Indianapolis, IN
Fight over dinner leads to shooting at steakhouse; off-duty IMPD officer held suspect at gunpoint
INDIANAPOLIS (WISH) — An argument between two men at a south side steakhouse Friday night led to one man being fatally shot and the other being held at gunpoint by an off-duty police officer, Indianapolis police say.
Randy Godfrey, 34, faces murder charges after he shot Robert “Blaine” Smith, 32, in the parking lot of Texas Roadhouse, 4335 Southport Crossing Dr. That steakhouse sits among several restaurants just southwest the I-65 interchange at Southport Road.
According to a probable cause affidavit, Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department officers were dispatched to the steakhouse just before 9 p.m. Friday to investigate a fight that later turned into a “person shot” run.
They arrived and found Smith suffering a gunshot wound, and Godfrey standing nearby with a holstered gun.
An off-duty officer at the scene told detectives they were eating dinner with their girlfriend when they heard yelling and saw Smith and Godfrey physically fighting on the restaurant floor. The officer later noticed Godfrey had a gun on his hip.
The officer ran over and helped two restaurant employees break up the fight. When the two men were separated, Smith walked out to the parking lot. The officer held Godfrey down, identifying themselves as an off-duty officer and asked their girlfriend to call 911.
According to the affidavit, Godfrey said, “‘I don’t give a (expletive) if you’re a police officer,’ then pushed the officer off, saying, ‘I’m going to shoot that (expletives).’”
Godfrey then ran out of the restaurant after Smith, the officer in tow. When the officer made it to the parking lot, they saw Godfrey walk towards a large vehicle, followed by multiple shots being fired.
The officer ran back inside to get their gun, then returned to the parking lot. They found Godfrey standing there with their firearm holstered.
The officer pointed their gun at Godfrey, telling him to lie on the ground.
Godfrey replied, “‘Just shoot me.’”
Police say the officer held Godfrey at gunpoint until first responders arrived and took him into custody.
Smith was found in critical condition with a gunshot wound. He was taken to a hospital, where he later died.
Godfrey’s fiancée told detectives at the restaurant that she, her sister, Godfrey, Smith, and Godfrey’s two kids were eating when Godfrey and Smith started arguing. Police did not say what the men were arguing about.
During the fight, Smith told Godfrey, “If you have a problem, say something.” Godfrey replied, “Well, let’s go outside.”
A physical fight broke out between the men before the officer got involved and the fight migrated outside. Godfrey’s fiancée saw Smith walk to her car, Godfrey following behind. She told police she then watched Godfrey shoot his gun downward, and Smith fell to the ground.
Godfrey asked, “Did I hit you?” Smith stood back up, then two more shots rang out. Smith fell back down.
Godfrey’s fiancée told police she ran out to Smith to put pressure on his wounds and to start CPR while they waited for medics.
Godfrey was arrested at the Texas Roadhouse and booked into the Marion County jail for a preliminary murder charge.
He was due in court for a hearing at 9:30 a.m. Tuesday.
Indianapolis, IN
That trail you walk downtown? It’s generated $3 billion for Indianapolis, study finds
See the 10th Street Cultural Trail Expansion ribbon cutting ceremon
Highlights: Indiana Ave. and 10th Street Cultural Trail Expansion ribbon cutting on Indiana Ave. on Thursday, June 20, 2024, in Indianapolis.
Since its creation, the Indianapolis Cultural Trail in the heart of Circle City has drawn millions of residents and visitors to its distinctive paved path. But according to a new report, the trail isn’t just beneficial for those looking to get out on an urban stroll or bike ride — it’s a driver for the city’s economy and quality of life.
The report, “Indianapolis Cultural Trail: A Legacy of Gene and Marilyn Glick at 20: Connecting People, Places, and Possibility,” was based on analysis by James Lima Planning + Development, a group of real estate, planning and economic development advisors. Here’s what to know about the report.
How has the Cultural Trail affected the city’s growth, development?
According to the report from 2026, the 10-mile trail has generated $3 billion in assessed property value around its path — money that supports the city and its governmental services.
The population along the trail has grown five times the city average and retail space near the trail has increased 39%, the report shows. Nearby food and beverage sales are almost twice the average per square foot in Indianapolis.
Additionally, the report shows, undeveloped land along the trail has the potential to add $1.4 billion of value in the near future. Since an initial study in 2015, the trail’s economic impact has grown from $1 billion to $3 billion.
“For nearly 20 years, the Indianapolis Cultural Trail has helped transform Downtown Indianapolis into a more vibrant, connected and economically competitive city,” Mayor Joe Hogsett said in a June 3 news release. “It is more than a trail. It is a nationally recognized public asset that drives investment, supports local businesses, connects neighborhoods and improves quality of life for the people who live, work, play and stay in our city.”
According to the report, over 1 million people use the trail each year, and almost half of downtown Indianapolis residents live within a three-minute walk of the path.
What other features does the Cultural Trail offer?
Users of the Indianapolis Cultural Trail aren’t limited to walking — the Pacers Bikeshare program, operated by the trail, has 57 bike stations throughout the city that are accessible 24/7.
The trail also features nearly six acres of plants and greenspace, offering locals and visitors an urban getaway. City planners from across the world have visited the trail to study its design, according to the report.
What is the future of the Indianapolis Cultural Trail?
Focus on the Indianapolis Cultural Trail has shifted from construction and maintenance to long-term operations and expanded resources for the public.
Kären Haley, executive director of the Indianapolis Cultural Trail, Inc. — the trail’s nonprofit — said it has grown into the “crown jewel” of the city with the growth and development it has created over two decades.
“The Cultural Trail is driving billions in investment and making surrounding neighborhoods thriving destinations,” she said in a June 3 news release. “As we enter the next phase for the Trail, we look forward to building upon our initial 20 years of impact.”
Mia Thurow is the breaking news and criminal justice reporting intern for the Indianapolis Star. She can be reached at mthurow@gannett.com.
ICYMI: Top 5 IndyStar business stories in May 2026
A busy month at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway reignited debates about hotels and the downtown heliport. Plus, Eli Lilly celebrated 150 years.
May came and went, and with it, we saw the closest Indianapolis 500 finish in history, the 150th anniversary of Eli Lilly and a contested primary election day.
There’s also been some movement in retail news ahead of the summer shopping season. On the north side, a new women’s clothing store opened while a piercing studio set up shop in Speedway. Meanwhile, an indoor children’s play place opened on the near north side.
Read on for four spots that recently opened and one in Broad Ripple that said farewell.
Openings
Monkee’s
8659 River Crossing Blvd., monkeesofindianapolis.com, opened in March
Monkee’s of Indianapolis, a high-end women’s clothing store, opened recently on the north side in the Shops at River Crossing near the Fashion Mall. The brand Monkee’s started in the South three decades ago and has since grown to nearly 70 locations. In Indianapolis, Missy Llewellyn and Whitney Schmitt started the franchise to bring the clothing brand to the Circle City.
The Nest Play Cafe
515 E 22nd St Suite 101, indynestplaycafe.com, opened early May
The Nest Play Cafe opened at the corner of Central Avenue and 22nd Street, offering an indoor space for parents and caregivers to bring their children to play. Caregivers can book 90-minute play sessions for $15 per child over the age of one. Tickets for additional siblings run $10. The cafe sells coffee and snacks, too.
Open Monday, Wednesday and Thursday 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.; Friday 8 a.m. to 6:30 p.m.; Saturday and Sunday 8 a.m. to noon. Closed Tuesdays.
Forget Me Not Piercing Studio
5324 W. 16th St., jessflowerspiercings.square.site, opened May 27
A new piercing studio opened in Speedway at the end of May just days after the Indianapolis 500. Forget Me Not Piercing offers traditional lobe, helix and conch piercings along with nostril and septum piercings. Artist Jess Flowers opened the one-woman shop on 16th Street.
Open Sunday and Thursday 1 p.m. to 5 p.m. and Wednesday, Friday and Saturday 1 p.m. to 7 p.m.
Black Orchid Barbers Fountain Square
1201 Prospect St. Suite 100, blackorchidbarbers.com, opened in May
Black Orchid, a local barbershop known for its sharp haircuts with a side of humor, opened its Fountain Square spot, marking the company’s seventh brick-and-mortar location. Walk-ins are welcome but Black Orchid recommends grabbing a time slot online for your preferred service.
Open Monday through Saturday 10 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Closures
Vitality IV Bar
6302 Guilford Ave., vitalityivbar.com
An IV-wellness spot in Broad Ripple shut its doors last month. Vitality IV Bar was located next to the Thieves cocktail lounge, formerly the Broad Ripple Starbucks location, before it went out of business.
Vitality IV still operates an Indianapolis-area location on Mass Ave downtown at 749 Massachusetts Ave where customers can book a variety of infusions with vitamins.
See a store opening or closing near you? Contact IndyStar reporter Alysa Guffey at alysa.guffey@indystar.com.
Forty-one names comprised the 11th layer of Springer’s “The Forgiving Sea VI,” an interactive painting that invites people to wr
-
South Dakota17 seconds agoTornado watch in effect as severe storms target South Dakota
-
Tennessee3 minutes agoTennessee Baseball Breakout Star Announces He Won’t Enter the Transfer Portal
-
Texas8 minutes agoCentral Texas soldier dies in Iraq during training incident, Department of Defense says
-
Utah15 minutes agoNew program at University of Utah aims to keep up with growing Utah industry
-
Vermont18 minutes agoVermont seeks dynamic pricing for state park access
-
Virginia23 minutes agoWest Virginia commit announces decision by blasting ‘Country Roads,’ lighting a couch on fire
-
Washington30 minutes agoSteelers Sign TE Darnell Washington to Four-Year Extension
-
Wisconsin33 minutes agoWisconsin DNR reminding ATV and UTV drivers that more wardens will be out this weekend
