 337 out of the greater than 2,800 particular person folks named within the data.
By way of interviews with Uyghurs outdoors China, CNN was capable of confirm the instances of eight kin, mates or acquaintances recognized within the doc.
The doc additionally rings true with the continued efforts of the Chinese language authorities to deliver the culturally disparate Xinjiang consistent with state-approved mainstream cultural norms. The regular development of Han Chinese language within the province is a direct results of a coverage push by Beijing to encourage migration to the Muslim-majority area.
Because the authorities launched its “Strike Arduous Marketing campaign Towards Extremism” marketing campaign in 2014, the native administration’s stance in direction of Uyghurs has hardened. The detention facilities have been constructed, Uyghur mosques and graveyards have vanished beneath bulldozers and even loyal Communist Celebration cadres have been imprisoned apparently resulting from their Uyghur sympathies.
Advertisement
In accordance with Zenz, this newly leaked doc seems to be partially primarily based on data gathered by Chinese language authorities staff who’ve been despatched to reside with and monitor Uyghur households in recent times. “This information is being collected by authorities staff who go to minorities, who reside with households, who sleep (of their homes), who spend time with them, who discover out each intimate and personal element … After which they enter all of this data right into a digital database by means of a wise cellphone app,” he stated.
Different probably sources of data are the neighborhood committees and cooperative relations who’re commonly talked about within the doc.
No launch dates are recorded for any of the detainees, even those that have had their return to the group permitted. In some instances, the detainee is beneficial to be launched from the camp however to proceed working within the “industrial park,” doubtlessly corroborating allegations that Uyghurs are made to carry out compelled labor.
If the doc is extrapolated for the remainder of Xinjiang, house to 11 million Uyghurs, there may very well be tons of of hundreds extra surveillance data like these.
The member of the family: ‘She isn’t any actual risk’
Advertisement
For some Uyghur expatriates, residing abroad with no phrase from their households for months or years, this doc gives the primary official affirmation of the destiny of their family members. For Rozinsa Mamattohti, it was a devastating coda to years of uncertainty and concern.
She moved to Turkey to review as a youngster in 2002, after dropping out of college at an early age to be a seamstress. Regardless of the gap between Xinjiang and Turkey, there are various connections between the 2. Uyghurs are thought of ethnically Turkic, and communicate a language carefully associated to Turkish. Activists pushing for Xinjiang to change into a separate nation name it “East Turkestan.”
Inside three years Mamattohti had married an area man they usually quickly began their very own household.
At first, she commonly stored in contact together with her household again in Xinjiang over the cellphone and later by means of e-mail and video calls.
She thought she’d have a few years to introduce her household again in Xinjiang to her kids. However then issues started to vary at house.
Advertisement
Rozinsa’s household tree
In April 2016, whereas Mamattohti’s dad and mom have been visiting her in Turkey, the information got here that her older sister Rozniyaz Mamattohti had been arrested by the Chinese language authorities.
Advertisement
Her dad and mom returned to Xinjiang to seek out out what had occurred, however quickly cellphone calls from Rozinsa started to ring out. Commonly used household cellphone numbers have been disconnected, with out clarification.
“I haven’t been capable of contact my household since June 2016,” she stated.
In January 2020, she noticed Uyghur translations of the leaked doc distributed on social media by exiled activists and her worst fears appeared to be confirmed.
“First, I noticed the doc with my older sister’s title on it. It was heartbreaking.”Rozinsa Mamattohti
A second undated case research reveals Mamattohti’s older sister Rozniyaz was despatched to a unique detention middle from their youthful sibling, Patem. She was detained for 2 purported violations: Having too many kids and holding an unused passport, which isn’t an official crime beneath Chinese language regulation.
Advertisement
In accordance with the analysis of each sisters, their household had been “cooperative” with the village committee. Regardless of having been despatched to the camp in March 2018, the undated analysis of the nameless assessor is that youthful sister Patem didn’t pose any hazard. “She isn’t any actual risk. It is suggested to finish her coaching.”
However the doc doesn’t say if Patem was free of the camps or how lengthy she spent inside.
Rozniyaz had already been launched, in response to her evaluation, though there isn’t a report of the size of her detention. She is recorded as coming to the group chief to “signal attendance each morning” and the neighborhood committee “each night time after work.”
“It is suggested she proceed her supervised life within the neighborhood.” Rozniyaz’s evaluation doc
Like Mamattohti, many different Uyghurs have moved to Turkey over time for work or to flee the political tensions again house.
Advertisement
Ipargul Karakas has misplaced contact together with her household in Xinjiang. In an interview at her house in Turkey, she informed CNN her brother and sister have been in jail, and through her final cellphone name together with her mom, the older girl claimed to not know who she was.
Karakas stated it was a shock when she acquired a translation of the leaked doc over social media and shortly acknowledged the title of her cousin, Mahire Mahmut.
In accordance with the doc, Mahmut was put in a detention middle as a result of her dad and mom and two elder siblings took a visit to Turkey in 2016, which the Chinese language authorities claimed was “unlawful.”
On their technique to Mecca in Saudi Arabia to participate within the Hajj, they’d stopped off in Turkey to go to Ipargul and her husband Hafiz.
“They got here right here legally. After they arrived right here, we noticed their passports, they needed to go to Hajj. We noticed their passports,” Ipragul’s husband Hafiz informed CNN in Istanbul.
Advertisement
There isn’t any phrase on whether or not Mahmut was launched or how lengthy she spent within the facility, though the report does suggest her launch. When it was written, she had three kids under the age of 14. It’s not clear what grew to become of them.
“After we take into consideration the troublesome and harsh circumstances (our household) is perhaps in again in Xinjiang … we simply sit and cry helplessly,” Hafiz stated.
The leakers: ‘Nothing is free’
Uyghur hip-hop artist Tahirjan Anwar was celebrating his thirty second birthday within the Netherlands when, with out warning, he acquired greater than 100 pages of categorised Chinese language data.
On the time, he had no concept what to do with the knowledge. However he knew that it was a “priceless reward.”
Advertisement
“As a result of that is essential proof. Details about ethnic cleaning in direction of Uyghurs by the Chinese language authorities,” he informed CNN, talking publicly for the primary time about his function within the leak of the doc.
Anwar has been residing within the Netherlands since his father despatched him away from Xinjiang in 2005. He was simply 17 when he left, however in response to Anwar his father may “really feel one thing was going to occur.”
He hasn’t seen his dad and mom in individual since, and the final time they spoke was by phone in 2016. He stated they requested how he was, informed him they cherished him after which stated: “Now, you aren’t my son.”
“The Chinese language authorities made my father say that to me,” he stated.
Anwar gained’t reveal the supply of this new doc, solely saying that they have been taken out of China and handed to exiled Uyghur activists. He stated if his supply’s id is made public “that individual will die.”
Advertisement
Anwar handed on the leaked materials to a different Uyghur exile within the Netherlands, author Asiye Abdulahad, within the hope she’d know the way to unfold the phrase. Between them, Anwar and Abdulahad have been chargeable for disseminating two of the Chinese language authorities’s most embarrassing inside leaks in a long time. They are saying neither of them was concerned in an earlier leak of inside Chinese language authorities paperwork to the New York Occasions.
Quietly-spoken author Abdulahad isn’t a member of any formal Uyghur group, however when the doc appeared in her inbox, she knew she needed to act.
“This doc is necessary proof that may show the unjustifiable and unlawful measures the Chinese language authorities has taken to arrest these folks and ship them to re-education facilities and prisons.”Asiye Abdulahad
The primary set of paperwork the pair distributed to the media was the leak revealed by the Worldwide Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ), which seems to be the working handbook for the Chinese language authorities’s Xinjiang detention facilities.
The paperwork, principally from 2017 and revealed in November 2019, reveal plans to assemble numerous closely secured amenities by which detainees are forcibly taught within the Chinese language language, correct “manners,” and “ideological schooling.”
Advertisement
“(Beijing) by no means actually denied that these weren’t Chinese language authorities paperwork, by no means stated something in regards to the categorised paperwork’ authenticity,” she stated.
Abdulahad stated that she believes the Chinese language authorities is aiming to hold out a “political cleaning” of Xinjiang by means of its detention middle program, to vary the character of the Uyghur folks within the area. She stated the technique was unlikely to succeed, including it has been tried earlier than by “many empires on this planet.”
“(Empires) all finish finally. It’s not possible for them to final,” she stated.
Anwar bluntly describes the actions of the Chinese language authorities as “ethnic cleaning.”
“We aren’t terrorists … We’re simply people. We’re simply Uyghurs. We’re similar to you.”Tahirjan Anwar
Advertisement
He stated that it wasn’t a troublesome resolution to disclose his function in leaking the doc, as he’s certain his household are already in jail. Privately, a part of him even hopes that his relations shall be paraded out by Chinese language state media to denounce him publicly.
“I shall be pleased (if that occurs) as a result of to start with, I can see that they’re alive,” he stated.
Abdulahad stated folks have to look past their very own household’s security and communicate out for change. “Nothing is free. You need to pay some worth so as to pursue the stuff you need,” she stated.
‘What’s their crime?’
Not one of the women and men behind the newly leaked doc believes it’s prone to result in a right away change of coverage by the Chinese language authorities.
Advertisement
Earlier releases of delicate paperwork have been stone-walled by Beijing officers, who claimed that they have been maliciously misinterpreted.
However previously six months, the Chinese language authorities has been working exhausting to attempt to defuse rising world concern about its detention system in Xinjiang.
Delegations of overseas diplomats and chosen media have been given excursions of the fortified amenities. Authorities officers have claimed, with out offering proof, that the camps are more and more empty.
“Individuals arrive and depart continuously,” stated Shohrat Zakir, chairman of the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Area in July. “Most have already gone again to society.”
In any case, the leaked doc exhibits that the Chinese language authorities is aware of intimately what its Xinjiang residents are doing, home by home, avenue by avenue. If the 11 million Uyghurs residing in Xinjiang ought to fall foul of Beijing once more, the Chinese language authorities is aware of the place to seek out them.
Advertisement
Uyghur exile Rozinsa Mamattohti stated she desires the entire world to know what the Chinese language authorities is doing to her folks.
“To the Chinese language I need to say — why? What’s the motive you have got arrested my growing older, sick dad and mom? What are you doing to them? What’s your function? And my harmless sisters, what’s their crime?” she stated.
Do you have got a tip or delicate materials to share with CNN?We provide a number of methods to succeed in our journalists securely.
Your guide to what the 2024 US election means for Washington and the world
We all know the slogan. But Donald Trump will not make America great again by waging war on his domestic enemies. Instead Trump’s vengeance campaign threatens the real foundations of American greatness.
The American military, the country’s leading universities, the Federal Reserve, the justice system, the free press, the scientific establishment, even the health of American citizens are all at risk. The president-elect has nominated vengeful crackpots to key positions and promised to let people like Robert F Kennedy Jr “go wild”.
The damage that Trump’s policies could inflict on America will delight the country’s real enemies in Moscow and Beijing. They know from their own histories that when a nation turns on itself, its international power can collapse.
Advertisement
Trump’s Maga shock troops believe that they can only make their country great again by first destroying their internal enemies. Trump has said the “enemy from within” is “more dangerous” than Russia and China. His appointees are willing to turn America’s institutions upside down in the pursuit of vengeance.
Pete Hegseth, Trump’s nominee as defence secretary, has written that “sometimes the fight must begin with a struggle against domestic enemies”. In a podcast, he demanded: “Any general, any admiral . . . that was involved in diversity, equity and inclusion programmes or woke shit has got to go.”
Reports are already circulating that Trump plans to establish a “warrior board” empowered to force out senior military officers, replacing them with loyalists. His team are also reportedly considering court-martialling some military leaders for their roles in the chaotic US withdrawal from Afghanistan.
In his first term, Trump was enraged when “his” generals insisted that their loyalty was to the constitution, not to him personally. Senior officers resisted Trump’s demands for the deployment of troops on American streets in the Black Lives Matter protests.
This time Trump will want absolute obedience from his newly promoted corporals and colonels, particularly if he intends to deploy the military to carry out the mass deportation of illegal immigrants. But purging your most senior generals can leave a country vulnerable and its military confused.
Advertisement
America’s intelligence services are also at risk. Trump’s nominee for the job of director of national intelligence, Tulsi Gabbard, is noted for her sympathy for Syria’s Bashar al-Assad and Vladimir Putin in Russia. She has consistently echoed Russian propaganda, suggesting that Nato expansion was responsible for Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and that the US was running secret bio-labs inside Ukraine. Her appointment will cause consternation among American allies, Britain foremost among them, which routinely share intelligence with the US.
American science and medicine lead the world. But Trump proposes to put a conspiracy theorist in charge of the health and human services department. Even the Trump-supporting New York Post concluded, after meeting Robert F Kennedy Jr, that he was “nuts on a lot of fronts”. If RFK imposes his vaccine hostility on the US as a whole, he will sow the seeds of future epidemics.
Seven of the world’s top 10 universities are in the US. But America’s institutes of learning are also on Trump’s enemies list. His allies claim that the universities are bastions of “wokeness” and antisemitism. Bill Ackman, a Trump-supporting financier, recently opined that Yale was “no different than Hamas”. The attack on wokeness can be used as a battering ram to try to cow the universities into submission on a wider range of issues. Over time, America could see a threat to the intellectual liberty on which great universities depend.
Press freedom, something that truly distinguishes America from its autocratic rivals, is also menaced. Trump has filed a series of lawsuits against media outlets that have displeased him — a favourite tactic of authoritarian regimes.
Trump regards independent institutions of any sort as a threat. There is widespread speculation that his administration will attempt to sack Jay Powell, head of the Federal Reserve. Powell has reminded journalists that Trump is “not permitted under law” to force him out.
Advertisement
But Trump has his own ideas about the rule of law. Matt Gaetz, his nominee for attorney-general, was under investigation by his Republican colleagues for alleged ethics violations that include having sex with a minor. Gaetz, who has denied the allegations, claims to believe that he, like Trump is the victim of a politicised justice system. Other close confidants of Trump, like Steve Bannon and Peter Navarro, have recently emerged from prison.
These are angry men, who may be intent on revenge. They could use the justice system to go after their enemies. That will be bad news not just for the individuals who get caught up in the witch hunt, but for the whole country.
American greatness is founded on the rule of law. That is a fundamental reason why foreigners trust American assets and the dollar as the world’s reserve currency. If Trump uses the justice system to go after his enemies — and to reward his billionaire cronies — then investors could rightly take fright.
Rather than making America great again, Trump’s assault on US institutions will make America more like Russia and China. Putin and Xi Jinping will benefit. Americans and America’s allies will suffer the consequences.
The North Fork Community Choir practices at the North Fork Baptist Church in Paonia, Colo., on Nov. 6 — the day after Election Day.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Advertisement
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Over the last few years and through this year’s contentious campaign season, which was rooted in America’s deep divisions, there has been a coarsening in the way people talk to each other. We wanted to explore how some are trying to bridge divides. We asked our reporters across the NPR Network to look for examples of people working through their differences. We’re sharing those stories in our series Seeking Common Ground.
PAONIA, Colo. — On a Wednesday night at a spacious, contemporary-looking church on the edge of Paonia, a small town in western Colorado, the 40 or so members of the North Fork Community Choir ran through their regular warmups.
“Really pay attention to that ‘E’ vowel,” said music director Stephanie Helleckson, as she guided the singers through various scales and arpeggios from behind a music stand. “See if you can make that a little bit rounder as a group.”
Advertisement
Helleckson listened carefully to how the singers’ voices blend; the details matter in an art form that’s all about achieving harmony.
Helleckson, who comes from a musical family and has spent most of her life in Paonia, said harmony is important — not just musically, but also socially.
“Because we’re all coming from different backgrounds and different perspectives, and we’re coming together to do something together, we have to learn how to not agree with somebody, but still work with them,” said the vivacious and businesslike music director.
A view of Paonia, Colo., and the surrounding West Elk Mountains.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
Advertisement
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
The North Fork Community Choir is based in a part of the country where the politics are all over the map.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
hide caption
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
Paonia has farming and ranching families, artists, winemakers, remote workers — and a mix of political views, one choir member says.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
The North Fork is an ideologically diverse community
Cooperation is not a given, since the North Fork Community Choir is based in a part of the country where the politics are all over the map. The singers have had to come up with creative ways to continue to sing in harmony.
“We’ve got people from pretty far right to pretty far left in the chorus,” said choir member Jan Tuin.
Tuin has been living in the area since 1964. He said his dad, an auto body repairman, moved the family from near Denver in search of a slower pace of life. Over coffee at Paonia Books, a hip, newish bookstore and cafe in downtown Paonia, Tuin said the mining, farming and ranching families who’ve been around for generations have in recent decades been joined by an influx of artists, winemakers and remote workers in fields like tech.
Choir member Jan Tuin, who helped found the first community singing group in the area, at his home in Hotchkiss, Colo.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
hide caption
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
“And so the people here now are much more diverse, I would say,” Tuin said.
Nearly everyone in the choir is white, reflecting the area’s racial demographics. But the members range in age from 11 to 87. Some of the singers believe in God; others do not. Some own guns; others do not. When the choir required masks and/or vaccines for rehearsals at various points during the COVID-19 pandemic in accordance with federal recommendations, some were happy to comply. But at least one member quit.
Tuin said people avoid bringing up potentially controversial topics during rehearsal. “We talk about our gardens a lot,” he said, laughing.
No matter their politics and values, all of the 20 or so singers NPR spoke with for this story said they focus on music-making as a uniting force and as a way to at least temporarily forget differences. This includes choir members Mary Bachran, the recently retired mayor of blue-leaning Paonia (“We make harmonies together. It’s just so wonderful.”) andChris Johnson, the recently appointed mayor of red-leaning Crawford, a nearby ranching community. (“We’re just all there to sing.”)
Advertisement
Mary Bachran, community choir member and former mayor, in downtown Paonia, Colo.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
Everything’s not good in “America”
Yet the music itself sometimes draws the differences out.
The choir’s Broadway program back in the spring is a case in point. It involved medleys from well-known musicals such as My Fair Lady, Rent, Pippin, Dear Evan Hansen — and West Side Story.
The song “America” from the latter, which premiered in 1957, might be one of the most famous in the American musical canon. But some of the lyrics describing Puerto Rico as an “ugly island” rife with disease and poverty did not sit well with singers like Ellie Roberts.
“I really struggled with that because it sort of implies that Puerto Rico stinks and why wouldn’t they leave?” Roberts said. “And it just sort of encouraged some of those stereotypes.”
Advertisement
Roberts, a local schoolteacher, said the chorus discussed the issue at rehearsal. “What are we celebrating and what do we not want to celebrate?” she said.
They thought about changing the lyrics, but ended up doing the song with a disclaimer that music director Helleckson made from the stage.
“You have to think about context for this piece,” Helleckson said in a video of the performance captured in May. “This piece has some things that are maybe not as acceptable in today’s day and age as they were when it first came out.”
The North Fork Community Choir practices at the North Fork Baptist Church in Paonia, Colo.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
Advertisement
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Music director Stephanie Helleckson, who has spent most of her life in Paonia, leads community choir practice at the church.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
hide caption
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
During community choir practice at the North Fork Baptist Church in Paonia.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Advertisement
“Master of the House” an issue too
Meanwhile, other members of the ensemble brought up a different concern to do with the raucous showstopper from Les Misérables, “Master of the House.”
In the song, a seedy innkeeper and his entourage of petty criminals invoke Jesus as they fleece their customers.
“It bothered me, because I did not want to use the Lord’s name that way,” saidsinger Kim Johnson, a Christian counselor. Johnson said she and some others from the group discussed the matter with Helleckson and came up with alternatives to singing “Jesus.”
“I sang ‘cheeses’ instead of ‘Jesus,’” said Johnson. “It worked.”
Advertisement
Pushing boundaries to launch conversations
Helleckson said she knew the Broadway program would be a little bit provocative.
“It’s pushing boundaries that some people are not comfortable with in our little rural pocket of America,” Helleckson said. “And so part of programming some of this music is to actually have those conversations. So we don’t just assume that everybody’s the same as us and everybody believes the same things and acts the same way.”
According to a Chorus America report assessing the impact of group singing, choir members are more adaptable and tolerant of others than the general population. “Almost two-thirds of singers (63%) believe participating in a chorus has made them more open to and accepting of people who are different from them or hold different views,” the study noted.
New York University sociology professor Eric Klinenberg said the mere act of coming together to undertake a regular, shared activity with others, such as choral singing, can promote bridge-building. But it’s possible for such groups to go further.
“If your objective is to just get a group of people together to sing well, forget about everything else in the world, maybe you don’t need to encourage those other conversations about politics,” said Klinenberg, who studies how people gather and connect both within and across ideological lines.
Advertisement
But, he said, if the objective is also to create a more decent society and bridge differences by using the relationships that you build while making music together as a foundation of trust to advance a conversation about something like politics, “that could be an amazing thing.”
Choir member Chris Johnson, the recently appointed mayor of Crawford, Colo., says: “We’re just all there to sing.”
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Advertisement
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Choir members hug at practice the day after Election Day.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
Advertisement
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
Small steps toward greater understanding
In a small way, the issues that arose with the Broadway concert point toward this aspiration. Choir member Chris Johnson, for example, said he didn’t have a problem with West Side Story. But he doesn’t fault those who pushed for the disclaimer.
“I don’t think that explanation was necessary, but it’s OK,” he said.
Advertisement
And singer Linda Talbott said her mind has been expanded as a result of the faith-based objections other singers in the group had to Les Mis.
“I think I’m much more aware now of what could be objectionable to certain people,” she said. “I don’t think I thought about it. There it was in front of me, I wanted to sing it, and I did.”
Helleckson said she would like to continue to program more material that inspires these types of conversations.
The North Fork Community Choir has been prepping for upcoming holiday performances.
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
hide caption
Advertisement
toggle caption
Luna Anna Archey for NPR
In the meantime, the ensemble is prepping for a pair of holiday performances of Handel’s Messiah. The singers said the music is challenging. But so far it’s not been too controversial.
Your guide to what the 2024 US election means for Washington and the world
Donald Trump has expanded his search for a Treasury secretary to serve in his second-term cabinet, throwing the contest for top economic official into confusion as he struggles to settle on a choice.
The Republican president-elect had been weighing whether to offer the job to Scott Bessent, a hedge fund manager, or Howard Lutnick, the co-chair of his transition effort and chief executive of Cantor Fitzgerald, the financial firm. But at the weekend, Trump moved to widen the net of possible alternatives.
People close to the process say Kevin Warsh, a former Federal Reserve Governor, Marc Rowan, the chief executive of Apollo Global Management, and Bill Hagerty, the Tennessee senator, are now also in the running, along with Robert Lighthizer, the former US trade representative under Trump.
Advertisement
Trump has announced a string of potential appointments over the past week in the areas of national security, justice, health and energy but has held back on making any decisions on the top economic positions so far.
Trump’s advisers are seeking assurances from the top candidates to be Treasury secretary that they are committed to his sweeping plans to raise tariffs, people close to the discussions said.
Elon Musk, the billionaire investor who has emerged as one of Trump’s top allies, weighed in over the weekend in favour of Lutnick over Bessent. Musk, who sat next to Trump at a UFC championship fight in New York on Saturday night, wrote on X that “Bessent is a business-as-usual choice, whereas @howardlutnick will actually enact change”.
Since Trump was elected, Bessent has been on the defensive about his commitment to enacting the president’s economic vision. In an opinion piece for Fox News last week, he described tariffs are “a means to finally stand up for Americans”.
But his critics have seized on comments to the Financial Times — that the agenda represented ‘maximalist’ positions that were negotiating tools — as a sign he would be soft on the issue.
Advertisement
Trump’s aides are reluctant to repeat the tensions over trade in his first administration, in which Steven Mnuchin, then Treasury secretary, frequently sought to moderate the tariff plans for fear of disrupting markets.
Several people familiar with the discussions inside Trump’s team said Lighthizer, who served as US trade representative in the first administration, had previously expressed interest in becoming Treasury secretary.
On Sunday, the Coalition for a Prosperous America, a pro-tariff think-tank, backed Lighthizer publicly for Treasury secretary.
“The next Treasury secretary must be 100 per cent aligned with President-elect Trump’s policy on tariffs,” it said in a post on X. “Former USTR Robert Lighthizer is a steadfast champion for the US economy and the best choice to carry out President Trump’s trade agenda,” it added.
Tariffs have long been central to Trump’s plans to boost US manufacturing, create jobs and lower prices.
Advertisement
He has described it as the “most beautiful word in the dictionary” and the “greatest thing ever invented”. He has also billed such levies as an effective way to cover the costs of other pillars of his economic agenda, including large tax cuts for Americans.
In addition to 60 per cent tariffs on all Chinese imports, Trump has floated a universal tariff of up to 20 per cent on all goods coming into the US.
Whoever Trump selects as his Treasury secretary will be instrumental — along with the top US trade official — in both putting these policies into action as well as managing the economic ramifications.
Reporting by James Politi, Colby Smith, Demetri Sevastopulo and Stefania Palma in Washington and Antoine Gara and James Fontanella-Khan in New York