Fitness
Should you use a treadmill or stair climber? Fitness experts reveal pros and cons
If you’re looking for a challenging, calorie-burning, engaging workout, should you use a treadmill or a stair climber? Either one is can be a good option, fitness experts say, but they’re not always right for everyone.
There are actually two types of stair climbing machines you might find in a gym, Chris Barucci, a physical therapist and certified strength and condition specialist at the Boston University Physical Therapy Center, tells TODAY.com.
When using the first variation, sometimes called a stepper, your feet stay in place on pedals that go up and down as you step. But when using the second type of machine, colloquially referred to by the brand name StairMaster, your feet leave the machine briefly while climbing a never-ending staircase. This type of machine is also sometimes called a stair mill, Barucci says.
That’s why, while you can get a great workout on either a stair climber or a treadmill, using a stair climber is generally more strenuous, Dr. Jeanne Doperak, a primary care sports medicine physician and associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, tells TODAY.com. But that also means it can be riskier than using a treadmill — especially for your knees, she says.
Here’s how to choose which machine is best for your goals.
Does a treadmill or stair climber give you a better workout?
Both a treadmill and stair climber can get your heart rate up, burn calories and work your lower body muscles.
But they impact the body a little differently, Barucci says.
When walking on a treadmill, people typically hit the tread in a “heel-to-toe pattern” and work the hamstring muscles on the back of the thigh, he explains. Whereas on a stair climber, “the pressure is mostly on the forefoot and mid-foot, which loads the lower leg, quad and hip muscles more,” Barucci adds.
Plus, the fact that a stair climber requires you to stay upright while stepping adds a balance challenge that engages your core muscles, TODAY.com explained previously.
With both cardio and strengthening components, a stair climber is generally going to be a more intense workout than a treadmill, Doperak says. That’s especially true if you’re comparing a stair climber to walking on a treadmill.
If you have a relatively high fitness level to begin with and are looking for the most efficient workout machine, a stair climber will likely be a better option.
But, the experts say, not everyone needs that. “In the right pace and the right population, (a stair climber) is a great workout,” she says. And the “vast majority of people will find that they can get as good a workout on some of the other apparatuses,” Doperak adds.
You can up the intensity on a treadmill by increasing the incline or speed, for instance, Barucci says. And you can build lower body strength with a dedicated strength-training routine in addition to using a cardio machine, Doperak says.
“Doing a cardiovascular workout and then having a separate strength workout that really is tailored to where you are in your fitness plan probably is the safest (option),” Doperak says.
Does a treadmill or stair climber have more impact on the body?
Climbing stairs is “one of the hardest things that we do on a daily basis as human beings,” Doperak says. When going up and down stairs, you’re putting “anywhere between three to seven times your body weight on your knee,” she adds. And stairs only become more challenging as we age.
For that reason, a stair climber inherently places more impact on the body — especially the knees — than a treadmill.
That also puts you more at risk for an injury to the knee when using a stair climber, Doperak says. “If we load the knee constantly with a motion that’s putting more stress on it, we get more cartilage wear,” she explains. And in the case of stairs, “people will get early wear and tear behind their kneecap,” she says.
To be fair, a treadmill can pose the same risks at a high enough incline. But Doperak is “often hesitant to recommend the stair climber as opposed to other things,” she says, “simply because I do think it puts many people at risk of having these knee issues.”
Should you use a treadmill or stair climber?
A stair climber is a great option for those who want to train for activities like hiking and climbing, Barucci says.
It can also be helpful for those who are just a little bored with their usual cardio workouts in the gym. “Because of the challenge the user faces needing to keep up with the staircase, it’s very difficult to not be focused on the activity while doing it,” Barucci says, “particularly if the speed is relatively fast.”
Additionally, stair climbers are particularly demanding on the quads and calf muscles, Barucci adds, so it can be a good option for people looking to work on those muscles.
But a stair climber isn’t necessarily a good option for beginners. “If the most you’re doing is a walk around the neighborhood, it feels like a big jump to a half an hour on the StairMaster,” Doperak says. She also cautions against using a stair climber if you have certain health concerns, particularly pain in the front of the knee.
A treadmill is ideal for those who want to continue their walking or running indoors, as TODAY.com explained previously. It’s also perfect for folks looking to build up their walking endurance before a big trip, for example.
Of course, there is also value in variety, Doperak says, adding that even stair climber enthusiasts probably shouldn’t use that machine every single day.
Whether you’re using a treadmill or stair climber, Barucci recommends starting with a time, speed and incline or resistance level that leave “plenty of safety margin.” Basically, start with what you feel comfortable with and increase those settings gradually.
Fitness
Study finds 5 more minutes of exercise could reduce your risk of death by 10%
The universal quest for immortality continues, and new research has hinted at a small lifestyle change that could reduce overall death rates in countries if we start taking our movement more seriously.
Conducted by a global research team, the study named ‘Deaths potentially averted by small changes in physical activity and sedentary time: an individual participant data meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies’ was published in The Lancet and suggested that adding five more minutes of physical exercise a day to your life could reduce death rates by 6 per cent.
Conducted on cohorts wearing on-person devices from Norway, Sweden and the USA, scientists analysed activity and sedentary levels to deduce what was causing higher death rates and found that a little change could go a long way.
With the help of the study’s author and additional experts from the field, we delved into the details and uncovered exactly what we need to do to make sure we are maximising our health before it’s too late.
A little change makes all the difference
We already know that we should all be getting out and exercising to ensure everything in our bodies is running smoothly, but just how important is that daily movement and could it be contributing to national mortality rates?
Professor Ulf Ekelund works in the Physical Activity and Health department at the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences and was one of the authors of the study. He broke down the data for HELLO!.
The professor explained: “We estimated the number of deaths potentially prevented by five and ten-minute increases in moderate intensity physical activity if all individuals in the population adhered to this increase.
“We analysed the data using two different approaches:
- ‘High-risk approach’ comprising the least active 20 per cent of the population
- ‘Population approach’ comprising 80 per cent of the population (excluding the most active 20 per cent).
He continued: “We found that six per cent and ten per cent of all deaths might be prevented in the two different scenarios, respectively, if all individuals made these changes.
“If an individual is completely inactive, every little move counts. For example, the least active 20 per cent in our study sample were only active for an average of about two minutes per day of moderate intensity. If all these individuals increased their activity by five minutes per day, it might reduce the number of deaths by six per cent annually.”
Dr Darren Player, a professor in Musculoskeletal Bioengineering at University College London, who was not involved in the study, shared his interpretation of the data with us and added: “The key finding was that an increase in Moderate-to-Vigorous Physical Activity (MVPA) by only five minutes per day for the least active individuals prevented 6 per cent of all deaths. This effect could extend to as much as 10 per cent in all individuals, except for those who are already very active.”
Exercise versus moderate intensity
In terms of how to achieve the correct level of activity and movement, we have to understand the difference between physical activity and moderately intense movement. They are different and will yield different results.
Professor Ulf explained: “There is a clear distinction between moderate intensity activity and exercise. Brisk walking is an excellent type of moderate intensity, whereas exercise is defined as something people do with the purpose to enhance fitness and/or health. It is structured and repetitive. Exercise is only a small proportion of all the physical activity people do.
“Physical activity [PA] is any bodily movement that increases energy expenditure above resting levels. It can be conducted with different intensities from very low to very strenuous. Exercise is a subset of PA which is planned, structured and done with a specific purpose.”
Could any of this add years onto our lives?
While this study was specifically about reducing death rates through exercise and movement, it made us wonder how it would affect the number of years we could all expect to live. Would incorporating an extra five minutes of movement add any time to the general life expectancy?
Dr Darren referred to data from the UK Biobank to share his estimations. He said: “This is quite a difficult question to answer, but there is some evidence. The following paper suggests that there could be an increase in life expectancy of 0.9 years for inactive women and up to 1.4 years for inactive men.
“The increases are dependent on the nature of physical activity, with higher intensity and greater volume (total amount of exercise) being the key factors. This is a large UK Biobank study, which does have some strengths for the analyses.”
He continued: “However, the factors that contribute to life expectancy and mortality are complex and varied, with further studies required to understand the picture fully. Particularly, the effect of resistance training combined with other forms of physical activity is likely to have a greater effect than one type of activity alone. Further research is required in this area to provide suitable evidence.”
What type of exercises can I do during my five extra minutes a day?
According to the NHS, there are a variety of movements that you can incorporate into your routine to make sure you are hitting the target of five extra minutes of exercise per day to increase your longevity.
These range from simple activities like making a cup of tea to pushing a lawnmower and dancing around your living room for fitness, depending on the intensity you are able for. While the study suggested five minutes of moderate intensity exercise, the health service broke down its recommendations into sections based on vigour:
Light activity:
- Getting up to make a cup of tea
- Moving around your home
- Walking at a slow pace
- Cleaning and dusting
- Vacuuming
Moderate activity:
- Walking for health
- Water aerobics
- Riding a bike
- Dance for fitness
- Pushing a lawnmower
- Hiking
Intense activity:
- Running
- Swimming
- Football
- Hiking uphill
- Martial arts
It also suggested some easy-to-do strength exercises that involve using a kitchen chair or filled bottles of water as props:
- Sit-to-stand
- Mini squats
- Calf raises
- Standing sideways leg lift
- Standing leg extension
- Wall press-up
- Bicep curls
Fitness
Fitness Class Volume Tied to Exercise Intensity Perception
About The Study: In this comparative effectiveness study, reducing music volume in group fitness classes did not lead to meaningful reductions in perceived exertion and may reduce the risk of noise-induced hearing loss. These findings support implementing safer sound practices in fitness environments and underscore the need for increased awareness and education on hearing protection.
Fitness
Reward yourself by exercising regularly at One to One Fitness | CWRU Newsroom | Case Western Reserve University
Now is the time to recommit to your health in time to feel your best for all your summer activities! One to One Fitness Center offers several ways to save in March.
Members of the Case Western Reserve University community can take advantage of sign-up specials designed to reward themselves for creating healthy habits.
Individuals can get 50% off the initiation fee (regularly $50 plus tax) and earn back what they do pay by exercising eight or more days in both April and May. Learn more online about this deal on initiation fees.
Students also can get additional savings:
- Graduate students who are enrolled for the spring semester receive summer membership free.
- With Spartan Shape Up memberships, affiliate students pay just $40 per month for membership from now through May, and no initiation fee or security deposit is required.
- Students also can pay $44 plus tax per month with a month-to-month, ongoing plan. No initiation fee or security deposit required.
One to One Fitness Center, owned and operated by CWRU, is known for offering personal, professional, friendly and clean services. Memberships include full access to the 28,000-square-foot fitness center, group exercise classes, validated parking in Lot 53, towel and locker service, and member discounts on programs and services.
Members also can add their spouse or partner to their account for $30 plus tax per month. The center also offers personal training, Pilates Reformer, massage therapy and sound bath therapy, swim lessons, and more.
Visit the One to One Fitness Center website, email onetoone@case.edu or call 216.368.1121 for more information.
-
World1 week agoExclusive: DeepSeek withholds latest AI model from US chipmakers including Nvidia, sources say
-
Wisconsin4 days agoSetting sail on iceboats across a frozen lake in Wisconsin
-
Massachusetts1 week agoMother and daughter injured in Taunton house explosion
-
Maryland5 days agoAM showers Sunday in Maryland
-
Massachusetts3 days agoMassachusetts man awaits word from family in Iran after attacks
-
Florida5 days agoFlorida man rescued after being stuck in shoulder-deep mud for days
-
Denver, CO1 week ago10 acres charred, 5 injured in Thornton grass fire, evacuation orders lifted
-
Oregon7 days ago2026 OSAA Oregon Wrestling State Championship Results And Brackets – FloWrestling
