Education
Indigenous Founders of a Museum Cafe Put Repatriation on the Menu

BERKELEY, Calif. — One among Vincent Medina’s most vivid recollections as a teen is of a category exploring his ancestry as a member of the Ohlone folks, an Indigenous tribe within the San Francisco Bay area. An aged trainer, wagging her fingers in anger, informed her younger costs that the close by College of California at Berkeley was “holding our ancestors in plastic baggage and paint cans” beneath the college’s athletic services, “though now we have repeatedly requested for a correct burial.”
The human stays had been saved within the basement of a gymnasium on the Berkeley campus.
“I take into consideration that on a regular basis,” Medina stated lately of the lesson. “There was a silence that went all around the room.”
Right this moment, at 35, he’s a co-founder of Cafe Ohlone, a restaurant and aspiring cultural heart on the terrace of the Phoebe A. Hearst Museum of Anthropology, on the identical Berkeley campus the place the stays of his and different Ohlone ancestors are entombed. Created in a uncommon collaboration with the college, Cafe Ohlone celebrates the traditions and delicacies of the folks whose ancestors have lived within the area for some 10,000 years, as its members press for the return of their sacred objects and stays.
Hummingbird sage and piles of crushed oyster shells convey the spirit of “oṭṭoy’’ — a phrase meaning to fix or restore in Chochenyo, an Indigenous language of the interior East Bay.
Therapeutic is what the cafe hopes to convey to its new web site. One of many nation’s largest repositories of sacred artifacts, the Hearst Museum has a posh and fraught historical past with the area’s Indigenous folks. It at present holds about 9,000 ancestral stays and 13,000 funerary objects collected for the reason that 1870s — the bulk Ohlone — and it has been gradual to repatriate them, in response to the California State Auditor’s workplace and the college itself.A further 200,000 archaeological objects within the museum are awaiting evaluation by tribal specialists to find out their significance.
After years of inaction, the college and museum have made the return of Indigenous cultural artifacts, which is required by federal and state legal guidelines, a precedence, and the museum has largely been closed to accommodate the trouble. Since 2020, 1,000 ancestral human stays and roughly 54,000 sacred objects and belongings have been returned, in response to the college. (The Ohlone stays beneath the gymnasium have been moved within the Nineteen Nineties and are actually housed in a safe museum area.)
“Our function is to take care of and home collections eligible for repatriation and to assist advance repatriation in as expeditious a method as potential that’s respectful to the tribes,” stated Caroline Jean Fernald, the Hearst Museum’s govt director. “It’s an emotional course of for a lot of.”
Amongst these main the way in which are Medina, of the Chochenyo Ohlones from the East Bay, and the cafe’s co-founder, Louis Trevino, 31, of the Rumsen Ohlones, a gaggle from Monterey County. The college reached out to them in an effort to redress many years of what it described this fall, in a information launch, as “structural violence and racism towards Native American peoples, the dangerous penalties of that are nonetheless confronted by communities as we speak.”
The High quality Arts & Displays Particular Part
The al fresco eatery was designed by the panorama agency Terremoto, with native crops behind lit screens and miniature shell-mounds that recall Ohlone village and burial websites alongside the East Bay shoreline that have been excavated by U.C. Berkeley archaeologists.
Birdsong and music sung by kids and elders — members of the family of Medina and Trevino — spill from hidden audio system in redwood columns carved with every singer’s title. Their repertoire features a love track to the Chochenyo language, sung to the tune of the Sixties hit “Angel Child,” and the form of gossipy banter that may be heard round an Ohlone kitchen desk.
The cafe made its preliminary debut in 2018 as a candlelit communal pop-up in the back of a e book retailer off campus, serving up acorn soup with bay nut truffles and different delicacies. From the beginning, it has been a deeply private enterprise. “We created Café Ohlone as a result of we felt remoted in our homeland,” Medina stated. “We wished to see our tradition mirrored on our personal phrases.”
Medina and Trevino, companions in life and delicacies, met eight years in the past at an Indigenous language convention. They have been in a car parking zone after they occurred upon an article within the U.C. Berkeley pupil newspaper through which Kent Lightfoot, a extensively revered archaeologist and anthropology professor, advised inviting the cafe onto the college’s campus as a therapeutic gesture. “We realized how lovely and symbolic it could possibly be to convey our baskets, mortars and pestles — all these dwelling objects — to be with the normal objects of our ancestors till they’re returned,” Medina stated.
Stone pestles with oil from historic fingers, feather baskets and different artifacts “have a personhood to them,” he added. “They inform who we’re. So they may sense our presence.”
Together with different Native Individuals, the Ohlone have been victims of genocidal acts and suppression of their language, faith, arts and even their names. They have been enslaved beneath the Spanish Catholic mission system, and, from the 1840s to the 1870s, have been targets of a “conflict of extermination” signed by the primary governor of California aimed toward eradicating Indigenous folks from land that settlers coveted. Hundreds of Native folks have been slaughtered by formally sanctioned militias and U.S. troops, and by vigilantes, in what the historian Benjamin Madley of the College of California at Los Angeles has referred to as “a well-funded killing machine.”
Searching for refuge, some Ohlones gravitated to remoted canyons within the East Bay hills — now largely suburbia — within the late 1800s, the place conventional ceremonies flourished. There they encountered Phoebe Elizabeth Apperson Hearst, the museum’s founder and benefactor, who continues to be known as “Auntie Phoebe” by some Ohlone elders.
Hearst, who was U.C. Berkeley’s first lady regent, employed many Ohlone girls, together with Medina’s ancestors, as housekeepers for her 53-room Hacienda del Pozo de Verona and supplied a modicum of stability.
Even earlier than the museum’s founding in 1901 the college served as a repository for Indigenous stays and funerary objects taken with out prior and knowledgeable consent from state infrastructure tasks; as soon as the museum was established, it grew to become “complicit” in persevering with such accumulating, Fernald, the museum’s govt director, stated in an interview.
In 1925, the influential anthropologist Alfred Louis Kroeber, who led the museum for 38 years, declared the Ohlone folks “extinct,” which two years later resulted in a lack of federal tribal recognition and rights to the land base. His view, which he later tried to revise, was predicated on the notion that solely primitive societies earlier than European contact have been genuine. Final yr, the college eliminated his title from what had been Kroeber Corridor, house of the Division of Anthropology, as a result of, within the phrases of Chancellor Carol Christ, Kroeber’s actions “clearly stand in opposition to our college’s values of inclusion and our perception in selling range and excellence.”
Throughout Kroeber’s tenure, for the sake of examine, the college excavated shell-mounds — ceremonial locations and burial websites created by Indigenous folks — and in addition took human stays and objects ranging from fish hooks to Abalone shell jewellery. “Our folks have been faraway from their cemeteries within the title of analysis,” stated Medina, who now sits on a state-appointed advisory committee beneath the Native American Graves Safety and Repatriation Act, at U.C. Berkeley. “It was an plain crime.”
However the Ohlone ancestors sized up Kroeber and his colleagues. “When he would come across the household would disguise their finery and baskets beneath the floorboards,” Medina stated, recalling tales his mother and father informed him about efforts to maintain the cultural inheritance alive.
Linguists and anthropologists from the Smithsonian Establishment’s Bureau of American Ethnology, amongst them John Peabody Harrington, recorded tribal elders within the mid-1900s concerning the “outdated methods” — religions, dances, looking and gathering practices — and the injustices they skilled. These archives and elders’ recollections allowed Medina and Trevino to show themselves the Chochenyo and Rumsen languages.
Extra providentially, the historic data proved to be a culinary gold mine — an Ohlone model of “Pleasure of Cooking” — brimming with knowledge about chia seeds, venison, gooseberries and different components. Medina and Trevino started experimenting with dishes, together with acorn bread, and scouring the panorama for watercress, yerba buena, and black walnuts.
Trevino’s culinary roots return to his boyhood as a cashier at his grandparents’ restaurant east of Los Angeles (“I by no means met my great-grandmother however was intimately acquainted along with her sauces,” he wrote within the quarterly journal Information from Native California). Their desirous about Ohlone delicacies has advanced: pastas harken again to Medina’s Sicilian great-great-great grandfather, who used broomsticks to dry them, and to Mexican and vaquero- inflected dishes like Venison Chile Colorado. (They nonetheless do the cooking in collaboration with campus cooks.)
The out of doors cafe is open by reservation and plans name for Medina and Trevino to curate an adjoining gallery when the museum reopens subsequent fall. Their broader purpose is to create a cultural beachhead -— one which may encourage regulation college students to plunge into tribal sovereignty points, as an example, or structure college students to change into attuned to sacred websites.
Lauren Kroiz, an affiliate artwork historical past professor and the Hearst’s college director, says the cafe will remodel the museum into “a spot of dwelling and resilient cultures,’’ informing future guests about language, meals methods and different subjects.
However main challenges stay. The Hearst has been “one of the crucial intransigent in returning stolen items and ancestors” and complying with federal regulation, stated Chip Colwell, the writer of “Plundered Skulls and Stolen Spirits: Contained in the Combat to Reclaim Native America’s Tradition.”
Many of the stays and sacred and cultural objects on the Hearst have been taken from ancestral lands of Bay Space tribes which can be nonetheless not federally acknowledged, stated Sabrina C. Agarwal, a bioarchaeologist and anthropology professor who chairs the state-appointed advisory committee at U.C. Berkeley.
The dearth of federal recognition, she stated, was the results of genocide, pressured migration and assimilation and “salvage anthropology” by early anthropologists like Kroeber who “believed erroneously that the tribes would die out, or already had, and wished to save lots of no matter they might,” Agarwal stated. The college additionally used the dearth of federal recognition as an excuse to “gradual issues down,” she added.
However the stability of energy is shifting towards enlisting Indigenous peoples to determine whose ancestors and belongings are affiliated with whom, led by the state’s Native American Heritage Fee. (The fee arrange the advisory committees all through the College of California system to guarantee every campus complies with federal and state rules.)
A 2001 California state regulation expanded eligibility for repatriation claims to tribes with out federal recognition, which embody the Ohlone. However the course of for returning materials stays complicated and time-consuming, Agarwal stated.
Whereas they wait for his or her treasured cultural artifacts and stays to be returned to the Ohlone, Medina and Trevino honor their ancestors by serving up dishes utilizing mortars and pestles, winnowing baskets and different historic implements, echoing those remaining within the museum.
They see the cafe as a “place of continuity,” the place basket makers and different artists from across the state may collect beneath its conventional redwood shade construction, or ramada. It’s already a brand new form of landmark the place, as Medina put it, “elders can dress as much as the nines, come out for a Saturday evening dinner and have the ability to sit on the head of the desk.”

Education
Video: Opinion | We Study Fascism, and We’re Leaving the U.S.

I’m a historian of totalitarianism. I look at fascist rhetoric. I’ve been thinking about the sources of the worst kinds of history for a quarter of a century. “Experts say the constitutional crisis is here now.” ”The Trump administration deporting hundreds of men without a trial.” “A massive purge at the F.B.I.” “To make people afraid of speaking out against him.” I’m leaving to the University of Toronto because I want to do my work without the fear that I will be punished for my words. The lesson of 1933 is you get out sooner rather than later. I’ve spent a lot of time in the last decade trying to prepare people if Trump were elected once, let alone twice. “Look what happened. Is this crazy?” [CHEERING] I did not flee Trump. But if people are going to leave the United States or leave American universities, there are reasons for that. One thing you can definitely learn from Russians — — is that it’s essential to set up centers of resistance in places of relative safety. We want to make sure that if there is a political crisis in the U.S., that Americans are organized. ”We’ve just gotten started. You haven’t even seen anything yet. It’s all just kicking in.” My colleagues and friends, they were walking around and saying, “We have checks and balances. So let’s inhale, checks and balances, exhale, checks and balances.” And I thought, my God, we’re like people on the Titanic saying our ship can’t sink. We’ve got the best ship. We’ve got the strongest ship. We’ve got the biggest ship. Our ship can’t sink. And what you know as a historian is that there is no such thing as a ship that can’t sink. “The golden age of America has only just begun.” America has long had an exceptionalist narrative — fascism can happen elsewhere, but not here. But talking about American exceptionalism is basically a way to get people to fall into line. If you think that there’s this thing out there called America and it’s exceptional, that means that you don’t have to do anything. Whatever is happening, it must be freedom. And so then what your definition of freedom is just gets narrowed and narrowed and narrowed and narrowed, and soon, you’re using the word freedom — what you’re talking about is authoritarianism. Toni Morrison warned us: “The descent into a final solution is not a jump. It’s one step. And then another. And then another.” We are seeing those steps accelerated right now. There are some words in Russian in particular that I feel help us to understand what’s happening in the United States because we now have those phenomena. “Proizvol”: It’s the idea that the powers that be can do anything they want to and you have no recourse. This not knowing who is next creates a state of paralysis in society. The Tufts student whose visa was removed because she co-authored an article in the Tufts student newspaper. [DESPERATE YELLING] I thought, what would I do if guys in masks tried to grab my student? Would I scream? Would I run away? Would I try to pull the mask off? Would I try to videotape the scene? Would I try to pull the guys off of her? Maybe I would get scared and run away. The truth is, I don’t know. Not knowing terrified me. It’s a deliberate act of terror. It’s not necessary. It’s just being done to create a spirit of us and them. “Prodazhnost”: It’s a word in Russian for corruption, but it’s larger than corruption. It refers to a kind of existential state in which not only everything but everyone can be bought or sold. “Critics are calling this a quid pro quo deal between Adams and President Trump.” “I’m committed to buying and owning Gaza.” “He made $2.5 billion today, and he made $900 million.” There’s an expression in Polish: “I found myself at the very bottom, and then I heard knocking from below.” In Russian, that gets abbreviated to “There is no bottom.” “We cannot allow a handful of communist radical left judges to obstruct the enforcement of our laws.” What starts to matter is not what is concealed but what has been normalized. There is no limit to the depravity — ”President Trump did not rule out the possibility of a third term.” — and the sadism — “The White House released this video titled ASMR Illegal Alien Deportation Flight.” — and the cruelty that we are watching now play out in real time. “This facility is one of the tools in our tool kit that we will use.” You have to continually ask yourself the question, “Is this OK? Is there a line I wouldn’t cross? Is there something I would not do?” People say, oh, the Democrats should be doing more. They should be fixing things. But if you want the Democrats to do things, you have to create the platform for them. You have to create the spectacle, the pageantry, the positive energy, the physical place where they can come to you. Poland recently went through a shift towards authoritarianism. Unlike in Russia, unlike in Hungary, the media remained a place, in Poland, where you could criticize the regime. And as a result, democracy returned. The moral of Poland is that our democratic institutions — the media, the university, and the courts — are essential. You know you’re living in a fascist society when you’re constantly going over in your head the reasons why you’re safe. What we want is a country where none of us have to feel that way.
Education
A $5 Billion Federal School Voucher Proposal Advances in Congress

Advocates for private-school choice celebrated this week as a federal schools voucher bill moved closer to becoming law, a major milestone that eluded their movement during President Trump’s first term.
The House Republican budget proposal that advanced on Monday would devote $5 billion to federal vouchers for private-school tuition, home-schooling materials and for-profit virtual learning.
The program in the budget bill could bring vouchers to all 50 states for the first time, including Democratic-leaning ones that have long rejected the idea.
Supporters hailed the proposal as “historic” and a “huge win,” but some cautioned that there was still much legislative haggling ahead.
“Ultimately, every child, especially from lower-income families, should have access to the school of their choice, and this legislation is the only way to make that happen,” said Tommy Schultz, chief executive of the American Federation for Children, a private-school choice advocacy group.
Opponents of the proposal were stunned at its sweeping implications. While it is in line with President Trump’s agenda, it had been considered somewhat of a long shot to make it out of the House Ways and Means Committee, because of its cost.
The program is structured as a $5 billion tax credit, allowing donors to reduce their tax bill by $1 for every $1 they give to nonprofits that grant scholarships — up to 10 percent of the donor’s income.
The option to donate is expected to be popular with wealthy taxpayers.
The resulting scholarships could be worth $5,000 per child, reaching one million students. Any family who earns less than 300 percent of their area’s median income — which equals over $300,000 in some parts of the country — could use the funds, meaning a vast majority of families would be eligible.
The proposal could pass through the budget reconciliation process, and could become law with only 51 votes in a Senate where Republicans hold 53 seats.
In the wake of the Covid-19 pandemic, many Republican-led states passed new private-school choice laws, overcoming decades of resistance from teachers’ unions, Democrats and rural conservatives. Opponents have long argued that vouchers hurt traditional public schools, by decreasing enrollment and funding levels. And they have pointed out that lower-income neighborhoods and rural areas often have few private schools, making it difficult for many families to use vouchers.
“We are against giving people tax breaks to defund public schools,” said Randi Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers, the nation’s second-largest education union.
She pointed out that while Mr. Trump and congressional Republicans have said they want to invest in work force education, artificial intelligence education and other priorities for student learning, they have consistently proposed cutting funding to public schools, which educate nearly 90 percent of American students.
“They don’t believe in public schooling,” she said. “What you’re seeing here is the fragmentation of American education.”
A boom in new private-education options, like virtual learning and microschools, has already changed the landscape — as has an influx of campaign spending from conservative donors, like the financier Jeff Yass, intended to build support for private-school choice.
Last month, Texas became the last major Republican-led state to pass such legislation. Advocates quickly shifted their focus to Congress and the opportunity to push a federal voucher bill.
Senator Bill Cassidy, Republican of Louisiana, is the sponsor of a Senate bill similar to the House proposal, and celebrated its inclusion in the budget package.
“Expanding President Trump’s tax cuts is about preserving the American dream,” he said in a written statement. “Giving parents the ability to choose the best education for their child makes the dream possible.”
But the proposal will still have to overcome opposition, on both the left and the right.
Advocates for public schools have said that the new generation of vouchers and education savings accounts, which are often available to relatively affluent families, are a subsidy to parents who can already afford private education.
In Florida, which has more children using vouchers than any other state in the nation, some public-school districts have experienced enrollment declines and are considering shutting down schools or cutting teaching positions.
Even some conservative parental-rights activists oppose the creation of a federal program, which they worry could create a regulatory pathway that could eventually be used to impose government requirements on home-schooling parents or private schools — for example, by requiring standardized testing, which is not mentioned in the current proposal.
“The federal government should extricate itself from K-12 education to the fullest extent possible,” said Christopher Rufo, a leading crusader against diversity programs in schools, and a supporter of school choice. “It’s best left to the states.”
Education
Harvard Letter Points to ‘Common Ground’ With Trump Administration

Harvard University struck a respectful but firm tone in a letter to the Trump administration on Monday, arguing that the university and the administration shared the same goals, though they differed in their approaches. It was latest move in an extraordinary back-and-forth between the school and the federal government in recent weeks.
The letter from Alan M. Garber, Harvard’s president, was sent a week after the Trump administration said it would stop giving Harvard any research grants.
Last month, the university took the government to court over what it has called unlawful intrusion into its operations. But on Monday, Dr. Garber’s tone was softer, saying he agreed with some of the Trump administration’s concerns about higher education, but that Harvard’s efforts to combat bigotry and foster an environment for free expression had been hurt by the government’s actions.
Dr. Garber said he embraced the goals of curbing antisemitism on campus; fostering more intellectual diversity, including welcoming conservative voices; and curtailing the use of race in admissions decisions.
Those goals “are undermined and threatened by the federal government’s overreach into the constitutional freedoms of private universities and its continuing disregard of Harvard’s compliance with the law,” Dr. Garber said in the letter to Linda McMahon, the secretary of education.
The university’s response came one week after Ms. McMahon wrote to Harvard to advise the university against applying for future grants, “since none will be provided.” That letter provoked new worries inside Harvard about the long-term consequences of its clash with the Trump administration.
“At its best, a university should fulfill the highest ideals of our nation, and enlighten the thousands of hopeful students who walk through its magnificent gates,” Ms. McMahon wrote. “But Harvard has betrayed its ideal.”
Rolling through a roster of conservative complaints about the school, Ms. McMahon fumed about the university’s “bloated bureaucracy,” its admissions policies, its international students, its embrace of some Democrats and even its mathematics curriculum.
Ms. McMahon referred to Harvard as “a publicly funded institution,” even though Harvard is private and the vast majority of its revenue does not come from the government. She suggested that the university rely more on its own funds, noting that Harvard’s endowment, valued at more than $53 billion, would give it a “head start.” (Much of Harvard’s endowment is tied up in restricted funds and cannot be repurposed at will.)
“Today’s letter,” Ms. McMahon wrote, “marks the end of new grants for the university.”
In Dr. Garber’s letter on Monday, he said that the university had created a strategy to combat antisemitism and other bigotry, and had invested in the academic study of Judaism and related fields. But he said the university would not “surrender its core, legally-protected principles out of fear of unfounded retaliation by the federal government.”
He denied Ms. McMahon’s assertion that Harvard was political.
“It is neither Republican nor Democratic,” he said of the university. “It is not an arm of any other political party or movement. Nor will it ever be. Harvard is a place to bring people of all backgrounds together to learn in an inclusive environment where ideas flourish regardless of whether they are deemed ‘conservative,’ ‘liberal,’ or something else.”
Although Harvard is the nation’s wealthiest university by far, officials there have warned that federal cuts could have devastating consequences on the campus and beyond. During Harvard’s 2024 fiscal year, the university received about $687 million from the federal government for research, a sum that accounted for about 11 percent of the university’s revenue.
The government can block the flow of federal money through a process called debarment. But the procedure is laborious, and the outcome may be appealed. Experts on government contracting said Ms. McMahon’s letter indicated that the administration had not followed the ordinary procedure to blacklist a recipient of federal funds.
Harvard officials are aware that, even if they challenge the administration’s tactics successfully in court, Mr. Trump’s government could still take other steps to choke off money that would be harder to fight.
The federal government often sets priorities for research that shape agencies’ day-to-day decisions about how and where federal dollars are spent. Some academics worry that the government might pivot away from fields of study in which Harvard has deep expertise, effectively shutting out the university’s researchers. Or the administration could simply assert that Harvard’s proposals were incompatible with the government’s needs.
Jessica Tillipman, an expert on government contracting law at George Washington University, said that it can be difficult to show that the government is using a back door to blacklist a grant recipient.
“You basically have to demonstrate and point to concrete evidence, not just a feeling,” she said.
Still, she said, Ms. McMahon’s letter could offer Harvard an opening to contest a protracted run of grant denials.
“It’s not as hard to prove,” Ms. Tillipman said, “when you have a giant letter that said, by the way, we aren’t giving you these things anymore.”
-
Austin, TX1 week ago
Best Austin Salads – 15 Food Places For Good Greens!
-
Technology1 week ago
Netflix is removing Black Mirror: Bandersnatch
-
World1 week ago
The Take: Can India and Pakistan avoid a fourth war over Kashmir?
-
News1 week ago
Reincarnated by A.I., Arizona Man Forgives His Killer at Sentencing
-
News1 week ago
Who is the new Pope Leo XIV and what are his views?
-
Politics1 week ago
Department of Justice opens criminal investigation into NY AG Letitia James
-
World1 week ago
New German chancellor aims for stronger EU ties with France and Poland
-
News1 week ago
Judge Orders Release of Rumeysa Ozturk, Tufts Student Detained by ICE