Connect with us

Ohio

Mailbox: Did soft schedule lead to Ohio State football ‘hype train’ being derailed?

Published

on

Mailbox: Did soft schedule lead to Ohio State football ‘hype train’ being derailed?


Have more comments, questions? Reach out to me at bwhite1@dispatch.com. Letters are lightly edited for clarity.

On Ohio State football

To Brian: I watched with jaundiced side eye at all the preseason hype of superstar transfers, returning talent and a new offensive coordinator combining to make the Buckeyes a national championship juggernaut. Even Ohio State’s detractors said this was the best team money could buy. All these prognosticators ignored Ryan Day and his choke factor in big games. Now that it’s apparent the hype train was derailed in Eugene, it may be time to reevaluate the head coach position if they gag in the playoffs.

Advertisement

Jeff Petsche, Delray Beach, Fla.

Dear Editor: With the Buckeyes’ loss to Oregon, it makes one wonder about their scheduling of opponents early in the season. Do the Buckeyes really benefit from beating the “Little Sisters of the Poor” teams 62-0 and then pound their chest and claim they are such a great team? I don’t think so. After those lopsided early-season blowout wins they then meet a “real” opponent and find it very difficult to handle the situation of a real competitive game. Maybe the Buckeyes should schedule some actual games where the outcome is not so assured early in the season to better prepare them for the more competitive teams that will surely follow. Chance favors those better prepared.

Chet Ridenour Sr., Worthington

To Mr. White: After rewatching the OSU vs. Oregon game, I have a question for Jim Knowles: Why do D-ends contentiously crash down inside and not maintain the edge? That should be their primary goal, pushing everything toward the middle for the D-line and linebackers. In Saturday’s game, one end failed to make a difference and the other did not maintain his assignment which resulted in the game-wining touchdown. Coach Knowles is paid enough to have his defense prepared for any situation and offense.

Fausto J Garofalo Jr, Columbus

Advertisement

To Brian: I’ve always criticized those who criticize amateur athletes, but I guess Ohio State football players aren’t really amateurs anymore. Nonetheless, those critical of Will Howard’s decision-making at the end of the Oregon game and Jeremiah Smith’s questionable penalty just before that overlook that they played well throughout the evening against a very good team in a hostile environment at night three time zones away and still almost overcame the deficiencies of the defense and a kickoff return player who demonstrated how playing back on your heels is less effective than being on your toes. 

Dennis Singleton, Dayton

On baseball catchers

To the editor: Having gone to Williamsport’s Little League World Series a couple of years ago with my adult grandson, we consider it a special place to showcase youth players.I do have a baseball and an umpiring complaint. It was not only “if” but “when” the issue would reach and impact Williamsport.In a recent LL game, the catcher was “framing” pitches to deceive the umpire into thinking it was a strike. Often called an art form, it is praised by MLB commentators. Catchers are often rated by their ability to influence a ball into a strike. Youth catchers and coaches have noticed. It has become blatant, successful and game-changing. You can not watch an MLB game without framing. But LL!Baseball has always included integrity challenges. Sharpened spikes, spitballs, illegal bats, betting and now, framing. What kind of a fair penalty could be administered?Umpires could treat the framed pitch as a walk unless the batter advances otherwise. After all, by framing the pitch back into the strike zone, what has the catcher admitted?Hitting a baseball is one of the most difficult skills in sports. Failing seven in 10 at-bats could make a Hall of Famer.Jim N. Reed, Lancaster

Advertisement

To Jim: Subtle framing, without moving the receiving arm, is indeed an art. But the exaggerated movement of the glove or hand should not throw off a good umpire, who can judge a pitch by where it hits the glove. That good umpire will ignore such catchers and they will stop the silliness.

On newspapers, deadlines and online coverage

To Brian: I’m just sitting here (about 2 p.m. Saturday) and thinking how this modern world can do so many things faster, smarter, and with more precision than in the past. I recall what the current media misses. Like, Woody had a TV show after the Saturday game, 10, 10:30 or 11 p.m. That included some of the outstanding players of the game.

Yes, the very next day the paper came out on Sunday morning with super stories from the game day. This week, we might (get a paper on Tuesday with a) little about the game. If they lose or win by a very small margin, the sports department will certainly tell how bad they are. That’s what they do all week. It sounds like the “USA Today” sports section doesn’t like to do anything positive for the team.

I also recall going to the games and getting an early Saturday paper, which told how great the team was. When do I see that now? I haven’t. The media help the Ohio State Buckeyes rise and fall. 

Advertisement

This is just history to all, but true. This might be how The Dispatch falls, too.

Bill

To Bill: Newspapers are different these days, with earlier print deadlines. In our case, that means any Ohio State game that kicks off later than 12:15 p.m. will not make the Sunday print editions. It’s been that way for many years now, with coverage of the games in Monday’s print editions. However, the timeliness of our coverage on Dispatch.com is better than ever, and shortly after the Ohio State-Oregon game ended we had published 14 stories, plus a photo gallery. All week, our website contains several articles that don’t make the print edition. Our Saturday print edition is now an electronic edition, available to all subscribers, but our Friday print editions include a separate game preview section. Lastly, our job as journalists is to report on the team in an unbiased and fair fashion, not to strive to do only positive things for the team. There are plenty of media in Columbus that do that. It’s just not our role.

More from the Mailbox

Is it time to put Pete Rose in the Hall of Fame?

Remembering Cincinnati Reds’ Pete Rose, a great hitter but flawed person

Advertisement

A tribute to overlooked, ‘indispensable’ photographers

Are Ohio State football games getting to be too long?

Reader takeaways on Michigan’s Connor Stalions; and what would Bo think?

Loyal Crew fan won’t stand for Haslams moving game to Cleveland

Reader wants to hear less from Pete Rose; and what’s with recruiting rankings?

Advertisement

Reader’s baseball Hall of Fame story takes a twist, featuring Al Oliver

Columbus Crew’s Aidan Morris misses 2024 Olympics, Ohio state football and more

Pete Rose was a great Ohioan, but what about Mike Schmidt, Cy Young?

Get more Ohio State football news by listening to our podcasts



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Ohio

Ohio State football reset: Key returners, departures after national championship run

Published

on

Ohio State football reset: Key returners, departures after national championship run


One week ago Ohio State was celebrating in Atlanta as national champions. Now it’s turned its focus to attempting a repeat.

Unfortunately for the Buckeyes, winning a national championship in this era means everybody wants a piece of not only the coaching staff, but also the players on the roster.

Ohio State spent the days following the title game trying to keep its roster together and avoid the transfer portal, but also watching its coaching staff field calls. It couldn’t fend off everybody, as the most notable departure was defensive coordinator Jim Knowles leaving for Penn State, to become the highest-paid coordinator in the country.

With the portal window closed, NFL Draft decisions finalized and Knowles on his way to State College, let’s look at how Ohio State is replacing what it lost both on the field and on the staff.

Advertisement

GO DEEPER

Penn State hires Ohio State DC Jim Knowles in same role

Coaching staff

The biggest loss this offseason was Knowles. It’s not just that Knowles left, but the fact he went to Penn State, which will likely be the preseason Big Ten favorite and one of the popular preseason national championship picks. Ohio State will play the Nittany Lions in Columbus on Nov. 1.

Replacing Knowles will be difficult. He’s one of the best defensive coordinators in the country and helped the Buckeyes turn around their defense to finish top-three in total defense the last two seasons. But, coordinators are replaceable, especially at a place like Ohio State where the talent is elite.

Day’s first step is to ensure the rest of the defensive staff stays the same. As of now, it seems like Ohio State is in a good position to do that. Larry Johnson is an Ohio State lifer, James Laurinaitis isn’t going anywhere, nor is cornerbacks coach Tim Walton. The lone worry would’ve been safeties coach Matt Guerrieri, who has been with Knowles from their time together at Duke. He came with him to Ohio State to help install the defense, before leaving for Indiana and coming back this offseason. I don’t think that’s a concern, though, because Day already had high praise for him in the championship celebration, calling him “one of the brightest minds in college football.”

Advertisement

Penn State also won’t have a safeties coach opening. Anthony Poindexter will be the safeties coach at Penn State again, so it seems like Guerrieri will stay on the staff. I wouldn’t be surprised if Day gave him an interview for the defensive coordinator job, considering he has play-calling experience.

A few outside names jumped to my mind from my flu-riddled bed on Sunday afternoon, led by Jeff Hafley. Day and Hafley know each other well, he was Day’s co-defensive coordinator and defensive backs coach in 2019 and though Hafley is the defensive coordinator of the Green Bay Packers, you have to make him say no first.

Pitt’s Randy Bates is an option. Even though his defense struggled this year, he. has had three top-25 defenses at Pitt.

Iowa State’s Jon Heacock is an option too. The younger brother of former Ohio State defensive coordinator Jim Heacock had four top-30 finishes in scoring defense, including two top-20 finishes in 2021 and 2022.

I’d kick the tires on Iowa DC Phil Parker also to see what you can pull off there.

Advertisement

Ohio State is fresh off a national championship, anything less than a national hiring process would be a disservice to the expectations at Ohio State. Even if Day eventually decides to promote from inside, he has to make some calls outside.

Now, to the roster.


Jim Knowles left Ohio State to become the DC at Penn State earlier this week. The Nittany Lions gave him a three-year deal with an average of $3.1 million per year. (Adam Cairns / Columbus Dispatch / USA Today via Imagn Images)

Quarterbacks

On the roster: Julian Sayin, Lincoln Kienholz, Tavien St. Clair
Leaving: Will Howard (NFL), Devin Brown (transfer), Air Noland (transfer)

This is going to be an interesting year at quarterback for Ohio State. The room is inexperienced but the potential is high. Sayin is the former No. 1 quarterback in the 2024 class, a player with an incredibly fast release and everybody you talk to at Ohio State raves about his ability to process quickly. He probably needs to add some muscle this offseason, which I’m sure he’ll do, but he has the chance to be really good.

Kienholz will battle for the spot in the spring, while St. Clair should be in a good position to adjust to college without immediate pressure. Sayin will probably be the guy when the season starts but minimize your expectations. A first-time starter opening against Texas and a Pete Kwiatkowski defense could be rough. It’ll be up to Day and Chip Kelly to make things easy for him.

Advertisement

Running backs

On the roster: James Peoples, CJ Donaldson, Bo Jackson, Anthony “Turbo” Rogers, Isaiah West, TC Caffey
Leaving: Sam Williams-Dixon (transfer), TreVeyon Henderson (NFL), Quinshon Judkins (NFL)

There will be wholesale changes here for the first time since Henderson stepped in and established himself as a star his freshman year, but there’s talent. Peoples didn’t play a lot last year, but you could see the potential when he did. He had 197 yards and two touchdowns on 49 carries, and in camp, he looked like somebody who could contribute right away if asked to. He’ll benefit from another year in the strength program, but pairing him with West Virginia transfer Donaldson will be a good duo. Ohio State will get Jackson, Rogers, West and Caffey reps this offseason, as well.

go-deeper

GO DEEPER

Ohio State’s Quinshon Judkins is draft-bound, but Sonny Styles to return

Wide receiver

On the roster: Jeremiah Smith, Carnell Tate, Brandon Inniss, Bryson Rodgers, Mylan Graham, Damarion Witten, David Adolph, Phillip Bell, De’zie Jones, Bodpegn Miller, Quincy Porter
Leaving: Emeka Egbuka (NFL), Kojo Antwi (transfer), Jayden Ballard (transfer)

Smith returns as the best receiver in the country and Tate is ready to establish himself as one of the best, making for a dangerous 1-2 combo. Inniss, though, is the one nobody is prepared for. He’s fast, physical and smooth in and out of his routes. He’ll take over Egbuka’s spot in the slot.

Advertisement

Tight end

On the roster: Max Klare, Will Kacmarek, Bennett Christian, Jelani Thurman, Max LeBlanc, Brody Lennon, Nate Roberts
Leaving: Gee Scott, Patrick Gurd

Klare will be a major weapon in next year’s offense. He led Purdue with 74 targets per Pro Football Focus and caught 51 passes for 685 yards. He will add another level of unpredictability to Ohio State’s offense. Add in the return of Kacmarek, Thurman and Christian, and the Buckeyes have the best tight end room they’ve had in a long time.

Offensive line

On the roster: Deontae Armstrong, Ian More, Phillip Daniels, Ethan Onianwa, Jayvon McFadden, Carter Lowe, Luke Montgomery, Tegra Tshabola, Austin Siereveld, Devontae Armstrong, Gabe VanSickle, Carson Hinzman, Jake Cook, Josh Padilla
Leaving: Donovan Jackson (NFL), Josh Fryar (NFL), Josh Simmons (NFL), George Fitzpatrick (transfer), Zen Michalski (transfer), Miles Walker (transfer), Seth McLaughlin

This will be the deepest Ohio State offensive line in a long time. Montgomery, Hinzman, Tshabola and Siereveld return with starter-level experience on the national championship run and Ohio State addressed its major concerns at tackle by adding Daniels (Minnesota) and Onianwa (Rhode Island) from the portal. They each gave up nine pressures last year and just one sack, per PFF.

Defensive line

On the roster: Caden Curry, Kenyatta Jackson Jr., Joshua Mickens, Dominic Kirks, Logan George, Zion Grady, Epi Sitanilei, Kayden McDonald, Eddrick Houston, Tywone Malone Jr., Jason Moore, Will Smith Jr., Eric Mensah, Jayquez Carter, Trajen Odom, Maxwell Roy
Leaving: Jack Sawyer (NFL), JT Tuimoloau (NFL), Mitchell Melton (transfer), Ty Hamilton (NFL), Tyleik Williams, Hero Kanu

Advertisement

This is probably the only question mark on the defensive side and it’s not for a lack of talent, just full-time experience. Jackson was really good in the postseason; McDonald and Houston should be a very good interior duo as well, but there’s a difference between playing second-team snaps to being responsible for 40-plus. We’ll see how they handle it, but the talent is here.

Linebackers

On the roster: Sonny Styles, Arvell Reese, CJ Hicks, Payton Pierce, Garrett Stover, Tarvos Alford, Ty Howard, Eli Lee, Riley Pettijohn
Leaving: Cody Simon, Gabe Powers

It’s crazy what a year can do for a linebacker room, but James Laurinaitis has done a great job adding and developing this room. Styles and Reese are the starters, but Hicks is a flexible player depending on how the new coordinator wants to use him. Add in young talent led by Pettijohn and Alford and an all-conference transfer in Ty Howard, from Duquense, this room is talented, experienced and deep.

Cornerback

On the roster: Davison Igbinosun, Jermaine Mathews Jr., Lorenzo Styles Jr., Miles Lockhart, Aaron Scott, Bryce West, Devin Sanchez, Jordyn Woods
Leaving: Denzel Burke, Jordan Hancock, Calvin Simpson-Hunt

Getting Igbinosun back was a massive deal for the Buckeyes, even if he has pass interference issues. You can’t duplicate his 6-foot-2 frame and physicality. Mathews will be opposite him, with five-star corner Sanchez, ready to fight for playing time. We’ll see how many defensive backs the next coordinator wants to use before looking at the slot corners.

Advertisement

Safeties

Returning: Caleb Downs, Malik Hartford, Jaylen McClain, Keenan Nelson Jr., Leroy Rokey, Brenten Jones, Faheem Delane, Cody Haddad, Deshawn Stewart
Leaving: Lathan Ransom, Jayden Bonsu

Losing Ransom will hurt, but Ohio State brings back the best safety in the country in Downs and will pair him with two young, high-potential players in Hartford and McClain.

(Top photo of Julian Sayin: Adam Cairns / Columbus Dispatch / USA Today)



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Ohio

Iowa basketball: Instant takeaways from Hawkeyes’ 82-65 road loss to Ohio State

Published

on

Iowa basketball: Instant takeaways from Hawkeyes’ 82-65 road loss to Ohio State


Iowa basketball entered Monday’s men’s contest at Ohio State shooting 51% from the field and 39.1% from deep. 

But the Hawkeyes’ high-octane offense did not show up in Columbus. On Monday, Iowa shot just 39% from the field and 28% from 3-point range.

Iowa was doomed by shooting struggles in the 82-65 loss.

Advertisement

Ohio State was mostly able to hold Payton Sandfort and Josh Dix in check. Sandfort had 13 points but was just 5-of-16 from the field. Meanwhile, Josh Dix didn’t score at all and was 0-of-7 from the field.

Monday had shades of Iowa’s offensive performance in last week’s loss to Minnesota. The Hawkeyes shot just 14.3% from deep against the Golden Gophers.

Iowa’s offense is what carries the team, and when the Hawkeyes have nights like these it’s very difficult to compete.

Iowa collapses in the second half

Iowa trailed by as many as 10 points in the first half but trimmed that deficit down to four at the break.

The Hawkeyes remained in the fight going into intermission.

Advertisement

But things started to unravel quickly after the break.

After an encouraging defensive performance in the first half, Ohio State shot 57% from the field after the break. Ohio State hammered Iowa on the boards in the second half, holding a 23-11 advantage, though that was in part due to the shooting discrepancy. Iowa wasn’t able to find a stable rhythm offensively.

The Buckeyes’ lead ballooned to as many as 25 points in what has become a familiar sight on the road for Iowa. The Hawkeyes were not able to sustain the level of offensive and defensive activity needed to win on the road. Ohio State looked comfortable and was in clear command of the game.

Ohio State outscored Iowa 52-39 in the second half.

Iowa’s road woes continue

The Hawkeyes still have not won a true road game this season.

Advertisement

Iowa is now 0-5. Only one of those games was decided by single digits. Other than that near-takedown of Michigan in December, Iowa has mostly not been very competitive. The Hawkeyes were clobbered by Wisconsin and UCLA. Monday fit right in with that narrative.

There are still more opportunities out there, but it’s not an encouraging development. Iowa goes on the road to Rutgers, Maryland, Illinois, Northwestern and Nebraska. Iowa’s troubles on the road makes the path the NCAA Tournament even more difficult.

Free throw issues still unsolved

The Hawkeyes again didn’t shoot well from the free throw line. Iowa finished Monday’s game just 10-of-17 from the charity stripe.

Seydou Traore was 7-of-10, Owen Freeman was 2-of-5 and Drew Thelwell was 1-of-2.

Had Iowa converted on every free throw, it still wouldn’t have been enough to turn the tide. But not taking care of the more controllable aspects like free throws makes winning an uphill battle.

Advertisement

The fleeting bright spots

Iowa stayed alive in the first half in part due to Freeman and Thelwell, who combined for 22 of Iowa’s 26 first-half points. That gave Iowa at least a chance.

Thelwell finished with a team-high 20 points on 8-of-10 from the field and 3-of-4 from deep.

Freeman slowed significantly in the second half, scoring just three points after the break. He finished the contest with 14 points.

Seydou Traore provided a boost in the second half, scoring 11 of his 13 points after the break.

But there were not nearly enough positive developments for Iowa to give Ohio State trouble, much less win the game.

Advertisement

Follow Tyler Tachman on X @Tyler_T15, contact via email at ttachman@gannett.com





Source link

Continue Reading

Ohio

Penn State lures defensive coordinator Jim Knowles away from Ohio State

Published

on

Penn State lures defensive coordinator Jim Knowles away from Ohio State


STATE COLLEGE, Pa. — Penn State has lured Tom Knowles away from Ohio State.

The Nittany Lions hired Knowles to serve as their defensive coordinator. Knowles held the same position with the national champion Buckeyes for three years.

Knowles replaces Tom Allen, who left to take the same job with Clemson after Penn State fell to Notre Dame in the College Football Playoff semifinals.

Ohio State had the top-ranked defense in the country in 2024. The Buckeyes held opponents to 254 yards while going 14-2 and earning the program’s second national championship of the playoff era.

Advertisement

While Penn State will lose several starters off a defense that finished seventh in the FBS in yards allowed — including Big Ten Defensive Player of the Year Abdul Carter, who is heading to the NFL — defensive linemen Zane Durant and Dani Dennis-Sutton, linebacker Tony Rojas and cornerback A.J. Harris will return.

Penn State head coach James Franklin called Knowles “a strong strategist and excellent defensive mind.”

The hiring is a homecoming of sorts for Knowles, who grew up in the Philadelphia area. He played collegiately at Cornell before going into coaching. Previous coaching stops include Duke, Oklahoma State and Mississippi.





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending