Ohio
Ohio’s anti-discrimination agency faces allegations of discrimination and workplace issues
The Ohio Civil Rights Commission is supposed to investigate discrimination claims. Now it’s being hit with those complaints from within
The Ohio Civil Rights Commission, which is supposed to protect people from illegal discrimination, is facing complaints from within about retaliation, bullying and discrimination by the director.
Nearly every top executive staff member has left or been fired since Angela Phelps-White took over as agency director in March 2020. The sole holdover filed a complaint against her, saying she retaliated against him for speaking up about poor management.
A state investigation found the retaliation complaint unsubstantiated but noted the agency “is not functioning at maximum capacity.”
In addition to that complaint, four current or former agency employees have filed lawsuits over workplace conditions.
“For more than two years, I have been subjected to and work in an environment where there is bullying, harassment, disrespect and secrecy,” said Darlene Sweeney-Newbern in her 2023 resignation letter.
Sweeney-Newbern, who served as director of regional operations, filed a federal lawsuit against the commission, alleging that she was frozen out of key meetings and information and given extra work such as untangling overpaid overtime issues that led to budget problems. She believes the treatment came in retaliation for participating in an Equal Employment Opportunity investigation.
In January, Civil Rights Investigator Eddie Marcus filed a complaint in the Ohio Court of Claims accusing the commission of not paying him and his co-workers overtime that they’ve been pressured to work.
Marcus is seeking to make it a class action lawsuit.
Earlier this year, the commission paid $650,000 to settle two other lawsuits filed by two former commission employees who accused Phelps-White of job discrimination.
Phelps-White answered written questions and Valerie Lemmie, chair of the commission, spoke for the agency. Lemmie described the executive staff turnover as a byproduct of a leadership change.
“I would say that the ability of the commission to do its job has not been compromised,” Lemmie said. “I have confidence that Angela will be able to do the work that is required. She has the support of the board, and she has the support of our staff.”
New leadership at Ohio Civil Rights Commission
G. Michael Payton retired as commission executive director after nearly two decades at the helm. The commission hired Phelps-White to replace him in 2020.
In short order, some employees complained that her style was inappropriate, demeaning and toxic.
In 2022, the commission chairwoman at the time, Lori Barreras, started an internal investigation.
Employees told Barreras about low morale, lack of communication, unreasonable workloads, personnel clashes and a lack of confidence in Phelps-White. They said the director made inappropriate remarks about LGBTQ+ people and dressed down employees in front of others.
“It is terrible working for Angela,” one worker told Barreras.
After interviewing the former human resources manager, Barreras noted: “He believes Angela is the worst nightmare for the commission.”
Following Barreras’ investigation, the commission hired attorney Christina Corl to conduct another internal investigation. In a January 2023 report, Corl described how employees alleged that Phelps-White yells profanity, retaliates against employees who challenge her and operates the agency with paranoia.
Corl found some of the claims against Phelps-White to be substantiated and that employees reported being overwhelmed by unreasonable workloads.
In Corl’s report, Phelps-White described how she has been trying to be a change agent to improve operations, modernize the commission and push employees to be accountable for their job performance.
Phelps-White’s personnel file lacks any disciplinary records or written performance reviews.
Skyrocketing claims, bigger workloads
The number of employment discrimination claims being investigated by the commission is skyrocketing − thanks to a sweeping change in state law made five years ago.
Legislators and Gov. Mike DeWine agreed to cut the time employees have to bring a claim from six years to two years and require that all claims start at the civil rights commission. The Employment Law Uniformity Act took effect in April 2021.
The number of claims sent to the commission increased by more than 140%, from 3,220 in 2020 to 7,779 in 2024.
Marcus said in his lawsuit that he faced a “drastic increase” in workload after the law changed.
Vince Curry, a housing discrimination investigator based in Akron, said the dysfunction and the higher caseload mean investigations take longer.
“I think it’s all interconnected. The dysfunction at the commission impacts our clients,” said Curry, of Fair Housing Advocates Association.
Lemmie disagreed, saying 90% of the commission jobs are filled, and a new $1.5 million case management system has helped with the workload. The administration added employee training and overtime as well, she said.
“We are doing our best to work with Angela and her team,” Lemmie said.
What is the Ohio Civil Rights Commission?
The state has a long history of prohibiting discrimination, starting in 1884 with the Ohio Public Accommodations Law that outlawed racial discrimination in public facilities.
The laws were expanded again in 1959, 1965 and 1976 to protect discrimination based on race, color, sex, disability, age, religion, national origin, ancestry, military status and family status in housing and credit in marital status. State law does not prohibit discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity.
Of the discrimination complaints handled by the Ohio Civil Rights Commission, about 25% relate to disability, 25% to race and 12% to age.
Laura Bischoff is a reporter for the USA TODAY Network Ohio Bureau, which serves the Columbus Dispatch, Cincinnati Enquirer, Akron Beacon Journal and 18 other affiliated news organizations across Ohio.
Ohio
Why MS NOW rates Ohio’s Senate race a Toss Up
Ohio is shaping up to be a top battleground state this year, and MS NOW’s election team now characterizes its Senate race as a Toss Up.
We are updating the race based primarily on multiple high-quality polls showing a very tight contest, as well as the candidates running and the broader political environment.
The contest is technically a special election to fill out the remainder of Vice President JD Vance’s term. Republican Jon Husted, who was appointed to the seat after Vance took office in 2025, is running to defend it for the first time.
The candidates and structural forces
While Ohio is still often thought of as a bellwether state, it has voted reliably Republican in recent presidential elections. The state has shifted to the right during President Donald Trump’s political rise, backing him in all three of his presidential campaigns.
Ohio’s last few Senate races, however, have been more competitive. Vance won by six points in 2022, while Republican Bernie Moreno beat Democrat Sherrod Brown by less than four points in 2024, narrowly ousting Brown from office after he served three terms in the Senate.
Brown’s showing two years ago is more impressive than it might seem at first blush. A relatively well-liked senator with working-class appeal, he was likely dragged down by his party’s brand. He came close to hanging onto his seat in an unfavorable environment for Democrats. That four-point loss meant he ran ahead of Kamala Harris, who lost to Trump by 11 points.
And 2026 looks to be a much better environment for Democrats.
Trump’s approval rating and the GOP’s favorability ratings are underwater amid an unpopular war and widespread economic dissatisfaction. Brown is running again, and polls indicate he has a real shot at flipping the seat.
The polls
No single poll should be viewed as definitive, but a clear pattern has emerged in recent weeks. A Fox News poll made waves four weeks ago, showing Brown with a lead outside the poll’s margin of sampling error. Since then, two more high-quality polls have shown a very competitive race: one commissioned by AARP and fielded by a bipartisan team of pollsters, and the other released this week by the New York Times and Siena College. Both show a three-point race, which is well within the margin of error, and they differ on which candidate is ahead. This is what polling in a true toss-up race looks like.
Ohio
Children found in ‘deplorable’ Ohio home were part of same family
HAMDEN, Ohio (AP) — The 16 children found living in “deplorable” conditions inside a small, dilapidated rural Ohio home are part of the same family, officials said Wednesday.
Authorities arrested four adults Tuesday on felony child endangerment charges after finding the children in the home. Some were in dire need of medical treatment, authorities said.
Vinton County prosecuting attorney William Archer said the four adults were charged with second-degree felony child endangering because it involves “serious physical harm.”
Gary Siders Jr., Gary Siders Sr., Christina Siders and Elizabeth Siders appeared in court Wednesday where a judge entered not guilty pleas on their behalf.. They have not yet been assigned lawyers.
Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson said Wednesday that the conditions inside the house in the tiny village of Hamden were almost indescribable, saying it “really looked third world.”
“It’s just almost beyond comprehension,” he said without providing details about what was inside.
It appeared that the children spent most of their time in just one room for much of the four years they lived there, Wilson said.
The house sits on a road tucked away alongside a steep railroad embankment, where tracks carry rumbling trains through Hamden. On Wednesday, its doors and windows stood open to the 94-degree Fahrenheit (34-degree Celsius) heat. A tangle of discarded children’s items — two busted bicycles, a plastic play table, a beach pail and two infant carriers — stood in a pile in the yard.
The Ohio Bureau of Investigation and local sheriff’s department searched the home on Tuesday.
The children ranged in age from 1 1/2 years to 18 years old and included both boys and girls, officials said. Seven were transported to hospitals in Columbus and two were flown by helicopters.
Hamden has a population of less than 1,000 people and is about 60 miles (97 kilometers) southeast of Columbus.
___
Seewer reported from Toledo, Ohio.
Ohio
‘Pure evil’: Adults arrested after 16 children found in deplorable conditions in Ohio home
Authorities arrested four adults on felony child endangerment charges after discovering 16 children in dire need of medical treatment Tuesday in a rural southern Ohio home.
The Ohio Bureau of Investigation and local sheriff’s department searched a home in the small village of Hamden, where they found the kids in what officials called “deplorable” conditions.”
“Conditions you cannot even imagine people being in, let alone children being in,” Ohio Attorney General Andy Wilson said at a news conference.
Law enforcement arrested Gary Siders Jr., Gary Siders Sr., Christina Siders and Elizabeth Siders. They have not yet been arraigned and assigned public defenders.
Vinton County prosecuting attorney William Archer said they were being charged with second-degree felony child endangering because it involves “serious physical harm.”
Officials did not confirm if the children were related but said it was not a human trafficking situation. They said the adults were not locals and appeared to have been traveling.
Hamden has a population of less than 1,000 people and is about 60 miles southeast of Columbus.
The children ranged from ages 1.5 to 18 and included both boys and girls, officials said. Several were in serious conditions when found, and two had to be flown to level one trauma centers because of their injuries.
Wilson said it was the worst scene he had ever encountered in his entire career, describing what he saw as “pure evil.”
Law enforcement were also executing a secondary search warrant at the home Tuesday, and the investigation is ongoing. The four adults will appear in court Wednesday morning.
“Justice will be served for these children,” Wilson said.
-
Politics4 minutes agoThe Many Ways Trump Is Trying to Tip the Scales for the Midterms
-
Lifestyle34 minutes agoMap: See Taylor Swift’s NYC Hotspots Ahead of Her MSG Wedding
-
Education39 minutes agoOpinion | 13 George Washington Interpreters on Embodying an Icon
-
Technology46 minutes agoMystery box shows are complicated for everyone — even the actors
-
World49 minutes agoAfter 1,000 days of war: Many Israeli children carry trauma into summer break
-
Politics1 hour agoTrump admin axes ‘Green New Scam’ appliance rules as Europe bakes in brutal heat
-
Health1 hour ago5 of America’s greatest medical breakthroughs revealed as the nation marks 250 years
-
Sports1 hour agoUSA World Cup star calls lack of appeal process for teammate’s red card ‘bogus’