Connect with us

Lifestyle

Tonally inconsistent ‘Dragon Age: The Veilguard’ is still BioWare’s best action game

Published

on

Tonally inconsistent ‘Dragon Age: The Veilguard’ is still BioWare’s best action game

Two buddies and a baby griffin enjoy a quiet moment of companionship.

Andy Bickerton/BioWare


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

Andy Bickerton/BioWare

In 2010, Canadian developer BioWare was in peak form. It released Mass Effect 2 to near-unanimous acclaim, winning over 100 awards, just one year after the successful launch of an old-school roleplaying series in Dragon Age: Origins. The company was the name in cinematic RPG experiences, with a near-pristine record of classics like Baldur’s Gate, Neverwinter Nights, and Knights of the Old Republic (we don’t talk about Sonic Chronicles: The Dark Brotherhood).

But in the following years, BioWare’s reputation began to falter. Dragon Age 2 was rushed and underbaked. Mass Effect 3 and Dragon Age: Inquisition sold well, but felt a little off — from Dragon Age brightening up its dark fantasy setting to Mass Effect failing to deliver the meaningful choices players expected. Then came the critical disappointment of Mass Effect: Andromeda, the commercial disaster of Anthem, leadership departures, and layoffs. BioWare’s heyday had all but ended.

Now, after a nearly decade-long development cycle, BioWare is shooting for redemption with Dragon Age: The Veilguard. After completing it in 60 hours, I’m happy to report that the game is packed with excellent combat, level design, progression systems, equipment optimization, and charismatic companions. It is, simply put, a well-executed action RPG. However, Veilguard’s wildly inconsistent tone prevents it from standing tall in BioWare’s illustrious catalog.

Advertisement

If you’re hoping for a return to the series’ origins, you’ll be disappointed. But if you’re looking for an expertly streamlined blockbuster, Veilguard is a delight.

Controlled detonation

Let’s start with Veilguard’s strongest feature — its action gameplay. Mastering combat and party composition is a thoroughly rewarding experience from start to finish. I began the game in normal mode, dying more than I care to admit with my rogue assassin build. After completing Shadow of the Erdtree, I thought, “I’m better than this!” — so I respecialized until I found the right archery-focused build, stacked gear buffs on gear buffs, assigned all the best combinations of companion skills, and demolished the game on hard mode.

My character's archery powers in their full glory.

My character’s archery powers in their full glory.

Andy Bickerton/BioWare


hide caption

Advertisement

toggle caption

Andy Bickerton/BioWare

I say this not to flex my true gaming prowess (although I’ll gladly take credit), but to show how well BioWare created mechanics that encouraged, nay demanded, mastery. Veilguard’s undoubtedly their strongest outing when it comes to action-focused combat — and plentiful accessibility and difficulty settings allow for a more casual experience, if you want to take it easy.

Similarly, the level design, clearly inspired by 2018’s God of War, beautifully improves on Inquisition’s bland open zones. Rather than focus on formulaic checklists, Veilguard offers side quests that consistently reward exploration with useful loot and impactful plot points. I was often surprised by the depth of Veliguard’s missions, particularly when they involved factions or the history of Solas and Mythal (hint hint: do that one).

Advertisement

Avengers assemble

Compared to its predecessors, Veilguard often feels ripped from a different franchise. Some scenes are distinctively Dragon Age, while others feel more like a Disney movie. It’s an M for Mature game with an excess of tonally conflicting E for Everyone moments. On the one hand, you have blood mages ritualistically sacrificing enslaved people, a horrifying blight decimating villages, and ancient Elven gods turning innocent people into monsters. On the other hand, you have a silly skeleton butler soundtracked by music that feels like Christmas morning at Hogwarts.

All seven companions, gathered in the game's home base.

All seven companions, gathered in the game’s home base.

BioWare


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

BioWare

It’s not wrong to pepper moments of levity into a grim storyline — lord knows The Last of Us Part 2 could have used some — but Veilguard’s jarring tonal shifts betray the compelling dark lore Dragon Age was founded on. Ultimately, it doesn’t add up to a cohesive, well-realized world.

