Connect with us

Fitness

Fitness: Is exercise still considered important for weight loss?

Published

on

Fitness: Is exercise still considered important for weight loss?

Carrying too much weight increases the risk of heart disease, high blood pressure, stroke, type 2 diabetes, some cancers and breathing problems.

Article content

The American College of Sports Medicine recently published a consensus statement summarizing the latest research on physical activity and excess body weight. Exercise has long been recommended as part of treatment plan designed to lose unwanted pounds, but does science still support the notion exercise is an important component in weight loss?

Societal standards of what constitutes an ideal weight aside, most health-care professionals advocate weight loss based on its effect on health, not how you look in a pair of jeans. Carrying too much weight increases the risk of heart disease, high blood pressure, stroke, type 2 diabetes, some cancers and breathing problems.

Advertisement 2

Article content

Advertisement

Yet the difficulty in prescribing exercise as a weight-loss tool is not only does it take a lot of exercise to affect weight, but individuals carrying excess pounds are less likely to start an exercise program and if they do, they are also more likely to drop out.

Another issue is weight-loss success from exercise alone isn’t guaranteed, even if the same group of people follow the same exercise routine. And while there’s some evidence suggesting it takes a minimum of 150 minutes per week of moderate to vigorous intensity exercise to move the numbers on the scale, there’s no consensus among experts it’s enough, especially given the variability of the results in study subjects.

Even then weight loss is modest if there’s no concurrent reduction in the daily number of calories consumed. According to the ACSM, one can expect a modest weight loss of only 0.5-3 kg when using exercise as the sole strategy to lose weight. It’s only when diet and exercise are combined the results become more significant.  

“When combined with an energy-restricted diet, the effect of physical activity on body weight and adiposity is additive to diet and enhances weight loss by approximately 20 per cent, compared to what is observed with an energy-restricted diet alone,” said the authors of the ACSM’s latest consensus statement.

Advertisement 3

Advertisement

Article content

As to what kind of exercise is most effective at losing unwanted weight, there is little evidence suggesting one form of physical activity is better than the other. But if you want the most bang for your buck in the gym, it’s clear intensity matters. Moderate to vigorous intensity workouts will burn calories at a greater rate than light intensity activities, so keep that in mind if finding time to exercise is an issue.

The same goes for diet. There’s no evidence suggesting one diet is more effective than the other when it comes to creating a successful weight-loss routine, including time-restricted eating and intermittent fasting. The most important thing is to consume fewer calories, how you do it seems to make little difference in the long run.

“At the population level, one type of diet and macronutrient composition does not appear to be more effective for weight loss when compared to other approaches, provided these approaches result in similar effects in achieving negative energy balance,” stated the ASCM in its consensus statement.

Advertisement

In addition to clearing up any confusion as to whether one diet and exercise combination is more effective than another, the ACSM also addressed the idea eating at a certain time of day may be more advantageous for weight loss. Based on the theory exercise blunts appetite and eating fewer calories in the morning results in a greater negative energy balance than eating fewer calories at night, there’s little evidence restricting eating and exercise to certain times of day is an effective weight-loss strategy.

Advertisement 4

Article content

Also, worthy of mention by the ACSM is except for intense exercise (greater than 70 per cent of maximum effort), physical activity has little effect on appetite. Any suppression of hunger post-exercise is short-lived and doesn’t have an effect on the number of calories consumed daily, so don’t count on exercise to make that trip to the cookie jar seem less appealing.  

Advertisement

What does aid diet and exercise in whittling down body weight is the use of smart watches/wearables and apps. Not surprisingly, the ability to set daily activity and energy expenditure goals, track physical activity and diet and get real time feedback on lifestyle habits as well as reminders to get moving has proved to enhance weight loss.

“In 73 per cent of instances, greater monitoring of physical activity behaviour was linked to greater weight losses,” stated the ACSM consensus statement. “This suggests that for those with overweight and obesity, the self-regulatory process of monitoring raises awareness of physical activity and diet behaviour and enables a feedback loop of gathering and receiving personal data to make progress toward weight-related goals.”

Advertisement 5

Article content

Advertisement

This latest update on the role of exercise in weight loss hasn’t shaken the ACSM’s belief it’s still a valuable weight-loss tool, including for those taking anti-obesity medications. Diet and exercise still move the numbers on the scale. It’s also a reminder the benefits of exercise go beyond cinching your belt a little tighter. Improved health, vitality, sleep and mood and more muscle mass are just some of the advantages of regular exercise, even for those who struggle to reach their weight-loss goals. It takes as little as a five per cent decrease in body weight to start accruing health benefits, so every workout offers a reward — even if it can’t be seen.

“ACSM advocates for physical activity to be a key element of prevention and treatment efforts for exercise body weight and adiposity, with a focus on implementation of inclusive approaches to facilitate adoption and sustained engagement of physical activity of all persons,” stated the ACSM in their consensus statement.

Recommended from Editorial

Advertisement 6

Article content

Advertisement

Article content

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Fitness

How Jackass Star Chris Pontius’ Simple ‘1-Rep’ Rule Keeps Him Jacked at 51 – and Why it’s so Effective

Published

on

How Jackass Star Chris Pontius’ Simple ‘1-Rep’ Rule Keeps Him Jacked at 51 – and Why it’s so Effective

You might know Chris Pontius as ‘Party Boy’ from the Jackass films and TV series that defined the early 2000s. Now 51, he’s back on our screens for Jackass: Best and Last, the fifth and final instalment in the franchise. Away from the stunts, though, Pontius has also become an unlikely source of practical fitness advice, regularly sharing workouts from his home gym.

In a recent Instagram Reel, he shared: ‘I have a very simple exercise tip for people who are having trouble getting motivated to exercise. Just lift the weight one time, do one rep, one push-up, whatever it is, and once you’ve started you kind of go, “Well, I might as well just keep going”.’

‘So try it, it’s worked for me every time and it’ll probably work for you,’ he says.

The advice is grounded in behavioural science. By taking one small step towards your workout, you’re more likely to overcome the initial mental resistance because the task feels more achievable. Once you’ve started, it’s far easier to build momentum and complete the rest of your session.

Our Fitness Director Explains Why This Method Works

‘There’s a bit of science behind this, too,’ says Andrew Tracey. ‘Behaviour-change researchers have looked at “all-or-nothing thinking” around exercise – basically, the idea that if you can’t do the full session, exactly as planned, you may as well sack it off completely. Giving yourself permission to do the smallest possible version of the workout is a way around that.

Advertisement

‘Tell yourself you’re only doing the warm-up. Or one round. Or five minutes. You’re allowed to stop there. But often, once you’ve started, you realise the hard part wasn’t the workout itself. It was getting going. Research also shows that the way a workout feels can affect whether you come back for more. So a small win that feels doable is almost always better than the perfect session you never start. So while the “minimum dose” might feel like a cop-out, it could actually be a way in.’


If there’s one thing Kori Sampson knows, it’s how to optimise your body composition for performance. To tap into his knowledge as an elite athlete and coach, we asked him to create a 4-week plan to help you move faster, recover quicker and keep pushing when the fatigue sets in – all while improving your muscle-to-fat ratio.

Ready to build muscle, burn fat and come out the other side looking, feeling and performing better? Click here to get 14 days of free access to the plan via the Men’s Health app.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Fitness

“Forget living longer, exercise can make life easier right now”—a 72-year-old fitness influencer and marathon runner shares two accessible ways to start moving

Published

on

“Forget living longer, exercise can make life easier right now”—a 72-year-old fitness influencer and marathon runner shares two accessible ways to start moving

Retirement is often a time when people slow down, but in Christine Hobson’s case, she’s speeding up. When her daughter persuaded her to join a running club so she wouldn’t get bored, she had no idea she’d get the fitness bug and run 125 marathons in total, visiting all seven continents.

And the 72-year-old former teacher has plans to run the North Pole marathon in 2027.

Continue Reading

Fitness

Why 21-15-9 Might be the Smartest Workout Format in Fitness – and How to Use it to Drive Muscle Growth

Published

on

Why 21-15-9 Might be the Smartest Workout Format in Fitness – and How to Use it to Drive Muscle Growth

CrossFit means a lot of things to a lot of people – because it’s made up of a lot of things.

Since the rise of the fitness giant, countless brands, events and training methods have sprung up around it – not claiming to be CrossFit, but looking suspiciously CrossFit-esque.

There are, however, a handful of things that are uniquely CrossFit: the ‘Girls’ benchmark workouts. The Hero WODs and, of course, its signature rep schemes.

Chief among them is ’21-15-9′.

The 21-15-9 rep scheme may just be the single most CrossFit thing in existence. But what exactly is it? Where did it come from? And why might it actually be better at building muscle in a hurry than its conditioning roots would have you believe?

Advertisement

Let’s have a look.

What Is 21-15-9?

If you’ve never encountered it before, the format couldn’t be simpler. Choose two exercises (occasionally more) and perform 21 reps of each, then 15 reps of each, then nine reps of each, completing the entire workout as quickly as possible – with good form.

Probably the best-known example is ‘Fran’: 21 thrusters and pull-ups, followed by 15 of each, then nine. On paper it doesn’t look especially intimidating. In practice, it’s one of the most feared benchmark workouts in fitness.

Where Did it Come From?

Unlike many modern training methods, 21-15-9 didn’t come out of a study. It came from the gym floor.

CrossFit founder Greg Glassman has explained that the format emerged through years of coaching and experimentation in the 1990s. Rather than chasing a perfect sets-and-reps prescription, he was looking for a workout that allowed athletes to maintain a high power output from start to finish.

Advertisement

The thinking is surprisingly elegant. You begin with 21 reps while fresh. By the time you reach the set of 15, your ability to produce force has already fallen. By the final nine, you’re significantly more fatigued – but the workload has dropped by almost the same amount.

Instead of grinding through increasingly miserable sets of the same length, the workout ‘meets you where you are’, reducing the work required as your capacity declines. The result is a workout that encourages you to keep moving instead of standing around trying to recover.

The numbers themselves are also remarkably practical. Forty-five total reps per movement provides plenty of training volume without turning the session into an endurance slog, while every set divides neatly into thirds if you need to break it up.

(Although I’ve got to be honest, I’m a 20-15-10-5 man myself, just for the sake of round numbers.)

Why Does it Work So Well?

Although there isn’t research showing that 21-15-9 is somehow the magic formula, there are obvious reasons why it consistently produces brutally effective workouts.

Advertisement

Descending reps help maintain intensity. As fatigue accumulates, reducing the target allows movement quality, bar speed and overall work rate to stay higher than they would if you simply repeated the same number of reps over and over.

It also tends to land in a physiological sweet spot. Most 21-15-9 workouts take between three and eight minutes, depending on the movements and the athlete. That’s long enough to create a serious cardiovascular challenge while still requiring meaningful force production throughout. You’re taxing your anaerobic systems hard while relying on your aerobic system to help you recover just enough to keep going.

Finally, there’s the psychological trick. The hardest-looking part comes first. Once you’ve survived the opening 21, every remaining round appears more manageable. ‘Only 15 left.’ Then, ‘Just nine.’ In reality, you’re becoming more fatigued with every rep, but the shrinking target keeps you attacking the workout instead of pacing too conservatively.

Why it Might be Surprisingly Good for Building Muscle

Perhaps the biggest misconception about 21-15-9 is that it’s ‘just cardio with weights’.

Choose the right load and something interesting happens. Very few athletes complete every round unbroken. Instead, the workout naturally evolves into a series of short, broken sets separated by only a few seconds of rest.

Advertisement

Your 21 might become 11-5-5. Your 15 becomes 8-4-3. Your final nine might stay unbroken – or become 5-4.

In effect, you’ve accidentally turned the workout into a form of rest-pause training.

Those brief pauses allow just enough recovery to squeeze out more high-quality repetitions before fatigue catches up again. By the latter stages of each mini-set, you’re repeatedly working very close to failure, recruiting the high-threshold motor units with the greatest potential for muscle growth.

It’s a similar principle to rest-pause training, myo-reps and cluster sets: all methods used to accumulate hypertrophy-friendly volume while keeping the load relatively heavy and the rest periods brutally short.

You’re basically speed-running a large number of hard, growth-stimulating reps in a very small window of time. Could this help explain why elite CrossFit athletes often carry an impressive amount of muscle despite spending relatively little time performing traditional bodybuilding splits?

Advertisement

It’s certainly plausible, although the ‘elite’ part often selects for athletes with the greatest muscle-building potential.

Much of their training isn’t simply conditioning. It’s high-density resistance training performed under accumulating fatigue, with only fleeting recovery between efforts. In other words, they’re often doing something bodybuilders have deliberately programmed for decades: packing a lot of hard work into a very short period of time.

That’s not to say 21-15-9 is superior to a well-designed hypertrophy programme. If your sole goal is building muscle, there are more efficient ways to do it.

But if you’re looking for a workout that develops fitness, tests your mettle and still provides a meaningful stimulus for strength and size, it’s easy to see why this deceptively simple rep scheme has remained one of CrossFit’s defining fingerprints for more than 20 years.

Best Bodyweight 21-15-9 Workout: ‘JT’

If you’re looking for an interesting twist on the 21-15-9 format, look no further than Hero WOD ‘JT’, which concentrates the muscle-building potential of the format into a brutal upper-body workout.

Advertisement

Created in honour of Petty Officer 1st Class Jeff Taylor, who was killed in Afghanistan in 2006, the workout strips away barbells altogether and relies solely on three bodyweight movements:

21-15-9 reps of:

Don’t let the lack of equipment fool you. The volume – 45 reps of each movement, 135 reps in total – combined with the descending rep scheme makes this a brutal upper-body test, hammering the shoulders, chest and triceps while demanding serious muscular endurance.

Better still, it perfectly demonstrates one of the biggest strengths of 21-15-9. As fatigue mounts and the sets naturally fragment, the workout begins to resemble one giant rest-pause set, allowing you to accumulate a huge number of hard, near-failure reps in less than 10 minutes.

If your goal is building an impressive upper body while developing serious work capacity, there are few bodyweight workouts that deliver quite so much bang for your buck, making ‘JT’ one of my personal favourites.

Advertisement

fitness magazine cover featuring a muscular man with kettlebells

If there’s one thing Kori Sampson knows, it’s how to optimise your body composition for performance. To tap into his knowledge as an elite athlete and coach, we asked him to create a 4-week plan to help you move faster, recover quicker and keep pushing when the fatigue sets in – all while improving your muscle-to-fat ratio.

Ready to build muscle, burn fat and come out the other side looking, feeling and performing better? Click here to get 14 days of free access to the plan via the Men’s Health app.


Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending