Detroit, MI
Lawsuit claims Detroit police officer killed ‘restrained, defenseless’ dog in search
Detroit — A Detroit woman and her two adult sons are suing the city of Detroit and a group of Detroit police officers, claiming one of them killed the family’s dog for no reason before the residents were taken into custody without probable cause.
The incident happened Jan. 2, 2023, when Officer Austin Rymarz and five other “John Doe” officers executed a search warrant at a house on Roosevelt Street on Detroit’s west side, according to the 15-page lawsuit that was filed March 3 in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan.
Attorney Cyril C. Hall told The Detroit News the officers handcuffed his clients, Lashaye Taylor and her adult sons Desjuan Taylor and Saron Blanding, after falsely claiming there was a warrant for their arrest.
Lashaye Taylor was held in a squad car “for several hours,” while Desjuan Taylor and Blanding were held in the Detroit Detention Center for four days before being released without charges, Hall said.
“There was never any warrant,” Hall said. “None of them have been charged with any crimes related to those unlawful arrests.”
While carrying out the search warrant, the lawsuit accused Rymarz of fatally shooting Lashaye Taylor’s dog while it “was restrained, defenseless, and posed no immediate danger.”
Detroit police spokesman Vic Pratt said the department couldn’t discuss the specific details of the incident, citing the ongoing lawsuit.
“However, the DPD can confirm that incidents involving high-risk search warrants are extremely dangerous and require officers to make split-second judgment calls regarding potential threats,” Pratt said in a statement. “Unfortunately, aggressive animals are sometimes posted near doors to alert the occupants that police have arrived and to prevent officers from entering the location. Pursuant to DPD policy, physical force against any animal will be used only to prevent harm or injury to a person. This matter will be referred to the City Law Department for proper action.”
According to the lawsuit, the dog was chained to a fence in Lashaye Taylor’s yard during the raid, and “posed no threat to the officers. The dog could not have reached or attacked officers due to the chain’s length. Police body camera footage and trial testimony confirm that the dog remained in its position and did not advance toward any officers.
“Lashaye Taylor and her son Terrance Blanding told (the) officers that they could remove dog in front,” the lawsuit said. “Shortly thereafter, (Lashaye Taylor) heard flashbang and three shots from (a) firearm causing (her) to scream.”
The lawsuit, which does not specify the amount of damages sought, alleges the officers violated the plaintiffs’ Fourth Amendment rights, and claims the city failed to properly train and supervise the officers.
Hall told The News he received body-worn camera footage and transcripts from Rymarz’s trial board, during which he admitted under cross-examination, “I could see that (the dog) was attached to something,” and that “he did not know how far the chain reached.”
“Despite Defendant Rymarz’s observation, he fired three shots, killing the dog,” the lawsuit said. “The dog was restrained, defenseless, and posed no immediate danger. Officer Rymarz later falsely claimed the dog was aggressive and advancing, despite video evidence contradicting this assertion. He testified, ‘The dog was in the same spot before and after the shooting.’”
The lawsuit accused the officers of violating the Detroit Police Department’s Dangerous Animal Policy, which states that “an officer shall not discharge a firearm at a dog or other animal, except to protect a member or person from imminent physical injury and there is no opportunity to retreat or other reasonable means to eliminate the threat.”
The policy further requires that “before using deadly force, every attempt will be made to use other reasonable means to contain the threat of a dangerous animal.”
The lawsuit also accused the officers of removing the dog’s remains without the owner’s consent, and failing to follow the department’s reporting requirements for the destruction of an animal.
The lawsuit is the latest to accuse Detroit police officers of unnecessarily killing dogs. In 2023, a woman claimed in a federal lawsuit that a Detroit police officer unlawfully entered her backyard and fatally shot her dog. A 2019 lawsuit claims officers shot a woman’s two dogs without cause, killing one of them.
The city in 2015 agreed to settle a $100,000 lawsuit with a man after police shot his dog while it was chained to a fence.
ghunter@detroitnews.com
(313) 222-2134
@GeorgeHunter_DN
Detroit, MI
Detroit family’s home damaged, Christmas gifts lost after fire spreads from vacant house
DETROIT – Detroit fire officials are investigating multiple house fires that broke out Tuesday morning, including a blaze that destroyed two vacant homes and damaged one family’s home on Dwyer Street.
The fire started around 1 a.m. in a vacant house, leveling it before spreading to a neighboring vacant property and then damaging the home of Joel Whitner and his family.
Whitner described how his family woke up to the sound of neighbors pounding on their door.
“When we walked out the door, the wind gusts and the fire just kind of like blew us back,” Whitner said, describing the intensity of the blaze.
The family’s home has significant damage, including water damage throughout the interior and damage to the roof.
The family lost Christmas gifts, furniture, and clothing in the fire.
A GoFundMe has been started to help support the family.
In a separate incident around 3 a.m., firefighters responded to another residential fire on Ashland Street, where a family of 15 evacuated safely after a space heater caught fire in an upstairs bedroom and spread to the attic.
“I grabbed my fire extinguisher, and I started spraying it right there, and that made it go up more, so I ran to the attic and started spraying in the attic,” said Jerome Hill. “Keep a fire extinguisher by your bed because if I didn’t have that by my bed, there’s no telling what would’ve happened.”
It comes after a house fire that killed a 6-year-old girl on Sunday (Dec. 14) and another fire that killed three on Monday.
Fire officials say space heaters are responsible for four out of five home heating-related fire deaths.
The Detroit Fire Department is reminding families of home heating safety tips.
Captain Edward Davis emphasized the importance of having a safety plan in place in case of an emergency.
“You want to create a fire safety plan for your home in the event of an emergency,” Davis said. “What are two ways to get out of the room, out of the home – where are our families meeting up? How do we alert other members in the home?”
The department’s safety guidelines for space heaters include:
-
Place heaters on flat, stable surfaces
-
Keep heaters at least three feet away from combustible items
-
Plug heaters directly into wall outlets
-
Turn off heaters when leaving rooms or going to sleep
-
Keep heaters clear of walkways and exits
The department is also reminding families of important carbon monoxide safety tips:
-
Install carbon monoxide alarms low to the ground, near gas furnaces, dryers, or heaters.
-
Test CO detectors monthly and replace them every five to seven years.
-
Avoid using a stove, oven, or grill as a heat source.
-
Keep gas and charcoal grills outdoors only—never in garages or enclosed spaces.
-
Hire only qualified professionals to inspect or repair heating systems, fireplaces, and chimneys.
Copyright 2025 by WDIV ClickOnDetroit – All rights reserved.
Detroit, MI
4 dead, Detroit firefighter injured in slew of fires. What to know
House fire safety: Essential steps to stay safe
This video outlines critical steps to take in the event of a home fire. It covers calling emergency services, safely evacuating, and ensuring family safety while waiting for professional help.
A fire that claimed three lives in Detroit began with an electrical incident, officials say. Now, in the wake of that deadly blaze, another fatal fire and multiple other recent blazes – including one that injured a firefighter − Detroit fire officials are urging residents to take fire safety steps this holiday season.
Four people died across two fires on Sunday, Dec. 14, and Monday, Dec. 15, in the city, and firefighters tackled three housefires that displaced residents in the early morning hours on Tuesday, Dec. 16.
A cause was not yet available for the Dec. 14 fire that killed a 7-year-old boy, originally reported by officials as a 6-year-old girl. That fire took place in the 12000 block of Rutherford Street, near Greenfield Road, and also left a woman critical and a 4-year-old with smoke inhalation.
In the case of the Dec. 15 fire, more details were beginning to emerge.
A man, a woman and a teen girl all died after a house fire reported about 6 a.m. in the 19000 block of Wildemere Street, near Detroit’s Palmer Park and off 7 Mile Road. An elderly woman was also critical after the fire.
Clutter in the house slowed down rescue efforts, officials previously said.
And speaking to the media on Tuesday, Dec. 16, Fire Investigation Division Chief Dennis Richardson said an electrical event caused the fire, and combustibles in the house contributed to the blaze.
The specifics of the electrical event are still being looked at, but Richardson said the house already had electrical issues, and it’s believed wiring played a role in the fire.
Fire department team members “hate seeing this,” and are trying to convey messages around fire safety this time of year, Richardson said.
A spike in fires
That message is one the department works to share months ahead of the holiday season, said Detroit Fire Marshal Donald Thomas. Headed into next year, the department hopes to use data to work with specific neighborhoods with vulnerable structures that see home heating and electrical fires.
“We do notice that there is a spike in some of the fires that we have during our colder season,” Thomas said.
While the causes are still under investigation, the department also saw multiple houses in flames on Dec. 16:
- A fire was reported about 12:45 a.m. in the 19100 block of Dwyer Street, said Corey McIsaac, Detroit Fire Department media relations director. Firefighters arrived to find fire in one home, but it extended into four homes nearby. One home was occupied, but no one was injured.
- A house fire was also reported just before 3 a.m. in the 19600 block of Charest Street, McIsaac said. Firefighters arrived to find all residents and dogs outside. The fire was put out but rekindled a little after 6 a.m. and was doused again.
- Additionally, a fire was reported just before 3:10 a.m. in the 2100 block of Ashland Street, McIsaac said. The upstairs flat in the two-family home was on fire, and all residents were out when firefighters arrived. One firefighter was injured during the response but was released later in the day.
All displaced residents were connected to the American Red Cross or Detroit Housing Services for housing assistance, McIsaac said.
Fighting time
Fire can double itself every 30 seconds, so residents and responders are “fighting against time” when flames break out, said Detroit Fire Capt. Edward Davis of the Public Instruction Unit.
Steps he suggested to avoid a fire in the first place include:
- Plugging space heaters directly into wall outlets instead of extension cords.
- Not leaving space heaters unattended while sleeping or leaving the home.
- Keeping space heaters on a flat surface and three feet away from clothing, paper products or other combustibles.
- Keeping space heaters away from children and pets, as the little ones can knock the heaters over or get burned.
- Not using ovens or stoves to heat a house.
Steps he recommended to prepare for safety during a fire included:
- Having working smoke detectors and checking them every week.
- Creating a fire safety plan that includes two routes of escape, where to meet and how to alert others in the house without risking personal injury. That last part could be done with whistles or air horns. Additionally, having a plan on how to shelter if escape isn’t possible. Sheltering could include closing a door to slow a fire’s progress.
- Possessing fire extinguishers and knowing how to use them.
- Possessing a ladder, if a resident wants, but being sure where it is and how to use it because of how quickly fire doubles.
The fire department also released additional information on getting fireplaces and furnaces inspected and avoiding the dangers of carbon monoxide in the winter months. For more safety suggestions and details on those, go to detroitmi.gov/fire.
In addition, those facing housing concerns, without proper heat, or displaced from the fires can reach out to the Detroit Housing Resource HelpLine at 866-313-2520.
Detroit, MI
‘We stay praying about it:’ Suspect in deadly Detroit hit and run charged
Man charged in deadly hit-and-run from 2024
It’s the first holiday without Darnell Scott, who was killed in a hit-and-run in the summer of 2024 on Detroit’s east side. You might remember this video, showing him getting hit and neither driver stopped.
DETROIT (FOX 2) – A Detroit man was run over not once, but twice, all on video. Many might remember the incident from last summer but on Monday there was a big break in the case.
Big picture view:
It’s the first holiday without Darnell Scott, who was killed in a hit-and-run in the summer of 2024 on Detroit’s east side. You might remember a video showing him getting hit and neither driver stopped.
These cases can be tough to solve, but the Detroit Police fatal squad painstakingly pieced together footage from Green Light cameras and license plate readers, leading them to Daryl Rice in November.
He is now charged and was given a personal bond, which means he’s out for now.
“I honestly didn’t give up hope because we stay praying about it,” said the victim’s twin sister, Dana Scott.
The family is sickened by the damning evidence. Apparently, Rice made a false insurance claim on his car after the hit-and-run, lied about how the damage happened, but in the process, police say he incriminated himself.
The family wants others to hold out hope.
“Don’t give up, because it can happen, your wishes and answers can come true,” said Dana.
-
Iowa3 days agoAddy Brown motivated to step up in Audi Crooks’ absence vs. UNI
-
Washington1 week agoLIVE UPDATES: Mudslide, road closures across Western Washington
-
Iowa4 days agoHow much snow did Iowa get? See Iowa’s latest snowfall totals
-
Maine1 day agoElementary-aged student killed in school bus crash in southern Maine
-
World1 week ago
Chiefs’ offensive line woes deepen as Wanya Morris exits with knee injury against Texans
-
Maryland3 days agoFrigid temperatures to start the week in Maryland
-
Technology6 days agoThe Game Awards are losing their luster
-
South Dakota3 days agoNature: Snow in South Dakota