It’s not like the writing is awful. Companions are generally likable, and much of the dialogue feels organic and engaging. Your home base in the Fade, The Lighthouse, is crammed with rewarding character development, fun interactions, and, of course, romance (not just between you and your chosen partner, but also between companions themselves!).

Relationships are the horse driving the cart rather than, say, the political and religious complexities of Inquisition. It feels more like Mass Effect than Dragon Age in that sense — and that’s not always a bad thing. BioWare has always been ahead of the curve in diverse representation, and Veilguard incorporates a storyline involving a character coming out as non-binary. You can even have your character, “Rook,” identify as trans.

Advertisement

A new age

Another critical element of any BioWare game is player choice. On that front, there were several times I had to take a long, hard look in the proverbial mirror. The lasting consequences of many decisions tie together seamlessly in Veilguard’s stellar finale, and the scale of potential outcomes feels grander than any past BioWare game (it’s not as grand as the ending Larian pulled off in Baldur’s Gate 3, but it’s still quite impressive). One choice hit me with a gut punch so hard that I’m still grappling with it days after finishing the game.

One of the game's big bads, the blighted Elven god Ghilan'nain.

One of the game’s big bads, the blighted Elven god Ghilan’nain.

BioWare


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

BioWare

But like Mass Effect 3, if you’re hoping for decisions from prior entries to matter, you’re in for a letdown. There are only three choices that you can set for Veilguard’s world state, and they’re all from Inquisition — flying in the face of the “Dragon Age Keep” system that recorded your decisions across the whole series. I can understand how complex it would have been to honor every choice made in prior titles, but it’s a tragic lost opportunity not to reward fans who have been playing since Origins.

It’s easy to see how this squandered potential, along with the tonal inconsistencies, could have arisen out of Veilguard’s near-decade of troubled production. David Gaider, Dragon Age’s lead writer and creator, left BioWare in 2016. Originally designed with substantial live-service components, Veilguard shifted to a full-on single-player RPG in 2021, six years after development began.

But I’m ultimately hopeful. Even though BioWare didn’t quite hit the mark in Veilguard, if it could take its best innovations and stick the landing with consistent storytelling, the anticipated Mass Effect 5 could restore the company to its prior glory.

Advertisement

Golden Age BioWare is dead. Long live BioWare.

James Perkins Mastromarino contributed to this review.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Lifestyle

N.F.L. Style Will Never Beat N.B.A. Style

Published

on

N.F.L. Style Will Never Beat N.B.A. Style

You want to see some real fashion ingenuity? Watch the N.F.L. draft.

I’m not saying it’s all good, but where else are you going to see someone in a double-breasted suit made by a company better known for making yoga pants? Or an Abercrombie & Fitch suit jacket so short that it exposes the belt loops on the pants beneath?

On the whole, the style on display at the N.F.L. draft last night was very overeager senior formal: a lot of suits in colors beyond basic blue. The quarterback Ty Simpson wore a custom suit by the athleisure label Alo, which, I have to say, looked better than I would have envisioned had you said the words “Alo Yoga suit” to me.

I thought it might have been from Suitsupply, but the conspicuous “Alo” pin on his right lapel put that idea to rest. Simpson, smartly, unfastened that beacon before appearing onstage as the 13th pick to the Los Angeles Rams. He had, perhaps, satisfied his contractual obligations by that point.

Earlier in the evening, as the wide receiver Carnell Tate threw up his arms in exaltation after being picked fourth by the Tennessee Titans, his cropped Abercrombie & Fitch jacket revealed a swatch of rib cage. He looked like a mâitre d’ who had just hit the Mega Millions.

Advertisement

During the N.B.A.’s extended fashion awakening, its draft has become a sandbox for luxury brands to cozy up to would-be endorsers. The Frenchman Victor Wembanyama broke a kind of cashmere ceiling when he wore Louis Vuitton to go first overall in the 2023 N.B.A. draft.

The N.F.L. draft has none of that. The brands you see are often not brands at all, but custom tailors that reach the league’s neophytes through a whisper network among players. The draft is also a platform to raise the curtain on longer-term brand deals that better suit these rookies. We may, for instance, never see Simpson in a suit again. Nearly every photo from his time at Alabama shows him in a T-shirt or hoodie. It makes sense for him to sign with Alo.

Football is the most mainstream of American cultural entities. And it’s one that still hasn’t, in spite of the league’s best efforts, taken off overseas. Few players, save some quarterbacks and a tight end who happens to be engaged to a pop star, feel bigger than the game itself. If you’re a new-to-the-league linebacker, you’ll most likely never harness the star power to grab the attention of Armani, but you might have just the right pull for Abercrombie.

The N.F.L. draft is therefore one of the few red carpets where the brands worn by the athletes may also be worn by those watching at home. How many people watching the Oscars will ever own clothes from Louis Vuitton or Chanel? People may comment online about Lady Gaga wearing Matières Fécales to the Grammys, but how many of those fans and viewers could afford to buy clothes from it?



Advertisement

Yesterday, I published a deep dive into how a newish crop of Japanese designers are soaking up all the attention in men’s fashion right now. This was a piece I was writing in my head long before I sat down and finally started typing. I remember sitting at a fashion show in Paris over a year ago — I believe it was Dior — and being asked by my seatmate if I’d made it over to a showroom in the Marais to check out A.Presse. That Tokyo-based brand is now part of a vanguard of Japanese labels that, on many days, seems to be all anyone in fashion wants to talk about. I spent months talking with designers, store owners and big-time shoppers to make sense of why these brands have kicked up so much buzz and, more than that, what makes their clothes so great. You can read the story here.


Continue Reading

Lifestyle

How to have the best Sunday in L.A., according to Tig Notaro

Published

on

How to have the best Sunday in L.A., according to Tig Notaro

Thirty years ago, comedian and actor Tig Notaro didn’t have a clear direction in life, so she followed some childhood friends who wanted to get into entertainment to Los Angeles. Secretly wanting to do stand-up, Notaro decided to try her luck at various outlets in town, which became the start of her successful career.

“I stayed on my friends’ couch near the Hollywood Improv on Melrose, and a couple months later, got my own studio apartment in the Miracle Mile area,” Notaro says. “I love all the options for everything in L.A. — the entertainment, the restaurants. I like to stay active. So many people love the hiking options in Los Angeles, and I’m one of them.”

Sunday Funday infobox logo with colorful spot illustrations

In Sunday Funday, L.A. people give us a play-by-play of their ideal Sunday around town. Find ideas and inspiration on where to go, what to eat and how to enjoy life on the weekends.

Advertisement

Notaro appears in Season 3 of Apple TV’s “The Morning Show” and is a series regular on Paramount+’s “Star Trek: Starfleet Academy,” as she was on “Star Trek: Discovery.” She’s also a touring stand-up comic and hosts “Handsome,” a comedy podcast, with Fortune Feimster and Mae Martin. The trio will be taping a live show May 4 at the Wiltern with the cast of Netflix’s “The Hunting Wives.” The live shows include interviews, but also “incorporate some ridiculous things,” she says. For example, upon hearing that some of the hosts always wanted to learn to tap dance, Notaro “hired a tap instructor to come to our live show in Austin and teach us how to tap dance in front of the audience.”

Notaro lives near Hollywood with her wife, actor Stephanie Allynne, their 9-year-old fraternal twin boys, Max and Finn, and three cats, Fluff, Linus and Skip. When she’s not touring, her ideal Sundays include sampling vegan restaurants, wandering through bookstores or museums, and doing something physically active with the family.

This interview has been lightly edited and condensed for length and clarity.

6 a.m.: Up with the kids

Because we have active children, we still wake up at 6 a.m. or 6:30 a.m. on Sunday, but there’s not as much of a rush to get going. Stephanie and I will often have coffee and chat in the living room together. I love that part of the day. Stephanie may cook breakfast, but Max and Finn are pretty self-sufficient and can make certain little meals for themselves. Max is really starting to take an interest in cooking, so he’d make breakfast for himself. Our family is vegan, but he eats eggs, so he makes himself an egg sandwich with avocado a lot of times.

Advertisement

9 a.m.: Daily morning walk

After breakfast, we usually have a morning walk around our neighborhood. That’s a daily thing I like to do, regardless of what’s going on. Now that I’m not touring as much, tennis is back on the schedule. So I’d go to Plummer Park in West Hollywood and play for a while, then join the family for lunch.

11:30 a.m.: Hike with a side of chickpea sandwich

I love Trails, a cafe in Griffith Park, where you can eat outdoors. It serves simple food, and has good vegan options. I usually get their chickpea salad sandwich. The food there is great. Afterward, we’d visit Griffith Observatory, where there’s lots to see. There are lots of great trails in the park, so we’d go for an hour hike before leaving.

3 p.m.: Browse the shelves for rock biographies

Advertisement

Bookstores are fun, so we’d head downtown for the Last Bookstore, which is in a historic building with lots of vintage books. I really love all things plant-based, and I’m a very big music fanatic. So I love to look for vegan books, nutrition books, rock biographies and autobiographies. It’s just fun to browse around the stacks.

If we didn’t go to the bookstore, we’d probably go to LACMA. Our sons are huge fans of art and want to go for each new exhibit. They love Hockney, Basquiat and Picasso, to name a few.

4 p.m.: Cuddle with cuties at a cat cafe

We’d then make a quick stop at [Crumbs & Whiskers], a kitten and cat cafe on Melrose for coffee, snacks and to pet the cats. It’s best to make reservations in advance. There’s cats all around the place that need to be adopted. You can visit and pet them, or find a new roommate. I’d love to take some home, but we already have three.

5:30 p.m. Italian or sushi, but make it vegan

Advertisement

We’re an early dinner family. One restaurant we like is Pura Vita in West Hollywood. It’s the greatest vegan Italian food, and for non-vegans, nobody ever knows the difference. It’s the first 100% plant-based Italian restaurant in the United States. They make an incredible kale salad and I love the San Gennaro pizza. It’s got cashew mozzarella, tomato sauce, Italian sausage crumble and more.

Then there’s Planta in Marina del Rey. It’s right on the harbor and you can sit outside and look at the boats coming in and out. They have sushi, salads and other plant-based entrees. They’ve got a really great spicy tuna roll that’s made out of watermelon. They are magicians.

Or there’s Crossroads Kitchen in West Hollywood. They play the best classic rock, and the atmosphere is upscale, fine dining. The appetizers that we always get are called Moroccan Cigars, which are vegan meat substitutes fried in a rolled batter. I really like the grilled lion’s mane steak, their mushroom steak with truffle potatoes, or the scallopini Milanese, that has a chicken or tofu option. I get the chicken with arugula on top. I always love to have a decaf espresso with dessert, which is either a brownie sundae or banana pudding.

7:30 p.m.: Comfort watch or word games

After dinner, the kids often like to watch an episode of “Friends,” a show that all ages enjoy, sports or “The Simpsons.” Or we’d play a game where each of us will add a word to a sentence and create a weird or funny long sentence until one of our sons says period. Then they’ll try and remember the whole sentence and repeat it back.

Advertisement

9:30 p.m.: Bubble bath then bed

The boys usually go to bed at 8:30 p.m. and bedtime for us is 9:30 p.m. Stephanie and I would read or chat. I like to take a bubble bath, if people must know. The best Sundays for me mean finding a good balance of relaxing and being active. I feel very lucky that my family and I can do those things together.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Lifestyle

It Started with a Midnight Swim and a Kiss Under the Stars

Published

on

It Started with a Midnight Swim and a Kiss Under the Stars

When Marian Sherry Lurio and Jonathan Buffington Nguyen met at a mutual friend’s wedding at Higgins Lake, Mich., in July 2022, both felt an immediate chemistry. As the evening progressed, they sat on the shore of the lake in Adirondack chairs under the stars, where they had their first kiss before joining others for a midnight plunge.

The two learned that the following weekend Ms. Lurio planned to attend a wedding in Philadelphia, where Mr. Nguyen lives, and before they had even exchanged numbers, they already had a first date on the books.

“I have a vivid memory of after we first met,” Mr. Nguyen said, “just feeling like I really better not screw this up.”

Before long, they were commuting between Philadelphia and New York City, where Ms. Lurio lives, spending weekends and the odd remote work days in one another’s apartments in Philadelphia and Manhattan. Within the first six months of dating, Mr. Nguyen joined Ms. Lurio’s family for Thanksgiving in Villanova, Pa., and, the following month, she met his family in Beavercreek, Ohio, at a surprise birthday party for Mr. Nguyen’s mother.

Ms. Lurio, 32, who grew up in Merion Station outside Philadelphia, works in investor relations administration at Flexpoint Ford, a private equity firm. She graduated from Dartmouth College with a bachelor’s degree in history and psychology.

Advertisement

Mr. Nguyen, also 32, was born in Knoxville, Tenn., and raised in Beavercreek, Ohio, from the age of 7. He graduated from Haverford College with a bachelor’s degree in political science and is now a director at Doyle Real Estate Advisors in Philadelphia.

Their long-distance relationship continued for the next few years. There were dates in Manhattan, vacations and beach trips to the Jersey Shore. They attended sporting events and discovered their shared appreciation of the 2003 film, “Love Actually.”

One evening, Mr. Nguyen recalled looking around Ms. Lurio’s small New York studio — strewed with clothes and the takeout meal they had ordered — and feeling “so comfortable and safe.” “I knew that this was something different than just sort of a fling,” he said.

It was an open question when they would move in together. In 2024, Ms. Lurio began the process of moving into Mr. Nguyen’s home in Philadelphia — even bringing her cat, Scott — but her plans changed midway when an opportunity arose to expand her role with her current employer.

Mr. Nguyen was on board with her decision. “It almost feels like stolen valor to call it ‘long distance,’ because it’s so easy from Philadelphia to New York,” Mr. Nguyen said. “The joke is, it’s easier to get to Philly from New York than to get to some parts of Brooklyn from Manhattan, right?”

Advertisement

In January 2025, Mr. Nguyen visited Ms. Lurio in New York with more up his sleeve than spending the weekend. Together they had discussed marriage and bespoke rings, but when Mr. Nguyen left Ms. Lurio and an unfinished cheese plate at the bar of the Chelsea Hotel that Friday evening, she had no idea what was coming next.

“I remember texting Jonathan,” Ms. Lurio said, bewildered: “‘You didn’t go toward the bathroom!’” When a Lobby Bar server came and asked her to come outside, Ms. Lurio still didn’t realize what was happening until she was standing in the hallway, where Mr. Nguyen stood recreating a key moment from the film “Love Actually,” in which one character silently professes his love for another in writing by flashing a series of cue cards. There, in the storied Chelsea Hotel hallway still festooned with Christmas decorations, Mr. Nguyen shared his last card that said, “Will you marry me?”

They wed on April 11 in front of 200 guests at the Pump House, a covered space on the banks of Philadelphia’s Schuylkill River. Mr. Nguyen’s sister, the Rev. Elizabeth Nguyen, who is ordained through the Unitarian Universalist Association, officiated.

Although formal attire was suggested, Ms. Lurio said that the ceremony was “pretty casual.” She and Jonathan got ready together, and their families served as their wedding parties.

“I said I wanted a five-minute wedding,” Ms. Lurio recalled, though the ceremony ended up lasting a little longer than that. During the ceremony, Ms. Nguyen read a homily and jokingly added that guests should not ask the bride and groom about their living arrangements, which will remain separate for the foreseeable future.

Advertisement

While watching Ms. Lurio walk down the aisle, flanked by her parents, Mr. Nguyen said he remembered feeling at once grounded in the moment and also a sense of dazed joy: “Like, is this real? I felt very lucky in that moment — and also just excited for the party to start!”

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending